r/zen • • Aug 27 '25

Why is Zen so counterculture about compassion?

0 Upvotes

Definitions

Counterculture: a culture with values and mores that run counter to those of established society

Christian compassion: feeling sorry for the less fortunate to the point of trying to fix them.

Zen Master Huangbo: compassion really means not conceiving of sentient beings as to be delivered.

Personal experience

The belief that people should be saved is so dominant in Western culture that people have gotten angry with me for not being tolerant or friendly or kind to frauds and predators and ignoramuses. The idea of "saving" people through tolerance and kindness is so entrenched in all the Western religions that Zen "rudeness" is really upsetting to people; as if you can't say "@#$% off" to people who want to sell you a Trump Bible!

Compassion in Action, Counterculturally

When Muzhou heard Yunmen coming he closed the door to his room. Yunmen knocked on the door.

Muzhou said, “Who is it?”

Yunmen said, “It’s me.”

Muzhou said, “What do you want?”

Yunmen said, “I’m not clear about my life. I’d like the master to give me some instruction.”

Muzhou then opened the door and, taking a look at Yunmen, closed it again.

Yunmen knocked on the door in this manner three days in a row. On the third day when Muzhou opened the door, Yunmen stuck his foot in the doorway.

Muzhou grabbed Yunmen and yelled, “Speak! Speak!”

When Yunmen began to speak, Muzhou gave him a shove and said, “Too late!”

Muzhou then slammed the door, catching and breaking Yunmen’s foot. At that moment, Yunmen experienced enlightenment.

Muzhou understood he didn't have anything for Yunmen, but that Yunmen mistakenly believed Muzhou did.

Muzhou was content in his compassion and didn't need to "fix" anything for Yunmen, or "teach" anything to Yunmen.

Christian Compassion means thinking ur special

Do you believe that you have something other people don't? Do you believe you can write a high school book report nobody else can write?

Do you tell yourself you have a special understanding that makes you different from other people?

That's not Zen compassion

I will say that the steady flow of harassment that I get on Reddit from New agers and Zazen worshipers doesn't seem to fit any definition of compassion.


r/zen • • May 08 '20

META [Meta] Why do new age dogen shamanic lsd meditation buddhists refuse to quote Zen Masters?

0 Upvotes

TL;dr: Zen just isn't compatible with new age dogen shamanic lsd meditation buddhism

  1. new age - the name for philosophies and beliefs with no established tradition or history

  • Zen is full of this kind of stuff... Juzhi's One Finger Zen! Mazu's Mind is not the Buddha! Why not quote Zen Masters?

  1. Dogen prayer-meditation "dharma gate" - It is a method for getting enlightened!

  • Zen Masters talk about dharma gate stuff all the time! Wumen references it in his first page of instruction! Why not talk about the dharma gate teachings of Zen Masters?

  1. shamanic lsd - People who talk about taking drugs, having hallucations, or immersing themselves in alternative lifestyles.

  • Zen has Fire God and non-sentient beings expounding the dharma and dragons and @!#$! Why would any self respecting shamanic psychonaut refuse to reference Zen teachings like that?

  1. Meditation - a vigorous physical exercise involving mental focus and self awareness

  • Every Zen text mentions meditation! At least once! Why not quote these texts?

  1. Buddhism - a religion based on the Eightfold Path and the Four Noble Truths.

  • Zen shares many terms, ideas, and a rich history and culture with Buddhism... why wouldn't Buddhists compare and contrast the many many times Zen and Buddhism bump into each other?

.

(Welcome link) ewk link note: Given that Zen has such a long, famous, colorful history, and so much to offer really every area of interest, it's really shocking how reluctant so many people are to quote Zen Masters... it's almost like these people would have to go out of their way to avoid referencing Zen teachings no matter what the topic!

It's almost like new age dogen shamanic lsd meditation buddhists have some kind of... bias against Zen, right?

.

EDIT: You'll notice that there isn't much objection to what I say... no counter evidence, arguments or citations... and it's passed 100 comments so far...


r/zen • • Jul 17 '15

My name is Ken, AMA

2 Upvotes

Minna San Konnichiwa, my name is Ken.

Yoroshiku Onegai Shimasu ^

First a little introduction. Let me tell you about my journey so far

I’m a 29 year old American Zen Buddhist and Japanese culture enthusiast. I like to practice calligraphy (kanji) like "Mu" (無) on my tablet, and spend my days doing zazen whenever I can (I already reached the First stage of Bosatsu), and I do koan practice and even the occasional Zen archery.

But my main passion is my Blade. I train with my Katana every day, this superior weapon can cut clean through steel because it is folded over a thousand times, and is vastly superior to any other weapon on earth. I earned my sword license two years ago, and I have been getting better every day. I follow Bushido (Samurai) ethics to a T.

I speak Japanese fluently, both Kanji and the Osaka dialect, and I write fluently as well. I know everything about Japanese history and their Zen religion, which I follow 100%

When I get my Japanese visa, I am moving to Kyoto to attend a prestigious High School to learn more about their magnificent culture and about the Zen religon. I intend to become a Zen priest some day. Soto is fine, but Rinzai is more in tune with my love for Samurai culture and my somehow ... martial spirit, shall we say. Hehe.

I own several kimonos, which I wear around town. I want to get used to wearing them before I move to Japan, so I can fit in easier. I bow to my elders and seniors and speak Japanese as often as I can, but rarely does anyone manage to respond.

Wish me luck in Japan!

It's me


STANDARD AMA PART:

Not Zen? (Repeat Question 1) Suppose a person denotes your lineage and your teacher as Buddhism unrelated to Zen, because there are several quotations from Zen patriarchs denouncing seated meditation. Would you be fine admitting that your lineage has moved away from Zen and if not, how would you respond?

