r/steelmanning • • Mar 07 '20

Pedophilia should be destigmatized.

3 Upvotes

PEDOPHILIA IS NOT CHILD ABUSE THIS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH CHILD ABUSE. IF ANYONE ABUSED A CHILD THEY RIGHTFULLY SHOULD BE PUNISHED BY THE LEGAL SYSTEM.

For many reasons the least important of which is that it is functionally an orientation and can't be changed. Having a support group would help pedophiles who need help from offending, we know through countless studies having a real support structure is on of the best ways to manage any issue.

Next would be that stigma, telling people they are wrong for reasons other than actions, is a great way to make people stop adhering to social structures and laws. As with the last example this will only affect a percentage but dont we want every advantage we can get to stop the horrific possible outcomes?

The most important practical reason though is it makes it possible to study, and wouldn't you rather know? Studying the actual majority of pedophiles not just the ones who are caught means we can better stop abuse. Through multiple means, better at catching signs of abuse, better at preventing abuse before it happens through more effective treatment, and it means you know who they are. They however won't come out unless they know they won't lose everything. So it makes sense from a practical standpoint to destigmatize pedophilia.


r/steelmanning • • Aug 21 '18

South Africa farm seizures BEGIN: Chaos as first expropriation of white-owned farms starts | World | News

Thumbnail
express.co.uk
2 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jun 20 '18

How the Koch Brothers Are Killing Public Transit Projects Around the Country

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
7 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jul 09 '18

If the world was flat, the sun would never set. It would stay above drawing circles in the sky. Every sunrise or sunset is naked-eye proof that the world is round, and turning.

4 Upvotes

EDIT: Sorry first post and did it backwards. Thanks for the discussion anyway! Will try reposting this idea properly soon.


r/steelmanning • • Jun 21 '18

Socialism is the only defensible political ideology

7 Upvotes

Seeing as there is no free will, no one deserves anything more than anyone else. In other words all inequality in the world (including biological, psychological and socioeconomic inequality) is not justified. The world is irreparably unjust. There is no justification for a tall person being happy with their height and a short person being unhappy; for a attractive person to have good self esteem and an unattractive person bad; for a conscientious person to self actualize and a neurotic person to be paralysed by guilt. For a smart person to study whatever they want and an unintelligent person to have to limit their ambitions; for one child to have a supportive family and another an abusive one; for a rich person to satisfy all their material wants and a poor person going hungry.

Even if there are aspects of our existence that will forever remain unjust, those aspects we can control we should strive to make just. To start, there should be a system for ensuring that every person has the opportunity to develop to their fullest potential, which in practice implies universal child support, health care and education.

Once all basic needs to fulfill potential are satisfied, disposable income needs to be equalised. In practice this would require that all disposable income generated be distributed equally among the population for all to have a fair chance of getting what they want within the limits of civilisation's productivity.

In essence, the world will always be unjust no matter what we do because there are only certain things within our ability to change. The only way to make the things we can change just, and thereby minimise the injustice of our condition, is socialism.


r/steelmanning • • Feb 12 '20

Can we steelman a rebuttal to this narrative? The narrative that politically active women are purely selfish actors.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jul 16 '18

Communism can't work because it has no clear examples of succeeding

15 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jul 11 '18

Steelman The Flat Earth

14 Upvotes

There is no way that an individual can truly know without a doubt that the world is round without traveling either to space or antarctica. Since our eyes are prone to a myriad of optical illusions, any tangible evidence we think we see can be explained as such. And since only a handful of people travel to outer Space & Antarctica, and usually those are government funded trips, it could be possible that they are all paid to keep the true shape of the world a secret. We can only guess as to why that would be until a whistleblower comes forward with the truth.

To be clear: This argument is not postulating that the world is flat. This argument is postulating that *you can't be sure either way unless you personally travel to Antarctica or Space.*

Edit: didn’t expect to have a debate on whether or not to have a debate with a flat earther. But here’s my response to that: just because you don’t know how to debate with a flat earther doesn’t mean it’s impossible.

