r/medicine • • Nov 22 '21 Bravo

A detailed description of how you die from COVID in the ICU

8.1k Upvotes

Good morning.

I squeeze your hand.

“It’s Friday at 9 o’clock in the morning.” I look out the window. “Gloomy day. It rained last night.”

You say nothing, because you’re chemically paralyzed and deeply sedated. All the drugs in the world to keep you from trying to breathe. My machine does it much better than you ever will.

I look over the fingers on your left hand. They’re falling off. You’re so sick that I was forced to choose your brain and your bowels to get blood instead of your fingers and toes.

Later that day, I take a long camera and put it down the tube breathing for you. I need to get some of the mucous in your lungs out. I quietly apologize for moving around your tube. It’s in your neck now, a surgically created hole, because the tube in your mouth caused your tongue to bleed. Your heart rate on the monitor shoots up. You’re paralyzed, but this is hurting you. I can tell by your heart rate. I ask your nurse for more medications to drip through your IVs. Please go back to sleep.

I watch your nurse troubleshoot your new kidneys. Except it’s a machine, your kidneys, because they stopped working from the weeks of toxins I gave you to try to keep you alive.

I’m not sure, but you probably don’t know who you are anymore. Your brain is so confused by the forced paralysis, the forced sleep, the inability to think, that you’ve become lost. Who are you?

Your family wants you to live, as every loved one wants for their person, so every day I watch your body die a little more. Every day I add a new medication to stave off the inevitable. A new side effect. You haven’t had a bowel movement in weeks. Your body is starving.

Eventually, your immune system and your body can’t fight off the bacteria living in your own body, your own skin, the normal things in the air. The bacteria take hold. They start using your blood to grow. They fill up your lungs with their damage. I add more medications.

I watch your last weeks alive. I watch your organs fail. I watch your fingers fall off. I watch your skin stop being able to protect your muscles and fat and just wear away in places. I watch your last few weeks alive, not knowing who you are, forcefully keeping you asleep. I hope you don’t feel this.

In 25 days, I will tell your family that despite every possible forceful thing I can do to keep you alive, your last little bit is now dying too. It might be your heart, starved for oxygen and trying so hard to keep up that it finally couldn’t squeeze any more. It might be your brain, where weeks of dying finally gave you a stroke.

If they’re kind, your family will tell me to keep you asleep and let you die. If they don’t believe me, I will spend my last moments with you watching someone crack every rib in your chest. A demand to your broken body that I can no longer demand. Stay alive.

I am angry for you. I am angry someone lied to you. I am angry that you were taken advantage of, for reasons I will never understand.

If you have not been vaccinated against COVID-19, this is how you die from it.

Please reconsider. You are wrong. Please give the small part of you that whispers, maybe I have been lied to, give it a chance.

Do not die like this.

-a tired ICU fellow.


r/medicine • • Jan 08 '26 Helpful Thanks This Heartwarming Bravo

To the physician that tried to check a pulse in Minneapolis today

5.0k Upvotes

Thank you for being human in an inhumane situation. I am so sorry you were forced to stand there and do nothing. What happened to this woman and her family is unthinkable. There is a lot of secondary trauma occurring here that we can’t even imagine. I could hear it in your voice, just saying the words “I’m a physician”. I don’t know how I would react in this situation, but I think you did everything you could without risking additional deaths. The scene was just not safe. I just want you to know that you are seen and appreciated. I hope you have a few minutes to talk to someone about all this because we need physicians like you to be ok.


r/medicine • • Mar 26 '20

3 Days of Inpatient Care in New York

5.0k Upvotes

Day 1.

3 COVID cases in a census of 14 (one hospitalist called out sick today so I got to spend my morning scrambling to get caught up with the new adds).

49M with no significant PMH who tested positive for COVID. Fever and DoE for a couple weeks now. A couple weeks. Now it’s at rest too, which brought him in.

He was desatting to the high 80s on 2L O2, nurse bumped it to 4L. SpO2 mid 90s now. He feels fine so long as he doesn’t get out of bed.

His lungs sound like shit, bilateral basilar rales to about a third of the way up. Nurse is concerned and I’m concerned that he’s heading towards ARDS. So I do the typical CXR and ABG so I can at least get a baseline if he goes south.

I found out later that to minimize exposure, we shouldn’t get serial imaging or labs more than once a day. Oh, and BIPAP doesn’t help apparently so the progression is just maxing out O2 on a nonrebreather then proceeding directly to intubation. Do not pass go, do not collect $200, just straight to the tube.

The hospital is receiving 3-4 extra non-COVID patients from another hospital that is already maxed out. Already.

The other residents not already scheduled for inpatient or the ICU got told to expect to be mobilized to come in.

I’m terrified.

I’m going to do what I can to protect my team as the senior. I’m going to make COVID cases volunteer only, or I’ll see all of them myself and write the notes.

All I want to do is go home and cry and go to sleep.

Day 2

“Queens is drowning, it’s underwater.”

All hands on deck meeting with the medical director of the hospital. Went over the new guidelines (which change daily) about the number of transferred patients we’re getting from maxed out hospitals, and everything from personal protection equipment, to the shitty disposable stethoscopes in the rooms, to COVID management, to the fairest way of splitting up positive COVID cases among the hospitalists. Lots of back and forth on the idea of COVID-only rounders vs evenly splitting up the cases. They flat out said the extra Residents would be working a COVID only service.

I chimed in asking how long it was before we are a COVID MAJORITY hospital, at which point this becomes moot. I figure it’ll be with the next 2 days.

37 confirmed positive COVID patients. 17 rule outs. 7 COVID patients on ventilators. (Overall census is low too, only 139 active cases because we’ve been kicking out the not-too-ill.)

2 confirmed on my census, 2 highly likely pending, 1 low likely.

One of those high-likely is 29.

Had a curbside consult with an ICU attending.

Med redditors: I’ve now heard from both a pulmonologist and ICU attendings who say unlike your typical septic patient, COVID cases should be dry before they need to be intubated. And having patients self prone can improve SpO2 by 5-10%.

Oh and when I said one my patients is hypoxic on high flow O2 and might need to be intubated, he asked her age (88), flat out said she’d never get off the ventilator and then darkly implied that we’re close to a point where “decisions” would have to be made.

...

Last night, immediately after I got home I vomited from the anxiety of the day. Held it together that long at least.

Day 3.

Code Blue right off the bat at 7:35. COVID in the ICU, transferred an hour earlier from another maxed hospital. From the chart: 66F with DM2, CAD, HTN. 5 days of cough and body aches, a little short of breath. She was seen by an ED physician just after midnight two days ago. Within 8 hours she had crashed and required intubation. Multifocal pneumonia with positive COVID. Officially admitted to that ICU 24 hours later. Transferred to our ICU 24 hours after that, and 1 hour later her Discharge Note for the Expired Patient was written.

She marks the first COVID patient I’ve seen die.

The anxiety I felt a couple days ago isn’t so bad now. It’s clear there was no avoiding this mass casualty event. Now there’s just work to do.

The thing about intubating a COVID case is it’s a high risk droplet bomb going off around the guys and gals most needed right now: intensivists, anesthesiologists and those badass ICU nurses who are all needed to tube people whose lungs are filling up with fluid. Hospitalists might be able to pick up the slack, but they haven’t the same muscle memory.

So as I’m watching this woman die in her closed glass box of an ICU room, a grizzled doctor with the swagger of an old intensivist says to no one in particular, “Is that a confirmed positive? Not going anywhere NEAR there!”

A nurse over to my left says, “We shouldn’t have to Code cases like this.” And it’s not with the same tone as “This is pointless,” it’s “This puts us in danger for nothing.” I stay out of the room, the extra manpower of one extra resident won’t be worth the PPE for chest compressions. But my chief resident is in there.

He’s a good guy; hope he doesn’t get sick.

(As I write this, I get a call that one of my patients has died. Non-COVID, was in denial about her metastatic cancer, COPD, CHF progressively worse shortness of breath but still wanted to be intubated. She got her wish and died within an hour or two still.)

