r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Jan 25 '15
Discussion Season 1 Episode 19: Coming of Age
2
u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Jan 26 '15
The premise is interesting but the episode falls flat.
I like the idea that we get to see the admissions to Starfleet academy but this doesn't seem right.
I understand that at this early in the show Starfleet is shown as being held to such a high standard, but this is ridiculous. The entrance exam is brutal to the point where you'd expect there to be a severe shortage of cadets. Are we to believe that this is the same academy that Barclay made his way through?
Also the 1:1 matter antimatter thing is contradicted in "Galaxy's Child" where Geordi had adjusted the ratio against the designs and wishes of Dr. Leah Brahms. Personally I'm on "Coming of Age"s side on this one, but it's a point I couldn't help but notice.
The Zaldan thing was probably the best part of the Wesley subplot. That's a pretty good test IMO.
Oliana Mirren clearly was out of her league and was shoehorned in as a love interest for Wesley. T'Shanik was there to fill out the numbers. Really the academy thing was Mordock and Wesley's half hearted competition.
Also the psych test. They tear apart a lab and have crew members as actors? Someone could have conceivably died? I can understand the writers didn't have their minds on the fact that holodecks exist if they didn't show Wesley hanging with Worf inside the holodeck in a completely conspicuous manner.
Now on to the Picard/Quinn thing. I'm going to say I liked the premise in general for one reason. Good use of foreshadowing. We'll find out about this "problem" in the federation later.
That said, there ARE problems on the Enterprise. First of all I'd be pretty alarmed if a kid that was upset because he didn't cut snuff to try out of the academy straight up stole a shuttlecraft and damned nearly died. Remmick was absolutely right to ask if the shuttle bay was secured! Sure the kid made it back after Picard told him how to bounce off the atmosphere (damaging the shuttle). He was "punished" but I don't know, man. Kid totally committed 24th century grand theft auto.
The entire crew, most notably Riker, rebuffs Remmick at every opportunity while being under orders from Admiral Quinn to cooperate completely.
In conclusion, I feel kind of bad for Remmick. Poor guy was a dick because it was his job, and a reasonable job at that. He fell in love with the place and was never seen again. You could see the undercurrent of "not on my watch, kid" in Picard's eyes.
I'll give it credit for the premise, but the writing's immature. 5/10.
1
u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder Jan 26 '15 edited Jan 26 '15
Also the 1:1 matter antimatter thing is contradicted in "Galaxy's Child" where Geordi had adjusted the ratio against the designs and wishes of Dr. Leah Brahms. Personally I'm on "Coming of Age"s side on this one, but it's a point I couldn't help but notice.
Yeah! I thought they talk about ratios in later episodes!
I was curious about the ratio thing, and found this: http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/inconsistencies/treknology-power.htm#power
To sum it up: warp plasma needs to be generated in order to power the engines with said antimatter, so it's possible more deuterium is used than anti-deuterium to supply this plasma, which is also supported by the fact that the deuterium pods are always larger than antimatter pods.
1
u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Jan 26 '15
It does make sense they'd want to make sure all antimatter was annihilated. Reading this it occurs to me I didn't really ever know how a warp engine creates power. Interesting. I never knew what the dilithium did.
3
Jan 25 '15
I think that this is the best episode of the first season, at least at this point in the rewatch. It may be supplanted by one of the few remaining episodes, but I think that's unlikely. I hold this one in high regard because, despite a clunky Wesley storyline, I think that this is the first show to have a good grasp of the characters and to leave me with a feeling of familiarity that would eventually become standard in later seasons.
The Wesley story line is silly. The process to get into the Academy makes no sense, and the ethics of psychological torture seems to be at odds with the utopia of the universe that we've seen so far.
I think the conspiracy story is one of the best in the season: good call backs, allows the crew to show their characters, creates a plot that can be paced out nicely.
The dropping of the conspiracy at the end of the show seems insane unless you know that the storyline is continuing. I think that knowing this severely alters your perception of the episodes quality.
The transporter gets "Hulk strength'd" here: the power and ability is modified to suit the story. Here, they can't beam the kid off the shuttlecraft even though they regularly beam people to the planet, which is obviously farther away.
The first Riker Manuever!
The first shuttlecraft appearance! Shot very oddly!
The last Picard-Wesley scene is possibly the best scene of the show so far, despite Wesley. THIS is the Picard I know, not the quick to anger, doesn't quite get anything version we've seen so far. Good writing.