EDIT2: Wow, spirited debate. Well done, ya'll. I definitely learned some things from this, so thanks so much to everyone who participated (or is continuing to participate)


r/steelmanning • • Jul 11 '18

Topic Trump pardons ranchers whose arrests led to armed occupation of wildlife refuge

3 Upvotes

Make your steel man for or against this in the comments.

Excerpt:

76-year-old Dwight Hammond and his son, Steven Hammond, have won a pardon from President Trump. (AP)

President Trump on Tuesday pardoned the father and son from Oregon whose imprisonment for setting fires on federal land sparked a 41-day long takeover of a wildlife refuge in the state.

Trump signed the order granting clemency to 76-year-old Dwight Hammond and his son, Steven Hammond, 49, who were convicted of arson in 2012 for fires that burned on federal land in 2001 and 2006.

Coverage: Fox News, Oregon Live, CNN, NBC, The Hill


r/steelmanning • • Jun 27 '18

Other Everyone here should read Dostoyevsky

5 Upvotes

He was a master at steelmanning opposing viewpoints.


r/steelmanning • • Jun 10 '19

7 linguistic tricks people use to deceive you

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
17 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jul 15 '18

Equality is neo colonialism.

0 Upvotes

People on the left don't realize that expecting people from a different culture to automatically fit into their culture is a form of neo colonialism. It's literally impossible to get someone from a different culture to just "become" culturally the same as the native population. That's why the diversity industry has to impose things like affirmative action and diversity quotas to adjust to the structural racism of white society.

For example, when white liberals try to blame crime in inner city black neighborhoods on poverty they fail to realize their underlying racism. In a white supremacist society it is impossible for an African American to commit a crime. To us what they are doing may look like a crime but in reality they are acting in self defense against the structural racism of white society. "Black crime" is in fact a continuation of the same old neo colonialist expectations.

This brings us to Ebonics and pigeon English. The ridged structure of the English language itself propagates unhealthy expectations. When white and black individuals are discussed in the media the language used is absolutely problematic. Just like during Hurricane Katrina when white were finding supplies while African Americans were "looting".

With this we can easily see who the real racists are. Real racists are people who want to mold and shape others to be more like themselves. That's genocide. We must preserve the worlds diversity. We must respect and live alongside our human brothers and sisters.


r/steelmanning • • Jun 26 '18

Topic Steel manning communism?

19 Upvotes

Hi my fellow intellects, i've got a request for the brightest minds that browse through this subreddit. I have a friend that speaks non-stop about communism, and he isn't that stupid (yeah they exist) and it pisses me off. How do I counter his main arguments ?


r/steelmanning • • Jun 21 '18

Though I disagree with it, family separation at the US Mexican border is the most realistic humane option in the short term.

38 Upvotes

EDIT: Point conceded: https://www.reddit.com/r/steelmanning/comments/8sncso/though_i_disagree_with_it_family_separation_at/e10udjd/?context=3

I had a good time, lads.


  • Can't let go criminals committing a crime just because they have children for one crime in particular. This precedent would throw the justice system into chaos as everyone starts using 'my child' as a defense.

  • Can't incarcerate the children with their parents because the children have no agency and are not guilty

  • Can't have a fully open border. It would firstly radicalize the right even further and secondly overburden the already cracking social safety net of America as everyone from worse places makes a dash for it.

  • Can't gun everyone down at the border, obviously an actual atrocity.

  • Can't really just put up a "wall" without a long and painful cultural and legal reform that would have to be aimed at employers that take advantage of illegal immigrants to go with it, as it would be circumvented

Whatever remains, however distaseteful, must be the the most ethical solution. Thus in the short term, family separation is the only feasible way to deal with the problem. Hopefully news of this will serve to turn back other would be illegals and that the children are reunited with their parents in a timely maner at the point of depotaton


r/steelmanning • • Jun 20 '18

Though I Disagree With It, I Think There is a Strong Case to be Made for Racial Profiling in Airport Security

31 Upvotes

I apologize if this seems like a bit of an oversimplification. This is my first post here, so bare with me.

