r/starcraft2 • u/PrinceAdam42 • 3h ago
What StarCraft II Taught Me About Desire, Mental Processing Power, and the Present Moment
I've been playing StarCraft II since Wings of Liberty. I reached Diamond during Heart of the Swarm and eventually climbed to around 4950 MMR as a Zerg player during Legacy of the Void. At one point, I was spending 12–16 hours a day trying to become the best player in the world.
I would wake up, drink water, exercise, eat something light, and do some jumping jacks before playing because I understood that physical exercise could help the brain process information. I took competitive StarCraft quite seriously.
When I reached the upper end of Masters, I started questioning why I was losing games despite having strong mechanics. I was achieving spending scores of 140+ or higher, which put me within the range of Grandmaster players. I remember watching Stephano play during Legacy of the Void and noticing similarities between our gameplay, although looking back on it, I think he was more patient than I was.
Eventually, I began examining the role my emotions played in my performance, and I stumbled upon a rather interesting philosophical problem that had implications far beyond StarCraft.
Desiring something in the future pulls you out of the present moment and consumes mental processing power that could otherwise be utilized in the present, thereby decreasing your efficiency.
The Desire to Win
Winning a game of StarCraft is something that occurs in the future. However, every action necessary to achieve that victory must occur in the present moment.
When you're actively experiencing the desire to win, you're utilizing a portion of your mental processing power on that desire. This is processing power that could otherwise be utilized for managing your economy, controlling your army, gathering information, analyzing your opponent's decisions, or determining your next course of action.
It's almost like having an unnecessary background process consuming CPU resources while you're attempting to perform a computationally demanding task.
In a game as mentally demanding as StarCraft II, where information is constantly changing and numerous tasks must be performed simultaneously, this can become a significant impediment to performance.
The irony is that you're expending mental resources desiring an outcome at the expense of the mental resources necessary to achieve that very outcome.
This isn't the same as strategic planning. Thinking about future possibilities can serve a practical function in determining what actions to take in the present. The desire for a particular outcome, however, can consume mental processing power without contributing anything toward its realization.
The Paradox of Desire
There is another layer to this problem that I find particularly amusing.
What happens when you realize that relinquishing your desire to win might improve your chances of winning, and you subsequently attempt to relinquish that desire because you want to win?
I eventually formulated the following statement:
"You have to not want what you want to get what you want..."
The amusing thing about this statement is that the moment you consciously attempt to apply it in order to obtain what you want, you've already contradicted it.
The original desire hasn't disappeared. You're now potentially utilizing even more mental processing power, both desiring the outcome and attempting to suppress that desire.
This introduces an interesting distinction between establishing an objective and continually desiring its realization. You can enter a game of StarCraft with the objective of winning without continually experiencing the desire to win throughout the course of the game.
The objective can inform your actions without becoming another mental process competing for the resources necessary to execute those actions.
Four Interesting Philosophical Parallels
Years later, while exploring philosophy and spirituality, I became interested in whether ancient philosophical traditions had addressed anything resembling what I discovered through competitive StarCraft.
Interestingly, I found parallels in several different philosophical and religious texts, each addressing a different component of the phenomenon.
The Bhaddekaratta Sutta (Majjhima Nikāya 131)
This Buddhist discourse advises against pursuing the past or placing expectations upon the future, instead directing attention toward discerning what is presently arising.
This addresses the temporal component of what I experienced in StarCraft. Our minds can become occupied with something that no longer exists or something that has yet to occur, while our ability to act exists in the present.
The Dvedhāvitakka Sutta (Majjhima Nikāya 19)
In this discourse, the Buddha recognizes that even prolonged thinking about wholesome subjects can tire the body, strain the mind and interfere with concentration.
This is particularly interesting because the subject of our thoughts doesn't necessarily need to be negative for the mental activity itself to become counterproductive.
Even a seemingly beneficial thought can consume mental processing power that could be more effectively utilized elsewhere.
The Bhagavad Gita (2:47–50)
Krishna instructs Arjuna to perform his actions without becoming attached to the fruits of those actions. These verses also associate equanimity in success and failure with skill in action.
The Sanskrit expression yogaḥ karmasu kauśalam is often translated as "Yoga is skill in action."
There is an interesting relationship here between detachment from a future outcome and the efficiency with which we perform actions in the present.
The Zhuangzi (Chapter 19)
An ancient Chinese philosophical passage describes an archer whose skill remains intact when competing for something relatively insignificant, but whose performance deteriorates as the value of the prize increases.
The person's underlying skill hasn't necessarily changed. Rather, the importance attributed to the outcome interferes with their ability to utilize that skill.
I think competitive StarCraft players can probably appreciate this distinction. Someone might perform exceptionally well in practice games only to find themselves underperforming in a tournament, despite their mechanical and strategic knowledge remaining relatively unchanged.
The Implications Beyond StarCraft
This phenomenon has implications for virtually every aspect of human existence.
A musician desiring to impress an audience may consume mental processing power that could otherwise be utilized in their musical performance. Someone attempting to fall asleep might inadvertently keep themselves awake through their desire to fall asleep. Someone desperately wanting to relax might expend considerable mental energy attempting to determine whether they're actually relaxing.
Even the desire to acquire knowledge can potentially interfere with the efficiency of acquiring knowledge.
What I find particularly interesting is that the desired outcome need not be detrimental, nor does the person necessarily need to be experiencing negative emotions. Excitement about winning can potentially interfere with gameplay just as fear of losing can.
The underlying problem is the expenditure of mental processing power in the present upon the desire for something to occur in the future.
I find it rather amusing that I stumbled upon this philosophical problem while spending an absurd number of hours playing StarCraft II, and that I've since encountered different components of it scattered throughout ancient Buddhist, Hindu and Taoist texts.
Some people might diminish the significance of a philosophical discovery because it originated from playing a video game. However, I think competitive StarCraft provides an extraordinarily interesting environment in which to examine the relationship between consciousness, emotion, desire, mental processing power and performance.
The game gives us immediate and measurable feedback concerning the consequences of our decisions. At higher levels of competition, where considerable mechanical proficiency has already been developed, it can become particularly interesting to investigate the mental processes that interfere with the utilization of that proficiency.
One of the greatest lessons StarCraft taught me was that the intensity with which we desire something does not necessarily increase our ability to accomplish it. Sometimes, the very act of desiring something in the future diminishes our ability to bring that future into existence.
I'm curious whether other competitive StarCraft players have independently arrived at similar realizations, or whether they've discovered other interesting philosophical principles through their experiences with the game.


