r/DaystromInstitute • • Dec 08 '19

In Memoriam Rene Auberjonois has passed away

1.9k Upvotes

Actor René Auberjonois (most significantly, Odo, but also Colonel West, Ezral from ENT: Oasis, and known for Benson, Boston Legal, the M*A*S*H film, and much more) has died today at the age of 79 after battling metastatic lung cancer.

Share your thoughts and reflections here.


AP News.

r/startrek thread.


r/DaystromInstitute • • 17d ago

In Memoriam Patrick Stewart has passed away

1.6k Upvotes

Actor Patrick Stewart has passed away.

A statement from his family reads:

We announce with great sorrow the passing of Sir Patrick Stewart yesterday at his home in Los Angeles, in the loving care of his beloved wife Sunny, following a brief and poignant journey with Alzheimer’s Disease and Lewy Body Dementia. He has been held in the warm embrace of family and friends, surrounded by live music, prayer, tears, laughter, and the kind of profound emotion that only he could inspire after a lifetime of devotion to us all. We will forever cherish the peaceful ease and reflection on his face, an enduring reminder of his invincible grace.

A son of Mirfield in the West Riding of Yorkshire, he travelled from the Royal Shakespeare Company to an equally acclaimed career spanning six decades on Broadway, the silver screen and television.

His sonorous voice and singular talent will forever be synonymous with indelible performances in every genre. He explored the human condition in all its poetic complexity and brought hope not only to the far reaches of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but into science fiction’s most iconic final frontier aboard the Starship Enterprise.

His professional accomplishments were humbly matched by his philanthropy and activism on behalf of human rights, survivors of domestic violence, global refugees, veterans’ mental health services, and animal welfare, particularly his cherished foster pitties. He was a Knight, Chancellor, motor sport enthusiast, and lifelong Huddersfield Football fan. He will be remembered for the dignity, compassion and humanity he brought to every role - in his art and life.

“Like me, Jean-Luc has lived an unusual life that has taken him far beyond the bounds of normal human experience. But he is also someone who has remained true to his earthbound roots, for they are what gave him his identity. In the end, he feels the call of home, as do I.”
— Patrick Stewart, Making It So: A Memoir

The family says memorial contributions may be made to Johns Hopkins Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center Fund and Alzheimer’s Foundation of America Caregiver Resources.

Thoughts, reflections, and memories may be shared in this thread.


BBC

NY Times

Variety


r/DaystromInstitute • • Sep 01 '20

Cardassians are Star Trek's most fascinating race. Why? Because they're the most human. They are also especially fascinating to non-Western fans. Here's why

1.4k Upvotes

This is a bit of an essay. Sorry for the long post but please believe me that I couldn't make this any shorter without sacrficing essential details. I made it as short as I possibly could to the best of my abilities.

I'm a life long Star Trek fan. Yet it was only this year that I watched DS9 for the first time. However, I was already fascinated by the Cardassians in TNG, specifically from the two-part Chains of Command. However, I am from and live in a country where I can get to appreciate the Cardassians far more than any Trekkie in a developed, western democracy.

They are the most fleshed out race and civilisation in all of Trek. Far more than the Klingons, the Romulans, the Vulcans, the Changelings, the Borg, the Ferengi. You get my point.

Why do I say so? Because each of these races were intended to be one-dimensional extremes or manifestations of one or two human characteristics. The Klingons are grunting machos. The Romulans are cunning fiends. The Vulcans are rational objective thinkers. The Changelings are the bullied who became bullies. The Borg are all-conquering Mongols. The Ferengi are capitalists. I know that I must have missed some nuances but these descriptions are the gist of it and are what is intended by the writers. Each race is meant for the audiences to look at one or two aspects of their humanity vividly.

It is not so easy to put the Cardassians into such a box. There were so complex and multi-faceted. The episodes where this really becomes exemplified are S1 E18 "Duet", S2 E5 "Cardassians", S2 E18 "Profit and Loss", and S3 E5 "Second Skin." In these episodes you really get to see the very complex political and social situation on Cardassia. They aren't a monolithic people represented by the state. They have dissidents. They have anti-government activitists. They have people who want revolution. They have high ranking military officers who want regime change. In these episodes and over the course of DS9, Cardassians were shown to be as diverse and difficult to fully describe as humans are.

"Second Skin" really hit me emotionally. Ghemor is no different than any human parent who wishes to be reunited with their long lost child. The drama of his character and the interplay between him and Kira was not alien or unrelatable at all. These episodes were especially heartbreaking because they were a big reminder of the tragedy my own country is.

This brings me to how Cardassia is especially fascinating and difficult for someone like me to watch. I've seen many of you comparing the Cardassian Union to fascist Italy or the Third Reich. I would disagree because Cardassia is typical of a third-world military dictatorship on present-day Earth. There were military dictatorships in the recent past just like them in South America and there are ones today in Africa, the Arab world, and Asia whose politics and internal security practices are exactly like the Cardassian Union.

These dicatorships are poor, mid-level regional powers with bloated military budgets spent at the expense of their people. I am not revealing my country or my continent because my own country has an internal security and intelligence agencies just like the Obsidian Order. They can hear and see and know everything and make people disappear exclusively for something you post on the internet. They are also very powerful and have much more influence and control over government than our "elected" parliament. Their agents could be the guy who is selling you fruit and vegetables on the street corner, or even a plain simple tailor who speaks in half truths and in a very devious opaque manner.

The torture scene in Chains of Command is just too real. The way our own dissidents and suspected terrorists are treated in our own secret facilities is exactly the same. The interrogator is usually a well and softly spoken man who tries to befriend you while doing monstrous things to you simultaneously. My skin crawled watching that episode and remembering testimonials from our torture victims.

Lastly, the Cardassian justice system was not something the writers creatively came up with. It was merely a literal and explicit depiction of how the justice systems in these petty military dictatorships actually work. If you are arrested for political reasons, the authorities have already decided what's going to happen to you. It might as well be as explicit as it is on Cardassia. The trial is just for show, to show the people how victorious the state is over its enemies and send a warning to anyone who dares to even think a single thought of dissent.

I hope you found my essay interesting and I hope you've learned something new. And I hope that you will appreciate the Cardassians even more and perhaps in a whole new way. This is why they are my favourite race.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Sep 22 '19

In Memoriam Aron Eisenberg has passed away

1.4k Upvotes

StarTrek.com obituary

Statement from his wife, Malíssa Longo

What a terrible loss. It's always hard for me to find the words in situations like this, but I do want to extend an invitation for everyone to share what Aron and his character Nog meant to them. My thoughts go out to his family.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jul 09 '20

From the perspective of the Borg, the Federation is terrifying

1.4k Upvotes

Imagine. We are the Borg. We are happily assimilating the Delta Quadrant. Resistence is futile as species after species is added to our collective. One day we receive a subspace message sent from the past from the other side of the galaxy. This message is from ourself directing us to an unexplored sector of the Alpha Quadrant. Is it a target? Is it a warning?