People like Sam Harris and other sceptics of Islam regularly state that airport security should be given the authority to profile passengers.

They often site Israel, a surprisingly safe country considering its location. In Israel security will literally rate how dangerous you are based on how they look, act, who they talk to, etc. See this video for more in-depth information

The argument often says something along the lines that we should concentrate on people who look more likely to be terrorists, for example Arabs, and ignore people who look less likely to be terrorists, for example Norwegians. They argue this is because we have limited resources and we should use them efficiently in a way that will prevent the largest number of attacks.

I think it is a very good argument because when you initially think about it, it simply makes sense. It seems like basic logic, and especially because there are practical examples of it working.

Just my thoughts!


r/steelmanning • • Jun 21 '18

though I disagree with it, involuntary euthanasia for those with genetic diseases makes sense.

5 Upvotes

On an individual level, hereditary diseases decimate quality of life, increase the hardship of mundane tasks and are often degenerative, they promote feelings of shame that others need to give up large portions of their lives to help you and can cause permanent pain. More widely, close family and friends are left with a choice of giving up important aspects of their lives to care for the sick or be branded as a bad person if they either fail to choose the former or complain about it in any way. On a societal level, researchers could be freed up to pursue other avenues, that might benefit larger populations, since breakthroughs in one hereditary disease only benefit that small group, not all sufferers of any disease, doctors could spend more time with their other patients and money that would otherwise be spent on hopeless causes would flow into other areas.


r/steelmanning • • Jul 09 '18

Steelman Inequality or the unequal distribution of wealth or anything isn’t a political problem and analysing it politically is the wrong way to go about addressing the causes.

14 Upvotes

Equality cannot be solved through political means because it’s not at its core a political issue or even caused by politics or economics, it’s an issue much deeper on the levels of biology and psychology.

Inequality exist in our society regardless of economic or political systems, while inequality can become worst or better it’s always present and it will never ever be or will be at a level that we are satisfied with.

The problem is we see the unequal distribution of let’s say wealth as a political issue and analyse it using the wrong lens (a political lens) a hint that inequality isn’t an political issue Is price’s law. The majority of scientific papers are published by a very small group of scientists, a tiny proportion of musicians produces almost all of the recorded commercial music, just a handful of authors sell all the books, you can apply this principle of unequal distribution to every aspect of society as well as everything outside of our society to for example the mass of heavenly bodies which a very few hoard most of the matter, this seems to hint at unequal distribution is a natural state that exists outside of the political arena and until we understand this we will continue to make political, social and economic decisions on false and wrong assumptions.


r/steelmanning • • Jul 07 '18

Steelman Farmers are the ideal Marxist. They own their own means of production.

10 Upvotes

Farmers own their own means of production. Yet are universally hated by Marxists. Why might that be? Wouldn't a farmer be the ideal Marxist? A worker who owns their own means of production? If Marxists believe that Marxism is the workers owning the means of production, why is their first step towards Marxism abolishing private property? That seems to be a glaring contradiction.

In the United States the idea of freedom and liberty orbit around the idea of an individuals private property. Freedom in the US does not mean, "just do whatever you want." No, there is a complex moral framework in the context of American freedom that stems from the Lockean social contract and a hodge podge of enlightenment economic theory.

For example Lockean labor theory of value is essential to understanding the American perception of freedom. Someone who works the land in conjunction with a legal claim is said to own it. Land cannot just be owned by idle capital. It must be actively improved upon to be considered truly owned. A merchant who, like a parasite, makes all of their income off of rent is not adding to the economy and more often then not not improving the land they exploit through rents. In this way when analyzing Marxist theory ideas when it comes to abolishing private property we can say rent is what is meant to be abolished, not a situation where the worker owns their own means of production.

