r/spikes • • 1d ago

Article [Article]Competitive formats 2027 annoucement

52 Upvotes

Article

Big things pio RC 2026–27 Regional Championship, running April 10 to May 23, 2027, will also be Pioneer!

then a pio rcq season follows that.


r/spikes • • 5h ago

Standard [Standard] There’s no way the worlds deck has a chance online, right?

41 Upvotes

(context + decklist: https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/8041802#paper )

So this is the deck that took down worlds, it’s basically the same playstyle as izzet lessons but can draw way more cards once [[anthropological mission]] is properly set up, and then wins with [[ral, crackling wit]] or a sideboarded [[bothersome noisemaker]].

I already had the manabase on arena, so i was able to craft it very cheaply and test it out in some games and… unless i’m playing it wrong, it *really* seems like a product of its environment, and was successful only because stefan knew what to tech against going into the tourney (which is a skill in and of itself, i’m not trying to detract from his accomplishment)

But man, this deck immediately folds to anyone playing [[inevitable defeat]], and if your wincons get hit by [[duress]] or [[deceit]] a couple times you’re basically screwed too.

to me, It genuinely does feel like its only good matchups are the aggressive decks like momo/prowess/GW counters (which was most of worlds), and everything else feels almost impossible to navigate.

Has anyone else tried this list online? or has anyone brewed up their own version of Izzet Mission that has a less polarizing matchup spread?


r/spikes • • 9h ago

Standard [Standard] Thoughts on my Mono Green Landfall build?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’d love to get some feedback and suggestions on my current Mono Green Landfall list:https://moxfield.com/decks/MhLqsJxdTEKjLoZn06gMCQ

I run this exact same 75 both on Arena and in paper at my LGS. I'm currently running 1x Stable Wormhole and 1x Jadzia Dax, Living Legacy as fun-ofs since I just pulled them at prerelease and wanted to test how they perform in actual games.

My most common matchups are:

  • 4c Jeskai

  • GW Gearhulk

  • GW Ouroboroid (+1/+1 Counters)

  • Dimir Control

  • Jund Sacrifice

  • Izzet affinity

I'd love your thoughts on the overall 75, especially on the sideboard to better handle these specific matchups. Any cuts, additions, or sideboarding tips are super appreciated. Thanks!


r/spikes • • 1d ago

Article [Article] Red Deck Wins - A History of 1 Drops

31 Upvotes

Article

World's is here! Except, there no Mono Red Aggro in the decklist dumps! Since my beloved RDW isn't at World's, I decided to take a trip down memory lane and look at all the 1 mana creatures that Red Aggro played over the years.

All the embedded images make the article seem much longer than it really is, but its not a short article (30 years of history after all).

I looked at how creatures evolved and how they haven't and what titans of yesteryear are up to now

Please feel free to check out my other work:

Burn Baby Burn:

Modern Burn Primer | Modern Burn Tips & Tricks | Modern Burn Mulligans

Level Up Series:

Git Gud Scrub | Biggest Myths | Practice Like a Pro | Winning on Margins | Spiking Tournaments

Your Move:

Modern | Legacy | Pauper

Other:

Cheaters Never Prosper

Content List


r/spikes • • 2d ago

Results Thread [Standard] The World Championship offers a really terrible viewer experience

137 Upvotes

After day 1 of the world just ended, there’s no way to find any insight to the day 1 result. If you go to the offical website. When you click standing it’s just list of players, it doesn’t show their records, it doesn’t show their deck list and there’s no link to provide any further information.

Normally the day 1 highlight at least post the deck win rates, they didn’t even do that in this world despite having all the data. The reporter just writes that Boros Pixie has 60% win rate, and both landfall decks are sub 40% then offers no additional insights.

It’s honestly frustrating really. However it’d be interesting to see if Boros Pixie can maintain its high win rate when most of the landfall decks don’t make it to day 2.


r/spikes • • 3d ago

Standard [Standard] Magic World Championship 32 Standard Metagame Breakdown

76 Upvotes

r/spikes • • 4d ago

Modern [Article] October ’26 Metagame Update: Month of Champions

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/spikes • • 4d ago

Standard Why is Dimir Control (draw-go version) pulling ahead of Azorius? [Standard]

Thumbnail reddit.com
13 Upvotes

r/spikes • • 5d ago

Standard Are allies a viable best of three paper deck? [allies] [standard] [4c] [control]

0 Upvotes

Pretty simple. I just got into magic about 5 months ago. I started with monument/artist’s ta;ent, and that isn't so good anymore, so I naturally pivoted to jeskai lessons before realizing lessons actually suck and so then to 3 color control, lacking enchantment removal, to 4 color control, and now here I am playing in a group of [people who have been playing for years and years and have tier 1 decks and I think I might want to start winning some. 4 color control is hard!

