r/tolstoy • • Jun 29 '26

I can’t finish Anna Karenina

1 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong, the writing is beautiful, but the storyline itself is not so amazing. I want to finish it and get it over with. I’m on page 739/924 (part 6, chapter XXVIII) but I’m so done with it. Is it going to get better?
UPDATE: nvm i just didnt understand it. i love it now! def going to reread it!


r/tolstoy • • Jun 07 '26

Anyone else think Tolstoy is a little woo woo? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Very light spoilers on War and Peace ahead -

I’m almost done listening to the audio book and can’t help but think Tolstoy is a little woo woo. His musings on death and returning to this source of infinite love struck me as a very spiritually agnostic take, even though he’s doing it through the lens of christianity. Pierre’s journey for example - he seemed to have a sort of kundalini awakening as a POW that, upon returning to life after the war, gave him a very strong sense of his inner intuition. He suddenly knows what to do because he’s tapped into that omnipotent source power. Prince Andrei goes through this too, first while laying on the battlefield and feeling that yearning to be absorbed into the feeling of infinite abundant love, and later in the days before his death, he undergoes a “change” that reads a lot like a third-eye opening nirvana. Of course Natasha is also similarly transformed by that experience.

Anyway just a silly lens to view it through being a little woo woo myself. I have absolutely loved this book and laughed and cried the whole way through.


r/tolstoy • • Dec 24 '24

Defenders of War and Peace's epilogue.

0 Upvotes

Are there people around here that actually unironically defend the ending pseudo philosophy bad essay writing at the end of War and Peace or is it something we all chuckle about when someone like me comes along?


r/tolstoy • • Sep 21 '23

I can't get into Anna Karenina

2 Upvotes

I'm on the part where Anna confess his love for vrosky and it seems so fake, pretentious, how can this love happen when they both haven't even been together? For this reason I can't seem to get into Anna karenina eh.


r/tolstoy • • Jun 04 '25

Question was tolstoy vegan towards the end of their life?

0 Upvotes

just been mulling over contradictory comments i've heard about tolstoy. I've heard many in the anarchist vegan community refer to them as solely a vegetarian but the tolstoy wiki page says this:

>"Whilst on his vegetarian diet, Tolstoy was eating eggs daily but was questioned by one of his friends if eating eggs amounts to taking life. He commented that "Yes, I ought to have stopped taking eggs. At least from now I shall stop it".[99] By 1903, Tolstoy had removed eggs from his diet. Vasily Rozanov who had visited Tolstoy noted that vegetarianism was a way of living for Tolstoy and at the dinner table surrounded by family and guests who were eating meat and scrambled eggs, Tolstoy was eating kasha.[100] In a letter to A. D. Zutphen (a Dutch medical student), Tolstoy wrote that "My health not only has not suffered; it has in fact improved significantly since I have given up milk, butter and eggs, as well as sugar, tea, and coffee."[96] Tolstoy described his vegetarian diet consisting of oatmeal porridge, whole wheat bread, cabbage or potato soup, buckwheat, a boiled or fried potato and an apple prune compote.[101]"

Anyone have a clue whether tolstoy was vegetarian or vegan at the end of their life? from the above it sounds like they were vegan for maybe over a half decade, which would be insanely cool.


r/tolstoy • • Jun 30 '23

Best way to experience War and Peace without reading it

1 Upvotes

I know, I know, I should just read it. But it's 1000 pages long (literally) with one consensus best translation against which the rest all apparently pale in comparison. But it's also the rarest and most expensive translation of the lot (to find in bookstores/libaries/etc) and apparently has tons of footnotes and whatnot you need to read in order to get a sense of the setting. I don't have unlimited free time and I do have ADHD, so reading the entire book is pretty much out of the question, as amazing as it may be. I've heard the Bondarchuk movie is great, but then there's also a very highly acclaimed miniseries, there's a King Vidor movie, etc. Even if I need to watch multiple things I'd like to see it anyhow. What's the best way if the book isn't an option?


r/tolstoy • • Oct 19 '25

An unpopular opinion. Tolstoy was not an artist in the traditional sense.

