r/TrueAnime • • Nov 02 '25

I hate how modern anime viewers have such a skewed view of the medium

1.2k Upvotes

Whenever I see anie get talked about in parts of social media that aren't for anime exclusively, it feels like a lot of modern anime viewers tend to see the medium from three categories:

NO-GO ZONE: Isekai (long names), Shoujo, Mahou Shoujo, and Romance (too girly), Slice of Life and CGDCT (boring), ecchi and anything with young girl characters (for gooners)

RESPECTABLE ANIME: Battle shonen, non-shonen that have a lot of action, shows that would be considered "no-go" but are super popular ex: Bocchi the Rock

CLASSICS: The same like 10 shows made before like 2005.

Anything that doesn't fit in these three categories just doesn't exist.

I have no problem if you have a preference for certain types of anime but this absolutely skewed view of the medium is so prevalent it limits the type of discussion that can be had. Granted that's probably the case for other types of mediums.


r/TrueAnime • • Jan 26 '16

What FLCL Means (for me)

410 Upvotes

FLCL (fooly cooly or furi kuri) made its U.S. debut on Adult Swim in 2003.

I have read a lot of theories on FLCL but have never been really satisfied by them. There is the popular "it's a metaphor for imperialism" analysis that gets bandied about on message boards, which makes for a grade-A college paper but doesn't resonate with me at all. When people say that "it's a metaphor for puberty," I think to myself "sure, but is that it?" Not only is it a shallow observation, it suggests that this series conforms to the conventional coming of age tale, when really it deconstructs and then shatters it. I find FLCL so singular and compelling and realized that, for me, it can't really be understood using literary analysis but by just bringing your own life experience to it. So here is what FLCL says to me. And remember, it's just my opinion.

Note: There is a fantastic interpretation of FLCL posted on this thread, "The Oedipus Complex and FLCL," that is very worth reading.

Some quick context: I first saw FLCL on Adult Swim in the summer of 2003. I was twelve, my family had just moved back to my hometown where I had always felt out of place. I was a new kid again, my older siblings had left for college and I was just generally miserable. So FLCL struck me like a thunderbolt - I thought it was this radical, shocking, miraculous thing. It was provocative, exuberant and deeply empathetic. Like most people, I couldn't understand a lick of it - but I felt like it was the only thing in the world that understood me at that particular time and place in my life.

It wasn't until last month that I revisited FLCL as a 24-year-old - an entire lifetime since I first connected with it. It has been a revelatory reunion. What was once a fond memory has become a priceless artifact in my emotional understanding - I am so grateful that this story exists. It took all of my life experience in between for me to really understand it. It's sort of like reflecting on a pivotal event in your life and understanding it in a way you never could have before.

I know that many people find FLCL inscrutable, but I think in a lot of ways it wears its heart on its sleeve. Look past the psychedelic imagery and gonzo digressions; just watch how these characters interact with each other. I think too many people get hung up on the sexual allegories. Of course sexuality is a crucial component of puberty and the show is right to emphasize it, but it's not really what Naota's journey is about. FLCL has a lot on its mind but its message is obscured by the show's chaotic rhythm and the haziness of each characters' motivation. Which is pretty much the same case as life.

I envy anyone who sees FLCL for the first time, because there are few experiences as luxuriously discombobulating. Some people despise it: I've seen friends visibly develop a headache during the first episode alone and then politely ask we watch something else. You are either on board or you violently want to get off the ride, and that's part of the cult appeal of the show. Scour the Youtube comments and you'll see a consensus that FLCL is a psychedelic without internal logic. I find this both thrilling and sad: this series is admittedly a mind trip on a first watch but it pains me to see it so widely misunderstood.

FLCL does have internal logic and every moment serves a narrative purpose. The stylistic whiplash it gives viewers is part of its artistic integrity; I can't think of another work of art that better articulates the confusion and discomfort a person feels during puberty. Everything is anchored by Naota's blossoming perspective; we are confused by everything we see because we see it through the eyes of a 12-year-old who is being confronted by sexuality and the escalating complications of life for the first time. Fittingly, the only way to understand FLCL is with re-watches. Every time you sift through this zany chain of events and interactions, they increasingly gain clarity. This perfectly simulates life itself. We can never understand what's happening to us during puberty until we reflect upon it later in life, when we have gained more experience and emotional understanding.

I feel like FLCL isn't about a boy becoming a man but instead about how we are only hurting ourselves when we actively pursue "adulthood," or our idealized self. It's kind of the anti-coming of age story, because it dares to question what adulthood even means.

I'm going to use a lot of key scenes from "FLClimax" to illustrate my points, so here's a link to that episode in case you want to check out the moments I'm referencing to see for yourself: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pm7o4q0k0GY

It is during its final episode that FLCL finally exposes its big beating heart, and it casts a new light on everything that had unfolded beforehand.

Something that always mystified me is how Haruko is stunned when Naota confesses his love for her. It's the first time she is truly flustered. But why is she so surprised? She's spent the entire series trying to worm her way into Naota's heart. Except that I don't think Haruko actually knows what love is, and that's her fatal flaw that keeps her from growing as a person (and why she will forever remain 19). She is a teenaged Peter Pan, refusing to grow up and recruiting Lost Boys instead of Wendys. Is she in love with Atomsk or does she want to eat him? It's both - she idolizes him and wants to become him, and that's her idea of love: becoming someone who is her own idealized self. I realize now that her shock is not so much because Naota's affection is a surprise, but because this is the first time she's ever been confronted by what love actually looks like.

Throughout FLCL, Haruko treats intimate feelings like they're a joke ("Were you just about to confess your great love for me? How embarrassing!"). She expertly uses sexuality and affection as tools to manipulate. The one moment when she hints at having the capacity for empathy is when she allows Naota to hold her tightly as he cries, but even then she remains an enigma. Her far-off stare while Naota sobs into her chest (11:42) is one loaded poker face. What's going on behind those eyes? Is she mournful, regretful or just bored? You can never really tell with her.

[Side note: Naota breaking down in Haruko's arms is one of my favorite scenes in FLCL because it casts a deeply bittersweet light on their relationship. Who is Haruko to Naota? On one level, living without her has made him realize how much she has become his world - he is in love with her. But when he asks her why she left and abandoned him, his question is also directed at his brother Tasuku. On another level, the way he clings to her is an acknowledgement that Naota is a boy without a mother. We realize now why Naota has been so hesitant to open himself up - he feels abandoned by those he loves. Does Haruko recognize this? As she comforts him, she's acting as his lover, his sibling, his parent. And yet she can never really allow herself to be any of those things for Noata. Kinda breaks my heart.]

For me, her posture and expression in that moment looks like someone who recognizes that they're getting in too deep, that they're teetering on the edge of feeling personal responsibility to another person. Naota began as a means to an end for her but when he cries in her arms she is reminded that this isn't a game anymore. But her bracelet keeps clinking away - indicating that Atomsk is near - that reminder that she's close to getting what she wants, to becoming that person she sees herself as. She's resigned to her destiny and just tunes this moment of honest connection out. She simply cannot allow herself to feel anything - because once that door is opened, she'd be letting in feelings like doubt, insecurity, regret. She would no longer have control over her identity. Haruko views emotions like they're pathogens and she has steeled her immune system accordingly.

Someone becomes that numb to intimacy because it scares them. Haruko embraces the perks of adult behavior (developed sense of humor, sexuality, freedom) but she's a coward when it comes to actual intimacy. She's incredibly brave in other ways: when piratized Naota is barreling down on her, she's defiantly ready to be crushed. But when Naota confronts her with his vulnerable, sincere feelings? For the first time, she's speechless. Terrified. In that moment, she's a confused kid just like the rest of us. Then she must watch Atomsk, that rock god whose the coolest of the cool, fly away. She's not worthy - but then again, no one can actually become Atomsk. He's an ideal, that aura we perceive in those we look up to. But no one has it all figured out - there is no stage in life where you are free from insecurity and doubt. If Haruko actually caught Atomsk, she would ultimately become very disappointed.

The characters keep asking what Fooly Cooly means. Something kinky? Is it just gibberish? I think, in the end, the show tips its hat to what it's all about: love, baby. Sex is an important and thrilling discovery as you're growing up, but if that's all you ever care about then you'll become Naota's Dad, who is gonna die alone. Obsessing about sex is ignoring the bigger picture. It's not physical sexuality that really paralyzes us during puberty - what's really scary and frustrating are the anxieties and insecurities that come with sexual intimacy. Kids are given this narrative that love will be this wonderful feeling that can only brighten your life, but it's much more complicated than that. In reality, love is traumatic and can tear you apart if it goes awry.

FLCL captures the body horror and chaos of discovering sexuality, but if FLCL was only about sex, it would have ended when Naota swung the bat and hit a home run. This show understands that the most terrifying thing about sexuality is emotional intimacy. Because that means taking off your "mask" and being truly naked. Many people are scared to show their true selves - they become convinced that there is something wrong with them and that to be loved they must become this other person - their idealized self. Because of this, many folks don't make it through puberty intact - they've lost a crucial piece of who they are during the process and spend the rest of their lives trying to recapture it. I am certain that N.O. waves are triggered whenever a person feels an overwhelming emotion that cracks the false identity they've made for themselves, when they hit this wall that exposes their lie, that contradicts the role that they are trying to play.

Every principle character in FLCL falls prey to this. Kamon is a widower (or divorcee) who never really made it as a journalist, so he yearns to be seen as distinguished and desirable (like Lupin III, perhaps?). He would have sprouted a robot from his head when he caught Naota and Haruko kissing if he had the gift. Mamimi has been bullied and abandoned so she feels too helpless to take command of her own life. Her protector (savior) was Tasuku, so she desperately tries to continue her role as his girlfriend even after he has moved on. Ninamori is devastated that her family may be broken up, so she adopts the persona of a dispassionate independent in order to cope. Her infatuation with the story of "Puss in Boots" ('his lie eventually becomes the truth') is maybe the most important clue to my understanding of FLCL. These characters cannot confront their sadness and insecurity, so they commit to these false identities in the hopes that they will become happy.

The only exception is Canti, who is completely at ease with himself. He not only accepts the world but embraces it, freeing him up to be kind and giving to those around him. How appropriate that the only character in FLCL who is free of insecurity or selfishness... is a robot.

Tasuku didn't need to move to America for their to be a gulf between him and Naota - he is years older and at a different stage in life. People with older siblings know this all too well - there comes a point where you feel forcibly separated from this person you love, where they have gone to a place you can't follow. The physical distance between these two brothers only makes the emotional gap between them literal. So Naota adopts his "mask" of being a rational adult in the hopes that if he can commit to this role, then he can bridge the divide between him and Tasuku and feel connected to his brother again. He walls off his emotions and aspires to be mature even when it makes him miserable. All of the times Naota refers to his town and how much he hates it ("Nothing amazing happens here"), he's talking about his own headspace. His town isn't the problem - Masabe seems like a perfectly fine place to grow up - what makes him feel alienated and hopeless are the walls and borders he's built inside of his own head. The smoke that pours out from Medical Mechanica - that's Naota's anxiety, clouding his mind and numbing his true feelings.

It all comes to a head for Naota in the penultimate episode, "Brittle Bullet." After getting some sort of handle on his blossoming sexuality (he swung the bat!), he thought that he had crossed some figurative finish line, believing that he had become his idealized self - his brother. His newfound ego keeps building as his friends geek out over his exploits ("You're the pilot!") and it reaches a boil when Mamimi indicates that she's jealous of Haruko (doesn't every young adult fantasize that they're the focal point of a love triangle?).

But Naota's ego starts to crumble when Mamimi makes it clear that what they have isn't romance and that he's overstepped the arrangement. His ego then thrashes out in self-defense when, in her moment of panic, Mamimi calls out for Tasuku, not Naota. He can never become his brother; just because you swing the bat doesn't mean you get the girl. So he bristles with rage and hits his lowest point. Sure, it's a good thing that he takes back his name ("don't ever call me Takkun again!"), but his whole outburst is kinda unfair to Mamimi. He never loved her - the reason why he's so enraged is because his ego has been bruised.

