r/tnvisa • • Sep 20 '25

Miscellaneous BREAKING: New H1-B visa petitions are now subject to a $100,000 fee to be paid annually by the employer. Will Canadians be the new H1B for US employers?

314 Upvotes

https://www.ctvnews.ca/world/article/trump-signs-proclamation-imposing-100k-annual-fee-for-h-1b-visa-applications/

An Executive Order was just signed by President Trump implementing a new $100,000 annual fee for every H1-B petition filed by an employer in the United States.

I think this might redirect the attention of employers in the US towards TN status/visas for Canadian and Mexican nationals. What do you guys think? Assuming this EO survives guaranteed incoming litigation, will TN be the new H1-B?


r/tnvisa • • Jan 21 '25

Miscellaneous TN Visa to Greencard in 3.5 Years AMA

278 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I have recently received my green card after adjusting straight from my TN visa. I plan to write a lengthy post on the topic with a full breakdown of timelines etc. in the future because it would be helpful for many readers :)

But in the meantime, I'm happy to answer any questions anyone has.

Here is some quick info: I work as a SWE. Born in Canada. Eb3 Category, adjusted in the US via I-485. It took me ~3.5 years to get the GC from starting work. I did not switch to H1B. I did not get a combo card, got EAD and AP separately. I was able to renew my TN before applying for my I-485

EDIT: I have made another post with full timeline: https://www.reddit.com/r/tnvisa/comments/1ifchr2/tn_visa_to_green_card_in_3_years_4_months_and_7/


r/tnvisa • • Feb 01 '25

Miscellaneous TN visa to Green Card In 3 years, 4 months, and 7 days, AMA

Post image
243 Upvotes

r/tnvisa • • Jan 02 '26 Polished Gold Turd This

Miscellaneous Regret waiting so long to move to the US.

192 Upvotes

Edit: Some people asked about the Green card process, normally for L1s it's I140(premium processing available) then EB1C - which is usually current. Compared to other paths this is quite quick.

In my case I had a US citizen spouse and kids so our lawyer just filed the I130 and I1485 since you are much less likely to get an RFE when you have a US spouse/kids.

Edit 2: Never expected all these bitter comments from the elbows up cbc types. Wtf are you doing on this sub? This isn't r/Canada..f off with your Canada is so great bs .


This is for anyone who’s on the fence.

I moved to the U.S. on an L-1 almost two years ago. I’m now a permanent resident, and honestly, it already feels like home.

My only regret is waiting so long. I had no idea how straightforward an intercompany transfer could be.

I was just back in Canada recently, and I couldn’t wait to return to the sun and warmth. Alberta weather is rough, and it really reminded me why I left.

The career opportunities and salaries are significantly better here. The weather alone is a huge upgrade for me—I love heat and sunshine—but the U.S. really has every climate you could want, from Alaska to Florida. There’s simply more to do, more energy, more life.

I love driving around the US and going to different states.

It’s not even a fair comparison for me anymore.

If you’re on the fence and you have the opportunity, take it and go.

And if you come from an immigrant family, let’s be honest—the U.S. was always the destination our parents talked about. This is where opportunity pulls you.

Anyone with ambition, drive, and a solid education should seriously consider being here.


r/tnvisa • • Apr 06 '25

Port of Entry (PoE) Discussion Fear mongering for current TN visa holders is INSANE

183 Upvotes

I have been crossing at Alexandria Bay for years, got my TN successfully there and travel back and forth almost monthly. I just crossed back over today and he asked me 2 questions and then I proceeded to have a VERY lighthearted conversation about the bread from my favourite bakery I was bringing over with the border agent 🤣

I can’t speak for being approved for a new TN currently, but if you are a valid TN holder and act like a normal person you probably will not have any issues.

Since people are obsessed with race I’ll point out I am first generation Canadian and look middle eastern and have an ethnic first and last name.


r/tnvisa • • May 30 '23

Hello, I have been living in Canada for past 10 years love this country. However, cost of living is killing me. I don't see any future for me. I am IT professional thinking of applying for jobs in US. How willing are US companies to sponsor TN1?

173 Upvotes

r/tnvisa • • Oct 02 '25 Helpful Heartwarming

TN Success Story TN Visa Eligibility Checklist (Used by Border Patrol)

Post image
162 Upvotes

I’m creating this post as an extension of someone else’s thread so people can see the TN eligibility checklist, but also to share my own experience in hopes it helps someone else. I’m a Canadian who has gone through the TN visa process at least five or six times. Personally, I’ve had the smoothest experiences crossing at Rainbow Bridge and Peace Bridge. These days, an interview is mandatory, so being prepared is everything.

One tip I strongly recommend: once you’re approved, go get a Nexus card. Nexus is a trusted traveler program for crossing the Canada–U.S. border, and I use it whenever I go back to visit family. It also comes with TSA PreCheck benefits at all U.S. airports and many international airports that recognize it. Having Nexus has made my crossings much smoother—they rarely hassle me anymore, and I don’t get stuck answering random or “gotcha” questions.

Here are some of the biggest things to watch for in your TN application:

Addressing the letter: It must be addressed to: U.S. Department of Homeland Security U.S. Customs and Border Protection Do not use “To Whom It May Concern.”

Job title: The title has to be exactly one of the TN-approved professions on the official list—no variations. Example: Let’s say you’re a qualified teacher, and the company wants to hire you as “Director of Education.” Even though the role requires teaching credentials, “Director of Education” is not on the TN list. That could get you denied. The safer approach is for the company to list you as “Teacher” in the job offer letter, bring you in under TN status, and then adjust your title internally once you’re hired. Promotions or job title changes within the company don’t require a new TN.

Job description: The wording in your letter should align closely with the Bureau of Labor & Statistics description for that profession. During my last application two years ago, I had an officer literally pull up the BLS website in the interview and compare my job description line by line with the official listing.

