r/withings • • Nov 14 '25

What's happening at Withings? An open letter to the company

363 Upvotes

Over the past few days, this subreddit has been flooded with concerning posts about Withings' recent business practices. As a customer who has trusted you with two watches already, the smart scale and the BMP Core + , I'm writing this to consolidate the growing frustration and hopefully get someone from Withings to take notice.

The Issues We're Seeing:

Aggressive subscription tactics - Multiple users report that the Health Mate app now feels like it's designed primarily to push W+ subscriptions rather than provide straightforward access to our health data. Basic metrics that should be instantly visible are buried behind subscription prompts. I hate the new app, sorry.

Confusing billing practices - Customers are being charged $99 immediately for subscriptions they thought had 14-day trials, with no warning that they'd already used their trial period previously.

Questionable marketing emails - Many of us are receiving emails that feel deceptive, trying to trick us into paying for unnecessary subscriptions.

Retroactive feature removal - This is perhaps the most concerning: users report that devices they've owned for years are suddenly losing functionality. Features like oxygen saturation tracking and heart measurements are disappearing from Scanwatch devices. BPM Connect devices are losing sync capabilities. Some users even report their devices being essentially "bricked" unless they agree to new privacy terms that allow data selling.

No battery replacement service - Withings offers no official battery replacement program for their watches. This means an expensive, fully functional watch becomes e-waste the moment the battery degrades. This is not only wasteful for customers who invested a big chunk of money, but it's environmentally irresponsible. In an era where we should be fighting planned obsolescence and reducing electronic waste, Withings is forcing customers into a cycle of consumption and pollution. A quality watch should last years with simple battery replacements, instead Withings treats them as disposable. The situation is so absurd that individual users have had to search for and test different batteries ON THEIR OWN, going through a costly and potentially dangerous DIY process just to repair a watch that should have official service support. When your customers are forced to become amateur repair technicians because you won't provide basic maintenance services, something is fundamentally wrong.

Why This Matters:

Withings built its reputation on quality health tracking devices and user trust. What we're witnessing now feels like a company in financial trouble making desperate short-term decisions that will destroy long-term customer loyalty.

We paid good money for these devices with certain features and privacy expectations. Retroactively removing functionality or forcing us to accept new data-sharing terms to continue using products we already own is not just poor customer service, it feels like a breach of trust.

To Withings Leadership:

If anyone from Withings is reading this: you're losing customers. Not just potential future sales, but active users who loved your products and recommended them to others. We're now telling people to avoid Withings entirely.

The W+ subscription could be a reasonable offering if:

  • The base product remained fully functional as purchased

  • The subscription added genuinely valuable features

  • The pricing reflected the actual value provided

  • Existing device features weren't stripped away to force upgrades

Instead, it feels like you're holding our own devices hostage.

To Fellow Users:

Has anyone managed to get in touch with Withings support about these issues? Has anyone received satisfactory responses? Are there any Withings representatives actually monitoring this community?

Withings, please engage with your community. We're not just complaining, we're asking you to reconsider the path you're on before you lose us entirely.

Fellow Withings users: please share your experiences below. The more visibility we can bring to these issues, the more likely we are to get a response.


r/withings • • Oct 15 '26 Bravo

Body Scan Withings' official response to the Apple Health paywall is absolute PR garbage. Don't fall for it

Post image
352 Upvotes

#SyncGate

So Withings just posted their official "clarification" on the support forum regarding the $99/year paywall for Apple Health sync, and it is a masterclass in corporate gaslighting.

Let’s break down the sheer amount of bullshit in their statement:

1. "Withings+ funds the services around your data" Absolute lie. Writing your weight to Apple Health via HealthKit or Google Health Connect is a local, on-device API call. It happens directly between the Withings app and the Apple Health app on your phone. It requires ZERO cloud computing, ZERO server maintenance, and ZERO of their new "AI Connector" processing. It costs Withings exactly $0.00. They are intentionally holding a free, local API call hostage to force you into paying for their AI medical features that nobody asked for.

