r/theravada • • Sep 03 '26

Dhamma Misc. Why I get frustrated with some Western Buddhists...

Post image
21 Upvotes

Before anyone misunderstands, I do not hate Western Buddhists as people. What I hate is a certain attitude I sometimes see, where someone discovers Buddhism and suddenly thinks they have downloaded the entire 2,500-year-old tradition into their brain.

They learn a few words like dukkha, karma, nirvana and impermanence and suddenly they think they have figured out Buddhism. Congratulations, you learned some basic Pali/Sanskrit words 🤓. Now apparently you are ready to explain Buddhism to everyone else.

For us, these words are not some fancy spiritual vocabulary we discovered in a book, podcast or a weekend meditation retreat. These are words we grew up with. They are part of our everyday language, culture, traditions, temples and the way we understand life.

What annoys me is this constant “everything is impermanent” response to everything. I once posted about why Buddhist temples in India look less aesthetically maintained compared to historical temples elsewhere and many replies were basically, “Everything is impermanent 🤓”. Seriously? Is that your entire understanding of Buddhism?

Buddhism survived for 2,500 years because people built massive temples, created beautiful statues, preserved scriptures, supported monasteries and passed down traditions. Do you really think, if Buddhists throughout history just sat there saying “everything is impermanent” and did nothing else, Buddhism would have survived for 2,500 years?

You can understand impermanence and still appreciate beauty. You can practice detachment and still respect art, architecture, statues and cultural heritage. These things are not against Buddhism.

The problem is when someone learns Buddhism from books, the internet or a meditation app, and then starts telling people who grew up around Buddhism what Buddhism “really is”. Buddhism is not just a collection of deep-sounding words you discovered yesterday.

And another thing I find strange is how people get so triggered when Buddhist history is discussed, especially when it involves India. Why? Why are we hiding from Buddhist history now?

Like seriously, you became Buddhist but you still get triggered when Buddhist history connected to India is brought up? Even after becoming Buddhist, are you still going to carry the same biases? 🤔 You need to learn Buddhism better. Buddhism is not just about memorising a few concepts and repeating them everywhere. It also means understanding the history, cultures and people who preserved this tradition for thousands of years.

You cannot claim to respect Buddhism while ignoring or dismissing the very history and country that helped shape it and where it originated. Learn Buddhism beyond the surface level.

And honestly, the biggest issue is this: do not go around telling others what their Buddhism should look like. You do not have the right to decide what Buddhism is supposed to mean for everyone else. Buddhism is not your personal philosophy project that you discovered yesterday. It is a living tradition that millions of people have practiced in different ways for centuries.

The funny thing is that the majority of Buddhists around the world are not sitting around debating Theravada, Mahayana or Vajrayana all day. Most people simply go to temples, light incense, offer flowers, pray to the Buddha, make offerings and come home. That is Buddhism too.

Practice Buddhism, learn Buddhism, appreciate Buddhism. But have enough humility to understand that your interpretation is not the only version of Buddhism that exists.

Touch some grass 🌱 and understand the ground reality of Buddhism. A 2,500-year-old tradition is much bigger than a few concepts you learned online.


r/theravada • • Jan 06 '26

Question THE FIFTH PRECEPT: ABSTAINING FROM ALCOHOL

0 Upvotes

Sentence 1: A person called to have clear virtue and wise awareness should not let body and mind steep in worldly bad things like tobacco, coffee, tea, cannabis, opium, or any kind of alcohol - things that make people drunk and addicted, harm the body with illness, strain and disturb the nervous system, turn a person dull and foolish, and so on - leading to addiction that cannot be given up. In human life, there are many worldly vices that easily cause our body and mind to be absorbed and intoxicated.

Sentence 2: A person who is truly virtuous and clearly aware does not allow the body and mind to become immersed in worldly unwholesome things such as tobacco, coffee, tea, cannabis, opium, or any kind of alcohol. These things intoxicate, create addiction, cause illness, disturb the nervous system, dull the mind, and lead to addiction that cannot be abandoned. In human life, there are many worldly vices that easily cause our body and mind to be absorbed and intoxicated.