Contract details: The letter must include compensation and the length of the position (1–3 years max). The phrasing I was told to use: “The contract/position is for one year not to exceed 36 months.”

Discretion factor: Officers do have some discretion, but the more your paperwork follows the checklist, the less you’re leaving to chance.

This process is very black-and-white, and honestly, it’s safest to treat it that way. The closer your paperwork matches what’s on the checklist, the smoother it will go.


r/tnvisa • • Mar 07 '26

TN Rejection Story The TN process is slowly dying

134 Upvotes

Maybe this is a bit dramatic, but I honestly think we’re witnessing the slow decline of the TN visa.

For background: I’ve worked in the U.S. for over 10 years and have had 7 TN visas.

My most recent experience actually brought me to tears.

I received a new offer from a new employer and put together my TN package — letter to the border, offer letter, transcripts (not sealed… we’ll get to that later), all the usual paperwork.

When I arrived, the agent questioning me was beyond rude — loud, irritated, and clearly annoyed by my presence from the start. The interaction got so tense that I asked for a supervisor (I’ve done this before without issue). This time it made things 10x worse.

Her reasoning for denying the visa was that my transcripts were not sealed, so she couldn’t accept them. Fair enough — that part was technically my mistake. But the tone of the entire interaction was completely unnecessary.

Visa denied. The paper simply stated: did not provide sealed transcripts.

Second visit — 1.5 weeks later.

I came back with sealed transcripts.

The agent questioning me was nicer, but still pretty rude. She seemed almost confused that I was applying again for the same visa. She asked me to sit down and then came back saying that the other agent (the supervisor) said my job didn’t fall under the Mathematician category.

This is the fourth time I’ve received a TN under that category. My work is math/computational and clearly fits.

But that’s not even what the first agent said. She never mentioned that issue at all. The official denial paper from my first visit literally states: did not provide sealed transcripts.

Denied again.

At the end of the day, the rules and designations seem completely at the discretion of the agent. It feels less about the business relationship TN was originally meant to support and more about the interpretation of whichever officer you get that day.

I’ll probably apply again using my previous government job offer (which I kept as a backup).

I’ll also say this: lately it feels like the broader political discourse around immigration has seeped into these interactions at the border. The tone feels different.

What’s ironic is sitting there in the customs office seeing informational materials about coming to the U.S. and the importance of cross-border relationships — while having an interaction that feels completely at odds with that message.

People will continue to be admitted and denied. This is just my perspective as someone who has gone through the process many times.

Yes, I made a mistake the first time with the transcripts. But the overall experience this time around was incredibly frustrating and disheartening.

Good luck to everyone dealing with it.

TL;DR:

Denied twice.

**edited by chat.


r/tnvisa • • May 18 '24

My TN "Visa" Experience as a Canadian

131 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I just wanted to say thank you to the r/tnvisa community - it helped me so much with my own process.

So, I just wanted to explain my own experience because I think it may be helpful to others. I have a bachelor's in Statistics and Economics (dual major), and I entered under the category 'Mathematician (including Statistician)' as a Data Analyst.

The new employer has immigration lawyers it partners with, and they wrote my TN packet after I submitted my personal information and scanned documents on their portal (called Envoy).

The packet consisted of a G-28 form, TN letter, and a few printouts about the company itself. I was emailed this packet (no wet signature), and I had it printed at Staples on nice stiff paper (optional, of course - but I didn't want to waste all my own printer ink on their colourful images that were part of the company profile section).

In addition to this packet, I presented my original bachelor's degree (interestingly enough, my degree doesn't state my major, it just says 'Bachelor's of Science') as well as the transcript I had ordered from the school 2 months prior. I kept it sealed in its original envelope, and I knew that the CBP officer would rely on this transcript since my degree itself did not specify the field of study.

On the day of the TN appointment, I presented my packet (each item like the G-28, support letter, etc, in their own transparent protective sleeve) in a single folder. In addition, I handed him the transcript in its sealed envelope along with the original degree.

He asked me to sit down, and he went through my documents. He started making photocopies and typing stuff (so in my mind, I was sure he didn't flat out reject me at this point).

After 10 minutes, he called me up and asked me a few questions. He asked me:

  1. How did you find the job? My answer: Through LinkedIn, I thought it was a great opportunity for my career growth.

  2. What do you currently do for work? My answer: I'm a data scientist, so quite similar duties.

  3. Can you walk me through your day-to-day? My answer: I maintain or build new reports for different teams in the company based on the data they need. (I kept it quite simple and high-level).

  4. Is this your first time earning $XXXXX per year? My answer: Yes sir, it is. (Note: he asked this in a joking way, and ended by commenting "especially in USD").

  5. Will you be doing any managerial duties? My answer: No sir, just what's outlined in the job description in the support letter (Note: I believe that if I would have tripped up and answered 'yes', he would have rejected me here due to the 'managerial' aspect being part of a different NAFTA category altogether). This may have been a 'trick question', but answering it honestly was the best course.

Overall, questioning was not intense - he seemed quite light-hearted and just wanted to see that I could answer his questions.

VERY IMPORTANT - Before my appointment, I called a few ports of entry like Detroit and Niagara Falls with NAFTA officers and just asked them questions so I could be sure what to expect. You will often hear that people say YOU NEED A WET SIGNATURE. This is not true. How can I say this? Because I called the port and spoke to a CBP officer and asked him this before I went. He said 'it's generally preferred, but not required. Most importantly, we need to have a phone number we can call, and it has to be a business phone number so that it's obvious - not some random person's cell phone number'. So, be sure that your support letter has a business phone number of the HR rep or anyone else involved in handling your case.

THEREFORE, call the ports and talk to some real-life CBP officers there and ask them yourselves. Don't just go based off what you see on Reddit - although it can be useful.

All in all, that was my experience - he approved my TN and I paid the fee, and I was on my way.