How does the contradiction of the petite bourgeois come into play? If they own their own store front or farm how are they exploiting the anyone? If they are both owner and worker who is being exploited? If workers own their own means of production, do they not immediately become owners? Or the enemy, bourgeois?

In conclusion my critique of Marxism and private property are meant to outline the reality of how ownership is not intrinsically tied to exploitation. Rent and other forms of usury applied to private property are. Rent is one of the most abhorrent forms of usury in the modern world. It is parasitic and takes value from hard working people. Rent adds nothing to the economy. It builds no equity. It seems to me the only people who want to abolish private property, don't own any. In my opinion, when Marx calls for the abolition of private property he does not mean the small farmers. He means the absentee landlords.


r/steelmanning • • Aug 13 '18

Steelmaning Request: existence of the Christian God.

16 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jul 19 '18

Topic Using 'Men are the problem' is unreasonable.

22 Upvotes

So to expand on my main idea. I think that when referring to violence statistics, it is reasonable to say that violence is more often perpetrated by men, but it is not reasonable to use masculinity or men generalization as a basis for an argument about tackling these issues.

So for context, I am wanting to construct better arguments as I am constantly arguing with one of my teachers in class (it is civilized) about her extreme feminist viewpoints. I should say that I do agree with most of what feminism stands for and do not really think that her points are 'real feminism' (I am aware that this falls into the 'no true Scotsman' fallacy but my main point here is that I do think that feminism is ok, I am not anti feminist, it is just that sometimes there are bad apples in feminism and I think that my teacher is one of those bad apples). Her obvious extreme feminist view points are for example

  1. Men cannot be raped because a guy cannot get a boner if he is not consenting and that a guy cannot get a hard on in his sleep (has she not ever heard of morning wood)

  2. Men deserve to suffer because women have suffered from sexism (just obviously destructive, I even pointed out that do you think I (18 and in high school, am white and male) have to suffer from what people did 60 years ago, and she basically justified it. That is racism and sexism right there as I have not even done anything with my privilege against a non privileged person and it is based on skin and sex)

She also changes the topic a lot, like when she said talked about domestic violence, I sad that in Australia domestic violence is around 60-40 so I think it is not a high enough proportion to say that it is a women's issue, I think saying that is just neglectful to the men who are victims. She then changes it to sexual violence. She said that violence is a women's issue and I pointed out that most of the victims of violence are men 8% where women are 6%, so she changed it to who does the violence.

So now my arguments are against the classic lines of 'men should stop raping', and 'men should change'.

  1. This is an unfair generalization. Imagine if it was something said like, black people should stop committing crimes. That is obviously racist, and justly so is that sexist.

  2. Most perpetrators of violence are men, but most men are not violent. These lines give a misrepresentation of how men are violent. It assumes that they are violent by nature but really it is just a small proportion.

  3. It is just calling names and assuming everyone is an assaulter.

Please do give strong counter arguments and also some other points which will help my argument. Also if you do think that one of my arguments could be better, by all means help me there. Thanks for reading and sorry for the mess.


r/steelmanning • • May 23 '19

7 logical fallacies you need to avoid

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
17 Upvotes

r/steelmanning • • Jun 21 '18

The Argument For Social Justice

13 Upvotes

As someone who stands wholeheartedly against the social justice movement. I'm curious if there is anyone willing to engage in a debate on the topic. I'm interested in steelmanning both sides of the argument so that we can figure out when social justice is appropriate and when it overreaches.

Edit: For clarification purposes I view social justice (in it's current state) as the use of identity politics, political correctness, feminist theories and other related concepts to achieve what they believe to be societal progress.


r/steelmanning • • Jun 29 '18

Steelman State skepticism

4 Upvotes

If I have obligations to a state then they can be explained by a theory and a history that manifests the theory.