Then a Rapid Response at 7:56. Then a Rapid Response at 8:01. Then a Rapid Response at 10:30. That last one was for the patient I just mentioned who passed, we put her on BIPAP and loaded her up with Lasix. Then a Rapid Response again at 12:30, again for my patient, watched the intubation occur. There was a minor discussion of where to put her, since the ICU and CCU were full. We’re in the process of transitioning the SICU into another ventilator bay.

Lunch arrives sometime after 13:00. Here’s one silver lining to all this: the community has gone out of its way to shower us with food. My lunches and dinners (residents know to always raid the hospitalists’ office and grab a plate before heading home to crash) have been Mediterranean chicken kebobs on Sunday, chicken piccata on Monday, and pizza today. It genuinely raises moral.

Another Rapid as I’m talking to some other residents and wolfing down a slice. Most of these Rapids have been for non-COVID cases. The ones that are about COVID cases turn into intubation events.

I was wrong yesterday when I predicted we’d become a majority COVID case hospital in 2 days. We crossed the 51% threshold today.

I was naïve when I thought I could volunteer for the resident-run COVID wing so that one less of my fellow residents would be put at risk. We’re all at risk. So now we have 3 residents and an outpatient attending looking over 10 confirmed COVID cases.

My census of 13 today has 5 confirmed and 1 suspected COVID patients. I wish we could make these cases voluntary, but all we can do now is limit exposure and spread out the cases somewhat.

I get a call that our 88 year old COVID patient is desatting on 6L supplemental O2 via nasal canula. So we put her on a non-rebreather. I get a call that she’s desatting down to the mid-80s when talking in long sentences despite the 100% oxygen she’s receiving via mask. The nurse is spooked, and the current plan is to do a Full Code should she tank. So the patient and I get to have The Talk.

The Talk is basically asking people if they want to receive (often futile) CPR that cracks their ribs as they die, or if they would prefer to be attached to machines when they die. But I don’t put it like that. I say things like “chest compressions” and “a plastic tube down your throat” but made it clear that if she were to be sedated for the intubation, she may never wake up. And despite our plans and treatments, her body is taking actions that will most likely (but we can never say guaranteed) going to end her life. Not today, but it’s a good time to put things in order.

The patient said her daughters want everything to be done for her, but she doesn’t want to be on machines when she dies. I said that was reasonable. She asked me what I would do, and what I would want for my mother.

I’m not proud of this next part.

I told the truth. I said that my mom and I have worked in medicine, and she would never want to be intubated if it was a long shot she’d ever recover. I told her I recently only rescinded my own Do Not Intubate order because were I to get COVID and need intubation, I’m a young, healthy guy who could survive it. But were I hit by a truck and braindead, I’d never want to be intubated. She said she’d call her daughter back and explain things.

I get a call later saying this very sharp 88 year old lady has signed the form declaring her Do Not Resuscitate / Do Not Intubate.

Intubation would have been the wrong choice here, I believe that. And I only told the truth (which I usually avoid by saying things like “it’s not for me to make you decide either way.”)
I helped the patient make her personal wishes count at the end of her life so she could die on her terms.

But, in the back of my head, I was also thinking I saved the nurses from having to witness a pointless and traumatic CPR and I saved one likely-inevitable ICU bed and a ventilator.

…

I don’t feel like writing anymore today.


r/medicine • • Dec 11 '20

Help! A doctor in my hometown was kidnapped by the police and tortured.

4.8k Upvotes

Well, here goes nothing, I hope this gets at least some visibility so doctors outside of Mexico find out what it's like to work here. I'm afraid it'll be a long post since I couldn't find any news in English, I'll link to a source in Spanish at the end if someone would like to read it first-hand.

Dr Azucena Calvillo works with critically ill COVID patients at the ICU in a public hospital in Durango, México; last Friday she left her job at around 8:30pm and her family lost track of her. Local medical colleges started sharing her data and a picture in case anyone saw her or knew anything regarding her whereabouts. Later that same day we found out she had been taken by the local authority; they put her in a safe house and tortured her, then she was imprisoned without a trial.

Medical Colleges now nationwide started raising their voices and she was released and thankfully is now home; however, she's still being charged with attempted murder, at least she's not in jail anymore...

They're accusing her of trying to murder a magistrate who was under her care in the ICU under mechanical ventilation, suffering from severe COVID-19. The prosecutor's office claims she came into the hospital outside her work hours and tried to shut off the man's ventilator, but the alarm went off and she ran away. We're talking about a 34 year old female internist who's been battling this disease for more than 9 months, putting herself and her family at risk, with a spotless record.

They claim to have video evidence of her leaving the room, and her car being in the parking lot at that time; however all you can see in the video is someone clad from head to toe in PPE, impossible to even determine with full certainty that it's a female. Off this evidence she was taken without a warrant into police custody, due to legal reasons they've yet to reveal how exactly she was physically tortured, but what we know for sure is they threatened to kill her, her husband who is a nurse working in the same hospital and her daughter if she didn't sign a confession, or if she dared speak about what happened.

Why her? No clue, apparently she had a recent argument with the magistrate's sister who's also State Delegate of Tamaulipas Social Security Institute (IMSS), basically a very influential person. Apparently that was her mistake, antagonising someone powerful.

So that's basically it, I tried to keep it as short as possible, if you want more details or you can read Spanish here's a link to the story

Hope this gets some visibility, because it's a terrible situation.

Edit: Sorry, not health secretary, was a mixup on my part she's IMSS' delegate

Edit 2: UPDATE: All charges have been dropped, but now it seems no one is responsible, so the colleges are still pushing for consequences for those involved in the kidnapping; it's all real shady, but at least now she is not at risk of losing her freedom again. Thank you everyone for your support and your interest in the matter. Apparently protests will continue, I'll keep you all updated

UPDATE 2: There was a march yesterday and there's now a change.org petition moving around asking for the prosecutor's destitution The marches will keep up until there are consequences for those responsible for her kidnapping


r/medicine • • Apr 22 '26 Helpful Thanks Bravo Regret Heartwarming

How things are going in America…

4.6k Upvotes

Today I had a patient, who I have not seen for over a year, send me a MyChart message out of the blue. She has been uninsured for about a year, which is why she has not been able to come in for any appointments. She is not currently taking any meds (because, you know, no insurance). She has two special needs kids who have had to ration care because of expense.

She was able to get a job with Walmart, but her benefits don’t kick in for 90 days. So she can’t come in because, despite having a job, doesn’t get insurance until her other benefits kick in. The kicker to all this though, is she wasn’t even messaging me about her meds. She was wondering if I could write her a note so that she could have a chair or a stool available to her while she is checking customers out. She had spinal fusion surgery 4 years ago and can barely stand for any amount of time. So, instead of just letting her have a seat, Walmart required her to ask her doctor for approval, despite not providing any insurance to see said doctor.

And yes, I did write her the letter.

Update: Apparently the letter wasn’t good enough. I now have to complete paperwork for the ADA claim that was filed on her behalf. Remember, this is so she can sit on a stool or chair while working at the checkout register…


r/medicine • • Dec 29 '21

Powerless [Rant]

4.6k Upvotes

Last week I picked up a really sad case. He's a 31 year old man paraplegic from a gun shot wound he suffered in 2014. He's poor and black. Most of our patients are wealthy and white. He was admitted almost 8 weeks ago with for acute on chronic sacral osteomyelitis and has been on piperacillin-tazobactam and minocycline basically since then. My first day meeting him we were short staffed due to holiday coverage, and I had 23 patients on my census so I did not have the time to explore his chart. I read through the novella-length progress note written by the previous hospitalist and was able to gather the basics. The plan I inherited was to find an orthopedic surgeon at another institution who'd perform hip disarticulation or possibly hemipelvectomy. The big academic shop in town apparently recently lost their surgeon who did those, and the smaller academic shop has a guy who does it but "only for oncologic indications" (???) according to the note. The hospitalists before me had tried a few other centers and identified a list of candidate surgeons, most of whom had declined. The last remaining candidate is a few hours away, and documentation indicates that my colleagues have faxed the records for review and consideration for transfer. The note contains a phone number for me to call and follow up. I call and get a nurse who confirms they have the records but informs me the surgeon is out of town for Christmas but he'll be back Monday (yesterday) so please call back then.

