r/writing • • Feb 21 '24

Discussion Avoiding a sexual pitfall?

0 Upvotes

How do you avoid, or try to avoid, people reading sexuality into relationships which are not sexual?

I'm working on a story where a bachelor starts a relationship with a single mother of a little girl. The adults are each about 30, and the girl is about 7 or 8. The man isn't bothered by the little girl and is sometimes amused by her antics. He is sexually attracted to the mother.

But I'm not certain how to depict him as not being attracted to the little girl without actually saying "Jimbo wasn't attracted to the little girl." I mentioned this because someone in my writing group asked me about the issue.

Thoughts?

1st Edit to Add:

A crowd already occupied the church as they entered.

"Mr. Harold, you're here," came a girl's voice. Harold turned to see Roshana approaching him with her mother (Christina) moving to catch up.

"Morning," said Harold.

"Mom wasn't sure you'd be here. She said you might be too hungover after drinking with Adam. What's hungover?"

Christina had the grace to look embarrassed and moved to shush her daughter.

"I'm only a little hung over. And you'll learn about hangovers when you're older."

The exchange amused Harold. He had realized he wanted children only after being a biological father became impossible. And Christina again struck him as a pretty woman.

2nd Edit to Add:

On reflection, I think the question came because an antagonist in the story makes the accusation. It's baseless and the character making the accusation is a toxic jackass. And the MC reacts violently to the slander. The person in my writing group seemed to think the MC reacted that way because they had been caught. Not the case, or at least not what I intended.


r/writing • • Aug 15 '24

Friend said my world is like FMA; can't write anymore since

3 Upvotes

I have a novel I've been working on since the beginning of this year, its my first time writing since my early teens and I was quite proud of it. I have a scientific background and love fantasy, so I tried to merge the two into a "scientific magic" system. Imo a lot of modern fantasy tends to be really derivative, so I went out of my way to build my world out of whole cloth and deliberately avoided any tropes

I described my fictional universe to my friend and they said, "oh its just like fullmetal alchemist!" I've never watched that show before, but it left a sour taste in my mouth. I've spent so many months building this world from the ground up, that they immediately compared it was so discouraging.

Now I find I can't write anymore. I just feel angry and frustrated whenever I sit down to. I thought of watching FMA but decided not to, because I didn't want it influencing my decisions, but it's taken the wind out of my sails.

Has this ever happened to you? Have you had an original idea you were really proud of, only to find out it's not original after all? How do you deal with it?

Edit: i took the advice and decided to watch an episode of FMA brotherhood. There are quite a few similarities in themes and mechanisms, I'll admit, esp from glancing at the wiki, but it's also a good show. Plus, my setting and plot is completely different

I want to thank everyone for their advice and encouragement. It's helped me get out of my head, and I feel a lot better about my work now. Previously it felt like if something isn't original then it isn't worth doing, but in retrospect that seems a bit silly. I just hope to write the best version of my story now :)


r/writing • • Apr 26 '25

Why there is so much bias against action-focused stories?

0 Upvotes

There's authors who omly write romantic stories, who only writer comedy, horror etc.

So why when i tell people i only want to write action-focused story with fights and etc, they always call me imature, a kid, violencetard, edgy etc?


r/writing • • Mar 24 '26

Discussion people keep giving terrible advice about how much writers should read

3 Upvotes

so ive been seeing tons of posts from newbie writers asking stuff like "is it ok if i only finish like 3 books per year" or "how many books do i actually need to read" and the responses are driving me crazy

everyone just says generic stuff like "oh yeah 2-3 books annually is totally fine" or "just stick to bestsellers" and its all complete garbage advice

look the actual number of books doesnt really matter that much since some are way longer or more dense than others. what actually matters is making it a daily thing. you gotta be reading every single day for at least an hour or two depending on your schedule

thats literally the only way your writing voice and understanding of story structure will develop naturally. even if youre not actively studying what youre reading your brain picks up on patterns and techniques just from constant exposure

but heres the bigger problem - when people ask "how much should i read" it sounds like they think reading is some annoying homework assignment. if you want to be a writer you have to actually love reading books. like why else would you even want to write if you dont enjoy consuming written work