I don't want to copy somebody else’s deck at the store, and nobody has allies. What do you think about allies? Are they viable and will continue to be after the ban? Thanks!


r/spikes • • 5d ago

Standard [Standard] Star Trek Day One - What's Working and What's Not?

41 Upvotes

The new set is out on digital clients, and Worlds is this weekend! It seems like there are nowhere near as many people playing today as there was for Reality Fracture, which is not that surprising.

What's working for you and what's not?

[[The Naked Time]] is one of the strongest cards in the set, and I am experimenting with it in various Boros builds. When you get it in your starting hand it's amazing, but the deck is way less explosive without it.


r/spikes • • 6d ago

Standard [Standard] Advice for RCQ deck

10 Upvotes

I had a great run with the classic belladonna tokens List before, made top 8 in the last RCQ I played in.

https://moxfield.com/decks/u4WgAb4YVXKg4gCiO1YgfA

I was looking at the new set and found [[Troubling Tribbles]] I have been tinkering with a new deck that focuses more on the ETB triggers.

https://moxfield.com/decks/uKuhAQp1cX6F25yl8kJACA

But im not sure what of the two I should run for the next RCQ.

What does the hivemind say?

Edit: I took Tribbles back out again sadly its bad


r/spikes • • 6d ago

Standard [standard] Brazen Bluff in Jeskai Revelation?

3 Upvotes

Could [[Brazen Bluff]] see play in [[Jeskai Revelation]] decks? I feel like it could but I want to hear some thoughts on it, my main reason for thinking it could see some play there is that if you hold it until you have a revelation in hand its a lose lose situation for your opponents, either they can have their spell exiled, or they can gamble on the chance you have a revelation, and if you do then you can still return the spell to their hand while getting the rest of revelation, additionally if your opponent knows your playing revelation then the exile is essentially forced if you cast bluff in the early game, or else they risk giving you a revelation as early as turn 2


r/spikes • • 6d ago

Scheduled Post Weekly Deck Check Thread | Monday, November 09, 2026

7 Upvotes

Hello spikes!

This is the place where any and all decks can be posted for all spikes to see. The goal of this is to fit all your needs for competitive magic. Maybe it's a card consideration given an X dollar budget. Maybe you need that sweet sideboard tech that no one else thought of? Perhaps you just can't figure out the best card to beat a certain matchup. The ideas here are only limited by your imagination!

Feel free to discuss most anything here. We only ask that with any question, you also make sure to post your decklist so people have some context to answer your question. Otherwise, have at it! If you have any questions, shoot us a modmail and we'll be happy to help you out. Survive your deck check and survive your competition!


r/spikes • • 7d ago

Standard [Standard] Weapons Manufacturing and Engineered Explosives

28 Upvotes

Hi Spikes, as many of you know Star Trek will reprint into standard [[engineered explosives]], since i mainly play modern the first thing i thought of once i saw this card spoiled was to pair it with [[Weapons Manufacturing]] to one-shot my opponent’s face/board. I started brewing a list with the usual suspects of [[Pinnacle Emissary]] and [Ravenous Robots]] and i landed on grixis once i saw [[Collation Trimatrix]] spoiled. I rounded out the deck with the other 0/1 drop artifacts in standard to get as many tokens as possible in a big early turn. I wonder if somebody already tinkered with the idea and if you guys have any suggestions, both about cards to include/cut and if you think this would be actually viable in this meta. One of the goals of the deck is also to be kinda “rotation proof” since this version it would only lose [[Legion Extruder]] in february.

https://moxfield.com/decks/nKWJ3vS9VEm1CbwtBTzrmg


r/spikes • • 8d ago

Standard [Standard] Dimir Midrange RCQ 8th place report

32 Upvotes

After winning my first standard RCQ of the season, I was hoping to make it 2/2 to double qualify. Didn't quite get there, but it was a fun tournament and I'm happy about making top 8! Figured I should do a little report here, it helps me reflect on the tournament and hopefully can help some other folks too. This is my list, and my (updated) sideboard guide is in there too. I got to talk about my matches with another Dimir player much better than me, and I'm more confident on my plans now than before. MN means I mulled N times, OMN same for my opponent.