Which one do you like the most? WHEN READ THE TEACHING, YOU CAN PRACTICE RIGHT AWAY.


r/theravada • • Nov 30 '23

Practice From a Buddhist Perspective, there is nothing wrong with Buddhists condemning other systems of thought as false and refuting them.

0 Upvotes

I write these words as a Buddhist who enjoys refuting non-Buddhist systems of thought, but who have often been confronted by other Buddhists and by non-Buddhists who assert that to dismiss other schools of thought as false and to try to refute them is un-Buddhist.

Refuting such false claims about what Buddhists can do when interacting with other systems of thought can be refuted through appealing to 3 sources of knowledge: Buddhist scriptures, Buddhist history and tradition, and Buddhist authors' writings.

Buddhists' scriptures portray the Buddha Shakyamuni himself as describing certain systems of thought as false. In the Brahmajala Sutta, Shakyamuni Buddha describes views advocated by other systems of thought and dismisses them as wrong view.

Buddhists' scriptures portray the Buddha Shakyamuni himself as willing to confront and refute as false non-Buddhist systems of thoughts' claims.

In the Assalayana Sutta, the Buddha Shakyamuni, confronted by Brahmins who claim that caste is important, refutes their claim that caste is important in a debate.

In the the Brahma-nimantanika Sutta, the Buddha encounters a being who claims to be the supreme god and proves, through easily understandable questions, that the being is not supreme.

My opponent may allege that a Buddha, by definition, is superior to a non-Buddha and can refute other systems of thought even though Buddhists are forbidden from doing so.

To this, I cite the Brahmana Sutta, in which the Buddhist Ananda is confronted by a Brahmin who tries to argue that Buddhism's model of salvation cannot end because it involves using desire to eliminate desire. Ananda then refutes the Brahmin's claim and converts the Brahmin to Buddhism.

My opponent may allege that even though the Buddhists' scriptures present Buddhists as refuting other systems of thought, this did not establish a tradition of Buddhists' refuting non-Buddhist systems of thought.

To this, I cite Buddhist history and Buddhists' writings.

There is a long Buddhist tradition of refuting other systems of thoughts' claims through both writing and through public debate. The Buddhist masters Aryadeva and Vasubandhu were famed for their doing this, Xuanzang described such actions as occurring in India, and Migettuwatte Gunananda Thera in Sri Lanka during the 19th century led multiple debates by Buddhists against Christian missionaries, most famously at Panadura. Similarly, the 19th and 20th century Bhikkhu Dhammaloka (who had been born in Ireland before going to Burma in order to ordain as a Buddhist monk), refuted the claim that an uncreated creator god exists in arguments against Christian missionaries which are collected in the book "The Irish Buddhist: The Forgotten Monk Who Faced Down the British Empire".

Buddhists' writings outside the Buddhists' scriptures, furthermore, reveal a long tradition of Buddhists' refuting other systems of thought. I cite a brief and incomplete list of titles and authors known to me.

The Buddhist Nagarjuna (c. 2nd century CE) in his Twelve Gates Treatise refuted the claim that an uncreated creator god exists.

The Buddhist Vasubandhu (c. 4th century CE) in his Abhidharmakośakārikā, refuted the claim that an uncreated creator god exists.

The Buddhist Shantideva (c. 8th century CE), in his Bodhisattvacaryāvatāra's ninth chapter, refuted the claims that an uncreated creator god exists.

The Buddhist Ratnakīrti (11th century CE), in his Īśvara-sādhana-dūṣaṇa, refuted the claim that an uncreated creator god exists.

The Buddhist ChĂśdrak Gyatso, 7th Karmapa Lama (15th century CE), in his "Ocean of Literature on Logic" - the relevant portion of which has been published as "Establishing Validity" - refuted the claim that an uncreated creator god exists.

The Buddhist Ouyi Zhixu (1599–1655), in his "Collected Refutations of Heterodoxy", refuted the claim that an uncreated creator god exists, specifically refuting Christianity.