0 Upvotes

I call an artist a creator who gives form to material, clothes to thoughts. Therefore: the more beautiful the form-clothing, the bolder the thought, the greater the creator, the more universal the work. In Tolstoy's work, everything is accurately depicted, everything is real, as if seen through a window. There is no stormy genius here, no rushing, attacks and takeoffs, it is calm and objective. Much is forged here, smoothed, chiseled, planed, but everywhere it is well planed. But you will not notice any care in his work, objectivity is maintained throughout. In his prose, everything is eternally unchanging, as if life itself had made it. "The Death of Ivan Ilyich", "Three Men", "How Much Land Does a Man Need" can be read now, they could have been read before Christ. Here is not the spirit of the era, but the primordial unchanging soul of humanity, drowning in eternity.

Everywhere in his works,life is boiling: whether in the church of "Resurrection" or in the nature scenes of "The Cossacks". Tolstoy learned nothing from his art. His works are like eternally solid rocks, in which not even his own personality is left, it has dissolved in them. Therefore, in my opinion, due to this brilliant realism of his, he cannot be called an artist in the traditional sense, like Goethe, for example, because you will not find fictional things in his work, he does not arouse in us either fantasy, inspiration, desires, or superiority. He does not show anything superhuman, but is the embodiment of everything earthly. He is not distinguished by any poetic gifts, he has the same human powers, only he can expand them to infinity. His work is a discourse about reality. And this discourse is amazingly powerful. However, this is not true art, this is realism.


r/tolstoy • • Sep 23 '26

Do you think I should read/buy "Anna Karenina" by Leo Tolsoy?

9 Upvotes

So I don't read very often. I've read some Agatha Christie novels, a book from Murakami called Killing Commendatore and some other books like "Never let me go", ... (I haven't read much lol)

Now, someone recommended the book "Anna Karenina" to me, written Leo Tolstoy, and said I should buy it and read it. But before I do that I wanted to know some opinions about it. Is it good/bad? Is it worth reading/buying?

(NO SPOILERS PLS)

(P.S I've also noticed there is a film with Keira Knightley called Anna Karenina which I would assume is based on the book -> should I watch that first?)

(Sorry for my terrible English)


r/tolstoy • • Sep 08 '24

The love of Anna Karenina Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Why do many people say that Anna Karenina is the story of a brave woman who dared to stand up to the hypocrisy of society and yet received a cruel punishment? In fact, the book is about the moral decline of a young noble lady. Who seems perfect at the beginning of the book, but succumbs to the worst form of love, forgetting all her responsibilities as a wife and mother. And finally, she kills herself under the influence of drugs to cause suffering to her beloved, as his passion fades, and her selfish love mixes with hatred, and she herself does not want to accept the fact that suffering is an inseparable part of life. To me, this seems like a warning that free love will not bring happiness.


r/tolstoy • • Aug 15 '26

Book discussion Unpopular Opinion: Anna Karenina is insufferable and Levin is a massive hypocrite.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/tolstoy • • Sep 18 '26

What do you think of this quote from Tolstoy about there being only two types of stories in all great literature?

1 Upvotes

"All great literature is one of two stories; a man goes on a journey or a stranger comes to town. "

I have often thought about this quotation from Tolstoy without being able to come to any conclusion about its universality. What does this sub think?

Edit; Looks like I misattributed this quote to Tolstoy. I remember reading somewhere about this being a Tolstoy quote and never verified its antecedents. Please excuse me.


r/tolstoy • • Aug 24 '25

The art of Tolstoy and Dostoevsky. Their fundamental difference.