Round 1: Azorius Momo 1-2

Game 1 (Draw): Kept a 2 Curiosity hand with Siren. Not the matchup I wanted to see, but I got lucky and drew all of my Curiosities, which let me do some chump attacks and still draw a *ton* of cards. They had the Riddler scam but for once I was able to outvalue it with Curiosities. I drew 18 cards one of the turns lol W

Sideboarding: +2 Vren +2 Day +1 Tidebinder, -2 Kaito -2 Siren -1 Betrayal. I'm happy about this plan on the draw, but my Dimirror opponent (round 4) argued that on the play we need to prioritize pushing damage more, and suggested -2 Curiosity -2 We Say instead. The We Say Thee Nay do feel kind of weak, so I can see the value of this plan. Need to test it more to make sure though.

Game 2 (Draw, M1 OM1): t1 Drum t2 Riddler scam t3 Momo + Sage is basically impossible for me to beat, I fear. I don't remember much about this game, but I didn't draw enough removal to deal with that. Had to hardcast a Kaito at some point just to stay alive but it wasn't enough =( L

Game 3 (Play, M1 OM1): She Riddler scammed t3 this time, so not as bad, but then found 2 Sage of the Skies. I kept a bit of an awkward hand, definitely possible that I should have gone to 5. Can't remember exact hand but it was slow, a little removal but couldn't deal with all the Sages. Killed 1, Wasp'd the other, they killed the Wasp, eventually just got outrun by them. L

Tough matchup, not a good start. But I knew with 17 players I could afford at least one loss, so I was not too discouraged. Not a ton of new insights into Momo, it's a bad matchup and we need a lot to go right. Need a way to stop Riddler scam, them not to draw too many Sages, and god knows what else. Not super common matchup I guess so I won't complain.

Round 2 - Azorius Control 2-0

Game 1 (Draw, M1): Kept a very creature heavy hand, and that's basically all I needed. Just kept playing dorks until they didn't have enough responses. They had 2 wraths but I was able to hold enough threats that it didn't ruin me, and I found a couple Curiosity, so that's great. Not much else to say. W

Sideboard: +3 Duress +1 Negate +1 Tidebinder +1 Annul, -3 Hex -1 Shoot -1 Betrayal -1 Drowner. Pretty happy with this plan, I knew there was a lot of Control in my region and played 3rd Triumph over the 2nd Shoot, felt pretty rewarded (Round 3 was the same pairing). Last cut is interesting, obviously if I was on 2 Shoot I'd cut that, but on 1 I think the Drowner is the 60th card. I could see it being incorrect to cut a creature though, especially because Annul only gets Seam Rip and Starcage. Moving forward I think I'd keep the Drowner. It's not great but it is a threat.

Game 2 (Draw, M1): Kept a Duress, Beavers, and Kaito, so that's great. Their hand was Wan, 3 steps ahead, No more lies, and lands--I took the Lies as the cheaper counter. Again not much interesting happened, just drew enough creatures to keep the pressure on, drew Kaito and then Curiosity, and that's all she wrote. W

Felt great about my tiny meta call of 3 Triumph, killed Jace with Triumph both games and then the third game we played for practice. I'd play 2 Triumph 2 Shoot on an open meta to be clear. On the practice game, I did terribly misplay--forgot to crack 2 maps before attacking the Theorist, which would have let me kill it, and I ended up losing that game by being buried by Theorist. Thankfully cracked all the maps I needed during the real games though.

Round 3 - Azorius Control 2-0

Game 1 (Draw): Again, just drew enough creatures and lucked out on them not having a counter for Curiosity on the turn I took a chance on it because I was low on cards. They had a pretty bad draw. W

Sideboard: same as last round

Game 2 (Draw): Kept Siren, Beavers, and some 2 drop (Wasp I think?), but no Curiosity or Kaito. Didn't draw either until turn 5 or so, but had good tempo with Drowner, and enough nonlands on top to kill the Theorist when they got it down. Drew a Kaito eventually and killed them quick with Soulstone Sanctuary and Kaito beats #NinjaTribal. W

Love this matchup, not just because it's good but because it's a nice interactive one. I don't think it's a bye in any case, maybe 55%. Just need to draw lots of creatures, and *eventually* some card advantage. If they have the right removal and counters where they need it though, it's tough. 2-1 now so if I win the next one I'm locked in for top 8. Got bad news for you though...

