r/StarTrekViewingParty • • 17d ago

Announcement Remembering Patrick Stewart and Walter Koenig

96 Upvotes

STVP remembers Patrick Stewart and Walter Koenig, who both passed away within the past few days.

Chekov is really a minor character in the context of TOS (at least from the modern lens), but he brought a lot of energy and humor with the screentime he had. I think it's easy to forget how important his presence was in the cold war era; a Russian on the bridge of the ship. That's something. And away from the screen, by all accounts he was a wonderful human being.

Picard is the second captain that I remember watching. Kirk was first, but I watched the most of Picard growing up. There are quotes of his that I still repeat to this day. It's a masterful performance and a masterful character. There's a lot of depth and nuance in a lot of his performances, and watching him act alongside people like Spiner and DeLancie is great. A lot of underrated humor too. I was honored to meet Stewart briefly, long ago, and he came across as a very friendly and intelligent guy.

The death of Stewart is like realizing that your family can, and will, in fact, die. It's a sobering reminder of the march of time. Now that I have kids, watching them grow up, it hits differently.

That's all I wanted to say.


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Jan 05 '18

Supplemental I made episode guides for each Trek series that aggregate ratings and ranks from sources all over the web into one awesome spreadsheet per series, enjoy!

79 Upvotes

I started re-watching the Trek series a few months ago (my first time trying to binge them all), but I didn't have time to watch all the episodes, so I wanted to find which ones were generally considered the best or essential to watch. Plus, I haven't seen every episode of Trek, so maybe I'd find some gems I'd missed before. I started looking around at different sites, but quickly became overwhelmed. I was curious if I could assemble an aggregated ranking of ALL trek episodes, per show and season, to build a sort of automated "watch guide" that I could then customize to fit the episode load that best worked with my schedule.

After many hours of searching the web and toying with Google Sheets, I finished the following collection of watch guides, one for each Trek series, that I now present for you to enjoy:

The guides

Each spreadsheet aggregates ratings and ranks across sites like IMDB, Ex Astris Scientia, AV Club, Penksy Podcast, and more, for all episodes, into a couple customizable views (all generated automatically from the source data). There are three primary sheets per document:

  • Basic watch guide: For those who just want a quick recommendation, highlights the most highly ranked episodes in the series by season.

  • Custom watch guide: For a deeper dive, allows you to specify an "optimal load" of episodes to watch per season (copy the document to make your selection). It will then show you the n top ranked episodes per season (based on the number you selected), and the top n * (number of seasons) episodes for the whole series (in episode order), depending on how you want your journey to progress. Also provides a few extra columns, like the exact averages and deviations, for analysis.

  • Best episodes: Unlike the previous two sheets, this one does not maintain episode order, and instead ranks the episodes of the whole series from best to worst. Copy the document and you can change how you want to judge the top ranked: By average rank or average rating (since not all sources have both).

"Essential" episodes

Incorporated into each sheet is another scoring dimension: An indicator of "essential" episodes (i.e. considered critical to plot, or feature a major event, like the introduction or departure of a character). Each episode's watch-or-not recommendation will take this into account: If the episode is very highly ranked, it will be marked as "Watch" regardless of plot importance. Otherwise, it must have been deemed an "essential" episode by some source (configurable), or it will be listed as "Optional watch" (similarly, episodes that fall just below the rating threshold, but are still essential, are marked as "Consider watch").

Understandably, what episodes count as "essential" is up for debate, and I'm not sure I've captured it 100% to my satisfaction here, but I think it's a key element that a watch guide must have to be truly useful. I've found it very helpful in my own journey thus far. I'd like to incorporate more sources, to mitigate potential bias, but for now I just have one for each series: Watch guides from various authors at r/DaystromInstitute (linked in each sheet). I started work in a few of the sheets to try and chart each individual plot thread and major character arc in detail, to provide a more decisive recommendation, but I didn't get far (lots of work...), so the daystrom guides work well enough for now.

I think in a perfect world I'd have objectively based (as possible) determinations of plot importance to pair with the more subjective ratings/rankings, with three basic levels: Low, medium, and high. Right now it's a simple "yes or no" decision, but I think a three-tiered approach would best capture the difference between episodes that truly are critical versus those that are simply referenced later.