10 Upvotes

Tolstoy's work goes in the direction of the body, Dostoevsky's in the direction of the spirit. They go as far as Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo had just reached. The only similarity between Dostoevsky's work and Tolstoy's work is that, going in opposite directions, they finally meet, as two travelers would meet, one going from east to west and the other from west to east. Their meeting is possible only in eternity, and the fruit of this meeting would be a new union of man as body and spirit.

Tolstoy's heroes are victims. Man does not go to his final completion, but drowns in the elements of nature. There are no tragedies here, there are only separate tragic knots, without a unifying end. No beginning, no middle, no end. Dostoevsky's man, a personality rising from darkness to spiritual heights. That man of the third dimension, a measure to a depth whose end you will never reach. In Dostoevsky's novels, one can feel the struggle of heroic will with the spirit of moral duty, as Raskolnikov does, the struggle with the element of passions, which is expressed in Svidrigailov. Only in that struggle does a person's inner "I" remain intact, and is even more pronounced. All of Dostoevsky's heroes seem to strain the last forces of their will and declare their self-will.

Tolstoy is a true epic, calm, objective, straightforward, Dostoevsky is sensitive, impressive, the formulator of dialogues is a tragic. You will feel art in Tolstoy's story, inaccuracy in dialogues. Dostoevsky's story is uneven, tiring, but the dialogue is incomparable. Tolstoy is a genius when he speaks himself, Dostoevsky - when he lets others speak. Tolstoy's hero hears when you see Tolstoy applying a brush, Dostoevsky's heroes see when you hear them speaking.

Tolstoy's work is a boundless ocean, you can't swim anywhere, you can't stop anywhere, everywhere is the center, everywhere is equally important. Dostoevsky's work is a triangle. Everything is irresistibly approaching the final point from a wide base. There is nothing superfluous and nothing that would interfere or be more important than our only center of attention.

Tolstoy's heroes are so corporeal, they simply smell like animals, Dostoevsky's heroes are incorporeal, of one spirit, their feet do not reach the ground.

In Tolstoy, there is neither good nor bad, everything is equally important, Dostoevsky's bad is always translated into good. The cloudy weather suddenly bursts into a rain of repentance and after the storm a bright refreshing sun of joy appears. Tolstoy's sky gradually becomes more and more gloomy. We are waiting for a storm, but there is still no storm. The weather is heavy, without mountains, without freedom.

Tolstoy's speed of action is always the same, without haste or stops. The speed of Dostoevsky's action is finally increasing and it seems that everything is irresistibly approaching destruction.

Tolstoy's people are rational, Dostoevsky's are already rational and carry out the action.

Tolstoy's people feel the passions of the body, and Dostoevsky's people the passions of the mind, of thought. Tolstoy's man is drawn to his true path by passions, Dostoevsky's man by passions of thought prompts him to rebel.

Only here is where the paths of Dostoevsky and Tolstoy coincide. Both of them torture their heroes. Tolstoy allows nature to torture man physically, Dostoevsky allows conscience to castrate man for his evil deeds. In this they are similar.

Tolstoy is a painter, a plasterer, a sculptor, Dostoevsky is a chemist, a laboratory technician, the head of the witches' kitchen. Tolstoy gropes the body - Dostoevsky the soul.

Tolstoy never lies, with him everything is true, real, with Dostoevsky you don't know where reality begins and where it ends.

Both maintain ties with religion: one with the religion of the God-beast, the other with the Christian religion.

Tolstoy is too earthly, having deified the body, Dostoevsky is too spiritual, having embodied the spirit. Tolstoy is static, Dostoevsky is dynamic; Tolstoy is epic, Dostoevsky is tragic; Tolstoy is a vertical, Dostoevsky is a horizontal line. One went towards the body and almost reached the spirit, the other went towards the spirit and almost reached the body. If it weren't for this almost, they would have discovered each other in infinity and, combining these two opposites, would have formed the value of the zenith point - man. How far they were from the goal, only those who dare to follow their paths and continue the directions they started will be able to say.


r/tolstoy • • Jun 22 '25

Why do people like Anna Karenina??