Right after that, on the same day, I went to the nearest SSA with my TN and i94 and applied for my SSN (after printing my i94 at a local UPS store). Do it the same day, don't delay - you will need your SSN for the background check, most likely (at least, I did). I then crossed the border 2 days later (because your SSN won't be ready right away, they say their database updates over night) to pick up the actual number itself (they wrote it on a post-it note for me). The actual SSN card takes like 2 weeks to ship, and I cannot afford to wait that long before submitting it for my background check (and yes, the SSA can ship it to a Canadian address, even though the official word is that they need a US address).

Please DM me if you have any questions!


r/tnvisa • • Dec 05 '24 Diamonds are Forever Galaxy Brain All-Seeing Upvote Bless Up Hehehe Bravo I’ll Drink to That Wholesome Seal Helpful Heartwarming Popcorn

Miscellaneous How to Find TN Visa jobs

129 Upvotes

I’m not sure if I can share this here, but I want to post it because many people here are looking for employers with a history of hiring TN visa holders. That’s why I want to share this.

Step 1: Visit the Casewise.ai Playground tab and research sponsors who have previously hired TN visa holders. (Demo video)

Step 2:

Step 3:


r/tnvisa • • May 06 '26

TN Success Story Not your everyday TN success story

124 Upvotes

I wanted to share my TN experience because it ended up being way more stressful and inconsistent than I ever expected. Maybe this helps someone else in the future.

Background: I have a Computer Science undergrad degree from Canada and work in software engineering.

My first TN was in August 2022 at the Port Huron POE. I applied under the Engineer category for a software engineering role with full support from company lawyers. The process was straightforward. The officer asked basic questions about my degree, relevant courses, and job duties, and I was approved.

I renewed/reapplied in August 2025 at Philadelphia International Airport for the same company and same TN category. This time I was approved without being asked any questions at all.

Fast forward to 2026. I signed a new software engineering offer with another company and submitted my 3-week notice at my current employer. The new company’s lawyers prepared my TN package during the week before my intended start date.

On a Wednesday morning I went to the Alexandria Bay POE and presented my TN package under the Engineer category. I was asked similar questions as before: what are your job duties, where will the work be performed, and what degree do you hold.

About 30 minutes later I was informed my application was denied because of my Computer Science degree. The officer stated that a Computer Engineering degree would be required for the Engineer category in my case. I asked whether I could reapply and he said yes, but only if I either obtained an engineering degree or applied under a category that aligned better with my education, such as CSA.

I was admitted under B-2 status and told to gather my belongings in the US and return to Canada ASAP.

That same day I updated both the company and the lawyers. We collectively agreed to reapply under the CSA category since my actual job duties aligned well with CSA duties. To their credit, the lawyers worked overnight and sent me a completely revised TN package the next day.

Since I was staying in Ottawa while waiting, I went to the Ogdensburg POE because it was closer.

The experience there was immediately hostile.

The officer at the booth was visibly upset that I was reapplying one day after a denial and that I chose a different POE. Once inside, I was repeatedly asked to justify why I was attempting to reapply. One officer explicitly told me he would NOT be processing my application that day. Another officer joined and accused me of committing fraud.

They scanned my documents, took fingerprints, and continued chewing me out during the process. I pleaded with them to contact either my lawyer or the company since both were aware of my arrival and standing by for questions, but they refused to contact anyone and said their decisions were already made.

I was then told to never apply for a TN visa at any POE again and was denied entry into the US.

I stayed at a motel near the border and later attempted to re-enter the US through Alexandria Bay just to collect my belongings for real this time. Even then I faced additional scrutiny because of the failed reapplication attempt. Eventually they admitted me under B-2 again but only gave me 4 days in the US.

While I was panic-selling my belongings on Facebook Marketplace, my lawyer informed me that they had gotten in touch with the assistant director at the Alexandria Bay POE. Apparently he was extremely concerned with how my applications had been handled and offered both a personal apology and an opportunity to reassess my case if I was willing to return.

On the last day of my permitted stay, I drove another 9 hours back to Alexandria Bay (not knowing if I would be allowed to return).

The assistant director met me in person and was incredibly professional and polite. He explained that TN applications can be interpreted differently depending on the CBP officer and their level of familiarity with TN adjudications. He also acknowledged that the way I was treated, especially at Ogdensburg, was unacceptable and asked me to document my experience through the CBP survey form.

Another officer then handled my third TN application attempt under the CSA category.

This time I was approved with zero questions asked (!)

One important thing the assistant director told me was that both of my applications, under Engineer and CSA, were valid and would likely have been approved had he personally reviewed them.

This entire experience really showed me how much variance there can be between officers and POEs. Huge relief that everything ultimately worked out, and huge shoutout to my lawyers for advocating for me throughout the process.

Oh, and believe it when people tell you to avoid the Odgensburg POE on this sub. I didn't, and I found out lol. AMA! Happy to help.


r/tnvisa • • Mar 03 '25

Travel/Relocation Advice Traveled internationally for first time since Trump

117 Upvotes

Canadian living in US via TN Visa. I traveled internationally for the first time since Trump came in,

And for the first time, immigration asked for additional documents when I came back into the US. Usually in the past, I just show my passport that states my I94, company name, category, and expiration date. But this time, they asked if I had additional documents.

Luckily, HR warned me this might happen before I went on my trip. They gave me a supporting letter to take with me. But I'm guessing the future will remain like this.


r/tnvisa • • Oct 20 '21

Successful First-time TN-1 Visa Application at YYZ under Computer Systems Analyst. Ask me anything!

116 Upvotes

Hi guys, just got my TN-1 approved. Here is my story.

Preamble

A few months back, I had an interview at a huge U.S. pharma company. As a Canadian citizen, I was a bit off put because the position was located in the US, but I said fuck it, what's the worst that could happen? At first when I applied, I googled 'is h1-b sponsorship?' And somehow I got an answer that said no it is not. One of the pre-screening questions were 'do you require sponsorship?'. Thinking that h1-b does not require sponsorship, I applied. THIS IS INCORRECT. A H1-B VISA REQUIRES SPONSORSHIP. When I realised this, I was kind of crushed and looked around a little bit for other options. That's when I found the TN Visa, a work visa for NAFTA eligible professions to temporarily work in the US.

