r/spikes • • Nov 10 '15

Mod Post [Mod Post] Gender, Inclusiveness, and Foresight on /r/spikes

0 Upvotes

Hey spikes!

Other posters and I have noticed that the subreddit has been trending toward the use of male-centric pronouns when writing discussion and content. Hell, even I've made that mistake. It's a common thing to do, and it's not the absolute end of the world when it happens.

That being said, there are non-male competitive players (Female, Gender Fluid, etc.) that frequent this subreddit, and any chance I have to make this environment more inclusive, I'll happily take.

Consider this exchange that occurred recently on /r/spikes:

"When you get a good opponent (you'll know...I hope), see how many games you can jam with him."

Consider using a more inclusive pronoun (them, for instance, would be great here).

Essentially, this is a quick PSA to take a few extra seconds when posting or commenting to realize that everyone plays and enjoys this game, including in the competitive sense. Be mindful of that when choosing your words.

Thanks, and keep making the subreddit awesome.

~tom


r/spikes • • Feb 14 '15

Discussion [Discussion] A friendly reminder from someone playing in the competitive scene - Testing on Cockatrice is not valid competitive testing.

16 Upvotes

Too often I see new primers for decks posted here. "It seems pretty competitive / good against the meta! I've only lost one or two games on Cockatrice!"

Cockatrice does not have good players, and it is not a competitive environment for testing. I understand that there are exceptions, but in general, this is true. Can we please use more serious methods of testing as evidence of success? The MTGO standard queue's or dailies are a great example of a good testing environment. You will be playing against t1 decks with good pilots.

If you only play paper magic, then take your deck testing to a competitive event aside from FNM. Winning FNM is not /r/spikes level of competition, and if you don't do anything aside from FNM then you don't really need to be on here as the advice here is more suited to PTQs and other pro events.

As a member of spikes for over 3 years, non-competitive people posting their new deck tech has always been a problem. That, coupled with the unfortunate FACT that the majority of people subscribed to spikes are NOT competitive players, but rather players who WANT to get better, and you get a lot of false or misleading information passed around the subreddit and upvoted by people who don't know any better.

We can make this a better subreddit with better advice, but it has to start with you, the people trying to get better, because you are the majority here and your voice is the one that gets heard, not mine. So please, try to refrain from bad testing and, even though you're really eager, don't post new deck-tech until it has been proven on a competitive level, as you will only get upvotes from people who don't know any better and you will not become a better player.


r/spikes • • Oct 02 '21

Standard [Standard] Unless you specifically need a turn 3 land, don't play Expressive iteration before turn 4

0 Upvotes

URx decks are always a counter spell threat and if you cast turn 2/3 Expressive iteration against the wrong hand (which you have no way of knowing on turn 2/3 especially on the play), you can easily just die to an all in opponent.

Turn 4 is the earliest turn you can play a land with Expressive Iteration AND hold up relevant counter magic mana. Play to this fact.

In summary:

  • Turn 2 EI: Should never be cast unless you MUST cast a 3 mana spell next turn and do not have a third land in hand.

  • Turn 3 EI: Should only be cast if you are not scared of their 3/4 drop on the play/draw respectively.

  • Turn 4+ EI: Proceed as normal


r/spikes • • Mar 06 '15

Discussion [Discussion] We don't need a spoiler thread for EVERY SINGLE NEW CARD.

39 Upvotes

Almost the entire front page is currently discussing every single individual card spoiled, with the "oh my, is this competitive!?".

Probably not. And they probably don't all need their own thread. Could we make a megathread during spoiler season, and condense all of the discussions into one thread?


r/spikes • • Jul 06 '17

Modern [Modern] The best version of Devoted Druid combo. Period.

1 Upvotes

I posted this on /r/ModernMagic as well, but maybe it's better suited here.

Decklist and write-up, including some of the biggest matchups

Let me start by saying this deck is absolutely top tier. It is good against the field, and it is very capable of winning a tournament - large or small.

I worked on this list for months leading up to Grand Prix Las Vegas. I went into the tournament with the goals of putting the deck on the map, and making top 8.

I finished day one at 8-1. I faced a good variety of matchups, including Grixis Shadow, Eldrazi Tron, Burn, UW Control, Dredge, Counters Company, and Tron. There were three strange judge calls that day, but I'll save them for another time.

Day two I went a disappointing 3-3. My losses came from UB Fairies, Affinity, and a different Devoted Druid brew. All of them went to game 3, and all of them were very winnable, aside from an onslaught of bad draws on my side and good draws on the other side of the table.

Throughout the entire tournament, I was constantly rewarded for small tweaks I had made to the deck. It was the most prepared I have ever been in a grand prix and it felt amazing.

I fell short of putting the deck on the map by making top 8 or even getting a feature match or deck tech, so I am here today to share it with the world.

Deck-building explanations and matchup breakdowns can be found in the description, below the deck list (follow the link).


r/spikes • • Feb 02 '21

Discussion [Discussion] Is this subreddit still focused on competitive Magic?

10 Upvotes

I was looking to get back into playing competitively again for the first time in a few years (played casually or not at all for awhile, used to play competitively a lot) and came here to see how things were here as this used to be one of my go to places for discussion and ideas.

Looking over standard posts from the last week it looks like most are bad brews and whacky combos - which while neat don't really seem like they are on topic for a competitive focused sub reddit.

Is this more of a deck ideas forum rather than competitive things these days? I like brews as much as most people, but things used to have to have at least some results behind them to deserve a thread here.

Edit: Based on the defensive comments about bad brews I have my answer. Enjoy yourselves, magic is a great game with lot of sweet decks, stop kidding yourself that they are competitive though.


r/spikes • • Apr 16 '14

Other Is it just me or is MTGO useless for all constructed testing?

7 Upvotes

For the longest time I just played with friends or randoms on Cockatrice for testing constructed. Many people told me/where of the opinion that this was useless. I was told over and over that if I wanted real relevant testing for constructed magic on the computer you had to be using MTGO.

Well, after having owned cards in every constructed format on MTGO for the last six months I must say - I feel like I've been lied to.

Literally every format (Standard, Modern, Legacy) is heavily skewed towards cheap decks that play quickly to allow multi-games to be played more easily.

In standard right now, you play Burn or RDW almost every other match.

In legacy belcher, opps all spells, and decks playing ghost quarter instead of wasteland appear to be the norm.

So spikes - if you are considering buying into MTGO so you can get competitive testing out of it - I strongly encourage you to look elsewhere. For folks looking for decklists, I remind everyone to take anything that has done well on MTGO with a huge grain of salt.


r/spikes • • Dec 15 '15

Modern [Modern] Ordering Stoneforge Mystics now

0 Upvotes

So I just ordered my playset of stoneforge mystic. It's a risk but I'm taking it, if unbanned the card will easily skyrocket to 65 per copy

Dunno how much those swords will go up to but I won't go balls deep in that investment risk just yet

What do you guys think? Maro hinted strongly about this card being played, it's the promo at a modern gp, and let's be honest, wotc is barely supporting legacy these days

If mystic is unbanned I truly think next year bloodbraid elf will become unbanned too. Jts, jitte, deathrite need to stay banned as they severely limit card diversity

White is in serious need of a wincon, it's a garbage modern color that has great sideboard cards and primarily lingering souls and path. Black has bob, blue has tiago, green has goyf, dare I say red has eidolon? White needs something man, it can't stand on its own

Stoneforge will really push abzan and hate bears

Is a turn 3 skull as scary as a turn 3 or turn 4 on the play hasty titan, or a turn 3 etched champion equipped cranial plating?

