r/withings • • May 12 '24

Withings Body Scan DO NOT BUY

Post image
1 Upvotes

Really I have a -62% decrease in my body mass???? This product is literally JUNK. also refuses to measure my heart Rate , plus the thing vibrates the floor and wakes up my wife. Support has ghosted me, I think these guys are weeks away from declaring bankruptcy.


r/withings • • Feb 23 '26

Body This is my U-Scan after almost one year… disgusting

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/withings • • Aug 11 '20

ScanWatch not for me.

0 Upvotes

I was keen on having a-fib readings available on my wrist but the ScanWatch just doesn't feel or look right for me. I managed to get on of the initial early 1000 but won't be keeping it.

A-fib readings are hit and miss. Build quality, display and other functionality is all spot on but after wearing a Fenix for several years this dainty watch on my wrist isn't me.


r/withings • • Nov 02 '25

My Body Cardio calls this 18.7% body fat

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/withings • • Feb 21 '24

Horrible product, please don’t waste your money

0 Upvotes

I got a Body Cardio last year which was working fine for about 2 weeks - then it started giving me absolutely irrational measurements (eg 3% bodyfat when it was measuring 19% the day before). I had a lot of back and forth with the horrible customer service to confirm that I have not used any cleaning products on it that would damage the sensors, I have reset it 6 times, and confirmed I do not have athlete mode on. After a very painful experience I did get an exchange product which I have been using for the past couple of months. This one was giving me a consistent 20% bodyfat (which is acceptable - I’d say I’m around 20-25%); but has started giving me 10-13% in the past couple of weeks (again, I’d say I’m close to 25%). Ok. Ignore the body fat, at least it syncs my weight to Apple health. Today, that stopped. I have reset everything multiple times. It does not sync to the app anymore. This is completely unacceptable, I don’t even trust the weight it shows me anymore. For anyone considering buying a Withings scale, don’t.

You can buy scales from Amazon that also sync to Bluetooth, does not get damaged if you look at it, and does not have an annoying app that has half a screen blocked for “medals” that I absolutely don’t care about. Worst €200 ever spent.


r/withings • • Jul 15 '26

Body Comp Body Composition failure

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve had my Body Comp for a few years and the body fat and composition features have been hit or miss. Lately after cleaning and factory resets, I am unable to get any sort of reading beyond weight, heart rate, and EDA.

I contacted support and the solution was a 30% off coupon since I’m beyond the warranty window. Anyone have tips or tricks to get this back in action? I’m hesitant to buy a new product. I’ve had a Withings scale since 2018 and appreciate the historical data. Might be time to move on.

Body Scan seems to have mixed reviews and fluctuations on body fat measurements.


r/withings • • Dec 20 '25

Scanwatch 2

0 Upvotes

When I get out of bed and go to the lounge this stupid watch adds some of the time I am awake sitting in my chair watching the news on tv to my sleep time. It won't take ecg's.

It is not fit for purpose.


r/withings • • May 27 '24

Confirmed -the Body Scan is highly inaccurate.

0 Upvotes

I've been using the Body+ scale for years now. Like all body fat scales, I know it's inaccurate, and I'm fine with that as long as it's close enough and consistent. The Body+ tells me I'm cose to 50% body fat. My mirror tells me that's about right.

I've been on a mission to get my health on track since November and I've lost about 60lbs since then. I'm tracking everything I can, and I saw that the Body Scan offered some additional details at the body segment. I was going to a local health clinic for this, but I thought it would be great to get it from home.

This morning was my first weigh in, and the Body Scan had me at 17% body fat. I tried again, this time with athlete mode enabled (I do workout daily nowadays), and it dropped to 14%. The Body+ had me at 49%.

So I'll call Withings in the morning and speak to support once before I send it back, but - yeah looks like it's going back tomorrow afternoon.


r/withings • • Jul 21 '18

Withings or the permanent nightmare of Android app !!

0 Upvotes

Some other android users of Withings products ? I'm thinking seriously here to prosecute them in justice for permanent failure to keep Android app working (needs reinstall every few updates, loose synchro features also every few updates) and it's like that since years !! Each time you complain they do nothing about it and next update combines all bugs with new ones....

Even basic features like an alarm for missing synchro has never been implemented (probably too complicated for their so bad android programmers !).

Someone else in same situation ?