Requirements

The requirements for a TN Visa are as follows:

  • You are a citizen of Canada or Mexico

  • Your professions listed under the list of NAFTA applicable professions

  • You have a prearranged full-time or part-time job with a U.S. employer for this NAFTA profession

  • You have the qualifications to practice in the profession in question - either your degree or experience

At first I thought my position was more of an accounting position, so I was planning to apply under the Accountant position even though my degree (Software Engineering) did not relate, however this was a flawed approach. When I finally got the job offer, it was under the title Analyst, (department name). Therefore, with my educational background, I chose to apply under Computer Systems analyst for my analyst role. If you apply for a TN, read the profession list thoroughly.

Here is the list of professions: https://www.nafsa.org//file//amresource/8cfr2146.html.

How to apply

For a TN Visa, you need to apply at any POE into the States, or at a Preclearance office. Here are the list of Preclearance offices: https://www.cbp.gov/travel/preclearance . There is a fee of $51 USD that you will have to pay on the spot.

To apply, make sure you bring the following items:

  • Resume

  • Offical copy of your degree (Didn't fit in my suitcase with the frame, so I took it out and put it in a small box)

  • Unofficial copies of your degree

  • Sealed Transcripts

  • Unofficial transcripts

  • Official Job Letter

  • Support letter detailing why you are eligible for the visa

How my application went

I chose to go to apply at YYZ. A lot of people say YYZ is an unfavourable place to do your application, but there were a few factors into why I chose YYZ. Firstly, if I had my parents drive me down across the border, they would both need to take COVID-19 tests and both would have to be negative to re-enter Canada which would be $150 each. Additionally, when I consulted a lawyer (free consultation) they said that Peace Bridge has been unconsistent of late. (I didn't purchase the lawyers services because she was asking for 2.5k usd to write one support letter and I just thought to myself that I can write better than most people and had the same amount of schooling so fuck it, I'll do it myself. And as a bigger fuck you, I'll give y'all a template too.) For those reasons, I chose to go to YYZ. I purchased a refundable ticket just in case and prepared everything and went.

How applications at YYZ work:

You do not need an appointment to apply at YYZ. Simply book your ticket, plan your COVID test accordingly and you are good. Once you enter the airport, check in your luggage you want to check in. Get your boarding pass and carry-ons and say goodbye to your loved ones. Proceed to enter the clearance area where they scan your carry-ons and make you go through the X-Ray machine. Don't panic, you will apply later on in the process. Once they have checked out your person and all your items, they will direct you to US Customs and Border Services. Essentially a big room with multiple posts that make you line up to speak with an officer at the booth. When I went, this was 4 rows long and took me roughly 40 minutes. Come extra early. Don't fuck around with your application.

When it is your turn, you will be called up to the agent and will be required to show them your boarding pass and Canadian passport. They will also ask you to remove glasses and mask to take a picture. This is the part where they usually ask you for your purpose of visit. Everyone traveller goes through this process. However, this is where it begins to differ in your case. Instead, as soon as you come in front of the booth, give the officer your passport and boarding documents and ask the officer "I would like to make an application for a TN-1 Visa". Sound as earnest as possible, trust me it helps. The officer asked me if I had prepared my application package, and I said yes. He asked me if I had done this before, I said no. He then said "Okay, I will take your passport and boarding pass and we will go to the secondary screening room and the officer inside will handle everything."

I followed the officer inside, was instructed to sit down, and after a short wait I was called up. The officer asked for the documents, and I removed a folder I had prepared with all the documents for my application. He asked me to remove all the documents and give them to him and I did so. He also asked me to open the sealed transcript letter and hand him the contents. He then gave me a form to fill out which asked for my daily job duties and what percentage of my day to day they make up. I had no idea what I am doing as I haven't started, so I just looked at my email and listed the requirements, focusing on the ones that were mostly aligned with the CSA job duties as listed on the Occupational Outlook Handbook here: https://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/computer-systems-analysts.htm#tab-2. At this point, he directed me to the officer at the leftmost booth, and that officer told me to meet him at the cashier kiosk for payment. After this, I sat back down, but then the officer processing my application asked me for my employers phone number. I didn't know so I asked him if I could search it up and he said "that's fine". I then gave him my employer's number and he also confirmed the address with me. I then packed up everything, all my documents that he doesn't keep such as my degree and whatever documents he didn't need like my flight intinerary and was directed to exit to boarding.

TN-1 Support Letter

This by far is one of the most crucial pieces of the application and will help you immensely especially if your degree is not directly related. This is what the lawyers will charge you for, and it is sooo simple to create. Follow this linked template that I created here, and you should be fine: (Not sure how to create documents anonymously and share them so if someone has a solution, lmk.)

Here are the best tips for your support letter:

  • Look a the OOH jot notes for job duties and then look at yours and try to make an amalgamation. Make sure your job duties are specific, but general enough that they can't be framed as something that you are not applying under.

  • You need the company letterhead and need a signature. My signature was not in ink, but printed.

  • The actual job offer doesn't need to state temporary status, but the support letter must.

  • The support letter must clearly state job title, job duties in layman terms, source of remuneration, salary and benefits, and and duration of employment

Here is the checklist the officer is working with: https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B_6gbFPjVDoxZFA1WmIyWjdLZ3c/edit?resourcekey=0-COFGgsKu6vdG0dWaabmv2Q

If you made it all the way to the end, give yourself a pat on the back. It's better to be prepared. Always. This community helped me and my anxiety while I was creating this application, so why not give back and gather all information in one place? If I missed anything, let me know. If you have any questions, I will answer them all. Thanks a lot for everything guys, and wish you all good luck on your applications.


r/tnvisa • • Jul 18 '24

Let’s cool it with the fear mongering please. TN is a skilled status and mass migration of students who can’t even get white collar jobs in their home countries aren’t going to magically get hired by American firms.

