The top sentences are filled while editing:
This post is aiming that the balancing council is not doing their job. Please focus on this statement.
Serral is a great player. He won the latest IEM Katowice because he was better than Maru.
Remember, this game is about a story and war of three races, not only for Zerg and Terran.
Hello, I am a Korean guy who enjoys playing StarCraft2 and also a big fan of StarCraft2 pro tournaments, including GSLs and periodic ESL tournaments.
After the 5.0.13 PTR balance update note was released, I thought deeply about the recent changes in SC2 and its gameplay. I want to discuss the current balance updates with many SC2 fans on Reddit, so I created this post.
In a nutshell, I would demonstrate that the current and the previous balance updates have been inconsistent for all three races and have hurt the SC2 pro scene.
Note that the majority of the arguments in this post originated from my personal opinions.
Part 1. The current pro scene of SC2 is unhealthy - PROTOSS IS CRYING.
In this part, I want to emphasize that the pro Protoss players and their fans have a hard time playing/watching big tournaments.
For the last few years, there has been only one Protoss champion, herO [ref1]. Specifically, for 27 premier SC2 tournaments from 2020 to the present, herO only got the trophy twice.
Let me briefly introduce the statistical test of these results. Here are the following assumptions: the number of players for each race is equal, and the win rate for all the matches is equally 50% for the perfect balance assumptions. In this setting, the p-value (tells how likely this event is occurring under the null hypothesis, in this case, the null hypothesis is “the balance of SC2 for pro players is perfect”) of this scenario is approximately 5 over 10 thousand (0.00005). I was shocked after this analysis because the event with this level of p-value can be simply considered a randomized error that does not occur in usual.
Of course, this result is not accurate, since not every match for any 2 players cannot show 50% win rates and there are a bunch of unexpected situations while playing SC2, e.g., a condition of one player for that match is not good to show his/her 100% strategies. But, however, I would demonstrate that there exists a serious balancing problem, especially for Protoss, through the previous analysis.
Although only herO has won in recent tournaments, I wish to emphasize that Protoss pro players are not necessarily lagging far behind players who specialize in Zerg or Terran [ref2]. When comparing the number of Protoss players that advanced to Ro8 for the current version (the balance update was done by the balancing council) and the previous version (the balance update was done by Blizzard) for the premier tournaments, at least one Protoss player was advanced to Ro8, except the latest IEM Katowice (Skillous & herO ends their tournament at Ro12).
Also, to my knowledge, the point at which the balancing council began to be involved in balance updates started from IEM Katowice 2023. It is interesting to see the results that, when comparing the number of Protoss players in Ro8 (for GSLs, I included Ro10 players), the average number of Protoss players decreased after the balancing council was launched [ref2]. Moreover, when excluding the records of herO from tournaments held before the establishment of the balancing council (due to his victories in the 2022 GSL S3 and DH SC2 Masters 2022 Atlanta), the number of Protoss pro players is slightly higher compared to the number after the balancing council was established.
I strongly argue that there must be a huge unconventional change for Protoss. I’m not claiming that Protoss is weak because all SC2 pro players show the same performance. Of course, the skilled player should win. But, this game is played by humans and we are watching the tournaments with human participants. Shouldn’t games be fun and tournaments be exciting? Remember, the StarCraft series is a war of three races, not for Zerg and Terran. And I fervently wish to witness the war among the three races.
Part 2. The balance updates are inconsistent across the three races.
In this part, I will dive into the details of the current and previous balance updates and demonstrate my opinions. I’ll first discuss individual units and then conclude with an overall discussion.
A. Cyclone
The day before the intervention of the balancing council, we can produce Cyclone from Factory with Tech labs, and it has a usage for all-race battles. Usually, Cyclone is used for defending early invasions and sometimes used for early aggressive strategies. The point I want to emphasize is that this unit is not one that wasn’t used before. Regardless of whether the intention was good or bad, Cyclone has been changed. To be honest, I cannot understand the initial attempt by the balancing council to change Cyclone, which was used for mech army vs Protoss. Anyway, as a result, Cyclone has become a problem in itself. In TvT, Cyclone is the main culprit that makes both sides extremely sensitive, and in TvP, it does not help at all with the intended mech army. Is there a reason why this unit should be so disliked?