The Buddhist Ju Mipham (19th century CE), in his uma gyen gyi namshĂŠ jamyang lama gyepĂŠ shyallung and Nor bu ke ta ka, refuted the claims that an uncreated creator god exists and that creation can be from nothing.

The Buddhist Bhikkhu Sujato, in 2015, wrote the essay, "Why we can be certain that God doesn’t exist" which can be read here: https://sujato.wordpress.com/2015/01/14/why-we-can-be-certain-that-god-doesnt-exist/

My opponent may allege that the Buddhist Shabkar taught that all religions are really created by Buddhists in order to lead people to virtue. To this, I say the following.

Shabkar, as a Geluk Buddhist, based his claims upon authorities which I, as a Buddhist with faith based only upon the Pali Canon, do not regard as authoritative.

Shabkar's claims, as my argument has revealed, were not and are not universal.


r/theravada • • Oct 19 '24

Article People need to know that it is extremely disrespectful to do this type of thing.

14 Upvotes

A friend sent me a video and mentioned that many people in non-Buddhist countries engage in this behaviour. It's important to inform them that it is disrespectful.


r/theravada • • May 02 '26

Dhamma Reflections My Biggest Life Regret Is Buddhist Ecumenical Organising

7 Upvotes

Like the title says. Getting some of my mistakes off my chest anonymously because I really hope you can consider not making the same mistakes as me.

You will nearly definitely make some of the same ones I did. I was also warned about this at the time but did not listen.

  1. Re Ecumenical/cross tradition Buddhist organising.

It is ok if your only goal is to meet up people (any people) for tea and snacks & no-one opens their mouth.

But chances are, you might want to do something apart from merely being in the same room as other traditions. At some point, you might want to run a serious program based on say, uposatha observance or Pali texts.

That's when the criticism starts coming and the "H" word comes into it.

Why are you always so narrow minded, they say. Why can't you just accept that tantra is some people's path? Why is Theravada so superficial?

By the time the criticism starts coming, it is too late to quit. It may not be day one of your lovely ecumenical program. But it will be there and it inevitably will come. By the time it does, you are structurally committed to sharing a platform with these people, the mahayanis, who you thought were your friends. You thought if you could be "polite" about difference, they would reciprocate. But you forgot that Mahayana requires a Hinayana counterpart to even exist...which is apparently you.

3 representatives, one for each tradition, is fair, right? Congratulations, you have just delivered the world a permanent Theravada structural minority.

You start thinking about it some more: why can't the Theravada monks and nuns you know stay at the Mahayana temple down the road? The real answer is because the Mahayana place would kick them out the moment they started doing things like practising vinaya, or telling the truth about the origins of Mahayana texts.

The truth is that the emergence of Mahayana was marked by conflict. Just look at the histories of any Theravada country and how much effort it took to purify their sanghas of fake texts. What the Theravada ancestors fought hard for, we give away too easily today: our moral standing as having a canon largely free of fraudulent materials.

The question at the heart of it is really about fraud.

We know, 100%, for a fact, that Mahayana texts are fraudulent.

Most Christians have no problem saying that Mormons aren't Christian. When are we going to wake up that the entire Mahayana movement is the Buddhist equivalent of Mormonism? I.e. a movement based off opportunistic fraud?

We were told that we needed to unite for strength, but this is simply not true. The most influential religious bodies in my country do not organise across sectarian lines. They are influential precisely because their members take their religion seriously.

If you are clear with the government that you prefer to meet separately to the Mahayanis, they are never going to force you to be on the same platform to them to be heard (in my country).

So the concept of ecumenical organising is pretty much always going to be a loss for Theravadins, because you will sacrifice your moral standing and gain enemies doing things you could have done by yourself anyway, while doing nothing to challenge the status quo, or worse, accidentally creating Mahayana majorities.

You have all been warned.


r/theravada • • Aug 21 '24

Question Looking for anarchist bhikkhu/nis

2 Upvotes

I know about (and like) Bhante Sujato, but I’m looking for others who use anarchist principles in their organizational philosophy. Pls feel free to DM as well.

