r/writing • u/tech151 • Jan 09 '24
Advice Adding in non-binary characters
I was thinking about characters that often seem to be under represented in novels and thought about adding a non-binary character to my story. However I have some concerns. First as a cis male, would writing a non-binary character be appropriate or appropriation? Also I was curious if anyone had any recommended pitfalls I should make sure to avoid. I'm not planning to make their gender identity a significant plot point but it will at least come up in the use of pronouns. I also haven't 100% committed to this idea yet as I'm nervous about introducing them organically and not making their identity feel forced. Any tips anyone has would be greatly appreciated. I'm very much in the research gathering and brainstorming phase and my intent is pure so I hope this post isn't misconstrued.
21
u/IndependenceNo2060 Jan 09 '24
Your intentions are good, and I believe you can write a non-binary character respectfully. Just remember to avoid stereotypes and characterize them as a multi-dimensional human. As long as you're empathetic and genuine, your writing will do justice to the character.”
20
u/foolishle Jan 09 '24
You probably write lots of characters who don’t share your gender. It shouldn’t be disrespectful to include more genders! You’re “allowed” to include non-binary characters just as you’re allowed to write men/women (which ever one of those you aren’t)!
9
u/Sufficient_Spells Jan 09 '24
Write humans, write about life, use places in the world where you and everyone else lives. Or the universe, we all live there. Just do your best is all.
31
Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 10 '24
Just treat them like any normal character and you should be fine. If their gender is of no real importance to the story, just write them like you would any other character and use whatever pronouns you want the character to have without drawing any unneeded attention to it.
As a nonbinary person, I have no problem with you writing a nonbinary person and I would love to see more variation in character gender in books where it isn't the main plot! (Not saying there aren't a lot already, or anything, just that it's always good to see.)
7
Jan 09 '24
As another nonbinary person, "nobinary pronouns" is a misleading term as all sets of pronouns used by nb people can reasonably be called nonbinary pronouns. Some of us exclusively use he/his or she/her.
OP, your character doesn't have to use they/them (or neopronouns) to be nonbinary!
3
Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24
I only said that because OP said that they wanted the character's gender to come across in pronouns.
Sorry if that didn't come across, I understand you don't have to use specific pronouns to be nonbinary, I'm not trying to gatekeep or anything.
Thanks for reminding me, though, I've changed it now, sorry for the misunderstanding.
8
u/Effective-Key- Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 09 '24
Nb here, I apologise if the comment sounds all over the place bc I wrote it while still trying to follow a lecture about tax law lol. Maybe gonna edit later to correct or add things.
One of the reasons it is considered somewhat inappropriate for cis people to write trans/nb characters is because we are often included for diversity‘s sake or to have a weird quirky uwu unconventional character, not because the author actually wants to write an nb.
But as long as you’re not doing that it’s actually more than appropriate, please do! Queer people just exist in the real world like everyone else so there is no reason we should only exist in by queer for queer media. So you also don’t really have to worry about committing to the idea or introducing them organically. Just have them be there.
If you introduce them alone you can describe them to look visibly queer or wearing pins with pronouns and then just have the other characters use those pronouns like they would with anyone else.
If you want them to present more fem or masc and less visibly queer you can always work the pronouns in another way. Some people introduce themselves with their name and pronouns. Others don’t or sometimes forget and then correct people afterwards.
*characters meet blabla * „Oh I like her! We shou-„ „Them.“ „Oh I like them! Wh should really blabla“
and other variations.
The character’s identity really doesn’t have to be a big deal or play a role in the plot. They’re allowed to simply exist just because you want them to. Hell, you can even make jokes with/about it as long as the joke is not haha NB weird. Like in the little conversation above.
I could go on and on with more examples of what you can do but the reality is NBs are just as diverse a group of people as any other so you can basically do whatever you want with them, not just the stereotypes.
Rather I’ll tell you what not to do. Don’t include them if you’re not willing to put in the same amount of character building as with all the others and just want them to have someone „different“ in the cast.
Don’t have them unnecessarily act outside of gender roles and societie‘s expectations for the sole reason of showing how outside the binary they are. For example for an afab character don’t do stuff like „i don’t like cooking and makeup because that’s for girls“. If you want them to have those traits make them have normal reasons for having them „I’ve never really liked cooking, too much work for the result and I’m honestly not really good at it. same with makeup tbh“. Stuff like that.
