r/stepparents • u/Lolslitxxx • Mar 19 '22
Discussion No, kids can't always tell if you don't like them (and if they could, that might be okay too!)
I have seen this so often recently, even on this sub. It makes me want to tear my hair out. So, let's get into it. Couple things.
NO. Kids cannot "always tell" if you don't like them. They don't "sense everything." No, a child cannot "feel all your resentment bubbling away inside you" if you are ACTING KINDLY. The way some people talk about children, my god. They're not some kind of fey being endowed with powerful ESP. They are HUMANS who are honestly a little LESS sensitive and intuitive than adults are, in most cases. The people who are screaming this at you when you express, god forbid, ambivalence or antipathy or even -- GASP -- aversion to your stepchild are either: A. stepchildren themselves, who realize they behaved badly as children but have constructed a kids-are-always-sweet-and-innocent-and-deserving-of-love-so-any-adult-that-doesn't-love-every-single-child-is-inherently-evil narrative to absolve themselves of responsibility for the crummy relationship they had/have with their own stepparent(s) and the fact their stepparent now obviously dislikes them, or, B. a BIOPARENT without the emotional maturity to identify the true root of their feelings. These parents don't truly believe, deep down, that kids are extra-sensory savants who can all tell automatically that we don't like them. What they believe, and what they really mean when they say "your step kids can tell you don't like them!" is, "MY biological kids would be able to tell if I didn't like THEM." So, they have the emotional reaction to you saying you don't like your step kids that they would have if their own, biological child believed that they didn't adore them: horror. It's not appropriate, it's not helpful, and it's not rooted in reality. If you have ever had a boss you didn't like and kept your job in good standing anyway, you cannot convince me (nor should you try to convince yourself) that kids somehow inherently know how you feel about them. What matters are BEHAVIORS. If you can behave with kindness, respect, and emotional openness toward your stepchild (or anyone!), they will not care or ever notice how you truly feel.
It might not actually be the end of the world to allow your stepchildren to see that you dislike them -- because as with most people, we don't inherently dislike them as much as we dislike their behaviors and how they treat people. We are not our stepchildren's parents, in most cases, nor do they want/need us to be. It's not the 19th century: most second marriages occur because the first ended in divorce, not widow(er)-hood. There is nothing to be inherently gained from convincing someone who is behaving badly and acting objectively unlikeable that they are liked. A child is entitled to a parent's unconditional love; they are not only not entitled to everyone else's unconditional love, and they don't actually benefit from people around them being emotionally dishonest. A kid who is acting out does not benefit from people lying and saying "aw, that's cute," in the same way that an adult acting out doesn't benefit. In either case, it makes a ton more sense for natural consequences to be allowed to teach that individual a lesson about how to behave. It's not inherently cruel to react with aversion to anybody (child, adult) that is treating you badly. People who tell you it is are, again, projecting: these are parents who understand that if their BIOchildren behave badly, it's really their fault as parents, and they're trying to sublimate their own guilt by insisting the rest of us unconditionally love their walking parenting failures.
So, if you are like many of us, gritting your teeth and being obliquely pleasant to a child who, objectively speaking, doesn't behave in a likable way, please rest easy. Your stepchildren cannot intuit your feelings. When people tell you that they can, give them a check for conditions one or two, above.