I don't think its going to cripple equipment ideas for the future, maro already said they will never make equipment as good as batterskull or jitte again

I could be out of 80 bucks too, it could realistically happen


r/spikes • • Nov 15 '17

Frontier [Frontier] Notes on Testing in Frontier

1 Upvotes

Testing for S3

I’ll try to keep this article concise as I can’t give away my exact list. Signups close November 15th at midnight for the Untap Open League’s S3. Signup here if interested.

Still, I’m happy to talk a little about the testing process. For season three of the league, I was part of Team UB. In three weeks of testing “in house” I played 158 matches with my team, which was just the result of playing ten matches a day almost everyday.

For me, personally, the best deck was Atarka Red, which is no surprise. The deck is great. I went 24-10 with Atarka Red against some of the best Frontier players in the world and you could do much worse than the list Phillip Bickle took to a top 8 finish at NA Champs earlier this year. I went deep on the archetype and this list here. You could also consider a list similar to what Daniel Fournier took to the top 8 of the last Frontier Showdown.


Decklist


Atarka Red by Philip Bickle

Land

  • 4 Wooded Foothills

  • 4 Bloodstained Mire

  • 1 Windswept Heath

  • 2 Cinder Glade

  • 6 Mountain

  • 1 Forest

  • 2 Ramunap Ruins

Creatures

  • 4 Monastery Swiftspear

  • 4 Soul-Scar Mage

  • 1 Zurgo Bellstriker

  • 3 Abbot of Keral Keep

  • 2 Reckless Bushwhacker

Instants

  • 4 Wild Slash

  • 4 Atarka's Command

  • 4 Lightning Strike

  • 2 Stoke the Flames

  • 1 Become Immense

Artifacts

  • 4 Smuggler's Copter

Sorceries

  • 4 Dragon Fodder

  • 3 Hordeling Outburst

Sideboard

  • 2 Chandra, Torch of Defiance

  • 1 Plummet

  • 2 Blazing Volley

  • 1 Goblin Heelcutter

  • 1 Ramunap Ruins

  • 1 Outpost Siege

  • 2 Kari Zev's Expertise

  • 1 Smash to Smithereens

  • 2 Natural State

  • 2 Exquisite Firecraft


What makes Atarka Red the king of the format is both how powerful and consistent the list is. It’s the best Smuggler’s Copter deck, which is not a fair Magic card. A 3/3 flier for two is already above rate. That it dodges wraths and gives us free loots makes it pretty nuts. Honestly, I don’t want to play aggro lists without it. It’s just too powerful of a tool.

Be warned, despite what you’ve heard, it’s not an easy deck to play. Other players on my team had a much lower win percentage with Atarka. These aren’t bad Frontier players. It’s just hard to get full value out of every card, to know when to bluff or when to shove a Copter into open Fatal Push mana and to know how to adjust sideboarding game to game. Also, Copter loots can be pretty hard. I remember losing a game where I discarded a redundant Zurgo Bellstriker, when, a removal spell later, the dash would have been lethal (with a top decked Atarka’s Command, of course.)

The other known deck which absolutely crushed for me during testing was Abzan.


Decklist


Abzan Vehicles by Matthew Hoffmann

Creatures

  • 2 Thraben Inspector

  • 4 Toolcraft Exemplar

  • 2 Warden of the First Tree

  • 3 Hangarback Walker

  • 4 Walking Ballista

  • 1 Thalia, Heretic Cathar

  • 2 Anafenza, the Foremost

  • 2 Siege Rhino

Planeswalkers

  • 3 Gideon, Ally of Zendikar

  • 1 Sorin, Solemn Visitor

Artifacts

  • 1 Heart of Kiran

  • 4 Smuggler’s Copter

Instants

  • 4 Fatal Push

  • 2 Dromoka’s Command

  • 1 Abzan Charm

  • 1 Murderous Cut

Land

  • 4 Spire of Industry

  • 4 Blooming Marsh

  • 4 Concealed Courtyard

  • 4 Windswept Heath

  • 2 Caves of Koilos

  • 1 Scattered Groves

  • 1 Forest

  • 3 Plains

Sideboard

  • 3 Duress

  • 2 Authority of the Consuls

  • 1 Tragic Arrogance

  • 2 Anguished Unmaking

  • 2 Hallowed Moonlight

  • 1 Ishkanah, Grafwidow

  • 1 Hornet Nest

  • 1 Anafenza, the Foremost

  • 1 Thalia, Heretic Cathar

  • 1 Ultimate Price


I wrote indepth about this list and this Abzan variant here. While in testing I tended to favor different builds of Abzan, Hoffmann’s is still quite viable.

While I played less games with these lists when compared to some of my teammates, when I did the deck won at an astounding clip (69%). The key to getting a good Junk deck is to understand the metagame and to build your sideboard right. When you do this, you end up with a list that is generally 50%, with one or two bad matchups and a very good matchup against the deck you should expect to see the most at the top tables, Red. For a player comfortable with the format, this is a great place to be.

The other classic list I logged a lot of games with was Control.


Decklist


Grixis Control by Simon Tubello

Creatures

  • 4 Jace, Vryn’s Prodigy

  • 2 Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet

  • 2 Torrential Gearhulk

  • 1 Tasigur, The Golden Fang

Instants

  • 4 Fatal Push

  • 1 Fiery Impulse

  • 4 Censor

  • 1 Negate

  • 1 Disdainful Stroke

  • 1 Disallow

  • 2 Kolaghan’s Command

  • 1 Unlicensed Disintegration

  • 1 Hieroglyphic illumination

  • 3 Dig Through Time

Sorceries

  • 1 Ruinous Path

  • 2 Yahenni’s Expertise

Planeswalkers

  • 3 Liliana, the Last Hope

Lands

  • 4 Polluted Delta

  • 4 Bloodstained Mire

  • 3 Flooded Strand

  • 4 Wandering Fumarole

  • 2 Sunken Hollow

  • 2 Smoldering Marsh

  • 1 Cayon Slough

  • 1 Fetid Pools

  • 2 Island

  • 2 Swamp

  • 1 Mountain

Sideboard

  • 1 Roast

  • 1 Radiant Flames

  • 1 Dragonmaster Outcast

  • 1 Ob Nixilis Reignited

  • 1 Dragonlord Silumgar

  • 1 Kolaghan’s Command

  • 2 Dispel

  • 1 Negate

  • 1 Disdainful Stroke

  • 1 Transgress the Mind

  • 2 Collective Brutality

  • 2 Lost Legacy


We tried a lot of variants of UBx Control. Anything from the UB lists Mussie and I ran in Season two, to Esper approach, to 4c Control (with and without copycat, with and without approach.) The best lists are still straight UB or Grixis.

As Tubello is probably the best control player in the format, I’ll share one of his lists as an example. This list is pre-Vraska’s Contempt and Search For Azcanta, but wouldn’t be hard to update.

As Jeremy Dezani wrote, “if I had to say what is the best Frontier deck, I would say UB control.” I mean, the deck combines the format’s best answers with the its most powerful card, Dig Through Time. Dig is banned in all other formats (well, restricted in Vintage.) For me, if Legacy is the Brainstorm format, Frontier is the Dig format.


