I was denied my TN for Computer Systems Analyst, I have a Bachelors Degree in Computer Science. Job responsibilities are of a AWS systems analyst. The application was for 3 years, and i had 2 Petition (1 Full time - in person and 1 part time remote). The officer dealing my case was super nice he even gave me some advice to handle rejection, although I am just unsure why they were asking me unrelated questions to the job, and then generally quoted “we do not think you are qualified” (for the whole interview). One officer was polite, one absolutely came for my life, decision was made based on shared judgement. Questions asked and what went wrong (Approx questions asked = 10) :
Are you going to be coding on the job - Answered, No. What is the difference between python and java, do you Know C ++ ? I had been a developer in the past, but have not built APIs in a while. I just do not understand, why such broad questions. I messed this answer up, I said Java is high-end language (i meant to say , java can support more users than python). In hindsight, i should have said something about the syntax differences. I think i overthought under pressure, I still do not know why they were pressing me about this. My job letter said, they rely on my experience of software engineer to have the knowledge to work as computer systems analyst. When was Java or python built ?(somehow we are supposed to memorize this). I am sure this question was not the only reason my application was rejected.
There were some grammatical errors in the support letters, one duration of petition was wrong. But it was definitely not an option to correct it on the spot. lol.
There were some other concerns with my history in the US, although Never anything illegal. Although any explanation i would give, they would say i am bull-shitting . I visit quite often, one really long vacation , within legal limit of the law. Yet they thought i was working under the table.
That said, all above were just the bad aspects of the interview (2.5 hours with wait), they were not giving me enough time to answer the questions. I tried explaining AWS technical details (which i was right about, they just cared if i got generics right in less than 2 seconds), else it was assumed that I did not know my stuff. They said to my face straight, we do not think you are qualified, after answering right for AWS questions. lol. They cared more i messed up on front end and backend questions.
This was my first TN, I was super nervous due to the current political environment ( I am 26), just out of college. I had all documents, original diploma, transcripts, WES evaluation, certifications proof.
My advice, Have a Lawyer read through your documents, and prepare you for the interview. Some officers are polite, but you cannot hope on getting the polite one’s. During my application surprisingly all the officers came down to interview me. I am not kidding, they expected me to respond to the answers in less than 2 seconds. Purpose of this post is just advice, Hire a lawyer, and understand the requirements of the Visa thoroughly. These Visa’s are just under increased scrutiny currently. Now i have a rejection for absolutely no reason, and i will have to explain this each time i cross the border. Personally, think they should close this visa category, if they are going to try to accuse us of wrongdoing, just because of the political environment. From my perspective, everything was within the legal bounds, the job position, time, education. Just increased scrutiny. I have asked another lawyer to review my application , and provide guidance. Clearly the company’s lawyer was not adequate for the job. They are now being understanding about the situation, since they had grammar errors.
Point of this post : I understand my application had holes, and i could have been rejected. I want to primarily just advice people trying to get TN, to make sure your documents are correct (have a lawyer read over it). In current political environment, past advice is not applicable. I am the most frugal person i know, but i also check details. This experience has taught me not to trust reditt post and think you will be right. Also i do not have any issues with the officers, i am sure they were doing their job. Rather, that expect people to interrogate the shit out of you. Clearly this cannot be taken as going to the DMV, i am just trying to raise awareness. Cuz i thought i knew everything, by reading this subreditt.