r/steelmanning • • Jun 21 '18

Anarchy means no rulers, not no rules.

101 Upvotes

Equating anarchy with chaos is a deliberate trick by those who psychologically rely on the state for emotional support. Democracy causes a form of Stockholm syndrome in the host population. People are led to believe that they can vote the corruption away. That voting can cure any and all societal problem.

Anarchy means no rulers, not no rules. A society can exist without a sovereign but it cannot without societal norms, a system of morality, and a loose legal framework to protect contractual agreements and property rights.

Anarchy can exist with a system of "true community policing", and though a individual sovereignty of the citizenship or anarcho monarchism.

Stateists will have you believe that a centralized authority is necessary for a stable system. I dispute this. We must decentralize everything. A decentralized world is a free world. A decentralized world is an anarcho monarchist world.


r/steelmanning • • Jun 27 '18

Topic Any adult should have the inalienable right to end their own life at any time for any reason. This will never happen, but there's got to be a middle ground someplace.

66 Upvotes

Full disclosure up front: this is a very real issue for me. My wife is terminally I'll with a disease that will slowly rob her of her memories, her personality, her ability to function at all, then finally her life. This will happen over the next 3-5 years.

We are both pragmatic. We know that a time will soon be here when there is nothing left for her but pain. But the government has somehow inserted itself into the process of dying. So how do I counter all of the "Every moment is sacred" arguments with a steelman argument saying that this should be the ONE thing in life, our lives themselves, that we have control over?

I don't even have much to start building the argument beside the fact that I believe in an ultimate right to autonomy, so any help is appreciated.


r/steelmanning • • Jun 23 '18

Steelmanning AnarchoCapitalism - damn this is hard

53 Upvotes

I am as antiancap as it gets. Check my post history.

However, I got challenged to steelman anarchocapitalism.

This as incredibly difficult for me, because I've argued with ancaps for a very long time (this account is new, but I've been at it for 2 years or so), so I have encountered every argument and am even less convinced than I was before.


My steelman of ancap centers around a underrated and underused ancap argument about individualism.

This goes vaguely like this 'In a market, private businesses can only survive by pleasing the customers. Private businesses do bad things only because they can get away with them because the government gets in the way of market competition and protects businesses from consumers via their laws that are imposed on the consumers using their own money'.

This point is often left underdeveloped in favor of providing examples of bad things government has done (easily countered by examples of good things government has done) but can be developed into something much stronger.

The modern corporation functions on two things: shareholder funds and limited liability. A corporation cannot operate if it's shareholders and agents are personally responsible for the wrongdoings of the organization beyond their initial investment and losing their job, because it would no longer be worth the risk of being involved in such a large and uncontrolled enterprise.

In an anarchocapitalist society, unrestrained businesses will not be able to actually act as if they are unrestrained, because the business going 'evil' so to speak, is a massive personal risk to every shareholder and employee of the business. For instance, BP cannot even remotely risk an oil spill, because all of it's employees are neighbors of people who like swimming in the waters at risk, and will quit in order to avoid being sued by them.

TLDR: Radical individualism means individuals can't hide behind big organizations as limited liability agents in order to profit from the organization doing bad shit at no personal risk. Therefore, organizations that do bad shit cannot exist in anarchocapitalism


r/steelmanning • • Jun 21 '18

Is "Steelmanning" a Harmful Form of Sophistry?

47 Upvotes

Xenophon tells us that 'corrupting the youth' by encouraging skeptical questioning was one of the dubious charges that were leveled against Socrates in the trial that led to his execution, and surely we would not wish to side with Anytus and Meletus who wanted to censor the pursuit of wisdom because it seemed dangerous to their interests. And yet, Socrates' most famous follower Plato was keen to point out the foolishness, and possible harm done, by certain sophists who claimed to be able to argue on either side of any question and "make the weaker argument the stronger." Perhaps then there is some reason to question whether this idea of "steelmanning" is really a good thing.

Before we ask whether Steelmanning is harmful sophristry in itself, I would point out that there is a very practical reason to doubt whether it is useful: nobody lives forever. We recognize that human lifespans are limited, and we all have a finite span of time to ask questions and search for knowledge - so why then should we spend our time trying to make strong cases that what is false is true and vice versa? It's one thing to make arguments because it's a pleasant kind of intellectual masturbation, but given that in many cases it's hard enough to figure out what is true and what is false, why should we make it harder on ourselves to know things by wasting our time on what we know to be untrue?

That question leads to me the more substantial point: self-delusion is relatively harmless, and if you squander your time on foolish pursuits then you are probably not doing any harm to anyone but yourself. However, if I follow the example of Hegesias "the death-persuader" and write a very convincing argument about how painful and full of suffering life is, and by doing so I encourage people to commit suicide, then have I not done great harm to other people? Perhaps then you will respond that censorship of some ideas is not so bad after. Subreddit censorship rule #1: no posts encouraging suicide, or murder, arson, infanticide, etc.

