r/twilightimperium • • Oct 28 '22

Unpopular Opinion: Games of TI4 do not need to take 8+hrs and if they do, you are doing something wrong.

0 Upvotes

I come from this with a bit of experience, having played over 190 games mostly to 14 points within the past 4 years (100 games pre-pok, 90 games post-pok), both on TTS and IRL. Only on two occasions has a game of TI4 extended beyond the 9hr mark, the first was the first game of PoK I played on TTS, where there were 7 other people learning the expansion, and the second was in an IRL University Tournament, where there was just 1 point between the top 4 players (to 14 points).

I have taught over 20 completely new players and have ran games where it was five newish players (less than 3 games experience) with PoK and none of those games have lasted beyond 4-5hrs even when played to 14 points. I read a lot of posts and comments which regularly tell stories of games lasting beyond 16hrs. Myself and my other players regularly attempt to understand how those games can possibly last that long on a regular basis.

I would normally not care about these posts and the length of other people's games, but I genuinely believe that the constant messaging of "This game will last 12-16hrs easily" is fundamentally untrue and damages the reputation of the game we love and if your games are lasting that long, you are fundamentally doing something wrong. I'm not claiming the games isn't big, and I'm not claiming that there isn't a steep learning curve, but 12+hr games are ridiculous.

Multiple potential new people I have spoken to recently have expressed their enthusiasm to play the game, but have come to this subreddit and gained the impression that it will destroy their weekend and therefore have become intimidated by the sheer 'size' of the game.

EDIT: I've seen what people have been saying about this, and I do agree that I could have used less inflammatory language. But I still believe my points still stand and that some clearing up on my part is needed.

  1. Some people implied that I was forcing negotiations to be short/non existent and forcing people to rush their turns. I reached out to several of the players of my group to ask whether they ever felt rushed or that I 'played their turns'. They claimed that I didn't and I trust their opinion on that.

  2. there's been people suggesting that the group is not socialising during the games, that we are looking at TI as a purely mechanical system. This isn't true, the table is still filled with unrelated conversations and joking etc. But the main focus of everyone around the table is the game. We also do take an hour for lunch every game, where the game grinds to a halt.

I've been asked to put in the timesaving habits that the table has adopted to prevent longer game lengths, so I'll do that below.

  1. 99% of negotiations do not need to be long. If the agreement has not gone through within 2 minutes, it ain't going through. Arguing over and over for small trade good values or a promissory note, isn't going to change the result. I've noticed that within the groups I've played with, players which excessively do not accept that a trade deal isn't going through is punished by the table with others being unwilling to consider trades with them later on.

  2. It is up to you to keep an eye on your turn. You should be constantly aware of when it is your turn

  3. Plan your turns while other players are doing there own thing. This allows you to speed up your turns cause you are doing the thinking while other people are moving components.

  4. Bring a notebook, i understand there's a lot to remember. Write down the secondaries you want to do, the ships you want to build during warfare etc.

  5. If there is a rule disagreement and you can't find the answer within 5 minutes, roll a dice. 1-5 it's one way, 6-10 its the other. Post-game you can spend as long as you like to find specific wording.

  6. RTFM have an incredible video on the basics of the game, which I recommend all beginners watch.

  7. Don't be afraid to ask questions.

  8. If someone is doing something that isn't affecting the table, you can move on. A person selecting a tech or deciding whether they are going to remove an infantry for a command token due to a red exploration card, is very rarely going to affect your turn.

I hope these tips help people who would to decrease their playtime. Also a lot of people are claiming that I'm trolling/pulling numbers out of my arse. I am playing a game next Saturday, and I will keep detailed timings. Of course some people still might not believe me but that's all I can do to prove otherwise.


r/twilightimperium • • Oct 17 '26

Homebrew I may have slept with AI and did a thing...

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

Play-testing a single player TI4 game with actually capable bots. My love of a niche handheld (Miyoo+) and a niche boardgame knows no bounds.

Have not released it yet (still need to get 6 more factions in from PoK) but I'm really close.

Ideal state of this is to have Discordant Stars, Absols Tech and agendas, and Monuments. All optional, so you can play the type of TI4 game you want to play.


r/twilightimperium • • Apr 02 '25

Art I think we need to have a discussion about AI on this subreddit

28 Upvotes

PLEASE READ: I think I came off too mean in the post, and I'm very genuinely sorry. I'm not super educated in this and I don't want to attack anyone who uses AI, sorry if it came across as such. I don't think you're a bad person if you use it or anything like that. I just wanted to see community opinions on AI and offer my ideas.