115 Upvotes

Preface: I do think that although there’s no massive TN wave from Canada or Mexico to the US, there should still in principal be a 5 year minimum requirement as a citizen of either country before someone is eligible for TN. I see you in the comments complaining that I said this and I don’t care. Applying for a TN while simultaneously applying for your first Canadian passport (can literally see this on your profiles) is disingenuous and immoral. Go argue with a wall. I can point out the gross racism on this sub, while also being against unethical practices.

Canadian citizen since I was a child. I’m making a new account to post this. I’ve noticed some incorrect (and frankly dog whistling) rhetoric on this sub lately. This isn’t the sub for that. I have an issue with unskilled mass migration to Canada too! But some of the comments here appear like they’ve never even interviewed for an American role in their life 🤦🏻‍♀️, and it seems many are just browsing this sub after it was posted about in r/canadahousing. If you’re genuinely looking to move to the U.S. and haven’t done any research on either the TN or even how to get a U.S. job, then I suggest you start instead of making absurd angry comments on here that only scare people looking for honest advice about the process. I question if some of you are even eligible for the TN. I mean claiming that someone who can’t speak English and has a diploma from a strip mall is going to get an American CSA role and take away your chance at a TN? Jesus Christ.

But The TN has been around for DECADES. If skilled educated immigrants wanted to take advantage of this in the crazy noticeable droves that are being talked about on here in red-scare like language, then it would’ve happened already. Canada’s post-2018 mass migration is almost exclusively of unskilled students. Most of these students do not hold bachelors from their home countries & if by chance they do- they’re from low tier universities that hiring managers from both Silicon Valley & New Delhi see right through. Most of these students haven’t even seen New Delhi. They’re from tiny Punjabi villages…To even get a normal work based Canadian PR, it’s still the points system and there are actually higher caps on skilled immigration from India than China. The Indian middle class and higher is not interested in Canada. Indian media regularly mocks Canada as a failing state and pokes fun at the fact that Canadian community colleges are stuck recruiting from a very specific socio-economic demographic. In fact, if this so-called infiltration to the U.S. via TN was true then by that logic we would’ve already seen mass waves of TNs from Mexico. But we have not. There are millions of Mexicans that want to immigrate to the United States, but getting a U.S. job & then a TN isn’t easy just because someone has eligible citizenship. The Mexicans on TN status are highly skilled and an asset to America. USCIS knows this.

My parents are white collar professionals (doctor & engineer) from India who came to Canada decades ago through the rigorous points system. My parents have paid God knows how much in taxes and have invested millions into the economy. Canada is no longer attracting immigrants like my parents.

Now compare this to the U.S. where Indian Americans are the highest income sub-group and pretty highly regarded. 1% of the population paying 6% in taxes. To now act like huge waves of Indians are “sneaking” into the US via Canada, just because OUR country can only recruit the unskilled, is extremely insulting and arrogant.

I’m not denying that some skilled immigrants will absolutely be using the Canada PR -> citizenship-> TN route. But it’s not in huge waves. The numbers on skilled migrants to Canada don’t support this.

I would still love if there was a restriction of “need to have held Canadian or Mexican citizenship for 5 years minimum” but USCIS is not going to bother.


r/tnvisa • • 26d ago

Travel/Relocation Advice $120K CAD in Vancouver vs. $150K USD in Chicago suburbs - Would you consider long distance for 1–1.5 years?

113 Upvotes

Hello fellow Redditors,

I'm 35M, married, no kids, and currently living in Vancouver. I'm looking for some advice from people who may have been in a similar situation.

I currently make $120K CAD and recently received an offer for $150K USD for an Operations Engineer role in the suburbs of Chicago. My prospective employer is willing to support my TN visa application through the USCIS preapproval process and has already made changes to the role to support the application.

Here's where things get complicated.

When I initially started exploring opportunities in the US, my wife had been unemployed for almost a year. We were both open to relocating because she was having a difficult time finding a job in Canada.

However, things have changed. She recently landed a job in Vancouver paying $125K CAD, which is great news! Understandably, she doesn't want to leave a new job after being unemployed for so long.

This leaves us with two options:

  1. Decline the US offer: Stay together in Vancouver, where our combined household income would be $245K CAD.

  2. Accept the US offer: I relocate to Chicago while my wife stays in Vancouver. We live long-distance for approximately 1–1.5 years, after which she would potentially join me in the US.

The US opportunity is appealing from both a salary and career perspective, but living apart for that long is obviously a significant consideration. We'd also have to maintain two households during that period.

I'm trying to figure out whether the potential long-term career and financial benefits justify the short-term sacrifices.

Has anyone here been in a similar situation, especially moving from Canada to the US while their spouse stayed behind?

How did you approach the decision? Was the move worth it in hindsight? Are there any financial, immigration, or relationship-related factors we might be overlooking?

Would appreciate any advice or personal experiences.

Thanks!

Update: Hi everyone, thank you all for taking the time to share your thoughts, advice, and personal experiences. I really appreciate it!

I ultimately decided to decline the offer and stay in Vancouver. It was a difficult decision, but what really helped us was thinking about where we'd be after 1.5 years of living apart.

At the end of the day, I decided that being with my family matters more to me than the additional money or career opportunity.

Cheers!


r/tnvisa • • Sep 29 '25

Application Advice TN visas aren't "easy approval"

112 Upvotes

Too many people walk into the TN process assuming it’s a quick rubber stamp. The category looks simple: job offer in a listed profession, proof of qualifications, employer letter. But officers at the border or USCIS know the playbook better than anyone, and they are quick to pounce on weak applications.