Lastly one thing that I see weirdly often that’s also related to the last point is writers trying to write the only nb (who’s often an alien or robot for some reason) as outside the binary through their personality but end up just writing a charicature of neurodivergence; adhd and autism to be specific. Notably there is quite the overlap between transness and neurodivergence but there pretty much the same rules apply. As long as they’re not the butt of the joke, allowed to just exist and aren’t a weird stereotype you can write that and mix and match it with other identities as you wish.
Basically the tl;dr is as long as you’re not writing them for diversitie‘s sake, to make them the butt of the joke or as a weird charicature you’re good. And if it ends up not being very good you’ll get feedback and learn. win win either way.
First edit already: if your original intention of adding them is to bring diversity into the cast that’s perfectly fine as long as you actually develop them beyond that into a proper character with plot relevance.
16
u/Summerlycoris Jan 09 '24
Hello- i dont agree with the previous commentator that it would be appropriation. Because otherwise, the amount of nonbinary characters would always be very small, if the only people allowed to write them would be nonvinary people. Especially if you weite their character respecfully.
Anyway, youre looking for research? Ive got some links I found on google.
Bryn Writes part 1 of writing nonbinary characters.
These should be good jumping off points.
3
u/AmputatorBot Jan 09 '24
It looks like you shared an AMP link. These should load faster, but AMP is controversial because of concerns over privacy and the Open Web. Fully cached AMP pages (like the one you shared), are especially problematic.
Maybe check out the canonical page instead: https://brynwrites.tumblr.com/post/190062852159/how-to-write-non-binary-characters-a-three-part
I'm a bot | Why & About | Summon: u/AmputatorBot
2
5
u/Kiaider Jan 09 '24
Harry Potter is about a child/teen male and it was written by an adult female. No one gave her flak for her not writing about a child/teen female. So it shouldn’t really matter if you want to write about a non-binary character even though you’re a cis and male.
Heck, in school I (female) took a creative writing class and wrote a couple short stories and had the MC be male and my teacher didn’t say a word about it. I’m certain she would have told us we could only write about characters that were the same as ourselves (sex, sexual preference, race, religion, those kinds of things)
As for your question, as long as you’re doing your research to write them respectfully then it’s appropriate
5
5
u/its_dezi Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 09 '24
People have given plenty of good feedback, but as an added side-note for inspiration: a person doesn't have to go by they/them pronouns to be non-binary. A person can be feminine, go by he/him and identify as NB. Or look like a 'typical man' with he/him pronouns and be NB. Maybe the character passes as a cis woman who doesn't care about the pronouns people use, but she's still NB.
Of course there are challenges to writing these different characters that would require specific research, but if you're interested in writing non-binary characters I would consider the variety with which they can express their identity besides going by they/them. (Though it's perfectly cool if your character goes by those pronouns, just wanted to make sure you know there's other options too!)
Optionally, adding multiple non-binary characters could help with the pressure of getting the representation 'right' in a single character, and ease some of your worries about accidentally making them a token character. Though obviously you know best whether that works for your project, or whether you'd rather focus on a single non-binary character and develop them well ^^
6
u/auro_morningstar Jan 09 '24
Please yes, we need more nonbinary representation
Feel free to DM me with questions, also there are some subreddits I follow that may be of use to you if you don't already follow them:
5
u/mmoota Jan 09 '24
Hello, non binary person here! Firstly, I want to say I'm happy you've made a decision to add some queer rep to your cast, and that you're reaching out for help with making sure you do it right!
Imo, it's not appropriation to create a non binary character when you yourself are cis, but it can become problematic if your character's only defining trait is their gender. Make sure you flesh out your character, give them a personality, all that good stuff. Just treat them how you would any other character.
2
u/Patapotat Jan 09 '24
What you have to remember about non-binary characters is that they are just characters. Ultimately the same rules apply to them as to any other character.
Which pronouns are applicable will depend on the POV you are writing in as well as the culture and knowledge of your setting; unless you want to make a statement (which you can, it's your story; just be conscious of it).
A couple hundred years ago the concept of "non-binary" did not really exist the way it does today. Same with most forms of modern sexual/gender identity. That doesn't mean people didn't feel the same way back then, they just didn't have the concept to put it into words.