B. Liberator, Widow Mine, and Hellbat in previous updates
The current problematic TvP matchup would be expected to show a noticeable difference by the nerf of Liberator and Widow Mine. However, Liberators and Widow Mines are also crucial units in the current TvZ matchup. Can Terran handle these nerfs? If my speculation is correct, Terran should be more proactive in using Hellbats against Zerg in the late game, which was shown by Maru a few years ago. But why? Hellbats don’t handle Zerglings as effectively as they used to! Because the balancing council nerfs Hellbats in the previous balance updates. Well, let me ask again. What should Terran do now?
C. Sentry & Observer
Is the balancing council kidding me? Is this change really needed? Is the early game of PvP coming to an end?
D. High Templar
This unit needed a buff. Compared to other spellcasters that can be put into the comparison, especially those that will be mentioned in the following part, it’s definitely garbage.
E. Overlord
Did Zerg not use the Overlord drop in nearly a year? According to comments [ref3], it’s expressed that it was to compensate for the losses caused by the nerf to the Baneling, but it was being well utilized despite the losses.
F. Infestor, and Viper
I’ve finally reached the part where there’s the most to talk about. Infestor is arguably one of the most disgusting units in the entire history of SC2. We’ve come from the era of the “Broodlord - Corruptor - Infestor” in Wings of Liberty to where we are now. The role of spellcaster once burdened by the Infestor has been separated through the appearance of Viper in Heart of The Swarm. And even now, these two units are incredibly powerful. Specifically, with the buffs from the previous update, the Infestor’s fungal growth has become incredibly easy to use (with Infestor being able to use fungal growth right after it hatches), and the combination of burrow and fungal growth has become a disaster for Terran bios.
Of course, not all Zerg players are proficient with Burrow Infestors. Currently, only Serral is extremely proficient with it. When used with skill, this unit, which can be devastating, gains an additional range of 1. A very interesting point is that Serral, being the most recent champion, actually received additional support.
Serral is undoubtedly a skilled and excellent player. In the current pro scene, it’s hard to doubt his ability to win, except perhaps in a few specific ZvZ matchups. The key to Serral’s high win rate in ZvT and ZvP matchups lies in his proficiency with strategies that involve securing numerous bases, consistently encouraging appropriate resource exchanges, and then actively utilizing spellcasters to secure victory in games. But let’s consider this for a moment. Is this the only way Zerg can win?
Absolutely not! This game is a real-time strategy game, and Zerg, as one of its proud races, can certainly choose strategic changes. And as far as I know, most amateurs, and even some pros, prefer strategic changes that precede late-game spellcaster usage. Are they wrong then? This game is about adapting in real-time to the opponent’s movements and skillfully executing one’s various strategies. Are you saying there’s only one strategy?
Someone might argue, “So if you nerf Zerg’s Infestor and Viper because they’re overly strong, then how should both Zerg pro players and amateurs win the game?”. I’d like to provide two responses here. Firstly, then just buff the other units to compensate for it! For instance, if we nerf Viper so that it can no longer abduct massive units such as Mothership or Carrier (it’s fascinating how Protoss’s skill level appears to be lacking to the extent that even small Vipers can abduct them). Without modifying other units, Zerg might have a low chance of winning against Protoss if the Protoss prepares Golden Armada. To resolve such a problem, just buff Corrupter. Is it impossible to do it like this? This type of update is clearly dangerous and thus updating for balance is certainly challenging. However, the current approach tends to homogenize strategies, leaving amateurs unfamiliar with spellcasters still stagnant.
There is still a second response remaining. In the sloppy example I just presented, Zerg received a “compensatory” buff. Indeed, this Overlord patch explicitly mentioned it as a “compensation”. My second response is simple: Terran and Protoss usually don’t get compensation! Why why why why always Zerg gets a bunch of compensation? Is it possible to establish fair criteria for all three races and patch accordingly?
Conclusion
For the aforementioned reasons, I believe that the balancing council has significant problems. The changes experienced through the balancing council have caused significant distress not only to the pro players but also to amateurs, leading to a great sense of disillusionment among many fans who have loved StarCraft2 for a long time. Since you mentioned gathering opinions from various communities for balance updates [ref3], I hope my opinion can also be considered. It’s my first time expressing my opinion on Reddit rather than the Korean StarCraft2 community, “우주전쟁 마이너 갤러리 (you can call this as WMG)”, and I hope we can engage in meaningful discussions.
Last but not least, I have one final thing I really want to say. Protoss players are absolutely, absolutely, absolutely not rats. Harstem, you must apologize.