To be cautious, we send a reconissence craft to the very outskirts of Federation territory. We easily assimilate a Federation outpost. Their resistence was futile. In their database we learn about a mortal enemy of the Federation. The Romulans. We assimilate their nearest outpost and again, resistance is futile. We analyse the Federation. There is nothing unique about them. Their technology is less advanced than many of the other species we have already assimilated, yet there must be something more, how else can we explain the message from the past?

As we decide how to proceed, a Federation ship appears out of nowhere in system J25. This system is thousands of lightyears from Federation territory. We send a cube to investigate. We analyze the ship. While it has some technology that we can assimilate, how did it get here? The propulsion system is obsolete. We decide to proceed with standard assimilation protocols and just as we are about to defeat them, they disappear in the blink of an eye. But how? There must be something we have yet to discover. It is time for an assult into the heart of their territory.

We decide to send a cube to Sector 001, the heart of the Federation. Maybe on Earth we will discover the reason for the message from the past. The USS Enterprise approaches. The same ship we encountered in J25. They will not escape this time. We capture Jean Luc Picard and easily assimilate him. As we absorb his knowledge into the collective you learn about the entity known as "Q". This entiry seems more powerful than anything we've ever encountered. Why is it trying to help the Federation prepare for our assault?

We decide to continue on to Sector 001. As we move furtherr into their terrritory we wipe away all resistence. We easily destroy an armada at Wolf 359. This is going well with minimal loss of resources. We've fought stronger opponents than this many times in the past. We make it to Earth, and as we start planning the assimilation of the planet, the cube begins acting strangely. As communication begins to fail we detect our ship has been destroyed. How? There is no Federation technology that can do this. Was it a warning from the past? Was this more interference from this "Q"?

Wecdetect a distress signal from a crashed Borg ship in a remote system. There is another cube within several days travel which we divert it to investigate. We discover a lone drone has survived. As we begin the standard upload process to reintegrate him back into the collective, we find a cascade error. The Federation found the drone first. We do not know how, but somehow it has been sabotaged by the Federation. As the error begins to ripple through the collective we are forced in a panic to disconnect the entire cube. The Federation are even more cunning than we expected. Now they are using our own drones against us. Perhaps we need to reevaluate how we are going to deal with the Federation.

We begin analysing the history of the Federation, trying to find a clue as to why there were Borg in the past. What were they attempting to do? Searching through the memories of assmiliated Federation citizens, we keep noticing the event referred to as First Contact and the founding of the Federation. Perhaps the message from the past is telling us the way to defeat the Federation is to stop it from being founded. To stop first contact. We send another ship. This time it isnt as easy to get to Earth. The Federation is stronger, their weapons more powerful. They are adapting. We barely get to Earth before our cube is destroyed. In desperation we launch our time travel sphere. We detect the sphere enter the time travel vortex, but.... nothing changes. The Federation is still there. Our attempts to defeat the Federation in the past have somehow failed. In fact there is some sort of paradox. Is it possible we created the Federation with the action we just took? Have we unleashed this monster?

For a time we decide to give the Federation a wide berth, while we consider our next move. They seem to be keeping to their side of the galaxy. We turn your attention to a new relm of space which we have discovered. Fluidic space. We engage Species 8472, and realize they are unbeatable. We lose battle after battle. We are losing entire sectors of space, thousands of cubes, millions of drones. One day, out of nowhere a small Federation ship appears thousands of lightyears from know Federation territory. This time, they offer us a solution to our problem with species 8472. How is this possible? They do not have the technology travel this far out, is this another one of "Q"s tricks? There is no reason that Federation should be involved, yet here they are, offering us the technology to defeat an enemy who is more powerful than anything we've encountered before. Why are they offering us this help? What is their endgame?

We cannot destroy Species 8472, they are too powerful. We order our last remaining drone on the Federation ship to enter fluidic space. We know it is a lost cause, but it is the only option left at this point. We watch as the Federation ship opens a rift into fluid a space and disappears. We recall the first expedition we took into fluidic space. Hundreds Cubes destroyed in minutes. It is over, species 8472 is going to destroy the galaxy. Suddenly we detect Species 8472 retreating across the front. Somehow the Federation has won. We detect the Federation ship reemerge from fluidic space. Now is our chance to assimilate them to find out their secrets but the Federation ship escapes. The next time we detect it, it is now thousands of light years away again. How are they travelling this fast? What power do they hold? They destroy several of our ships to steal transwarp coils. They are on the offensive now. We manage to finally assimilate Janeway. We learn they are the only Federation ship in the entire Delta Quadrant and they have done all this by themselves. Now we have them. But then they infiltrate our mainframe and liberate thousands of drones from unimatrix zero. As the Federation ship escapes again, we don't have time to go after them. Our empire is now fighting a rebellion for the first time. The Federation is continuing to turn our own drones against us. Even Seven of Nine, a drone who had been with us since she was a child has turned against the Collective.

One day we receive a subspace signal from a Borg drone. This drone is from the future and is advanced beyond anything the Collective has assimilated, yet somehow it is on the Federation ship. How did it get there? We have no record of this drone. We must attempt to recover it. We manage to retrieve it from the Federation but when it joins us, it uses its future technology to destroy our ship and we never hear from it again. A message from the past? A drone from the future? How is going on?

Then one day we detect the Federation ship enter the nebula containing our transwarp hub. The Federation ship retreats but we observe a Federation shuttle arrive from a time vortex. They are trying to use time travel to attack us, just as we failed to do to them Suddenly the Federation ship returns to the nebula, it has technology that we've never seen before. Our weapons are ineffective. We manage to capture a Federation Captain from the future. She will not escape this time. When we attempt to assimilate her, she introduces a virus into the unimatrix. As our systems are failing, we watch as the transwarp hub collapses. One sphere makes it through to Earth, but again our vessel is destroyed in Sector 001. The Federation is the most terrifying civilization we have ever encountered.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jun 19 '18

Voyager spent the first 2 years literally flying in circles, to gather supplies

1.3k Upvotes

Two of the longtime gripes with Voyager are 1) how it takes so long to get through Kazon/Vidiian space, which are both seemingly larger than the Federation, and 2) how the plot point that Voyager has limited supplies was mostly forgotten after a couple of seasons.

Summary:

I propose there is a simple in-universe explanation for this: Voyager spent the first 2 years flying in circles through space Neelix was familiar with, gathering supplies in preparation for their long journey home. By the end of season 2, Voyager was essentially the same distance from home as they were in Caretaker, but had gathered enough supplies to survive a long trip (including a lot more photon torpedoes).

