Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zQO1vX7ofyU
Rough Transcript: -You're going to see a lot of flat out wrong information from Western sources and even Japanese sources on how anime and otaku culture in general transitioned from one trend to another, and the otaku subculture followed suit. Most of these sources are at best ignorant to the intricacies and deeper implications of the otaku trends and the value systems behind them and at worst have nefarious intentions to destroy otaku culture and the integrity of the media itself.
-Here, I want to shed just a little bit of light on the truth of otaku trends and meaning behind them from the 60's to the 00's, from a very broad overview. I will discuss these trends in greater detail as well as the unique nature of the current decade in follow up talks.
-It's absolutely crucial for people to have an accurate understanding of otaku history so that they can properly understand the value system behind it, and people like Gigguk are completely screwing over the information on this subject, making people come to false conclusions and painting otaku media as something it isn't.
-When it comes to otaku history, the big elephant in the room is the one major trend shift that stands out from the little ones: the establishment of "moe" as a thing and the establishment of "moe" as the face of anime. I have addressed this topic slightly in the past, but now I can truly address the topic.
-But before I begin, I must point out how absolutely garbage the other anitubers' address of this topic is. Look far, look wide and all you will see is people pretending to know what they're talking about here. Gigguk's video "The Moe Anime Revolution" is one of the worst examples I've ever seen. And at the end of the video he literally says "It's videos like these that require the most time, research, and resources." You mean Wikipedia, dude? The sad thing is you'll get similar nonsense no matter where you look. Even Digibro who can at least claim more passion and investment into otaku culture than his peers couldn't sound dumber when he talks about this subject. He said something like how Kyoto Animation and A-1 pictures "cracked the code" on doing cute girl shows and then a bunch of similar crap followed or something. In other words pretty much the same erroneous shit Gigguk was saying. Did they read the same retarded article or something? Even Patrick Galbraith, who has been in the subculture way longer than these other tools and is really invested in the subject says extremely misleading crap, as he accurately points out the nuances and intricacies of the way that infatuation and preoccupation with 2d girls has basically always been a thing with the otaku but then goes on to draw incomplete or inaccurate conclusions. But at least he can get the chronology of his trends right.
-Getting back to otaku history, while each decade and semi-decade is significant and unique in its own right, nevertheless, otaku history can be divided into two overarching eras: the first era is what I call the "Liberal Era" and the second era is what I call the "Conservative Era." Please forget about the political connotation of these words for a moment and think about these words from a more sociocultural perspective. The Liberal Era marks everything before the early 00's, arguably peaking in expression in the 80's, while the Conservative Era marks everything in and after the early 00's, arguable peaking in the mid 00's.
-Now, to define these eras, I will start by describing the Liberal Era. These are the main traits I will ascribe to the Liberal Era: A more "earthly" aesthetic affinity. What I mean by that, is that we can define two archetypal classes of aesthetics: "earthly" and "heavenly." Earthly aesthetic is defined by a closer adherence to things as they are in the real world, embracing the organic disorganization that occurs in nature. Heavenly aesthetic is defined by a closer adherence to things as they exist in an abstracted ideal, embracing a level of organization and deliberate arrangement of details that would never normally exist in nature. One obvious factor that gives the Liberal Era a more earthly affinity is simply the analog tools with which the anime was produced, as opposed to the digital tools used later. Now, that is not to say there wasn't plenty of "heavenly" aesthetic affinity in the Liberal Era, it just wasn't dominant.
Next trait: more "diverse" casts. And now again, don't think of that in the modern connotation of the word. Just simply think of it in terms of a higher variation among character designs.
The next notable trait is a higher acceptance of change or a lack of tenacity for tradition. Tropes and archetypes weren't so solidified and demanded over and over again. Everything was a little more liquid and in flux.