Predicting the Metagame


In season two of the Untap Open League we saw a below average number of Atarka Red lists, for how dominant the archetype is and a healthy amount of Control. The playoffs ended up being three UB Control lists, two Sligh decks, two Bant decks and a lone Abzan list. As I write this Atarka Red has made its way to finals and Abzan is squaring up against UB Control Wednesday afternoon to see who the other finalist will be. I’m rooting for Katie and Rasmus (the Abzan and UB pilots, respectively) who are teammates of mine for this season.


Looking Back, Season 2 Meta


Aggro (16)

  • Atarka Red & Sligh - 5

  • BG Scales - 1

  • Abzan Aggro - 2

  • UR Ensoul - 1

  • UR Prowess - 2

  • Grixis Prowess - 1

  • Temur Aggro - 1

  • B Eldrazi Aggro - 1

  • Bant Coco Humans - 1

  • Naya Coco Humans - 1

Midrange (5)

  • Temur Energy - 1

  • Naya Walkers - 1

  • Jund Planeswalkers - 1

  • “Dredge” - 1

  • Mardu Tokens - 1

Combo (7)

  • Cat Combo - 3

  • Temur Marvel - 1

  • Sultai Marvel - 1

  • Tezzerator - 1

  • God-Pharaoh's Gift - 1

Control (8)

  • UB Control - 5

  • Esper Control - 1

  • UW Approach - 1

  • Jund Seasons Past - 1


Most Popular Deck : UBx Control (6)

Most Popular Aggro Deck : Red Aggro (5)

Most Popular Combo Deck: Jeskai Saheeli

Most Played Cards :

  1. Fatal Push - 59 copies across 17 lists. 50% of field.

  2. Opt - 45 copies across 12 lists. Appears as a 4 of in all but 2 of the astounding 11 lists it appears in. 33.3% of field.

  3. Lighting Strike - 45 Copies across 11 Lists. 28.5% of field.

  4. Monastery Swiftspear - 36 copies across 9 lists. 25% of field.

  5. Negate - 30 copies across 14 lists. 38.8% of field.


I think from this we can gather that a higher percentage of the field will be on jank online than at a major tournament at Hareruya, or in Toronto. To compensate for this, you want to play a deck with a higher overall power level. Any of the three decks discussed above do this: either by being proactive with aggressive curves backed up by the format’s best removal, or by playing Torrential Gearhulks, Dig Through Time and Fatal Push.

We know that Blue Black was the most successful list in this particular tournament by a lot. So, what else has happened since season two in major Frontier tournaments?

Well, Atsuki Kihara took down the largest tournament we saw with 4c Control and Rally came back in a real way. In Toronto, Atarka Red has continued to dominate and W(u) Aggro emerged as a viable variant of White Humans. So, the question you have to ask yourself is how influenced will the UOL population be by these tournaments? If you think the influence will be major, you’ll want to have more hate for Control, Atarka and Rally then you previously had.

There’s also the question of known players, which I won’t go into here, but we certainly discuss as a testing team. At the end of the day, though, we’ll rely mostly on our testing and try to play the best deck for the tournament based on the hundreds of matches we logged. Last season when I teamed with Rasmus, we thought that was UB Control. I’ll write a part two for this article when decklists get published with my seventy-five and further rationale for choosing it.

Again, if you want to give Frontier a try, signups are here and /r/spikes members are more than welcome.

/u/nascarfather


r/spikes • • Jun 13 '18

Standard [Standard] Store Championship -- "Slimmed Down" Steel Leaf

3 Upvotes

My local LGS is running their store championship next weekend. I'm turning to the community to help shore up my deck (it's not quiet a budget build but I also can't afford the cash cows like Carnage Tyrant and Ghalta to make it a stock Steel Leaf deck).

THE DECK:

MAINBOARD:

4x Llanowar Elves

4x Ixalli's Diviner

2x Rhonas the Indomitable

4x Steel Leaf Champion

3x Wayward Swordtooth

3x Ripjaw Raptor

1x Vizier of the Menagerie

3x Verdurous Gearhulk

3x Blossoming Defense

3x Enter the Unknown

2x Shapers' Sanctuary

2x Nature's Way

1x Aethersphere Harvester

1x Nissa, Vital Force

1x Skysovereign, Consul Flagship

4x Hashep Oasis

16x Forest

2x Field of Ruin

1x Scavenger Grounds

SIDEBOARD:

1x Blossoming Defense

2x Heroic Intervention

3x Naturalize

1x Nature's Way

2x Sorcerous Spyglass

1x Aethersphere Harvester

3x Crushing Canopy

1x Thrashing Brontodon

1x Nissa, Vital Force

The Choices:

I'll skip over the staples like Llanowar Elves and Steel Leaf Champion as anyone running stompy already knows why they're there. Instead I'll focus on the "odd/budget" choices:

Ixalli's Diviner -- Most decks run Merfolk Branchwalker in this slot, however in a Chainwhiler dominated meta it dies easily (either to Chainwhirler if it hits a land, or to any of the removal in R/x decks). Worst case it hits a land (giving us card draw advantage) leaving it still able to block half of R/x's threats. If it gets the +1/+1 instead, it's able to chip in for damage and can stall a chainwhirler all day long.

Wayward Swordtooth -- Can't attack or block without Ascend makes this a very questionable choice, but it turns on Rhonas, and can crew Skysovereign until it's turned on. Moreover, because it can't attack/block, opponents will often leave it alone allowing you to ramp (and if they do take it out, it's eating a removal spell that would have otherwise hit one of our other attackers).

Ripjaw Raptor -- Card draw on a body is good. Card draw on a body that can survive an exerted Glorybringer, destroy Scarab God zombies, etc. is even better. I'm tempted to run 4 but feels it's a bit greedy given the CMC.

Vizier of the Menagerie -- A dash of spice that plays well with the deck but is terrible in multiples. This deck can pump out a lot of its lands early meaning we have mana to spare in the mid-game. Casting creatures off the top of the deck is virtual card draw and knowing when lands are on top lets you time your use of your late game Enter the Unknown/Ixalli's Diviner.

Nissa, Vital Force -- Turns your land draws into card draw; can come down as early as turn 3 (albeit very rarely given we only run 1 in the main).

Enter the Unknown -- Ramp that pumps your creatures. Aggro decks eat Elves but usually can't deal with this card; and against Control either they let it resolve giving us more mana and a pump, or they counter it leaving them down a counterspell against our protection spells.

Shapers' Sanctuary -- Early card draw engine. Elves always wants to be answered, as do most of our threats. This can often help draw answers too (it's a cast trigger, which means you can draw a Blossing Defense off it for instance).

Nature's Way -- A one-way Fight ability that also gives trample and vigilance. Can kill pesky flyers, remove a scarab god, etc., clearing the way to get in with a solid attack.

Aethersphere Harvester -- I'm not happy about maindecking this, but in the current meta having a MB flyer seems like a must.

Skysovereign, Consul Flagship -- I never want a 2nd of this and don't even like running a 1-of, but it's a necessary evil. The ping kills pesky annoyances, be they creature or planeswalker.

Field of Ruin -- With so many non-basics out there, this helps deal with the worst (e.g. Azcanta/Legion's Landing).

Scavenger Grounds -- This feels bad and I might cut it, but it can shut off Scrounger recursion and if you kill a Scarab God then activate, they dont get it back at the end of turn.

Blossoming Defense/Heroic Intervention -- Extra protection. This deck doesn't have the big baddies so having more ways to protect the smaller ones is a necessary evil.