Other notes

Both ratings and rankings are aggregated using a weighted average. Sources with only ratings have are given ranks for each episode according to those ratings (with identical ratings given the same rank). The average rank and rating for each episode across all sources are displayed in the "Custom watch guide" and "Best episodes" sheets, along with an "Overall rank" column based on if you chose to prioritize rank or rating in your final watch score. All sources have their ratings converted to a 10-point scale (I copied Metacritic's thresholds for this), but are not normalized. However, I left the option in each source sheet to do so.

There's some other cool tidbits in here as well. If you look at the Ratings or Rankings sheets, you can compare the converted ranks/ratings from each source side by side, with highlighting of the specific ratings that deviated strongly from the other sources (e.g. which sources tend to rate higher or lower than others, and for which episodes).

As a side note, I made the documents easily reproducable for almost any TV series, not just Trek. You just need to input the episode names and numbers into one sheet (Episodes), and then create separate sheets for each rating or ranking source (supports rank-only as well as normalization of 10-point, 4-star, and A-F grade ratings). Just list the sheet names under Ratings or Rankings, and it will auto-generate the rest of the document!

Hope you enjoy! Let me know if you'd like another source of ratings and/or rankings introduced, and I'll check it out.

Sources

All sources are linked in each sheet, but here's a summary of the sites I used:

[edit] Added trakt.tv


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Sep 30 '24

Announcement Community Update

43 Upvotes

Greetings Shipmates!

Just wanted to provide a community update to everyone. We will be kicking off our inaugural second watch-through of Star Trek within the next couple of weeks. Voyager was lost in the Delta Quadrant for 7 years, and by my calculations it will take us roughly the same amount of time to journey through every series of Star Trek. We hope you will join us as you’re able. We don’t want this to feel like a commitment to anyone. We expect, and want, you to pop in and out anyway that fits your lifestyle. If you want to tag along for the entire ride. . . we would love that as well! Remember, our only goal is to WATCH STAR TREK TOGETHER! Details are as follows:

STARTING SERIES: The Next Generation. We debated back and forth a bit about how we wanted to start things off, but ultimately landed with TNG.  

FREQUENCY: We will be watching TWO episodes per week, both of which will have separate discussion threads posted simultaneously on Sunday each week. This will give everyone the chance to watch and comment at their own pace without feeling a sense of urgency. You can keep conversations going on a specific episode well after we move past it, in fact we encourage you to do so if you’re having good interactions.

START DATE: 13 October 2024 is when the first discussion threads will go up for Encounter at Far Point: Part 1 and Part 2.

We will be conducting our pre-departure checks between now and the 13th and expect to see everyone on-board as we push out of space dock for departure . . . . to boldly go where no subreddit has gone before!

Clear skies and calm winds

Live Long and Prosper

~STVP Mod Team


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Jan 04 '26

Discussion TNG, Episode 5x26, Time's Arrow

40 Upvotes

-= TNG, Season 5, Episode 26, Time's Arrow =-

An engineering team finds evidence of an alien presence on Earth in 19th century San Francisco: Data's severed head, buried five hundred years ago.

 


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Aug 06 '16

Discussion DS9, Episode 1x1 & 1x2, Emissary

34 Upvotes

-= DS9, Season 1, Episodes 1 & 2, Emissary =-

A new crew is assigned to a former Cardassian space station: Deep Space Nine. It is a joint Federation/Bajoran force, with Commander Sisko in charge, but his life is dramatically changed when he is declared the Emissary to the Prophets by a Bajoran priest.

 

EASIMDBAVClubTV.com
8/107.4/10B8.6 (I) & 8.7 (II)

 


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Jul 27 '16

Discussion TNG, Episode 7x25, All Good Things...

34 Upvotes

TNG, Season 7, Episode 25, All Good Things...

Picard learns from Q that he is to be the cause of the annihilation of Humanity and begins an incredible journey through time from the present, to the past when he first took command of the Enterprise, to twenty-five years into the future.

