Easily my favorite car I've owned, up until recently.
A series of symptoms led me to taking it in for a diagnostic, first to the dealer (in case the issue was covered by the emissions warranty still in effect) and then to a local mechanic shop with lots of experience with PHEVs and Volts (according to manager). Each shop came up with a different report of findings with very little overlap, but both quotes were quite expensive, as were the diagnostic fees. With a 12-year-old car that is no longer supported and how much I depend on it for work, I decided it was time to cut my losses and yesterday I bought a much newer PHEV.
I got a pretty low offer from Carvana ($1300) which would be reduced by 50% since I live 150+ miles from a dropoff location and would need them to pick it up, so I thought I'd check in here with the r/volt community to see what y'all think before I make the appointment.
The details:
129K miles, never had any major issues (no BECM or EGR issues). Lately there was a cyclical whining sound when the engine would decelerate while in L/regenerative braking mode, so I made an appointment to have it looked at when I got back from a work trip to LA (I'm 100+ miles North of there).
On the way home from the work trip, the "Check Engine" light came on, so I pulled over and checked my ODB scanner: "Cylinder 3 misfire". The last leg of my drive would have been up a mountain pass and I was out of electric-only miles, so I opted to have the car towed back home and drove on electric-only for short distances until I delivered it to the dealer. Their diagnostic report said 12V battery failed load test and they saw evidence of rodent damage in the air filter. Coupled with a damaged front turn indicator from a fender bender I'd had a while back, their quote for repair was $1700, so I opted to get a second opinion at the independent shop down the road.
The mechanics kept the car for nearly a week, trying to hunt down the sound I described to them, without being able to duplicate it; their deep-level diagnostic findings showed torque mount nearly split, motor mounts sagging, oil separator diaphragm leaking. Quoted $4K for repairs.
The discrepancy in the findings from the two diagnostics make me wish I was more mechanically inclined. The car never showed the "Check Engine" light again after that first time, and apart from the weird sound at deceleration, has not driven rough or had any noticeable issue.
I know I'd be crazy to imagine there's not some grain of truth to either of their diagnostic reports, and I'm ready to move on, but it hurts my feelings a little to think I would only clear $650 from the sale to Carvana. Before I surrender, I came here to share my sad little story.
Anyone have any opinion or feedback on this? Many thanks for a reply.
~Dejected in Central California