Naturalize -- Brontodon is the go-to in Stompy but I'm of the same opinion as /bricarp -- my deck wants a cheaper (aka faster) way to handle artifacts/enchantments.

Sorcerous Spyglass -- This feels bad but also necessary. It shuts off planeswalkers, ballistas, Scarab God activations, flip land abilties, you name it (literally).

Crushing Canopy -- This is a ground-pounder deck, flyers are a real issue. Hitting enchantments is a bonus.

Thrashing Brontodon -- Thinking of cutting this as well but not sure what to bring in instead. Gives an extra body and it's ability may be slower but still good.

The Gameplan:

Overall it plays like Steel Leaf Stompy - drop 4 and 5 power baddies, swing in. While it has none of the big threats to close out games, it does have a lot more card draw and ramp than the usual version. That lets me drop more threats on the board, and earlier which helps offset the lack of raw power.

I want to improve it as best I can but adding the $$$ cards is just not an option. Any thoughts, suggestions, questions are welcome. Thank in advance!

Edit: Formatting. 2nd Edit: Realized I had 61 in the MB. Fixed now.


r/spikes • • Jun 14 '15

Discussion [discussion] Was my opponent a scumbag?

0 Upvotes

So I went to my first modern PPTQ yesterday in Socal. The deck I play is Leige Rhino

Going undefeated into round 3 my opponent was on grixis twin. My opponenet was very condescending and had been bragging to his friends about going 13-2 in vegas. I tried joking around with him a bit but he wasn't having it. Anywas, Game 3 I quickly build up an overwhelming board and force him to tap out on his turn. I windmill slam a Sigarda while he is tapped out. My opponent takes a 15 seconds or so to read it and says ok. Next turn I have him dead 6 ways to Sunday, he's at 5 life i have sigards, loxodon smiter, a birds of paradise, and i think a couple lingering souls tokens as well as gavony plus the mana to activate. I try to move to combat and he goes into the tank for 2-3 minutes and comes up with the play of deceiver exarch tap Sigarda. I immediately point out that it has hexproof and he plays it off like he forgot. He quickly concedes to a lethal attack.

It really bugged me though because i think the chances are slim to none that he 'forgot' sigarda had hexproof considering he read the card then was in the tank for so long. This brings me to the conclusion that he was attempting to make an illegal play to try and stay alive hoping that I let him tap sigarda. What do you think about making a play like that?

I did not call a judge( though I regret it now) because I won immediately after and it would be impossible for the judge to definitively determine that my opponent intended to make an illegal play. What would you have done?

thanks for the input

EDIT: some people feel like this is unnecessary or that I am escalating a small or simple situation. That the player in question doesn't deserve to be called out. Or that he had to make an account to defend himself. My response is: It was a big deal to me, that is why I posted. Also, to defend what? the player and his friends are the only ones who know his identity, no one is getting slandered or attacked. If you don't feel like it is worth talking about go to a different post?


r/spikes • • Nov 13 '15

Modern [Modern] Deck Tech: Bant Legends

2 Upvotes

http://www.mtghashtagdreamteam.com/deck-tech-bant-legends/

I wrote up a dech tech on my current brew.


r/spikes • • Nov 08 '15

Standard [Standard]Temur Midrange. How it feels after playing it for a week.

0 Upvotes

3 Icefall Regent

4 Thunderbreak Regent

4 Savage Knuckleblade

1 Dragonlord Atarka

4 Rattleclaw Mystic

2 Beastcaller Savant

4 Draconic Roar

3 Temur Charm

1 Crater's Claws

4 Stubborn Denial

4 Woodland Wanderer

4 Frontier Bivouac

3 Yavimaya Coast

4 Shivan Reef

2 Cinder Glade

2 Lumbering Falls

4 Forest

2 Island

2 Mountain

2 Sarkhan Unbroken

1 Haven of the Spirit Dragon

SB: 1 Dispel

SB: 2 Disdainful Stroke

SB: 2 Radiant Flames

SB: 1 Roast

SB: 2 Evolutionary Leap

SB: 2 Exert Influence

SB: 2 Ashcloud Phoenix

SB: 1 Burn Away

SB: 2 Encase in Ice

So, This is my temur list that I have been playing with for the last week, and it's been great. Temur has some of the best cards in the format, in my opinion at least. Being able to play Thunderbreak Regent, Woodland Wanderer and even Stubborn Denial which people never expect, its a wonder why this deck isn't bigger. our best match ups are RG aggro (landfall or atarka red) and most control decks, our threats are big enough to block and resilient enough to kill control. our worst match up is, really nothing, I have not lost a game where it was not even close. now to the reasoning to the cards:

Thunderbreak: shouldn't have to say why I am playing this card

Icefall: Icefall is great for shutting down other creatures, not a bad beater against control, and great synergy with thunderbreak

Dragonlord Atarka: As a one of, I love it, it can come down late game against aristocrats and wipe the creatures they are attempting to protect, he can come and kill a pesky jace. Mana is never a issue with this deck, I am not usually flooding, but I can reach seven with no problem.

Knuckleblade: Great Beater, not much to say besides a great blocker as well for mono red decks

Woodland Wanderer: My pick for biggest sleeper, its usually a 5/5 trample vigilance for 4, it can also be a 6/6 with beastcaller or sarkhan. I will take either of those options.

Rattleclaw/Beastcaller: our mana accelerators, one I love, one I hate. Rattleclaw is always so good, if I am missing a color (which is rare) It can fix it by flipping, it is my favorite turn 2 play. Beastcaller Savant, is the shiniest turd, we have nothing else to play so we play him, needless to say if a better 2 mana dork or a 1 mana dork is printed in the next set, he will be replaced.

4 Draconic Roar: Great removal currently, for the pesky early creatures that we can't contend with early (cough cough mantis rider cough cough)

Stubborn denial: my favourite blue spell in the format. Sometimes its worth playing a knuckleblade on turn 3 with a rattleclaw then just holding up denial. always worth holding up when you can.

Temur Charm: this card is weird, sometimes its super good and does what I want it to, but other times I feel it just sits in my hand because I would rather be playing a creature. not sure what I am gonna do with it.

Sarkhan Unbroken: I love this card, this card is the reason I am playing temur, almost always its "play sarkan minus 2". Sometimes my opponent just silkwraps the dragon and kill my sarkhan, but if they don't do that, its so powerful.

Crater's Claw: not sure if this card is worth playing, when I draw it I feel it needs to much set up for not enough reward, needs more testing.

not going to talk about the sideboard, as it needs a lot of work, it does what it needs to do, but I feel it could be better.


r/spikes • • Oct 04 '26

Standard [Standard] First time playing in an RCQ, are they all like this?

0 Upvotes

I played my first RCQ today (Standard) and was wondering if you guys felt or experienced these same things.

First off, I'm running Boros Dragons in standard, I had every piece except a couple Voice of Victories were magda or Jennifer Walters to save some money. I've played the deck plenty on Arena BO3 and know it inside and out, but..

Every single player at this tourney (that only had 9 players btw) was playing some form of control. Now im not super anti-control or a giga hater, but I think I saw maybe 2 or 3 creatures the entire 5 hours of this RCQ.

Despite playing an aggro deck, the rock paper scissors idealogy failed me and control just beats kinda everything in standard now in case you havent played (Mono green landfall only exception).

