r/withings • u/xerman-5 • Nov 14 '25
What's happening at Withings? An open letter to the company
Over the past few days, this subreddit has been flooded with concerning posts about Withings' recent business practices. As a customer who has trusted you with two watches already, the smart scale and the BMP Core + , I'm writing this to consolidate the growing frustration and hopefully get someone from Withings to take notice.
The Issues We're Seeing:
Aggressive subscription tactics - Multiple users report that the Health Mate app now feels like it's designed primarily to push W+ subscriptions rather than provide straightforward access to our health data. Basic metrics that should be instantly visible are buried behind subscription prompts. I hate the new app, sorry.
Confusing billing practices - Customers are being charged $99 immediately for subscriptions they thought had 14-day trials, with no warning that they'd already used their trial period previously.
Questionable marketing emails - Many of us are receiving emails that feel deceptive, trying to trick us into paying for unnecessary subscriptions.
Retroactive feature removal - This is perhaps the most concerning: users report that devices they've owned for years are suddenly losing functionality. Features like oxygen saturation tracking and heart measurements are disappearing from Scanwatch devices. BPM Connect devices are losing sync capabilities. Some users even report their devices being essentially "bricked" unless they agree to new privacy terms that allow data selling.
No battery replacement service - Withings offers no official battery replacement program for their watches. This means an expensive, fully functional watch becomes e-waste the moment the battery degrades. This is not only wasteful for customers who invested a big chunk of money, but it's environmentally irresponsible. In an era where we should be fighting planned obsolescence and reducing electronic waste, Withings is forcing customers into a cycle of consumption and pollution. A quality watch should last years with simple battery replacements, instead Withings treats them as disposable. The situation is so absurd that individual users have had to search for and test different batteries ON THEIR OWN, going through a costly and potentially dangerous DIY process just to repair a watch that should have official service support. When your customers are forced to become amateur repair technicians because you won't provide basic maintenance services, something is fundamentally wrong.
Why This Matters:
Withings built its reputation on quality health tracking devices and user trust. What we're witnessing now feels like a company in financial trouble making desperate short-term decisions that will destroy long-term customer loyalty.
We paid good money for these devices with certain features and privacy expectations. Retroactively removing functionality or forcing us to accept new data-sharing terms to continue using products we already own is not just poor customer service, it feels like a breach of trust.
To Withings Leadership:
If anyone from Withings is reading this: you're losing customers. Not just potential future sales, but active users who loved your products and recommended them to others. We're now telling people to avoid Withings entirely.
The W+ subscription could be a reasonable offering if:
The base product remained fully functional as purchased
The subscription added genuinely valuable features
The pricing reflected the actual value provided
Existing device features weren't stripped away to force upgrades
Instead, it feels like you're holding our own devices hostage.
To Fellow Users:
Has anyone managed to get in touch with Withings support about these issues? Has anyone received satisfactory responses? Are there any Withings representatives actually monitoring this community?
Withings, please engage with your community. We're not just complaining, we're asking you to reconsider the path you're on before you lose us entirely.
Fellow Withings users: please share your experiences below. The more visibility we can bring to these issues, the more likely we are to get a response.