reading should become as automatic as your morning routine. not something you force yourself through but something you genuinely look forward to

sure there will be books that suck and you hate them. but there will also be books that keep you up until 3am because you cant put them down. if you treat every book like a boring obligation youll miss out on those incredible reading experiences that make you want to create something just as powerful

plus how are you supposed to recognize good writing in your own work if you barely read anything and when you do its just something you rush through to check off a list


r/writing • • Feb 08 '23

Discussion “First Draft always sucks” is a bad narrative to promote…

0 Upvotes

I have seen this being said so many times on this sub. This phrase is being overused to the point that aspiring writers seem to aim for their first draft to be shitty. I saw a post a few days ago saying: “Why first draft sucks, but it is supposed to suck, right?”

I am by no means an accomplished writer. I hardly started writing my book. But I am personally aiming for excellence even in the first draft. I understand that a lot will change between first and final draft. I may indeed look back on my work and tell myself that it’s a pile of rubbish. But, I am of an opinion that I should not aim for that. Throw in anything and everything in my first draft or ignore grammar while writing. I should aim for the best possible result, so that edits to the final story will be minimal.

I understand that the story itself may change as I go along, but that doesn’t mean I shouldn’t try to make it as best as I can.

That is just an opinion, though. Probably going to get bashed in the comments. Have a good day!


r/writing • • Aug 03 '25

Stop trying to make everything beautiful

15 Upvotes

Your protagonist doesn't walk through a "cathedral of ancient oaks with dappled sunlight dancing through emerald leaves." Sometimes they just walk through some old trees on a sunny day.

Poetic description works best when it serves the story's emotional core, not when you're showing off your vocabulary. The most haunting images often come from finding the unexpected poetry in mundane moments rather than forcing flowery language onto everything that moves.

Save the elaborate metaphors for when they actually amplify what your character is feeling. Otherwise, you're just putting perfume on a pig and calling it literature.

What are your thoughts about poetic descriptions in fiction?


r/writing • • Aug 10 '16

"25 Reasons Why I Stopped Reading Your Book"

Thumbnail
terribleminds.com
24 Upvotes

r/writing • • Oct 21 '21

Is white the default race in fiction?

1 Upvotes

I see lots of posts asking how to write characters of color in a story. I never see characters described as white. Is white the default race if race isn't mentioned?


r/writing • • Oct 17 '23

Discussion Todays Mary Sues Are A Product Of The Push For Representation

0 Upvotes

I just had a thought after rewatching the sequel Star Wars trilogy (you can guess which character stood out to me on this topic) and wanted to get the take you guys had on it.

The push for representation in media is mostly a good thing, but it’s having an adverse effect on character writing across franchises. A lot of the characters written with representation in mind are overpowered, or almost too perfect. They don’t make mistakes unless the mistakes were a product of them being too good a person (trusting the wrong people, for example) or their mistake is “holding themselves back” (looking at you Captain Marvel).

I believe this is a product of the character being meant as a stand-in for an entire group of people. It ties the writers hands behind their back, because if you give the person that represents insert marginalized group real, tangible character flaws or sincere struggles, you are implying that the entire group has those same flaws or can’t overcome those same obstacles. It’s why the majority of morally complex or evil protagonists are white (in addition to that just being the default for Hollywood for a REALLY long time).

When they’re not trying to push representation, they have no problem showing Walter White is a sociopath, or that Jack Sparrow can’t really be trusted, or that Anakin was controlled by his need for power. That’s not to say there aren’t memorable, interesting and flawed characters from marginalized groups. Jessica Jones, Hancock, hell, even Fin was an extremely interesting character with the notable flaw of cowardice until they weeded it out of him. The push for any character to be the embodiment of a group seriously limits what can be done with the character in a story, and it seems far more practical to just write good characters that happen to be XYZ marginalized groups.

Thoughts?

EDIT:

Being downvoted into oblivion, which is fine because I came here for discussion and engagement which I am getting in the comments.

For clarification, I don’t hate ALL representation. People in the comments have been assuming that, and outlining all the good examples of representation that exist. Those are good! Those don’t have Mary-Sue heroes! Great! WE AGREE FOR FUCKS SAKE.