I don't have a lineage yet. I am moving to Japan for this very purpose, to find an authentic Rinzai Zen lineage, possibly with a history steeped in Samurai culture. I think only authentic lineages are valid. Dharma transmission documents can prove Satori. Without such documents, everyone can claim anything they want. I can say "I am a Sensei (doctor)" but if you come to cure your hernia or your eczema, you will want me to be certified, or you will say: "Baka! I'm not just gonna take your word for it! Prove that you're a real doctor." I remember my grandfather said, before he died: "Don't trust Eugene from across the street, don't let him touch you, he's not a real doctor!" - I wonder what he meant. But I digress. The primary Zen religious practice is sitting (Zazen) and strengthening Hara (KI).

What's your text? (Repeat Question 2) What text, personal experience, quote from a master, or story from zen lore best reflects your understanding of the essence of zen?

五輪書, without a doubt. ^ ^ (I think it's translated as "The Book of Five Rings" in English, but I don't like translations)

Dharma low tides? (Repeat Question 3) What do you suggest as a course of action for a student wading through a "dharma low-tide"? What do you do when it's like pulling teeth to read, bow, chant, or sit?

Energy Ki-practice. I usually go out and slash a bamboo tree with my Katana. The feeling of cutting what is essentially a tree - is sudden influx of Ki energy. I then do Mokuso, Susokan, to gather Ki in my Hara region, I chant 般若心経 (Hannya Shingyo for those of you who can't read kanji; btw. you should learn, it will improve your Zen study) - sometimes a little entertainment is OK, too. I suggest anime since anime has the spirituality of Japan written all over it. Western entertainment is poison. - Very hard to keep to Mu-mind while consuming Western culture.

Gassho


EDIT: Forgot to add as a response to Question 1 that I also practice Shinto - to boost my practice, I pray to the kami, mainly to Hachiman the God of War, also other spirits and gods of the Japanese pantheon, which I believe do actually exist and sustain my practice imbuing me with Ki. Please approach this topic maturely and with due respect.


r/zen • • Jun 16 '13

How I feel replying to self posts on r/zen. NSFW

Thumbnail
cdn.memegenerator.net
0 Upvotes

r/zen • • Feb 12 '13

Referendum on Moderator - EricKow

0 Upvotes

Is he doing his role properly? Do you think more moderators are needed to counter-balance EricKow's style of working.

He seems partial and slow to act. He allows ewk to run his course. He has earlier severely warned, to the point of kicking out taraingmobod (whatever his user name is, regulars know him). jamun was warned and he left out of sheer frustration. I found his koan postings more informative.

Add +1 if you approve current style of moderation

Add -1 if you disapprove of current stlye of moderation.

Add 0 if you are neutral.

  • If this post is censored or pulled out, EricKow will lose all respect *


r/zen • • Jul 10 '23

Nobody practices Zazen, everybody practices Zen: Religious BS vs Buddha Mind

1 Upvotes

By now everybody knows that modern the academic consensus is that Bielefeldt was right and Zazen prayer meditation Shikantaza was a Japanese invention that never had any historical or doctrinal connection to Zen.

Like any other kind of prayer, Zazen is fundamentally about make believe. You can't become a Buddha by meditation anymore than you can polish a brick into a mirror... a lesson learned by none other than Zen Master Mazu.

Mazu teaches that mind is Buddha. Nanquan teaches ordinary mind is the way. There's no make believe going on there. There's no secret method of activity.

Everybody already has ordinary mind. There's nothing to it. In that sense, everybody is already always doing Zen, even if they don't know it.

Even if they don't know it, everybody is already Buddha.

The people who do Zazen because some crackpot nutbaker messiah told them to aren't actually doing it, because it's not a real thing. Like praying to any number of deities,.there's no actual reality involved. It's all make believe.

See for yourself:

www.reddit.com/r/Zen/wiki/famous_Cases.


r/zen • • Oct 19 '15

Artist Rendering of Modern Day Zen Master Ewk

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/zen • • Oct 17 '24

Compassion for Dumb People

1 Upvotes

Huangbo famously defines compassion defines compassion in a way that's guaranteed to rub Buddhists and Christians the wrong way:

     Compassion is not conceiving
     of people as to-be delivered.

This means that you don't think of people as needing medicine.

You don't think of people is one cure away from not being losers.

Huangbo is saying that there isn't a treatment because there isn't a disease.

So when we're talking about religious bigots, book burners, people with mental health problems who come to this forum to trigger themselves and harass people, what is the compassion we show these people?

Religions wants them to change.

Religions want them to believe they can be different people.

Zen Masters like Huangbo see these people as not needing to be saved.

Empathy in Zen isn't sympathizing with other people's problems.

It's accepting people for who they are now, and not sugarcoating that or promising that it will change through faith.

When you meet someone who lies about what they believe, or lies about history, or lies about Zen, what is empathy?

It's keeping the precepts for the people who can't.

        EDIT 

I thought somebody would ask me about dumb... The reality is we're all dumb. That's why I don't do my own taxes anymore.

But understanding what you're dumb about, understanding who isn't dumb about it, and agreeing that you have to earn an opinion... That's how dumb doesn't equal suffering.


r/zen • • Dec 13 '23

Why aren't there lots of enlightened people on the Internet?

1 Upvotes

Meditation, which according to more than one church produces enlightenment, is wildly popular, having far more upvotes, forums, and articles about it than Zen, has yet to produce any enlightened people anywhere. In Zen's 1,000 year history in China www.reddit.com/r/zensangha/wiki/getstarted meditation was never credited with any enlightenments.