2. "Existing accounts are grandfathered! Nothing changes for you!" This isn't a favor; it’s a calculated divide-and-conquer tactic. They know that if they retroactively paywalled existing users, they’d face massive backlash, European consumer protection probes, and tanked app ratings overnight. By grandfathering old accounts, they are hoping we just shut up and look the other way while they screw over every new customer. Bought a scale for your partner or kid? Congrats, their new account is paywalled on the hardware you already own.

3. "You can still export a CSV for free!" Ah yes, thank you Withings. Let me just open a spreadsheet and manually import rows of data on my iPhone every morning in 2026. We bought smart scales specifically for automation. Offering a manual CSV export as a "feature" is frankly insulting. A $15 no-name Chinese scale off Amazon manages to sync automatically to Apple Health for free, but a $200 Withings scale can't?

Don't let them spin this as "funding the ecosystem." It’s a blatant, predatory cash grab. If they get away with paywalling basic, local API syncs today, what are they going to lock behind Withings+ tomorrow?

Please continue to vote and write >>>>> HERE in the official support forum <<<<<


r/withings • • Oct 16 '26

Body Scan Multiple major outlets reporting on the anti-consumer decision Withings made to screw over their customers Apple Health syncing. If you’re considering buying Withings atm, don’t.

Post image
301 Upvotes

r/withings • • Oct 13 '26

Body Scan Call to Action: Help pressure Withings to reverse the Apple Health paywall! (Link to official forum)

274 Upvotes

Hey r/withings,

As many of you have seen, Withings recently made a terrible, anti-consumer move: starting October 13th, new accounts are forced to pay $99/year for Withings+ just to sync their data to Apple Health.Writing to Apple Health via HealthKit is a local process on the phone. It requires zero cloud computing or server costs from Withings. This is nothing but a blatant cash grab, and it ruins the experience for families, partners, or anyone buying a new device.

Complaining here on Reddit is good, but we need to hit their official channels if we want them to backtrack.

I just created a thread on the official Withings Support Forum calling them out on this nonsense and their contradictory customer service replies (support literally told me it's a "standard free feature" and then in the next sentence said new accounts must pay for it).

Unacceptable: Apple Health Sync is now behind a $99/year paywall for new accounts – Withings | Support

Please take 60 seconds to click the link, upvote the post, and leave a quick comment. If enough of us make our voices heard directly on their platform, they’ll be forced to address it before this becomes the new standard.

Let’s not let them get away with paywalling basic features on hardware we already paid a premium for.


r/withings • • Oct 13 '26

Body PSA: New Withings accounts (from Oct 12, 2026) need Withings+ ($99.99/yr) to sync to Apple Health. Existing accounts unaffected for now

Post image
252 Upvotes

tldr: if you make a new withings account on or after oct 12 2026, the app won't send your weight to apple health unless you pay for withings+ ($9.99/mo or $99.99/yr). older accounts seem grandfathered for now.

set up a new withings body this week. bought it specifically because it's sold as apple health compatible. went to turn on apple health sync and got a paywall instead (screenshot).

"Syncing your measurements to Apple Health is part of Withings+ and needs an active membership. It starts the moment you join."

14 day trial then $99.99/year, or $9.99/month.

the funny part is importing FROM apple health into the withings app is still free. so they'll happily take all your apple health data, you just can't send your own weight back out without paying... you can still manually download a csv/pdf of your data.

as far as i know it's tied to your account, not the scale, so it should hit any withings device on a new account (body, body smart, body comp, body scan, watches etc). if you're an existing user don't delete your account and make a new one or you'll probably lose the grandfathering.

none of the "apple health compatible" listings on amazon mention any of this. returned mine.

if you set up a new account after oct 12 let me know if you got the same screen so people searching for this can see it confirmed.

also read:

https://www.reddit.com/r/withings/comments/1x3a30l/withings_is_locking_down_their_api_for_new/

https://developer.withings.com/developer-guide/v3/withings-solutions/withings-api-plans/


r/withings • • Oct 15 '26

Body Scan Mac Rumors Just Picked Up the Apple Health Story

188 Upvotes

r/withings • • 27d ago

Body Scan Update - Withings will not come back - 15 October 2026

174 Upvotes

TL;DR: Customer Support is actively lying to users about legal and technical API limitations to cover up a predatory cash grab. They know exactly what they are doing: monetizing hardware we already paid for because they want a piece of the software subscription pie.