I go meet the patient, a very polite and extremely sarcopenic young man. Always "Yes, sir," and "No, sir." I introduce myself and explain that I'll be picking up where the prior hospitalist left off. I explain that I called the transfer center and we're waiting to hear from a surgeon who's out of town, so please just relax over the holiday weekend and I'll let him know as soon as I hear anything. I examine his wounds and see that our wound care team is doing a great job, everything looks clean and freshly bandaged. He has temporal wasting. His calves are as big around as my wrists. I have difficulty auscultating the chest due to the sunken intercostal spaces. I tell him I'm sorry he'll be spending Christmas in the hospital but that I'll be seeing him each day and I'm happy to help him feel more comfortable in any way I can. He tells me his pain is well controlled.

The next day is Friday, Christmas Eve. I go in to see him with no updates and start making small talk. Football is on TV. He tells me he's a Tom Brady fan, and I joke that I can forgive him one wrong opinion. I look down at him and imagine our positions are reversed. He's one year younger than I am, slowly rotting to death in a hospital bed on Christmas Eve. I haven't seen a single visitor. He tells me he spoke to his 7 year old daughter on the phone. He tells me her name.

"Well...Is there anything you can think of that would make your day a little better?"
"I was hoping to get some of that jambalaya from the cafeteria. Or just something good to eat."
"What's your favorite restaurant around here?"
"I like Papa John's."

I ask him what he likes from Papa John's, and he rattles off his usual order complete with the dipping sauce he likes. I can tell he doesn't have much joy in life, and a favorite meal is something he can control and look forward to. A small piece of joy in an otherwise miserable existence, living from dressing change to dressing change. The nurse picks the order up from the front door and gets it to him.

The next day when I see him, he's eating leftovers and watching TV. He thanks me repeatedly, making eye contact each time so I know he means it. I tell him we're just holding the course until we hear from the medical center and thank him for his patience with me. I start him on topical ketoconazole for the dermatophyte infection on his face. After six weeks of broad spectrum IV antibiotics, and due to his chronic inflammation, he is significantly immunocompromised. He hasn't showered at least since he was admitted, just bed baths from the techs.

Finally Monday rolls around and late in the afternoon I get a call back from the medical center. The orthopedic surgeon tells me this is the first he's hearing of this patient and they have no records, oh and by the way he doesn't do that surgery. He usually sends patients to my city for it.

Fuck.

Holiday coverage ends and our staffing improves, so now I'm only following 18 patients and I have a few minutes to make sure I understand his hospitalization. I read that he presented with abdominal pain, and CT showed osteomyelitis of both ischial tuberosities, and of his left proximal femur. He had a left hip fluid collection thought to represent septic arthritis from direct invasion of the joint space by his unmanaged decubitus ulcers. Plastic surgery evaluated him when he came in and said he was not a candidate for sacral flap coverage unless he agreed to diverting colostomy. The patient, presumably dissatisfied with his already cachectic and broken body, was not interested in this idea. Eventually with ongoing pressure from several teams, he agreed to go for it. The plastic surgeon had signed off by that point, so the hospitalist re-consulted him for flap now that the colostomy was in place. Inexplicably, the plastic surgeon says he is not a flap candidate and instead recommends hemipelvectomy or pelvectomy by someone else.

I'm reading through all of the above history just moments after getting turned down by the orthopedic surgeon who practices few hours away, and in the back of my mind I'm remembering the questions the patient has been asking me -- "How is this going to heal?" It dawns on me that perhaps no one has told this young man that we're working to get him transferred to a place where the plan is to cut one or both of his legs off.

Today I went in to his room and told him we had some things to discuss. I ask him what he understands about our goals in transferring him to another hospital. He believes the idea is to "fix the bone."

"Did anyone tell you that the plan is to find a surgeon who will cut your leg off?"

He immediately starts crying. He is blindsided by this. We talk for 45 minutes. I can tell he is getting upset with me, but really he's upset with the situation. We agree on a new goal which is to try to find a surgeon who will consider him for flap coverage. Today I called every academic medical center within 500 miles. Not only do they not have any beds, they won't even offer wait list placement.

So tomorrow I'm going into work as a hospitalist. Completely useless to this man who needs a surgical procedure. All my consultants signed off weeks ago after collectively deciding it was someone else's job to give the patient his prognosis and options. I consulted palliative care so at least he can have continuity with someone who will advocate for him after I go off service. When I started telling the story to the palliative care physician, I unexpectedly started crying and could barely steady my voice to give the facts.

I'm angry, I'm sad, I'm useless to my patient. I look at him and I see a society that doesn't give a flying fuck about poor people, black people, or gun violence. Compare him to the 5 wealthy white patients I've had with traumatic paraplegia (and quadriplegia) the last few months. They all survived into their seventies or longer. They all have round-the-clock care. They don't have decubitus ulcers. They're not rotting to death alone in a hospital bed on Christmas while some useless fucking hospitalist like me flails about worthlessly and to no effect.

Edit: Thanks everyone for your support and suggestions. I alerted administration of the case and also developed a plan with the patient. Much of our efforts right now are confounded by COVID-19. I hope we have a plan to get him his second opinion. It was my last day on service with him. We hugged.


r/medicine • • Mar 24 '20

Dr. Usama Riaz has spent weeks screening, treating coronavirus patients even then he knew PPE was not available. He lost his battle today. Remember his name. He was 26.

Post image
4.4k Upvotes

r/medicine • • Mar 19 '20

There is no emergency in a pandemic

4.4k Upvotes

I was asked to repost this with the news of 13 Italian doctors dying from COVID-19. If you do not have proper PPE, do not go in. No matter what.

This post is for my healthcare workers, docs, surgeons, Nurses, aids, and ems, and all staff.

There is no emergency in a pandemic

You as a healthcare worker are a force multiplier. Your training and experience is invaluable moving into this crisis. So, you're going to be faced with some very difficult moments. You're going to have to put your needs first.

I'm speaking specifically about PPE and your safety.

If you're an ICU nurse, or an ICU doc, and you become infected, not only are you out of the game for potentially weeks (or killed) But your replacements could be people without your expertise. Your remaining co workers are short staffed now, more likely to make mistakes and become ill themselves. You stop being a force multiplier and start using healthcare resources.

You going in may save the patient, it may not. But you cant save any patients in the weeks you're laying in a hospital bed or using a vent yourself.

People are going to die. Do not become one of them.

There is no emergency in a pandemic.

During the Ebola outbreak, people were dying. But at no point did we rush in, we took the 10 minutes to put on our PPE with our spotter. If we didn't have proper PPE we did NOT go in.

There is no emergency in a pandemic.

You may work in long term care, and want to rush in to save a patient you have had for years. Do not go in without your PPE

There is no emergency in a pandemic.

You may have a survivor in the room, screaming at you to come in because their mother is crashing. Do not go in without your PPE.

There is no emergency in a pandemic.

You may have an infected woman in labor. Screaming for help. Do not go in without your PPE.

There is no emergency in a pandemic.

You may have A self qaurentined patient with a gun shot wound and is bleeding out. Do not go in there without your PPE

There is no emergency in a pandemic

Doing nothing may be the hardest thing you've ever had to do in your life.

Many of you say, I could never do that. I wouldn't be able to stop myself from rushing in and saving my patient.

Liberian nurses and doctors said the same thing, and many did run in to help, saying PPE be damned. My patients need me.

Then they became infected, they infected others. And they died. They didn't help anyone after that.

Do not let the deaths of hundreds of healthcare workers be forgotten.


r/medicine • • Jul 31 '25 Gold Blast Heartwarming Galaxy Brain Bless Up

Today, I was a hero

4.3k Upvotes

A family came in with their 2mo. And they were very hesitant about vaccines. "Which ones are really important?"

So I went through each disease for which the child would be vaccinated today.