  1. The biggest trap is the employer letter. Generic wording like “assist with projects” or “perform analysis” almost guarantees extra scrutiny. Officers want to see your role tied word-for-word to the NAFTA profession list, and they want to believe this is a temporary role. If the letter is vague, templated, or missing details like compensation or duration, it raises red flags fast.

  2. Another pitfall is non-immigrant intent. TN visas are temporary, and any hint you’re settling long-term can sink you. Officers read between the lines. If your answers about “plans after this job” sound uncertain or inconsistent, they start doubting. It’s not enough to have the right documents, you have to project the right story.

  3. And here’s one most people don’t hear: officer discretion is huge. Some ports of entry are notorious for being stricter. What passes in one place might get flagged in another. That’s why careful prep matters, not just good paperwork.

Takeaway: If you’re heading into a TN filing or border crossing, treat it like a serious legal test. Match your job duties precisely, craft a letter that speaks to the profession definition, prepare clear answers about your temporary intent, and don’t underestimate how much an officer’s perception can decide your fate.

(This is not personal legal advice and it can change depending on the details of your case. We share general rules and experiences, and this does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice tailored to your situation, consult an immigration attorney. This post was made and reviewed by immigration attorney Henry Lindpere.)


r/tnvisa • • Jan 22 '26

TN Rejection Story TN rejected for Software Engineering with CS degree (Waterloo CS)

111 Upvotes

I work at a medium size tech company.

Last week two of our Software Engineers were denied re-entry on TN. One in Vancouver and one in Montreal. Both were recent grads from UWaterloo CS.

EDIT: To clarify, their job tittle is "Software Engineer" and it was also the tittle used in their TN applications (Engineer category).

The instructions they (both) received was very unclear: one was told he needed to get an H1B to work as a Software Engineer without a proper degree, the other one was told he needed to apply to the proper category (I assume Computer System Analyst?).

Our in-house counsel has temporarily suggested that any employee on TN status for Software Engineering jobs without a real engineering degree (so computer science or math majors) stay in the country and delay travel, but obviously it’s unsustainable long term.

This would apparently be because of a new policy that is now enforced.

EDIT : It's been pointed out that this policy is over 20 years old

Is there any sign of the administration relaxing this policy? Have you heard of other similar denials?

(I posted about this on a thread, but making it a post for greater visibility)

EDIT: Because I received DMs, no, we're not looking to replace them and they are both white (at least, presenting).


r/tnvisa • • Mar 18 '26

TN Rejection Story got denied at the border today - software engineer position with CS degree

102 Upvotes

tried crossing over for my tn visa application earlier and it didn't go well. the border officer was actually really professional about it but basically told me my computer science degree isn't cutting it for the engineer category anymore. apparently there's been some policy shift since june that's making things tougher and he mentioned if i'd showed up a few months back this would have sailed through

he even went to double check with his supervisor but they both came back with the same answer. ended up having to turn around and head back

my employer is going to file directly through uscis now with expedited processing so i'll wait for that approval notice before making another attempt. bit of a setback but at least there's a backup plan


r/tnvisa • • Dec 24 '25

TN Rejection Story TN Denial at Peace Arch - Software Engineer Role and CS Degree

101 Upvotes

Attempted to apply for a TN today for a big tech company and was rejected. The officer was overall pretty calm and nice but told me later that my application is perfect but Computer Science degree (from Canada) isn’t enough for the Engineer classification. He said this is due to the notification from June and he would’ve approved me if I came before that. He said he’ll check with his boss and later said his boss thinks the same. I was told that my application will be withdrawn and returned me back to Canada.

Company said they’ll file directly with USCIS with premium processing so I’ll wait for that before going again with an approval notice.


r/tnvisa • • Oct 10 '25

Miscellaneous I am an immigration lawyer. AMA related to TN visas

101 Upvotes

Hello r/tnvisa!

Who am I?

I am Ernest J. Edwards, an immigration lawyer focused on business and family-based immigration.

What is this AMA about?

I will answer your questions related to TN visas.

How long will this AMA last?

I will try to answer as many questions as I can during this weekend (October 11 and 12, 2025).

How do I know you are a lawyer?

You can search my name here: https://www.mdcourts.gov/attysearch and here: https://my.dcbar.org/memberdirectory

You can also visit my website here: https://edwardslegalservices.com/

Is this legal advice?

Unfortunately, no. None of this is legal advice, it is only general legal information. This means I am explaining what the law is, I am not tailoring it to your specific situation or telling you what to do. You should contact a licensed lawyer for advice tailored to your case.

Will you prioritize answering certain questions?

Yes. Simple, straightforward questions that can be answered quickly are most likely to be answered. But I will try to get to as many questions as I can.

How do I know what you say is credible?

I have five years of experience with business immigration law. I've done a significant number of TN petitions (which generally have been approved), have encountered most common scenarios and even some uncommon situations. 

Does this create a lawyer-client relationship?

No, it does not. I have not agreed to represent anyone by answering these questions. But if you need further help, don't hesitate to reach out.

Leave some questions now and I will start answering them tomorrow. Ask away!

UPDATE (Sunday, October 12, 7:22 PM ET): 

  1. I will be concluding the AMA now.

  2. Thank you for sending me these questions. They were very interesting and I hope I provided some useful information and perhaps helped you with your TN case.

  3. I realize there are a lot of questions I didn't get to. Further, I would like to respond to them. For some of the questions that I didn't get to but I think are interesting, haven't answered already and believe that other people can benefit from, I will try to answer these questions in a YouTube video or perhaps write a blog/post article over the next week or so.

  4. If you have any questions or need any help dealing with immigration issues or know anyone who needs immigration help, please email [email protected] or call/text 226-612-6446. You can also visit my website and YouTube where I have discussed visas other than TNs. 