In fact, meditation seems to have the opposite effect of producing enlightenment, if we judge by the many sex predator scandals of meditation "masters", and the inability of their followers to #metoo out of that insanity: www.reddit.com/r/zen/wiki/sexpredators. All the people "enlightened" by sex predators became teachers, and kept claiming enlightenment even after their teachers were "retired" out of administrative positions.

But is that all there is to it? Meditation religions don't work?

No.

It's mostly an culture problem.

Listen to my verse:

Enlightenment isn't what you think it is.

If people are taught wrong then not only do they not get enlightened they don't know what enlightenment looks like

what Zen Masters teach

  • Turning freely in every direction (in public questioning, especially)

    • This was the reason Baizhang said, "Manifold appearances and myriad forms, and all spoken words, each should be turned and returned to oneself and made to turn freely." Going to where life springs forth, he immediately speaksi if you try to discuss it and seek it in thought, immediately you have fallen into the secondary phase.

    • At this time you do not fall into thought; in this situation you can, however, turn freely. - Hongzhi

    • When your insight penetrates freely and its application is clear, then when going into action in the midst of all kinds of complexity and complication, you yourself can turn freely without sticking or lingering and without setting up any views or maintaining any state, flowing freely: “When the wind blows, the grasses bend.” Yuanwu

  • Having nothing inside seeking for nothing outside (in public answering, especially) [Zhaozhou's Family Custom]

  • Meeting people where they are (in dialgoue, especially) [Wumen's instructional verse, Case 38 or something]

    • 路逢劍客須呈 Present a sword if you meet a swordsman; 不遇詩人莫獻 Don't offer a poem unless you meet a poet.

what people think

  • Keeping the wrong rules (sticking to mind pacification practice versus precepts keeping)

  • Kindness instead of honesty

  • Church affiliation instead of independence

enlightened eloquence

  • The majority of our records are from books of instruction written by eloquent enlightened people

    • Masters like Nanquan and Zhaozhou don't appear to have been good writers

    • Questions about enlightenment on the Internet are really about a subclass of eloquent enlightened, like Wumen, Yuanwu, and Wansong.

Zen is a threat to social order

There's lots of reasons to not promote Zen on the Internet.

  • Zen is anti-mysticism: "That which is before you is it, there is no other thing"

    • The people who start to practice doubt outside of churches fall quickly into the trap of "amorphous faith" that they invent themselves.

    • Mystics are uniformly illiterate. They can't speak or write persuasively, they only speak/write inspirationally. How many people can even persuasively argue the difference between the terms?

  • Zen is anti humanist

  • Zen is at least proto-intellectual, whereas anti-intellectualism is in favor in the West

    • It's not just the republican party... and the European Right... they represent half the society which informs the whole.

    • Looking at Yuanwu, Wansong, Wumen, Mingben, these dudes are not just educate, they are smart. You aren't going to get anti-smart people to upvote smart.

For enlightened people to get attention, they're going to have to have people who want to promote their content since the Internet is driven by likes.

But Zen is deeply opposed to what is liked by most people today and threatens the whole system of liking.

To separate what you like from what you don't like is a disease of the mind - Trust In Mind


r/zen • • Jul 01 '25

How does historical authentic Zen culture make your life better?

1 Upvotes

This is a question that comes up all the time and I'm still trying to figure out how to put it in layman's terms.

What is Zen culture?

Zen culture, historically, is (1) the Five Lay Precepts (2) The Four Statements Teachings (3) Zen's only practice, Public Interview

How do these things affect your life? Christians obey god to get to heaven, Buddhists do good deeds to earn merit for reincarnation, philosophers try to calculate what decisions will get them a good life. What do Zen students do, and what do they get?

Five Lay Precepts

In general, we all agree on not stealing, not murdering, and not raping. Or at least everyone understands the legal risks of these behaviors and the associated life wrecking financial consequences. Fewer people agree that not lying and not recreational drink drugging are essential rules, even if science agrees. Who cares about science? as a friend of mine likes to say.

The proof is in the pudding. Try the lay precepts six months and see what sorts of tangible costs and benefits you can actually measure.

But the hidden awesome benefit of trying to live your own version of the Lay Precepts is self awareness. Like a fitness boot camp, trying to keep the lay precepts teaches you who you are in a unique way. Do you have will power? Do you have self awareness? Do you have confidence to say "no" when people offer you a beer infused hot dog? Find out.

Four Statements

The Four Statements of Zen are in the sidebar, and religions and philosophies have nothing like them. Enlightenment can't be explained by people who have never experienced it. We all know that unless you've had an experience you can't understand it, but we don't admit this as a big part of life generally. Virginity. Addiction recovery. Foreign travel. College. Parenthood. Old age. All the big stuff is experiential.

Which means that when somebody, even someone claiming to have experience, tries to lay down the law on such experiences, doubt and skepticism are your best friends.

It turns out though that doubt a skepticism will protect you from a huge amount of stuff AND teach you whenever you use them.

Plus, marketing is just less effective on Zen students.

Public Interview

Nothing proves the point faster than asking questions. When someone can't explain why they believe, or what the belief is based on, or where a belief comes from? It's bogus. Multiple choice tests, that pillar of competence testing? It's a variation of public interview. Imagine if everybody who tried to sell you or convince you or recruit you had to do public interviews on youtube.

All you would have to do is click a link and you could figure out the truth for yourself.

But the flip side is also better than gold: when people ask YOU the hard questions, YOU benefit. You get to see how you perform against reality, not against your imagined dialogues. Real dialogue tests other people, but it also gives you a chance to see if your beliefs and ideas really work in the real world.

Zen?