Something extremely noteworthy about this era is the way that it frequently took blatant and bold influence from the works of the West. In fact, it's actually more difficult to find a work from this era that doesn't boldly state influence from Western works. This trait is actually the product of all the above traits. It is the result of a willingness to leave the home and explore the world as a whole. The Liberal Era marks the dominance of the Type-A Otaku, which I have described along with its peer, the Type-B Otaku in previous talks.
-Now on to the Conservative Era. These are the main traits I will ascribe to it:
A more "heavenly" aesthetic affinity. Moe is actually the main reflection of this, but it can be seen in the general aesthetic sensibilities of everything, even the writing.
Less diverse casts. This can apply to both the scope of a single work or the industry as a whole.
A tenacity for tradition. This means that character archetypes and story tropes as well as themes are going to be repeated consistently throughout completely different works.
And of course, less influence from works outside of otaku media itself. This is often what people to refer to as "stylistic inbreeding" or a synonym. This reflects a desire to keep the value system free of outside influences that could corrupt it.
-Now, there are probably several factors for why the Liberal Era gave way to the Conservative Era, but I can tell you what absolutely is not a reason yet is often cited as a reason by fools and malicious parties: the idea that moe is some cheat code for producing good sales. Marketing is not part of the equation here. Anyone more familiar with the industry understands that even to this day, trends in the otaku market are extremely grassroots-influenced unlike non-otaku media which is funded by infinite money and relies on the brainwashing of the masses. If there is a trend shift in the otaku market, it is because the otaku themselves asked for it.
-One factor that I know is very important to the equation here is actually the Western nerd. Now, I don't much about the Western nerd, considering it was essentially an utterly mutated subculture by the time I was a teenager, not to mention that Western media never really appealed to me for the most part with the exception of some Western video games from the 80's and 90's. But as I mentioned there was a time when the Japanese otaku and Western nerd actually had a good bit in common. That was the 70's and 80's. This is reflected in both the depictions of the otaku from those decades as well as in the interest sets of people who were considered otaku back then.
-Now, as I've been saying, the otaku transformed, gradually moving from the Liberal Era to the Conservative Era, which completed its manifestation probably around 2002 or so. But the Western nerd was the exact opposite. According to the series on the history of the nerd by The Distributist, the Western nerd of the 80's identified with a "liberal" label. Now, like the otaku of the same period, this didn't necessarily mean "politically liberal," although I believe it often did for the Western nerd. So, like two children that can be friends when they're young, but move apart as they get older, the Western nerd and the Japanese otaku split from one another, the Western nerd becoming increasingly liberal while the Japanese otaku becomes increasingly conservative. In retrospect, this split is fairly intuitive, as Western works never showed the consistent devotion to the ideals that the otaku works displayed. Beauty is the most obvious one here, as otaku works have always been highly concerned with the level of grace, beauty, and appeal with which they display (really) anything but especially characters, eventually culminating in the tradition being solidified under the term "moe." Western works never had this priority, with many of them acquiescing or even promoting ugliness and crudeness. The chasm that formed between the value system of the otaku and nerd was undoubtedly a large factor in inspiring otaku to tighten their borders and only deal domestically, as nerd works no longer provided one of the main incentives for otaku to look outward.
-Now, in Hiroki Azuma's book, he brings up the economic boom of the 80's and how the otaku, and perhaps the country in general, felt like they were at the forefront of progress at that point in time. There's no doubt in my mind that the economic crash of the 90's played a role in inspiring conservative values among otaku. Do not confuse this for Azuma's framing of the economic crash's influence, as I can confidently assert that he is wrong. Hiroki Azuma states, and is often aped by other people trying to sound smart such as Digibro, that the economic crash led the industry to start "playing it safe" and make low-risk works that aren't creatively bold. Due to the nature of the otaku market's trends being dominated by grassroots motivations, Azuma's claim cannot be true. He is ignoring the genuine ideological shift to more conservative concerns, which seek to coagulate and traditionalize that which best expresses their value system. These aren't big money organizations studying data to figure out the best product to put out. Otaku products are almost always put out by otaku themselves, sometimes simply to break even. There is an excerpt in the Moe Manifesto book where economist Morinaga Takuro explains the way that otaku products are made simply because people want to make them. (Article excerpt: https://i.imgur.com/aLmZaJO.jpg) Economic hardship will always inspire conservative, protective values in those who want to improve things, and the otaku simply changed their art to reflect these values.