  • I told them about diphtheria and the 30% mortality rate, how diphtheria toxin is one of the most toxic substances known, as a single molecule can kill a cell. I told them about how this disease use to terrify communities.

  • They'd already heard of tetanus. Everyone has heard of tetanus.

  • I told them about pertussis and the baby I saw who coughed and coughed and coughed and coughed and coughed...until he went into laryngospasm. We did everything we could. I will never forget his mother throwing herself at our feet begging us to not say what we were going to say. I let that family see the tears playing in my eyes as I described the memory. They needed to know that I am doing this because I fucking care. Not because of some quality metric.

  • We'd already discussed how hepatitis B is spread by nonsexual transmission and how in the prevaccine era, as many as 65% of infants born to HBV positive fathers had HBV by the tme they were a year old. We talked about how that is a life sentence before age 1.

  • They know about polio.

  • I talked about the baby I watched die of pneumococcal sepsis. Another mother at our feet. Another family destroyed by a microbe.

  • I described a cricoidotomy in graphic detail.

  • I was admitted for rotavirus in February of 1979. I still have the hospital bill for $20. My mother told me about how sick I was. And 25 years later, I became a resident and I saw babies with rotavirus. You could hear the diarrhea from across the emergency department. We had to do our own IVs at the NYC hospital. The babies were just so sick and all we could do was keep them hydrated and wait for them to recover. And then in the fall of 2006 the rotavirus vaccine came out. And in February of 2008 I was the senior on the floor and... there weren't any rotavirus kids. It was just gone.

And I asked that mother, now that she'd asked me which vaccines were important, I was going to turn the questions around. Which ones did she think were important?

That baby got every recommended immunization today. I won. RFJ Jr. lost. The parents won; that mother won't be throwing herself at my feet.

Most importantly, the baby won.

-PGY-21


r/medicine • • Oct 07 '20

My residency program thinks very highly of me as an individual

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

r/medicine • • Mar 08 '20

Testimony of a surgeon working in Bergamo, in the heart of Italy's coronavirus outbreak

4.2k Upvotes

«In one of the non-stop e-mails that I receive from my hospital administration on a more than daily basis, there was a paragraph on "how to be responsible on social media", with some recommendations that we all can agree on. After thinking for a long time if and what to write about what's happening here, I felt that silence was not responsible. I will therefore try to convey to lay-people, those who are more distant from our reality, what we are experiencing in Bergamo during these Covid-19 pandemic days. I understand the need not to panic, but when the message of the danger of what is happening is not out, and I still see people ignoring the recommendations and people who gather together complaining that they cannot go to the gym or play soccer tournaments, I shiver. I also understand the economic damage and I am also worried about that. After this epidemic, it will be hard to start over.

Still, beside the fact that we are also devastating our national health system from an economic point of view, I want to point out that the public health damage that is going to invest the country is more important and I find it nothing short of "chilling" that new quarantine areas requested by the Region has not yet been established for the municipalities of Alzano Lombardo and Nembro (I would like to clarify that this is purely personal opinion). I myself looked with some amazement at the reorganization of the entire hospital in the previous week, when our current enemy was still in the shadows: the wards slowly "emptied", elective activities interrupted, intensive care unit freed to create as many beds as possible. Containers arriving in front of the emergency room to create diversified routes and avoid infections. All this rapid transformation brought in the hallways of the hospital an atmosphere of surreal silence and emptiness that we did not understand, waiting for a war that had yet to begin and that many (including me) were not so sure would never come with such ferocity (I open a parenthesis: all this was done in the shadows, and without publicity, while several newspapers had the courage to say that private health care was not doing anything).

I still remember my night shift a week ago spent without any rest, waiting for a call from the microbiology department. I was waiting for the results of a swab taken from the first suspect case in our hospital, thinking about what consequences it would have for us and the hospital. If I think about it, my agitation for one possible case seems almost ridiculous and unjustified, now that I have seen what is happening. Well, the situation is now nothing short of dramatic. No other words come to mind. The war has literally exploded and battles are uninterrupted day and night. One after the other, these unfortunate people come to the emergency room. They have far from the complications of a flu. Let's stop saying it's a bad flu. In my two years working in Bergamo, I have learned that the people here do not come to the emergency room for no reason. They did well this time too. They followed all the recommendations given: a week or ten days at home with a fever without going out to prevent contagion, but now they can't take it anymore. They don't breathe enough, they need oxygen. Drug therapies for this virus are few.

The course mainly depends on our organism. We can only support it when it can't take it anymore. It is mainly hoped that our body will eradicate the virus on its own, let's face it. Antiviral therapies are experimental on this virus and we learn its behavior day after day. Staying at home until the symptoms worsen does not change the prognosis of the disease. Now, however, that need for beds in all its drama has arrived. One after another, the departments that had been emptied are filling up at an impressive rate. The display boards with the names of the sicks, of different colors depending on the department they belong to, are now all red and instead of the surgical procedure, there is the diagnosis, which is always the same: bilateral interstitial pneumonia. Now, tell me which flu virus causes such a rapid tragedy.

Because that's the difference (now I get a little technical): in classical flu, besides that it infects much less population over several months, cases are complicated less frequently: only when the virus has destroyed the protective barriers of our airways and as such it allows bacteria (which normally resident in the upper airways) to invade the bronchi and lungs, causing a more serious disease. Covid 19 causes a banal flu in many young people, but in many elderly people (and not only) a real SARS because it invades the alveoli of the lungs directly, and it infects them making them unable to perform their function. The resulting respiratory failure is often serious and after a few days of hospitalization, the simple oxygen that can be administered in a ward may not be enough. Sorry, but to me, as a doctor, it's not reassuring that the most serious are mainly elderly people with other pathologies. The elderly population is the most represented in our country and it is difficult to find someone who, above 65 years of age, does not take at least a pill for high blood pressure or diabetes.

I can also assure you that when you see young people who end up intubated in the ICU, pronated or worse, in ECMO (a machine for the worst cases, which extracts the blood, re-oxygenates it and returns it to the body, waiting for the lungs to hopefully heal), all this confidence for your young age goes away. And while there are still people on social media who boast of not being afraid by ignoring the recommendations, protesting that their normal lifestyle habits have "temporarily" halted, the epidemiological disaster is taking place. And there are no more surgeons, urologists, orthopedists, we are only doctors who suddenly become part of a single team to face this tsunami that has overwhelmed us.

The cases multiply, up to a rate of 15-20 hospitalizations a day all for the same reason. The results of the swabs now come one after the other: positive, positive, positive. Suddenly the emergency room is collapsing. Emergency provisions are issued: help is needed in the emergency room. A quick meeting to learn how the to use to emergency room EHR and a few minutes later I'm already downstairs, next to the warriors on the war front. The screen of the PC with the chief complaint is always the same: fever and respiratory difficulty, fever and cough, respiratory insufficiency etc ... Exams, radiology always with the same sentence: bilateral interstitial pneumonia. All needs to be hospitalized. Some already needs to be intubated, and goes to the ICU. For others, however, it is late. ICU is full, and when ICUs are full, more are created. Each ventilator is like gold: those in the operating rooms that have now suspended their non-urgent activity are used and the OR become a an ICU that did not exist before. I found it amazing, or at least I can speak for Humanitas Gavazzeni (where I work), how it was possible to put in place in such a short time a deployment and a reorganization of resources so finely designed to prepare for a disaster of this magnitude. And every reorganization of beds, wards, staff, work shifts and tasks is constantly reviewed day after day to try to give everything and even more. Those wards that previously looked like ghosts are now saturated, ready to try to give their best for the sick, but exhausted. The staff is exhausted. I saw fatigue on faces that didn't know what it was despite the already grueling workloads they had. I have seen people still stop beyond the times they used to stop already, for overtime that was now habitual. I saw solidarity from all of us, who never failed to go to our internist colleagues to ask "what can I do for you now?" or "leave that admission to me, i will take care of it." Doctors who move beds and transfer patients, who administer therapies instead of nurses. Nurses with tears in their eyes because we are unable to save everyone and the vital signs of several patients at the same time reveal an already marked destiny. There are no more shifts, schedules.