From the self-awareness of the precepts to the skepticism of the Four Statements to the Testing of public interview, Zen clearly offers things that religions and philosophies don't. But these are skills, not enlightenment. Which means you get these skills regardless if you don't get enlightened or even don't meet an enlightened person. For religions and philosophies, the benefits are after faith, not before it.


r/zen • • Feb 15 '22

500+ Years of Zen Masters tell you: Meditation doesn't work

0 Upvotes

500 Years of Zen telling you not to "practice" meditation?

Huineng, 700

Around 700 CE, Huineng went out of his way to reject sitting meditation as an effective practice for anybody, for any reason:

The Master said, "Stopping the mind and contemplating qui-etude is pathological; it is not [Zen]. Sitting all the time constricts the body—how does it help toward truth?Listen to my verse:

"During life it will sit, not lie;

After death it will lie, not sit:

A set of stinking bones—

How can it establish success?"

.

Patriarch's Hall, 900

We found an old text in a monastery in Korea dated to 900. It's called Patriarch's Hall. It is obviously discussing teachings before 900 that reject a variety of meditation methods because the goals of these practices are not Zen:

Patriarch's Hall: "Just be natural in accordance with our mind, do not engage in the practice of insight and do not stop your mind['s] activities"

Translator: naturally exist',is an important term in the text and accordance with one's original mind. This state is often contrasted lo 'artificial attainments which are achieved by traditional practices such as meditation,performance of good deeds,the reading of Buddhist scriptures, etc.

["insight"] refers to a certain type of meditation, ' introspection' which is part of the traditional Buddhist meditation practice of 'concentration and introspection refers to the practice towards a state of tranquility and mental peacefulness which is the basis for meditation.

'stop the mind' refers to a traditional meditation practice [and] following techniques: (1) contemplation on the impurities of all dharmas; (2) contemplation on the arousal of compassion; (3) contemplation on the fact that all dharmas are interdependent (cause and effect); (4) insight, discernment of the interaction between senses, sense-objects and consciousness; (5) contemplation on the process of breathing (often by counting) in order to calm down the confused mind. The practice of the 'five stops' was traditionally combined with the above mentioned technique of 'concentration and introspection'.

.

Wumen, 1200

Then, more than three hundred years after that, from Wumen's book of instruction in Zen Wumen's Checkpoint, we have this warning from Wumen:

Zen Master Wumen: To unify and pacify the mind is quietism and false Zen.

and

Sitting blankly in Zen practice is the condition of a dead man.

Welcome

Welcome! ewk comment: If Zen Masters test meditators for more than five hundred years and conclude that meditation in general is a waste of time?

Why are people coming in here talking about how meditation is going to be useful to them?

It isn't historically accurate, it isn't honest... but most of all, it ignores the fundamental evidence of the real world: Meditation has never worked for anybody.

.


r/zen • • Jan 12 '23

Zen is not Buddhism or Zazen: Huangbo's car keys, Original Enlightenment, and Sudden Awakening

2 Upvotes

Zen Master Huangbo

Mind cannot be used to seek something from Mind; for then, after the passing of millions of aeons, the day of success will still not have dawned. Such a method not to be compared with suddenly eliminating conceptual thought, which is the fundamental Dharma.

Suppose a warrior, forgetting that he was already wearing his pearl on his forehead, were to seek for it elsewhere, he could travel the whole world without finding it. But if someone who knew what was wrong were to point it out to him the warrior would immediately realize that the pearl had been there all the time.

So, if you students of the Way are mistaken about your own real Mind, not recognizing that it is the Buddha, you will consequently look for him elsewhere, indulging in various achievements and practices and expecting to attain realization by such graduated practices.

Where are your car keys?

Suppose you put the keys in your coat pocket and forgot about them. You originally have the keys (and the vehicle!). But people telling you Buddha-Jesus knows where you keys are, or Santa-Dogen will bring you the keys if you practice Zazen prayer-meditation enough, these methods will never work. The keys are in your pocket. No amount of seeking for the keys outside of your own coat is going to prevail. A thousand years could pass, nobody would ever find those keys looking everywhere else.

Suddenly your spouse reminds you

When somebody tells you your keys are in your pocket, you have to look in the pocket to verify it. You have to be able to take the keys out and use them in front of people to actually have the keys in a meaningful way.

This doesn't mean you didn't always have the keys, in terms of the keys on being anywhere else, but it's one thing to have them in your coat and another to have them in your hand.

Buddhism and Zazen prayer

Buddhists believe to get the keys you have to follow a specific method that only Buddha-Jesus knows. Zazen prayer worships believe their messiah, Dogen, invented the only key finding method, and they keys are only ever found when your priest loans you the church car. These are doctrinal questions, matters of faith for those religions.

Zen Masters saying "your keys, your car, your coat, figure it out" sounds like a doctrine *when compared to Buddha-Jesus and Santa-Dogen, but really it's just about your keys to your car being in your pocket. It's not a doctrine in the context of Zen, but only looks like a doctrine to people with religions of magic hide-a-key.

.

µ ^Yo͞ok  Welcome! Meet ^me  My comment: We seem to be getting more people with no experience of Zen in this forum lately and they get upset that there is no magical key finder, no magical keys, and nobody helping them feel better about the grocery store closing.

So I'm posting this for them.


r/zen • • Sep 22 '25

Zen is for Quitters!

1 Upvotes

If you never win and you never quit?

https://newsroom.haas.berkeley.edu/uc-berkeley-haas-researchers-uncover-a-psychological-bias-that-keeps-people-on-the-wrong-path/

“People don’t like to feel that what they did in the past was a waste, so they end up wasting more time in the future,”

When we wonder why people don't quit Zazen or chanting or believing in karma or going to places with altars or claiming that cults aren't cults, it's more about psychology than it is about reason

Zen Masters on stuff that don't work

For example,. meditation (including Zazen)

Foyan: sit[ing] on a bench with your eyes closed, rigidly suppressing body and mind, like earth or wood. That will never have any usefulness, even in a million years."