Aggro doesn't really exist anymore after the bans, and midrange is pretty much dead outside of Mono Green and occasional Dimir (which is actually Tempo).

But honestly I have no major issues with any of that, thats just how the meta has worked out.

My bigger issues were my opponents manners and the insane amount of flooding/screwing. Out of 5 rounds I played, at least 2 out of 3, one player was getting screwed or mana flooded and lost directly as a result.

I'm not lying, I saw multiple matches completely decided by screw and flood for every single player. It felt like half of the entire tournament was just decided by RNG. Do people really find pleasure in driving half to a full hour to play at these events for 30$ just to get nothing in return even with a few wins?

These shops all stopped providing any kind of fun single booster reward here and there for coming and winning a couple games.

But to top it off, my control players all just had the craziest mannerisms, and a few pretty salty and annoying behaviors that just pointed towards a more lack of social awareness than rudeness I hope but can't be sure.

I'm talking like, these control players would take 6+ minutes deciding what to play, just to pass with nothing played and holding all their mana. Which I GET, but they had they AUDACITY multiple times to ask me if I was done yet as SOON as i hit main phase two and not even two seconds has passed.

I shit you not, one guy asked me if I pass the moment combat phase was over after he killed my momo, and I was like umm no I have a main phase two and I'm gonna play my second momo. Then of course takes 10 minutes to play a Tablet and pass.

Is this really the RCQ experience? Has anyone else been to one lately and experienced any similar sentiments?

I'm just left wondering if this is what competitive magic has become, it just doesnt feel worth it to grind RCQs to grind RC to grind pro tour just to have a chance at the Championship.


r/spikes • • Sep 28 '17

Frontier [Frontier] Testing For Frontier Season Two

5 Upvotes

Frontier league season two is coming sign me up!! That’s what went through my mind when I heard that the league was going to be back for a second season. Coming off a second place finish with my Mardu Control list after losing to the eventual champion /u/glasseschan on Mardu Vehicles, I wanted to come back even stronger this season and hopefully take first place!

That being said I'm going to need a solid 75 if I’m going to stand up to the great players in the league, I thought, so I took a look at what the top decks were. Well those would have to be Atarka Red as well as Cat Combo. So, right off the bat I dismissed Atarka Red as a potential list as I don’t like to play aggro decks along the line of all in burn. That style of deck to me is very stale and not fun to play. I also expected a lot of hate, so I crossed it out, even if It has the most explosive wins in the format.

Ok, so one of the top decks out. How about Cat? With the new Planeswalker rule change I, alongside a lot of online Frontier players, thought that a new version of Jeskai Cat would come out. This new list uses Gideon planeswalker to accumulate value, such as the big daddy Gideon, Gideon Ally of Zendikar and Teen Gid as well in Gideon of the Trials allowing us to drop the green and make the mana better while still having a combo kill and a “fair” game plan because Gideon tribal is very fair against certain decks. Me and /u/nascarfather started to brew a list and this is what we came up with,


Jeskai Copy Cat Test List

Instants

  • 4 Opt

  • 3 Lightning Strike

  • 1 Abrade

  • 2 Negate

  • 3 Dig Through Time

Sorcery

  • 2 Radiant Flames

  • 3 Fumigate

Enchantment

  • 1 Search for Azcanta

Creatures

  • 4 Jace, Vryn’s Prodigy

  • 3 Felidar Guardian

Planeswalkers

  • 3 Saheeli Rai

  • 4 Gideon, Ally of Zendikar

  • 3 Gideon of the Trials

Lands

  • 4 Flooded Strand

  • 1 Polluted Delta

  • 2 Mystic Monastery

  • 2 Inspiring Vantage

  • 3 Spirebluff Canal

  • 2 Glacial Fortress

  • 2 Battlefield Forge

  • 2 Prairie Stream

  • 2 Island

  • 2 Plains

Sideboard

  • 4 Arashin Cleric

  • 2 Radiant Flames

  • 1 Abrade

  • 1 Fumigate

  • 1 Search for Azcanta

  • 2 Disdainful Stroke

  • 1 Negate

  • 2 Dispel

  • 1 Summary Dismissal


While I think this could’ve been a great deck for me to choose to play in the tourney. It has a resilient late game with Search for Azcanta to allow filtering and late game power to constantly keep searching for gas such as more Gideons or a Chandra or Dig to get even more card advantage to allow us to grind out our opponent’s and the deck can side into a more controlling deck if needed. It also has our traditional combo finish and the ability to just win out of nowhere. It had showed some weakness to aggro, though, which kept me looking at other options.

If I find full aggro burn decks like Atarka Red to be predictable and easily hated out, a tempo Pirate deck was something I could really get behind. I liked the idea of a sort of delver style deck with a tribal subtheme, but I think currently it’s not quite good enough. Perhaps with the release of the second set of Ixalan perhaps it’ll get what it needs to be a good deck.

Previously I had also brewed a Jund Delirium list and I think that with extra value engines I might have had some better game against control (which i assumed was going to be a big part of the meta as well aggro.) Here’s my latest attempt at the archetype, which showed real promise in testing.


Jund Delirium

Creatures

  • 4 Satyr Wayfinder

  • 4 Walking Balista

  • 2 Goblin Dark-Dwellers

  • 2 Ishkanah, Grafwidow

  • 1 Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet

  • 1 Tasigur, the Golden Fang

  • 1 emrakul, the promised end

Instants

  • 4 Fatal Push

  • 2 Kolaghan's Command

  • 2 Grapple with the Past

  • 1 Murderous Cut

**Sorceries

  • 4 Traverse the Ulvenwald

  • 2 Sweltering Suns

Enchantments

  • 2 Vessel of Nascency

Planeswalkers

  • 3 Liliana, the Last Hope

  • 2 Liliana, Death's Majesty

Lands

  • 4 Bloodstained Mire

  • 4 Wooded Foothills

  • 2 Cinder Glade

  • 2 Dragonskull Summit

  • 2 Hissing Quagmire

  • 2 Rootbound Crag

  • 2 Smoldering Marsh

  • 2 Mountain

  • 2 Swamp

  • 1 Forest

Sideboard

  • 2 Sorcerous Spyglass

  • 2 Tireless Tracker

  • 2 Transgress the Mind

  • 2 To the Slaughter

  • 1 Chandra, Torch of Defiance

  • 1 Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet

  • 1 Infinite Obliteration

  • 1 Manglehorn

  • 1 Nissa, Vital force

  • 1 The scorpion god

  • 1 Reclamation Sage


I thought the ability to test multiple Liliana’s was interesting, as was this more controlling take on a known archetype (Turbo Emrakul). I’ll save a longer analysis for another time, but, basically, I felt that the Saheeli list would’ve been a better choice than the delirium list. The cat combo finish is just so strong.

Ok, now the reason I passed up those great or almost complete decks, U/B control!! With the release of Ixalan this archetype gets a variety of different additions to the deck such as Opt , Search for Azcanta , Vraska’s Contempt and Drowned Catacomb . With these additions to the deck we get a great value engine in the Sunken Ruins of Azcanta, a great cantrip in Opt, a great catch all removal spell in Vraska’s Contempt and even better mana in Drowned Catacombs.

Also, this colour combination allows me to my pet card in frontier, The Scarab God. The Scarab God is a versatile threat which allows me to steal thing out my opponent’s graveyard to start to put the beatdown on them as well. It also double the potential Torrential Gearhulk in my list.