Social life is suspended for us. I have been separated for a few months, and I assure you that I have always done my best to constantly see my son even on the day after a night shift, without sleeping and postponing sleep until when I am without him, but for almost 2 weeks I have voluntarily not seen neither my son nor my family members for fear of infecting them and in turn infecting an elderly grandmother or relatives with other health problems. I'm happy with some photos of my son that I look at between tears and a few video calls. So you should be patient too, you can't go to the theater, museums or gym. Try to have mercy on that myriad of older people you could exterminate. It is not your fault, I know, but of those who put it in your head that you are exaggerating and even this testimony may seem just an exaggeration for those who are far from the epidemic, but please, listen to us, try to leave the house only to indispensable things. Do not go en masse to make stocks in supermarkets: it is the worst thing because you concentrate and the risk of contacts with infected people who do not know they are infected. You can go there without a rush. Maybe if you have a normal mask (even those that are used to do certain manual work), put it on. Don't look for ffp2 or ffp3. Those should serve us and we are beginning to struggle to find them. By now we have had to optimize their use only in certain circumstances, as the WHO recently recommended in view of their almost ubiquitous running low. Oh yes, thanks to the shortage of certain protection devices, many colleagues and I are certainly exposed despite all the other means of protection we have. Some of us have already become infected despite the protocols. Some infected colleagues also have infected relatives and some of their family members are already struggling between life and death. We are where your fears could make you stay away. Try to make sure you stay away.

Tell your family members who are elderly or with other illnesses to stay indoors. Bring him the groceries please. We have no alternative. It's our job. Indeed what I do these days is not really the job I'm used to, but I do it anyway and I will like it as long as it responds to the same principles: try to make some sick people feel better and heal, or even just alleviate the suffering and the pain to those who unfortunately cannot heal. I don't spend a lot of words about the people who define us heroes these days and who until yesterday were ready to insult and report us. Both will return to insult and report as soon as everything is over. People forget everything quickly. And we're not even heroes these days. It's our job. We risked something bad every day before: when we put our hands in a belly full of someone's blood we don't even know if they have HIV or hepatitis C; when we do it even though we know they have HIV or hepatitis C; when we stick ourselves during an operation on a patient with HIV and take the drugs that make us vomit all day long for a month. When we read with anguish the results of the blood tests after an accidental needlestick, hoping not to be infected. We simply earn our living with something that gives us emotions. It doesn't matter if they are beautiful or ugly, we just take them home. In the end we only try to make ourselves useful for everyone. Now try to do it too, though: with our actions we influence the life and death of a few dozen people. You with yours, many more. Please share and share the message. We need to spread the word to prevent what is happening here from happening all over Italy.»

Sources:

Original Facebook post

Italian newspaper (Corriere della Sera, edizione di Bergamo) transcript

EDIT: updated sources with original FB post


r/medicine • • Feb 22 '20

Scrubbing into a CABG with your mom as your attending

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

r/medicine • • Apr 24 '16

He is small for an eight-year-old boy, made even smaller by the big trauma room gurney beneath him...

4.1k Upvotes

He is small for an eight-year-old boy, made even smaller by the big trauma room gurney beneath him. Two skinny, sunburnt legs stick out from a pair of much too large, frayed, hand-me-down cutoffs. Green grass stains cover the skin of both knees. His bare feet are filthy, farm boy filthy. The kind of filthy that comes from playing in the cool dirt of an old barn floor, from running through uncut fields of wheat alongside the combines, and from climbing the giant hay bales that dot the rolling hills this time of year.

Two hours ago he was just another shirtless boy in a cowboy hat playing in the wheat.

His mother stands across from me. She is perhaps thirty-two. She has sandy blonde hair, just like the boy on the gurney. I can’t see her face because it is buried in her husband’s chest. She is completely silent but her whole body shakes, trembling like an old John Deere combine with something stuck in its blades. Her husband pulls her tight, his arms wrapping around her, trying to protect her from this place, this moment.

The two of them clutch to each other, here, in my emergency room.

At the head of the bed the ventilator chimes and puffs and clicks along as it pushes air into the boy. It pushes air into lungs that collapsed and now have chest tubes draining them. Lungs that cried out just loud enough to stop thirty thousand pounds of combine from turning the boy into chaff with the wheat.

The boy’s arm twitches. The nurse next to me blinks back tears and adjusts his IV.

A case like this is a bomb that detonates in our ER, in our town, in our lives. The shockwaves right now are spreading as neighbors call neighbors, as friends call friends, as family reaches out for family and parents run to check on their children. I know I will not be the only one unable to sleep tonight.

The father stares at his son on the gurney. His face is filled with questions for which I have no answers. How can this happen? How can something we love, something so full of life, be so fragile, so vulnerable, so easily cut down and taken from us in the blink of an eye?

He does not know it yet but he is now standing in a new life. A life that will always be different from the one he woke up to this morning.

I step over to the computer to order some more sedation for the boy while we wait for the helicopter. Taped above the screen is a brand new sign. It is a decal of five gold stars. It seems so out of place at a moment like this. The last few weeks the hospital has been putting them up everywhere. They are there to remind us to give ‘five-star’ service- to tell our patients how much we appreciate their business and hope they will choose us for their future healthcare needs.

They are to be called customers now, not patients, we are told.

Customers.

I tear it off the screen and wrinkle it in my hand into a ball, squeezing it tight. I shove it in the pocket of my white coat.

Twenty-two minutes later the whine of the helicopter engine fills the air as it prepares for takeoff. I stand outside with the father, watching the big blades spin up to speed in the late August light. Inside the helicopter there is room enough for only one parent to go with the boy. One hundred and three miles away a pediatric ICU bed is waiting.

The helicopter lifts off and a cloud of late summer dust fills the air. The father does not move as the debris cloud swirls about his head. Instead, he stares at the window on the side of the helicopter, the dark outline of his son just visible to us both.

We watch the helicopter rise above the pad and rotate slowly. It climbs a little further, hesitates in the air, and then races off above the wheat fields, the grains below bowing from the thrust of its blades.

I take out the five-star decal from my pocket, unfolding it carefully. I tear it in two and press the larger half against the brick wall behind us. I scribble my home phone number on the back.

“Let me know,” I say.

The father takes the paper and nods, still staring at the shrinking outline of the helicopter. At last it disappears over the mountains in the distance. He turns to me but his eyes are empty now. He is already departing, already arriving at the next place. We shake hands and he walks slowly off to his truck. He’s got a long, quiet drive to the city ahead of him.

I look down at what’s left of the ripped up decal in my hand.

The image of the boy burns bright in my mind. I know I will carry this day with me for a very long time.

I make a fist, crumpling the decal.

I respectfully disagree with those who want us to call them customers, healthcare consumers, or business opportunities.

The people we care for are sons and daughters. Mothers and fathers. Husbands and wives. They are neighbors, friends, and sometimes even colleagues.

They are people like you and me in a moment of need.

They are patients.


Addendum:

When I wrote this I thought maybe a couple dozen people would want to discuss it. I had no idea it would blow up like this. A couple short points:

  1. I really appreciate everyone's comments and insights- from the administrators, to the patients, to others in healthcare. I have learned a great deal just from reading your posts and I hope others have too. Those of you who share your insights and experiences with others are truly the best of reddit.

  2. To those determined to find and dox the boy in the story I say this: You are welcome to keep trying but you won't find him. Out of respect for my patients and because of HIPAA I always change enough details of anything I write in a way that makes it impossible to find the individual while staying true to what happened. I will say the original patient who inspired this story several years ago ended up fine.

  3. To those of you who asked if I have written anything else I wrote a book of short stories about being an ER doc in a small town. It's here if you are interested. http://goo.gl/7mzn2P

Thanks again for reading and for everyone's input.


r/medicine • • Apr 25 '20

This man has definitely had a huge impact on your practice. Rest in peace Dr. Burton Rose, the founder of UpToDate. Another victim of Covid-19

Thumbnail
statnews.com
4.1k Upvotes

r/medicine • • Aug 24 '21

The vaccine mandate was the last straw. I gave notice to my employer today.