Zhenjing: There is also a kind of Chan follower who is charmed by those foxes, even with eyes open, not even realizing it themselves. They wouldn’t object even if they poured piss over their heads. You are all individuals; why should you accept this kind of treatment? How should you be yourself?

where are the people that religion works for?

where's the evidence of faith helping anybody?

High school book reports? Always FTW

Huangbo: "Since you are fundamentally complete you should not try to supplement that perfection by such meaningless practices."

Just read a book. Then you'll know what it says.

Practical strategies include:

Reframing past efforts as part of the discovery process rather than a waste of time

Preserve earlier work in some way—for example, putting deleted paragraphs into a separate document for possible future use so they’re not simply discarded.

Define waste in terms of the future, which is all that can be changed, instead of the past, which is fixed


r/zen • • Oct 18 '15

Zen Poll. Upvote if sitting is an essential part of Zen, Downvote if Sitting has nothing to do with Zen.

5 Upvotes

r/zen • • Sep 20 '25

Why is Zen so against new age/Zazen?

2 Upvotes

A 2005 study published in Personality and Individual Differences the first attempt to explore the cognitive and personality correlates of New Age practices and beliefs.

The team of Oxford University psychologists behind the study discovered a correlation between New Age practices and beliefs and schizotypy, characterised by:

  • magical thinking - the belief that unrelated events are causally connected, despite no plausible causal link existing between them.

  • a disposition towards looseness of associations - a lack of connection between different ideas, resulting in disorganised thinking.

  • emotional hypersensitivity - type of emotional dysregulation that results in low frustration tolerance, impulsivity,

How do Zen Masters reject that stuff?

  1. Capable of Conversion: Conversation hinges on casuality. "Only give your own opinion when you've gone beyond Buddha".

  2. Zen koans are records of public interview practice. How can there be public interviews of disorganized thinkers?

  3. "Low frustration tolerance" describes tons of famous Zen failures.

Many of us have had experiences with people in this situation. It's important to note that:

Schizotypy is not, in and of itself, a mental health problem. In psychology, it is seen as a set of personality traits in the general population, and it involves a continuum of traits and experiences,


r/zen • • Jun 25 '21

The Only Two Opinions of r/Zen

0 Upvotes

There are only two opinions of this forum, and it entirely depends on what you read.

  1. Illiterates: People who read religious stuff like Thich Hahn, "Zen and xyz", anything about meditation, anything about mindfulness, anything about improving your life, anything about hacking anything, anything about Buddhism.

  • They are shocked to find out Buddhists lie about history more than Christians

  • They are offended that Zen Masters don't give a @#$# about faith, practice, or "good ideas"

  • They get really angry when their ideas of peace, kindness, and tolerance aren't compatible with Zen.

  • They are confused about why you have to read a book to study something "not found in books"

  1. Zen Students: People who have read ANY Zen sayings, let alone a Zen instructional text: www.reddit.com//r/zen/wiki/getstarted

.

There are people who think they have a third opinion of the forum, but when asked for the book report that proves that there is a third opinion, they can't cite sources or quote references.

This also explains why there are two opinions: Reading and writing at a high school level. All the complaining about this forum from subs like r/zens, r/zen_minus_ewk, r/zenbuddhism, r/zendo, begins and ends with a refusal to discuss high school book reports.

.

It only further confuses everyone when the illiterates turn out to be college educated, or even college teachers, or even college teachers of Buddhism. But facts are facts, people... if there can be hundreds of years of college educated Christians and Christians with Phds lying about historical facts, then it can certainly happen to "Buddhists".

Facts matter.


r/zen • • Nov 02 '12

"Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind" is a book of faith-based Buddhism. It is not Zen.

0 Upvotes

I read this book because it has been recommended several times around here.

The author, Shunryu Suzuki, makes it clear that the center of his Buddhism is desire. He talks about value of a desire for transcendence, the importance of the desire for purity of mind, the values that guide the desire for (what he perceives as) Good, and the desire to attain Rightness. He contrasts good desires or right desires with evil and negative desires. All of this diverges greatly from the Patriarchs and Zen Masters.

Shunry Suzuki's Dogen-centered Buddhism focuses on attaining a freedom from the bad while keeping the good, whereas Zen is concerned with absolute freedom. Shunryu Suzuki makes this explicit when he says, "The purpose of our practice is to cut off the karmic spinning mind." In contrast Zen Masters encourage something subtly different, not a cutting off, but a non-attachment that considers that cutting off itself is a desire as much as what is being cut off.

What Shunryu Suzuki is talking about in this book is a religion, a "Quietism" religion. His process of reasoning, the authority for his arguements, his expressions of faith, his discussion of the purpose of zazen - all of it is religious in origin and nature. Faith: He says that "Our practice is based on this faith." Authority: He says, "We are just Buddhists, we are not even Zen Buddhists." Purpose: "It is impossible to attain absolute calmness of our mind without any effort." Calmness of mind is Quietism, and Quietism is not Zen. He suggests that zazen practice will increase the calmness of daily life. Mental calmness is not the freedom of the Zen Masters.

Shunryu Suzuki says that attainment is a result of practice with right effort. Attainment, practice, right effort, this is not Zen. He says that practice is the purpose and expression of his religion. He says that attainment is both a consequence and manifestation of practice. Zen has no purpose and no expression. In Zen there is nothing to attain, there is no improvement, there is nothing to prefer. In Shunry Suzuki's religion there is a purpose, although he says that if you do zazen to achieve enlightenment, you won't. He says, "Do not try to attain anything" but this is not the same as in Zen, which is "There is nothing to attain." In his religion there is attainment, even if the path is not found through trying to attain it. In Zen there is no attainment.