This theory solves a number of problems, and makes intuitive sense.

Voyager’s problem, after all, is not really that it’s a small ship, as many of us tend to think. In fact Voyager is roughly the same size as a Constitution Class ship. Voyager’s problem at the outset is simply that it was not outfitted for a long mission. They were supposed to find Chakotay and then return to base. The ship is capable of an independent deep space assignment, as later seasons prove, it simply wasn’t prepared for one in Caretaker. Thus, they had to outfit themselves.

There are a number of key clues that Voyager was flying in circles. Some of them are overt, others are merely implied.

We keep running in to the same people

The most important piece of evidence is that we keep running into the same people. It’s not just that Voyager takes a long time to get through Kazon and Vidiian space; it’s that we keep running into Seska and Cullah and Danara Pel, in encounters that are months apart. If Voyager had been making anything even remotely resembling a bee-line for home, even assuming Kazon & Vidiian space is gigantic, they would have left all of those individuals behind shortly after their initial encounter.

But we keep seeing them over and over again, and not in adjacent episodes. Either there’s a fleet of people who’ve all abandoned their lives in order to stay close to Voyager, or Voyager is returning time and again to the same areas of space. The latter is far more plausible.

While it might be believable that Seska would follow them forever, or even that she might con a particularly weak Kazon leader into doing it, it's not believable that Cullah in particular would do it. He's the leader of an important sect that controls specific territory. He has obligations to specific planets and cannot abandon them without giving up his leadership role.

Note that I said Voyager is returning to the same “areas of space” in the plural. That’s an important distinction.

The Kazon and Vidiians are not in conflict

The next most important piece of evidence is the lack of interaction between the Kazon and Vidiians. We see them both continuously over the first two years, and yet there is no evidence of any conflict between them. Given the Vidiians drastic need for organs and their much higher-level of technology compared to the Kazon, the Vidiians should be well on their way to completely conquering the Kazon. At a minimum there should be constant warfare between them, as the Vidiians take what they need. Kazon should absolutely be living in fear of the Vidiians.

And yet they don’t; there’s no apparent conflict between them. In fact, I cannot think of a single time we see the Kazon and Vidiians directly interact at all, despite often running into them within one or two weeks of each other. The best example of this is episode 2-20, Investigations, where two episodes about the Vidiians literally sandwich an episode about the Kazon. Why are the Vidiians not harvesting every Kazon we run into?

Even if we assume that for some reason Kazon biology is not compatible with Vidiian and therefore the Vidiians aren’t interested in the Kazon, it’s not believable that the Kazon would dominante other races as they do in a shared space with the Vidiians.

The obvious explanation for this is that Kazon and Vidiian territories are distinct from one another, and Voyager keeps crossing the border from one to the other, as it goes in circles.

Smaller pieces of evidence

There are other smaller pieces of evidence that support this theory:

There are countless examples throughout seasons 1 and 2 of aliens saying something to the effect of “your reputation precedes you.” That type of dialogue becomes much more rare starting in season 3. This makes sense if Voyager was repeatedly traveling through the same regions early on.

There are countless discrepancies in how long it takes Voyager to travel places that only make sense if Voyager is not traveling in a straight line home. For example in Lifesigns Chakotay says Voyager will be in the vicinity of a Vidiian colony that’s 10 light years away in 22 days, equating to an average speed of less than 0.5LY/day. At that speed it would take Voyager nearly 400 years to get from the Delta Quadrant to Earth. To maintain its 70,000LY-in-70-years ETA, Voyager should be averaging about 2.7LY/day. The most likely explanation for taking so long to reach a destination (that they know for sure exists) is that Voyager is not flying in a straight line.

Finally, there’s the fact that it takes us 13 episodes through season 3 during which we do not see either the Kazon or the Vidiians before we reach the point where we’re beyond Neelix’s knowledge as a guide. Had Voyager been traveling in a straight line all this time, it’s unlikely Neelix would have had time in his life to go that far, gather intimate knowledge of everyone along the way, and then come back. Perhaps not completely impossible, but unlikely given limited Talaxian technology. This suggests that after staying relatively close to their Delta Quadrant entry point for the first 2 years, only in season 3 did Voyager really start to head home. It then only took them a matter of months to reach the edge of Neelix’s prior travels.

The one big problem:

The biggest problem with this theory, as I see it, is the repeated dialogue throughout seasons 1 and 2 about “setting a course for home.” Several episodes end with Janeway giving that order. It’s not “set a course to Planet R so we can get some torpedoes and replicator spare parts,” it’s “set a course for home.”

This only takes a little bit of mental retconning to work around: Voyager’s circuitous route follows a more or less predetermined plan (probably drawn up by Neelix), and Janeway is simply saying “let’s get on with our plan.”

This is a perfectly human way to say something. Everyone reading this probably uses similar language on a daily basis. If you’re at school or work and you’re about to leave to travel home, you might say “I’m going home” even if you plan on stopping to run an errand first. Janeway is simply doing that.

In fact it may even be an intentional moral-boosting strategy on her part: She’s gently reminding the crew that they are making valuable & necessary progress for their trip home, even if they’re not physically traveling in that direction yet.

tl;dr there is very strong circumstantial evidence that Voyager was flying in circles the first 2 years


r/DaystromInstitute • • Aug 04 '18

Patrick Stewart to Return as Capt. Picard in New ‘Star Trek’ Series for CBS All Access

1.3k Upvotes

Sir Patrick Stewart will reprise the role of Capt. Jean-Luc Picard in a brand new “Star Trek” series on CBS All Access, Variety has learned.

The exact plot details are being kept mostly under wraps, though the series is said to tell the story of the next chapter of Picard’s life. That indicates that it will take place after the events of “Star Trek: The Next Generation” rather than being a prequel or reboot.

The untitled series hails from Alex Kurtzman, James Duff, Akiva Goldsman, Michael Chabon, and Kirsten Beyer. Kurtzman, Duff, Goldsman, and Chabon will also serve as executive producers on the series along with Stewart, Trevor Roth, Heather Kadin, and Rod Roddenberry. CBS Television Studios will produce. The new series does not currently have a premiere date.

More information at Variety.com

Patrick Stewart confirms on Twitter

Please constrain all discussion of this news to this thread. Any other threads about this new show will be removed.

Given how little information we have about this new show, Rule 1 is relaxed—although not entirely suspended—in this thread.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Dec 23 '20

The episode "Darmok" is actually an abstract breakdown of memes, as well as what a memetic culture looks like to outsiders, created in a time before even the word "meme" had entered popular consciousness.

1.2k Upvotes

I came across a Terrence McKenna quote which encapsulated it well: "A meme is the smallest unit of an idea that still has coherency."