He's already in love with Haruko but cannot reconcile what he's feeling, largely because she defies his expectations. He has bought into the outdated conventional wisdom of what becoming a man is: being strong and protective of a vulnerable woman who validates your masculinity with her gratitude. So instead of accepting that he is madly in love with this domineering woman who doesn't need saving, he instead hinges his self-esteem on Mamimi's approval because she is both helpless and is a connection to his brother. Naota believes that if he can somehow fill the void Tasuku left in Mamimi's life, then he will have escaped from his brother's shadow. When she doesn't return his affection, this false identity he's made for himself cracks. He had been treating romance like a power play and gets mad when he loses. He berates Mamimi for not recognizing his worth (look at how big my robots are, woman!), but really he's just trying to convince himself that he is what she needs. He then goes into battle fighting for the sake of his own ego, so of course he loses. Adding insult to injury, it's revealed that he was the bullet, not the pilot. He never really had control. This idealized identity he had constructed for himself is completely broken down.

In "FLClimax," Naota learns what it truly means to swing the bat - coming to terms with the blistering intensity of loving another person regardless of whether or not they love you back. By doing this, he accepts his true self.

Admitting that you love someone is really hard to do because it's kinda stupid. And childish. Being in love defies all of your rationality and self-interest. It's making yourself totally vulnerable and ceding control - and Haruko looks down on vulnerability. While she's amused by a child's insecurity, she's repulsed when an "adult" like Amarao shows weakness. That's why she can't allow herself to love.

The climactic kiss isn't a physical consummation. Naota and Haruko had locked lips several times throughout FLCL, but it was always her kissing him. All of those times, the kiss was just a provocation - it meant nothing. In the end, Naota chooses to kiss her, and it actually means something this time. Furthermore, it means everything. It's not really the world that's at stake when Haruko and Naota clash - what's going on is a battle between the mind and the heart. Haruko is powered by self-interest and narcissism - what she wants is to vindicate her own ego by becoming the most powerful being in the universe, becoming her idealized self. Naota is powered by his love for her - he is literally bathed in the energy of a burning heart. Naota won't let her get what she wants - it would hurt too many people - but he basically surrenders to her. Instead of cutting her down, he admits defeat because he can't stand to hurt her. But by throwing in the towel, Naota has won.

One of the most wonderful things about FLCL is how every character is going through the same growing pains and confusion that Naota is, whether they know it or not. Every character is in love with someone who doesn't love them back, they're all lying to themselves in one way or another and they all aspire to be someone they're not.

I think Haruko's sort of "superpower" is that she has realized the absurdity of everyone trying to play their "adult" role. She recognizes how everyone is putting on a "mask" and thinks that they're suckers for even trying. This is why she is so adept at shifting identities - space cop, nurse, housekeeper, athletic superstar, tormentor, lover, Daicon V... she understands that these are just roles and that anyone can play the part. Her gonzo "Master the Guitar in One Millisecond Class" bit? On some level, I feel like that's her revealing her process to Naota - if you just pick up the guitar and pretend you're a rockstar, then people will believe you are one - it's that easy, dude. It's why she's so amused when Ninamori reveals her "Puss in Boots" scheme in episode 3; it's why she is able to identify what people want and manipulate them so easily. It's why Naota is endearing to her - he clings to his mask so tightly even as she picks away it. And it's why she takes such pleasure in twisting the knife in Amarao's self-esteem - as far as she's concerned, the guy only has himself to blame for his misery.

I think what Haruko "wants" is to escape from being like the rest of these suckers and adopt the ultimate mask - Atomsk - so that she can have the ultimate control over her identity and escape from all insecurity and self-doubt. Her bracelet clinking away whenever Atomsk is near - that's her anxiety. She seems in complete control because she always has her eye on the ultimate prize. Whenever that is threatened, her composure is immediately shattered and she reveals herself to be an angry, petulant child. That's why she's shaking with rage when Naota emerges with Atomsk's power - he has stolen her mask and reminded her that she will never have full control over her life and that, most insulting of all, she is going to remain on the same boat as everyone else.

When the tables are turned and Haruko is clearly outmatched by piratized Naota, Agent Amarao urges him to "teach her a lesson." Amarao keeps fretting about the end of the world but deep down his gravest concern is that Haruko may somehow get what she wants. He bemoans that Medical Mechanica is going to flatten and smooth out humanity's brains - which seems to mean they intend to rob everyone of their uniqueness and capacity to feel - but this is a guy who wears eyebrows to protect himself from his own emotions. Amarao has clothed himself in responsibility, taking on the safety of the world so that he never has to confront himself. He clings to his mask just like everyone else. What he really cares about is seeing Haruko punished for breaking his heart. He is among the many who emerge from puberty jaded and hateful of the opposite sex. That's not maturity - that's letting anger and spite dictate your life. Amarao could not understand why Naota would choose Haruko over the world - but that's because he has become a corrupted version of himself - only willing to love if he will be loved in return. That's thinking purely with your mind - all the wrinkles removed. He's become what Medical Mechanica wants everyone else to be: stripped of their uniqueness, conforming to adulthood without arriving to it organically.

After being betrayed by Haruko and gaining the most coveted power in the universe, Naota could have taken revenge. That's what Agent Amarao would have done. Instead, Naota discards that power and let's Haruko know that despite all that she's done and how much she has hurt him, that he loves her. To Haruko, Atomsk's almighty energy is the only thing that truly matters. Naota throws that power away like it's meaningless and makes her realize that, to him, she is all that truly matters. Even if she doesn't love him back. By doing this, he defeats what Haruko represents. Naota demonstrates that we are not measured by how much power we wield or control we have over our lives, but by how we affect those around us. The sexually charged nature of their relationship was a red herring the whole time: it was not Haruko's flirtatious advances that bewitched Naota, it was how she invited him to share a connection ("You're the one I saw first") and how her sheer uniqueness shattered the chains he had placed on himself. Haruko is at her most dazzling to Naota when she idly observes that eating a bowl of awful ramen can be fun - that's what he loves about her. She doesn't need to become Atomsk to be a shooting star, and by denying her what she wants while simultaneously affirming how special she is to him, Naota lets her know this. I think he deeply affects her with that gesture. At the very least, he rattles her worldview irrevocably.

FLCL began with Haruko giving Naota a kiss of life (the CPR) - he is never the same afterwards, even if it's not immediately apparent. Appropriately, FLCL ends with Naota returning the favor.

[Side Note: The kiss shared between Naota and Haruko makes my heart swell to the point of bursting. Their relationship is not conventionally romantic nor is it even appropriate because, let's face it, the kid's 12 and she should be on a neighborhood watchlist for the shit she's pulled. However, it's strikingly beautiful, with the pillows' "I Think I Can" sweetly approving of this union while Atomsk's energy wreathes above them in a halo. Naota's love for Haruko is unrequited; he knows that it will not be returned. Haruko is guided by her own ego; she has never been concerned with her responsibility to others. She invests in the people around her based on how she can profit from them; she's incapable of loving another person. When Naota lets her know that she is loved, he is defying all of her cynicism and selfishness and in that one perfect moment gives her a dose of redemption. She has helped him in so many ways but for her own dark, selfish purposes. But Naota chooses to be grateful for the journey.]

Haruko is a bad person, but when Naota kisses her, she is defined as a person who is loved, not as a monster. And let's be clear: becoming Atomsk (the idealized adult) was what Naota hungered for at the beginning of the show. Shedding that power is a sacrifice for him; it's rejecting what he had initially wanted. He lets go of the identity that all of the principle characters in FLCL desire, and it is a selfless act made triumphant because he realized how empty that status was if it meant taking Haruko out. Naota finally lets go of how he had presumed the world should be, who Haruko should be and, most importantly, who he should be. Instead, he honors what's really brewing inside of him. He grasps the enormity of the love he feels like he just discovered fire, because the only way to genuinely love is to arrive to that feeling like you're the first person to ever discover it - not because your feelings resemble what society tells you love is. His honesty trumps all of the insanity that's unfolding around him: the world-defining machinations of Medical Mechanica and the coveted power of Atomsk look so small in comparison to a genuinely meaningful kiss. The world is so chaotic and oppressive, it can make us forget that we are not defined by our identities but by the connections we share with each other. FLCL is about love, baby.

Haruko leaving Naota behind was the first truly altruistic thing she does in the entire show. She finally recognizes her responsibility to Naota as a person and, despite her soft spot for him, decides that it's time to let him off this ride she has taken him on. She also lets him know, in her own snide way, that it's okay to still be a kid and that he doesn't have to have everything figured out. The look on Naota's face, to me, shows that he had already come to this conclusion. He just wishes Haruko could find it for herself.

Haruko will continue after Atomsk but can never catch him, forever stuck in that selfish phase of setting aside genuine personal growth in pursuit of some fabled identity she feels entitled to. She thinks that there is a finish line to becoming who you want to be but that's just not true - no one has it figured out and the only way to grow is through experience. Atomsk is an unattainable goal - we grow through valuing the people in our lives, not using them as pawns to help us bolster our own self-worth. Haruko can't comprehend this and that's her tragedy. However, she takes Naota's guitar with her and leaves him her own as a memento. It's a sign of subtle growth for her - she would never have done something so sentimental beforehand. It's a gesture that he meant something to her and that she wants to leave a piece of herself with him, and that they will now always be carrying their experiences together. Her sociopathic drive has been cracked somewhat, and I suspect that it will only continue to chip away from there. The day she gives up on chasing Atomsk would be the day she finally becomes a person.

Naota learns a lesson that is very difficult to take in. Yes, you're going to get your heart broken. Some people are going to be fickle with your emotions and betray your trust. Everyone has their own motives and desires and you can never have complete control over your life. His odyssey isn't actually that unique - to any child, the politics of love are so complicated that they might as well be a giant alien conspiracy spanning the universe.

The question of why you would want to engage in life when it's just going to knock you down is a fair one. But you can't let your bitterness drive you, or else you run the risk of becoming Amarao, who has a self-esteem and identity built upon a foundation of sand. You can't let the fear of rejection or betrayal or abandonment keep you from growing or you will wallow like Mamimi, who had retreated from life waiting for someone else to fix it for her. It wasn't until she witnessed Naota's own revelation that she realized what had always been inside of her: creativity. Growing up is accepting that life will always be mysterious and messy but that you must always be open to the world around and within you.

Because we're all really just kids dealing with increasingly complex responsibilities and emotions - all you can do is have the courage to grapple with those things while maintaining your core decency. Never be afraid to swing the bat - but accept your strikeouts with grace and gratitude. I can't put it better than Charles Grodin does in this clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJlj3auSlKA

So what does "FLCL" mean? To me, it means both childhood and adulthood running parallel to each other. You need both in order to be a complete person. You never stop being who you are as a kid - there is never this line that you cross to become your idealized adult self. Suppressing the kid in you is denying your uniqueness, snuffing out your capacity to hope and love. So many people disown their true feelings and their true selves in order to become their adult self in the hopes that once they reach that finish line, they will be alright. Our anxieties and insecurities are created by who we think we are supposed to be. But playing these roles is what makes all of these characters profoundly unhappy - it is when they stop trying to deny their true selves that they find peace.

While Naota's relationships with Mamimi and Haruko were ultimately doomed, they gave him the wisdom to finally move forward with someone who truly deserves his affection. Because the person who Naota is actually compatible with is Ninamori. One of the most wonderful, unspoken ironies in FLCL is that because Naota is so preoccupied trying to decipher his feelings for Haruko and Mamimi, he is blind to the girl who is truly smitten with him. In a way, their stories are running parallel to each other - Ninamori is going through the same confusion and turbulence (she's the only other character who has a death-machine sprout from their head) but finally learns to work through it in a healthy way (13:15 in "FLClimax"). She calls him out when he's wrong but still views him with a deep curiosity. She sees him clearly and is frustrated by his attempts to be someone he is not and that's why she's always the one to dampen his ego before it gets the better of him (sometimes literally, like when she sprays him with her water pistol).

