r/twilightimperium • u/conceredti4 • Oct 28 '22
Unpopular Opinion: Games of TI4 do not need to take 8+hrs and if they do, you are doing something wrong.
I come from this with a bit of experience, having played over 190 games mostly to 14 points within the past 4 years (100 games pre-pok, 90 games post-pok), both on TTS and IRL. Only on two occasions has a game of TI4 extended beyond the 9hr mark, the first was the first game of PoK I played on TTS, where there were 7 other people learning the expansion, and the second was in an IRL University Tournament, where there was just 1 point between the top 4 players (to 14 points).
I have taught over 20 completely new players and have ran games where it was five newish players (less than 3 games experience) with PoK and none of those games have lasted beyond 4-5hrs even when played to 14 points. I read a lot of posts and comments which regularly tell stories of games lasting beyond 16hrs. Myself and my other players regularly attempt to understand how those games can possibly last that long on a regular basis.
I would normally not care about these posts and the length of other people's games, but I genuinely believe that the constant messaging of "This game will last 12-16hrs easily" is fundamentally untrue and damages the reputation of the game we love and if your games are lasting that long, you are fundamentally doing something wrong. I'm not claiming the games isn't big, and I'm not claiming that there isn't a steep learning curve, but 12+hr games are ridiculous.
Multiple potential new people I have spoken to recently have expressed their enthusiasm to play the game, but have come to this subreddit and gained the impression that it will destroy their weekend and therefore have become intimidated by the sheer 'size' of the game.
EDIT: I've seen what people have been saying about this, and I do agree that I could have used less inflammatory language. But I still believe my points still stand and that some clearing up on my part is needed.
Some people implied that I was forcing negotiations to be short/non existent and forcing people to rush their turns. I reached out to several of the players of my group to ask whether they ever felt rushed or that I 'played their turns'. They claimed that I didn't and I trust their opinion on that.
there's been people suggesting that the group is not socialising during the games, that we are looking at TI as a purely mechanical system. This isn't true, the table is still filled with unrelated conversations and joking etc. But the main focus of everyone around the table is the game. We also do take an hour for lunch every game, where the game grinds to a halt.
I've been asked to put in the timesaving habits that the table has adopted to prevent longer game lengths, so I'll do that below.
99% of negotiations do not need to be long. If the agreement has not gone through within 2 minutes, it ain't going through. Arguing over and over for small trade good values or a promissory note, isn't going to change the result. I've noticed that within the groups I've played with, players which excessively do not accept that a trade deal isn't going through is punished by the table with others being unwilling to consider trades with them later on.
It is up to you to keep an eye on your turn. You should be constantly aware of when it is your turn
Plan your turns while other players are doing there own thing. This allows you to speed up your turns cause you are doing the thinking while other people are moving components.
Bring a notebook, i understand there's a lot to remember. Write down the secondaries you want to do, the ships you want to build during warfare etc.
If there is a rule disagreement and you can't find the answer within 5 minutes, roll a dice. 1-5 it's one way, 6-10 its the other. Post-game you can spend as long as you like to find specific wording.
RTFM have an incredible video on the basics of the game, which I recommend all beginners watch.
Don't be afraid to ask questions.
If someone is doing something that isn't affecting the table, you can move on. A person selecting a tech or deciding whether they are going to remove an infantry for a command token due to a red exploration card, is very rarely going to affect your turn.
I hope these tips help people who would to decrease their playtime. Also a lot of people are claiming that I'm trolling/pulling numbers out of my arse. I am playing a game next Saturday, and I will keep detailed timings. Of course some people still might not believe me but that's all I can do to prove otherwise.