"Darmok & Jalad at Tanagra" & "Shaka, When the Walls Fell" are both iterations of that smallest unit McKenna is referring to in his quote. I know we tend to associate the word meme with ideas like "Sad Keanu Reeves" or "Distracted Boyfriend," but foundationally it's exactly the same thing, isn't it?


Edit: As this currently sits in the top ten of the Daystrom Institute's all-time posts, I want to use its visibility to leverage two memetic ideations into our shared discourse that I consider essential to Trek's continued importance in giving the world a vision of a future worth working together for: ST being MLK Jr's favorite show & Discovery's betrayal of Roddenberry's legacy.

Live long & prosper, y'all ✌️🙏🖖


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jul 31 '22

In Memoriam Nichelle Nichols has passed away

1.2k Upvotes

Kyle Johnson on Facebook

Friends, Fans, Colleagues, World

I regret to inform you that a great light in the firmament no longer shines for us as it has for so many years.

Last night, my mother, Nichelle Nichols, succumbed to natural causes and passed away. Her light however, like the ancient galaxies now being seen for the first time, will remain for us and future generations to enjoy, learn from, and draw inspiration.

Hers was a life well lived and as such a model for us all.

I, and the rest of our family, would appreciate your patience and forbearance as we grieve her loss until we can recover sufficiently to speak further. Her services will be for family members and the closest of her friends and we request that her and our privacy be respected.

Live Long and Prosper,

Kyle Johnson

Nichelle Nichols' official website

StarTrek.com: Remembering Nichelle Nichols, 1932-2022

New York Times: Nichelle Nichols, Lieutenant Uhura on ‘Star Trek,’ Dies at 89


r/DaystromInstitute • • Dec 03 '19

In memoriam Dorothy C. Fontana has passed away

997 Upvotes

As of today we've lost one of the most important contributors to Star Trek. D.C. Fontana was a script editor and writer on the original series; she was also the first woman to write for Star Trek, and one of the few people to work on each of TOS, The Animated Series, The Next Generation, and Deep Space 9. Her contributions to the lore of the Star Trek universe are almost too many to list, but perhaps the most notable was the degree to which she fleshed out Vulcan culture and the character of Spock, penning "Journey to Babel" and "Yesteryear", along with nine other TOS episodes, 5 TNG episodes, and DS9's "Dax."

Star Trek.com obituary

Facebook post from her longtime friend and fellow writer, David Gerrold.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Mar 27 '20

Ten Forward I just wanted to congratulate this sub on being a good example of fandom.

994 Upvotes

Michael Chabon was asked on Instagram his opinion of this subreddit, and he said,

I have gained knowledge there and enjoyed the intricacy and seriousness of speculation and debate. Not to mention the (mostly) collegial tone. An example of Trek fandom at its best, IMO.

With so many fandoms known for being toxic, bitter, and hateful, I'm really proud I get to be a part of this one.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Apr 16 '20

The mysterious room in First Contact, and a theory as to its purpose

958 Upvotes

So, I've seen many people complaining about the room that Picard leads Lily Sloane to after she steals his phaser. As noted by many people, it serves no apparent function, being a smallish room with only a Jeffries tube for access (there doesn't appear to be a regular door), and a window with no transparent aluminum, but just a sliding hatch and a forcefield. If you're not familiar with this room, it appears right around the 44-minute mark in First Contact; it's the one where Picard shows Lily that they're in space, and facetiously suggests that Lily jump out of the window but that "You may want to hold your breath; it's a long way down." For those of you interested, RedLetterMedia on YouTube gives a scathing indictment of this part of the movie on his First Contact review, which while pretty funny does raise some logical objections to the existence of this room.

However, to me at least, it seems obvious what this room's purpose is. For starters, it's not a "room" at all. It's a bay. It's a lateral sensor bay that just happens to be empty at that particular time. If this is the case, the "window" would make more sense, since it's not really a window at all, but rather an aperture for a sensor assembly, and when the assembly is installed, it would seat into that aperture/port with an airtight seal.

This would especially make sense if we assume that the lateral sensor packages onboard the Enterprise are modular, and designed to be swapped out as needed for particular mission profiles. It just seems to me that at this point, that particular bay had not been fitted with a sensor package.

This would also obviate the need for a regular door, since this compartment would not need to be manned most of the time, and a Jeffries tube should provide sufficient access for most maintenance needs.

I'm interested to hear if anyone can point out any logical holes in my assumptions about this room, or if anyone else has any insight or interesting headcanon that is different from my own.

EDIT: Thanks for the gold, kind stranger!


r/DaystromInstitute • • Mar 25 '19

In Memoriam Commander Njfreddie has died.

927 Upvotes

Commander Njfreddie has died.

His service record with Daystrom is here.

Commander Njfreddie asked that should he pass away his friends on reddit be told. I am posting Commander NJFreddie AKA Mr Sean Browns Obituary here as well.

Commander Njfreddie lived his life in the open and wanted to die in the open as well. With permission from the Daystrom Mods I am honoring his request.

For those who didn't know Commander NJFreddie; he was a very smart man, with impeccable manners, who worked very hard for the historical and humanistic causes he believed in. Like us all he loved Star Trek.

Take care My friend. Because of you we all can guess which Federation planets match which real stars in the sky , or Learn all the particles in Star Trek, and read everything about Dahar Masters we wanted to know but were afraid to ask.

Thank you for sharing your friendship and your Star Trek imagination with us here at Daystrom.

Rest well Commander, your Daystrom friends will see to your Ak'voh.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Feb 10 '19

The reason why Pulaski’s role as TNG’s version of McCoy doesn’t work.

915 Upvotes

McCoy gave Spock a fair few ribbings about being a Vulcan in his time, there’s no denying that, much like Pulaski gave to Data about being an Android. You know what the difference is, though?

Spock was just as rude and insulting to McCoy about being a human. The two argued on equal terms. Data, on the other hand, was never anything but polite and professional to Pulaski. On top of that, he has a much more childlike, innocent nature than Spock ever did.

Pulaski’s attitude throughout the series is honestly more reminiscent of a racist bullying an autistic child than two buddies jokingly being dicks to each other.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jun 07 '23

Meta - Announcement Daystrom Institute stands with /r/blind in support of third party apps

913 Upvotes

Attention all hands,

As many of you are likely aware, Reddit has announced that they are updating their API pricing model. The new prices, which will go into effect on July 1st, are so exorbitant that all existing third party apps (such as Apollo, RiF, Relay, BaconReader, and Narwhal) will be forced to shut down. Apollo specifically would need to pay Reddit $20 million per year to continue operating, a sum totally beyond their means.