3.9k Upvotes

To start with, I am fully vaccinated. I will probably get my third dose in the next few weeks.

I work in a small conservative rural town providing primary care exclusively to Medicaid patients. I live in a big city 200 miles away and for the last five years, have commuted to this job to work M-W. The clinic I am at was stood up after the ACA’s Medicaid expansion to give patients a PCP instead of having them rely on frequent visits to the ER. I have loved this job. I work three days a week. The pay is great. I get to care for the poor and underserved. I like to think I have made a pretty big difference in the community.

COVID has come with its stressors. Being a small conservative community, I have heard every conspiracy theory possible about COVID. Everyday it is me trying to educate and push back against the misinformation. Everyday is a fight to get people to wear masks (including coworkers). Everyday is a futile attempt to get people to get vaccinated. I have a panel of a thousand patients and to my continuing horror, I have only been able to talk one patient that was on the fence into getting the vaccine.

I have vials of vaccines in the medication fridge ready to go but nobody to wants them.

Nobody believes COVID is real or a serious issue. It is all a big “libtard” conspiracy. Yet this county has one of the highest infection rates in the state.

The supervising physician, the medical assistants, and the office manager are all unvaccinated. There is a second PA but they had a bad reaction to the first shot and never went back for the second. I am literally the only person in the organization that is fully vaccinated. They have refused to get vaccinated and have had no plans to get vaccinated. In fact, they have dissuaded patients out of getting the vaccine. I keep working there despite this because I think I am doing good for my patients and the community and feel compelled to “fight the good fight.”

Last week, our governor announced a mandate that all teachers and healthcare workers get vaccinated (barring legitimate medical exemption).

Today, the office manager told me that they may have to close the clinic down because none of them are willing to get vaccinated. They would rather shut things down and abandon the patients and our service to the community than to “get the jab.”

I gave notice today. I can’t work there anymore. I am at a point where the pay and perks aren’t enough. I can’t argue about it anymore. There is no educating or persuading. I just can’t do it.

I have pretty much lost all faith in people.

Edit: Wow. Thank you for the support! Last night was a little raw. It was nice to wake up and read this. Well... back to the clinic for a few more weeks. The grind goes on. :)


r/medicine • • Jan 29 '17

Hours After Landing in U.S., Cleveland Clinic Doctor Forced to Leave by Trump’s Order

Thumbnail
propublica.org
3.8k Upvotes

r/medicine • • Jan 24 '26 This Regret

VA Nurse murdered in Minneapolis

3.8k Upvotes

r/medicine • • Oct 22 '21

Clinical pearl - If your male patient says “I feel fine but my wife made me come in”, it has a positive predictive value for serious illness that is close to 100%

3.7k Upvotes

r/medicine • • May 11 '20

Typical day in the COVID unit

3.7k Upvotes

A lot of people have been asking me what it's like being on the COVID wards in the hospital, so I figured I'd share what a typical day looks like for me:

6am - Wake up. Roll off of my pile of money that Big Pharma gave me. Softly weep as it doesn’t put a dent in my medical school loans

6:30am - Make breakfast, using only foods from the diet that gives me everlasting life by avoiding all fats, sugars, carbs, and proteins. For details buy my book and check out my shop.

7am - Get to work, load up my syringes with coronavirus before rounds.

8am - See my patients for the day. Administer the medications that the government tells me to. Covertly rub essential oils on the ones I want to get better.

9:30am - Call Bill Gates to check how 5G tower construction is going, hoping for more coronavirus soon. He tells me they’re delayed due to repairs on the towers used to spread the Black Plague. Curse the fact that this is the most efficient way to spread infectious diseases.

10am - One patient tells me he knows “the truth” about coronavirus. I give him a Tdap booster. He becomes autistic in front of my eyes. He’ll never conspire against me again.

11am - Tend to the secret hospital garden of St. John’s wort and ginkgo leaves that we save for rich patients and donors.

12:30pm - Pick up my briefcase of money from payroll, my gift from Pfizer for the incomprehensible profits we make off of the free influenza vaccine given every year.

1pm - Conference call with Dr. Fauci and the lab in Wuhan responsible for manufacturing viruses. Tell them my idea about how an apocalypse-style zombie virus would be a cool one to try for the next batch.

2pm - A patient starts asking me about getting rid of toxins. I ask her if she has a liver and kidneys. She tells me she knows “the truth” about Big Anatomy and that the only way to detoxify herself is to eat nothing but lemon wedges and mayonnaise for weeks. I give her a Tdap booster.

2:45pm - Help the FBI, CIA, and CDC silence the masses. Lament the fact that I can only infringe on one or two of their rights. Oh well, there’s always tomorrow.

4pm - One of my rich patients begins to crash. Laugh as I realize I’ve mismatched her spirit animal and zodiac moon sign. I switch out the Purple Amethyst above her bed for a Tiger’s Eye geode. She stabilizes. I throw some ginkgo leaves on her for good measure

6pm - Go onto YouTube and see coronavirus conspiracy videos everywhere. Curse my all powerful government for how inept they are at keeping people from spreading “the truth”

6:10pm - Go onto Amazon and see that a book about “the truth” is the #1 seller this week. Question the power of my all powerful government. Make a reminder to myself to get more Tdap boosters from the Surgeon General next time we talk.

7pm - Time to go home. Before I leave, sacrifice a goat to Dr. Fauci and say three Hippocratic Oaths.

9pm - Take a contented sigh as I snuggle under the covers made of the tinfoil hats of my enemies, realizing that my 4 years of medical school and 3 years of residency training have been put to good use today.

Credit given where it is due: https://www.facebook.com/1555110237/posts/10217399602852760/?d=n


r/medicine • • Jan 30 '21

I think I have enough comment karma now... I painted my current feelings about outpatient medicine in the COVID era. "Plague Doctor (Self-Portrait)."

Post image
3.6k Upvotes

r/medicine • • Mar 15 '20

One Pager on COVID-19

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

r/medicine • • Mar 31 '20

3 Days of Inpatient Care in New York: The Story of You

3.5k Upvotes

You're a reasonably healthy guy in your mid 50s.

Sure, you had a health scare when you were in your mid 30s, a pretty big scare come to think of it. You had some chest pain whenever you worked too hard and went to a heart doctor and after a bunch of tests wound up getting some kind of mesh tube in your heart. Or something. Doesn't matter. You see your heart doctor every year and he tells you you're fine. Maybe lose a couple pounds. Here's a pill you should take for your blood pressure. Maybe you know the name of it, maybe you don't. But you still see your heart doctor, even two decades later, because you want to be healthy.

Your other doctor worries about your sugars. He tells you to take a different pill. Metformin. You know that one's name. Your other doctor also tells you to lose some weight. And he says he doesn't like how high this blood test number is. But you feel fine. It doesn't hurt like the chest pain you had.

Maybe you work at a gas station. Maybe you're a public notary, doesn't matter. You're definitely blue collar. Hair's thinning and mostly grey, you keep it buzzed pretty close to the scalp. You haven't shaven for the past week or so it seems, because you got sick.

You come down with the flu. Fevers that leave you sweating and chills that put you under the extra blankets you keep on the top shelf of your closet. You don't take a temperature though. You just feel awful. And the cough keeps you up at night. You're not coughing up any goo though, so that's good. Right?

You put up with it for a week. The fevers aren't going away. What's more worrying is that it's getting harder to breathe. Not the kind of hard to breathe when you had your heart issue, no, this is taking the wind from you when you walk the length of your room to go take a wiz. So you overcome your stubbornness and go to an Urgent Care.

This new doctor says he doesn't like the sound of your lungs and orders a chest Xray. Your new doctor says you have pneumonia and gives you two more pills to take. Antibiotics. They'll help you start breathing better again.

But you don't start breathing better. And the fevers only go away for a little when you take Tylenol. And you're having to breathe faster now even in bed. You wait three more days, taking the antibiotics which were supposed to fix you, until you're scared enough to head to the Emergency Room. Because you can't breathe.