[Side Note: Ninamori reveals that she resolved her crisis of angst by admitting to her parents that she was sad ("And then I cried and stuff to my mother and father"). If that sounds familiar, it's because that is literally the plot of "Inside Out." Yep; one of the most original movies of 2015 happened to Ninamori offscreen. With one blink-and-you'll-miss-it line, FLCL beat Pixar to the punch by fifteen years. Fuck, this show is brilliant.]

I suspect that Ninamori is still too young to make sense of her feelings for Naota - until she finds him sleeping alongside Haruko on a park bench. She is constantly irritated throughout FLCL as Naota's attention goes towards these two older women instead of her, but in that moment she realizes just how deeply and fully Naota has chosen Haruko and how much this hurts her. For all of the grief Mamimi and Haruko give Naota, he inflicts it right back onto Ninamori without even knowing it. It's a reminder that while this is Naota's story, everyone around him is experiencing the same journey. As the series draws to a close, it's hinted that Ninamori will become the woman in Naota's life and that he will be in good hands. The show is smart enough to not have them get together in the end, though. He's not ready to drink from her cup, so to speak. At least not now. They're just kids, after all. They have all the time in the world.

Some people still argue about whether or not Naota ever really attained "adulthood." Of course he did - he became Atomsk, after all. It's just that he realized that "adulthood" is a fallacy. Maturity is not some revelation, it's an ongoing process - it's gaining layers that strengthen who you already are. When Naota gained Atomsk's powers, he realized that he didn't want or need it - becoming Atomsk would just be putting on another mask (or a pair of fake glasses or seaweed eyebrows). He doesn't need to drink the sour stuff and he doesn't need to become his brother. He loves the sweet stuff, he loves his brother, he loves his boring old town and he loves Haruko - and he is no longer going to disengage from the world around him even if it can be rough. He's become grateful that he gets to love and learn and accepts that the world will always be mysterious and out of his control. Haruko can't accept this, and that's why she needs to keep on truckin' while Naota stays.

She only rescinded her invitation for him to come with her after he pointedly refused it with his silence. It's not that he couldn't follow her - he's just the one who is no longer lost. In a way, he has outgrown her.

Naota is back where he started by FLCL's conclusion. His town remains ordinary, his brother is still an ocean away, he still has Kamon as a father and he's back to square one when it comes to girls. Nothing has changed except for his attitude. He can now move forward with a clear mind and an open heart. And he will carry Haruko's bass guitar with him; if he learns how to play it, he'll have a helluva song to share. While the pillows' "Little Busters" serenades us one last time, telling us about how the kids are alright, the final shot of FLCL lingers on Haruko's guitar as it strums one last note. It's an acknowledgement that, even when they are flawed and disappointing, the most important people in our lives are those who strike a chord.


r/TrueAnime • • Nov 03 '25

losing interest in anime over the last couple of years.

365 Upvotes

I feel that the level of creativity and originality has been reducing drastically since the turn of this decade. In the last 5 years there are only two new shows that to me felt different in a way that pushes the medium being friren and orb on the movements of the earth. The rest felt largely formulaic with a focus on high quality animation rather than creating a story thats more than a montage of action or reused story lines. I truly think anime was different in the late 2000s and early 2010s. Death note, code geass, baccano, gurren laggan, nana, clannad, garden of sinners, kaiji. all came out in 2007 all being so completely unique and with very little to even compare to with works in the future. Am i the only one that feels the creative dept has been on a decline in anime and majority of the shows now are good and not great. where as before majority of the shows where bad but the good ones actually became classics people remember decades later.


r/TrueAnime • • Nov 04 '25

I’ve watched 450 anime over the years — here’s what never gets old.

360 Upvotes

It doesn’t matter how the animation evolves — good storytelling always hits the same. Every time a show nails real character growth, not just power-ups or flashy scenes, you can feel how much passion was put into a project.

I just wish more studios remembered that instead of just chasing the most expensive animation budget.


r/TrueAnime • • Aug 10 '20

Anime is becoming a trend and I hate it

313 Upvotes

Not sure if this is allowed to go here but imma tell you anyways.

More people are watching anime which is good but then again it fucking sucks. The reason why is because most of the people watching it are “normies”. Let me explain. As you could tell, there has been an increase in anime “fans” during quarantine who mostly spam about My hero Academia and Haikyuu (Or just any basic ass Shōnen) but what differentiates them from the average “new anime fan” is that they are normies (mostly Kpop fans, which is obvious to tell since they act like fucking children and spam “aesthetic vibes💞✨” or spam random letters instead of fucking laughing. We all know who they are and we all hate them. Most coming from twitter (which is a fucking cesspool I know)). They have ruined our once loved reputation of anime and morphed it into something that only adults with the mentality of a 14 year old would like. The wave of “new normie fans” won’t end for the foreseeable future since it is a trend. Mind you, these were the same people who complained that anime fans were pedos a few years ago and the same people who made fun of us for watching anime as kids. It’s just weird to see the these people now pretend that they’ve been a fan for a long time only because it’s a “trend” It just makes me angry.

You might call me petty, I don’t care but I want out old community back. I want the community that I grew up with back. I’m sure some of you won’t care and some of you might agree. It would be great for me to hear your responses.

I might’ve missed some things out but whatever, I guess.


r/TrueAnime • • Mar 21 '25

why are some anime fans so toxic, especially male fans?

274 Upvotes

Today I (F, 24) went to a photographer to have my passport photo taken. When one of the photographers picked me up, he asked me about my Jujutsu Kaisen T-shirt. I was mentally out of it at the time, which is why I didn't understand the jujutsu kaisen reference straight away and blanked it out because I just wanted to take a quick photo. When I was able to organise my thoughts clearly again, I noticed him making fun of me. He said in a grumpy tone something like: "why are you wearing an anime t-shirt if you don't know this anime at all?" i was shocked by this statement because i just came to take a photo. i made it clear to him that i had been watching jujutsu kaisen and that i was just off track and asked him to just take the photo because i was uncomfortable with him. When I sat down and got ready, I heard him say "typical, mimimi, I know more about anime than you do". after this action, I got up, told him that I wouldn't put up with that and left the shop. I started crying in the car because it was so damn disrespectful and unfriendly.
i've often had situations like that where i've had to prove to men that i'm a "real" fan.

i've never had anything like that with female fans. there were compliments from women about the hoodie or t-shirt. there was friendly conversation.

have you already had such experiences?

(i hope you can understand it. english is my 2nd language. )


r/TrueAnime • • Nov 21 '25

One Punch Man Season 3 discourse tells me that anime discussion is forever screwed beyond relief

247 Upvotes

The objective of this post is not to say that One Punch Man Season 3 is good. It is not to say that criticism of One Punch Man Season 3 is invalid, either. It is about how this season has brought out the absolute worse in anime fans.

I have literally seen people try to advocate for more people to hate the employees. Seen people try to find reasons to blame the director for a position he probably didn't ask for. Some people are outright trying to tune out any of the myriad reasons for why this production turned out the way it did (terrible scheduling, the best animators being busy with other projects/best studios being booked for years, declining anime industry as a whole) and just want to revel in the hate. It's literally this meme, people just want to be angry to the point that they cheer as the ratings for the latest episode drop further and further, which they themselves are contributing to.

I understand that OPM has fallen a really long way from its prime, even putting aside how much Season 1 was lightning in a bottle, but everything that this season has revealed about the community is, to me, a perfect example of why attempts to reform the anime industry have never succeeded. Rather than advocate for reform and better conditions, they harass the director off of Twitter. Rather than try to understand just how insanely hard and labor-intensive animation is, they demand overworked employees get fired and use fan animations as an excuse to ceaselessly bitch about how it's better than what they actually got, when the fan animation's conditions were infinitely better than the actual season's.

Fan culture is really just getting so insanely out of control.


r/TrueAnime • • May 02 '20

Discussion/Rant Anime is beginning to make me uncomfortable. [Contains NSFW topics & spoilers] NSFW Spoiler

150 Upvotes

POST WILL CONTAIN DISCUSSION OF SEXUAL ASSAULT IN ANIME AND MANGA

POST WILL CONTAIN SPOILERS FOR THE FOLLOWING ANIME/MANGA/WEBTOONS:

Grancrest Senki / Record Of The Grancrest War

Goblin Slayer

Fantasies Are Reality's Tears

51 Ways To Save Her / Kanojo wo Mamoru 51 no Hōhō

Black Lagoon

Drifters

Prelude:

The point of this post is to get some thoughts and beliefs about anime off of my chest, and to also see if other people notice what I notice, or if I'm oversensitive to these things because of personal beliefs and experiences.

I'm coming here instead of the r/.anime subreddit because I really don't like that place, mostly for subjective reasons such as their general content, moderation policies, and the kinds of things which are often defended and posted. I get a really bad vibe from there, which also ties in to part of the reason I have trouble with anime these days. I will be lumping things like Manga and Manga-styled webtoons in with these, since they almost universally suffer from the same issues that Anime does, if not more in many cases due to the almost complete lack of regulation on so many of them.

I've been watching anime for about as long as I can remember. I grew up with Inuyasha and .//hack on late night kinds/teens channels, and my dad bought me some DVD episodes of Gate Keepers when I was about 7 or 8 years of age. In secondary my interests turned towards very tropey shows like Shakugan no Shana and Zero no Tsukaima, along with hormonal teenager staples like High-school DxD or High-school of The Dead. This fortunately passed quickly, as I realized how sketchy these shows often were, with underage characters.

By the time I was a young adult out in the world on my own, my tastes had evolved to things like the horror & psychological thriller shows like Psycho Pass, Another, Re:Zero. I've of course always had a thing for action shows like Attack on Titan, Blood+ (except for the vore-y sequel), Legend Of The Legendary Heroes, and Black Lagoon. I also ended up getting really into political and macro-scale war stories, like Gundam, Macross, Legend Of The Galactic Heroes, and Aldnoah.Zero.

I could go on and on about my favourite shows. But there's one thing that I've noticed, and that's the fact that the number of new series I am comfortable watching seems to decline more and more every year. At first I thought it was just nostalgia glasses and "blah blah old stuff better heehaw" mentality, until I took a closer look at the reasons why I've been dropping shows, manga, and even comics and live action works. These reasons fall into a few categories which I'll list one by one.

Lolis and underage nudity:

There's really no way for me to say this in a kind way. I'm becoming genuinely fucking disgusted by the amount of sexualized children I'm seeing in anime & manga. I distinctly remember often being able to avoid this sort of thing by avoiding very specific shows back in the day, usually niche weird ecchi shows with low production values and were full of nothing but perv protag tropes. Of the last three anime productions I tried to watch, I ended up dropping two immediately.

No Game No Life was pretty much an instantaneous drop after less than ten minutes. I mean for fuck's sake, an excruciatingly detailed close-up of an 11 year old's cameltoe in striped panties? What in the actual god-damn fuck? And this is on fucking Netflix too!

Then came Expelled From Paradise. The show started us off with a fully grown independent woman, and then immediately de-aged her to a 16 year old, gave us an upper body nude shot, and then slapped her into skin-tight super skimpy bodysuit and made her into a bimbo-esque character being constantly made a fool of.

There's of course dozens more examples of this stuff. Honestly the entirety of High-school DxD is, in retrospect, rather disturbing as well, with a good chunk of the characters being 16-17 with constant nudity and creepshots. Creepshots in general are beginning to become very noticeable to me, and if I even *think* a show or anime game is going to be stuffed with creepshots, I just avoid it now. At this point it's becoming a game of mental gymnastics to even try to sort out child from adult in anime.

Rape and sexual assault:

When I was a kid, more often than not I simply didn't understand all the pervy characters, or the side-nods and 'off-screen' hints. When I did understand, or they were so blatant they couldn't be misunderstood, I was usually shocked and horrified. Especially when it was in a show seemingly aimed at my own age group (we're talking sub-16 here). Now that I'm older, understand more, and have been through some horrible events in both my own life, and the lives of others, I am constantly downright shocked and horrified whenever blatant sexual assault, explicit rape, or things like sexual gas-lighting are included in anime, manga, comics, and even live action productions.