There is no indication in this book at all that Shunryu Suzuki was a Zen Master, apart from the title his religion gave him. Within the context of his religion he uses the word Zen and some of the language and imagery that Zen has adopted from the religions, but not much more. There is no question that he was an admired and trusted man, a good man, a religious man. Zen is not concerned with admiration, goodness, or religion.

He discusses the importance in his religion of having a teacher. Every religion has this value, although most religions do not call them "teachers". Religions value this personal contact with religiously trained monks or priests precisely because one cannot learn to think from the perspective of the dogma or develop "right practice" without guidance. Zen has a history of solitary people because there is no dogma and no faith and nothing to practice. Shunryu Suzuki explains clearly that zazen practice is best with a teacher who facilitates the student's journey. There is no such facilitation in Zen.

Finally, his comments about zazen bear a remarkable similarity to Western discussions of religious prayer. The benefits of zazen are much like the benefits of some kinds of prayer, both have a need to pursue the activity regularly, both are concerned that having a purpose invalidates the process, both are a surrendering of the self to an activity, both are means of dealing with adversity. His discussion of bowing bears some of these same "prayer" hallmarks. None of this is Zen.


r/zen • • Feb 13 '18

What do Dogen Buddhists and other content brigaders really want? Legitimacy.

1 Upvotes

You know why doctors say they practice medicine rather than Yeti Telepsychic Healing? Because medicine is legit, and Yeti Telepsychic Healing is not.

You know why Yeti Telepsychic Healers sometimes claim they are doctors who practice medicine rather than admit they are Yeti Telepsychic Healers? Because medicine is legit, and Yeti Telepsychic Healering is not.

Dogen claimed he studied Zen because he wanted to legitimize his new religion. Content brigaders from r/newage, r/buddhism, r/meditation, and r/psychonauts want the same thing. We get self certified this, shamanic that, tantric whatsis, and psychic visions whosis in here because they want the legitimacy of the Zen legend... not because they want to talk about Zen legends.

Zen is unquestionably legit. Cases from Zhaozhou and Dongshan stop people in their tracks.

Recently somebody claimed that focusing on Dongshan and Caoshan and Zhaozhou and Wumen and Yangshan and Guishan and Yunmen and Deshan and Mazu and Wansong was "narrow" and "fundamentalist".

But nobody says that r/medicine is "narrow" or "fundamentalist" for talking about medicine instead of Yeti Transpsychic Healering.

Read a book: /r/Zen/wiki/lineagetexts.


r/zen • • Dec 28 '18

I am a Real Buddhist Monk. Ask me anything.

2 Upvotes

I am an American. Living in Thailand.

I am 25.

I have studied Zen for around 4 years and have practiced/retreated with Soto/ Rinzai Zen, Seon, Thien, and Chan masters.

Any aggressive comments will be handled with compassion.

A sword of peacefullness and an eye of detachment.


r/zen • • Sep 26 '20

Why Zen Masters reject meditation: Science provides clues

3 Upvotes

People who experience religous conversion often vote and content brigade in this forum, violating the Reddiquette in an attempt to make their meditation religion and meditation in general seem more legit.

It is important to remember that these people may be suffering from mental impairements caused by meditation, and not simply religous trolls with an anti-historical narrative and a pocket full of hate.

Relevant studies:

  1. https://www.newscientist.com/article/2251840-mindfulness-and-meditation-can-worsen-depression-and-anxiety/

  2. https://qz.com/1307380/yoga-and-meditation-boost-your-ego-say-psychology-researchers/

  3. https://aeon.co/amp/essays/mindfulness-is-loaded-with-troubling-metaphysical-assumptions

This all raises the question, "Were Dogen's sex predatoring "Masters" suffering from mental illness? https://www.reddit.com/r/zen/wiki/sexpredators

Zen Masters reject meditation because it doesn't lead to Enlightenment... https://www.reddit.com/r/zen/comments/gatr39/zutang_ji_a_whole_page_of_900_era_zen_masters/

But given how meditation was a part of monastic culture throughout China, it seems unlikely that Zen Masters weren't aware of the dark dark downside of meditation worship.

When we ask "Why don't religous meditation people have a forum on Reddit and end up content brigading here?" it may be that they just aren't up to it.


r/zen • • Sep 25 '20

Is Meditation Buddhism always anti-Zen? Yes, and here's why:

0 Upvotes
  1. Meditation Buddhism and Zen don't have a common textual history:

  • The three books written by Zen Masters, Gateless Gate, Book of Serenity, and Blue Cliff Record rarely speak about meditation.

  • The core text of Meditation Buddhism is FukanZazenGi, and it is mostly directions for people on physical posture and breathing.

  1. Meditation Buddhism and Zen don't a common doctrinal basis:

  • Zen Masters teach sudden enlightenment, not based on practices, virtues, or refinements.

  • Meditation Buddhism combines practicing prayer-meditation and Buddhist refinement doctrines like 8FP and 4NT.

  1. Meditation Buddhism and Zen don't have common traditions:

  • Zen has traditions based on Dharma Interviews, recorded in thousands of pages of Sayings and instruction.

  • Meditation Buddhism has traditions involving discipline and monastic vows.

  1. Meditation Buddhism has never found an audience, r/zen has 95k subscribers.

  • Meditation Buddhists often leave r/zen as soon as they find it. Others adopted multiple accounts in an attempt to circumvent Reddiquette restrictions against content brigading.