And even today, non-binary people, or anyone in the LGBTQ+ for that matter, don't walk around with a Post-It-note on their foreheads proclaiming "non-binary person coming through!". They are just regular people, and unless your narration is from the POV of this non-binary person, or the POV character somehow has knowledge on the non-binary status of the person, or is omniscient, then they cannot know the person is non-binary. And even if you do go omniscient, in your setting the concept of adjusting pronouns might not exist. It's a very modern and western cultural concept.
The fifth season is pretty decent in that regard. It, for the most part, completely ignores the declaration of sexual/gender identity as a meta-commentary. It simply describes how certain characters act, what they feel, and what they choose to do, and lets the reader interpret what that means for themselves in a world that's a lot less inclined at putting labels everywhere. It knows who's POV it's in and limits itself to that information. That doesn't mean there are no characters in there that, if they were living in today's western society, would not identify themselves as non-binary. There might be, but we don't actually know, since they don't know either. They don't share our cultural concepts, they've never heard of them. They simply are who they are and do what they do. It's the "show don't tell" approach to gender identity and sexual preference. Which I personally find a lot more engaging.
Not that there are no interesting ways to play around with it in a more modern setting or a different POV. You could switch between pronouns between different POVs depending on the Personal beliefs and the current information those people have on the character in question. The bigot might refuse to alter their use of pronouns for this character, and the woke-warrior might insinuate a pronoun change despite the character in question not conforming to the concept of it. Or the Karen who will use the adjusted pronoun in dialogue but still can't bring herself to think of the character in that way in her internal thoughts and ultimately her POV.
You could also change the use of pronouns within the story as new information is introduced and contrast different responses, or do it as a result of characters' changing worldviews throughout their arc or the larger narrative etc. There is lots of stuff one can do, but I don't see it done very often. In part that's because doing it a bunch is quite jarring for the reader. Just imagine a story with 3 POV characters, each one referring to one another in different pronouns throughout the story due to different ideals and beliefs, and then also have that vary between dialogue and narration, as well as change within POVs as the story goes on. The reader might get profusely confused and unable to follow all of that. So there is an argument to be made for simplicity here.
None of this is really new stuff. You'd have to go through the same thought process for any character/story. What's the POV? Who's the narrator? How much do they know? Who is my character? So long as you don't define your character as a label you should get most of the way there already.
3
u/Silent-Moose-8158 Jan 09 '24
You’ve unintentionally managed to sum up everything wrong with modern media. Does the character make sense for your story? if so, write them however you want, but definitely speak to non-binary people to understand their general perspective like any other research. Stop Pandering, writing for the sake of diversity, or worrying about offending anyone, and just write the story you want
-39
u/WizardTheodore Jan 09 '24
It would be appropriation.
6
u/tech151 Jan 09 '24
So is this to say that only people who identify as non-binary should write non-binary characters?
12
u/Eldon42 Jan 09 '24
It's not appropriation. You just need to be careful to represent your character in a positive, realistic way. If you know any non-binary people, it would be worth interviewing them.
6
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24
It's like saying only men can write men, women can write women, children can write children and we shouldn't have any books about animals, because animals can't write.
Write whatever you want, just be mindful.
10
u/VincentOostelbos Translator & Wannabe Author Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 09 '24
Presumably this is also why male authors are never allowed to write female characters or vice versa, and you can only ever include characters of your own race, age group, sexual orientation and socioeconomic status as well, right?
15
u/Dex_Hopper Jan 09 '24
Are you for real? Of course this isn't appropriation. People of differing identities existing in a story is not appropriation, even when written by cis writers.
3
3
Jan 09 '24
It would be appropriation.
Absolutely not, and I would not feel insulted or bothered at all
0
Jan 09 '24
[deleted]
6
u/lenapostrophe Jan 09 '24
if im watching an NB character that person HAS to show a behavior which reflects their gender, or must be put in a situation where their gender makes them act in a way a cis character won't act or face something a cis character doesn't need to
I'm really interested to hear examples of this, how would an NB character act differently than a cis character ?
-2
Jan 09 '24
NB people can feel alienated among both males and females
or be really confused how to behave with them or to behave like them or not
a character could be facing a conflict when there is both a male character and a female character which influence the NB character1
5
u/Morticiankitten Jan 09 '24
If you’re writing a story about a person who is cis, the story doesn’t have to be about them being cis to be meaningful. Honestly, it’s a pretty transphobic attitude to assume that a person’s gender identity HAS to be relevant in the story for them to be included. Nonbinary people exist and are more than their identity, so nonbinary characters can exist and be more than their identity. Imagine if you were giving this writing advice to someone and you said ‘oh if you’re including a woman in your story it HAS to include something about the struggles she faces as a woman, otherwise you might as well write her as a man’. You’re doing the same thing here.