Hey everyone,

As you probably noticed, Withings has been completely dead silent on their official English channels regarding the new $99/year paywall for Apple Health / third-party sync.

But I didn't want to let this go, so I did some digging into their replies on X.com (Twitter). It turns out, while they are ignoring the international community, they gave an exclusive interview to Numerama (a major French tech publication) defending their decision.

I read the article (you can translate it here: https://www.numerama.com/tech/2353527-la-vraie-valeur-cest-la-donnee-withings-defend-sa-decision-de-faire-payer-la-synchronisation-avec-apple-et-strava.html), and what their Product Manager (Vincent Brand) admitted completely exposes the bullshit their customer support has been feeding us.

Here is the "this, this, and this" of what they actually confessed:

  1. They lied about GDPR and Privacy When I confronted Customer Support, they explicitly told me the paywall was necessary to "upgrade privacy frameworks" and comply with "strict GDPR standards" for data pipelines. In the Numerama interview? Zero mention of GDPR or privacy. The Product Manager openly admitted it's purely a commercial decision for the "survival" of the company.

  2. "Data is the real value" They stated out loud that selling hardware isn't enough anymore. They are mad that third-party apps (like Bevel, Strava, or AI health assistants) are analyzing Withings data for free while Withings "takes all the R&D risks." So, they decided to hold our basic, local API sync hostage to force us into their ecosystem. Their goal is to become the "super health app in Europe."

  3. The "European Sovereignty" Hypocrisy They tried to justify locking the data by saying they want to protect users from American tech giants. But here is the kicker: if you pay them $99 a year, they will happily give you the premium privilege of... sending your data to those exact same American tech giants!

You can check out the original thread on their official support forum here: Unacceptable: Apple Health Sync is now behind a $99/year paywall for new accounts – Withings | Support

There are already hundreds of comments and upvotes from outraged users who feel completely betrayed. Honestly, at this point, I don't even know whether to ask you to keep posting and upvoting there to make noise, or simply tell you to abandon this brand forever and vote with your wallets.

This whole situation is beyond frustrating. #SyncGate #WithingsGreed


r/withings • • Oct 13 '26

Body Scan Withings+ Apple Health Paywall

174 Upvotes

Given the recent change to lock metric syncing to Apple Health (for new accounts now but who knows what’s next) behind a pointless $99/year subscription, aside from not buying any more products, we should update our App Store reviews to reflect our dissatisfaction.


r/withings • • Dec 05 '25

Thanks Withings. Seriously... A-Fib Detection.

141 Upvotes

I have long been critical of the sleep tracking function on my Scanwatch but around a week ago, it alterted me to something serious and, as a result I might just be sticking with Withings forever.

Last Friday night I had a buzz on my wrist which was a warning about an irregular heartbeat. I did a couple of ECG tests and they confirmed that something was wrong.

I managed very little sleep that night and when I continued feeling shaky the following morning, I repeated the test several times, all positive, so took myself off to the Hospital.

Within a couple of hours (thanks too to the ever-wonderful NHS) I had been diagnosed with atrial fibulation, given beta blockers and blood thinners and left with renewed respect to this wonderful piece of technology on my wrist.

Thanks to my Scanwatch, I didn't have a heart attack or a stroke, my condition was picked up quickly and dealt with before it had chance to do any real damage. I am very very grateful.


r/withings • • 27d ago

Body Smart Withings introduces Scale-As-A-Service; SaaS hits a new low

Thumbnail
youtube.com
126 Upvotes

r/withings • • Oct 17 '26

BPM Connect Withings Google Search

Post image
125 Upvotes

Hmmm…. Time to retreat and rethink….


r/withings • • 29d ago

Body Scan If Withings wants to charge us to export our data, we should stop letting them import ours

124 Upvotes

Withings has decided that new users must pay for Withings+ to automatically sync their data with Apple Health, Google Health Connect, and other third-party apps.

Fine. But if Withings wants to put our own data behind a paywall, why should we continue giving them free access to health data collected by devices made by other companies?