Perhaps reason why Nokia decided to sell it back to founder, they probably realised Withings is just nice marketing unable to keep at least their app in working order !!

PS: their support is pretty efficient to consider you like dumb ! When you ask support legal address of company for legal action, they ignore questions, and then suddenly offers to exchange your product that would have defective battery..... Very smart way to consider your customers....


r/withings • • Nov 13 '24

BPM Core is garbage

0 Upvotes

Complete and utter garbage.

I threw it away in less than 7 days of usage, wouldn't bother buying their BP machine ever again.

Its measurements are not precise. I tested it while connected to a real hospital vitals monitor and it showed way lower BP than I realistically had. That is quite dangerous for someone who checks up their health at home for obvious reasons.

Ergonomically this device is a nightmare. It was obviously designed by DIE hire. It looks like it is not designed with health in mind, but for the sake of bling (it has connectivity , nice app, sync with Apple health muuuuhh).

If you are at least a bit muscular ie. if you have large(ish) triceps good luck fitting the device on yourself. No matter what you do there will be a pocket of air and device's cannot fill the gap resulting in error. So you will have a quite frustrating time fitting this garbage on your arm. This issue could possibly be solvable if the cuff was not made semi-solid so it could wrap itself normally around the arm. Keep in mind I am not retarded, I do measure my BP regularly and I have multiple BP machines myself. And I am not shaped like bodybuilder, did not even hit the gym for 5 years. I do have some muscles but really nothing special.

The stethoscope fell off by itself during the night (the device was on the shelf nobody touched it)...Overall quality wise I felt like I bought 20$ Temu/Aliexpress device, but for 10x of the price.

Maybe the development team will figure things out with their next device, but this one is not usable for medical purposes, don't buy it for that. If you can spare some money for a medically themed toy/gadget than go for it.


r/withings • • Oct 01 '23

100 days of 10k steps. And all I got was this pop up on the watch

Post image
7 Upvotes

There should be badges for this, and the app should show both current and best streaks.


r/withings • • May 30 '25

Do not buy WITHING products - especially the Body Scan- terrible customer support.

0 Upvotes

I just got off an hour-long chat with Withings customer support, and it was awful. The issue was with the body scan, giving an error message that says “ inconclusive body scan.” This is a known issue, and there are many posts about it in this subreddit.

First off, it’s very difficult to find how to get support, and when you do, the reps literally just give you the runaround. Asking for more and more information— even asking for things that don’t make sense and won’t help fix the issue . For example, first, they wanted permission to access my device (fine), next, they had me do three measurements and send them the time and date(done), then they wanted me to send them pictures of my hands on the handles and the screen that says “ body scan inconclusive”— how the hell am I supposed to take a picture of that when I’m standing on the scale with my hands on the electrodes completely still per their instructions? They have my log and diagnostic information- how would a picture of the screen help? Also- the message shows on the screen for less than a second - so I couldn’t do it anyway. This obviously just a ploy to waste my time or find a reason to deny my claim.

I got really frustrated and gave up— at the end, she said some crap about she’ll escalate to another level of tech or something, but at this point, I accept the fact that this company sells junk, and I’m hoping that at the very least I can help the Reddit community help make their decision about whether they want to support this company or not. I’ve been a customer of this company for almost 20 years, and I will never buy their products again, and I am now a detractor. I posted a video of the chat I had so you can see what I mean— maybe I was a little bit frustrated, but I should be after spending this kind of money and getting the runaround.


r/withings • • Jun 03 '25

Withings Body Smart scale are complete joke, returned my, here is my rev

0 Upvotes
  1. Unpacking. I feel like I’m paying for a package, not for a product. It’s not 2005 anymore, Apple products have maybe 20% of the paper waste for x20 more expensive products.

  2. Subscription banner on the first screen that I can’t even remove? Seriously?

  3. Body fat % is way less accurate than all other smart scale I have tried. I got 18% from this, in a real life I have about ~21%. Xiaomi 2019 told me I have 24% and Xiaomi 2024 s400 told me I have ~22%.

  4. I got like 15 notifications in a week from just a scale. What?

So I decide to return this 70% of marketing 20% of package and 10% of actual product “device”.