I found myself absolutely horrified and sick to my stomach with the release of Goblin Slayer. I never made it past the rape scenes. As soon as I realized what was happening, I was gone. I actually haven't re-subbed to Crunchyroll as a result of their insanely negligent flub on not putting a proper rating and content warning!

Then there was Grancrest Senki. I started watching it back before there was a dub. I loved it! I loved it right up until Episode 9, which included a scene of sexual assault where the anime studio took an off-screen politically motivated and entirely consensual bedding, and turned it into an on-screen coercion, rape, and 1 minute view of the woman crying and thinking of the man she loves while it happens. Now before I am crucified on the off-chance I am wrong, I was told by a LN reader that this scene was not even in the light novel, it was only hinted at and mentioned as an off-screen and consensual happening. This show is also on Netflix. It's only content warnings are 'nudity' and 'gore'.

I had a pretty similar issue with Drifters, because of the mass-rape scene in the first few episodes. I honestly was only able to push past that because I had been warned by someone else beforehand, and told when to skip and to what time to skip to.

Then there's Black Lagoon. Actually one of my favourite shows, genuinely, but of course the anime adaptation adds a scene that is nowhere to be found, mentioned, or hinted at in the source material: The main female protagonist was sexually assaulted by a police officer. This serves next to no purpose in the story or character development, and is just tossed in there for ???shock value???

Then to comics. I'll do a couple at once here to get my example across. 51 Ways To Save Her is an older example (2007), but Fantasies Are Reality's Tears is a modern one, with chapters publishing every couple weeks. Both include very sudden, explicitly shown (without nudity) rape scenes which are included for literally no other reason than "bad guy bad, good girl hurt." Both times I ended up dropping the comic almost immediately.

Now here's the kicker. Fantasies Are Reality's Tears is published on a platform with direct and specific family friendly policies, and included absolutely no content warning until several hours (and hundreds of complaints) after it's initial upload. 51 Ways To Save Her only has content warnings on some of it's English fan translations. Goblin Slayer launched with no content warnings, as did Grancrest Senki. In fact, I don't think I've ever seen a content warning or 'viewer's discretion' warning on any episode of anime, anime film, or manga. Only unofficial fan translations, and a few decently sized web-comics/independent animations.

Conclusion:

All in all, I've noticed these issues starting to crop up more and more as time goes on. I don't think it's just me noticing them more, they're getting further and further into the mainstream. The sexualization of cartoon minors really feels like something that shouldn't be so blatantly on something like Netflix.

I've found myself becoming increasingly uncomfortable as each new show brings in pervy creepo harrassy characters, or introduces a rape scene, or makes rape a revenge point, etcetera etcetera. Studios platforms and outlets are also not doing their jobs in making sure these things have content warnings, or even policing them.

TL;DR

I think there's far too much sexualization of minors, far too many creepshots, and far too much usage and normalization of sexual assault & sexual harassment becoming mainstream in anime. It's beginning to make me uncomfortable with many new shows, and I'm honestly beginning to have difficulty even motivating myself to try new anime & manga. Even upon re-watching some of my favourite shows, I now cringe in disgust when I see these things.

Edit: Changed some faulty formatting. Too used to Discord's markdown text.


r/TrueAnime • • Mar 04 '17

Film Theory Pt. 1: Mise En Scene

111 Upvotes

So, new series! As some of you know, I've been working on the wiki for this subreddit, hoping to get it done by the end of the year. But I'm not really doing much for the community if I only pop in once every two months and say "here, another page, enjoy." So my new idea is to share my progress with you! Every week or two, I'm going to post a different excerpt from the wiki under construction. Although these posts are meant to be educational, please feel free to use these topics as a springboard for discussion.

Without further ado, let me teach you about mise-en-scene!


Mise-en-scene

The five formal elements of film are mise-en-scene, cinematography, editing, narrative and sound. To break them down in the most basic sense; mise-en-scene is what appears in a frame, cinematography is how it's shown (framing, camera angle, lighting), editing is how different frames relate to one another, sound is dialogue, effects and music, while narrative is the story that arises from the other four elements.

To begin analyzing the mise-en-scene, or shot composition/framing, one has to consider both what's on the screen and where it is on the screen. In considering what's on the scene, we can develop both literal and symbolic meanings. Especially in animation, nothing is on the screen by accident. Where things are on the screen in relationship to each other have psychological effects on the viewer that may convey additional meaning. Consider the following picture:

Marie Antoinette

The literal meaning of the baroque walls is to evoke a certain time period and social class. This is clearly a building that belongs to a very rich person, and the lady in the scene is probably related. As viewers, we probably knew that already, so this literal meaning is not terribly important. The symbolic meanings are more interesting; baroque stylings are very complex and ornate, much like french aristocratic society itself. Marie's placement in relation to the baroque walls suggests that she is being overwhelmed or dominated by whatever this baroque wall represents. All this meaning can be derived by two elements (Marie, the wall) and their relative locations in the frame.

So, a theory about what goes into a scene is difficult to articulate. The literal meanings are specific to their respective films and can't be generalized. The symbolic meanings are too numerous to give an adequate account of and often vary by context anyways. Instead, we're going to go a bit more in-depth on placement, listing out some relationships and giving examples:

  1. Objects on top dominate objects on bottom. This one is pretty obvious. A good example is almost any shot with a judge in a courthouse. Judge is near the top of the frame, symbolizing his power over the lower elements on the frame. Likewise with many king on his throne scenes.

  2. Bigger is more important. Another "well, duh" one! The greater a portion of the frame something covers, the more impact it has.

  3. Foreground is stronger than background. This one piggybacks a bit, since foreground objects tend to be larger. These first three are the general elements of power, and they may contradict each other in a single frame if the director does not wish to establish such power dynamics in his shot.

  4. Right is more positive, left is more negative. Here's an interesting one! It's a convention that seems to apply across cultures, so nothing to do with how we read our handwriting. Stuff on (or moving towards) the right side evokes a more positive feeling than vice versa. Right also implies future, while left implies past. Hence those stock evolution images.

  5. Symmetry is peaceful, asymmetry is tense. Symmetry is pretty obvious and easy to use, here's an example. An important related aspect to symmetry is the rule of thirds; split the image into thirds and the most important things should be on the lines. Here's an example of a symmetric shot that obeys the rule of thirds. Just because symmetry is peaceful doesn't mean you want to put things in the center; center shots often look too composed. Asymmetry can be used to make a scene feel just a bit less comfortable, such as this scene from A Clockwork Orange.

  6. The less space, the more claustrophobic. Especially in the direction characters are looking! This is known as lead space. For example, this first picture and this second picture both depict a woman running on the beach, but the second picture appears more tense because she is running out of room to run across the screen.

  7. Lines move eyes. Our eyes will naturally follow lines along an image, therefore something we'd want to notice should be placed where the lines point. Here is a really obvious one, the lines on the boat pointing to the palace. For a more subtle example, here's a wallpaper from the anime Jigoku Shoujo. Notice how the biggest leaves in the foreground point directly at her? Our eyes would be drawn to her even without the color contrast.

One final point to make about mise-en-scene is that the definition isn't quite as cut and dry as it seems. If mise-en-scene is everything in a frame, and the camera determines what's in the frame, then technically cinematography could be considered mise-en-scene too. So could acting, for that matter! Mise-en-scene is a concept that can basically be expanded to "everything but cuts", and this binary actually led to historical debates between film theorists advocating for cutting and those advocating for mise-en-scene. Those who favored mise-en-scene believed that since we experience time and space continuously, a superior form of cinema would recreate our experience of reality rather than resort to cheap cuts that take us out of the experience. This line of thinking extends to this day, where many critics praise long takes as if they were inherently superior to edited takes!


Pt. 2: Cinematography-Camera Angle and Camera Movement

Pt. 3: Cinematography - Focus, Lighting, and Aspect Ratio

Pt. 4: Sound and Foley Artists

Pt. 5: Editing and Soviet Montage Theory

Pt. 6: Auteur Theory and its Limitations


r/TrueAnime • • Feb 01 '14

“Rebel With A Misguided Cause”: How Madoka Magica Rebellion Disregards the Values of Its Own Predecessor [Spoilers]

109 Upvotes

TABLE OF CONTENTS¹:

Introduction: Beginnings

Section I: Trapped In This Endless Maze

Section II: Being An Ascended Meme Is Suffering

Section III: Obligatory Fan-Service Discussion #5403

Section IV: Lamentations of a Raspberry

Section V: “Local Girl Ruins Everything”

Section VI: Someone Is Fighting For You: Remembrance

Section VII: Someone Is Fighting For You: Forgotten

Conclusion: Eternal

Sidenotes/Miscellany


[There will, of course, be unmarked spoilers for the entire Puella Magi Madoka Magica franchise throughout the following essay. If you haven’t seen the series or the movies yet (and you should) and don’t want your perceptions of them preemptively altered (and you shouldn’t), then get on outta here.]


Introduction: Beginnings


Puella Magi Madoka Magica was an anime series that aired January 7 to April 22, 2011 created by Studio Shaft, their first original series in nearly a decade. It was directed by Akiyuki Shinbou, written by Gen Urobuchi, produced by Atsuhiro Iwakami, and featured character designs by Ume Aoki and music by Yuki Kajiura. It is a story about magical girls who discover that the reality of wishes and fighting for what you believe in is not quite what they at first thought. The first Blu-ray volume broke sales records, and a live broadcast of the entire series on Nico Nico Douga managed to pull in one million viewers.

It is a widely acclaimed, wildly successful series, and is my personal favorite anime of all time.

Puella Magi Madoka Magica The Movie: Rebellion was an anime film released on October 26, 2013, also by Studio Shaft. It, too, was directed by Shinbou (also Yukihiro Miyamoto), written by Urobuchi, produced by Iwakami, and featured character designs by Aoki and music by Kajiura. It is a story about magical girls who discover that the reality of the tranquil world they inhabit is not quite what they at first thought. To date, the film has earned almost two billion yen domestically, becoming the highest grossing film based on a late-night anime series in the process.

It has received a mixed reception amongst fans and critics, and I honestly don’t care for it very much.

What the hell happened?

Now let me make something perfectly clear: as I prepare to go on this overindulgent tirade as someone who was dissatisfied with Rebellion, hopefully representing others who were dissatisfied with Rebellion in the process, I don’t mean to infer that it is by any means a terrible or unwatchable film. I mean…have you seen this thing? It’s a gorgeous, gorgeous movie, an audio-visual feast with masterful animation, directing, aesthetics, voice-acting, and music (for the record, Colorful and Kimi no Gin no Niwa were probably the best songs to come out of an anime that year). And the fact that the film has been a demonstrable monster hit – not just domestically but as part of successful foreign film circuits in countries where most anime movies slip by unnoticed – with little more as support than its status as a sequel to an original series that had no basis in manga, light novel, visual novel or otherwise…dude, that’s fucking awesome. Everyone at Shaft deserves a high-five and a raise for making waves this huge. But that just makes the question more pressing: why, then, did this movie fail to please on quite the same scale as its preceding series?

The truth of the matter is that I could spend all day performing a frame-by-frame autopsy of this movie and every single one of its plot details and I don’t think it would ultimately amount to anything. There are, admittedly, some things about the plot itself that I just can’t ignore (and we will get there, in time), but to really understand a film like Rebellion, one of that is capable generating such dissonant and diametrically opposed responses, we have to tear the film wide open, past its meticulously-constructed outward appearances represented by the finished product, and examine its beating heart. We have to know why this movie was even made and what mentality drove it towards completion.