I’m also nonbinary and I would be delighted to see representation of nonbinary people just existing without it having to be a whole thing all the time. Also, I agree with you that being nonbinary CAN be alienating being among both men and women, but it doesn’t HAVE to be. I have a plenty of cis and binary trans friends and my gender identity is a non-issue. They interact with me like I am a human and I do the same for them. They respect my pronouns and I respect theirs. This representation is just as acceptable as showing a nonbinary person struggling because of their gender identity.
-2
Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 09 '24
Honestly, it’s a pretty transphobic attitude to assume that a person’s gender identity HAS to be relevant in the story for them to be included.
i say again, if you just want non binary people to exist in the story to show that yes these people are not specifically being excluded from the world of this narrative then you're allowed to do this, but make it side characters and not main characters
if you just want to include non binary main characters, you have to give it purpose. even if the character is not struggling their gender has to say something, anything which serves the story. maybe your main characters are non binary and don't go through struggle but the fact they are non binary says something about everybody else in the story, like how the specific culture of that area helped more people understand they are not really cis
now my problem with aimlessly making your character non binary is how the story turns from a narrative that ties with reality (taking real ideas like concept of cis and non binary genders) and turning into a pure fantasy. you most probably will never see a good bunch of non binary people where either the society is under conservatism or people have backward stigma towards them. In such cases non binary people are not actually FOUND there, but in fact hide their identity. That is why you can't go on including them without fixing the problem which is obviously the negative ideology of the society in which the person who hasn't come out as NB lives in.
this is way more frequent in stories where you will see often bigoted characters which with due time start opening up and become the representation you're actually trying to achieve, instead of just putting it right there, with no service to rest of the narrative because everything really is connected
similarly you won't see a lot of women in big armies and you won't see an LGBT population in iran or fictional places that resemble it
plus i don't see how cis characters are even in the same conversation as NB characters. it's like you asked for something and the other person gave you without asking anything meanwhile NB characters sure do represent a genuine conflict faced by real NB people. writing NB people in a leftist society YOU constructed for the story is like writing cis people in pretty much anything at which point you realise my character can be cis and still be the exact same person so there was no point in writing them as NB and have all my other characters speak their pronouns just to go like "yay representation, now see this fellow NBs" and all the people who aren't NB just have to witness as the writer indulges the reader for no other reason and ultimately the cis people have to sit through with something they can neither relate to nor fully understand because the author doesn't intend to provoke but only to play more into a disconnected fantasy
and the fact is writing gender with the intent to explore it is much more creative and good willed than writing gender with the aim to indulge; cis people aren't going to get a better idea of NB people just by seeing them externally act their gender, they will only truly understand them when the idea is explored and NB people will be much more impacted in this case too
2
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24
but make it side characters and not main characters
No, please, make us main characters without this whole "omg they are so fun and quirky and also sad and depressed" shit.
1
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24
if im seeing an NB character that person HAS to show a behavior which reflects their gender
The fuck are you talking about? How the hell do you think we, NB people, act? Most of us are literally the same as cis people and if we didn't tell you who we are, you would never be able to guess.
why else would i want to see an NB person anyway?
Because we exist maybe? Why would we want to see women in the story, if they're not in the kitchen making dinner for the main character? That's how you sound like to me.
do you give your characters a pet just to make pet owners feel represented or make them feel like people like them exist? no, its not needed if you write a pet into the story, the owner HAS to take care of that pet, or the pet is its own seperate character. the pet is not there to make pet owners realise characters can have pets too, the pet is there for the observer to understand the owner, or the pet has something to express in the story itself, which speaks for how we understand animals
No way you just compared non-binary people to some guy having a pet lol
0
Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 09 '24
i dont know what you expect
storywriting is about exploring concepts not just putting them up for display
if you're not going into the concept you shouldn't include it
to me this type of inclusion is a cheap way of saying i want NB people to be noticed but i don't want to explore what it means to be NB
and what do you do after NB characters are in your story anyway?
it doesn't help that real NB people will continue to be treated the way they are regardless of your inclusion
proper inclusion helps the reader to actually form an opinion and for you to influence them positively2
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24
You are pissing me off. How about you listen to actual nonbinary people in this thread, instead of telling us what is better for us?
that real NB people
I AM that real NB people.