Round 4 - Dimir Midrange 0-2

Game 1 (Play): Kept a hand with a few creatures, but no card advantage, and never drew Curiosity of Kaito. I draw a few too many lands and have some good beats with Sanctuary. Once they got low, I took the risk to attack with both Sanctuary and Reef, and they play Tidebinder completely turning off my Reef (3 mana strip mine anyone??). They also have the 1B Prowler that you can pay life to pump, and I found no removal so that killed me pretty quick :( L

Sideboard: +1 Vren +1 Tidebinder, -1 Wan -1 Betrayal. I plan to only bring Duress in on the draw (feels better to take turn 1 off to Duress on the draw). My opponent disagrees with that, arguing that information and avoiding Kaito is valuable enough that we are ok with the tempo hit, and I have to think... I'll test it for sure. He also argued, and convinced me, that counters are pretty weak in the mirror since we are so good at playing instant speed and it doesn't stop Kaito. I also love Vren here, but I like Curiosity and I don't think we can afford so many 4 drops. So my final idea is +2 Duress +1 Vren +1 Tidebinder, -2 Wan -1 We Say -1 Betrayal. Opp also argued for bring in 1 Day on the draw... I'm not sure, I see the value but it feels so slow. Maybe over the second We Say it's fine. Gotta test.

Game 2 (Play): Kept some weenies and Curiosities, 3 lands. Felt pretty great about it. t3 they had a Drowner, and I held up Tidebinder instead of playing a Beavers to look for a land because I was afraid of Kaito. They didn't have Kaito, so I took turn 3 off, which was a mistake--opp argued I should have jammed tidebinder to put on pressure, and I agree. If I drew a land I would then be able to play Curiosity and go off, and in the mirror you really need to put on fast pressure. Unfortunately I didn't draw a land, and by the time I did they had me too low. They Wasp the Curiosity, attack for Lethal, and I have to chump with Curiosity. I make a mistake here, could have killed the Wasp so my curiosity came back after it died. I'd be dead anyway but still. Rip L

Love the mirror, so fun. Sad that I got a little unlucky game 1 and made a couple small-looking but probably actually game losing punts game 2, but my opponent was a MUCH better player than me so they deserved it. I'm now not guaranteed to make top 8 even if I win the next one, but gotta try.

Round 5 - Mono Green Landfall 2-0

Game 1 (Play, M1 OM1): They open on 2 Chocobo which is rough. I take a chance and play Kaito turn 2, because they didn't play a fetch after Chocobo 2 so I assumed they didn't have it which meant Kaito would survive. On just 1 Chocobo I'd have -2 Kaito to make sure he survived, but given that I wasn't sure he'd survive I just 0'd to make sure he replaced itself. Unfortunately opp drew the fetch so Kaito down, but that gained me enough life. I took a chance on Betrayal and they chose to exile Chocobo instead of their Llanowar Elves which was really good for me, I then Hex the Cultivator they play instead of the Chocobo hoping to avoid the *value train*. I stun their Chocobo with Kaito, they get a Harmonizer down. They make a really good play with a pumped Harmonizer + pumped Elves making me choose between my life total, Curiosity, and Kaito, and I trade Curiosity for Harmonizer and let Kaito die which turns out was the right choice, but it's a hard one because I was so close to lethal). They then have a very large attack with Chocobo and some fetches on their last turn. I have to make a choice here--I can either play Wan for 4 so it gets an extra counter (which I was pretty sure I needed to kill them next turn), or play it for 2 and hope to draw a removal spell. I math it out that they can't *quite* kill me, so I play it for 4. I do draw a Shoot the Sheriff immediately so felt pretty mad lol but turns out I was right, I take 11 but they have no fliers so I swing for exact lethal next turn. W

Sideboard: +2 Vren +2 Day +2 Flashfreeze +1 Negate +1 Annul, -2 Kaito -2 Siren -1 Yuriko -1 Betrayal. This is a very tempo-oriented matchup so I do think trimming Kaito over trimming Curiosity makes sense. I love Vren, Day, and all the counterspells help us counter the Nursery which is really what kills us so those feel good too. The last 5 cuts I'm less certain about, though. Cutting Kaito makes me want to cut some one drops, and I think Beavers is better than Siren since it helps us dig. Yuriko also helps us dig, but it feels worse since they have so many ground blocks. I also cut 1 Betrayal--I'm less sure that that's good because of Cultivator now, but I still feel like it's too weak. If I played Snares I'd cut those too, but I made the meta call of playing 2nd Wan main over the Snare since I knew we have a lot of Landfall in my region, and got rewarded. I don't love cutting 3 one drops but unclear to me what else I could cut.

Game 2 (Draw, M1 OM1): Kept a slowwww hand, 3 lands 2 removal spells and a Curiosity. They have a slow start too though, and eventually I have curiosity going and enough tempo to get them to 8 life, and still staying pretty high since I had so much removal. They eventually draw the Nursery and make a ton of Saplings, but by that time I have a Vren, and a Day and Kaito in hand. I Day, and they can activate Nursery but I remind them that it doesn't really work since the creatures lose all abilities. They make another Sapling since one of their lands die, but I stun it with Kaito, and attack for 9 with Curiosity, Vren and a mapped Siren. Internally I was annoyed that I didn't get to make the rats but can't complain about winning. W

Don't love this matchup, but this match shows exactly why it's close. Just need to dodge Nursery, draw a few important cards, and we can get there. Curiosity is a HOUSE, I love Kaito but unfortunately must say Curiosity is the best card in the deck. I played the extra Wan main to hedge for this matchup and it feels good to be rewarded, it drew me so many cards. Love the bird. Anyway, my breakers are pretty good and I'm one of four 3-2 gamers to make top 8! Exciting.