-There was, of course, additional national scares such as the Kobe earthquake and whatnot which may have had a hand in inspiring more conservative intentions as well.
-Now, those are national influences, but what about influences within the otaku subculture itself? This is a subject that people fail miserable to get their information accurate on. No, it wasn't Kyoto Animation that changed everything or even Evangelion that changed everything and created this big market demand, blah, blah, blah... The conservative otaku value set could be found littered throughout works as far back as the 80's and possibly sooner, but they really started to coagulate in the video game scene, especially the gal game scene of the 90's. Now, while the absolute morons will rattle off the whole Evangelion, Haruhi, K-On trinity, the smarter folk will tell you about Tokimeki Memorial and how it was the first gal game to achieve something close to mainstream success, bringing this kind of conservative otaku aesthetic more to the forefront of the subculture. But the thing is, that it wasn't Tokimeki Memorial that influenced the trends. Tokimeki Memorial got popular because of the trends. Yes, it was technically a Konami game, and yes, it was ported to all the popular game consoles, but that alone doesn't make something go into high demand. The otaku were taking on these interests and Tokimeki was simply a way to satisfy these interests. Evangelion, and Kyoto Animation were the same thing. Hey Gigguk, did you not notice that Key's games were already famous among anime fans before Kyoto Animation even adapted one of them?
-Now, something that I have never seen addressed is another important role that video games played in shaping the otaku, specifically, the generation 2 otaku who were mostly active in the late 90's and 00's, pioneering the Conservative Otaku Era. Unlike the generation 0 otaku and generation 1 otaku, the generation 2 otaku grew up playing games. And I don't mean just playing games a little. Generation 1 played games a little. I mean religiously playing video games. Jun Maeda loved games and only ended up writing gal games because other game companies were too hard to get a job at. Ryukishi07 derived both his name and one of his famous heroine's name from Final Fantasy V. Obviously Zun loved games. Kinoko Nasu loved games. Nagaru Tanigawa loved games. I'd bet you that's it's damn near impossible to find an influential creator from the Conservative Otaku Era who didn't grow up with video games playing a vital role in shaping their outlook on the world. So why is this significant? It's because the video games they played inherently instilled conservative values into their minds. I mean, right from Donkey Kong for the arcade you play as a dude trying to get his girl back from a minority trying to rape her. That, my friend, is a conservative game. These games inherently conditioned conservative values into those who played them because they almost always dealt with themes such as invasion and protection and depicted masculine valor defeating plotting evil.
In Metroid, you literally genocide a parasitic invading species.
In Pokemon, you live in a prosperous ethnostate with a low enough crime rate for a young boy to travel around on his own.
In Dracula X, you fight a blood-sucking moneylender.
In Megaman, you fight a quantum physicist.
In Sonic the Hedgehog, you fight a Bolshevik, who tricks minorities into unwittingly acting for his agenda.
In Starfox, you fight a shapeshifting Saturn cube.
In Final Fantasy 7, you fight a Canaanite with a god complex.
In Final Fantasy 1, you fight a man who sneakily abused the system to obtain infinite power and became Chaos itself.
The list goes on. Many of these games had a strong or dominant amount of the Type-A Otaku aesthetic, but they all still blatantly condition conservative values into their players. Additionally, some popular games were even already pretty good reflections of what would become the main conservative, Type-B Otaku aesthetic such as the Tales of series.
-I hope you can see that the truth is much more complex and rewarding than some assholes have been making it out to be. It is absolutely vital to understand the past if we are to understand the present and move forward. Otaku will save the world, but first we must understand ourselves.