1
Jan 09 '24
im also non binary man
you just seem to not get my approach to it at all
why don't you just see that even though i am non binary i don't want such type of representation
and im clearly expressing why2
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24
And how about you realize that other nonbinary people DO want that representation. Not my fault you want to be miserable 24/7.
1
Jan 09 '24
and im saying how its unrealistic for writing because i can
and the original intention was to tell the person who doesn't have an experience with any of this
if you can go ahead and share your take on this and i can deconstruct what i think about it is unproductive then why shouldn't II just happen to treat stories as they are- fictional at heart but containing a true to life idea or theme
you can put representation but the only reason why i've been emphasizing that it needs to be purposeful is because a lot of the representation up till now has led us here with writers confused whether or not to write it this way
and i'm just saying by looking at other people do it that this can get really twisted1
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24
how its unrealistic
It's not. Just because you are miserable, doesn't mean everyone is miserable. Nonbinary people can have happy life, loving family and amazing accepting friends. How is it unrealistic to portray that in the story?
I just happen to treat stories as they are- fictional at heart but containing a true to life idea or theme
And I'm telling you, that not every story has to contain "true to life ideas" lmao.
it needs to be purposeful
The point is, it doesn't.
a lot of the representation up till now has led us here with writers confused whether or not to write it this way and i'm just saying by looking at other people do it that this can get really twisted
What are you even saying. You are the one treating nonbinary people as monkeys in the circus, most of us DON'T act any different than cis people. You saying that a nonbinary character needs to behave differently is what is really twisted actually. We are normal people, not clowns.
1
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 10 '24
Story writing is about writing a story, not every thing has to be a deep dive into someone's mentality.
if you're not going into the concept you shouldn't include it
We are not just a concept for your story.
0
Jan 09 '24
your philosophy for stories is escapism in a way
you're trying to imagine a world that looks like this world but doesn't work like it
i think that is extremely toxic
instead stories should influence the readers and give them a new perspective about their own lifesimply speaking, characters are not people, they'll always be puppets on a string
why don't you accept them that way and instead try to understand what the writer is trying to do with the puppets instead of projecting yourself on a puppet?2
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24
instead stories should influence the readers and give them a new perspective about their own life
No, lmao. Some stories can deep dive into philosophy, different concepts and different world views. Some are here to entertain you, because life is shitty and you want to read something fun. There's nothing toxic about that.
2
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24
Why the fuck are you constantly editing your comments?
instead of projecting yourself on a puppet?
Aren't you the one who is projecting? A nonbinary person can't have a normal life, because it doesn't fit in your narrative and "you don't want that representation", as if your way was the only way to write and represent A WHOLE COMMUNITY.
YOU are the one complaining that nonbinary people have to be different, look at things differently, do things differently and they should suffer, because the world is sad, and if someone makes the world happy, even if it isn't, then it's toxic and how dare they do that. Like be serious.
0
Jan 09 '24
you mean writing a utopian society which would make a real nb individual compare that to their surrounding and that person who feels stuck and alone would feel even more worthless
2
u/Teollenne Jan 09 '24
Not everything is about you. Just because you don't like a story, doesn't mean it's a bad story. Just because someone is treated well, doesn't mean it's an utopian story.
1
Jan 10 '24
In my opinion, needing your nonbinary characters to have their gender need to play a role in the story, even when the plot(s) aren't about identity or something similar can be bad. If nonbinary characters have to have their gender on display and a key part of the story then you're making it seem like nonbinary people are so fundamentally different to others that it has to be addressed in the narrative no matter what the plot is which can be just as alienating as just not adding them.
Plus, not all nonbinary people will act differently to cis people. I'm nonbinary and I act just like my friends who aren't, saying that we all need to act differently to them is just as much of a stereotype than the things we dislike homophobes/transphobes doing.
If we never treat nonbinary characters the same as we do cis or transgender characters then we aren't being inclusive or practicing equality.
If a cis or trans person identifying a certain way doesn't need to be brought up as a plot point in a story, than a nonbinary person doing the same shouldn't either.
83
u/EitherCaterpillar949 Jan 09 '24
As a nonbinary person I hereby by the powers vested in me give you whatever permission you may need to write a nonbinary character. Should anyone challenge your credentials refer back to me.
There. Just make it interesting or at least not insulting and you’ll be fine.