Quarterfinals - Azorius Artifacts 1-2

Game 1 (Play, M1 OM1): Kept a few weenies, Kaito, 3 lands. Could have bottomed land instead of Siren but was afraid of not finding the third land, punished immediately by drawing land t1 but it happens. I get a good amount of the way to killing them with creature lands. Make a choice to not activate Reef since it wouldn't speed up the clock t6 or so, could be that I should have. Wanted to keep Wasp up, which ended up being good by turning off their 5/5 vehicle. Unfortunately they get an answer for my Wasp, and the turn before I kill them they find a Synthesizer and then between killing my creatures and making hasty constructs they kill me pretty quick. A bit of a heartbreaker since I had them at 4 and just needed to draw almost any nonland to kill them any of 3 turns, and I draw only lands for the last like 4 turns of the game. But hey that's magic, it is what it is. L

Sideboard: +3 Duress +2 Day +1 Tidebinder +1 Negate +1 Annul, -3 Triumph -2 Wasp -1 Shoot -1 Hex -1 Betrayal. I'm happy about those ins, and I do think cutting most removal is good. After talking a lot with my opponent and my round 4 dimirror opponent, I do think keeping Wasp over Drowner is good. Killing constructs if better than stunning them, I guess.

Game 2 (Play): Kept a hand with just Duress, counters and Tidebinder, maybe a slow hand but I really feel like we need counters here so... I Duress and they have 4 lands, Synthesizer, Soul Stone, and Authority of the Consuls. I take Soul Stone because I drew a Tidebinder and I feel like I can turn off the Synth and the fast mana would be more trouble for me. They play a Relic turn 3, and I let it go and then realize at their end step that I wanna play Tidebinder just to put some pressure in (and because I have the counters for the rest of their stuff), so I feel pretty bad about letting them draw an extra card. They Starcage away my Beavers and their Relic (drawing one more card, 2 cards I could have stopped if I just played Tidebinder at the right time). They then play a Torpor Orb which stops their Authority of the Consuls, and they get some Constructs out past my counters, but I get creature lands going and manage to sneak in the kill after drawing a Hex for one of their constructs. Felt good to win this one tho cause I was feeling pretty bad about my punt. W

Game 3 (Draw): Kept Duress, Beavers, 2 Curiosity, 3 land. I draw Beavers t1 and Duress (I now believe I should have Beavers t1 to start putting on pressure, I don't think any of their t2 plays are scary enough to justify t1 Duress). They have 2 Land, Starcage, Bay, Relic, Blade, so I'm pretty sure I'm going to lose (this is called foreshadowing). I take the Bay, feels bad letting them keep Cage but Bay is basically any artifact they want so I gotta do it. They play Relic. I draw Wan Shi Tong. I really want to look for my fourth land now, because I feel like if I can establish Curiosity I can win. I play Beavers, don't find a land on top, so I decide to play the second Beavers even though they will get a 2 for 1 with Starcage. Still find no land, they Starcage, and I still find no land. I don't even get a second blue source to play Wan :c I find Tidebinder at least, after they already got Synthesizer down, but then t5 they play a Torpor Orb, so my Tidebinder can't stop their Synthesizer. They get a bunch of constructs out, I have to chump with all my creatures to survive, and then finally draw the 4th land but now there's no way to avoid dying next turn. A heartbreaker to go out on, but it's just how the game goes. L

This isn't the worst matchup, I think it might even be favored? But if you stumble even a little they can punish you so fast, it's just a very good deck. I could have played better for sure, and maybe that'd have been enough to win game 3, not sure. The matchup is tight, very rare to be able to survive a mistake. I think I learned a lot and am excited to play it more. Hope it keeps being a great deck so I can face it many more times!

In any case, I was happy about my list, happy about the tournament, and had a lot of fun with my opponents. Can't complain. Still loving Kaito, not switching decks anytime soon (because I'm poor, but also don't feel like it's as bad of a deck as everyone seems to think). That's all! Only one more chance to double qualify on the 29th! Wish me luck.


r/spikes • • 10d ago

Standard [Standard] Jund sacrifice discussion (aka: is Formidable Speaker the nuts?)

