I keep seeing people bend over backwards and do mental gymnastics to justify revolver use for serious applications. Massad Ayoob recently made a video where he talks about reason why revolvers still have their place. Needless to say, he makes zero sense. Here are his reasons, as well as why I disagree.
Simplicity- This is a training issue. While I donât necessarily disagree with using a revolver to introduce guns to new shooters, anyone who is carrying a gun who uses âsimplicityâ as justification for their choice of carry, should be seen as a major red flag. This reminds me of those tough guys who try talking their GFâs into buying revolvers because they think women are not intelligent enough to operate a semi auto.
Versatility- Yes, revolvers can take snake shot, and different odd loadings. But this is an extremely niche thing you are using to justify use of an outdated design. If you have to go so far off the spectrum to reach for arguments, I feel as though you have already lost.
CQB/Contact shooting- Again, what a niche argument you have to make. Contact shooting can be done with semi autos, but you have to do something that revolver users hate doingâŚtraining. Remember this argument, because Ayoob will be making the exact opposite argument next.
Accuracy- He just mentioned CQB as his argument, and how most self defense shootings are up close, but now he is saying the opposite? Youâre really reaching. He talks about fixed barrels leading to better accuracy. In my experience instructing, 90% of people arenât accurate enough to take advantage of the inherent accuracy of the gun. Why? Because they donât train or put in the time. And since we have already established that revolver shooters arenât big on training, they probably arenât going to be good enough to take advantage of the accuracy of a revolver.
Cross training- This is the idea that learning on a revolver will teach you better fundamentals. And to a degree, I agree. But only for revolvers. I donât often see people learning fundamentals on revolvers and crossing over to semi autos. But even if that were the case, why bother with the revolver at all, and instead just put in the time on a semi auto? You are just adding extra steps.
Discourages spray and pray- Know what else does? Training. All of these things are training related. Stop being lazy.
If you have a revolver, and you literally cannot afford anything else, thatâs the only excuse I can see for carrying a revolver. I have yet to hear an argument for carrying a revolver that has merit.