Got Xiaomi s400, way-way better.


r/withings • • Jun 28 '22

is this normal after taking off the watch?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/withings • • Aug 24 '24

Gained 15% muscle after switching to “athlete” mode? Seriously questioning this scale

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi all, I am a relatively fit 41 year old female. I won the body cardio Withings scale and have been using it for about half a year. I’ve upped my weight lifting to daily in the past 6 months but noticed that my body fat % was hovering around 25%, the remainder being muscle (72%) and bone. It didn’t make sense as I could clearly see muscle definition and knew it should’ve been changing. After some troubleshooting and suggestions on this sub, I switched to the “athlete” mode and all of a sudden my body composition shifted by 15%. Now my fat % is 12.8%, which is ridiculous. What kind of sourcery is this? How do I get it to actually do its job? Considering tossing this scale at this point.


r/withings • • Sep 26 '26

ScanWatch 2 Just bought the Scanwatch2 and it's absolutely terrible. Is this normal?

0 Upvotes

******update I've apparently had 3 bouts of AFIb now today!!!!!

All not even wearing the watch!!!!! Or having it even in the room!!

This app and watch is absolutely awful. I would NOT buy it for it's ECG capabilities because the bloody thing is absolutely nuts!!!!!!!!

Want it gone asap.

I have been having some random heart palpitation issues (extremely unlikely to be AFIb because I've had heart issues for 20 years and they are pretty much exclusively ventricular related, not atrial) and my cardiologist won't implant a loop recorder and suggested I get a smart watch to see if we can catch it.

I do have a proper ECG monitor I can wear all the time but it's a strap and extremely uncomfortable to wear 24/7.

We understand the restrictions of a 1 lead.

So we did our research and withings seemed to come out best 😬

First issue was that they don't make it clear that there's at least a 2 - 3 second pause after activating it that it starts recording which isn't ideal for sudden arrhythmias but we thought we'd give it a go.

Anyway it's got this blasted sleep thing on it so thought I would do that aswell and it started off ok but we're now on day 4 or 5 and it's gone nuts as I'm sleeping really well but every day it's telling me my sleep is worse and worse 😆

Started on a score of 78 then 63, then 40 something and today was 28 😆 and it said I slept for 3 hours which I didn't, I slept for 9. It's also telling me that I'm waking constantly throughout the night for an hour at a time which again, I'm not 🙈

And today it's started telling me that I'm having afib when I'm not even wearing the watch 😆

Now I am so in tune with my body, I can pretty much tell you what ventricular rhythm I'm in simply by feeling it and I'm normally correct if matched up with a 12 lead.

If I was in AFIb, I'll tell you now, Id be feeling something other than sinus rhythm.

First time I was sat on the bed and it was the other side of the bed and told me I was in AFIb at a rate of 125bpm. I took my pulse and it was sinus at 67bpm.

Second time was just now. I'm in the bath and the watch told me I was in AFIb again 🙄

Im not, I'm a good 6 metres from it.

It also sends me a notification every 5 minutes about something, anything, which is driving me mad.

So safe to say I don't think withings is for me 😆

But is this normal for this particular brand or are they all just a bit crap?

This is my first foray into smart watches and given I've heard withings is the best, I am somewhat nervous they are all going to be terrible.

I absolutely hate wearing watches and don't want any health monitoring besides the ECG thing so are there any out there which may fit my needs better?

Feel a little disappointed tbh.


r/withings • • Sep 13 '21

Withings alternatives? (Rant)

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

Just going to start with - I really do love my steel HR Withings watch. I've had it for about 8 months now, and it's been going strong. I swear I never need to think about charging it & it's the perfect size for me.
I understand that more features mean that the battery will drain faster - either from additional use or just the added power draw of a new wi-fi module, larger screen, colour etc. And part of the reason I got this watch was that I didn't want to pay for a bunch of novelty features that I will never use - it does exactly what I want... almost...

So my frustration comes from the fact that it only has 3 alarms?! Why?? is it a memory issue? Or the chip only has so many interrupts, and they made no effort to solve this issue in software. On top of this, their forum is next to useless - there is no communication or comments from the team on the majority of posts which makes the page(s) pretty redundant.

I know the alarms sound like a pretty minor detail, but I honestly searched around to see if I could hack the watch and program it myself to add more. I forget things a lot and want to keep myself on track without needing to have a blazingly loud alarm from my phone going off every 15 minutes.
Ideally, I'd love the app to be able to set alarms for me based on calendar schedules (no need to integrate anything fancier than the existing Bluetooth link into the watch to get this to work).