Many of us use Apple Health or Google Health Connect as a central hub for all our health data, combining information from smartwatches, fitness trackers, blood pressure monitors, and other devices. Withings can access some of that information with our permission and use it to enrich its own health platform.

Why should the data flow only one way?

I encourage everyone to review their Apple Health or Google Health Connect permissions and revoke Withings’ access to data collected by non-Withings devices. Only grant them access to the data they actually need to provide the services you use.

If Withings wants to build a walled garden, let’s stop giving them the materials for free.


r/withings • • Oct 17 '26

Body Scan I do t even care that I’m ‘grandfathered’ in any more.

Post image
122 Upvotes

15 years of good will gone.

There is only one language they understand


r/withings • • Oct 10 '26

Body Scan Body Scan 2 detected AFib this morning - currently writing this from the ER

119 Upvotes

Morning 👋

Just an anecdote as n=1.

I’m 37 and have never had any known heart issues.

This morning I woke up feeling completely fine and was getting ready to head out for a 10-mile hike.

Stepped on my Body Scan 2 for my weekly longevity scan and it detected AFib. Thought that was odd, as I’d never seen that before, and my WHOOP w/ECG functionality (which I’ve had for about a year) has always shown normal sinus rhythm.

So I ran an ECG on my WHOOP, which also detected possible AFib.

Fast forward a couple of hours - went to urgent care, who referred me to the ER after seeing the same on their ECG.

Now in the hospital with confirmed AFib, and I’m currently lying here while they run more tests.

The strange thing is I still feel completely fine. 🤞🙏

If it wasn’t for the Body Scan 2, I’d probably be halfway through my hike right now, completely unaware.

So, just some n=1 anecdotal evidence that the BS2 earned its money today. 👍


r/withings • • Nov 26 '25 Helpful Thanks

Withings Customer Concerns: A Complete Wrap-Up

118 Upvotes

Summary of what happened

After posting an open letter about Withings' business practices on r/withings , the post gained significant traction (299+ upvotes, 138+ comments). Withings' social media team (Rudy) kindly responded both privately and publicly. It has now been around 12 days since the original post. Here is, I hope, a comprehesive summary of what happened.

1. DEVICES BEING "BRICKED" BY SOFTWARE UPDATES

The Problem: Users report being locked out of their devices unless they accept new Terms of Service. No ability to postpone, skip, or continue using previously purchased hardware. Forced to provide additional personal data (country, age, etc.) to access devices they already own.

User quote: "Standing nude in my bathroom at 5 am after getting off the scale and you idiots want to require me to make an account change with no option to postpone it?"

Withings' Response: "We need your country to apply correct regulatory frameworks for medical devices and comply with local privacy laws like CCPA. Your personal data is never, ever sold."

Reality Check: Users don't trust this after the pattern of behavior. Forced collection with no postponement option feels coercive. New terms allow data sharing with third parties (even if not "sold" I don't know, maybe there is an exchange of info and then it's "legal"?).

What Should Happen:

  • Allow users to continue using devices without forced acceptance of new terms

  • Provide clear opt-out options with no loss of core functionality

  • For existing users, granular consent for new data collection only

  • Implement a grace period where users can postpone updates

2. DECEPTIVE SUBSCRIPTION EMAIL

The Problem: Email with "dark patterns" designed to trick users into subscribing. Button that instantly registered users without confirmation. No clear explanation of what the subscription was for. Made users feel their account had issues when it was just a sales push. Multiple users reported it to data protection authorities.

Withings' Response: "We understand the communication may have been misunderstood. We learned from this and it has already been adjusted. Nothing related to a subscription or your account being locked."

They sent a follow-up apology email admitting it "did not meet our standards." We have a confirmed german and english version (I just received the email, please confirm if you also got it).

Reality Check: Admission of error without clear consequences. The damage to trust is done. "Adjusted" is vague with no specifics.

What Should Happen:

  • Official public statement acknowledging the deceptive email was wrong

  • Clear commitment: "We will never use dark pattern marketing again"

  • Third-party audit of marketing practices to rebuild trust

  • Transparent explanation of what "adjusted" actually means

3. NO BATTERY REPLACEMENT SERVICE

The Problem: Expensive watches (€300-600) become e-waste when the battery degrade naturally. No official repair service despite premium pricing. Support only offers discount codes for new purchases. Users forced to attempt dangerous DIY battery replacements. Creates unnecessary electronic waste and environmental damage.