Edit: I’m sorry to see a legitimate question getting downvoted so much


r/theravada • • Sep 16 '25

Question What are the Monasteries doing to save children from mobile addiction ?

0 Upvotes

I hope the monasteries are able to design programs, which encourage youngsters to stay away from mobiles.


r/theravada • • Nov 30 '25

Dhamma Talk 2 Theravada Buddhist Monks Interview His Holiness Sam Harris

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/theravada • • Dec 09 '22

Practice Buddhist practice is for everyone... (except it's really not)!

1 Upvotes

The Buddhist practice needs pre-requisites:

"You need a teacher in order to be fruitful in your practice."

I have crippling social anxiety, so that's simply not an option.

"You need to be happy and peaceful in order to have a solid base to meditate"

Well, better forget about meditation then. Cause I am miserable and lonely every single day. Year after year.

"Having good friends isn't half of the Holy Life. Having good friends is the whole of the Holy Life."

I have social anxiety and have suffered from bullying all my life. And I think I developed Avoidant Personality Disorder as a result of it. I also have I don't have any friends at all. let alone a sangha. I can kiss the holy life goodbye then.

"The practice requires effort and motivaiton"

Well I have a mental illness, and one of the side effects is permanent low motivation. It can take me months to even unpack my suitcase after visiting my relatives.

So in short. Buddhism is only for those that have teachers, are already happy and peaceful, don't have any mental illnesses, and have good friends. In other words. not me.

When the Buddha said that he taught the Dhamma for everyone, he couldn't be more wrong. It's not for people with mental illness, depression, victims of bullying and people with avoidant personality disorder.

Time to leave this subreddit and give up on my Buddhist practice. It's clearly not meant for people who suffer, like me.

I'll go back to overdosing on junk food, sugar and gaming instead. And hope I die an early death from heart attack.

I clearly can not make any progress on the Buddhist path, since it requires me to have friends, a teacher, not have social anxiety, and meditation requires me to be happy to begin with.

Buddhism is for everyone, except those with mental illness. People like me are fucked.

I don't belong in society, and now I know I don't belong here as well.

Maybe suicide is the answer, after all.


r/theravada • • Nov 26 '23

Look what's not allowed on r/Buddhism!

Thumbnail self.buddhism_qa
0 Upvotes

r/theravada • • Dec 08 '25

Question Rebirth doesn't make sense without a self

4 Upvotes

To say, I was a certain type of being in a past life, or might be another type of being in a future life, talking about the Buddha's past lives, etc. None of that makes sense or seems to matter without a self. Even the idea of having complete amnesia about our past lives seems too convenient, it's likely just that past lives and future lives aren't real. If we only have this one life, or if there is an afterlife, but it's not dependent on the types of things the Buddha claims shape our experiences after death, what is the use of following Buddhism?


r/theravada • • Feb 23 '24

Question How do we, as Theravada Buddhists: deal/tolerate the fact that the countries with majority Theravadin Buddhists have some of the worst standards of living, and some of the worst problems on planet Earth?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Sri Lanka/Ceylon:

• One of the poorest in Asia • High corruption • Commonplace Domestic Terrorism • Only party democratic

Myanmar/Burma:

• Military government, not elected • Rohingya Genocide and Apartheid • Armed conflict • Poor Asian country

Thailand/Siam:

• Insurgent Attacks • Threats of Domestic terrorism • Flawed democratic process • Unjust justice system

Kampuchea/Cambodia:

• Water and sanitation crisis • Authoritarian regime • Draconian living standards • Arbitrary arrests

Laos/Lang Xan:

• One party communist state • Intense debt crisis • Deforestation • Lack of fundamental freedoms

Malaysia/Malay:

• Police abuse • Human Trafficking • Relatively stable • Relatively democratic

Singapore/Temasek:

• High income inequality • Death penalty legalised • Exploitation of workers and labourers • Restriction of LGBTQIA+ Rights

Note: I am not inferring, implying or stating that because these countries are Therevadin majority that they inherently have these problems. This is an observation that should be discussed

I will provide sources if it is asked for.


r/theravada • • Sep 29 '21

Why Westerners Do Not Like the Commentaries

0 Upvotes

Article Found in: https://americanmonk.org/only-in-the-west-only-in-asia/

Reposted here in text and picture format.