23 Upvotes

I have slogged all the way to page 700+ and I still don’t understand the hype.

Trying to get through this book has taken me months because I’m so disinterested. The only reason I keep going is because everyone reveres it as the ‘greatest book of all time’ so I figured I’d strike gold at this point in the story.

The only part I’ve really liked so far was Levin working in the field with the peasants. That’s it.

I have read many Russian novels so I am used to the pace, subject matter and even the history, but this book just ain’t it.

Maybe it’s just Tolstoy. I feel like his psychological prowess is immensely overblown; it is nothing compared to someone like Dostoevsky.

I don’t really care about any of his characters. Kitty is annoying, Anna is unstable and also annoying, etc. etc.

Someone please explain why they like it


r/tolstoy • • Feb 10 '26

Does Tolstoy make you sad for what Russia could have been?

0 Upvotes

Reading a Tolstoy book like War and Peace or AK Russia seems “ splendid!” Jt is a land full of ladies lords grand balls and magnificent churches.

It almost makes me sad to realize that within about 50 years of the average Tolstoy’s book all the people he writes about, Levin, Anna K, Pierre, Dmititri etc would have been wiped out or forced to flee the hideous Bolsheviks.

Do you ever sort of longingly wonder what Russia might have been if the revolution didn’t happen? If the Russia thay produced Tolstoy was permitted to flourish and endure? Might that Russia have been amazing and not horrid as the USSR was?


r/tolstoy • • Feb 03 '23

Can literature be a major reason or triggering element of fear or jealousy to start a war?If so kindly explain how and why. NSFW

0 Upvotes

r/tolstoy • • May 11 '26

Struggling with reading Anna Karenina because of Vronsky and Anna

28 Upvotes

I’m currently at the part where Anna tells Vronsky she’s pregnant, and honestly I absolutely hate both of them as characters.

I understand the nuance. I understand Anna is stuck in a loveless marriage, feels emotionally trapped. But I personally can never get behind infidelity, so it’s making the entire situation difficult for me to invest in.

Vronsky especially annoys me. He's your classic vain playboy who’s used to admiration and acts impulsively without considering the consequences. Poor Kitty (ofc the fault lies with her and her mom too)

And Anna’s avoidant behavior toward her husband especially when he tries to warn her after the party is just frustrating.

Anna and Vronsky are selfish hedonists who are prioritizing desire over everyone around them. Maybe, I am reducing them to some one dimensional caricatures with that sentence but that's how they've come across to me as for now.

I generally hate cheating tropes in fiction, so maybe this book was always going to be a challenge for me. On top of that, there are moments where the novel feels misogynistic or sexist in ways that leave a bad taste in my mouth.

What keeps me going is Tolstoy’s writing itself. It's brilliant. Also, the social dynamics and psychological observations are incredible (I really like Levin as a character!!) But emotionally, I’m struggling because I actively dislike spending time with Anna and Vronsky characters.

For people who’ve read it:

  1. Does the story become more psychologically compelling even if you dislike them?

2)Is it worth pushing through if the cheating aspect is already bothering me this much?

No spoilers please.


r/tolstoy • • Jul 08 '26

Question How do I read this?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Tryna read the death of Ivan ilyich but I can’t tell what’s page 2,3,4 etc


r/tolstoy • • Aug 03 '23

Sorry to gatekeep but PragerU has no business with Anna Karenina

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/tolstoy • • Feb 09 '25

The Kreutzer Sonata ruined Tolstoy for me

25 Upvotes

as a female i was disgusted reading this story. but it’s not even about the “deed” (trying to be spoiler free), and i’m usually unfazed by misogyny in 19th c novels, it’s not exactly shocking that women were considered property, let’s take that as a given. that’s why initially i found the conversations among this man and the other passengers on the train interesting, and i was curious to hear of his thinking behind his views, and his life experience that clearly shaped them, more so than the female passenger’s idealistic (perhaps naive, perhaps pure) view on love.