  5. Thanks again. Perhaps I can do another AMA if there are significant updates to USCMA or other significant policy changes.


r/tnvisa • • Jun 18 '25

TN News Non-engineering degrees may no longer qualify for TN Engineer under new USCIS guidance (Jun 4, 2025)

101 Upvotes

Official USCIS policy

Policy update

https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/document/policy-manual-updates/20250604-USMCAProfessionals.pdf

Policy Highlights

  • Provides guidance for specific occupations, such as Engineer

Policy manual

https://www.uscis.gov/book/export/html/68600

Engineer

A baccalaureate or licenciatura degree or a state or provincial license is required to qualify for TN nonimmigrant status under the occupational category for engineer. The degree must be in the related engineering field. Officers may refer to DOL publications, such as the OOH, to determine the types of degrees suitable for engineers.

An engineer may not fill computer-related jobs unless he or she has credentials as a computer or software engineer in a bona fide engineering specialty offering full engineering credentials, such as professional engineering licenses.


Interpretations

Richards and Jurusik, LLP

https://rjimmigrationlaw.com/resources/updated-stricter-tn-visa-requirements-for-engineers/

To qualify for a TN visa as an Engineer, applicants must have either:

  • A bachelor’s degree or licenciatura in engineering, or

  • A state or provincial license as a professional engineer

and

Officers now use the following four-part test to evaluate eligibility:

  1. Degree Match – The applicant’s degree must be in an engineering discipline directly related to the job.

  • Occupational Handbook Review – Officers refer to the Occupational Outlook Handbook (OOH) or similar resources to verify that the degree is standard for the role.

  • Job Duties Match – The applicant’s actual job duties must align with engineering tasks, not general tech support or development work.

  • Title and Role Clarity – Job titles like “Developer” or “IT Analyst” are not acceptable unless the job is clearly in computer or software engineering and meets all other criteria.

Jackson Lewis P.C.

https://www.globalimmigrationblog.com/2025/06/uscis-makes-changes-to-tn-policy-manual-key-updates-for-employers/

Specific Professions

Engineers must have a qualifying engineering degree in a field related to the engineering job being offered. The Engineer category should not be used to fill a primarily computer-related position unless the applicant’s background is truly in engineering and the category does not cover generic programmer or technician roles.

Implications

Applicants under the Engineers category with degrees unrelated to the job (even if they work in an engineering firm) could face denial. Companies in the tech sector need to ensure the Engineer category is not used for roles like software developer and IT analyst if the individual is not truly an engineer by training.

VisaNation, Inc.

https://www.immi-usa.com/news-tn-visa-eligibility/

Engineers – No More Room for General Tech Degrees

USCIS now requires TN applicants classified as “Engineers” to hold credentials in a recognized engineering discipline. Computer science graduates or software developers without a formal engineering license or degree in a bona fide engineering field may no longer qualify. This will likely impact many tech professionals who previously relied on the Engineer TN category.


r/tnvisa • • Mar 04 '26

TN Success Story TN Visa Situation After Israel-USA-Iran war (Toronto International Airport YYZ).

96 Upvotes

TL;DR
If you were born in Iran or previously had an Iranian passport:

  1. You’ll spend 4–5 hours just at the U.S. Customs. I missed my flight. Make sure you get to the airport much earlier than you’re used to. If you miss your flight because of them, ask them to stamp your paperwork so you can rebook without a fee. Show it to the airline rep at the gate and they’ll rebook you there.

  2. Bring your military service card or exemption card or at least your old Iranian passport that has an exemption stamp/text in it.

Full story

I'm Canadian citizen and I work as an AI software engineer in California, and my TN visa was about to expire. My employer prepared a TN application package so I could renew it.

I was originally planning to go to the Mexican border (the U.S. Customs at the San Ysidro crossing), but Tijuana was under lockdown after the Mexican government killed a powerful cartel leader, and gang members were making the city unsafe. The U.S. Customs asked people to avoid the area. So I had to go to Canada instead, and I chose Toronto because I have family there.

After I arrived, Israel and the U.S. started attacking Iran. Because I was born in Iran, I was worried the U.S. Customs would scrutinize me more closely. I went to Toronto Pearson International Airport (YYZ) on March 2.

This time, the experience was very different. Instead of 20 minutes, the TN process took 4 hours. They said TN visas were lower priority in their queue. They were scrutinizing everyone from West Asia (the Middle East), but especially Iranians. There was an additional form and extra questions. They asked for social media handles (Facebook, Twitter/X, Instagram, LinkedIn) and travel history. But the most important thing for them was determining whether I had completed mandatory military service and if so, whether it was with the IRGC (Sepah) or the regular army.

However, I had not completed any military service (my dad posted an exit-permit bond/collateral so I could leave the country many years ago, and I never went back). So I didn’t have a military service card or an exemption card. Then they asked for any document showing the exit-permit bond/collateral, but I didn’t have anything and couldn’t locate it.

They were getting frustrated, and then I suddenly remembered there was a stamp/imprint in an old, expired Iranian passport. I asked my family to take a photo and send it to me. They did, and I showed it to the officer on my phone. She took photos of it and asked me to convert the stamp dates to the Gregorian calendar, which I did using ChatGPT.

Another odd thing they did to me (and to someone else) was showing us a pre-filled form and point to my gender marked as “Male” (it only had Male or Female, no other category), asking me to verify it. I have very long hair, but I identify as male, so I confirmed it.

There was another guy (traveling with his boyfriend) who got upset and asked why they were doing that. He tried to take a photo or video of the form, but they refused. In the end, they rejected him claiming he is slowing down/ blocking the queue. What they were doing looked fishy.

Note: I might be wrong in describing exactly what happened to him. I was overhearing parts of it and can’t verify the details with 100% certainty. Phone use and video recording were prohibited, and I respected that except when you need to show them a document on your phone.

After 4 hours of waiting, they finally asked me to provide my TN application package. It took less than 5 minutes to approve it.