The nurses put some tubing under your nose and now you don't have to breathe so hard. You're seen by yet another new doctor in the afternoon. He's wearing a lot of stuff your other doctors never wore. It's hard to hear him as he speaks through two masks. He probably says something about that virus that’s going around. The COVID virus. And you're shocked because you thought it was the flu, and you haven't been around any sick people. You don't know where you got it from.

Four hours later a different doctor comes by (also wearing a lot of masks and a yellow dress) and says you're heading upstairs. He asks you even more questions. By this time, you had to switch to a face mask to get enough oxygen to breathe ok.

You spend the night in the hospital. You're woken up at 11PM, 1AM, 2AM, and 5AM for a nurse to come take your vitals. If you take your mask off for even a minute, you feel like you've just run up 2 flights of stairs.

Your newest doctors (there's a few of them) wake you up around 8AM. They listen to your lungs, look at the monitor next to your bed that beeps sometimes, and frown. You can tell even under the masks. They say you're going to get different pills. One of them isn't usually used to treat the COVID, but you're desperate to breathe and you agree to it.

Your nurse keeps coming into your room to check your monitor a few times in an hour. You're breathing just as fast as you were at home, even with the mask of oxygen on.

Suddenly there's a lot of talk outside your room. Maybe you can make it out over the sound of the whooshing air into the mask and your own breathing, maybe not. Doesn't matter.

If you were listening, you'd hear an anesthesiologist asking why he was called stat to the room when a decision hasn't been made yet to intubate or not. (Intubate. Do you know what that word means?) You hear a different doctor ask why they weren't called earlier to first evaluate the patient before the anesthesiologist was called. After a minute or two you see a tall doctor (you’ve lost track of how many new doctors you’ve seen) enter your room, again with the masks, and the yellow dress.

Things start to move faster now.

He speaks quickly but seemingly without worry in his voice. "How are you feeling?" (Did he even pause to introduce himself? You can't remember.) You answer in clipped words. "It's not hard to breathe," you say, "but I just can't catch my breath."

He explains that your oxygen is too low despite the mask. And he says the only way to help you keep breathing is to stick a plastic tube down your throat and hook you up to a machine. He explains you'll be asleep while it's in. You agree, because why the hell wouldn't you?

He exits just as quickly as he came in. Again, if you're listening closely, outside the door you hear him say to some people you can't see, "We don’t need to intubate in the room, we've got a good five or ten minutes before he goes south. Get him to the pack you."

You probably didn’t hear that last thing right.

You're rolled out of your room in your stretcher to an elevator. You go up and are wheeled into a busy room of lines with beds of other people with tubes down their throats, with only drapes to separate them. You’re pushed past dozens of people in yellow dresses and masks and plastic windshields on their face. There's more of those same dings and bells you heard from your own monitor, but they're all over the room echoing off the floors and walls and ceiling.

Another doctor says you're going to go to sleep. You look scared. You don’t ask any questions, you just keep breathing. The monitor behind you keeps dinging.

You don't even realize they pushed the medicine into your veins in the two seconds it takes for you to stop feeling or hearing anything.

…

Maybe you remember being in a fog as the medicine wore off a little. Maybe. You choke on the thing in your throat. Your eyes well up. Then you go back to sleep less than a minute later when you're given more medicine. You hope you don’t remember that.

Now you're wherever we go when we sleep.

You hope you wake up.


r/medicine • • May 15 '25

Brain dead woman in Georgia kept on ventilator to incubate 9 week pregnancy. Family told they have no choice due to Heartbeat bill

3.5k Upvotes

https://www.11alive.com/article/news/local/family-claims-atlanta-nurse-declared-brain-dead-kept-alive-pregnancy/85-eac5257d-a329-4dd7-b80f-5c0ecd30225a

The family of a 30-year-old metro Atlanta mother and nurse said she was declared brain dead more than 90 days ago — but is still being kept alive because she’s pregnant. Adriana Smith, a registered nurse at Emory University Hospital, was nearly nine weeks pregnant in early February when she started experiencing intense headaches.

According to her mother, April Newkirk, Smith sought treatment at Northside Hospital but was released after being given medication. Smith was declared brain dead. Her family has been by her side every day since, including her young son, who they said still believes his mother is just sleeping. She’s been breathing through machines for more than 90 days,” Newkirk said. “It’s torture for me. I see my daughter breathing, but she’s not there. And her son—I bring him to see her.”

Newkirk said doctors told the family the baby has fluid on the brain and they're not sure how much fluid. They're concerned about his health.“She’s pregnant with my grandson. But he may be blind, may not be able to walk, may not survive once he’s born,” Newkirk said.

Under Georgia’s heartbeat law, abortion is banned once cardiac activity is detected — typically around six weeks into pregnancy. The law includes limited exceptions for rape, incest, or if the mother’s life is in danger. But in Adriana’s case, the law created a legal gray area.

Because she is brain dead — no longer considered at risk herself — her medical team is legally required to maintain life support until the fetus reaches viability. The family said doctors told them they are not legally allowed to consider other options.

Not mentioned in this article but she was 9 weeks pregnant when she died. Insane to me that apparently the only legal option to turn her into a zombie incubator for 6-7 months.


r/medicine • • Mar 28 '20

3 More Days of Inpatient Care in New York

3.4k Upvotes

Day 4

“The residents should run the Code Blues, they’re probably better trained than us.”

I’ll start off with what is good.

We’re becoming more adept at treating COVID cases. With a growing census of confirmed COVID positive patients (10 COVID positive in a census of 16 today), we’re getting a better sense of how this bastard virus behaves. There are the easy presentations: 40F w/ no significant PMH presenting w/ a 7 day hx of fever, dry cough, fatigue found to have bilateral ground glass infiltrates, elevated LFTs, lymphocytopenia and even fucking hypokalemia on admission. Might as well not even swab to confirm. (But the ED will, oh yes, because now they’re swabbing everyone and costing us probably 30-40 PPE kits per admission while we wait the 24 hours for the COVID test to result.)

But then there was the subtle one: 73M w/ multiple comorbidities who was diagnosed with simple CHF exacerbation and sepsis secondary to a UTI (positive UA and UCx) who was tubed on arrival to the ED, admitted straight to the ICU, found to be COVID negative 3/21. He is taken off the vent within 24 hours and discharged to the floors. Because he’s COVID negative you see. We treat him with antibiotics, work up his NSTEMI which he managed to throw in during his first day admitted and kind of take mild interest in his recurrent fevers. But he’s not coughing and is satting well.

Yesterday, my team and I thought “This guy has a normal white count, elevated LFTs and recurrent fevers. Forget the last test, order a repeat COVID.” I do this several hours before speaking with the attending physician. During table rounds, he pointedly asked me if I was aware of the protocols the Command Center had put in place for repeat testing. I say no, as these protocols change every day. (Side note: N95s are now rated for indefinite use, not just 4 days. Hope we didn’t toss all those other ones away for no reason!) “Cancel the test, let’s get Infectious Disease on board and ask them their input.”

I put in for the ID consult, I... "forget" to cancel the COVID repeat or inform the Command Center. Busy day as you saw from yesterday. Comes back positive. We know what this bastard virus looks like.

But we spent 2-3 days in his room without our N95s on.

We would have spent more in there had we not tested.

We’re still early, but we know how fast or how slow a case progresses. Our younger patients, the 41F and the 49M might get discharged to home quarantine as early as tomorrow! They’re not reliant on supplemental oxygen and haven’t had fevers for >24 hours. Our older patients aren’t as lucky. No one on our census so far has been intubated. The 73M whose COVID we caught late rapidly progressed to requiring supplemental oxygen and was transferred to the SICU as the last stop before ventilator land.

We’re getting better as a team of residents. We’re all more than a little scared. I’ve talked to my favorite resident / current carpool buddy / best second-in-command about my anxiety about this situation. How the adrenaline kicks in when I’m on the floors and makes me feel less afraid and more focused. The crash after work is awful and the anxiety kicking back in takes a drink or two to knock down, but fuck it, I’m better at my work when I’m not terrified.

Oh and the food remains the best part of the day. Thank you, local places that sent great sandwiches for lunch and Greek for dinner. Makes the rest of this easier to write about.