Can the newer models do anything like this? Am I missing something? And are there alternatives (nothing like the Samsung galaxy - it's far too big and clunky, limited battery life and has heaps of useless features)?

I'm aware that I'm pedantic, but there are many pedantic developers out there that make features that impress me to no end. So maybe someone has some suggestions?

Am I the only one annoyed by the alarms and lack of feedback?


r/withings • • Dec 22 '19

Personal initial review of the Steel HR Sport

Thumbnail
blog.richardcrosby.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/withings • • Jun 15 '26

Body Scan The "90-second" myth, U18 restrictions & Pre-Update Longevity tracking x Body Scan 2

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’ve been testing the new Body Scan 2 and here are a few things Withings doesn't exactly highlight on their sales pages:

The 90-second scan is a myth. From picking up the handle to putting it down, it takes me exactly 2:30 minutes every single morning.

The U18 restriction: If you plan to use this with your family, keep in mind that body composition is completely blocked for teenagers under 18.

Precision: On the positive side, I did consecutive back-to-back tests and the consistency is insanely good (max 0.1-0.2% variance).

A quick note on the Longevity tracking: This review covers the longevity features (Vascular Age, ECG, etc.) before the newest firmware update. My scale hasn't received the update yet! Standing still for 2.5 minutes every morning just to get this data takes some serious commitment. I'm currently tracking how useful these long-term trends actually are and will drop a "Part 2" video specifically focusing on the longevity updates as soon as the firmware finally hits my device.

If you are on the fence about buying the BS2, you can check out my full visual test and the app data here: 👉 https://youtu.be/DDFaUhicHoA

Would love to hear your thoughts! Has anyone here actually received the new update yet, and does it speed things up?


r/withings • • Oct 16 '26

Body Scan Is a Withings+ subscription worth it?

3 Upvotes

Is there anyone out there who pays 100$ yearly for the subscription? What value does it bring to you? Is it really better then for instance HealthKit? Does it give you extra insights?


r/withings • • Jan 18 '23

The latest Health Mate update locks a 400$ scale feature behind a paywall?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/withings • • Apr 19 '23

Guess what is the most ugly icon on my Home Screen since yesterday?

2 Upvotes

I really liked to old icon much more. https://i.imgur.com/qXCk0Vn.jpg


r/withings • • Feb 17 '22

I feel like Withings doesn't even want us to buy their watches

0 Upvotes

Hello,

I have purchased 2 Withings watches and 3 bracelets from Amazon. After several days of delays in my order I found out it wasn't even sent yet. I then cancelled my purchase and ordered the watches off their website. After 2 days my purchase got cancelled with no other reason than that it was considered "suspicious". I contacted customer support who told me it was because I used a different billing and shipping address.

I was upset because I especially bought it during a sale and by the time my purchase was cancelled the sale was over. After calling customer service (finding a phone number was also more like a treasure hunt) it was agreed that I would replace my order and after would receive a reimbursment of the amount of the sale (since the order was cancelled on Withings side). So I replace my order, this time making sure I use the same adress for billing and shipping. After a few hours I see it's beeing manually reviewed AGAIN. I contact cutomer service and offer to send a copy of my ID to confirm that I am indeed the holder of the card used. Customer service tells me it was cancelled again, because it was suspicious and I should use another card.

I have been shopping online with the same delivery adress and same card for months. Never ever had any issue with any other website. What is going on seriously ? Did anybody face the same kind of issue with Withings ? I have already wasted a significant amount of time on this, plus one of the watches was a valentine's day gift which was obviously ruined. Do you have any advice on getting actual useful help from customer service ? At this point I feel like I have to fight to actually buy on of their products. It's a shame because I already have one of their watches and really liked it.

Would be grateful on any kind of advice !


r/withings • • Feb 11 '25

Body Fat Percentage

0 Upvotes

Since the body fat percentages on the scales are so off that they are unbelievable. Could it be that the body fat percentage isn’t what is commonly known as body fat percentage? I reached out to the company to find out their exact definition of body fat percentage, but im thinking they are calling an apple an orange, and we all think they are calling an apple an apple.

I just refuse to believe something so expensive could be so wrong.

What are your thoughts? Has anyone gotten clarity from the company?