18 Upvotes

I've been having a lot of fun playing Jund Sacrifice in Standard and have amassed a 19-5 record over 24 games (one of the losses I threw so technically a 20-4 record). But there is so many card options for this deck! This is the current list I'm running: https://moxfield.com/decks/EJC5XxBALE64LMJQy--sGw

So the biggest innovation to the deck I've made is adding two copies of [[Formidable Speaker]]. I found that most games I lost were because of me running out of gas and flooding out, and adding two speakers has helped quite a bit with this. Turning an extra land or shitty one drop into the missing piece between [[The Sackville Bagginses]], [[Biotech Specialist]] and [[Umbral Collar Zealot]] has worked out very nicely, and it also just blocks reasonably well. Bonus upside that comes up sometimes is that it curves quite nicely into a [[lively dirge]] for 4 mana because it can put a creature in the yard for you.

A small other change is that I have opted for [[Elegy Acolyte]] as the four-drop of choice over [[Smaug, the Magnificent]]. Smaug really didn't get a lot of value the turn he came down and was just kinda mid overall.

I'm very curious to hear about other people's opinions on the deck! Is [[Rottenmouth Viper]] a must-include? It's nice that it can't be bounced by sunderflock, but is it not an awkward card more often than not? And are there any other cards I could consider? And what do you think of the formidable speaker flex slot? Curious to hear other people's opinions!


r/spikes • • 10d ago

Sealed [Sealed] The Ultimate Star Trek Sealed Guide

1 Upvotes

Hey folks!

Star Trek prereleases are happening this weekend, and the set drops on MTGA next week, plus we've got Early Access behind us, where we saw people trying both ends of the spectrum with aggro and soup. Perfect time to drop our Sealed guide.

Bryan Hohns took a break from winning Reality Fracture Arena Direct boxes to write up a guide for Star Trek's Sealed environment, with an emphasis on archetypes, mechanics, and commentary on all the rares and mythics in the set.

Looks like there's a good bit of mechanical overlap and a decent number of "threshold" mechanics that want you to track what you've got going on in your deck, from creature types to unique lands to artifact creatures.

We also have the return of spacecraft, which were a bit odd in Edge of Eternities, and aren't doing anything that different in this set. There are some obviously great ones and an archetype centered around them, but they remain a question mark until we get out hands on them.

What are your thoughts on Star Trek right now? Which color pairs do you expect to perform well, and which ones will flop? And do you think the set leans in favor of 5-color piles or tempo/aggro decks? Let us know what you think, and hope the Sealed guide helps. Best of luck in your events! https://draftsim.com/mtg-star-trek-sealed-guide/
And if you want a slightly different perspective, The Daily Upkeep's latest podcast episode covers the format as well, with way more floudering over the lore and aesthetics of the set: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lYasiTFQ198


r/spikes • • 11d ago

Draft [Draft] [TRK] Georgiou, Terran Emperor: A+ vs. D+—how do you evaluate the risk?

11 Upvotes

Georgiou, Terran Emperor has the biggest expert-rating spread I’ve tracked this preview season: A+ from MTG Arena Zone versus D+ from Limited Level-Ups.

For reference, it’s a {4}{B}{B} 4/6. You don’t lose the game for having 0 or less life. At the beginning of your end step, you lose 3 life and draw a card, then create ten 1/1 red Officer tokens if your life total is 0 or less.

I gave it a B−, but I’m genuinely torn.

A six-mana 4/6 that draws a card on each of your end steps seems solid, though losing 3 life each turn is a real cost. When you’re low enough, making ten tokens could turn a game you’re losing into a very quick win.

The obvious problem: once you’re at zero or below, removal or bounce on Georgiou just kills you. My optimistic take is that your opponent may have spent their answers by then. My pessimistic take is that every removal topdeck becomes lethal.

Are we overvaluing the ten-token dream, or undervaluing a card that gives you a way back into otherwise lost games?

Disclosure: mtgsimon.com is my own card-rating app, where I’m tracking and comparing these preview grades.


r/spikes • • 11d ago

Draft [Draft] [TRK] I combined 10 Limited set reviews for MTG Star Trek. Here are the 50 draft cards reviewers disagreed on most.

14 Upvotes

I'm posting this one a little early; I’d hoped to have a few more reviewers who've graded the rares and mythics, but I’m heading out of town and wanted to share this before I leave. I’ll update the rankings as more rare and mythic grades come in. Once 17Lands has Star Trek draft data, I’ll add games-in-hand win rate and average taken at alongside the reviewer grades as those stats become available.