  • Zen students are interested in discussing Zen teachings, historical facts, and the practical demonstration of Zen views.

It isn't just a matter of Meditation Buddhists saying "pay attention to our religion, not to Zen Masters", which would be a kind of passive anti-Zen.

It's more a matter of Meditation Buddhism being very much interested in sitting quietly, which is antithetical to the core tradition in Zen of the Dharma Interview.


r/zen • • Feb 11 '13

Why does every answer in Zen reduce to "fuck you"?

5 Upvotes

Because the Real is not amendable to distinctions, which OTOH is a necessity to formulate a direct answer.

The Real is also a notable source of terror, in particular, the abyss is deeper the more you try to accost it with distinctions. Which is also why you can't find Zen, which is situated entirely within the Real, by symbolic thought: You're inflicting an aversion of yourself on yourself.

Thus, asking a question, like, say, "Does feeding ice cream to a dog expose its Buddha nature", is exerting tangible mental agony on the asked, and thus the answer to every Zen question, and, in the same spirit, the answer to this question and all complaints about /r/zen looking like it does, is:

Fuck you.

What did I mean by "reduce", though? I meant that the answer is not "Fuck you", only that it reduces to "Fuck you". "reducing" is an act of interpretation, that is symbolic thought, and therefore outside of the scope of a Zen transmission. That is,

Not Zen.


r/zen • • Jan 06 '12

Serious discussion: Why do you think Taoism influenced Zen?

0 Upvotes

Again, this is a serious discussion and I'd really like to have facts here. I've tried discussing with you these, but the discussions have become personal attacks, please don't turn this into that. Also please try to read this all before downvoting (or upvoting). For simplicity's sake I'm not expanding much my facts, but whatever you want me to give you a background of I can do.

Other than historical probable coincidence in time and space, I'd like to ask you for factual evidence of Taoism influencing Zen Buddhism. Core influence, not "well, they use TCM in China". Core value influence enough to say that Zen was created as a son of Buddhism and Taoism.

Here are my facts:

There's no eternal tao in Zen. Tao is translated to "path", "way" or "form". And for example the noble eightfold path is called Ba Zheng Dao (or Pa Zheng Tao). That's the only tao there is in Zen/Chan, and has nothing to do with the eternal tao. There's no conception of such.

There's no philosophical alchemy base (waning and waxing of ying and yang, extreme points, all of these which is philosophical alchemy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_alchemy#Yin_and_Yang).

There's no duality (agan, Ying and yang) which then translates to unity. And in fact, in Buddhism there are warnings about the illusory nature of duality.

There's no longing for balance or "natural state", in fact, a sense of balance or "natural state" it's only an attachment to your ego, because the universe is always in balance and can never be unbalanced, and only your ego can be egoist enough to think he can claim things are unbalanced from it's point of view.

The only coincidence that I've seen so far, and it's not a philosophical, disciplinary or moral coincidence is that Guanyin, as Avalokiteśvara is known in China, is also revered in Taoism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guanyin) as an Immortal. And this is an influence of Buddhism to Taoism, not Taoism to Buddhism.

Zen's beginnings are recognized with Gautama's speech in which he was supposed to give a speech to 10000 people. When he came in, he picked up a flower, showed it, and then left. At that moment Mahakasyapa enlightened. This is the beginning of Zen. Bodhidharma (Tamo) the founder of Zen was in the lineage of Mahakasyapa.

Zen is a translation of Dhyana (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhyāna_in_Buddhism), so Zen begins much before Taoism and is more or less of the same age of Confucianism, so Zen wasn't "invented" when Tamo traveled to China, but was something he was already carrying with him. What Tamo actually did was founding a school of buddhism specialized in Zen.


As a bit of a background to the beginnings of Zen in China as I was told (if you don't want to believe it I'm ok):

Zen is brought by Tamo to China, as a response to a challenge that was in India: Many people had tried to implement buddhism in China, but had failed to do so in a way that it would spread thru all China, and the monastic community wasn't pleased with it. So the challenge was, that the one who volunteered to the task of spreading Buddhism in China would have to succeed, or else, he would have to be dismembered. So Tamo took the task.

When he came to China, since Chinese were reluctant and harsh people he offered them the toughest form of Buddhism, which is Zen, and particularly, Tamo's Zen school. As an example of the harshness of Zen he once was meditating at his cave in Song mountain in Henan, China and fell asleep. He, disappointed by his failure cut his eyelids.

Another example of Zen's hardness is when Huike asked him to be his disciple. Tamo didn't want a disciple; so after much insistence he told Huike that he would take him as a disciple when the snow were red. Huike realizing that this would never happen and since he couldn't harm other beings, what he did was cut his own left arm and spread the blood all over the snow. When he showed Tamo, Tamo welcomed him as his first and only disciple because Huike had understood the true essence of Zen Buddhism.

The history of China and Zen/Chan is filled with many examples like this, there was also once a monk who was given the task to reach enlightenment in two days by the emperor of China or else this monk would be executed.


Conclusion

Zen/Chan is the toughest school of buddhism. My point is: Boddhidharma(Tamo) was a full ordained master of the law monk who didn't need teachings or influence from anyone, and he wouldn't accept it because his path was his own. His lineage died after 6 generations and there's a saying that it was foretold, but that's up to you to believe it or not.

There was Buddhism already in China, and Zen had existed long before Tamo and before Taoism, is as old as Confucianism and as old as Gautama's teachings itself. Tamo taught Zen/Chan, which was the true hit of Buddhism in China and in all Asia because of it's harshness. But Zen was before Tamo, Zen was with Tamo already like it's taught until today, only diverging in the sects that come from Chan.