In my lands I am running a couple cards that not everyone is running such as Westvale Abbey and Field of Ruin . The Abbey is in the list to help against control decks by allowing me to make threats at instant speed to pressure my opponent and while 1 a turn doesn't seem like much the potential to swing for one, then two, the, 3 adds up quickly. If you get to the point where they have to use removal spells on your tokens, you’re in a winning position. Games two and three this is even more pronounced when most of the sweepers will have been removed for more counterspells. Field of Ruins, on the other hand, is there to crimp my opponents on mana as well as to destroy the new flip lands from the enchantment cycle that Ixalan introduced. If you wish to see the deck in action you can watch our very own /u/skyburial and /u/xahhfink6 cover mine and Mars Goad’s league match here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=unD1XLM6QEM


UB Control

Instants

  • 4 Fatal Push

  • 4 Opt

  • 3 Essence Scatter

  • 3 Negate

  • 2 Censor

  • 2 Dig Through Time

  • 2 Disallow

  • 2 Vraska's Contempt

Sorcery

  • 2 Crux of Fate

  • 2 Languish

  • 1 Never to Return

Enchantment

  • 3 Search for Azcanta

Planeswalker

  • 2 Liliana, the Last Hope

Creatures

  • 2 Torrential Gearhulk

  • 1 The Scarab God

Lands

  • 4 Drowned Catacomb

  • 4 Fetid Pools

  • 4 Polluted Delta

  • 4 Sunken Hollow

  • 4 Island

  • 2 Swamp

  • 2 Field of Ruin

  • 1 Westvale Abbey

Sideboard

  • 4 Gifted Aetherborn

  • 2 Dispel

  • 2 Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet

  • 2 Sorcerous Spyglass

  • 1 Infinite Obliteration

  • 1 Negate

  • 1 Sphinx of the Final Word

  • 1 The Scarab God

  • 1 Vraska's Contempt


The most surprising thing here is probably that I am running 0 copies of Jace Vryn’s Prodigy, which is an excellent finisher as well as early game looter. While I do think that Jace is a great threat that can come out of control early let's look at the top 5 most played cards across the decks in the league,

Most Played Cards :

Fatal Push - 59 copies across 17 lists. 50% of field. Opt - 45 copies across 12 lists. Appears as a 4 of in all but 2 of the astounding 11 lists it appears in. 33.3% of field. Lighting Strike - 45 Copies across 11 Lists. 28.5% of field. Monastery Swiftspear - 36 copies across 9 lists. 25% of field. Negate - 30 copies across 14 lists. 38.8% of field.

With 55 other copies of Fatal push alongside 45 copies of Lightning Strike it’s unlikely that Jace flips, or gets to loot. Playing Search guarantees value as not many people will be running enchantment removal. It also lets us ramp to gearhulks, or use the extra mana to just hold up counters. That’s not even counting the “impulse” on a land you can use repeatedly!

I feel that this deck could potentially struggle against aggro because I chose not to run grasp, so I tried to offset that by playing 4 Gifted Aetherborn and 2 Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet for the lifegain and as early roadblocks. Also, being able to recur 4/4’s with lifelink deathtouch and the exile clause on Kalitas with The Scarab God is great against certain decks, even if it doesn’t synergize with The Scarab God’s activated ability (should you be able to get to that point without dying.)

With the current list I’m running I struggle slightly against Jeskai Cat game one, after sideboard however we get more tools to help us out and the matchups gets a lot better allowing us to get rid of our dead cards in order to fight the variety of planeswalkers they have at their disposal. I generally feel pretty solid about the rest of my matchups.

This has been a look inside my decision making for what I brought to the league this season, I’m Matt McTavish or known on reddit as /u/xeddrezz and thank you for taking the time out of your day to read my article have a good day and hope to bring you some more content soon!


r/spikes • • Aug 19 '13

[Modern] What do you think about banning Birthing Pod?

5 Upvotes

I was watching Andrew Cuneo stream the other day and someone in his chat asked if he had played any Melira Pod lately, a deck he has played a lot for quite some time now. Cuneo responded that no, in fact he hasn't and that he wouldn't mind if they banned Birthing Pod in the next round. He felt he is a bit bored playing with and against it and could u

Before you call this a witch hunt, there is some theory behind this idea.

The reason Green Sun's Zenith is banned is because it lowers the diversity among the decks that can play it. Do you have it in your opener? Get Dryad Arbor. Do you have no turn 2 play? Get a Nacatl/Bird/Elf. Do you have no turn 3 play? Get Pridemage/Goyf/Whatever.

The decks that could play GSZ if it were legal would most certainly do so due to its power level, but it would make your game play a lot more linear and remove a lot of the choices/variance thus leading to a more boring, stagnant strategy overall.

Birthing Pod works in a similar way, if a bit less ubiquitously due to being more of a Midrange Combo card instead of one that goes into all different types of green based decks. When you have Birthing Pod in your hand or in play, decision trees become very narrow. You either need to pod up an answer card to a dire situation at hand, or you pod your way towards a particular combo (Angel + Kiki, Melira + Sac Outlet + Persist guy, etc).

Most people I talk to consider Melira Pod to be the best deck in the format. Perhaps right now the gap between the potentially "best deck" and "second best deck" is not very wide, but it could increase over time as more creatures are printed. Cartel Aristocrat? Get in there. Scavenging Ooze and maybe even Archangel of Thune (with Spike Feeder)? Sure, why not!

One final argument against pod is another one that faces GSZ, and even more so Sensei's Divining Top: dexterity issues and tournament time wasted searching your deck. We already spend a ton of time utilizing a pile of fetch lands to craft our perfect 3-5 color mana bases. Birthing Pod mirrors? Prepare to shuffle a lot.


r/spikes • • Jun 21 '18

Spoiler [Spoiler][M19] Suncleanser Spoiler

3 Upvotes

When Suncleanser enters the battlefield, choose one -

Remove all counters from target creature. It can't have counters put on it for as long as Suncleanser remains on the battlefield.

Target opponent loses all counters. That player can't get counters for as long as Suncleanser remains on the battlefield.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I mean.... what is happening at WotC right now? It seems that there are far too few designer and playtesters creating the sets and they are overloaded with work and don't even care about the quality of their design anymore.

Three months before energy rotates, they give us this glorious "energy hate bear" that feels like the most stitched together, having no use in any other environment but energy whatsoever, makeshift pseudo answer that isnt even good and doesn't even fit in any viable deck / wouldn't have had fit in any viable deck as energy was around.

To quickly talk about the playability of this thing: Whatever option you chose, the energy player would either dumb all his energy into his [[Whirler Virtuoso]] or his [[Longtusk cub]] if you chose second, and if you chose first on the cub... well duh, tell me which energy player goes all in on his cub anyway.

The solution to a good format is so fucking easy and it's obious from vintage and legacy (and of course modern) so hard, I can't even understand how they did not come to there senses yet:

Whenever you make a theme in a block, be it graveyard synergies, energy or whatever, just print a few fucking strong hoser cards RIGHT IN THE VERY SET. So in case, the mechanic has the slightest chance of being too strong, the players already have the tools right their to sideboard. And don't make it just one card for 1 archetype (what should this have been for ... Wx death and taxes in standard??) but make a couple of cards for different archetypes or even an artifact so everybody can play it (like [[damping sphere]], which is, concerning modern, actually a nice option for people's sideboards).