No comments will be made by OP.. too much turbulence by people who don't know mainstream Theravada (which embraces this type of post).

Only In The West, Only In AsiaMost Westerners do not like the ancient commentaries or the Abhidhamma. Westerners are very far away from Asian culture in both time and space (miles), and because of this, they have difficulty understanding the cultural and ancient time differences.

A small story shows this example well. It might be useful for the next toilet paper shortage. This is picture and story of a bidet (which are used instead of toilet paper).

A monastic friend showed me his new sprayer he was going to install. My eyes lit up and I said, “Can I take a picture of that?”

“Sure. Why?” he said.

“(Giggle). People in the West think of the kitchen sink when they see one of these.” He made a “yuck” face and then the both of us laughed.

Sometimes, based on culture, time, and place, one can gain different but real interpretations that are counter intuitive to basic common sense. Using a sprayer like that in the kitchen sink is seen equally as using a clean toilet brush to wash the dishes. It just does not make sense and this is how an Asian person looks at the Western usage of a sprayer. It is beyond imagination for them. So if the commentaries explained that the spray guns are used for washing dishes, they would immediately reject such statements, like my monastic friend did with his “yuck” face.

Contrary, many Westerners criticize the Buddhist Commentaries and Abhidhamma which are the footnote explanations for the Suttas. While some points may seem counter-intuitive, they were based on a time and culture over 2000 years ago. It is hard to judge impartially, especially for a Westerner who grew up and lives very far away in time and space. Furthermore, this is the modern device. The Suttas mention "Water Pots For Toilets" and Western people think, "Oh this is for flushing the toilet." even though there were no flush toilets in the forest monasteries. They were used for the same purpose as mentioned above with a water bowl and smaller bucket used inside which is still used in Asia today. We have monk rules about how the water bowl should be stored upside down so it won't collect water and rust or get moldy (if plastic). So it is easy to make mistakes, especially for Westerners. That is why the Westerners and Modern Asians are quick to incorrectly judge the commentaries.

Enlightenment and nonself are counter-intuitive too. They go against our natural tendencies. That is why many Westerners like the content mentioned in Ajahn Mun’s Biography. The Thai Forest Traditions, which worship this book as a “bible” to monkhood seem to be the only thing in town for Buddhism in the West. This book helps one believe that an Arahant or even previous Buddhas exists after death with a “citta” that can never be destroyed which is similar to Mahayana and Vedanta in India, which is clearly wrong view according to proper Theravada Buddhism. Anything against this is written by those in theThai Tradition who reject the commentaries. Westerners in general just don’t understand that the “self” is really a “nonself” because it is made of materiality, feeling, perception, volitional formations, and consciousness which are continually arising and perishing moment by moment at incredibly fast speeds. There is no self and when the fuel runs out for those who are fully enlightened, nothing arises again. Nothing.


r/theravada • • Feb 24 '20

Italian hash I made for Sanghadana today.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/theravada • • Jun 01 '25

Question How to leave Buddhism

0 Upvotes

I took my precepts on a retreat over a year ago but let’s just say I feel I’m not compatible with Buddhism. Can I just stop associating myself with it and be done or is there a process for apostasy?


r/theravada • • Aug 25 '26

Sutta Are all the folktales and magial beliefs about what happens after we die essential to Buddhism?

0 Upvotes

I recently began reading the texts, and slowly "entering the stream" as it were. The teaching by and large feel like nectar; they ring true in every aspect of modern life. My only problem is I'd already rejected most religions' ideas of heave and hell, and as a former Hindu I also believe that most of the magical elements are all to imbue morals but are NOT actual events.