So then I move to make a less controversial argument: 'all people with blue eyes are possessed by demons.' And assuming I have made a very convincing argument, you might think this is not so bad - after all, you and I recognize that this a specious argument being made online, and it's not the kind of argument that's going to make anyone kill themselves or others or do anything truly harmful. However, what if someone else comes along and makes a similar post by exchanging the phrase "blue eyes" for "black skin" and replaces "possessed by demons" with some other adjective... I suspect that you too see that a problem will quickly follow, because human history will show that such categorical claims do end causing lots of real harm.

Take the previous two paragraphs together and you'll see my point - making strong arguments, even for a position that you don't agree with, can still cause harm because of the influence they have on other people. And couching your argument with the phrase "I don't believe this, but..." doesn't really solve the problem, because that saying "I don't really believe that you should commit suicide but here are some really strong points in favor of that conclusion" is just as likely to cause the kinds of immediate harm that we wanted to avoid as the same post without the disclaimer. Even worse, saying "I don't really believe this but there's something you should know about blue-eyed people" can serve as a kind of smokescreen, allowing me to say something designed to make you think that people with blue eyes are dangerous under the false pretense of making a theoretical point.

In conclusion I argue that Steelmanning is not necessarily a useful, positive endeavor. Before you embark on such a project, it's worth considering what the likely results of your argumentation will be: perhaps you think it will be a useful exercise, but if it causes real harm in the world then some arguments are better off not being made. Or perhaps instead of making arguments we don't really believe in, it would be wiser to devote our time to searching for truth.

P.S. - I have intentionally put some strawman arguments into this post - can you make them into steelmen?


r/steelmanning • • Jul 06 '18

Meta [Meta] "Steelmanning" is actually called the "principle of charity."

46 Upvotes

Just in case you wanted to know what the actual term was for this.


r/steelmanning • • Nov 04 '19

9 Philosophical razors you need to know (Occam, Sagan, Hitchens, Hume, Duck, Popper, Newton, Grice, Hanlon)

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
45 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • May 20 '19

That’s illogical! 7 fallacies you need to know

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
43 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jun 21 '18

Pro lifers want a 0% chance of killing a baby.

42 Upvotes

When life begins in the womb is hard to point out. There is contention amongst scientists that it maybe time x, week, y days or z months after conception. Each group Z,Y,X using different parameters to assert what consists of the formation of life.

Since when life actually begins is not 100% certain, and killing a living person is one of the worst moral evils. It makes the best sense to avoid abortion all together.


r/steelmanning • • Dec 29 '18

Why steelmanning is the best way out of false accusations

Thumbnail
kletische.com
39 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jun 21 '18

Though I disagree with it, family separation at the US Mexican border is the most realistic humane option in the short term.

38 Upvotes

EDIT: Point conceded: https://www.reddit.com/r/steelmanning/comments/8sncso/though_i_disagree_with_it_family_separation_at/e10udjd/?context=3

I had a good time, lads.


  • Can't let go criminals committing a crime just because they have children for one crime in particular. This precedent would throw the justice system into chaos as everyone starts using 'my child' as a defense.

  • Can't incarcerate the children with their parents because the children have no agency and are not guilty

  • Can't have a fully open border. It would firstly radicalize the right even further and secondly overburden the already cracking social safety net of America as everyone from worse places makes a dash for it.

  • Can't gun everyone down at the border, obviously an actual atrocity.

  • Can't really just put up a "wall" without a long and painful cultural and legal reform that would have to be aimed at employers that take advantage of illegal immigrants to go with it, as it would be circumvented

Whatever remains, however distaseteful, must be the the most ethical solution. Thus in the short term, family separation is the only feasible way to deal with the problem. Hopefully news of this will serve to turn back other would be illegals and that the children are reunited with their parents in a timely maner at the point of depotaton


r/steelmanning • • Jun 25 '18

Other [other] You can't steel-man a bad-faith argument

37 Upvotes

When somebody does not hold a logical position (that is, they're not attempting to hold a logically consistent opinion, but rather to hold their ground against all costs), there's no way to appeal to the best version of their argument, because there is no best version of their argument.

People of this subreddit, how do you feel about this? Do you think there is a way to steel-man motivated reasoning? Do you think there's a purpose to even bother trying to recombine a person's argument into a menu of steel man options off of which they will refuse to pick any of your choices?