We did it! Thanks to everyone for following along the past couple years. Here's to many more to come!


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Oct 13 '24

Discussion TNG, 1x01/02, Encounter at Farpoint

32 Upvotes

Welcome aboard the USS STVP! This post marks the official start of our 7 year mission. Thanks for joining us, and we expect to see each of you when we return to space dock August 2032!. Engage!

-= TNG, Season 1, Episode 01/02, Encounter at Farpoint =-

Captain Jean-Luc Picard leads the crew of the USS Enterprise-D on its maiden voyage, to examine a new planetary station for trade with the Federation.


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Sep 25 '24

Announcement Red Alert! Reboot Imminent

32 Upvotes

This community was created when two Star Trek fans bumped into one another on this digital highway we call the internet, and decided they wanted to share insights, memories, thoughts, and discussions with one another as they re-watched some of the most beloved television from their childhoods. That evolved into us creating this subreddit and wanting to share that journey more broadly with YOU. We had a great inaugural run, and created a lot of wonderful discussions and moments between fans. Evolving and learning along the way. To those of you have contributed or enjoyed the posts here, I want to say THANK YOU.

The subreddit has been dormant for some time now, and I am looking to breath new life into it by rebooting our initial mission. TO WATCH STAR TREK TOGETHER. As we are approaching our 10 year anniversary, I can think of no better time to start that mission than now. That being said, as we develop a new plan of action on the subreddits path forward, we would love to hear from you on any feedback you have. My initial inclination is to select what series we will watch via community polling.

So click on the notification button for the sub and keep an eye out for more details as we develop a gameplan internally. To old fans and members, we hope to welcome you back. To new fans who are just joining the Star Trek fandom, we hope you enjoy the ride as much as we did. Live Long and Prosper!


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Dec 18 '17

Discussion DS9, Episode 6x19, In the Pale Moonlight

32 Upvotes

-= DS9, Season 6, Episode 19, In the Pale Moonlight =-

Sisko asks Garak to help him get the Romulans to join the war against the Dominion.

 

EASIMDBAVClubTV.com
8/109.3/10A-9.5

 


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Aug 06 '16

Announcement We have just broken one thousand subscribers!

32 Upvotes

It's been quite an eventful few weeks here at STVP with the end of TNG, our "50 Days of Trek" events and the start of DS9 today. Coinciding perfectly with our first episode of the new series we have broken through the thousand subscriber mark with a day that shatters the records for most subs in a day! Thank you everyone for making our little community just a little bit bigger!


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Apr 16 '17

Discussion DS9, Episode 4x3, The Visitor

31 Upvotes

-= DS9, Season 4, Episode 3, The Visitor =-

An elderly Jake Sisko relates the story of how he lost his father to a temporal displacement accident.

 

EASIMDBAVClubTV.com
8/109.1/10A9.2

 


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Oct 05 '16

Discussion DS9, Episode 1x19, Duet

30 Upvotes

-= DS9, Season 1, Episode 19, Duet =-

A visiting Cardassian, Marritza, may in fact be the notorious war criminal Gul Darhe'el, butcher of Gallitep Labor camp, and Kira is determined to bring him down.

 

EASIMDBAVClubTV.com
7/109/10A9.3

 


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • May 01 '16

Announcement Congratulations, /r/StarTrekViewingParty. You're the Tiny Subreddit of the Day!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
30 Upvotes

r/StarTrekViewingParty • • May 21 '21

Just checking in

29 Upvotes

Just wanted to let everyone know that I haven't forgotten about this place. I'm in the middle of a move so I've been busy, but I have some plans. Revamping the styling of the sub for simplicity is one, and coming up with a new, easier schedule for everyone to watch along with. Stay tuned!


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Jul 31 '17

Discussion DS9, Episode 5x6, Trials and Tribble-ations

29 Upvotes

-= DS9, Season 5, Episode 6, Trials and Tribble-ations =-

Darvin, a disgraced Klingon spy, travels back in time. The DS9 crew must prevent him from altering the timeline.

 

EASIMDBAVClubTV.com
10/109.3/10A9.5

 


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Aug 16 '21

What next?

