With Strixhaven spoilers starting in full tomorrow, I think this is a good time to look back at which powerful cards are available in standard which have failed to break out as powerful build arounds, and consider what cards would need to be printed to make them playable. I think this retrospective can be especially relevant for cards printed in supplemental products, which might be forgotten because they aren't ever seen in draft or cracking packs. Here are some of my thoughts for each current standard set, but I'd love to hear the thoughts of more accomplished brewers.
Eldraine:
[[All that Glitters]] - We are unlikely to see a heavy artifact or enchantment theme this set, but historic has proven this card is strong with a critical mass of cheap synergy cards
[[Alela, Artful Provocateur]]: a pretty powerful effect, but a 4 mana 2/3 is too low rate.
[[Ayara, First of Locthwain]]: Black desperately needs a good 1 drop, but with a good 1 drop and a 2 drop that makes 2 black bodies, mono black could be interesting.
[[Dance of the Manse]]: This card has been in and out of play since printing, and is probably one good enchantment that kills itself away from play.
[[Emry, Lurker of the Loch]]: Emry is a busted card just looking for good artifacts to play with.
[[Faeburrow Elder]]: This ones a long shot, but an 2 mana artifact or land that says "this is all colors" could make this a very powerful ramp piece.
[[Gadwick, the Wizened]]: Gadwick is probably the best way to turn large amounts of mana into cards in the format.
[[Garruk, Cursed Huntsman]]: An innately strong walker, but I don't know what would make him good.
[[Kenrith, the Returned King]]: Without Fires, there hasn't been a good reason to play Kenrith, but he is still a fundamentally powerful card.
[[Korvold, Fae-Cursed King]]: Claim the firstborn and woestrider are still in the format, it would not take much for Korvold to be strong.
[[Shimmer Dragon]]: I legitimately forgot this card existed, but a 5/6 hexproof that draws you cards if you have some treasures or food seems good.
[[Syr Konrad, the Grim]]: A blue black mill deck combined with graveyard destruction could be an interesting combo kill.
[[Witch's Vengeance]]: A solid wrath if Elves or some other tribe ever becomes too oppressive.
Theros:
[[Aphemia, the Cacophony]]: I doubt this set will get it there, but a good 1 mana enchantment that immediately goes to the yard would go a long way for her.
[[Archon of Sun's Grace]]: Already sees play with Yorion some times, and could certainly have a break out with a few good cheap enchantments.
[[Bronzehide Lion]]: If there is ever a green/white good stuff deck, this is probably in it, though it does get wrecked by lovestruck beast.
[[Dalakos, Crafter of Wonders]]: I doubt this is the set for him, but there is a world where an equipment deck is good.
[[Destiny Spinner]]: Maybe the wizard school set will be dominated by counter magic and she will see hate play?
[[Dream Trawler]]: One of the better creatures in the format to search onto the board alone.
[[Enigmatic Incarnation]]: I have NO idea. The effect is strong, but it would take a better deck builder than me to make it work.
[[Gray Merchant of Asphodel]]: Like I mentioned with Ayara, mono black is essentially one good 1 drop from playable, and Gary might be a finisher.
[[Ironscale Hydra]]: Did anyone know this card existed? A 5 mana 5/5 that can't die in combat feels like it should be good in the right meta.
[[Heliod, Sun-Crowned]]: Heliod decks are always on the fringe. I don't think this set will have a big life gain theme, but who knows.
[[Nightmare Shepherd]]: Another piece of that mono black deck I've been keeping an eye on.
[[Nyx Lotus]]: Mono blue devotion combo was a meme a while back, another untap creature like Corridor Monitor could make it real.
[[Setessan Champion]]: if the Rune cycle didn't get this card there, nothing will, but who knows.
[[Terror of Mount Velus]] If there is a "summon multiple creatures to the battlefield they get haste" card, this is probably one of the payoffs.
[[Thassa, Deep-Dwelling]]: A sufficently broken ETB might be worth playing Thassa as a way to double it up.