If this change goes through, the only way to view Reddit on a mobile device will be through the official app. In addition to a generally inferior interface and extremely lackluster moderation tools relative to the various 3rd party apps (our team uses a mix of RiF, Apollo, and BaconReader), Reddit's official app is very bad for visually impaired users. Reddit has been well aware of this issue for years but have never prioritized it, and now they are pulling the rug out from under the visually impaired community with nothing more than a promise that they'll make their own app accessible eventually. Reddit's recent update in response to the growing uproar makes no mention of this problem. This is not sufficient.

A site wide protest is in motion, and as of this writing over 2,400 subreddits have agreed to participate. Daystrom Institute is among them, and like the rest, we will be going dark (either restricted or fully private) on Monday, June 12. How long we stay that way will depend on how Reddit chooses to respond.

We encourage anyone interested in contributing to this movement to reach out to the admins themselves (via modmail at /r/reddit), or to moderators of subreddits you frequent. Tell them you support this protest and you want them to take action.

Wherever you choose to express yourself, don't be a jerk about it: genuine opinions shared truthfully and politely will do far more to sway the undecided than insults and deceptive arguments. We on the mod team are proud to support a community capable of maintaining these standards.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Feb 27 '15

In Memoriam Leonard Nimoy has just passed away. I'd like the Institute to take a moment to remember all of his great work, and the legacy he's left behind

902 Upvotes

As the New York Times reports, Leonard Nimoy has passed away this morning due to end-stage chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

I won't say much here, but in a loss this great I felt the Institute should open discussion for a few words on the subject.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jan 26 '20

“Because it was no longer Starfleet!”: Viewing the change in the Federation through a generational lens

894 Upvotes

I was struck when watching the episode at how deeply the synth attack on Mars ingrained a cultural hatred for synthetic life forms in Federation society, evidenced by the journalist’s style of questioning to Picard, zeroing in on his defence of synthetic life forms and his relationship with Data, and Dahj’s horror at the idea that she might be one of those “killing machines”.

Compared to the supposedly enlightened attitudes of the Federation only a few decades on, it seemed the attack on Mars brought about a rapid change in their outlook, and as Jean-Luc pointed out, Starfleet stopped being Starfleet. Of course an attack as devastating as that would have drastic consequences, but the change in the Federation makes more sense when you examined through a broader look at the timeline - Picard and the crew we watched and loved are old now, their outlook is a dated one which roots back to their own youth in the 2340s-60s, when Starfleet was all about peaceful exploration and discovery - so much so that the flagship carried families.

Then came 2365 and the sudden awareness of a dangerous new threat the Federation (for the most part) never knew existed. A year later, the captain of that family-laden flagship is kidnapped by that enemy, altered to become one of them and used by them to destroy 39 starships and 11,000 lives, getting as close as Earth itself before it’s stopped. Starfleet starts to pull back from family accommodation and starts building ships designed especially for combat and defence rather than exploration. The fear of another invasion by this dangerous enemy of unknown scale seeps through the Federation for the rest of the 60s - many are directly affected, having lost loved ones in Wolf 359 (and some of them even harbour resentment or suspicion towards the man involved).

Four years later Starfleet learns of the Dominion. Now there are two new hostile threats, each from a distant, mysterious, unknown quadrant of the galaxy. In a very short space of time, Starfleet finds it must prepare for potential combat against two unforeseen major adversaries. They step up their production of ships designed for war rather than peace. The Federation has even suffered an internal fracture as a significant number of people rebel and take up arms for the cause of the Maquis. In the first three years of the 2370s, the Maquis destabilise Starfleet’s internal coherency while the Founders cause further destabilisation through infiltration - culminating in an (albeit brief) emergency situation on Earth which sees at least one explosion at a conference and martial law imposed. The Founders also destabilise the Federation’s long alliance with the Klingon Empire which results in a short conflict between the two. While the Federation is trying to deal with all of this, the Borg return for another attempt at assimilating Earth, and the Dominion ally with the Cardassians before declaring war.

The Federation had had wars over the 24th century, including with the Cardassians, but they were distant skirmishes to the average citizen on Earth. By contrast, the Dominion War was the most severe conflict the Federation endured since the Klingon War of the 2250s, and it surpassed that conflict in every way. It was a war so severe that it saw the first direct attack on Earth in living memory and necessitated the Federation allying not just with the Klingons - now friends again - but also the Romulans, until now the Federation’s “oldest enemy”. The war lasts only two years but its cost is enormous - countless lives are lost, and Federation worlds have to rebuild after being conquered by the Dominion.

As the 2370s close, we know less about what happens within the Federation. We know that the crew of Voyager dealt a crippling blow to the Borg, which left them either destroyed or severely damaged (we’ll find out soon). In the absence of any further conflict, the Federation might have started to “remember when (they) used to be explorers”. But then the 2380s bring the Synth attack and the Romulan refugee crisis - two events which are still fresh in people’s memories by 2399.

We’re used to following Picard, Sisko, Janeway and their crews. All born in the first half of the 24th century. Picard himself was born in 2305, the Federation he got to know as he grew up was one which had recently achieved peace with one of its oldest and most fearsome enemies. All of these characters grew up knowing a Federation that was focused on peaceful exploration. They were adults when the Borg threat emerged and the Dominion War was waged. For them, the Federation and Starfleet were always about peaceful exploration first, and those conflicts were about defending that. So of course Jean-Luc resigned when the Federation refused to help the Romulans. Of course he spoke out against the ban on Synthetics. His disgust in the interview was so tangibly real - it really wasn’t the Starfleet he knew anymore.

But what about the young starship crews of today? Let’s take the journalist and Dahj as two case studies. The journalist looks to be in her 30s - so she was born in TNG’s time, the 2360s. She grew up on an Earth which had nearly been assimilated and which was sabotaged and later attacked by the Dominion. She knew a Federation and a Starfleet that was gearing up for conflict with two deadly enemies - one of them a race of cyborgs. The ideals that Jean-Luc and the others grew up knowing are old fashioned to her. She would have been in her early to mid 20s when the Synths attacked. Her perceptions, her world (universe) view was shaped by those darker times. Dahj’s background is made up - we know she’s a form of android but she believes herself to be a human, looking to be in her early 20s - had her backstory been real, she would have been born not long after Nemesis. The Synth attack would have been one of the first major galactic events she would have been aware of. Her views on Synthetics shaped by the anger and propaganda which materialised in the aftermath of the attack and the imposing of the ban.

Jean-Luc is dismissive of it (“forget everything you’ve heard”) but as we know from our own media, such messages can be very pernicious. People of that generation - 2399’s cadets, ensigns, perhaps some lieutenants, would have grown up constantly absorbing the message that synthetic life forms are dangerous, monstrous, even evil. Even people born a decade earlier (2350s) would have been shaped by it - indeed, many of them would be Dominion war veterans.