Yes, the two cultures have met many times, but the influences are not core influences. Both practices (Taoism and Buddhism) are still very different and would be misleading, naive and ignorant to think that they are "interchangeable" in any part.

Edit:

If no evidence is there other than conjectures to face the facts that I'm quoting here, I'd like to ask you to consider that this thought of Zen is Taoism with Buddhism is actually a fallacy. I've been practicing Buddhism for 4 years now with my master, and I firmly think that seeing Taoism as Buddhism and viceversa is an obstacle and a illusion in your path, because I did think so myself once and I realized it stopped me from advancing in my Buddhist path, and I think it's likely that this will happen with you. I love and respect Taoism and like many works an practices of Taoists, but in order to study it and respect them both, Buddhism and Taoism, I think it's the most accurate and true thought to know that these are very different paths and conduct to very different goals.


r/zen • • Sep 14 '22

r/Zen has a problem

4 Upvotes

All over the internet, definitely all over Reddit, people love to complain about r/Zen being a bunch of out there loonies who are out of touch with the real world... one assumes the "real world" is those who follow these people and practice Buddhism.

Since I know a few of them lurk periodically in this forum (how else could you morally justify hating on somebody unless you knew what they said?) I thought I would point out how r/Zen doesn't have a problem... the haters have a problem:

  1. Dogen not a Zen Master, Zazen prayer-meditation was never a Soto Zen practice

  • Bielefeldt proved the origins of Zazen prayer-meditation weren't Soto Zen in his book Dogen's Manuals of Zen Meditation.

  • Sharf acknowledged in 2014 that Zazen prayer-meditation was an indigenous Japanese practice in the view of non-sectarian scholars.

  • This means Dogen lied repeatedly (as well as plagiarized) in FukanZazenGi, and throughout his later career.

  1. Can't define Buddhism and say what Buddhists believe? You can't claim Zen is part of any category you can't define as your definition of Zen.

  • r/Zen goes out of it's way to quote Buddhists, including the genius Hakamaya: www.reddit.com/r/zen/wiki/buddhism. Zen haters can't say the same about Zen Masters.

  • "Zen is all about" is a phrase people use when they can't quote Zen Masters... and it's just as bigoted as "Japanese culture is all about" or "Feminism is all about" or "Black/Gay/Indigenous/Immigrant/Communism is all about". Be ashamed more.

  • The intellectual integrity of r/Zen critics is very much on the line... if they have different standards for different forums? That's dishonest. If they can't keep the precepts? They don't represent Zen.

  1. Zen's nearly 1,000 year WRITTEN TRADITION OF INSTRUCTION is not "stories", not "riddles", not "designed to confuse", that's all a product of racist and religiously bigoted anti-historicism... please stop.

  • Again, 1,000 years of writing is more than Buddhists have, more than Christians have, more than Dogenists have.

  • 1,000 years of writing is not something you can dismiss based on your own ignorance.

  • 1,000 years of writing is going to take some subject matter expertise to unravel, so let's not pretend some priests or anybody who can but won't translate "無" is an expert.

NOBODY anywhere on the internet provides a counter argument to this stuff, and NOBODY on Reddit even dares bring it up. As I've said before, facts take awhile to change people's minds.

.

Here endeth the rant.

Be fair if you can't be awesome.


r/zen • • Dec 27 '24

Do you think you're enlightened? Met an enlightened person?

1 Upvotes

why people think enlightenment

The West has very little experience of Zen and most people who think they experience Zen enlightenment are having a religious experience much like Christianity. In fact, Buddhist Christian and other religions have common elements of the religious Revelation.

  1. Experience of awe

  2. Unfathomable truth of a teacher

  3. Sense of wonder at transformation

religious experiences are fragile

Yeah, when we look at the public behavior of people who have religious experiences, we see something very different from what we see in this end tradition.

  1. Avoid public confrontation

  2. Discussed in small groups; supportive/ inclusive

  3. Can be shaken by public scrutiny and mockery

  4. Truth coming from within is valued

What Enlightenment does

Regardless of the psychological aspect of what zen Masters experience and that they tend to say very little about it, the public behavior of Zen Masters after this experience is remarkably different.

  1. Constant public confrontation

  2. Experience not discussed at all. Almost irrelevant.

  3. Not shaken even in defeat, eager to engage in mockery of self, lineage, religion, philosophy, everything really.

  4. Freedom is valued over truth

Why Zen Masters love books

It can be weird to mix these two groups together. The religious group feels attacked and insulted. The Zen master group feels indignant and unfairly imposed upon.

The Zen record is full of the Zen tradition handling this, throwing people off bridges, burning statues etc. and the problem is that it's not a contest at all . Zen Masters always win. In general, people who studies in without enlightenment can apply Zen teachings to achieve very similar victories against religious people.

What's a Zen master to do for a challenge?

Zen masters love to test themselves against their tradition because there are really no other worthy opponents, and certainly nowhere the number of worthy opponents that we find in the exhaustive historical record of Zen koans.

This book loving aspect of Zen culture also explains why the conflict with religious experience is so thematic and perpetual:

Religious experience is often the first step in a transformative process.

Zen enlightenment is more often associated with embrace of reality over transformation, clear-Sightedness over inate mysticism.

queue Nanquan

Nanquan said to a Buddhist lecturer "What Sutra are you lecturing on?"

The Buddhist replied, "The Nehan Sutra."

Nanquan said, "Won't you explain it to me?"

The Buddhist said, "If I explain the sutra to you, you should explain Zen to me."

Nanquan said, "A golden ball is not the same as a silver one."

The Buddhist said, "I don't understand."

Nanquan said, "Tell me, can a cloud in the sky be nailed there, or bound there with a rope?"