I am personally against generative ai, since it steals from people who put in actual creative effort to make something. I've seen ai images for custom factions and memes (I would like to say I also think a photoshopped meme looks nicer and has more charm) and of course, as is often criticised, in discordant stars. What do you guys think about ai art, especially in terms of ti and this sub, should it be banned, limited, unrestricted or even encouraged?

I ask for you NOT TO DOWNVOTE POSTS YOU DISAGREE WITH so we can see a range of opinions.


r/twilightimperium • • Apr 14 '25

Exploration kind of sucks

2 Upvotes

This is super obviously a personal opinion but I'm wondering if anyone shares my opinion or could provide some enlightening perspective to show me what I'm missing also what would you do differently. For context I regularly play BOTH POK and base game and exclusively play in person. I just find it so painfully BORING.

It's aggressively RNG. Increases the fiddlyness to an already very fiddly game (that I as the host receive the brunt of). Regularly gets missed/forgotten still after double digit games with it to the point that I feel like the majority of my interactions with it can be summed up as someone forgetting to grab the card then asking for it later to an uninteresting effect. Really feels tacked on and can be a noob trap unless you're playing a faction that gets additional benefits from it.

The coolest interactions with are undeniably it's interactions with legendary planets but It's just not enough. Most of it feels very uninteresting to the rest of the table in a game were usually EVERYTHING is interesting to everyone.

I just can't help but feel that the game would be more fun without it (and necessary rebalancing). I will say that seeing exploration done so well in games like eclipse second edition aren't helping my opinion of it in TI but understand that wouldn't work in this game. Lastly, I accept that I am kind of just being a hater as I have no idea what I would have done differently nor suggestions for improvement.


r/twilightimperium • • Dec 15 '24

Am I cooked?

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/twilightimperium • • 11h ago

General Discussion Free unofficial TI4 rules desk: ask a rules question in plain English, get a direct answer

6 Upvotes

Hey folks, I built a free, unofficial Twilight Imperium 4 reference that I wish I'd had at the table: https://ti4rules.com

  • Ask a rules question in your own words ("do Saar's floating factories count against fleet supply?") and it takes you to a direct answer that cites the rule text.

  • Over 2,000 answered rules and interaction questions.

  • Designer rulings from Dane Beltrami are included, labeled separately with source links. If newer official text overrides one, that's noted.

  • Full Living Rules Reference v2.0, FAQ and errata, Codex changes, Thunder's Edge and Twilight's Fall.

  • A compendium of 1,278 components with current text.

  • A beginner's guide for a first game: how you win, how a round works, and what to do on your turn.

  • Works on your phone and offline.

It's a fan project, not affiliated with FFG or Asmodee, with no ads and nothing for sale. Every page has a Report an error link, and I'm happy to take "this answer is wrong" feedback in the comments too.


r/twilightimperium • • Aug 08 '23

Smart 9 Year Old Cousin Update

0 Upvotes

Title says it all…I’d like to know how they did!


r/twilightimperium • • Oct 16 '24

Prophecy of Kings 🐍 Do you Naalu'ans ever sell 💰 Agent use to other players?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/twilightimperium • • Jun 17 '26

Thunder's Edge Support for the Throne seems kinda dumb

8 Upvotes

I don't like this mechanic. Had it happen a few times where someone got gifted 2+ supports and then they insta catapulted into a win despite being massively behind.

Feels like a way for people to grief and just throw the win to someone else because they feel they don't have a chance to win and don't really care anymore.

Promotes boat floating because you're more likely to get gifted supports/ win the popularity contest if you don't ever do anything aggressive

We ban support swap but people still trade the support


r/twilightimperium • • Feb 10 '21

Black History Month

11 Upvotes

February is Black History Month in the United States. I just want to give a shout out to all the TI fans who are also POC. I’m always looking to make my table more inclusive and welcoming, and I welcome all suggestions for improvement.

Edit: Not sure why so many seem to think this is a joke post or trolling. I’m not interested in critiques, devil’s advocacy, or your white fragility. If you don’t have any suggestions, move the fuck along to the next post.


r/twilightimperium • • Mar 22 '26

The Agenda Phase is terribly designed

10 Upvotes

Hi all, relatively newer player here, 3 games under my belt with my group.

One thing we've all sort of come to the conclusion on is how badly the Agenda Phase is designed.

- it slows the pace of the game down to a point where it feels like the excitement of the game is literally sucked out of it.