I thought Buddhism was about understanding the nature of our existence and our bodies/minds and coming to terms with it. I thought of how in science we have somewhat of an understanding for the universe and I accept that while we may not know everything about the world, we are in essence a coincidence of atoms. I

Now, I see that there are various schools of Buddhism, each one with its own different take on what happens after we die. All of them talk about cycles of birth and rebirth, and suggest realms like heaven and hell. I dont understand, is this magical stuff all essential to Buddhism?

Or is it an added construct that was caused by a slow deviation from what the Buddha preached. Or was the Buddha just partially wrong. I dont know, I'm just a bit confused.


r/theravada • • Mar 12 '24

Buddha bowing

1 Upvotes

A lot of information on the topic has come to light in this thread. I'm going to use this space to summarize and keep a running tally on what we know so far.

  1. The Buddha never made statues of himself to bow to.

  2. The Buddha never, as part of his practice to attain enlightenment, bowed to any statues of anyone else.

  3. The disciples of the Buddha never bowed to statues of him, or of anyone else.

  4. The Buddha never mentioned or advocated anyone bowing to statues as part of the Eightfold Path or a way to enlightenment.

  5. The Buddha said some people are worthy of having a monument, so that when people saw it, they would be uplifted, similar to something like the Lincoln Memorial, etc. The Buddha never said to bow to such a monument, bring it flowers, plates of food, etc.

  6. The Buddha said "relics of memorial" could be made for similar reasons as described in 5: to remind people of good qualities, teachings of the Buddha, and to uplift them. He never said to bow to relics as part of the Path to end suffering.

  7. The making of Buddha statues to venerate didn't start happening as a common occurrence until a few hundred years after the death of the Buddha, primarily, although not totally, as a result of Greek influence.

  8. Bowing as a social sign of acknowledgement and respect is a common practice and custom in many, if not most, Asian cultures.

  9. Bowing as a sign of respect is not and has never been a common social practice in most, if any, Western culture(s).

  10. Bowing in Western cultures has religious connotations and overtones that don't necessarily exist in the same way in Asian cultures.

  11. Excepting India, Buddhism didn't originate in any Asian country where it is practiced today.

  12. The cultures that imported and assimilated Buddhism into their societies added their own distinct cultural practices and attitudes into the practice, while removing or failing to adopt cultural practices from other Asian versions of Buddhism.

  13. Many people appear to believe that Western cultures don't have that same right, i.e., to adopt Buddhism into their societies as it best fits with their own cultural practices, without also having to adopt the distinct practices of other (Asian) cultures. These people appear to believe Buddhism in the West should be practiced exactly the same way Buddhism is practiced in Thailand, Sri Lanka, Tibet, China, Japan, etc., even though Buddhism in Tibet isn't practiced the same way as it is Thailand, or in Japan the same way as it is in Sri Lanka, or in Korea the same way it is in Cambodia, etc.

I think that's where we are so far. I'm open to any corrections or suggestions.


r/theravada • • Mar 11 '25

Worried about newbies getting misinformed?

5 Upvotes

so, im NEW here, even new to REDDIT as a whole.

just checking.... everyone here already knows right, that there's so many things "odd" about Maha/ Vajra, and SO MANY things do not add up at all whatsoever?

people are outright LYING about Theravada over there at r/Buddhism every other day, and when we step in to correct the lies, WE get our replies, deleted, and we get banned, for pointing out the lies and corruption they spread there about Theravada.

but they can LIE? and we cant even speak the truth??

so, is this one of those things where "it is what it is, get on with life", thingie?

its just so FRUSTRATING/ worrying. it kinda BOTHERS me, that so many newbies come there asking beginner's questions about Buddhism, and they get a whole bunch of lies.

i reckon, here at r/Theravada, we just prefer to just not talk about this, and just carry on with practice instead?

im not complaining, im just getting a feel of whats going on, the norms etc around here.


r/theravada • • Sep 24 '18

Theravada Buddhism : The only non-falsifiable teaching

0 Upvotes

The only non-falsifiable teaching

The only non-extreme

The only teaching that works in real life

The only honest teaching

The only humble teaching

The only profound teaching

The Buddhas Charter of Free Inquiry

The Buddhas Middle Path and the Four Noble Truths ( Wikipedia - Four Noble Truths , )