Withings' Response: "Should we offer a battery replacement service or broader repair services? The answer is yes, and it's obvious we need to move in that direction. We aren't able to provide a specific timeline today, but yes, we take this topic very seriously."

Reality Check: No timeline = no commitment. "We take it seriously" without action is meaningless in my opinion. Meanwhile, perfectly functional devices continue becoming e-waste. It's crazy, it's insane.

What Should Happen:

  • Announce official battery replacement service WITH A SPECIFIC TIMELINE (e.g., "Q2 2025")

  • Provide interim solutions: mail-in service, third-party authorized repair centers

  • Retroactive program for devices that died due to battery degradation

  • Commitment to right-to-repair principles in future product design

4. AGGRESSIVE IN-APP SUBSCRIPTION PROMPTS

The Problem: Withings+ advertising plastered throughout the app. Cannot be disabled or hidden. Appears on home screen, persists when scrolling, shows up in every section.

User quote: "Who in their right mind would throw €600 and willingly sign up to be shown ads?"

Withings' Response: "I hear your concerns about how it can feel intrusive vs your product price point, and your feedback has been passed along to the team."

Reality Check: Acknowledged concern but no commitment to change. "Passed along to the team" is corporate speak for "noted." again without any commitment. We need actions, we are on 2025 and we know the corporate mumbo-jumbo, we just don't buy it.

What Should Happen:

  • Add toggle to hide all Withings+ prompts for users who don't want it.

  • Stop treating customers who paid good money for hardware like free-tier users.

  • Respect that hardware purchase should mean ad-free experience.

  • Limit subscription prompts, ability to op-out of them.

5. FEATURES DISAPPEARING FROM PURCHASED DEVICES

The Problem: Users report losing access to oxygen saturation tracking, heart measurements. BPM Connect losing sync capabilities. Uncertainty about whether this is bugs or intentional feature removal.

Withings' Response: "Never, ever, has any measurement available at the time of product purchase been moved behind a paywall. If this is happening, it may be a bug."

Reality Check: Users report real functionality losses. Whether bug or intentional, it's happening and damaging trust. "May be a bug" is not reassuring. Please, contact the users, address the problems, keep us updated and well informed.

What Should Happen:

  • Immediate investigation and public report on all reported feature losses.

  • Clear statement: "Here's what's included with hardware purchase, here's what requires subscription".

  • Promise: Written on stone: "features present at time of purchase will never be paywalled".

  • Bug fixes for all reported feature losses with transparent and public changelog.

ADDITIONAL LONG-TERM CHANGES NEEDED

Rebuild Trust Through Actions:

  • Regular community engagement on Reddit (not just during crises).

  • Customer advisory board for product decisions.

  • Annual sustainability report showing e-waste reduction efforts.

Subscription Model Refinement:

  • Make Withings+ genuinely valuable (not just AI fluff or a way to collect money after we buy the hardware)

  • Never use coercive tactics to push subscriptions. Be simple, be clear. It's very easy to not be sneaky.

  • Hardware buyers should feel respected, not exploited

BOTTOM LINE (IMO)

What Withings Did: Acknowledged problems, provided explanations, but made zero concrete commitments with timelines or measurable actions.

What Withings Needs To Do: Move beyond damage control to genuine accountability. Words without actions will continue losing customers.

Please, share your opinion, your ideas, they clearly matter because we have been heard, now let's keep pushing to get real actions.


r/withings • • Dec 17 '23

Details on Android battery drain issue with watches

106 Upvotes

In case anyone was interested in the details on the battery drain issue that Withings hasn't fixed for nearly 2 months, I figured I'd post this here. Since Withings doesn't seem intent on fixing it quickly and hasn't been providing any (correct) details, I did some investigation of what was going on myself a while ago. I couldn't live with my phone battery randomly dying when I was out.