Now on to what’s not good.

The hospital is now greater than 2/3rds COVID cases. The ratio of ventilators for COVID patients to non-COVID patients is 7:1.

We’re maxed out on the capacity of our Intensivists, intensivist PAs, and Anesthesiologists. The sprawl of the traditional ICU has taken over essentially anything that used to be elevated care and we’re still scrambling for beds. A handful of Internal and Family Med Hospitalists are being recruited to act as lieutenant Intensivists overseeing the ventilated. I mean lieutenant in its original definition: "substitute,” “deputy," literally "place holder." They report to the Intensivists directly.

At lunch today, it was declared that due to the sheer number of Rapid Responses and Codes, and due to the overwhelming census of the Greater ICU, Residents responding to Rapid Responses are not expected to get any Intensivist backup.

I’m no stranger to Rapid Responses. You hear the call over the PA and are given a floor, you rush upstairs and enter a room blind with someone either choking, or unconscious, or bleeding, or seizing, or with a heart rate incompatible with life. You remain calm, you ask the patient questions while asking the nurses to give a summary of the patient’s medical background, current admission issues, latest changes, vitals, labs, imaging. Scary, but doable.

During the meeting, the Medical Director said the Hospitalists would be asked to run Code Blues. The Hospitalists balked.

See, Intensivists ran every single Code Blue in the hospital before now. One Hospitalist said, “We haven’t run a Code since residency! The residents should run the Code Blues, they’re probably better trained than us.” The room of a couple dozen full-blown-attending Hospitalists nodded in agreement. I was the only resident there, too stunned to speak up. No final decision was made.

I know the timing of Epi pushes and ACLS algorithms enough that a couple days’ review would cement it pretty well. But the actual pressure of making the call for a defibrillation or a push of atropine or adenosine is so beyond what I’m emotionally prepared for.

CPR is a violent, ugly thing with a fatality rate that is 100% for COVID patients with lungs too full of fluid for their heart pumping to matter. Even if I were to run everything perfectly, the person is still going to die. Let alone if I make the wrong call.

I’ve come to terms with the idea that I’m going to see COVID patients die under my care a whole fucking lot.

I don’t want to be forced to watch them die under my care from three feet away while I make a series of life or death decisions that are guaranteed to be utterly pointless.

Day 5

“If you’re going to stroll around here, you’re going to need full PPE”

“Usually takes about 20 minutes, then everyone’s arms get tired”

If this hospital is at war, it’s ceding territory at an alarming rate.

Here’s the layout of the field: we’ve got medsurg wings on the cardinal points of the compass (except 2SW for some reason) in a somewhat random pattern from first floor to fifth: 1N, 2S, 2SW, 3N, 3E, 5E, 5S. The ICU, CCU, CICU, and SICU are floating around the periphery of the 3rd floor.

By the time I started Day 1, 2SW and 5E were already on lockdown and designated as COVID territory. My team alone had a total of two pending and one confirmed COVID cases.

By Day 2, the CICU became a conflict zone and joined 2S and 5E. 5 COVIDS or pendings.

By Day 3, my team had pending tests in 5S as well. 6 COVIDs or pendings.

By Day 4, the 5th and 2nd floors were entirely given over to COVID. 3E still had some non-COVID evacuees waiting to be transferred to the last bastions of 1N and 3N. Everything ending with -CU is overrun by this point.

It’s Day 5. My census stands at 15, of which 9 are COVID positive. There’s talk of clearing out 1N sooner or later even.

The hospital is fairing less well: of the 170 or so inpatients (not counting the 25 or so Greater ICU COVID positive people on vents), 100 are COVID positive, and a third more have pending tests.

…

So those are the numbers. Actually walking the halls puts the change from Day 1 to Day 5 in starker contrast.

The amount of PPE used per nurse or CNA has steadily increased. On any floor (except the Last Bastion wings), if you squint your eyes all you can see is uniform green paper scrubs with blue hairnets and and blue paper booties and blue paper masks +/- an N95 underneath. If you look further down the hall you’ll see a spray of yellow as one of them gowns up to enter a patient’s room. (The nurses have been using Sharpies to write their names on the paper gowns so people can tell each other apart.)

Maybe you’ll spot a Resident in a long white coat rush by.

And by every single door on wheeled tables usually topped with hospital food are boxes and boxes of blue gloves and yellow gowns. Might be my imagination, but the boxes of face masks are disconcertingly not as ubiquitous.

The Greater ICU is less colorful. Just window after window of people on vents. Walk the whole length of it and count maybe one person who’s conscious. Most don’t look like our usual ICU clientele of the cachectic elderly. These are mostly men (my imagination?) ranging from their 50-70s.

I made the mistake of asking who the youngest intubated COVID patient on the unit was.

Younger than me.

So we finish at the ED. It’s not chaotic like a Saturday night. Sure there are a few beds in the hallways, but that’s nothing new. I walked the length of it too. Some people on oxygen here and there, wider variety of ages.

Lots of people getting gowned up to enter rooms though. And I know we’re supposed to take them off at the door of the patient’s room, why are people walking around-

“HEY! If you’re going to stroll around here, you’re going to need full PPE. With an N95 on!”

The ED is now considered COVID home territory.

…

I don’t feel like a soldier. I don’t feel brave for showing up to my job. I most certainly don’t feel like a hero.

I feel like the tide came in way too fast and now I'm staring at waves from below.

Day 6

“There’s another Anesthesia Stat. Don’t know where we’re gonna put that one.”

55M with PMH of uncontrolled DM2, HTN, CKD3. Admitted 5 days ago for fever, SoB, dry cough, you get it. COVID positive on Day 1. Went to a COVID medsurg floor, experienced worsening hypoxia on NC, and started on nonrebreather. By Day 5, transferred to the newest territory grab of the Greater ICU, the Post-Anesthesia Care Unit - the PACU. We’re not doing surgeries anymore, so no anesthesia, so that’s free real estate to park the intubated.

One other thing. The PACU was never meant for anything longer than a few hours’ stay and has only drapes between beds. No doors or walls means this is COVID home turf. You have to completely PPE up to even enter the unit.

This newest long walk of ventilated COVID patients is kept alive by 2nd string equipment. No modern touch screens, no real time graphs, just an aged-beige box with some dials and digital-clock-red settings. It does the same job - you can set the PEEP, FiO2, RR, AC/PSV just as precisely as the modern machines.

Even the third tier stuff never intended to serve as ventilation for the 10-14 days of ventilation COVID patients may require works well. These are the surgical ventilators the anesthesiologists used to use back when we did surgeries. They have been liberated to serve the Greater ICU. We’ve even drafted the ad hoc ventilators of the local community of outpatient docs to act as reserves.

Code Blue called on the 55M gentleman above. The team rushes up and I am deeply relieved that it’s not a Code I have to run. By the time we get our PPE on (takes about 3 minutes), he’s already being intubated. No chest compressions required. We put in some orders, we watch the Veteran Attendings tube their first patient of the day. It is only about 8AM.

”Anesthesia Stat to the ED” heard on the overhead PA means someone is getting intubated essentially right after they enter the door. The Intensivist sighs and wonders out loud where they’re going to place this next patient on a vent.

The Greater ICU is quickly becoming The Empire of the ICU as more unused departments get swallowed up by the need to house the intubated.

...

I try to comfort myself with knowing I'm still living in the good days, relatively speaking.

No one on the hospital staff is sick. No one on my team or Residency program is sick. I'm not sick. We still have beds and ventilators, at least for the time being.

We've still got a week and a half for this to reach its peak.


r/medicine • • Mar 17 '20

I'm a physician and I was just denied COVID-19 testing because I don't have a history of travel or a direct contact with COVID-19 patient.

3.4k Upvotes

You read it right.

We have multiple confirmed cases at my hospital already.

I have low grade fever, dry cough, malaise, stuffy nose, fatigue, headache.

Instead I was asked to stay home for 14 days because I don't meet the criteria for testing but I'm still symptomatic so I can't come to work.

Where are the tests we were promised this week?

How does any of this make any sense?