Ajahn Chah : Meditation , Clarity of Insight , The Mindful Way (Documentary)

Nanavimala Thera : Advice on Meditaion

What the Buddha Taught: Wikipedia , pdf

Theravada Texts: Tipitaka , Access to insight

About the appeal of Buddhism: The appeal of Buddhism , Misconceptions about Buddhism , Rational teachings of Buddha


r/theravada • • Mar 25 '25

has anyone witnessed "the matrix" right as they were falling asleep?

0 Upvotes

so, something super weird happened to me.

i was already asleep, but mosquitoes were biting my feet, and it was SO SUPER ANNOYING and itchy.

so in a half-groggy state, i woke up and scratched my feet, without getting up.

but it was so annoying and itchy, it was difficult for me to get back to sleep, even though i kept trying my hardest.

--

after what seems like 30 minutes of trying (to get back to sleep), suddenly, a SUPER LOUD HUM/ ROAR/ VIBRATION slowly crept up into a crescendo.

i opened my eyes slowly, and witnessed that the entire reality was turning into like a "the matrix" scene, where everything was was a lattice/ net of energy, and everything was vibrating, and everything was in super-black and brilliant-white - the whites were like electricity/ lightning.

its like a lattice/ net, fractals, vibrating, ala "the matrix" style.

the roar of the hum/ vibration is pretty much the whole of reality, my entire being was vibrating.

it was like a "cosmic trumpet" sorta thing. SUUUUPER loud. "!!!!!!!BHHHHHHHHOOOOOOOOOOOMMMMMMMMMMM!!!!!!"

"trumpet" isnt really the best word, it was very low-note and low-pitched, like that Inception movie horn sound.
a trombone?

it was as if the whole entirety of reality was "collapsing", or something.
you know, like when you switch off an old-school TV, everything collapses into a flash of white random patterns down into a single dot, before finally disappearing?

--

the weirdest thing also, was how i reacted.

i said out aloud "OH MY FOKKING GOD, FINALLY!!!"

as if i was already FAMILIAR with such a sight, and i knew somehow that i was going back into dreamland. (i was exhausted from work, so i REALLY needed sleep.)

and sure enough, i blacked out, and went to sleep.

woke up the next morning remembering every single detail of the event, feeling very confused/ curious.

what the heck was that???


r/theravada • • Oct 07 '24

What do you think about Jordan Peterson saying being too kind and virtuous is weak and can make your life difficult?

0 Upvotes

r/theravada • • Feb 14 '25

Practice A Reflection on My Time in Buddhist Communities

5 Upvotes

I’ve spent some time on these Buddhist subreddits, reading, observing, and engaging in discussions. I am not a Buddhist; it is not conceit to say that. I have tremendous respect for the Buddha and his teachings. I met many philosophers and thinkers but I have not encountered anybody like the Buddha. I came here not to argue but to explore and reflect, questioning certain aspects of Buddhism with sincerity. I’ve posted about eating meat, kamma, rebirth, and the precepts, not to challenge anyone’s faith but to understand more deeply. The Buddha himself encouraged questioning, yet I’ve found that questioning here is often met with resistance, sometimes even hostility.

Many responses I received had an air of condescension, assertiveness, and, at times, outright aggression. Some people reacted as if questioning their views was a personal attack. Others accused me of ego, even when I was being kind and respectful. A Mahayana mod removed my post, saying, I quote:

"This is not a venue for your personal views nor is it your substack. You never actually participate in threads and instead just widely repost your views to various Buddhist subs and disappear."

Some comments were quite assertive and absolute so I didn't think they were going to engage mindfully so I didn't participate. I'm sorry if I looked conceited. Discussions about eating meat weren’t allowed at all. And in one case, just for gently questioning someone's attitude in relation to Right Speech, I was told to shut the f... up. I removed some of the posts because they entailed unnecessarily harsh manners.