- it feels insanely swingy and downright NPE at times. one player in our group has essentially had their game fall apart twice in two separate games, midway through, because of blind dumb luck (being on the wrong tile when an agenda is drawn)

- on the other hand, a lot of the time it's the exact opposite and feels the agendas are things that are so inconsequential that people just want to power through it to get back to the fun.

has anyone come up with a homebrew system or alternative system that helps this part of the game suck less? I absolutely adore TI4 so far but the Agenda Phase just feels bloated, swingy, tacked on and dull.


r/twilightimperium • • Aug 08 '25

Will there be breakthroughs for the Discordant Stars fan expansion

2 Upvotes

With the new Expansion is there any news if breakthroughs will be available for the Discordant Stars factions. I just got the professional print for Discordant Stars and now it looks like it will not be playable in a few months.


r/twilightimperium • • Jun 05 '25

Homebrew Radio Mecatol Scenario: Twilight Concord

Post image
1 Upvotes

A scenario inspired by the last week's episode of Radio Mecatol. What do you think? You can listen to the episode here: https://radiomecatol.podbean.com/e/rules-we-dont-likeer/


r/twilightimperium • • Aug 18 '26

General Discussion Last Bastion feel absolutely knee capped compared to the other TE factions

8 Upvotes

Seriously, how did these guys get through playtesting?
- 1/0 starting planet and 2 commodities WITH your special station
- Nebubla HS for ultra slow starts
- No component actions
- Clunky to awkward BT that often doesn't feel worth the investment
- Requires Space Dock 2 to not fall behind massively

On top of this, you are MASSIVELY dependent on a suitable slice and/or getting the exact Strategy card you need, and if any of that gets disrupted you are instantly behind.

and in return you get... Galvanise? And an extra token/card each round. Don't get me wrong, Galvanise is strong as an ability in a vacuum, but it requires you fight or you get no value from it.

I... I just don't understand what Dane was thinking here. DWS and CR get to break the game in their own special ways and Bastion gets hardmode difficulty setting.

As much as I love TE as an expansion, I think outside of Ral Nel Dane did a really bad job with the factions. DWS and CR are busted, F/O is awful to unplayable. Last Bastion is kneecapped. Ralnel feels like the only well thought out faction that's both fun to play and reasonably balanced.

It's a shame as well as I don't see a codex/errata coming that will do much to change these fairly massive issues.


r/twilightimperium • • Nov 27 '25

Any players in Jerusalem?

0 Upvotes

I bought the base game just over a year ago, got POK a few months later. Now have Thunders Edge, looking for more players. Someone who can host would also be nice, we've been playing in our university dorm but it's a bit cramped.

We normally play over the course of a few sessions, so the time commitment is a bit more spread out. So far we've been playing games with fewer players, so 14 points has been our go to, and it's gone quite well. I will say that while we do have diplomacy at the table, we don't shirk away from battles.

Regarding the ruleset, we generally play RAW+LRR, including for map setup. The only exception is when picking factions. The way we do it is that everyone picks a faction before building the map, and then after the map is built, starting with the speaker, everyone has the opportunity to switch factions with any unchosen ones. This continues until a full round has passed with no one switching factions. This enables players to choose a faction they want to play atthe start, but also to switch if they feel like the map is more conducive to them playing a different one. It also prevents a case where one player hard counters another (this can also be used to stop a player from taking an annoying faction, by choosing one of their hard counters).


r/twilightimperium • • Jan 11 '22

TTS Situation

18 Upvotes

CW: Homophobia, Transphobia

So apologies if there was discussion of this elsewhere, but I feel this is pretty important needs to be discussed.

For those not in the know, there were some recent developments this past weekend with respect to discrimination on tts, and the response from the devs has, to put it lightly, not inspired confidence. Full context can be found here.

Since tts is a pretty indispensable tool for this community at the moment, and meaningful change from the devs seems unlikely, I am sure I am not alone in being uncomfortable continuing to support this company.

With that said, moving to another service is no doubt a huge undertaking for the mod makers, and will no doubt take time to accomplish. I guess what I’m asking is if there are plans with respect to moving to a new platform, and what the nature of that move might look like.

Thanks, and take care everyone.

edit: grammar


r/twilightimperium • • Aug 01 '24

How do I explain to a New Player (IRL group) that TI isn't Space 🚀 Risk 🎲 ??