So while Jean-Luc and the other characters we’ve known for so long were shaped by their youth in a peacefully expanding and exploring Federation, those younger than them grew up and came of age on an Earth that was darker, more threatened and vulnerable than it had been in a very long time, in an era marked by conflict, war, loss and fear. It’s a reverse of the generational divide we’re experiencing, wherein the older generations tend to be more insular and close minded about certain issues while the younger generation are fighting for ideals. In 2399, the next generation have turned inwards, and it’s the older people (in this case, Picard), who will be fighting for what the Federation should still represent.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Feb 17 '21

Vague Title The reason why Klingon ships are so dark

884 Upvotes

Answer: They're not. They're dark to us because of the spectrum of light we can see. Klingons see into the infrared spectrum, something we see here on earth with several predator species, so their lighting has less "visible" light in it. This is also why we see so much red with interiors--their light spectrum likely has red near the center of it, compared to ours which has green in the middle. In other words, our red may be white to the Klingon eye.

That is all.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jul 20 '20

Roddenberrys "no melodrama" rule was very important for TNG, and even DS9 and VOY.

884 Upvotes

Everybody has heard, in some form or another, of the rule of Roddenberry to have no conflict between the main characters. Often it is raised as a weak point, missed opportunity and even as an insult towards Roddenberry together with the "salvation" that happened when he departed the production. I firmly believe that this rule was very important to set the overall tone of TNG, and even VOY and DS9.

From the ST:TNG Writers Bible, first the section on Believability, and then the section on what does not go into an episode script:

BELIEVABILITY IS EVERYTHING. IT IS THE MOST ESSENTIAL ELEMENT OF ANY STAR TREK STORY.

If you're in doubt about a scene, you can apply this simple test: "Would I believe this if it was occurring on the bridge of the battleship Missouri?" If you wouldn't believe it in the twentieth century, then our audience probably won't believe it in the twenty-fourth.

Especially, the people must be believable -- just as believable as if they were living in our 20th century. The crew of the Enterprise are intelligent, witty, thoughtful, compassionate, caring human beings -- but they have human faults and weaknesses too -- although not as many or as severe as in our time. They have been selected for this mission because of their ability to transcend their human failings. We should see in them the kind of people we aspire to be ourselves.


8. STAR TREK is not melodrama. Melodrama is a writing style which does not require believable people. Believable people are at the heart of good STAR TREK scripts.

With that in mind, in TNG the crew is introduced with a very important aspect which sets the tone from the start: They are professionals. They are professionals, they have a job, they have a mission, and they know they can't get it done alone, so they work together to accomplish their goals.

As a thought experiment, imagine Riker treating Data as Pulaski did, maybe even worse and with less respect. Or if Worf would treat La Forge, Yar or Crusher as less worthy because they are not "real" warriors. Or if La Forge would constantly push Wesley Crusher around because he ain't got any real-world experience. Actually, we all can remember how Picard reacted when Wesley was on the bridge for the first time, imagine if that tone would have stayed between them. Personally, I have a hard time imagining all that, because of the way the characters were introduced and how they interacted with each other all the time, it seems absolutely implausible. And it would make for a much worse experience, of course.

They all have their flaws, of course, every single one of the main characters has flaws, but they do not dominate them, and they do not matter to each other. When La Forge creates a sentient hologram by mistake, he does not try to sweep it under the rug. He could have kept his mouth shut and the others might have never figured out what really happened, but he immediately told Picard the moment he realized what had happened. Picard does not scold him in any way, he sees how such a mistake could have happened and moves on to finding a solution to the problem they have. This repeats many times with different characters and it sends a clear message: Mistakes happen, it's more important who finds the solution than who did make the mistake.

I believe that this basic sentiment that is cemented into the core of TNG also carried on to DS9 and VOY.

In DS9 Sisko is being send to an outpost far off the main land, and Kira is assigned as his first officer. From the first moment she makes it very clear that she's not a fan of this, neither of the situation nor the Federation, but without hesitation sets to work. Yes, there is conflict between these characters, but it never crosses a certain line, it never becomes unprofessional. There is a chain of command, and as much as Kira dislikes the situation, she never evades the chain of command, she never sabotages her commanding officer and she never openly opposes him. They grow on each other, of course, but only because they gain respect for each other through their professional relationship.

In VOY we have similar premise, but a different situation altogether. The Maquis crew, pretty much what you could call rebels, must join a Federation crew to ensure their common survival. Janeway does not take them in as refugees, or cargo, or second class citizens, from the first moment she knows the only way to make this work is by making Chakotay her first officer and integrating the Maquis into their crew seamlessly. Again, there is conflict, but it never crosses a certain line. Chakotay never took over parts of the ship, or tried to leave the Federation crew behind on a planet, he never tried to cross Janeway just because he can. There is "Scorpion" of course, but he did not act out of smite against Janeway, but because out of his hate against the Borg. Then there is "Worst Case Scenario", in which we learn that Tuvok planned to take measures against a possible Maquis uprising, but I guess it was new to everyone else that he did that. And it finally peaks in "The Voyager Conspiracy", when Janeway and Chakotay have reason to doubt each other. Even though they do doubt, they again never drop their professionalism, which in the end allows them to come to a simple explanation.

Even though there was conflict in DS9 and VOY, it never crossed certain lines, they were always professionals which worked together towards a common goal. It seems like the rules established in TNG still ringed in everybodies ears and made sure that it never escalated too far, that it never became too melodramatic. Of course Roddenberry had flaws, like everyone else, and he for sure was not a saint and not into this solely to better humanity, but some of his rules were good to have in the end. And I believe this one was very important.


r/DaystromInstitute • • May 15 '20

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds - New Star Trek Series To Follow Captain Pike, Spock, and Number One

882 Upvotes

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds is real! In lieu of a Comic-Con announcement, Anson Mount, Ethan Peck, and Rebecca Romijn have announced the new series on YouTube.

More information at Deadline.com

In its ever-expanding goal to be Star Trek all year round, CBS All Access has now picked up the Spock, Captain Pike and Number One starring Star Trek: Strange New Worlds to series.

With a title lifted in part from James T. Kirk’s beloved introduction to the original mother show, the third full live action show in the Alex Kurtzman-pioneered Trekverse after Star Trek Discovery and Star Trek Picard will feature Ethan Peck, Anson Mount and Rebecca Romijn reprising their respective roles from Season 2 of the Sonequa Martin-Green-led Discovery.

Please constrain all discussion of this news to this thread. Any other threads about this new show will be removed.

Given how little information we have about this new show, Rule 1 is relaxed—although not entirely suspended—in this thread.

[EDIT]

More details from Variety

“Star Trek” is boldly going back to its roots.