All in all, this is a complete joke. This entered the M19 file right when they realized, that they made Energy too strong but before the bannings and now they still ship us this joke of card, with a very cheap, excusing smile: "hehe, sorry we messed up with energy, this would've been our answer, nice, mh?

No, not nice... bullshit. Wizards get your shit together. Make proper hoser cards, whenever you make a new mechanic that has the slightest chance of being busted (anybody said pushed vehicles??). Also make hoser cards for all colors again. Where are the circle of protections? Where is stuff like [[boiling Seas]], [[Wrath of Marit Lage]] and shit? Stuff like this keeps the format together and keeps archetypes in check if they get too strong.

The Mare of M19 cicle is a nice try in the right direction, but obviously are too weak. The white horse could somewhat be viable against red, but you are on the backfoot with white anyway, so nobody cares, that it can't be blocked by red creatures. The lifegain might be somewhat nice, and if (big if) there is a white low-to-the-ground deck, this is a good sideboard card against red aggro.

Anyway. To come full circle, the hoser card, that keeps legacy and vintage together I was referring to is of course [[Force of Will]] which hoses any too-fast-for-fair-cards combo strats and keeps the format sane. Imagine those formats without force, it would be completely dumb. It's right there, wizards, RIGHT THERE.

(For Modern, it's of course more diverse between thing like Stony Silence, Relic of Progenitus, Artifact hate etc.)

Sorry for the rant, but really. It's not that hard, just do it and then Standard will be fine sometime in the future.

Cheers and nice brewing season :)


r/spikes • • Jan 20 '19

Bo1 Mythic Bo1 Turbo Fog Guide [Standard]

2 Upvotes

Hey /r/spikes, I wanted to post the list I used exclusively to climb from Diamond IV to Mythic. It's a turbo fog list with a unique trick that I haven't seen any other decklists posted use yet. It's tuned aggressively to beat mono-red aggro and mono-red burn and has a surprisingly favorable matchup vs most control.

Somewhat surprisingly, the decks it struggles most with are decks which turbo fog usually has nearly unlosable matchups vs, namely decks that are all about creature damage. This is because you only run 4 fogs, and you're very low on enchantment hate, so green/white angels landing an Ixalan's binding can really ruin your day.

The interesting combo I've added to greatly skew the burn matchups in our favor are 4x [[Revitalize]] (nothing special here) and 2x [[Sanguine Sacrament]]. The combo potential with [[Wilderness Reclamation]] is insane. I've had games where I get triple digit life totals off it since if you get a few Reclamations going you can X = 20+ for massive life gain, putting you out of the reach of mono red or Radkos burn decks (which is about 85% of what I'm queuing into right now).

I also added Tezz, since I once had a turbo fog mirror match last over an hour because I went off first, exiled all his permanents, but had no way to win the game, and neither of us wanted to concede. Tezz represents an alternate win condition to Teferi exile in the mirror, or if you get into a situation where you get your Teferi Ixalan'd but can still generate infinite turns.

Some things I've struggled with are deciding on an exact deck list, and this has gone through many iterations. Part of me misses the 4x Nexus of fate, but I feel 3 is plenty given how many times you can pop off once you flip a [[Search for Azcanta]].

I'm also not an expert on mana bases, so someone who is, feel free to offer suggestions.

Things I am sure of: 4x Revitalize and a couple Sanguine Sacraments are must haves. 4x Wilderness Reclamation has to be right. 4x root snare are needed. This deck sacrifices turbo fogs usual ramp potential (no [[Gift of Paradise]] and only 2x [[Growth Spiral]]) in favor of life gain and cycle, which seem much more useful in this meta for consistent results. Gift feels great when you play it on curve, but it doesn't cycle for you, and once you have 5 mana it's useless. Likewise, Growth Spiral is wonderful on turn 2, but an overcosted cantrip once you have 5 mana.

I am playing this deck as a Bo1 list, so there's no sideboard, but if you wanted to take this list into Bo3, I would add [[Carnage Tyrant]]'s, counterspells, Lyra, and more fogs/novas/settles to the sideboard.

I actually think this deck could perform reasonably well in Bo3 because the control matchup actually feels pretty favorable for us--there are just too many things to counter. In order to beat us, Jeskai needs to reliably keep all our Azcantas, all our Wilderness Reclamations, and all of Teferis off the board, where previously as long as they countered Teferi they probably won.

Tips and Tricks:

  • Don't be greedy with your root snares vs mono-red. Once we get 5 mana and a wilderness reclamation, we'll probably win the game, but we have to get there. It's perfectly reasonable to root snare 3-5 damage on turn 3.

  • Try and get value out of your growth spirals. If you have 2 lands in play but none in hand and a revitalize/[[Chart a Course]] in hand, I would play the card draw first to try and insure you get a double land out of your spiral. We're very low on ramp, so if we get one of our two hard ramp cards, we should make it count.

  • Get in the habit of always clearing and re-entering your end phase stop. The UI is currently bugged and will not clear the visual indicator of your end phase stop, and if you don't refresh it during your turn, you will waste all your wilderness reclamation triggers.

  • In the mirror, always focus on slowing them down. Minus'ing your Teferi to tuck their Azcanta or their Teferi is almost always the right play. Your goal in the mirror is to slow them down as much as possible and cycle through your own deck as quickly as possible.

Any other questions, suggestions, or comments, feel free to chime in! Thanks!

Proof: https://i.imgur.com/KbiNe6Z.png

Decklist:

3 Nexus of Fate (M19) 306
1 Island (RIX) 193
2 Growth Spiral (RNA) 178
4 Teferi, Hero of Dominaria (DAR) 207
4 Revitalize (M19) 35
4 Wilderness Reclamation (RNA) 149
4 Root Snare (M19) 199
3 Chemister's Insight (GRN) 32
3 Chart a Course (XLN) 48
2 Sanguine Sacrament (XLN) 33
4 Temple Garden (GRN) 258
4 Hinterland Harbor (DAR) 240
4 Glacial Fortress (XLN) 255
4 Sunpetal Grove (XLN) 257
3 Plains (RIX) 192
2 Breeding Pool (RNA) 246
3 Hallowed Fountain (RNA) 251
3 Search for Azcanta (XLN) 74
1 Cleansing Nova (M19) 9
1 Tezzeret, Artifice Master (M19) 79
1 Settle the Wreckage (XLN) 34

r/spikes • • Sep 30 '17

Frontier [Frontier] Magic, The Final Frontier - F2F Final Frontier Showdown, UoL Top 4, and Ixalan Metagame Planning

2 Upvotes

Hi again /r/spikes, Kevin Finkle here with another episode of Magic, The Final Frontier, a podcast about Competitive Frontier. Our goal is to provide up-to-date news, commentary, and analysis from real Frontier experts, trying to bring together regional players with one unified voice on Frontier. We recently released our fourth cast which was focused on the final tournaments of HOU Frontier before Ixalan starts shaking things up next week. We also brought up Magic Arena, and talked some about our testing for metagame changes with Ixalan cards. This episode turned out great so I hope you all take a chance and enjoy it: Episode 4 - Final F2F Showdown and UOL Top 4!.