Most of you won't care about the details, but you may want to know how to work around the battery drain until fixed. There are a lot of incorrect reports that this is fixed on the support forum, only for the users to find out it wasn't truly fixed a few days later when the issue gets triggered.

What causes the battery drain? Why doesn't it drain all the time?

Some buggy code was introduced in 6.1.0 that computes the width in pixels of text sent from your phone to your watch for a notification. This code did not exist prior to 6.1.0; it only computed the height and not the width. The bug will only be triggered when a notification is forwarded that contains a 0-width (invisible) character, which are frequently used. When these are encountered, the application will get stuck in an infinite loop and use all your battery.

Some examples I have found are:

  • A newline: the end of a line has 0 width... This is the dumbest one

  • Heart emoji "❤️": this is actually a heart symbol ❤ followed by a 0-width "Variation Selector" character to make it red.

  • Frowning Face emoji "☹️": Similar to heart, this is a ☹ symbol followed by a Variation Selector to make it yellow. There are several others like this as well.

  • Zero Width Space "‍​": these are used by some apps (including Messages) to separate emojis from words and allow wrapping

  • Hair Space "‍ ": just a very narrow space used for layout

  • Zero Width Joiner "‍": this is used in several emojis, including family 👨‍👩‍👧 and many skin tone variations such as 🏃🏿‍♀️. There's a large list here.

How do I prevent the battery from draining in the first place?

Do one of the following:

  1. Disable notifications on your watch by going to "My devices" in Health Mate, then clicking "Notifications", then unchecking "Enable Notifications". Afterwards, "Force stop" the Health Mate app and open it again to ensure that the infinite loop is not still running.

  2. Install Health Mate 6.0.1 from apkmirror as suggested by many people in the support forum. It does not have the bug from a bytecode inspection.

  3. Disable notification on your watch only for apps which may send one of the characters listed above. This may be hard to do though.

  4. Patch the bytecode to remove the buggy code and rebuild with apktool. That this beyond this post.

A new 6.x version gets released, how do I tell if it's truly fixed?

Copy/paste the following and send it to yourself in a text message: "❤️☹️​ 👨‍👩‍👧"

Then look for battery drain. Alternatively run adb shell top -H if you have that capability and look for the Withings app using all your CPU:

But didn't Withings say this was caused by Android 14 and that they need to work with Google to fix this?

Yep. But it's caused by trying to measure the width of 0-width characters, which isn't related to your OS version.

But they just released the 6.2.0 update after 6 weeks, surely it's fixed?

The issue still exists in 6.2.0. I also checked the bytecode in the APK and nothing was changed.

Withings said that uninstalling and reinstalling the app would help?

Don't waste your time. This will kill the process stuck in the infinite loop (same as a force stop), and it will disable forwarding notifications to your watch until you set it up again, but the issue will come right back as soon as you get one of those 0-width characters.

Technical Details

If you want to patch the bytecode yourself, or are just curious on what changed, then take a look at the DeviceImageFactory class. When the watch receives a character that it doesn't know how to display, it asks your phone for an image of that single character (in UTF-32 format) instead. There is code that tries to scale the character (most likely an emoji) as large as possible, so it keeps making the font size bigger until it exceeds the maximum size, and then uses the last font size that fit. The problem is that with 0-width characters, this limit will never be exceeded and the loop never ends. The code to check the width never existed before 6.1.0, so this wasn't an issue there.

Here's the (pseudo)code:

        int width = 0;
        do {
            width++;
            paint.setTextSize(width);
        } while (paint.measureText(str) < maxWidth);

You can just remove that loop in the bytecode if you want notifications to work on 6.1.0 or later if you know what you are doing.


r/withings • • Jul 27 '21

My Scanwatch was right about the "signs of afib" warning

106 Upvotes

My Scanwatch has been showing me warnings about signs of atrial fibrillation semi-regularly - about once every two months.

I didn't pay much attention because I always ran an ECG directly afterwards and it always came out ok. I though it was probably just a bad reading caused by bad positioning or something like that.

Then I read a post here a few months ago here where someone had the same happen to them and they decided to do a checkup anyway... Turned out they had a real medical condition. Reading that post prompted me to take it more seriously and go to the doctor.