Fortunately, we have a partial means of speculating that. The Madoka Magica The Rebellion Story Brochure, which was sold at theater screenings in Japan along with the movie, contains in-depth interviews with most of the core production staff, most notably Akiyuki Shinbou and Gen Urobuchi²; if you have the time, I highly recommend digging through this material, as it contains a lot of behind-the-scenes gold and is perhaps the single biggest contribution to the validity of my thesis (translations for each of these interviews are helpfully arranged on the Puella Magi Wiki here). And it is here that Shinbou conveniently determines the springboard from which Rebellion was launched:

Question: The TV version of Puella Magi Madoka Magica garnered a lot of attention during its original on-air run starting in January 2011. Shinbou-san, when did you start wanting to make this new chapter?

Shinbou: Right around when the TV series broadcast ended. During the broadcast itself, we had our hands full actually making the show, so there was no time to think about a “next”. But the fan reaction was above and beyond what we hoped for, so I started wanting to make a sequel. I don’t actually remember when we started to hold meetings about it, but the first run of the screenplay was decided upon in the summer of 2011, so I think we were holding meetings over the script around then.

This in itself isn’t too surprising. Most sequels are made to capitalize on the success of an original idea. Most of them are indeed colored by what Shinbou calls “fan reaction”, catering to elements of the original work that captured audiences without the full understanding of why they did so. Most of them, subsequently, are inferior in quality.

What is surprising is that Rebellion, in my opinion, follows that exact same trajectory almost to a tee, even with some of the industry’s best talent working on it. The same team that created Madoka freakin’ Magica did not overcome the obstacles erected in the way of a solid sequel. That is perhaps a testament to the self-contained nature of the original to an extent, but believe it or not, I don’t doubt the possibility that a satisfying follow-up to Madoka Magica, one far less divisive than the one we received, could have been made. That it didn’t, even in the hands of the people who should know Madoka Magica better than anyone, is suspect. It makes me wonder to what extent the aforementioned motive for even starting production of the film affected the result.

I thus offer the following two theses:

1.) The success of the original Puella Magi Madoka Magica TV series can be explained primarily through its adherence to a number of vital principles (pacing, thematic consistency, understanding of its artistic pedigree, etc.) which, in concert, exhibit mastery over the storytelling craft. I propose that Rebellion does not achieve the same victory because it does not adhere to the principles that made the original series great.

2.) I also propose that the cause for said lack of adherence is the by-product of what I will label, as inspired by Shinbou and for the lack of a better term, fan response. Rebellion, in its entirety, is colored by the creator’s reactions to how viewers perceived the original work. In-so-doing, it forgets or discards what helped generate those reactions to begin with. To put it another way, the phenomenon of Madoka Magica was so great that it cannibalized the potency of its own sequel.

The following sections will attempt to support these premises by culling artistic examples from both Rebellion and its predecessor. As a result, they will frequently serve as affirmations of Madoka Magica’s pristine, timeless radiance just as much as they serve as condemnations of Rebellion’s comparative shallowness and misguided nature. The ways in which the original’s brilliance is either ignored or altered by fan response cover a wide spectrum of elements that will take a great deal of time and words to cover, but the important thing to remember throughout all of them is this: whatever you may think of these elements on Rebellion’s own terms, they are far removed from what made Madoka Magica shine so brightly.³


NEXT: Trapped In This Endless Maze


r/TrueAnime • • Mar 21 '26

Why do people care so much about characters being students?

107 Upvotes

I sometimes see comments in the style of "I wish this was in college instead" or "I wish the characters were adults" and I'm like... why?

I've watched from anime where the characters are kindergartners to anime where they're all adult. from shougaku to kougaku.
In a lot of anime, those can be interchangeable: Sonny Boy and Onani Master Kurosawa are set in middle-school, but feel like high-school and I watched it with that mindset.
Ruri no Houseki are about highschoolers interacting with college students, but if you told me it was about middle-schoolers interacting with a senior highschool club, I would believe in you.

The highschool parts of Onani Master Kurosawa and Sonny Boy feel more like college, while the HS parts of Ikoku Nikki feel like... HS.
You could've told me that the JS's and JC's in Nanoha ViVid are actually JC's and JK's and I would've believed in you.

I could keep giving examples all day, but my main point is that Japanese schools are such a distant experience compared to the schools we went to that we might as well put "Japanese School Anime" in the same category we put "Fantasy Isekai".


r/TrueAnime • • Oct 07 '26

New gen anime watchers care too much about Fandoms

103 Upvotes

Statements such as “i didn't watch ____ because it's Fandom is weird” is something am sure we've all heard. Animes such as MHA, JJBA and bleach have suffered from this hivemind bandwagon mentality post covid anime watchers suffer. Once anime became “mainstream” anime studios such as mappa pushing out animes at a unprecedented rate rather then taking time. Mass consumerism in the anime industry

I of the opinion anime should have stayed niche. What do you guys think


r/TrueAnime • • Oct 20 '25

Mushoku Tensei is morally bad, and the writing isnt good either, heres why: [Spoiler] Spoiler

102 Upvotes

Content and Spoiler Warning! but if you’ve seen MT, nothing worse than that. I’m well aware this isn’t even a dead horse; at this point, we are arguing over ashes. And yet, I still see people defending MT and Rudeus to this very day. I find it so morally reprehensible that if I didn’t at least make a post, I’d feel complicit, and I think I can convince most people of it by the end.

To start off, I really did give MT a fair chance. I heard about the pedophilia aspect, but also that it was handled with some tact and actually had a narrative purpose.

This was untrue. I found the first episodes of MT uncomfortable to say the least, pedophilia is immediately farmed for essentially comic relief, which is not what you want to see. The butt of the joke is Rudeus, yes, but the victim of Rudy's predation is still sexualized nonetheless. The narrative says "look at this pathetic creep", but what’s on screen says "look at this eroticized child’s body". To make matters worse, Rudeus's legitimate desire is not at all contrasted with his predatory desire. When he creeps on his adult mom (not actual mom, reincarnation mom), the framing is identical, same shots, same joke. There was a chance here for actual separation and condemnation, if the shots with children were kept modest. But nope, we see what Rudy sees, really what the author wants us to see (or more cynically, what the author wants to see). I honestly feel like a bad person for continuing to watch at this point. It’s already in the territory of tactless representation of pedophilia. But I soldiered on.

It does not get better. At first, we are shown child sexualization, then we are shown as explicit a child sexual abuse scene as is allowed. Eris, who is 15 at this point, over Rudeus in an overtly sexual way, as she starts foreplay. And then we are told what happens. Eris cannot consent at this point, and I am 100% sure that if Eris knew who Rudeus actually was, she would not have initiated, not that it makes it any worse that Rudeus doesn’t reject her advances. This would probably be the worst scene in the show, if it weren’t for one that comes later. Considering everything that came before (or frankly, without considering it), this is already seriously crossing the line of what can be considered representation of pedophilia for a literary purpose.

Later, Rudeus has another graphic, and this time violent, sexual encounter with his childhood friend, Sylphie, who is 16 at the time. He groomed her using proximity, which is a sentiment he literally spells out earlier: "We'll grow up together and I'll gradually raise her to be my ideal woman". Sylphie again doesn’t say no, which you'll notice is the theme, but she does get hurt during sex, and we see blood. I don't think I need to explain how problematic this is. Rudeus's actual sexual advances are essentially never rejected, or at least aren't for long. It feels like the author "toes the line" by not having the girls actually reject his advances, just not be in a position to accept them as minors, as if to give legitimacy to his pedophilia. Well, he's a pedophile, but at least he's not a rapist (except he is).

Neither of these instances is framed as a tragedy, nor does Rudy suffer any punishment for them. It makes you wonder, why is the author so intent on showing frequent, erotic, and sometimes violent content depicting children but never doling out consequences to Rudy, or even the girls who he rapes? The latter of which is particularly egregious; it’s not like I expect the author to treat their characters like real people and punish them accordingly, but not having any consequences for the girls (aside from Sylphie bleeding) makes it seem like the author is saying that, as long as CSA is consensual, it’s harmless. Because he is. Hint; the author is a piece of shit.

At this point, the line has been firmly crossed. If it wasn’t before, this would now be firmly in the territory of CSA fantasy and apologetics, with Rudeus as a vehicle (or worse, a self-insert). But at the very least, if Rudeus had an arc where he realized both his past and present wrongdoings, it might be a salvagable train wreck. But nope, he goes on to marry each of the children (plus 1 child looking adult because why not) he sexually abused and groomed throughout the story. But it’s not framed like an anti-climax where the villain got his way. No, it’s a happy ending and we are supposed to believe that Rudeus has changed his ways, when really he just kept on course and got rewarded for it. A truly redeemed Rudy would’ve stepped away from the girls, now women he groomed, maintaining at most a cordial friendship, and then looked elsewhere. Not only is it morally reprehensible, it’s bad writing too. He doesn’t sacrifice anything to be redeemed, or really redeem himself at all. He just changes his circumstances.

To sum up, the story contains rampant sexualization of minors, explicit depictions of CSA, a young girl chained by the neck that one time, pedophilia played for jokes, the list goes on. So it begs the question, why would the author write and draw something like this other than to titillate? There is no answer. It’s a shameless self-insert CSA fantasy, and in a cruel twist of grotesque irony, he got a huge reward for it ,in the form of tens of millions of dollars, just like Rudeus did. In the making of the god-awful stain on the Earth that is MT, he actually made a better critique of pedophilia and how normalized, accepted and rewarded it is, by accident, than I think anyone could've on purpose.

TL;DR? Too bad, read it. Also, Rifujin na Magonote is a worthless, pedophilic piece of human trash and the world would be better without him in it.


r/TrueAnime • • Nov 12 '25

Do you ever find yourself leaving a sub of an anime you like, just because the posts are so immature or plain dumb that they start draining your love for the series?

95 Upvotes

It’s always the same posts. Aura farming, gender-bend jokes, TikToks with dance edits and people there seem to love them.

But when there’s finally a serious discussion, they ask questions or make statements that anyone who’s actually watched the show should already know. 🤷🏻‍♀️


r/TrueAnime • • Feb 14 '16

The long promised /r/TrueAnime guide to anime!

Thumbnail reddit.com
92 Upvotes

r/TrueAnime • • Jun 18 '14

Last year my wife and I decided to quit our jobs in the animation industry to start our own animation studio. Our goal is to combine the best qualities of Japanese and Western animation. AMA!

91 Upvotes

For many years, I dreamt of making my own anime. This dream was the driving force that motivated me to teach myself CG and allowed me to break into the US animation industry. While working at Laika, I met my wife and found out that she had the same dream of making orginal anime-inspired cartoons. We were determined to someday make this goal a reality. Last year we quit our jobs and have been working hard creating our own original content ever since:

Our demo reel:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oygmok5_by4

and

A trailer for our upcoming original animated music video - "Heavenly Escorts":

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fWeq_l4XWSM

For those interested, my wife /u/Kyarohime did an AMA about working in the anime industry a while back.

We are Studio Gattai. AMA!

(EDIT#1) For any that are curious, Here is a link to a video we created demonstrating our production pipeline.

(EDIT#2) Here are links to our Tumblr, Facebook Page, Youtube and Twitter.

(EDIT#3) For anyone interested in the music here is a link to Digiflesh on Facebook

(EDIT#4) 12:24pm Alright everyone, we're gonna sign off for tonight! We had a lot of fun and I hope we answered all your questions. If you have anymore questions, or just missed the AMA yesterday, feel free to keep the thread alive and we'll check back periodically to answer anything that's posted here! Thanks a lot everyone!!


r/TrueAnime • • May 20 '21

Kentaro Miura has passed away

87 Upvotes

Just announced not too long ago. It may not ever be finished, but he's created one of the greatest works ever, Berserk. Rest in peace.


r/TrueAnime • • May 28 '26

Anyone think anime is better when you watch what you want and not engage with other fans?

86 Upvotes

I've watched a lot of anime to count and I can't help but wonder if it's better for me to just be myself and not listen or interact with other fans, especially online. My preferences are huge as I watch like a variety of different genres and just find what I find, but I can't help but think if I'm just lonely for not having fans who are as passionate or more accepting of anime as much as me. Anyone else feel the same and wish they had more people who liked anime they know?


r/TrueAnime • • Jun 12 '14

Differences in taste between r/anime and r/TrueAnime, based on user's MALs

81 Upvotes

Recently I did some web scraping to harvest MAL links from users' flairs in both r/anime and r/trueanime (More frequent posters were more likely to be picked up). From this I was able to find users' average ratings for shows (Only counting those which had a decent number of ratings). These results may not be scientifically sound but they're hopefully interesting.