3.5/5
2
u/Eljeune Apr 19 '15
There's huge flaws in the academy storyline, but I still like it, even though Mordok clearly couldn't have a better score than Wesley based on what we saw. The psyche test was interesting, and the scene with Worf was great. I wonder what the others characters psyche test was.
The Remmick part was nice because it gave every character a little scene to flesh them out. Worf killed it with his "Is it required, sir?"
1
Jan 26 '15
Someone submitted a link to this submission in the following subreddit:
This comment was posted by a bot, see /r/Meta_Bot for more info. Please respect rediquette, and do not vote or comment on the linked submissions. Thank you.
7
u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder Jan 25 '15 edited Jan 25 '15
I took notes as I went... And there's a lot.
I already smells the seeds of completely unrelated A and B plots. The only question: is Quinn an asshole yet? Update: He's an asshole.
Wesley meets a human girl. You could cut the sexual tension in the air with a knife. Also, how long did that handshake last?
I see Mordok is taking his downers at this time.
Why only 1 cadet out of these 4? Is it a simple rule that they have to eliminate 75% of all candidates in order just to have enough space? The Earth Starfleet Academy IS tiny when you consider cadets come from over 100+ member worlds. West Point only has just shy of 5,000 cadets. Even if you quadrupled that number, that still leaves only 20,000 cadets for 150 worlds, or 133 cadets per world. Still, if all of them could "easily qualify", shouldn't they try to weed out the people not as smart as these folks? Or are all young people on this level of brainiac?
The Enterprise-D crew is supposed to be top notch, best among their peers, head of the class. They are portrayed this way to the point of arrogance. Professional, reasonable... Until they get a visitor, then they become a bunch of childlike assholes. Riker especially. Remmick is hanging around taking notes, and Riker flips the fuck out. What gives here? "Full Cooperation" = Yell like a child until the annoying guy goes away.
...wait, seriously? These kids know about warp field mechanics, all kinds of other technical jargon, they learn calculus at age 9, and the question that trips them up (and the question that's supposed to bring out the best and brightest) is that? That's a stupid question, and it's stupid that the girl couldn't get it. Of course, women are bad at science, am I right? am I right? /s
"You're lucky you're cute Wesley, or you could be really obnoxious." Well, I hate to break it to you...
You SHOULD apologize, Riker. You yelled at the damn captain! Way to be a shining beacon for how professional the Enterprise crew is.
Our first Riker maneuver! I would be legitimately intimidated by that.
This is a tired trope of storytelling, particularly with lawyer dramas, or whenever an asshole authority figure is brought it. They always take a perfectly reasonable situation, then twist the facts and circumstances until it suits their narrative, and not the facts. The protagonists always protest; "That's not how it happened!" However, they are ignored, or come up with only the weakest possible protestation, or both. In the enlightened future of the human race, apparently you can still make Paris the capitol of Russia if you just ignore what someone else is saying... Or if your opponent tries to give you the right answer by saying "Um, well, uh, I think, you know, I t-think it's, uh, France..." Very convincing, Geordi. In this case, Remmick acts like Kosinski talked Picard into giving him command of the ship for an unproven, wild experiment. The truth is, Starfleet Command ordered Picard to comply. What else is he going to do? "Oh, nah, I don't think I will". For all we know Admiral Quinn gave the order! But all Geordi can do is protest weakly. How about "He was following orders, if you want to blame someone, blame Starfleet. They let Kosinski onto two ships before us." Remmick, of course, ignores this, and quite frankly, so does Geordi, when it's the only argument that matters.
I know they are trying to make Remmick out to be an asshole, but it's counterproductive to his later stated goals, his previously stated goals, and it's a discredit to the episode as a whole. By Remmick's logic, I am responsible for allowing 9/11 because I did nothing to stop it. "But you had nothing to do with that! You were 14 years old!" Well, I would call that doing nothing to stop it.
The scene between Worf and Wesley is, so far, my favorite scene in this episode. I really like it. Worf's acting is good, his character spot on, it's a nice moment. Wesley is good as well.
One of the funniest scenes that I can recall from Star Trek is that stupid kid declaring "I'M LEAVING!" and then immediately fucking up everything. This comes to mind.
Why didn't they tractor the shuttle immediately? Exactly how fast did that shuttle fly away to get out of range so fast?! They can beam people to the planet, but they can't beam people off a shuttlecraft near the planet?