I’m just trying to examine the connection between writers that create a character for the sake of representation and how those CAN turn into Mary-Sues. Not that they will, but that they CAN.

I’m not saying representation=bad writing. I don’t know how people abstracted that opinion. I’m saying that a character written for no other reason than representation COULD EQUAL a Mary Sue protagonist.

EDIT 2 Electric Boogaloo: Good great heavens I have rustled some Jimmie’s with this post.


r/writing • • Aug 29 '22

Conservative writers/publishers?

0 Upvotes

It seems that a lot of what gets published these days is very liberal. That’s fine for people who lean that way, but not everyone does. Some of us writers are not only conservative, but write work that is critical of our current culture. I’m one of those writers.

Are there any others here? If so, do you know where I can publish my short stories? Thanks!


r/writing • • Jul 11 '26

Advice Debut Novel is over 250k words, Wait or Cut?

0 Upvotes

Hello,

The queer fantasy novel I have been working on for 5 years and had hoped to be my debut, is currently at 260k words. I have made a few passes to cut it down and could maybe shave off 50k. However, I have been reading recently that agents wont typically look at any queries over 100K words. That more than half my novel! I have had a few friends of mine read it and they have said the pacing is good and the word count feels earned in the worldbuilding and characters and so forth.

My question is should I keep trying to cut it down to fit in that debut novel word count threshold or should I move on to writing something else (much shorter and simpler) to use that as my debut, with hopes to put this behemoth forward once I am more established?

Any help or guidance is greatly appreciated!


r/writing • • Dec 14 '25

Discussion Okay, I don't care if it's out of place with the story, if there are gonna be teenagers in a story, (Fantasy and Action especially) please have them ACT like Teenagers

6 Upvotes

Like I shouldn't be seeing underaged Warhammer 40K Hardened Warriors. Okay, one or two being somewhat like that is fine, maybe there's been some trauma that has had them be like that. I'll take it, But COME ON (I know this is more of a Manga issue, but I know there are probably some novels that have this sort of thing as well and it can be very griping and annoying at times) not only can teens acting like hardened soldiers 24/7 be boring, but it's so. Damn. LAME. Like, give them a break!


r/writing • • Oct 24 '21

Advice Can I drop high school to become a writer?

187 Upvotes

I've always been a writer, already wrote several books and I all that is left for me is to be published. The problem is I don't have time to write anymore because of school. And I'm not adapted to the school system, failing all my exams etc... Hence why I'm asking if uts possible to drop high school in grade 12?


r/writing • • Feb 02 '25

Discussion How many aura points did I lose for shouting at my characters for being so in love?

15 Upvotes

A lighthearted, silly post. I'm literally punching the air at how in love my two main characters are. They're too effing cute. I can't get over how happy I am for them as if I didnt make them up myself lol.

Tell me the times you were over the moon by something sweet/loving/cute that your characters did!

Edit: you're all making me so happy. This will be a good post for me to go back to when I need some feel goods


r/writing • • Jan 09 '24

Advice Adding in non-binary characters

0 Upvotes

I was thinking about characters that often seem to be under represented in novels and thought about adding a non-binary character to my story. However I have some concerns. First as a cis male, would writing a non-binary character be appropriate or appropriation? Also I was curious if anyone had any recommended pitfalls I should make sure to avoid. I'm not planning to make their gender identity a significant plot point but it will at least come up in the use of pronouns. I also haven't 100% committed to this idea yet as I'm nervous about introducing them organically and not making their identity feel forced. Any tips anyone has would be greatly appreciated. I'm very much in the research gathering and brainstorming phase and my intent is pure so I hope this post isn't misconstrued.


r/writing • • Nov 11 '25

Other I hate writing, but I feel I have to

2 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel the same way? The writing process is torture and punishment for me. Only when I read what I've written do I sometimes feel satisfied. Likewise, the vision and need to write a book are my only motivation to write. I hate doing it, but I want results...


r/writing • • Sep 11 '25

Discussion Of these 10 villain-based tropes, which would you say is the most overused?