CBS revealed Friday that it had given a series order to “Star Trek: Strange New Worlds,” a new show that will take place on the starship Enterprise in the years prior to James T. Kirk coming aboard as captain. The new show is set, like other recent “Star Trek” spinoffs, to stream on CBS All Access. But it will, according to co-creator and executive producer Akiva Goldsman, hew more closely to the original Kirk-era “Star Trek” in structure and tone than those other recent additions to the franchise have.

Looks like we're really getting some old fashioned Star Trek.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Mar 15 '21

Shakespeare’s Hamlet is a comedy in Klingon culture

860 Upvotes

“TaH pagh, taH beH!” To be or not to be, General Chang says in Star Trek VI, and every Klingon at the table starts laughing.

Known as one of the all-time great tragedies in human culture, the play gets a significantly different reception with Klingon audiences. For them, Hamlet is an uproarious comedy.

Bumbling fool Hamlet, the Prince of Denmark, is too stupid to realise that his uncle has murdered his father in order to usurp both his throne and his marriage bed. Not only does he fail to challenge the usurper king and avenge his father’s death, it is only when told by the ghost of his own father that he was murdered that Hamlet finally recognises there is something rotten in Denmark.

Yet the fool does not immediately march into the castle’s great hall and challenge the usurper to honourable combat. No, instead he feigns madness and concocts an elaborate scheme — a play within a play — to demonstrate the usurper’s already well-established guilt. Soon after, Hamlet has the perfect opportunity to exact vengeance as the usurper prays to the (long dead) gods for forgiveness, but fearing that an honourable death would send the usurper to Sto’vo’kor, Hamlet instead kills a servant hiding behind a tapestry.

Hamlet discovers that the usurper is now plotting to have him killed. Instead of confronting him, Hamlet arranges a duel with Laertes, the brother of his now-dead lover — who was so distraught at his rejection of her advances that she drowned herself! The usurper uses poison — a dishonourable tool — on both Laertes’ blade and Hamlet’s wine. Except Hamlet’s mother drinks the wine and dies, Laertes is wounded by the poisoned blade and dies, and Hamlet survives the poison just long enough to finally, finally wreak vengeance in his father’s name and kill the usurper once and for all.

Seen from the perspective of a feudal warrior culture, obsessed with combat, personal honour, and familial integrity, this plot would come across as uproariously hilarious. It’s not hard to imagine a chorus of Klingon guffaws at Hamlet’s famous soliloquy, where he opines on whether or not he should go on living; to the Klingons, life is indeed but a walking shadow, and to think otherwise is humorous at best.

The bumbling, fumbling way in which Hamlet realises his revenge would be similarly comedic to the straightforward Klingons, and the thought of a strong woman of noble birth killing herself over the lost affections of a fool like Hamlet would have had the Klingons rolling in the aisles.

Each death in the play, which generally provokes shock and dismay in humans, would instead have provoked laughter and goblet-slamming in a Klingon audience.

This humorous tale of a usurped Great House brought to ruin by the insipid, overly convoluted revenge plot of a foolish Prince is also a cautionary tale for Klingon audiences. The question for them is not “to be or not to be” — they settled that conundrum long ago. Better to die on your feet than live on your knees, so take caution from this human story of the fool Prince of Denmark: if a man usurps your House, whether he’s family or not, you kill him then and there, and be done with it.

Anything less is uncivilised.


r/DaystromInstitute • • Aug 24 '18

Captains Picard and Sisko represent two leading and competing ethical theories

857 Upvotes

In ethics, the branch of philosophy, systems of ethics are primarily divided into two camps: utilitarianism (or consequentialism) and deontology (often typified by the work of Immanuel Kant, but much broader than Kantianism). Utilitarians believe that the ethics of a decision are based on the consequences of it, in particular the amount of harm or happiness the decision brings to the world, while deontologists believe that actions have inherent moral status regardless of their consequences.

The most famous example of the difference between the two systems is The Trolley Problem, usually attributed to the philosopher Phillipa Foot. The general form, as per Wikipedia:

You see a runaway trolley moving toward five tied-up (or otherwise incapacitated) people lying on the tracks. You are standing next to a lever that controls a switch. If you pull the lever, the trolley will be redirected onto a side track and the five people on the main track will be saved. However, there is a single person lying on the side track. You have two options:

Do nothing and allow the trolley to kill the five people on the main track.

Pull the lever, diverting the trolley onto the side track where it will kill one person.

Which is the most ethical option?

A utilitarian says "pull the lever", since the result of this action is that one person, rather than five, will die. A deontologist says "pulling the lever is murder, and murder is morally wrong", therefore the ethical choice is to do nothing.

Problems like this make utilitarianism look obviously superior, but there are also cases where utilitarianism looks obiously inferior. For example:

A brilliant transplant surgeon has five patients, each in need of a different organ, each of whom will die without that organ. Unfortunately, there are no organs available to perform any of these five transplant operations. A healthy young traveler, just passing through the city the doctor works in, comes in for a routine checkup. In the course of doing the checkup, the doctor discovers that his organs are compatible with all five of his dying patients. Suppose further that if the young man were to disappear, no one would suspect the doctor. Do you support the morality of the doctor to kill that tourist and provide his healthy organs to those five dying persons and save their lives?

Suddenly the utilitarian option that saves five lives at the expense of one seems a lot less fishy.

Star Trek presents us with these types of dilemmas all the time, and also the opportunity to see how they confront them, and I believe the show sets up Picard and Sisko as great examples of deontology and utilitarianism, respectively.

Take Star Trek: Insurrection. The Federation has created a plan where it will stealthily move a few hundred people off of a planet that keeps them eternally youthful and onto one where they will age and die naturally. In exchange, it can harness the rings of that planet to create medical technology that will save untold numbers of Federation lives. To them, the utilitarian calculus seems obvious.

But Picard is willing to risk his commission because he believes the rights of the Baku to stay, unmolested, in their home are paramount and that the act of forced relocation is wrong -- even when it stands to do good. His rebuttal to Admiral Dougherty is about as bald-faced a critique of utilitarianism as one can imagine.

DOUGHERTY: Jean-Luc, we're only moving 600 people.

PICARD: How many people does it take, Admiral, before it becomes wrong? Hmm? A thousand, fifty thousand, a million? How many people does it take, Admiral?

Picard makes an even bigger deontological decision in "I, Borg" when he decides that it's morally wrong to use Hugh as a weapon to attack the Borg collective. In that case, he is literally valuing the life and autonomy of a single individual over all the lives threatened by the Borg Collective. And tellingly, it is his discovery and admission that Hugh is a person, with person's rights, that brings him there.