[[Underworld Breach]]: Pioneer has proven how busted this card can be. We're probably one good ritual away from it getting banned in standard.
Ikoria:
[[Call of the Death-Dweller]] By far the strongest reanimation spell in standard. A few good black 1 or 2 drops will probably get it into decks.
[[Death's Oasis]]: A weird value engine, but for 3 mana it has some real power to it.
[[General Kudro of Drannith]]: A human synergy deck isn't out of the question.
[[Gyruda, Doom of Depths]]: If a deck comes together that happens to play all evens, why not?
[[Lukka, Coppercoat Outcast]]: Lukka is one search target away from being broken again.
[[Luminous Broodmoth]]: I could actually see this card being played in mono white side boards right now.
[[Rielle, the Everwise]]: Totally plausible in a wizards or magecraft deck, or even in cycling.
[[Slitherwisp]]: It hasn't made a home in rogues, but its plausible if a powerful non-rogue flash creature gets printed that it makes the cut.
[[Song of Creation]] Probably a meme, but a cycle of 0 mana cards could make it real.
[[Titans' Nest]] One of the strongest mana engines left in standard, but its interface on arena has made it unplayable.
[[Vadrok, Apex of Thunder]] Maybe someday mantis rider that sometimes casts a card from your yard for free will be good enough for standard?
[[Vivien, Monsters' Advocate]] She's seen a bit of play in green food decks, but a green card that reduces its own cost so that her -2 would let it search up something huge would probably make her a real force.
[[Winota, Joiner of Forces]] We're one good human target away from Winota breaking standard like it did in historic. Clarion spirit is already exactly the 2 drop the deck wants.
Core set 2021:
[[Archfiend's Vessel]]: The right reanimation card could let this see play.
[[Azusa, Lost but Seeking]]: I don't think we know what land cycle we are getting in Strixhaven do we? Until then, I'm not ruling Azusa out.
[[Chandra's Incinerator]]: Between magecraft and potential new burn spells, the incinerator has a chance to be format breaking.
[[Conclave Mentor]]: Abzan counters always feels like its right on the edge of being good. Who knows what support would push it over the top.
[[Grim Tutor]] There is a world where some busted combo deck is out there that wants a tutor.
[[Griffin Aerie]]: Maybe they'll print a "you gain 3 life per turn" card.
[[Jolrael, Mwonvuli Recluse]] I'm honestly a bit surprised that no deck has managed to make Jolrael work since Widerness Rec, but I guess bonecrusher giant is kinda a good card. One good cantrip likely gets her there.
[[Teferi, Master of Time]] notable with the already revealed Kasmina because she doubles the rate he reaches ultimate.
[[Transmogrify]] Similar to Lukka, the right payoff creature could make this card fantastic.
[[Ugin, the Spirit Dragon]] I don't know, 8 mana is pretty expensive and 3 per turn isn't a fast clock. Probably not playable.
Zendikar:
[[Forsaken Monument]] I doubt a mono brown deck will work in standard, but its worth keeping an eye on.
[[Grakmaw, Skyclave Ravager]] a key piece if Abzan counters gets support
[[Kaza, Roil Chaser]] A wizard tribal payoff in a set with magecraft set in a wizarding school?
[[Magmatic Channeler]] probably the strongest 2 drop in the format if you can meet its 4 spell requirement
[[Scourge of the Skyclaves]] death's shadow decks in historic have shown this can be a house, not that I'm expecting much without shock lands.
[[Sea Gate Stormcaller]] I'm keeping an eye on basically anything that copies spells on the stack.
[[Yasharn, Implacable Earth]] A possible tech card if a sac deck becomes dominant
[[Zagras, Thief of Heartbeats]] I'm going to let this stand in for all the party cards. I don't believe party will ever be competitive, but at the moment wizards does seem to the be the weakest link. Maybe a really busted wizard in Strixhaven somehow pulls it together?
This post is already way too long, and Kaldhiem is still fresh, so I think I'll leave it there.