Here are the top 15 for r/trueanime:

Name                                           Avg Score  # Ratings
Yojouhan Shinwa Taikei (Tatami Galaxy)         9.26           15
Monogatari Series: Second Season               9.12           16
Princess Tutu                                  9.07           13
Kino no Tabi: The Beautiful World              9.05           17
Mushishi                                       9.00           20
Ookami Kodomo no Ame to Yuki (Wolf Children)   8.92           12
Cowboy Bebop                                   8.83           23
Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion 8.80           20
Haibane Renmei                                 8.79           19
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood               8.75           20
Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica                     8.70           37
Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu                  8.65           26
Katanagatari                                   8.65           17
Usagi Drop                                     8.59           17
Tenkuu no Shiro Laputa (Castle in the Sky)     8.58           12

Here are the top 15 for r/anime:

Name                                           Avg Score  # Ratings
Monogatari Series: Second Season               9.36           107
Steins;Gate                                    9.3            180
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood               9.25           147
Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu                  9.15           115
Yojouhan Shinwa Taikei (Tatami Galaxy)         9.13           40
Clannad: After Story                           9.12           101
Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica                     9.08           174
Mushishi                                       9.06           48
Shinsekai yori                                 9.06           89
Katanagatari                                   9.05           75
Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica Movie 2             8.98           43
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann                     8.97           164
Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica Movie 3             8.97           63
Chihayafuru 2                                  8.97           31
Mononoke Hime                                  8.96           100

Overall, r/trueanime tends to give lower ratings than r/anime. Here are all the series that r/trueanime gave a higher rating than r/anime:

Name                                            Difference
Hotaru no Haka (Grave of the Fireflies)         0.31
Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion  0.21
Yojouhan Shinwa Taikei                          0.14
Ookami Kodomo no Ame to Yuki                    0.14
Paprika                                         0.13
Eve no Jikan                                    0.13
Cowboy Bebop: Tengoku no Tobira                 0.10
Top wo Nerae! Gunbuster!                        0.09
Majo no Takkyuubin (Kiki's Delivery Service)    0.09
Ghost in the Shell                              0.09
Serial Experiments Lain                         0.05
Mushishi Special: Hihamukage                    0.05
Uchouten Kazoku                                 0.05
Byousoku 5 Centimeter                           0.03

Most of these are probably not statistically significantly higher, though unlike most they're at least not lower.

Here are the 15 series that r/trueanime most gave a lower rating to compared to r/anime:

Name                                     Difference
Ano Natsu de Matteru                     -2.36
IS: Infinite Stratos                     -2.24
High School DxD                          -2.12
Ore no Imouto etc. Specials              -2.07
Steins;Gate: Fuka Ryouiki no Déjà vu     -2.05
Guilty Crown                             -1.98
Kill la Kill                             -1.97
Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai Next        -1.96
Toaru Majutsu no Index                   -1.82
Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai             -1.81
Kyoukai no Kanata                        -1.80
Mirai Nikki (TV)                         -1.74
Angel Beats!                             -1.67
Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo               -1.63
Ore no Imouto etc.                       -1.63

These differences are quite large.

Conclusion: Not enough people either here or in r/anime have watched Legend of the Galactic Heroes :P. Also, I really need to watch The Tatami Galaxy.


r/TrueAnime • • Jun 11 '26

I feel like the more anime i watched i've started to prefer it over western animation

78 Upvotes

To me anime has everything most western cartoons failed to do, even if people say "it has mature themes/writing"

Shows like adventure time, steven universe, gravity falls weren't for me; i couldn't stand all the jokes and all the tell-don't show, whereas anime taught me that silence is important (Ma)

This is why i cherish stories such as monster and mushishi and this medium as a whole


r/TrueAnime • • Mar 24 '15

Tentacle Hentai: Anime History

76 Upvotes

I highly recommend reading the pdf here as it has essential images and better formatting. Thanks!

Tentacle Hentai is just one of those things that really defines the negative image of Japan in the minds of many people in the United States. In order to understand tentacle hentai you need to place yourself in a completely different cultural context. To achieve that end, here is an article on the origins of tentacle hentai in Japan. Enjoy.

Shunga and the “Pornification” of Pop Culture

Ukiyo-e was an art style popular during the Edo period in Japan (17th-19th century). Shunga was the erotic version of ukiyo-e. Shunga was also used as sexual education for new wives. Many artists dabbled in Shunga as it was not stigmatized in a way modern "cartoon porn" is. The connection with modern doujinshi is the subjects eroticized. Popular anime such Naruto, Bleach, etc. is “pornified” in many doujinshi. This “pornification” of pop culture is not a new expression either. To have an Edo-era example I will use the popular artist Hokusai. Hokusai did many Ukiyo-e pieces as well as many shunga pieces. One piece “The Dream of the Fisherman’s Wife” would have been interpreted in the minds of its intended audience as “pornifying” the story of Princess Tamatori which was popular during the Edo Period. It tells the story of a woman who marries Fujiwara no Fuhito who is searching for a pearl stolen by Ryujin, dragon of the sea. She obtains the jewel and escapes through Ryujin’s army of sea creatures including octopi. In the image, big Octopus says “he will bring the girl to Ryūjin's undersea palace.”

Modern Origin: Dream Hunter REM

If we are looking for a modern beginning to tentacle hentai in animation, we need to look at an anime that came out in the mid 1980’s. Dream Hunter REM tells the story of Rem Ayanokouji who works as a "dream hunter," a person capable of entering the dreams of sleeping people and fighting the demons causing nightmares. The first OVA came out as a hentai but the creators decided to reboot the series as a regular anime. The tentacle dream monster raping the girl in the hentai OVA is the first example of tentacle hentai. However, the popularity, and infamy, of tentacle hentai has roots in the animation Urotsukidoji (1989) because of its darker themes.

Censorship: Why Tentacles?

Contemporary censorship guidelines in Japan have origins in the Meiji Period during the late 19th century. In order to westernize, and therefore modernize, the Meiji Government began to adopt western influences into their system of government. A borrowed system brought in by the new leaders of the Meiji Government were issues of censorship. Sexual censorship in terms of a European Victorian era style are not flexible in their application. They focus on traditionalist views toward sexual acts which meant showing genitalia or a “sensual” scene in a bedroom. These specific depictions become flagged by censorship authorities. After WWII, the same traditionalist censorship standards continued and much to today still hold strong. To really look at this phenomenon, we have to consider the section above. The traditionalist views towards sex made a “typical” sex scene “obscene” and of course showing genitalia was a no go. So, people still want pornography right? People who sell pornography want to push the boundaries while still staying out of the eyes of the censorship authorities. Therefore, many artists in manga and anime began looking at ways to circumvent censorship guidelines. To look at a personal opinion let’s take a look at the animator Toshio Maeda. He stated:

“At that time pre-Urotsuki Doji, it was illegal to create a sensual scene in bed. I thought I should do something to avoid drawing such a normal sensual scene. So I just created a creature. His tentacle is not a penis as a pretext. I could say, as an excuse, this is not a penis; this is just a part of the creature. You know, the creatures, they don't have a gender. A creature is a creature. So it is not obscene - not illegal. (“Manga Artist Interview Series (Part 1),” 2002)”

The way to circumvent a strict traditionalist approach to pornography is to remove the sensual interactions between male and female. If one of the partners in the sexual scene has no gender then there is no attack on specific social norms for interactions between males and females in Japanese society. Thus, tentacle monsters are created from a creative approach to pornography that both takes inspiration from shunga and from the repression of modern censorship.

Modern Relevance of Tentacle Hentai

Tentacle rape or shokushu goukan (触手強姦) is focused on monsters having sex with female characters. The sex is usually forced but can be considered consensual in some hentai. In looking at data on tentacle hentai, I used Google Trends in my research. Google is the second most used search engine in Japan so I felt its results would be relevant for this article. Looking at search data for “tentacle hentai,” it has been steadily increasing reaching its highest point in August of 2014. United States is third in total searches for tentacle hentai while the Philippines and Singapore are first and second. In Japan, there is a strong correlation between searches on “触手” and “強姦.” However, the search data obtained is steadier reflecting a continued interest rather than a rising one.

Hey there if you thought this was a good read check out my article on lolicon here. I’m also on YouTube.com at “Anime Historian” if you want to see my videos. I love talking to you guys so every comment is appreciated. Have a nice day you guys.


r/TrueAnime • • Apr 09 '15

Who is Lain? (Serial Experiments Lain Spoilers)

75 Upvotes

Two threads for me today; I figured I should share my Lain article I wrote recently. Hope you all enjoy.

EDIT: Thank you very much for the gold!!

EDIT 2: Wow... you guys really liked this. Thanks for all the positive feedback and support!


The purpose of this article will be to explain who Lain is as a person and go over her personality, her strengths, her flaws, her goals, and relationships within the show. Lain is such a dense character that you could write papers on her alone even completely ignoring the show’s other messages. With this article I hope to establish a starting point where I may go into different character explorations as they relate to the show.

Human, God, or Machine?

One of the most important places to start, specifically for Lain, is determining what exactly she is. At initial glance she is indeed a 14 year old girl (younger in the video game, which I may also touch on at some points) with brown hair and a penchant for bears. She has a family (who isn’t actually all that supportive) and at least one good friend which is normal for her personality; shy, quiet, introverted, doesn’t want to make trouble for anyone. Human flesh, human friends, human family. There isn’t anything immediately odd about her situation or the like.

However later on Masami Eiri calls her a “human of artificial ribosomes”. If he is to be believed (which is up for debate) Lain was his own product. She is nothing more than a homunculus that he created for whatever reason; even though he wished for humans to all leave their bodies he gave Lain a human form. Unfortunate for him this granted her power to control not only the Wired but reality as well, to the extent of potentially becoming “God” if she had wanted to.

If Lain is software like Eiri stated then she would be the actual embodiment of Protocol 7, which came about due to the human unconscious trying to become the active human conscious. This would make Lain more of a machine than anything if we accept that Eiri created her both by giving her the body and giving birth to her through Protocol 7’s creation. However thanks to the blurring of the lines between reality and the Wired it’s hard to say how much of Protocol 7 is actually a machine and how much is the actual human mind.

By the end of the show it’s pretty clear that she is a God in some way shape or form. But arguably she has that power from the very beginning of the show. We see her early on in episode 4 manipulating reality around her by breaking the Men in Black’s scanners only by shouting at them to go away. We also see evidence of Lain’s omnipresence from episode 1 where she leaves the train and ends up in her house, her school, a subway station, and the train tracks (which may also be indicative of her time travel).

In addition, according to Thought Experiments Lain, it’s possible that Lain is the spirit of the planet – Gaia, if you will. This reasoning is achieved through understanding that Protocol 7 was achieved through the Earth’s own electronic resonances and that Lain herself is a product of Protocol 7, or a manifestation of it. She is the true God who came to replace Eiri once he was revealed to be the false god – the placeholder god for the true god (goddess in this case). This also brings up several interesting questions about religion, but that should be saved for a later article.

My opinion is that Lain is a manifestation of Protocol 7, though I am still unsure of whether to think she was created by Eiri or came into existence of her own accord. With the game’s continuity of Lain being 11 years old and aging into a 14 year old girl it’s even harder to pin down an exact date that Lain may have been created; it’s also possible that she has always been, but has not always existed in a human form. I believe she is Protocol 7 though because she is part of the collective unconscious and her powers are more easily explained when you take into account the breakdown of reality and the Wired merging together. She’s able to manipulate reality through people’s memories, to the point where they all believe or forget the same thing. But we’re not exactly done with defining who she is; we still have to look at her personality(s).