I personally believe no, there is no point to this, and I can't even conceive of a way for this to work, in my own experiences, but feel free to provide me with concrete examples of where this has worked for you.


r/steelmanning • • Nov 08 '19

The Argument—A great political podcast for those who want to hear calm, intelligent cases for both sides of each issue.

Thumbnail
podcasts.apple.com
36 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jun 29 '18

Meta A first impression of the sub

36 Upvotes

I’ve read through just two posts/responses, and I suggest a very stringent rule be applied: specificity as to the basics. Otherwise the question falls into general reddit shitfest of sloppy arguments and goalpost moving.

I’ll give an example: the post about right to die. The specific question is, what is the best steelman for a person’s right to die? One user introduced the argument “don’t worry about the legality,” while another focused on the “of sound mind” part of the debate.

They’re both off topic, and should be an entirely new post. They do not debate the question, but another element entirely. (The first- legal v. moral, the second, mental health).

I just find it all rambling and lacking in coherence when off topic responses gain traction. They’re good enough for their own discussion, and the answer to a right to die is too.

Thoughts?


r/steelmanning • • May 06 '19

21 tips to improve your critical thinking

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
35 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Sep 17 '18

How to get Smarter: A guide to critical thinking, cognitive biases, and logical fallacies

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
35 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Oct 14 '19

200+ Critical thinking questions

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
34 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jun 21 '18

[Suggestion] Focus on building on and improving arguments in this sub

34 Upvotes

I think this sub is an interesting idea, but I sense one problem early. I imagine that many of the people coming here will be interested in argument and discussion, and that many of the posts here will be somewhat controversial topics. Which means it is likely we'll see someone attempt to steelman an argument, only to have the comment section poking holes and disagreeing.

It seems to me that a more valuable approach in keeping with the theme of steelmanning would be for commenters to attempt to further improve the argument. So it's fine to raise issues with the OP's argument, but you must then pose some kind of solution or concession that attempts to build up the premise, so that the thread as a whole genuinely does provide a generous and well-argued interpretation of one side of any issue.


r/steelmanning • • Oct 15 '18

How to get Smarter: A guide to critical thinking, cognitive biases, and logical fallacies – Part 10

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
33 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Oct 21 '19

50 Critical thinking tips

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
31 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Apr 17 '19

It may or may not be of interest to you but r/samharris is overrun with ideologues who don't share any of Harris's opinions or ideas. While having people in a sub to challenge ideas is a good thing, turning the sub into an anti-Harris sub, which is essentially what it has become, is frustrating.

31 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Nov 11 '18

Meta Try to steelman the case against steelmanning

31 Upvotes

One of the best arguments against steelmanning is the notion that your partner is responsible for the clarity and choice of his/her arguments, not you, and that attempts to steelman his or her arguments also leads to the dangers of misrepresentation (best case) or condescension (worst case).

Edward Clint has put forward these arguments quite convincingly.

Trying to integrate the original idea of steelmanning with his thoughts, what conclusions do you reach?

Here's one thought:
Steelmanning should rather be seen as a direction for personal development if one tends towards distorting (i.e. strawmanning) strong arguments of others. In that case (only), it can be a helpful idea for self-correction. It is unhelpful, however, if the arguments of others are weak or if one already tends towards crediting one's interlocutors with undue respect or unwarranted regard for chinks or flaws in their position.

(This thought is also based on German psychologist Schulz von Thun's idea that a development goal can also be understood as a virtue, and that this goals (or virtue) is inextricably twinned with a corresponding sister virtue, however. Thus, in principle, both virtues must be pursued at the same time. If one virtue is pursued in excess, i.e. with disregard for the corresponding sister virtue, the former virtue is devalued or deprecated; then the development goal becomes a deficiency itself. )

Any thoughts?


r/steelmanning • • Jun 20 '18

Though I Disagree With It, I Think There is a Strong Case to be Made for Racial Profiling in Airport Security

31 Upvotes

I apologize if this seems like a bit of an oversimplification. This is my first post here, so bare with me.

People like Sam Harris and other sceptics of Islam regularly state that airport security should be given the authority to profile passengers.

They often site Israel, a surprisingly safe country considering its location. In Israel security will literally rate how dangerous you are based on how they look, act, who they talk to, etc. See this video for more in-depth information

The argument often says something along the lines that we should concentrate on people who look more likely to be terrorists, for example Arabs, and ignore people who look less likely to be terrorists, for example Norwegians. They argue this is because we have limited resources and we should use them efficiently in a way that will prevent the largest number of attacks.

I think it is a very good argument because when you initially think about it, it simply makes sense. It seems like basic logic, and especially because there are practical examples of it working.

Just my thoughts!


r/steelmanning • • Dec 24 '18

How to get Smarter: A guide to critical thinking, cognitive biases, and logical fallacies – Part 2

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
30 Upvotes