1 Upvotes
  1. If they’re a jerk? Then they’re a villain. Always.

  2. They won’t let anyone else kill the hero.

  3. They never stay dead.

  4. The villain is inexplicably overpowered.

  5. Main supervillain must have some kind of similar power to the hero.

  6. No matter what, their goons and sidekicks are extremely loyal.

  7. Generic 4-person villain team (the leader is an abusive control freak accompanied with a dumb brute, femme fatale, and sadistic/very weird guy)

  8. Someway, somehow, all your villains need to right-wingers.

  9. The villain seems to have a proper motivation? Better make it incredibly ambiguous anyway.

  10. The female villain has to be defeated by another female.


r/writing • • Sep 05 '26

You’re not going to learn write using your intelligence.

0 Upvotes

There’s a lot of comments here that suggest taking a scientific approach to learning how to write.

“Read analytically” is one thing I keep seeing. “Go through a page of a book and highlight all the action, all the exposition, and all the dialogue, and calculate the percentage of each.”

Along with that is a hyperfixation on quantitative metrics and patterns: how many words per paragraph, how many scenes per chapter, how much dialogue, how much description, how much interiority, how much action?

It’s all a very Reddit-like desire to treat everything like a code that can cracked or a formula that can be solved.

It’s like people very much want to believe that through their intelligence, the same kind of intelligence that perhaps helps them in something like coding or engineering, they can gain a command of storytelling.

That ain’t how it works.

Storytelling has no fixed formula. There’s a generally recognized and expected flow of a story, but there are infinitely different ways to do it.

I’m a big fan of craft books like Saves the Cat, but those don’t exist to be prescriptive. They exist to be descriptive. They’re providing a lens through which to interpret the way many stories flow, not a code you can memorize and reapply.

The only way to learn to write, the unskippable cut scene of the whole thing, is to create a daily reading habit. Reading is FUN and you should WANT to do it. You do not have to treat it like a research assignment with highlighters and notations. Just read books you like every single day.


r/writing • • May 11 '25

Discussion LitRPG is not "real" literature...?

91 Upvotes

So, I was doing my usual ADHD thing – watching videos about writing instead of, you know, actually writing. Spotted a comment from a fellow LitRPG author, which is always cool to see in the wild.

Then, BAM. Right below it, some self-proclaimed literary connoisseur drops this: "Please write real stories, I promise it's not that hard."

There are discussions about how men are reading less. Reading less is bad, full stop, for everyone. And here we have a genre exploding, pulling in a massive audience that might not be reading much else, making some readers support authors financially through Patreon just to read early chapters, and this person says it's not real.

And if one person thinks this, I'm sure there are lots of others who do too. This is the reason I'm posting this on a general writing subreddit instead of the LitRPG one. I want opinions from writers of "established" genres.

So, I'm genuinely asking – what's the criteria here for "real literature" that LitRPG supposedly fails?

Is it because a ton of it is indie published and not blessed by the traditional publishers? Is it because we don't have a shelf full of New York Times Bestseller LitRPGs?

Or is this something like, "Oh no, cishet men are enjoying their power fantasies and game mechanics! This can't be real art, it's just nerd wish-fulfillment!"

What is a real story and what makes one form of storytelling more valid than another?

And if there is someone who dislikes LitRPG, please tell me if you just dislike the tropes/structure or you dismiss the entire genre as something apart from the "real" novels, and why.


r/writing • • Feb 04 '25

Can I write a book about Japanese mythology?

0 Upvotes

I did a minor in Japanese during my undergrad, and during my independent study, I researched a particular part of Japanese mythology and history during the Heian period that I found incredibly interesting and got inspired to write a fictional adaptation on it. I now worry that being an American with no ethnic ties to Japan, I could get hate for publishing my book. I love a lot of mythology-based novels that I've read, but I feel like all of them were written by people from that ethnicity or country. Opinion on this?


r/writing • • 3d ago

Discussion "Natural Sounding Dialogue" is overrated

0 Upvotes

It's a common critique I've seen in various media - dialogue that doesn't sound like something a real person would say. I think there are plenty of situations where elevated language is perfectly fine, especially within certain genres.