Long story short, my doctor managed to identify a case of fibrillation and we're now looking at possible causes and treatments.

So to Withings: thank you guys for developing this. I don't think I would've identified it otherwise, and it would've gone unchecked for a while.

For everyone else: trust the watch, the sensors may not be perfect (nothing is) but it's always better to be safe than sorry.


r/withings • • 27d ago

Body How the new Withings sync paywall seriously harms current users

100 Upvotes

Withings has been trying to argue that, since current users continue to receive Apple Health integration and other syncing, they're no worse off with the new paywall. I want to explain why that's obviously wrong.

We bought Withings products that were advertised with a specific set of features. We now can't transfer those products to family members or friends without them incurring significant subscription costs, nor can we resell the products without buyers incurring significant costs. Withings has, unilaterally, radically reduced the market value of the products that we purchased and own. A used device that requires a $100/year subscription is obviously worth much less. Withings has literally taken money out of our pockets.

This isn't just the opinion of some random person on Reddit. The Federal Trade Commission has specifically flagged this problem area: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/blog/2016/07/what-happens-when-sun-sets-smart-product

I sincerely hope a consumer protection regulator takes a hard look at this.


r/withings • • Feb 28 '26

ScanWatch 2 Charging the Scanwatch 2 be like:

98 Upvotes

r/withings • • Feb 14 '24

Still best looking smartwatch imo

Post image
94 Upvotes

I know we've had such a buggy app (on Android) , but no other smartwatch I've had in the past looked this good. Still after 2 years wouldn't switch to another .

No point to this post, just something positive on this thread


r/withings • • Dec 09 '22

New app update awful

93 Upvotes

The new withings app is horrible. I’m a withings scale user, and I can’t see anything useful in my trends and I liked having weight, body fat and muscle all on the same screen, like seriously what gives?

When my weight was starting to go in another direction, the end of the line on the graph would start to go the other way so I could see it. Now the resolution on the graph line is way poorer and you can’t see any recent upticks or downswings… awful


r/withings • • Oct 11 '26

Body+ Withings is locking down their API for new accounts

89 Upvotes

Withings is locking down their API so that new accounts (signups after today) need a Withings+ subscription to export data. It looks like existing accounts will be grandfathered in (for now...)

Notice on the API page (& link):

Withings+ becomes required on the Start for Free API plan from October 12, 2026.Details

Withings accounts created after that date will need a membership to share health data with a free-plan app, including apps that are already live.

Accounts created before that date are unaffected, and Enterprise lifts the requirement for specific use cases.

https://developer.withings.com/developer-guide/v3/withings-solutions/withings-api-plans/


r/withings • • Oct 16 '26

Body Comp Returning my scale: How this policy played out in a two-person household

86 Upvotes

Throwaway so my main username isn’t tied to a consumer complaint. Happy to give Withings my case number by DM.

Adding a data point for anyone at Withings counting lost sales.

I ordered a BodyFit on September 14, and received it September 21. Apple Health export for me and my wife was one reason I chose Withings over a cheaper scale (and there are many!). I set up my account October 2 but my wife couldn’t create an account before October 13 because she was traveling and dealing with health issues.

Then Withings announced its policy in which one of us was grandfathered in and the other was not.

Support confirmed on October 16 that the Withings+ requirement is platform-wide and no exceptions are possible. I filed a withdrawal for a full refund immediately, with the policy change stated as the reason, and the case is now with senior support.

So u/TeamWithings, that’s one $279 sale reversed, in writing, because of this. I’d have kept the scale and recommended it. I’ll be buying a Garmin Index S2 instead, which syncs both of us to Apple Health for free.


r/withings • • 18d ago

software YourOwnWeigh - Sync your Withings scales anywhere you want (for free)

84 Upvotes

I started a project to try to add support for syncing our Withings scales wherever we want, over wifi and for free.

It is a bit rough around the edges currently, but my Withings scales are now syncing automatically into Apple Health over wifi, and without anything going to Withings.

Any feedback / help would be great!

Blog post: https://www.tomanthony.co.uk/blog/withings-yow-free-wifi-sync/

Github project: https://github.com/tomanthony/YourOwnWeigh/