Full Star Trek draft rankings and individual reviewer grades

The Needs of the Many had the widest interquartile range (IQR) at 50 points. U.S.S. Voyager, Lone Wanderer also is interesting, with a 32.5-point IQR and a 40-point spread from D+ to B across seven ordinary grades. I’m looking forward to trying it in multicolor decks, where it can take me from four lands to six and hopefully hit my splashed colors.

Other big spreads included Mirror Universe Intrusion (D to A-) and, among the Stardates, Borg Queen, Hateful Legacy (F+ to A-). The Queen has only four ordinary grades so far, so that comparison is still pretty thin. I’d lean more toward C+ to B- for her, and I’m looking forward to rare drafting a few of these controversial late-game bombs. Let me know what you think, and best of luck at your pre-releases!

A quick note on the tables: Overall rank is by average grade across all 336 cards. The first table is sorted by IQR, with ties broken by standard deviation. IQR measures the middle half of the grades; full spread is the highest score minus the lowest. Both use the site's 0 to 100 comparison scale. Letter grades are equivalent bands on that scale. Counts include ordinary numeric grades only; conditional-only grades, including build-around-only assessments, are excluded.

50 main-set cards with the widest IQRs

CardOverall rankMedian gradeIQR (points)Full spread (points)Grade rangeOrdinary grades (n)
The Needs of the Many#322F+5070F to C+6
Gul Dukat, Colonial Prefect#245C-43.860D- to B6
The Naked Time#277C42.565F+ to B-8
Cloak and Phaser#256C+4075F to B-5
Test of Courage#314D37.560F+ to C+4
The City on the Edge of Forever#192C37.560D to A-6
Grand Nagus Zek#284C-37.550D- to C+6
Lt. Cmdr. Geordi La Forge#229D+3550D to B5
Ensign Pavel Chekov#241C3550D- to C+7
Rules of Acquisition#324D-3540F to D+7
Support Mission#294C-32.560F to C8
Gray and Adira, Forever Joined#266C-32.540D to C+8
U.S.S. Voyager, Lone Wanderer#134B-32.540D+ to B7
Spatial Anomaly#215C32.545D to B-8
Mirror Universe Intrusion#110C+3060D to A-6
Test of Conviction#272C3067.5F+ to B8
Exploratory Mission#227C3045D to B-9
Kai Winn, Faithless Leader#264C-3040D to C+5
De-evolve#219C-3040D+ to B8
Peace in Our Time#332F3030F to D5
Class-F Shuttlecraft#257C3030D to C8
Lore, Positronic Provocateur#219C-3030D+ to C+8
Saru, Unthreatened#215C-3035D+ to B-8
Branching Timeline#328D-3030F to D5
Isolinear Processor#281D+3030D to C8
Vulcan Mind-Meld#304D+27.560F+ to C+8
The Measure of a Man#217C27.545D to B-7
Dominion Saboteur#214C27.240D to C+8
Sarek, Federation Ambassador#287C-2570F to C+6
Deep Space 9#278D+2550D to B6
Those Old Scientists#299D2555D- to B-8
Captain Benjamin Sisko#151C+2550D to B6
Federation Resupply#303D+2550D- to C+6
Temporal Anomaly#194C+2545D to B-8
The Holodeck#263C-2550D- to C+6
Data, New Life#165C+2550D to B8
Deep Space Scan#325D-2540F to D+4
Neelix, Moral Support#251C-2540D to C+8
Enterprise NX-01#241D+2530D+ to C+7
Melkotian Adjudicator#262C2530D to C7
The Unicomplex#105B-2530C- to B5
Final Frontier#275D+2530D to C7
Relentless Drednok#197C23.150D to B8
Year of Hell#330F22.550F to C-6
Brazen Bluff#333F22.540F to D+6
Culber and Stamets, Star-Crossed#208C22.550D- to C+8
Dominion Assault Force#249C22.550D- to C+8
I'm a Doctor, Not a . . .#289C-22.550F+ to C8
Warp Core#251C-22.545D to B-8
Set Phasers to . . .#246C22.545D to B-8

10 additional main-set cards with a wide spread in grades

Eight of these cards had a 50-point spread. Warp Speed had the widest range in this group (60 points, F+ to C+), and Engineered Explosives had the narrowest (45 points, D to B-).