0 Upvotes

We have just taken in a new player into our Galactic Council. Friendly person, good company and all, but they are a very aggressive player and they keep making militaristic analogies when talking about TI... 🤷

They make 'fleet formations' with their unbuilt plastic, and they always move their ships point-forward right up to the edge of the system hex tile towards their neighbours (they call them enemies).

How do I tell them to stop yelling 'Get some!' when they fire their PDS (with no obvious strategic gain) and to stop quoting Genghis Khan all the time?


r/twilightimperium • • Oct 05 '26

Homebrew Custom TI faction week (5/7): The GALACTIC DEFENSE COUNCIL

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

We're back after a (longer than I intended) hiatus! Got sick, dealt with college starting, so it's not really custom faction week anymore, but here we are.

Day 5 gives us a faction designed around what I consider to be a very cool but insanely underused mechanic from Thunder's Edge - neutral units. My goal was to make a faction that can both increase the prescence and quantity of them on the board, and be able to use them for their advantage. They are meant to fit in with real TI's lore; if you've read the back of the faction sheet and are wondering what the heck the Aquarius Corporation is, it's a custom faction created by one of my friends. I'll try to convince him to post them here at some point.

As before, most of the templates were created by JaHeit (link is https://www.reddit.com/r/twilightimperium/comments/kl4v4b/new_ti4_pok_custom_faction_templates_link_in/ here) and slightly modified by me.

Obviously, please don't re-upload or claim ownership of my designs.

Link to the original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/twilightimperium/comments/1wd2ocy/custom_ti_faction_week_day_17_the_kerbal_space/


r/twilightimperium • • Jul 31 '22

Meme Mfw I lost a 10pt as Sol when every objective was control

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/twilightimperium • • Mar 04 '21

10 point games were not great in the base game, they are even worse with the expansion and we should all switch to 12-14 pointers from now on

5 Upvotes

r/twilightimperium • • May 21 '26

Thunder's Edge Does anyone else think Agenda phase is lame and kinda wished it wasn't part of the game?

0 Upvotes

I know Agenda Phase is one of the reasons this isn't just space risk but still, I never feel good during the phase even if I'm winning something. Just feels tedious trying to navigate the house of cards with the votes and knowing when to go all in with my own votes versus others. Also, some of the options are pretty brutal like the table can just vote to blow up your fleet practically.

It's either fairly inconsequential to the point where the time spent voting feels kinda low value like it didn't really matter so just do whatever. Or it's like, mega nuke a player out of the blue. This disrupts entire engines and can very much cripple you. You can spend multiple rounds carefully getting your tokens up to 5/5/5 for a big play and get wiped down to 3/3/3. The fact this also serves as a fleet nuke is also lame. For me it feels like already too much politics just managing aggro on the galaxy map like you can have 2 players gang you and deal with you that way. Even if you have good influence economy it barely matters, very easy for a light wind to blow you out of whatever outcome. I really don't like this phase

Aside from all that, IRL this point is less true but Online the time it takes is dumb like I have to basically wait through 1-2 hour wait per player to do their votes and a lot of the time its just abstaining or something. A lot of the time nobody even talks like I'm trying to chat with the other players about it and nobody interacting at all so just waiting around for something random to happen. So basically gotta mess around for a day for what could have been a full cycle of tactical actions and strategy cards for something that doesn't give any enjoyment.

Do you like the Agenda phase? Or kinda feel the same way as me?


r/twilightimperium • • Jun 19 '25

Homebrew Xxcha Hero Homebrew

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I always find it quite annoying that Xxcha has the only passive hero that doesn't get purged, so I wanted to try something new.

Another idea would be that the Xxcha player picks 5 Agendas from the deck at game start insted of drawing two resolving politics, but that requires very experienced players with deep knowledge about the agendas to be useful and not much of an overhead at game start.


r/twilightimperium • • Oct 06 '26

TI: 4th Edition What to get: PoK or TE?

1 Upvotes

I have played 2 base games, and I wanted to get an expansion, but I'm torn.

I like the races in PoK, but I don't like the leaders, as they cause a mess on the board. I adore the mechs though. On the other hand, TE feels like half an expansion, with the other half being Twilight's Fall. I'd get some of my localised Codex cards, and also the Breakthroughs and Rift.


r/twilightimperium • • Jan 15 '26

Fix Muaat

0 Upvotes

Muaat is currently a bad faction, but I feel like fixing them with simply saying that their flagship is a 3rd warsun would be just so easy. What do you think about this, why is this not the case? Would this break any game mechanics? Would they be too op? I heard this idea in an old SCPT episode and cannot get it out of my head.