PICARD: I think I deliberately avoided speaking with the Borg because I didn't want anything to get in the way of our plan. But now that I have, he seems to be a fully realised individual. He has even accepted me as Picard, Captain of this ship, and not as Locutus.
LAFORGE: So you've reconsidered the plan?
PICARD: Yes. To use him in this manner, we'd be no better than the enemy that we seek to destroy.

Picard will always make the decision he considers morally right, even if the consequences are staggeringly grim and the payoffs quite small, cosmically speaking.

Now let's consider Benjamin Sisko. The most obvious episode to point to as proof of his consequentialism is, of course, "In the Pale Moonlight", where Sisko lets a whole lot of immoral actions stack up in the name of winning the war-- and stopping the death of his friends and comrades-- culminating in being an accessory to the assassination of a Romulan Senator.

So... I lied. I cheated. I bribed men to cover the crimes of other men. I am an accessory to murder. But the most damning thing of all... I think I can live with it. And if I had to do it all over again - I would. Garak was right about one thing: a guilty conscience is a small price to pay for the safety of the Alpha Quadrant. So I will learn to live with it... Because I can live with it... I can live with it... Computer - erase that entire personal log.

Another example comes in "For the Uniform", when Sisko detonates the trilithium torpedos to catch Eddington, although in this case whether the ends really justify the means is iffier. But it is further evidence that Sisko is a moral relativist. It's hard to imagine that, faced with Picard's dilemma in "I, Borg", Sisko would have called off the plan like Picard did. It's even harder to imagine Picard bombing a planet to catch one wayward criminal.

On a smaller scale, we see Sisko's utilitarianism from the very beginning. He's willing to blackmail Quark to keep him on the station. We also see that it has its limits: A truly committed consequentialist would have agreed with the Jack Pack in "Statistical Probabilities" when they recommended the Federation surrender to the Dominion -- unless Sisko simply disagreed with their analysis.

What I find so interesting about this observation is that both Captains are portrayed as heroic in the decisions they make. Star Trek thus affords us positive examples of both ethical frameworks, without favoring one over the other. It shows us that there are some situations that seem to require a Picard and others that seem to require a Sisko-- and that there are real consequences to committing to either philosophical position.

What do you think? Do you agree with my overall framing? Can you find counterexamples? And what about Kirk, Janeway, and Archer-- do you think they have consistent or unique ethical frameworks?


r/DaystromInstitute • • Jun 04 '20

Meta - Announcement The /r/DaystromInstitute moderators stand with those who fight injustice and police brutality

856 Upvotes

Normally the /r/DaystromInstitute moderators do not comment on current events, however in this instance we felt a moral obligation to do something.

We stand in solidarity with everyone who has taken to the streets to protest the systemic racism that pervades the US justice system. To that end each moderator has donated $47 to the George Floyd Bail Fund. If you have the means, we encourage you to make a donation to one of the causes below.

One last thing: current events invite a number of comparisons to various episodes of Star Trek. If you would like to discuss those parallels, please use this thread to do so, and keep the conversation constructive and respectful.


/r/startrek has compiled a list of causes and resources which I will reproduce here:

Causes:

Resources:


r/DaystromInstitute • • Sep 24 '19

Q Sent Voyager Home

845 Upvotes

I've had this fan theory in the back of my mind for a while but a recent post on the Trek subreddit finally game me a reason to articulate it:

Five episodes before the finale is the episode Q2. In the episode, Janeway plays an essential role in preventing Q's son, Junior, from being thrown out of the continuum. The episode ends with this exchange:

Q: Oh, before I leave.

Q gives her a PADD, containing a new route back to Earth.

Q: I did a little homework for you. Consider it a thank you for everything you did for Junior.

JANEWAY: Not that I don't appreciate it, but this will only take a few years off our journey. Why not send us all the way?

Q: What sort of an example would I be setting for my son if I did all the work for you?

The critical observation here is that Q's actions alter Voyager's flight plan... which promptly causes them to stumble upon a huge threat to the entire galaxy. The statistical chances of them coming across such a small structure in a region as vast as the Delta Quadrant are astronomical, even moreso when you consider that Voyager's route was likely based on the best path they could have conceivably taken based on their knowledge of stellar cartography. That Q could offer a "better" route implies that the information they were using wouldn't have lead them along the course that eventually lead to the transwarp hub. So put simply, without Q's intervention they would have never discovered the transwarp hub, never saved the galaxy, and not gotten home in the way they did.

When you step back and consider Q's larger relationship with the Federation, it makes perfect sense that he would help humanity in this way. After Q originally exposed the Enterprise to the Borg, Picard wonders if Q orchestrated the confrontation to discourage the Federation's complacency. Little did he know at that time that the Borg were already at Federation's doorstep as evidenced in the episode The Neutral Zone. If it weren't for that knowledge, the Borg would have arrived at Earth before the Federation understood the nature of the threat (to say nothing of gaining the advantage entailed by Picard's time is Loctus). Tapestry? Q puts Picard through a life changing ordeal all to encourage the personality traits which prove essential to him saving the Federation time and time again. All Good Things? Q provides Picard with the experiences critical to him stopping the anti-time anomaly. Q-Less? Q rewards data for his assistance not by granting him what he desires most (humanity) but rather by encouraging him to continue his pursuits by showing it is possible for him to experience emotion. In each of these circumstances Q could have simply stated all important information or more relevantly, he could have simply intervened and solved the problem himself. Instead, Q has always avoided "doing all the work" for us and instead pushed us subtly in ways that ultimately saved us.

Or to put it in non-universe terms, by the time this episode was written the series producers must have known that the show was coming to an end and have had some sort of idea of how they were going to end it. The question then becomes, from a storytelling point of view, what would be the point of having Q alter their course if it ultimately would have no significance in the long run? They're certainly are examples of Q getting involved with Federation business and then leaving without helping or rewarding humanity in any way. There's no reason why this episode couldn't have ended the same way and still been consistent with his character. Having Q be the unsung hero of Voyager perfectly blends with the mysterious nature of his character and lessens how abrupt the ending feelings.

EDIT: /u/linuxhanja makes an excellent point that adds another beautiful angle to this theory:

I love it. even moreso because it steers janeway towards a cheat which causes her to behave in a way contrary to herself, but also like herself...

and i like the idea that in the beginning of the finale she knew Q did this, and thats a part of her moral struggle... >she knows its a Q - gift that will work, and that's the problem, for her. much more so than if the plan was a big >risk as I've always read the story.

I think this is an important observation because it parallels the episode Tapestry so closely. In Tapestry, Q forces Picard to confront a path not taken... and he is disturbed by what he sees. Likewise (as /u/linuxhanja observes here) Janeway is confronted with a glimpse of what the journey home will do to her, what it will take from her. If Q orchestrated this confrontation, then the lessons that come from it will change Janeway into a profoundly different person than the Admiral we see.