Me, Myself, and I

Lain’s personality is also extremely hard to define. To make it as simple as we can we’re going to have to break it up into the three defining personalities: Lain Iwakura, Lain of the Wired, and Evil Lain. Lain Iwakura suffers from Dissociative identity Disorder (aka Multiple Personality Disorder) in the show as evidenced by her appearance in Cyberia as well as the switch when she is talking to the Men in Black’s Boss – the explanation for this is that the Wired is breaking into reality thus making it easier for Lain of the Wired (and Evil Lain) to take over Lain Iwakura’s body in times of extreme stress. Let’s look at each one individually though:

Lain Iwakura

The human girl who, at the beginning of the series, likes bears, is extremely shy, has very few friends, and isn’t very good with technology. She doesn’t say much to anyone around her even with her friends. Even when she talks to the delivery man in episode 2 about her computer she kind of hides behind the truck. She’s even reluctant to talk to her PARENTS of all people (although she might just be subconsciously uncomfortable with talking to them because she knows they’re adoptive parents).

But oddly enough, even though she’s introverted and alone all the time, she’s extremely LONELY. She craves human contact. She latches onto anyone who shows her the slightest bit of love. In the video game, when Lain’s father went on a business trip, she built a robot replica of him because she didn’t know when he was coming back. Her most extreme fear is to be left alone by Alice.

In the end she commits the ultimate selfless sacrifice (which ironically is also selfish in a way) by making herself permanently lonely. She remains in her human body and refuses to become the god of a new universe because she loves all humans. Everyone loves Lain and in return Lain loves all of them, even if they don’t know it. She struggles with this to an extreme degree, however. It’s only after being comforted by her father (or rather, the IMAGE of her father) that she is able to accept her sacrifice and move on with the rest of… eternity most likely. She essentially commits suicide in the most extreme way; beyond removing herself from the world she removes herself from existence, remembered only faintly by those who were closest to her.

Lain also struggles with several problems beyond loneliness. She’s a compulsive liar, especially in the video games. She tells her therapist that she has a friend just so the therapist will stop badgering her about having friends; she keeps up this lie for THREE YEARS. She also tries to tell a story about going to her aunt’s house with her family but can’t remember the exact details. She ends by saying that she went to her aunt’s house alone.

She’s also extremely depressed when she is lonely or if she feels like she is causing trouble for someone. Several of her diary entries from the video game say something to the effect of “I wish I was never born”, “I just end up getting in the way”, “I’m a terrible person”, and other things. Some of the entries are only one line. There are many other entries as well but the volume of these specific messages should be reason for concern alone.

Of course, one of her other issues is her identity. It kind of goes along the same lines this article is going over; she is confused about her memories, her personality, her family, and everything affecting her life to where she’s not even sure if she’s in control of her own body or ever was. Her DID doesn’t help with that either. Some of her initial concerns in the show seem to be raised when her friends beginning to ask her if she was at Cyberia the night before. It’s important to also look at her other personalities, first with Lain of the Wired.

Lain of the Wired

The bad girl, the wild child, the bossy and sassy Lain. This is the exact opposite of Lain Iwakura. This is her online personality – in the real world she would be hiding behind a username or an anonymous tag and using this persona to live out her desire to act in a way she never could in real life. This translates to the show through the Wired into Lain’s bad girl personality, which takes over mostly in Cyberia in the early parts of the show (due to Cyberia even further blurring the line between reality and the Wired) but during Lain’s talk with the Boss of Tachibana Labs Lain of the Wired comes out to take over in Lain Iwakura’s state of extreme stress.

This personality is, as said before, a complete opposite of the shy introverted girl known as Lain Iwakura. We see proof that the two are one in the same however when Lain enters the Wired and starts acting exactly like Lain of the Wired. She is much more adult than Lain Iwakura as well – she appears well dressed for a club and talks to people probably twice her age as if she is their superior.

Evil Lain

The Knight’s creation. This version of Lain is horribly cruel and Lain’s voice actress even purposely voiced her like an evil villain. Evil Lain kills without any concern for human life; in fact it almost seems that she enjoys it as episode 7 shows. She’s seen laughing at the Wannabe Knight implying she knows that she is going to kill him. She has no fear of death either, finding it amusing when Lain is “committing suicide”.

The most important thing to note about Evil Lain is Lain Iwakura’s line of dialog in which she states that Evil Lain is “all the parts she hates about herself”. This means pretty clearly that Lain at least shares some THOUGHTS with Evil Lain, if not the outright desire to cause chaos. She’s the result of the Knight’s desire to create a clone of Lain and sabotage any ideas she was getting in her head that would go against the Knight’s own objectives.

Lain’s Relationships

Lastly I feel like it’s important to look at the relationships Lain has to some of htr friends and family and the other less noble characters in the show (to put it lightly). These characters will possibly be examined later on more in depth in a separate article. Right now I am going to look at the most important people in Lain’s life, specifically.

Masami Eiri

Lain’s “creator” and the false god of the Wired. He had delusions about becoming an all powerful god and saw the Knights and Lain as pawns in order to accomplish his goals. In relation to Lain he tries to control her and convince her that he is above her. She eventually realizes that she has more power than him and defeats him and his own ideals because he became too greedy and tried to go against Lain’s massive power. He is the false god to the true god of Lain.

Lain’s Family

As was stated before most of Lain’s family isn’t very supportive. Her mother has a total of 10 lines, MAYBE? throughout the entire series. Her sister is a more of an interesting case for episode 5 alone but she at least shows a passing interest in Lain even after she becomes a fax machine. Which leaves us with… her father.

At first it may seem like her father is a supportive character; he seems to be the only one that Lain has any interest in talking to in the family and even warns Lain against the dangers of mixing the Wired and Reality. But at some point it almost seems like Yasuo Iwakura is more interested to see what Lain will do with her Navi. In the end of the show it turns out that he did love her even though he never enjoyed “playing house”.

But the most important thing to note here is that besides one other character Yasuo might be the one that Lain gets the most support from; he’s the one that she is comforted by in the very end (even if that might not even be Yasuo himself). She uses his image as a comforting thing. He even breaks the rule of not saying good bye to Lain when the family is supposed to leave her.

Alice

Perhaps the most important character to Lain, Alice is the one that gives the viewer a way to measure reality within Serial Experiments Lain. More importantly she’s the one who loved Lain without worshipping her. She constantly rushed to Lain’s side when Lain was in a touch position while Reika and Juri stood by on the side. Lain also gets extremely attached to Alice, getting distraught when Alice suggests that Lain may not be having fun.

In the end Alice is the one to remind Lain about the importance of being human and the importance of having a body. She convinces Lain to stop with the plan to connect everyone and Lain listens because Alice is the one she loves the most. She even reminds Lain that Lain herself has a body by making her bleed (even though it was unintentional).

So Lain removes herself completley from everyone’s memories, even Alice’s. Because in the end Protocol 7 caused more problems than it solved and Lain decided to rectify that. She even keeps her body to remember what being a human is like. Alice is perhaps the one who saves everyone from being joined together in the Wired.

Conclusion

So that’s it. I’ve said everything I can think to say on Lain in… quite a lot of words I think. She’s a introverted girl who happens to be insanely depressed and a compulsive liar who has multiple personalities. But she also has a big heart which loves all of humanity and wants those closest to her to be happy. A truly complex character and an incredible example of a character who goes through their own unique struggles and develops from it.

I hope this article has been informative and I hope to write more on Lain’s themes and characters in the future. Thanks for reading, and remember to love Lain.


r/TrueAnime • • Dec 28 '15

Incest Hentai: Anime History

73 Upvotes

Hello everyone. Been awhile since I posted last. I wrote this one oneand off for awhile. To be perfectly honest I didn't proofread this so it might be a rough read. I just wanted to complete it for my own sake. Thanks you guys.

Mother-Son Relationship in Anime

The Japanese Women: Cultural Assumptions

Traditionally, since the Meiji Restoration (Late 19th century), the female identity has been tied to the domestic sphere. The traditional feminine ideal is referred to as the “Yamato Nadeshiko.” Exemplifying the attributes of Filial Piety and Feudal Loyalty. Basically, a women needs to show special respect for men, especially older members, within the family and social structures (such as laws). The expectations for being a good Japanese woman show up in common sayings and even the structure of the language itself. Japanese sayings such as “Good Wife, Wise Mother” express that expectation. Even the Japanese word for “wife”, 家内(kanai), is made up of two kanji that literally mean “inside home.” This word is, now, politically incorrect.

The period after WWII saw a devastated Japan. The rebuilding of its economy and physical landscape was prioritized. The United States drafted the new Japanese constitution which completely dismantled the military. This restricted money flow to other industries which facilitated an increased economic recovery. However, the military was a governing structure for the conditioning of the ideal Japanese citizen. This open vacuum was filled by the school system. Essentially creating the modern 学連社会 (gakurenshakai), or school society, where the dutiful and successful student is the image of a successful Japanese adult. This helps strengthen an environment where the mother is a central figure in raising a successful student.

Amae 甘え: Interpretations of Dependency between “Mother-Son” Relationship (from a previous article here) The concept of “Amae” in Japanese culture can enlighten how the specific mother-son relationship functions within a Japanese cultural context. The literal translation of Amae is “lack of self-reliance” or “depending on others.” A basic understanding of the typical mother-son relationship in Japan is based on a child’s dependency to their mother. The child is viewed as an entity fully reliant on their mother. Their identity is manifested in their relationship with their mother and the mother, likewise, has her identity manifested in their motherhood. The mother is culturally expected to know and act on every need of a child. The child, in turn, is expected to completely rely on the mother. This is a fusional relationship that, unlike western concepts, grows instead of declines as the child grows up. A relationship of self-sacrificial interdependence. A typical child in America is expected to seek independence from their mother where a Japanese child grows interdependence with their mother. This is where we can see the Amae concept come into play both in infancy and adulthood. The seeing of “self” attached to someone else creates the implicit need for dependency on that individual. For more information read Lachkar, Joan. 2014. The Rising Power of Japanese Women: A Pop Culture Revolution. The Journal of Psychohistory. 41, no. 4: 301.

The Bento:

The bento is an iconic piece of Japanese culture and shows up in anime frequently. The bento usually contains rice, vegetables and some sort of protein with the food products inside the bento arranged in an artistic manner. The approach I’m using to analyzing the bento in looking at the mother-son relationship is to fashion the bento as a symbol. I mentioned the physical elements of the bento in the first few sentences but ironically the importance of the bento as a food item is overshadowed by its cultural implications often referenced in anime. Scholars have argued that the labor that goes into making the bento is a task that not only represents the woman herself but also is a symbolic representation of their prowess as a mother to a larger community of mothers. The reason I bring up the bento in exploring the mother-son relationship is because of how important the bento becomes in romantic relations between males and females in anime. The thinking, creation and, eventual, presentation of the bento to the male protagonist is an important step in their romantic involvement. These romantic situations involving the bento are connected to the mother-son relationship in two ways.

  1. The presentation of the bento shows that the female would be able to perform essential functions of motherhood, such as cooking. (Based on what they have seen from their mom)

  2. The bento represents a connection to warm feelings associated with their mother.

I argue that the subconscious implications of the bento in the mother-son relationship are worth exploring. For my first point, in a culture that encourages the values of domestic femininity, the presentation of female “motherhood” qualities such as cooking, cleaning and taking care of children is highly encouraged. Anime keeps to this line in exemplifying the positive values of domestic skills with females. In romantic anime, the connection between the male and female characters are strengthened from the acceptance of gender roles. Males work and females take care of the home. This is a broad generalization of anime I am aware but take a look at a majority of “typical” romantic and rom-com anime; it shows up more than you think. For my second point, the bento as a food object is just as closely related to the person who makes it. For a “typical” Japanese child, the bento is a creation of the mother. The bento has long been a food object connected with the laboring mother. To argue that the implications of the bento have a complete lack of association with the mother is to deny years of psychological connection between bento-mother. The bento is a symbol of the mother and as such resonates with some level of familiarity, especially when made by a female figure. Psychotherapist Elayne Savage says that, “…familiarity is a big reason people may choose someone like Mom or Dad as a partner. When you grow up familiar with a certain type of person, you're attracted to that same type of person because it feels comfortable, whether you like it or not…” The subconscious comfort found in a female figure that echoes familiarity represents, in this case, a strong connection with their mother.