If there is such a theory and manifesting history that explains obligations to a state then the state would promote these in an effort to have people respect these obligations. Especially during times of civil unrest.

No state promotes, or has ever promoted such a theory and manifesting history, which demonstrates that I have no obligations to a state.

Belief declaration: I think this argument is sound.

Edit: steelman v1.1 in a comment below.


r/steelmanning • • Jul 04 '18

Topic Star Wars: The Last Jedi

15 Upvotes

I hope film discussion is ok here. It seems like the perfect thing to try to steelman.

Obviously this whole thing requires spoilers so go see the movie before you read on if you somehow haven’t already. I know this topic is a firebrand on some subreddits, but in many of the discussions I’ve seen one side or the other is dismissed in some way. For example, many think that the critics of this movie are sexists or misogynists and I’m sure the critics think the people that love it have just been sucked in by... actually I don’t know what so I won’t put words in their mouths.

Can we have a discussion where we get to the substance of the criticism of this movie and the counterpoints to it?

Here are a few common sub-topics to spark discussion:

  1. Holdo not telling Poe the plan. My personal opinion is that it isn’t a problem per se that Holdo didn’t share the plan with Poe but the manner in which she did so. She seemed to both understand that she was dealing with a hothead who didn’t trust her and do the exact opposite of what would help calm him down in the “we’re all going to die” moment that he was in. This runs counter to characterization of Holdo as an amazing admiral. She didn’t seem like a leader until after the turn, which made the hiding part feel contrived. That said, it took me many watchings of the movie to realize how obviously sexist Poe was being when he said, “THAT’s admiral Holdo?” I think a lot of the reading of Poe is based on whether that seemed sexist early on to the viewer. If so, then Holdo’s behavior towards him makes more sense, but I still find her behavior not terribly convincing as a military leader.

  2. Rose and Finn’s story. I don’t really have much to say on this that isn’t entirely subjective so I’d like the critics reading this to expand on what they see as the lacking parts of this portion of the story. What are the key elements that seem off?

  3. Luke’s change from Return of the Jedi. I actually loved this portrayal, and I don’t know the substance of the criticism here beyond “I didn’t like it” so please elaborate here as well.

Despite the above I absolutely loved the movie. Visually it was great, and though I think it does have a few clear weak points they are (in my opinion) overwhelmed by the positives. I’d be interested to pull out the meat of the negatives though, if that’s possible.


r/steelmanning • • Dec 03 '18

If government is to claim just taxing powers it must explain the jump from the real to the ideal

10 Upvotes

You get a tax bill from your government and you pay it. There is nothing extraordinary about this story. It happens billions of time a year around the world. But there are actually two stories there, the real and the ideal. The real story is about how you get a bill and you pay it. The ideal is that it is a government that is sending you a summary of your tax obligations, and you are satisfying those obligations.

The real can be simply observed. We know it happened because we saw it. The ideal takes more work. We must clarify our ideas and map them on to the real.

I can get a bill and pay it in a way that has nothing to do with taxes. Like when I ordered my new cell phone. Paying that bill is distinct from paying taxes. It is a different kind of obligation. I agreed to pay for a product. The product was sent to me and now I have an obligation to pay for it. This series of step, often called a contract, takes us from the real to the ideal.

There are few ways to make this jump. Above was one way. Crime is another. If I violate you then I have an obligation to make you whole as though I never violated you. If I make a human life then I am obligated to nurture it.

If I do, in fact, have an obligation to pay a bill then there is a real story that explains that obligation. The story will begin with no obligation and end with an obligation. To begin with a government is to begin with an asymmetry in obligation. To explain an obligation to an ideal like government we must begin with ungoverned men. We must explain how these men created the obligations of government.

Does that clearly explain why appealing to statutes to explain tax obligations is merely to recast the problem?