Yeah, you stupid whiny kid, now you want help. And now that you are being given help, you argue with the damn captain, because obviously you know how to fly a shuttle, except you can't fly one for 10 seconds without turning it into a flying dumpster fire.
I know Starfleet likes to be inclusive of all cultures and traditions, but if Worf doesn't get to kill Picard if he thinks the captain is being a coward, then the giant asshole yellowshirt shouldn't get to yell at kids. Just wait till the test where they offend a Klingon warrior and have to take part in a battle to the death, naked and drunk on bloodwine, using flaming bat'leths covered in the blood of the innocent. Hey, it's his culture, bro.
"Do you want this to become violent?" Wesley I'm pretty sure that guy has eaten bigger burritos than you.
Worf gives the best interview so far. Data is a close second.
"How would you characterize your relationship with Captain Picard?" I mean yeah we blow each other sometimes but it's not a thing. I just like, I dunno, I don't believe in possession, ja feel? /s How is that question in any way appropriate? Apparently they don't have sexual harassment training in the future.
They didn't even interview Yar!
That looked one of those browser games. Don't worry, Mordok, in 14 hours you can try again with more lives, or pay $0.99 now to resume immediately! Don't forget your $1.00 booster packs or your $0.25 decorative hat!
"So sorry, sir, I tried my hardest to make something out of nothing and offend everyone on the ship -- I even harassed their doctor!" Lt. Cmdr. Remmick, Galaxy's Worst Investigator.
"I need people I can trust, so I did everything in my power to break our bond of trust." Admiral Quinn, Galaxy's Worst Counter-Conspirator.
Mordok looks like he just got violated. You're next, Wes!
Wesley is psyching himself out already... And he's literally sitting in an empty room. But an ACTUAL emergency occurs, and he's fine! Note to self: if you want to torture Wesley, just put him in an empty room and make him wait. He'll crack in no time!
I feel like Wesley's "greatest fear" is kinda pulled out of thin air. I mean, sure, it makes sense when you think about his Dad, and I appreciate that part of the reveal relating to Picard, but honestly I don't know if it's played up that much, nor has there ever been any indication that this is something that weighs heavily on Wesley's mind.
"It's unfair that only one candidate from Relva gets to go, so we're gonna be unfair, because fuck you, that's why." Not to mention that Wesley isn't from Relva, and every test that we see had Wesley do just as good or better than Mordok, except for the speed test, which apparently wasn't the only deciding factor?
The final scene between Wesley and Picard is also good. Picard isn't completely at ease with kids, still, but he does genuinely care about Wesley. It's another good scene.
In final review, the conspiracy feels like it should be a much bigger deal, but in true Season 1 fashion it amounts to nothing and is immediately forgotten. And, in true fashion, "Let's go off to our next mission!"
The episode is kinda weak, and I'm not a huge fan of it.
The Good! Wesley is not annoying, rather he's actually likeable, and was given a solid storyline to work with and gives a good performance in turn. The conspiracy storyline had the potential to be interesting. It has some good scenes: the Worf-Wesley scene, the Picard-Wesley scene, the scene where Picard has to help that stupid, hapless kid out of the mess. It has continuity, referencing events in "The Battle", "Where No One has Gone Before", "The Naked Now", and "Justice". It has the first appearance of a shuttlecraft, and I do like the model, despite it being a tad squat. The first Riker maneuver, and it comes off nicely with Riker getting in Remmick's face. The interview scene where Remmick is going back and forth between characters was good, and I enjoy the fact that Remmick was playing the part of the asshole, and even wants to join the crew after his current assignment. The editing is better than previous episodes. Remmick and Quinn give good performances (even if their actions are dumb).
The Bad... There's still way too much to distract from that. The shuttlecraft kid, the girl, Mordok, and others act very poorly. Jake Curland in particular is, to borrow Ex Astris Scientia's terminology, the TNG cliche "Pussy of the Week". The Remmick plot is cliche, overacted, doesn't make sense, and then the conspiracy line gets tossed out at the very end like it's not a big deal, and we're off to our next mission again! Yar is a glaring absentee, only showing up to yell a few lines during the shuttle scene. Wesley isn't the problem in the exam plotline, but the plotline has big mistakes that I just can't get over. TNG is coming together by now, but it's not there yet.
After listening to the Pensky File and re-watching some stuff I'm convinced to give it a slightly higher rating. I can be very nitpicky. Nevertheless, the episode has serious flaws, and we've already had many better episodes in the series (Where No One Has Gone Before, The Big Goodbye, and 11001001 being good examples).
4/10