CardOverall rankMedian gradeIQR (points)Full spread (points)Grade rangeOrdinary grades (n)
Warp Speed#301D2060F+ to C+7
Dathon, His Heart Open#311D2050D- to C+5
Dr. Joseph M'Benga#218C2050D to B5
Dathon and Picard at El-Adrel#310D+1550F+ to C8
Red Alert!#321D1550F to C-8
Tactical Officer#289C-12.550F+ to C8
Bat'leth#104C+1550D to B9
Impossible Choice#219C1050D- to C+8
Cetacean Ops#304D+12.550F+ to C8
Engineered Explosives#208C1045D to B-5

r/spikes • • 11d ago

Standard [Standard] Feedback on sideboard guide for Dimir Midrange

6 Upvotes

Wrote a little primer for myself for my current Dimir Mid list ahead of my RCQ this weekend. The list is very metagamed (a lot of Landfall and control around here), but I’m still curious to get feedback about my plan for any matchup. I’m not a beginner but certainly haven’t played with the deck enough to feel extremely comfortable with all my plans (as you can see by my indecision in some points).

https://moxfield.com/decks/uVn3GAtLZEK4x-Vk-IsJlQ

Didn’t write about the last two matchups cause I’ve haven’t really played them much. For anyone who’s getting into the deck let me repeat: this is my own primer for myself where I’m trying to consolidate my thoughts, I’m not an authority on the deck. I feel good about my play with it, I q’d for an RC with it and I hope I can do it again, but don’t take my word over basically anyone else who’s doing well with the deck. Thanks!


r/spikes • • 12d ago

Pioneer [Pioneer] Mardu Aggro Dredge

16 Upvotes

This is a long shot. But I just played against a mardu aggro dredge deck that looked really sweet. The only cards I saw where:

Bloodghast

Hardened Academic

Moonshadow

Dark Matter Manipulator

Narcomoeba

Prized Amalgam

Stitcher's Supplier

Creeping Chill

Practiced Offense

Mardu lands

Has anyone seen such a list? I can't remember the name of the player and searches online have not turned anything up. It looked really awesome and I want to tinker with it.


r/spikes • • 13d ago

Standard [Standard] Viable combo strategies in Standard

32 Upvotes

Spikes, I'm mainly a modern player, which has started dipping it's toes into the competitive scene in mtg, I've played MTGO extensively and just went to my first RC recently.

I'm already qualified for the Standard season RC, I was playing mainly 4c control, a bit of excruciator, but my real affinity is for combo decks.

I honestly know very little about the current standard, I have played around 40 matches or so, and I played around 10 on the season before the modern season that just passed, (I was playing dimir midrange for that one).

The thing is I'm not too well versed on what combo decks are there in the format, what are the most degenerate things one can be doing to win as quickly as possible, and what are the difficulties that the combo decks face in standard.

From the top of my head:

  • 4c Kona: Putting an omniscience into play into some bouncing shenanigans.

  • Dimir Reanimator: Classic archetype aiming to reanimate big stuff for value.

  • Bant Airbending: Flickering for free and generating infinite tokens iirc?

What else is there in the combo sphere? Why are these decks not that popular (except reanimator now that it's getting a resurgence), and what preys on these decks?


r/spikes • • 13d ago

Scheduled Post Weekly Deck Check Thread | Monday, November 02, 2026

15 Upvotes

Hello spikes!

This is the place where any and all decks can be posted for all spikes to see. The goal of this is to fit all your needs for competitive magic. Maybe it's a card consideration given an X dollar budget. Maybe you need that sweet sideboard tech that no one else thought of? Perhaps you just can't figure out the best card to beat a certain matchup. The ideas here are only limited by your imagination!

Feel free to discuss most anything here. We only ask that with any question, you also make sure to post your decklist so people have some context to answer your question. Otherwise, have at it! If you have any questions, shoot us a modmail and we'll be happy to help you out. Survive your deck check and survive your competition!


r/spikes • • 15d ago

Draft [Draft] Newer Player looking for Draft advice

19 Upvotes

Newer Player looking for Draft advice

I’ve been wanting to get some insight into drafting for a while now as someone who started playing Magic about two months ago.

It’s a bit difficult getting definitive answers to some of the questions I’ve had from videos and guides, so I thought I might throw some of those questions out there. Any answers or resources would be much appreciated.

Regarding early picks:

Is it correct to say that picking single colored cards are safer than going for stronger dual colored cards earlier? And does that also apply to higher mana value cards as opposed to lower (for splashability purposes).

How late is too late to pivot game plans given the scenario that the opportunity presents itself in one of the colors you’re already drafting for?

Should I be prioritizing value and/or card advantage over synergy?

Regarding later picks:

Is there ever a point in the draft where I should know that another card in the pack is likely coming my way again, and if so, what does that scenario look like or how can I tell?

What is the best or earliest way to recognize that my colors are being drafted in most sets (excluding this set with the fractured pairs)?

To follow up on the previous question, what is the best approach to others drafting your colors?

Should I draft flat out worse cards if it means fixing my curve?

And finally, how early into the draft should I recognize my game plan? When should I be able to recognize it? What are the most common game plans with draft decks?