BUT to me the story becomes truly unbearable when the man opens up in private. i was ready to accept his view, even if i may not have agreed, maybe he went through a profound experience in his life but no, there was nothing redeeming about the man, it was just out of pathetic jealousy, selfishness, no sign of remorse or repentance, he probably wept at the end convinced that he’s still a victim. this is what repulsed me the most, and the story really failed me. and it’s hard to convince myself tolstoy did not share this view. i will continue reading his works, but i will continue to hate this one.


r/tolstoy • • Dec 21 '25

Ukraine relevance

0 Upvotes

Tolstoy's relevance to Russian invasion of Ukraine via Alexis Vinogradov

"...The bells will ring and Russian people will dress in golden clothes and begin to pray for the murders. And an old, terrible thing that has long been known to everyone will begin. People will fuss under the guise of patriotism, will fuss all sorts of officials, anticipating the possibility of stealing more money, the military will fuss, receiving double wages for killing people. They will receive ribbons, crosses, braids and stars. They will drown out their souls with songs, debauchery, vulgarity and vodka. They will be cut off from peaceful labor, from their wives, mothers, children. They will chill, starve, get sick, die of illness on the battlefields, killing people of whom they will never they did not see and did not know that they did nothing bad. And when thousands of Russian sick, wounded and killed, there will be no one to pick up from the fields, and when the air is already infected with cannon fodder, they will somehow be wounded and dumped in heaps. The dead will be buried as if they were sprinkling their bodies with lime. And again they will lead the crowd of savages further, and they will become furious and become completely wild. Love will move away from the actions of barbarians for tens and hundreds of years. And again they will say that war was necessary and future generations will become accustomed to this thought, thereby corrupting their souls and hearts..."

Л.Н.Толстой. "Christianity and Patriotism"


r/tolstoy • • Sep 16 '24

Help with an assignment on Tolstoy

1 Upvotes

Hi! I am an english literature student. I have been asked to analyze two short stories of Tolstoy. Can someone help me out with two stories that have some similar theme/idea that I can explore for my assignment?


r/tolstoy • • Oct 12 '26

Anna Karenina is a horrible person and so is the love interest Vronsky and her husband was actually nice—as far as I've read(Part 2 Chapter 9) (Spoilers ahead?) Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/tolstoy • • Oct 20 '22

What would you say are Tolstoy's best works?

0 Upvotes

How would you rank his major works essentially(War and Peace, Anna Karenina, Resurrection, The Death of Ivan Illych, Kreutzer Sonata, etc)


r/tolstoy • • May 03 '26

Accurate Pierre depiction imo

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Created by ai


r/tolstoy • • Jun 22 '26

Book discussion heard that war and peace is a bore

0 Upvotes

So, I'm a Tolstoy fan, through and through. When I say that, I mean that I loved Anna Karenina notwithstanidng that one farming sequence (iykyk), and I think it to be one of the most perfect representations of society. I also read one of his religious compilations (confessions), where he goes into depth regarding his unique approach to christianity. He considers himself a Christian, but the archetype of traditional christianity does not align with his own, so idk if he really is a christian (apology for the digression but that is a another topic for another time).

I also recently finished Resurrection but honestly thought much of it was a bore. Regarding other books that I read and enjoyed, I loved C&P and Brothers K and the idiot from Dostoevsky. Brothers K is my favorite book of all time. These were absolutely excellent books. Notes from the Underground was absolutely trash though and I couldn't even finish it.

Just wanted to give a brief history of my likes and dislikes within the realm of Russian literature in an effort to ascertain whether War and Peace would be something that would fit within my interests. I love long books, but am not a big fan of war sequences (which I've heard war and peace is rife with).

So, based on what I've said, do you guys think war and peace would be a good read based on your experience with it? lmk