I don’t share this to complain but to reflect on something deeper. It made me ask: Why do discussions about a path that teaches non-attachment, wisdom, and compassion often lead to pride, harshness, and defensiveness?

Of course, this isn’t unique to Buddhism. Any ideology can become rigid when people attach their identity to it. But Buddhism teaches us to let go of views, not cling to them as a measure of self-worth. The teachings warn against quarreling over opinions, yet I saw many here holding so tightly to their perspectives that they seemed unable to entertain other possibilities without reacting emotionally.

Ajahn Sumedho once mentioned that he brought up Buddhadasa Bhikkhu’s name in a discussion with some Thai monks, and they became so angry they looked ready to strangle him. How does that happen? How does someone devote themselves to a path of wisdom and yet still be consumed by anger when their beliefs are questioned? Seeing this kind of reaction both in history and here on Reddit made me realize that one can study Buddhism for years, even wear robes, and still miss the deeper transformation the path offers.

I also noticed something else: spending time here affected my own mind. I remained kind and calm, but I could feel subtle agitation arising, a feeling of needing to explain, to clarify, to defend my sincerity. Even when I recognized it and let it go, I saw how easy it is to get pulled into the same cycle. I realized: this isn’t where I need to be.

I won’t be posting or engaging here anymore. I might look up practical information, but I see no benefit in debating or discussing these things in a space where the practice of Right Speech, patience, and humility is so often disregarded.

This isn’t a criticism, just an observation and perhaps a mirror. If anything in this post resonates, I hope it serves as an encouragement to reflect, not just on the views we hold, but on how we hold them.

Additional: After posting this, Mahayana mod banned me permanently.

May you all find peace and wisdom on your path.


r/theravada • • Aug 29 '25

Question Can we refuse to reach Nirvana?

4 Upvotes

I don’t want to give up my desires. I want to enjoy pleasant times with women. For this, I can endure suffering—can I remain in the endless cycle of rebirth by my own choice?


r/theravada • • Apr 14 '26

Question What is Theravada's thoughts on Tarot cards?

4 Upvotes

Do you think it works or not? if so, how do you think it works it works according to the Dhama? I don't think it can get rid of Kamma, but I think it helps you to see what the heaviest kamma and gives you a chance to change your mindset about it. I also think there is a danger of getting too reliant on it.

EDit: I'm happy most people are keeping this discussion civil. Just want to clarify to everyone:

  1. I don't think the cards themselves are magical.

  2. I is just so happens to be a way for iddhi to manifest as if you use them the way the altered deck was intended, you are supposed to meditate on the symbolisms and not is not at all a accurate way to tell someone's exact kamma... It does exist but only few have that power. Only general stuff.

  3. I do keep saying it is dangerous and will lead you away because it is chasing iddhi. I am not at all trying to say it is great everyone should do it...


r/theravada • • Nov 01 '23

Question Does the first precept include ourselves?

0 Upvotes

Hi

I've been debating with non-Buddhists.

They told me that there is a contradiction in Buddhism.

I'm going to rephrase what they said in my own way.

Basically, they say that the first precept of Buddhism is not to intentionally kill living beings. Now, this implies that you shouldn't intentionally kill yourself. Now, we can imagine a thought experiment where a mafia kidnaps us and tells us that we must crush the cockroach, or else the mafia will kill us. Consequently, Buddhism is contradictory, because :

  • if the Buddhist intentionally crushes the cockroach, then he breaks the first precept ;

  • and if the Buddhist intentionally refuses to crush the cockroach (knowing that this will cause the mafia to kill him), then the Buddhist is breaking the first precept (because his intentional refusal to crush the cockroach is behavior that causes the mafia to kill the Buddhist, so that the Buddhist has intentionally caused his own death).

I replied that one can very well want to do an action without wanting the known consequences of the action. For example, I can "walk and want to walk in the forest - knowing that I will unfortunately crush insects - without wanting to crush insects".

I also said that I don't know if the first precept applies to ourselves.

What would you have said?

Thanks in advance

May all beings suppress passions