As I had missed my flight, I asked the officer what to do. They stamped my boarding pass and told me I could rebook at the airline gate without any extra charges. I rebooked for the next day. The next day, I simply showed my newly issued TN stamp to the U.S. Customs officer, and they allowed me to pass through to the gates without any additional screening or waiting.


r/tnvisa • • Jan 29 '26

Travel/Relocation Advice Move back to Canada

95 Upvotes

Hey, I’m currently in the U.S. on an L-1B visa in Seattle. I’ve been here for about seven months, and I’m thinking about moving back to Canada.

The main reason I’m considering moving back is that, for some reason, I’m just not enjoying it here. I’m far from my family and friends, and I constantly find myself regretting why I’m here. I’m 25 years old, and the work I’m doing right now is something I absolutely hate. I feel like I’m not learning anything. I’m originally from Toronto.

Right now, I don’t see a clear path from Seattle to New York where I could move closer to family and friends, especially with all the layoffs. I’m wondering whether moving back to the U.S. later on a TN visa would be harder, or if I should continue trying to change cities while staying in Seattle. I worry that if I stay here, I’ll just become more demotivated.


r/tnvisa • • Jan 02 '25

Miscellaneous Does anyone want to return to Canada?

95 Upvotes

I have a degree and work experience that is eligible for a TN visa. I am currently suffering from a "grass is greener where you water it" situation

I work in Toronto and make a decent salary where I can save comfortably. I also have a solid support system here. A part of me has major FOMO knowing how much money I could be making in the USA. Money isn't everything but is it worth to uproot your life if you are content where you are for an extra 50k-100k? For those who are more extroverted, are you happy in the states? I love the sense of community and the people in Canada. I have noticed that my friends who say they never would move back often are more introverted and didn't make an effort to meet people aside from their partner.

Edit: also before people say things regarding Trudeau, housing and affordability issues are happening in all the common wealth countries post COVID. USA seems to be the only English speaking country that has the quickest potential for prosperity


r/tnvisa • • Dec 09 '24

Miscellaneous Top Companies that Hire TN Visa Holders and File for Green Cards

95 Upvotes

Data Source: Casewise.ai

S.N.Company NameCityStateZip Code
1MICROSOFT CORPORATIONREDMONDWASHINGTON98052
2Amazon.com Services LLCSeattleWASHINGTON98121
3GOOGLE LLCMOUNTAIN VIEWCALIFORNIA94043
4RIVERVIEW LLPMORRISMINNESOTA56267
5FACEBOOK INCMENLO PARKCALIFORNIA94025
6GENERAL MOTORS COMPANYDETROITMICHIGAN48265
7AMAZON.COM SERVICES INCSEATTLEWASHINGTON98109
8NVIDIA CORPORATIONSANTA CLARACALIFORNIA95051
9INTEL CORPORATIONSANTA CLARACALIFORNIA95052
10AMAZON WEB SERVICES INCSEATTLEWASHINGTON98121
S.N.Company NameCityStateZip Code
11APPLE INCCUPERTINOCALIFORNIA95014
12ERNST YOUNG US LLPSECAUCUSNEW JERSEY7094
13DELOITTE CONSULTING LLPPHILADELPHIAPENNSYLVANIA19103
14EPAM SYSTEMS INCNEWTOWNPENNSYLVANIA18940
15KFORCE INCTAMPAFLORIDA33605
16AMAZON DEVELOPMENT CENTER US INCSEATTLEWASHINGTON98121
17BLOOMBERG LPNEW YORKNEW YORK10022
18PACIFICSTRUCTURES INCSAN FRANCISCOCALIFORNIA94103
19EDATAWORLD LLCFRISCOTEXAS75033
20Diversified Automation IncLouisvilleKENTUCKY40223
S.N.Company NameCityStateZip Code
21OAK VIEW FARMS LLCLAWLERIOWA52154
22LINKEDIN CORPORATIONSUNNYVALECALIFORNIA94085
23UBER TECHNOLOGIES INCSAN FRANCISCOCALIFORNIA94158
24Across Borders Management Consulting Group LLCLake MaryFLORIDA32746
25AMAZON DATA SERVICES INCSEATTLEWASHINGTON98121
26Valley Queen Cheese Factory IncMilbankSOUTH DAKOTA57252
27GJW LLCAinsworthNEBRASKA69210
28KFORCE INCTAMPAFLORIDA33607
29CISCO SYSTEMS INCSAN JOSECALIFORNIA95134
30FIVE RIVERS CATTLE FEEDING LLCJOHNSTOWNCOLORADO80534
S.N.Company NameCityStateZip Code
31FCA US LLCAUBURN HILLSMICHIGAN48326
32Honda Development Manufacturing of America LLCMarysvilleOHIO43040
33BHUVI IT SOLUTIONSSCHAUMBURGILLINOIS60173
34MEXICO FOODSADDISONTEXAS75001
35Legacy Farms LPPlainviewTEXAS79073
36META PLATFORMS INCMENLO PARKCALIFORNIA94025
37GLOBAL TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATES LLCRESTONVIRGINIA20191
38THE BOSTON CONSULTING GROUPBOSTONMASSACHUSETTS2210
39MAPLEBEAR DBA INSTACARTSAN FRANCISCOCALIFORNIA94105
40CRUISE LLCSAN FRANCISCOCALIFORNIA94107
S.N.Company NameCityStateZip Code
41ABS GLOBAL INCDE FORESTWISCONSIN53532
42LYFT INCSAN FRANCISCOCALIFORNIA94107
43BROSE NORTH AMERICA INCAUBURN HILLSMICHIGAN48326
44NS INTERNATIONALTROYMICHIGAN48084
45GULFSTREAM AEROSPACE CORPORATIONSAVANNAHGEORGIA31407
46Ascent Aviation ServicesTucsonARIZONA85756
47JP MORGAN CHASE COCHICAGOILLINOIS60603
48Seaboard Foods LLCShawnee MissionKANSAS66202
49MOBILE APPS ENTERPRISES LLCATLANTAGEORGIA30339
50THE SIEGFRIED GROUP LLPWILMINGTONDELAWARE19801