No one would ever say "I'll get there, if I leave everything but my bones behind" in real life, yet in the context is awesome. I think stylized dialogue can certainly elevate a piece or set a certain mood.

What people actually have a complaint with is awkward dialogue. This is more of a skill issue, when a writer tries to stylize but needs more practice. And of course, not everything should be stylized.


r/writing • • Dec 27 '25

"Just Write" is overrated advice

0 Upvotes

On a regular basis, I see posts with a two-word thesis "just write" as advice for aspiring writers, often delivered in a rather vulgar and condescending tone. Many users eat this advice up, but I find that it's rather overrated, and not always helpful.

To be precise, "overrated" does not necessarily mean "useless." The story you're dreaming about will never become a reality unless you actually write it, and while it may not be perfect, you can go back and edit it later. Getting practice writing is also the best way to improve your skills at it.

That being said, I find the often-repeated piece saying that "Your first draft will be bad" (replace "bad" with your adjective of choice) to be rather unhelpful. Editing is a necessary part of the writing process, but I've found that putting a bit of thought into the story to iron out kinks in advance can save you a great deal of effort later. I'm not saying you should spend countless hours doing worldbuilding, but, for example, knowing what you want to do with a character helps prevent them from being underutilized and/or inconsistent, among other problems.

I've also found that some genres require more planning than others. I'm currently working on a mystery, and find that I need a plan of who the culprit is, how they commit the crime, what evidence they leave behind, how the protagonists find them, etc. Going into the story with half-baked ideas could potentially result in problems that snowball over time as I write, thus potentially necessitating heavier than normal revisions or even a rewrite. There are stories that can work if you "pants" them, but the story I'm working on isn't one of them.

One recent poster likened the first draft to a "foundation" of a building, and I'd argue this is a poor analogy. I'd say that the foundation is more likely to be the opening chapters, which establish the characters and setting, set the plot into motion, and lay the groundwork for future chapters. If the opening doesn't do its job, then it could potentially require retcons or rewrites down the road, if the story doesn't collapse under its own weight.

I've tried to "just write" in the past, but often, momentum only takes me so far if the idea doesn't click with me or I haven't given sufficient thought to the key elements of the story.

I can definitely see the appeal of the advice to "just write." It's simple, catchy and to-the-point. It also appeals to the popular mindset of putting your nose to the grindstone and powering through your problems. Most of all, it helps you get things done. Unfortunately, it's little help to those who are trying to figure out key aspects of their stories, and tends to save much of the effort for later.

Abraham Lincoln once said "Give me six hours to chop down a tree and I will spend the first four sharpening my axe." I'm not so sure about the ratio of time spent sharpening to time spent cutting, but the "boring" work of preparation can make the more "fun" work of actually writing easier.


r/writing • • Apr 06 '22

Advice How do I get my friends to be interested in my work?

0 Upvotes

Hey, I've been spending half of my life (I'm 22) working on this fantasy world that I need help with.

I got a lore guide and am currently working on a cosmology guide for myself as a way to keep the rules of my universe inline

I got characters with development and concepts and archs for all of them. I even do art!

And yet none of my friends seem to be interested. Neither is my family. I've kinda given up on having my family have an interest in it but not my friends! I was thinking on making a DND campaign revolving around my work. I was wondering if this is a good idea or if it's just a waste of time...

Please... I just want someone to care.


r/writing • • Nov 11 '23

Discussion Why do women romanticize abuse? NSFW

5 Upvotes

A very popular sub-genre right now is mafia romance. I admit, as a teenager I was very into those kind of novels but as I got older, I realized the main male lead is almost always abusive, even when most of the time he is a savior from an abuser. Why is that? I'm not saying enjoying morally grey characters is wrong, but these characters aren't written with self awareness. The male leads abusive behavior is portrayed as romantic and arousing. It makes sense to a point why this could be enticing but I would really like some insight on this. Is it because women are taking control of a narrative used to harm them, and using it as a trope to cope with how men treat them in reality?

Edit: I've gotten a lot of feed back and I think the main point is that its really not that deep. People enjoy fiction of all kinds and some woman like the 'I can fix him' vibe. Everything is within the safety of the page and you know they will end up in love and together happy at the end.