r/twilightimperium • u/AC2273 • 1h ago
General Discussion The Boat Float Cope
I have been gaming several decades now with lots of different games and people. Everything from competitive chess, to cooperative fantasy, to deck builders, etc.
For thousands of years, and recently in modern human development research and game theory research, people have pointed out that by its very DEFINITION, all gaming is cooperative.
Players voluntarily accept unnecessary obstacles/rules for the sake of the activity. This cooperation in the rules primarily subordinates the antagonistic/competitive element. Games are defined as the voluntary attempt to overcome unnecessary obstacles (typically with other people.)
Chess is a great example. Both players agree to follow the same rules to complete an activity. As long as the rules are followed, chess is cooperative. Many papers have been written on this topic academically for at least 60+ years. (Dr. Bernard Suits is one example of many)
But what happens if someone just picks up your queen and tosses it off the board? Now cooperation has ended. Now it is antagonistic. Now its not a game, it can legally be considered abuse, and possibly assault.
Same thing for when someone runs an aim bot in a first person shooter. If everyone follows the same rules in Modern Warfare, we are all cooperating. Once that ends with a trainer/bot/etc, its not a game but is abuse.
Recently, I've had many friends decide they don't want to play war/competitive games anymore. I'm actually fine with that, we have lots of options. Finding what interests the group any particular evening is a bit of the fun.
But sometimes they give the reason "I don't want to be mean" or "I don't want to antagonize other people". Then we end up talking about what Suits or Nguyen have said about this, and my normally rational friends (with advanced degrees in many cases) can't seem to see passed it. The whole concept that this is just "fun", has almost politically gone out for them.
One good friend said that kind of gaming doesn't promote "equality" cuz someone is taking from others. When i pointed out that we all agreed, without coercion, to participate in the activity, and thus its all consensual and nothing is truly stolen, then he had to relent the point. Rationality was apparently still on the table.
But I also pointed out that for years we walked away from the table with more, since we all enjoyed the game, win or lose.
It's strange to say the least to see these opinions.
Then we have the TI community. I've played in a few online games. Due to my chess background, I'll see a good advantageous move. Sometimes it's taking a homeworld, sometimes its just gaining 3-4 points in a turn, sometimes it's just threatening either of those. But in many cases following this kind of move, 1 or 2 (or several) people in the game just quit communicating or putting in their turns. The game is no where close to being over, but they are done. It's happened three times to me recently. 2 of those times, it wasn't even all that devastating. For example, I just gained +1 point over the group, and was threatening to maintain it.
People want to play TI like its solitaire. They want to gain points in their slice and never leave. They want to pretend the ships are never meant to be used, cuz its mean. It's not mean, it's a game. We are all cooperating to perform a task. Before the game started, we all agreed to this, without coercion. That's the point!
But it seems like recently, this "boat floating" has been pushed on the community. Almost seems political in nature. Quite frankly, its irrational and not a lot of fun. Why bother playing a large space game with dreadnaughts and war suns, and then decide they are "too mean to use"? Just go back to solitaire. It's more your kind of game.