28 Upvotes

So, first off, apologies again for not attending to this sub sooner. It's taken a back seat to a lot of other stuff I have going on in my life.

But STVP is still very important to me. I don't want to see it die, even if that's a bit beyond my ability to stop at this point.

So, what's next? Do we go back and rewatch everything again? I'd like to see what people's thoughts are. Potentially it would be something that's once a week instead of twice a week, but some folks also prefer a faster pace. Lemme know.

I'll also be setting up things with scheduled posts so I won't fall behind. Less overhead overall should make things go smoother.


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Sep 12 '24

Who would be interested in another viewing party?

27 Upvotes

I’ve been lurking this subreddit for years now since I’ve watched through TNG and halfway through DS9, I’ve checked the posts for each episode but I’d love to join for another watch through and hear what everything thinks years after the original viewing parties.

I’m not sure how active the moderation here is but I hope we can organise something and even gather a group of people to join and contribute to the episode discussions, doing a redux of sorts.

Please comment your thoughts I’m interested to hear if anyone is down!

Edit: Theoretically we would star at TOS and work from there, which would be awesome because I’ve never seen it before and I’ve been planning to watch it after DS9


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Dec 24 '25

Discussion TNG, Episode 5x21, The Perfect Mate

26 Upvotes

-= TNG, Season 5, Episode 21, The Perfect Mate =-

Picard serves as host for a peace treaty between two warring planets, but he may be unable to resist the reconciliation "gift" -- a beautiful empathic metamorph who is to be presented by one leader as the other's wife.

 


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Nov 22 '17

Discussion DS9, Episode 6x12, Who Mourns for Morn?

25 Upvotes

-= DS9, Season 6, Episode 12, Who Mourns for Morn? =-

Morn is killed in an ion storm and Sisko informs Quark that Morn left his entire estate to him. But Quark has a little competition.

 

EASIMDBAVClubTV.com
5/107.6/10B+8

 


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Jan 04 '26

Discussion TNG, Episode 5x25, The Inner Light

24 Upvotes

-= TNG, Season 5, Episode 25, The Inner Light =-

An alien probe controls and disables Captain Picard, who wakes up as "Kamin" a resident of the planet Kataan.

 


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Dec 08 '16

Time Warp Throwback Thursday: TNG, 7x15, Lower Decks

Thumbnail
reddit.com
24 Upvotes

r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Jun 22 '16

Discussion TNG, Episode 7x15, Lower Decks

24 Upvotes

TNG, Season 7, Episode 15, Lower Decks

Junior officers speculate on the reasons for recent unusual actions taken by the command crew near the Cardassian border.


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Jun 19 '16

Discussion TNG, Episode 7x14, Sub Rosa

23 Upvotes

TNG, Season 7, Episode 14, Sub Rosa

Beverly Crusher attends her grandmother's funeral, but a mysterious entity that inhabited her grandmother is now focusing on her.


6/23/16 Announcement -- I'd like to point out to everyone that Ghost Sex Sub Rosa is now the 8th 3rd 1st highest commented episode discussion in STVP history, and the most commented in over a year since S2... That's a good thing, right?


r/StarTrekViewingParty • • Aug 23 '26

Discussion Final Thoughts

22 Upvotes

Wow! We are officially at the end of TNG. It's hard to believe that we started this journey (for the second time) over 2 years ago. Thank you to all the crewmembers who have joined us along the way. We hope you have enjoyed it as much as we have.

To close out the season, we wanted to have a post where you could post your final thoughts on TNG as a whole. What did the show mean to you? What was your favorite season, characters, or moments? TNG was an entry point for so many Star Trek fans, so feel free to share!

-----INCOMING NEW TRANSMISSION-----

You know what they say ... Every goodbye is just an opening to the next act! Don't put away those uniforms just yet! You have all been reassigned station Deep Space Nine. We are ditching the Enterprise for something a little more. . . stationary.

We are excited to start Season 1, Episode 1/2 of Deep Space Nine next week! Hope to see you all there as we being our nearly TWO YEAR watch-through of the series.

Live Long and Prosper,

- STVP Mod Team