Oedipus vs. Ajase Complex:

Discourse on psychoanalyzing the sexual urges of a child toward their mother typically rely on a Freudian Oedipus theoretical understanding. That being, a desire to get rid of the father to have all of the mother’s attention and love. Certainly, there is credibility in attempting to analyze repressed father anger in children. However, the underlying assumption of the Oedipus Complex is patriarchal (male based). The assumed tension revolves around the father over the mother’s affection. In a western context, this can be applied more successfully as the child is, more or less, expected to emulate his father. The father-son dynamic creates a competing need for the love of the mother. However, understanding the family dynamic from a Japanese cultural standpoint reveals more than that specific father-son competing dynamic. As discussed above, the cultural significance of Amae in the mother-son relationship creates a more matriarchal family dynamic. In contrast to a patriarchal based theory where the desire places significant importance to the male figure in the family, the matriarchal focus in a Japanese context shakes the dominance of Oedpius Complex in applicability. This argument against the Oedipus Complex is, however, not new. Heisaku Kosawa argued against the Oedipus Complex in 1931. The theory he proposed was the Ajase Complex. Based on a Buddhist myth, the Ajase Complex proposed a theory that aligned more with Japanese culture. The Ajase story is quoted below:

Ajase was the son of a king in India. His mother, fearing the loss of her youth and beauty, wanted to bear a child so she could retain her status. A prophet told her that a hermit who lived in the forest would be reborn as the king's son. The queen, however, wanted the child as soon as possible and killed the hermit, who then entered her womb. The child that she bore was named Ajase. Just before being slain, the hermit had told the queen that he would be reborn as her son and curse his father. The queen, fearful of what she had done, tried to abort and kill the baby, but she failed and Ajase survived. When Ajase grew up and learned the secret surrounding his birth, he became angry with the queen and attempted to slay her, but was dissuaded from this act by a minister. At that moment, Ajase was attacked by a severe guilt feeling and became afflicted with a dreadful skin disease characterized by so offensive an odor that no one dared approach him. Only his mother stood by and lovingly nursed him. Despite his mother's devoted care, Ajase did not readily recover. Seeking relief, the queen went to the Buddha and told him of her sufferings. The Buddha's teachings healed her inner conflict, and she returned to continue to care for her Ajase. Eventually, the Prince was cured to become a widely respected ruler.

Two major themes emerge from this story:

  1. The conflict does not lie with the father figure (king) but rather with the mother.

  2. Only after receiving forgiveness and care from his mother did Ajase recover.

The first point is interesting because the story relies on exploring the specific mother-son relationship. The king is mentioned but bears no weight to the prince’s eventual success. This is an important aspect to the way this story can be interpreted from a Japanese point of view. Heisaku Kosawa chose to use this story because it addressed a specifically Japanese concept. The reliance on the subjective dominance of Oedipus theory is malleable. The psychological interpretations of both Heisaku and Freud can be looked at in what they are specially trying to explain. Simply an eastern vs western thought process.
The second point addresses a major point of discussion above, the “amae” concept. The guilt/forgiveness aspect illustrates the essence of the mother-son dependence dynamic. Ajase’s hateful actions result in his downfall. His eventual surrender to his mother amongst his own reluctance drives home the point of the negative reality of self-dependence. When Ajase gives into his mother, he is eventually healed. Even more than that, he goes on to rule as a widely respected ruler. His reward for giving into his mother is physical well-being and success. Permitted and Prohibited Desires: Mother-Son Eroticism Moving forward from our previous section, let’s take a look at a “generic” mother-son hentai and explore what cultural implications we get some from it. First, let’s look at where the cultural “fad” of mother-son erotica hit its peak. Below is a quote from scholar Misty Bastian:

“In the 1980s a number of stories about mother-son incest were reported in the popular press in Japan. The elements of each were remarkably consistent: An adolescent male entering the period of intense study leading up to entrance exams is distracted by sexual desire. His mother, who has assumed the role of a kyoiku mama, notices the distraction and worries that it will obstruct the boy's work. To prevent this, she offers to become her son's lover and thereby satisfy his pressing need. The boy complies and the two commence an affair. The sexual relationship, found deeply pleasurable by both partners, quickly turns the boy into a model student. In the end the boy typically passes his exams and is appreciative to his mother for her help. The incest, however, does not end. Rather, the confusing relationship between man-woman and mother-son is left unresolved at the story's close.”

The eroticism of the scenario can be looked at multiple different angles. For this article I will focus on exploring the explosion of interest in the mother-son taboo from 3 angles.

  1. The cultural implications of the mother choosing to engage in the sexual relationship. As discussed above, I have argued the mothers expected place in the home with her identity being closely associated with her son’s success. If we take that stance on interpreting what her actions mean than we can better understand what she is trying to accomplish. The mother has an identity that finds success in her son’s success and her job is to do anything that can make that happen. The stories then create a “problem” concerning his uncontrollable sexuality. Now, we have a situation where a problem is interfering with their future success. As a mother, she needs to address this issue that will potentially destroy his future. Her actions to address the issue create a paradox. In addressing his rampant sexuality, she on one hand helps him remove his distraction and therefore succeed. But on the other, she violates all of the cultural rules of what’s expected of mothers. But Of course, this problem is blown out of proportion in multiple ways because the story is ultimately about showing erotic material but the base from which it is built is entrenched in expectations of both the hardworking student and the mother who is expected to help him succeed.

  2. Popularization of a cultural fantasy.

The popularization of mother-son incest in hentai has polarizing opinions to say the least. From high level traditionalists to low level students the opinions vary in range from congratulatory to sickening. Even in the late 1970’s early 80’s the situation and popular reporting of the issue was in a polarizing state. Status quo media commentators stressed the tragedy of incest culling from sources such as the Daiyaru Hinin Sodanshitsu (1979) a telephone counseling agency that publicized it was receiving calls of mother-son incest. However, a majority of the calls were suspected to be boys using incest as a fantasy. What, then, is fantasy? The fantasy I describe here is an idea connected yet disconnected from reality. A desire that exists outside of the normal reality from within which you exist. The popularity of the mother-son incest is not to be confused with a factual number of actual incestuous relations. Scholar Kakinuma argues that Japan has no more occurrences of incest than in other similar countries such as the United States. This fantasy of the mother-son incestuous relationship is a cultural fantasy which gained popularity due to its polarizing nature and, normally, unobtainable status.

3. The role of the non-existent father.

Finally, the issue not addressed is the role of the father. The father is many times left out of the mother-son incestuous dynamic because of his assumed role. In a strange way, the destruction of family values created by the incest is an action meant to help the boy become a productive member of society as discussed above. The father is merely a symbol of what the boy is to become. Conquering the mother is a way to both succeed his position as thus become him. The two points above argue more toward an Ajase Complex while this point is more Oedipus Complex because the two theories can be mutually compatible. The constant absence of the father is a critique on the salaryman expectation of the Japanese male. Ironically, the boy’s actions to replace him only continuous the same absent Japanese father.

TL;DR: Cultural standards in Japan made incest a very prominent and publicized fantasy.

Thanks for reading everyone. This one took forever to finish and I thank you guys for reading. There are references in my word file but they don't transfer to Reddit well. As always all comments are appreciated. (Even the dumb ones because they make me laugh)


r/TrueAnime • • Aug 20 '16

Different Ethics and Morality in Dubs/Subs: Boku no Hero Academia

72 Upvotes

Spoilers Ho!

As much as I defend certain dubs, there is an issue particular to them that everyone should be aware of. It proliferates to subs too, though usually to a lesser extent.

Comparing the scene in Boku no Hero Academia where All Might takes on the Nomu (Ep 12 ~16:00): In the climax of the Japanese dub, he says (sorry for romaji, haven't installed Japanese on new comp): "Hero to wa sudeni pinch wo buchikowashiteku mono" [A hero is such [a concept/person] that they can bust out of a dire situation] followed by: "Villain-yo, konna kotoba o shitteruka? Sara ni mukou e - Plus Ultra!" [Villain-dude, do you know of these words? 'You must strive to go beyond' - Plus Ultra!].

This is different than the English dub, in which he says: "A real hero will always find a way for justice to be served!" followed by "Now, for a lesson. You may have heard these words before, but I'll teach you what they really mean, go beyond - Plus Ultra!"

The differences might seem minor, but they have significant implications. The reference to justice in the English dub paints All Might as a punitive enforcer: someone who uses violence to see that the scales are balanced. The point of that scene was to showcase an argument between Shigaraki's view (all authorities are fascist violence peddlers) and All Might's (force can be used exclusively to protect innocents). This point is lost if All Might preaches about justice - because he is supposed to be a character who lives to help people, not punish them.

For an easier example Japanese All Might shares motivations with Flash, English All Might shares them with Batman. English All Might is likely to say "criminal scum", Japanese All Might is likely to say "you guys just don't get it".

The second phrase change in the dub is even more important. The original Boku no Hero Academia is a reconstruction of superhero tropes. It specifically avoids painting its protagonists as zealous enforcers of "right" and "wrong". The villains don't lose because the narrative favors heroes, they lose because they're miserable and misjudge other people to be just as miserable as they are. So, when English All Might says, in essence, "let me teach you what real effort looks like", he's just being a bully with the powers the author gave him - showing Shigaraki that his machinations are doomed to fail because All Might is just that tough. The implication in the English dub is that All Might is just a big strong man and you can't beat big strong men, especially when JUSTICETM is on their side!

...Of course the Japanese dub paints a wholly different picture. Boku no Hero Academia is a reconstruction - its characters aren't just heroic, they consciously choose to act like comic-book superheroes. Many of them for profit/fame but, some, like All Might, for the sake of public well-being. When Japanese All Might says "you must strive to go beyond", he means that people should endeavor to achieve ideals. His massive strength is reflective of his ethical commitment to peace and protection, not beating up criminals. When Japanese All Might punches the nomu into starspace, it's a physical metaphor for his insurmountable devotion to helping people. When English All Might does it, it's showing his devotion to hurting them (albeit "evil" ones).

Consider, also, the nobility of a single person pursuing a personal truth (altruism), versus someone fighting on behalf of a national ideal (justice).

This grievance might not be as apparent to anime-only viewers, but there is a mountain of evidence in the forthcoming story as to how grossly inaccurate the characterization is. I doubt this was intentional on the dubber's part, but that it is United States' cultural values being projected onto the work via script translation. Not to say that 'Japanese culture isn't extremely anti-criminal' - but Boku no Hero Academia is notable for not being that way.

Some people who read this might be anti-criminal, pro-justice, etc. That's not my grievance - it's that the meaning of the work has been changed and now goes along with what a general audience expects from their entertainment instead of saying something unusual but morally significant. Compare and contrast early Naruto (everyone has psychological scars) vs later Naruto (super explosion no bloodline jutsu).

It happens in a lot of translations, but I really like BnHA, so it motivated me to write this out :(


r/TrueAnime • • Aug 29 '21

What do you think of people who hate Anime?

71 Upvotes

So I went to this small forum page dedicated to the hate for weeaboos and anime itself. I asked why they hate anime so much and to my surprise, they were actually very reasonable and they're arguments given were understandable.

Most of what I've seen from that page and other forums/sites for reasons for the hate were:

  1. Weeaboos (And I mean REAL weebs, not the insult thrown at actually anime fans)

  2. They think it's weird (The weird shows with sexulized minors seemed to be the ones hated the most)

  3. They think the art style is weird (I believe they're referring specifically to the art style used in shōjo)

Even when they found out (at least I think most of them did) that I myself am an anime fan, they didn't bludgeon me with "kys weeb" insults and were very insightful, and I wanted to know what people here think of people like that.

Note: For the love of all that is holy, DON'T go to any these sites/forums and harass any of the people there, but that should be obvious and pretty sure everyone here knows better.