Podcast topics

Introduction (00:08)

1:05 Top 8 Lists from the Final Frontier Showdown at F2F

21:45 UOL Season 1 Top 4 Lists

36:43 Testing for UOL Season 2

51:27 MTGArena


In this episode:

Final Frontier Showdown F2F Games Top 8:

1st Place: John Blinov, Atarka Red

2nd Place: Matt Mealing: Blue White Humans

3rd Place: Daniel Fournier, Atarka Red

4th Place: Simon Tubello, Grixis Control

5th Place: Liam Kane, Mardu Vehicles

6th Place: Chris Ha, Abzan Aggro

7th Place: Benny Wong, Abzan Aggro

8th Place: Dylan Harkness, Grixis Ensoul

UOL Top 4:

1st Place: Jesse Vuoti, Mardu Vehicles

2nd Place: Matthew Mctavish, Mardu Control

3rd Place: Thomas Snodgrass, Jeskai Black Control

4th Place: Rasmus Enegren, Esper Vehicles

We also discussed how testing had gone for our experts, and what they were thinking of building for Ixalan Frontier. They also made some predictions about the metagame which turned out to be true. The most popular decks for the new UOL season were U/B Control, Atarka Red, and Jeskai Saheeli combo.

UOL Full Season 2 Lists - Final


Sorry for the short post this week, I’ll try and have some great content to go along with next week’s release for anyone who reads but doesn’t listen! I’ll be hanging around in the comments and am happy to discuss all things Frontier with you in relation to Showdown, next season, or anything else!

Also, if you haven't yet, please check out our first three episodes. In the first we introduce ourselves and go over two of the most important tournaments from last season Pilot Episode.

In our second episode we took a deeper dive on analyzing the format by trying to determine what our experts felt was tier 1 based on what had been showing up in tournaments, what was still powerful but not being seen as much (such as GB Scales and Aetherworks Marvel), and what was on that borderline of being dominant. We also had a special guest Matt Hoffman, the winner of the Toronto GP North America Champs tournament, so it gave us some special insight! That episode turned out great so I highly recommend a listen here: Episode Two

Last week’s episode was a review of Ixalan and how those cards might shake up the Frontier Metagame: Episode Three

Thanks!

-Xahhfink6


r/spikes • • Oct 08 '17

Standard [Discussion] Why Vraska's Contempt over Hour of Glory?

2 Upvotes

It seems unanimous that Vraska's Contempt is seen as the superior exile removal spell in Standard right now, but I must be missing something. Hour of Glory doesn't hit Planeswalkers, but that's never really been much of something I've had to consider before. The mana is also less taxing, requiring a single black over double. Is the lifegain seriously that important right now? 2 life is literally nothing. - Ramunap does that in a heartbeat. Is the Planeswalker target truly so relevant?

EDIT: I'm sorry I asked what seems to be a stupid question. I've been playing Magic for just under a year, and was recommended this reddit as a good place to get advice and learn from others. I've been playing Ramunap Red at my LGS and have not come across Vraska's Contempt yet personally. I'll refrain from asking questions here if it upsets people. Sorry to have wasted everyone's time.


r/spikes • • Mar 24 '21

Standard [discussion] Which "engine" cards have failed to perform in standard so far, and what synergy pieces are you looking for to enable them to shine?

0 Upvotes

With Strixhaven spoilers starting in full tomorrow, I think this is a good time to look back at which powerful cards are available in standard which have failed to break out as powerful build arounds, and consider what cards would need to be printed to make them playable. I think this retrospective can be especially relevant for cards printed in supplemental products, which might be forgotten because they aren't ever seen in draft or cracking packs. Here are some of my thoughts for each current standard set, but I'd love to hear the thoughts of more accomplished brewers.

Eldraine:

[[All that Glitters]] - We are unlikely to see a heavy artifact or enchantment theme this set, but historic has proven this card is strong with a critical mass of cheap synergy cards

[[Alela, Artful Provocateur]]: a pretty powerful effect, but a 4 mana 2/3 is too low rate.

[[Ayara, First of Locthwain]]: Black desperately needs a good 1 drop, but with a good 1 drop and a 2 drop that makes 2 black bodies, mono black could be interesting.

[[Dance of the Manse]]: This card has been in and out of play since printing, and is probably one good enchantment that kills itself away from play.

[[Emry, Lurker of the Loch]]: Emry is a busted card just looking for good artifacts to play with.

[[Faeburrow Elder]]: This ones a long shot, but an 2 mana artifact or land that says "this is all colors" could make this a very powerful ramp piece.

[[Gadwick, the Wizened]]: Gadwick is probably the best way to turn large amounts of mana into cards in the format.

[[Garruk, Cursed Huntsman]]: An innately strong walker, but I don't know what would make him good.

[[Kenrith, the Returned King]]: Without Fires, there hasn't been a good reason to play Kenrith, but he is still a fundamentally powerful card.

[[Korvold, Fae-Cursed King]]: Claim the firstborn and woestrider are still in the format, it would not take much for Korvold to be strong.

[[Shimmer Dragon]]: I legitimately forgot this card existed, but a 5/6 hexproof that draws you cards if you have some treasures or food seems good.

[[Syr Konrad, the Grim]]: A blue black mill deck combined with graveyard destruction could be an interesting combo kill.

[[Witch's Vengeance]]: A solid wrath if Elves or some other tribe ever becomes too oppressive.


Theros:

[[Aphemia, the Cacophony]]: I doubt this set will get it there, but a good 1 mana enchantment that immediately goes to the yard would go a long way for her.

[[Archon of Sun's Grace]]: Already sees play with Yorion some times, and could certainly have a break out with a few good cheap enchantments.

[[Bronzehide Lion]]: If there is ever a green/white good stuff deck, this is probably in it, though it does get wrecked by lovestruck beast.

[[Dalakos, Crafter of Wonders]]: I doubt this is the set for him, but there is a world where an equipment deck is good.

[[Destiny Spinner]]: Maybe the wizard school set will be dominated by counter magic and she will see hate play?

[[Dream Trawler]]: One of the better creatures in the format to search onto the board alone.

[[Enigmatic Incarnation]]: I have NO idea. The effect is strong, but it would take a better deck builder than me to make it work.

[[Gray Merchant of Asphodel]]: Like I mentioned with Ayara, mono black is essentially one good 1 drop from playable, and Gary might be a finisher.

[[Ironscale Hydra]]: Did anyone know this card existed? A 5 mana 5/5 that can't die in combat feels like it should be good in the right meta.

[[Heliod, Sun-Crowned]]: Heliod decks are always on the fringe. I don't think this set will have a big life gain theme, but who knows.

[[Nightmare Shepherd]]: Another piece of that mono black deck I've been keeping an eye on.

[[Nyx Lotus]]: Mono blue devotion combo was a meme a while back, another untap creature like Corridor Monitor could make it real.

[[Setessan Champion]]: if the Rune cycle didn't get this card there, nothing will, but who knows.

[[Terror of Mount Velus]] If there is a "summon multiple creatures to the battlefield they get haste" card, this is probably one of the payoffs.

[[Thassa, Deep-Dwelling]]: A sufficently broken ETB might be worth playing Thassa as a way to double it up.

[[Underworld Breach]]: Pioneer has proven how busted this card can be. We're probably one good ritual away from it getting banned in standard.


Ikoria:

[[Call of the Death-Dweller]] By far the strongest reanimation spell in standard. A few good black 1 or 2 drops will probably get it into decks.

[[Death's Oasis]]: A weird value engine, but for 3 mana it has some real power to it.

[[General Kudro of Drannith]]: A human synergy deck isn't out of the question.

[[Gyruda, Doom of Depths]]: If a deck comes together that happens to play all evens, why not?

[[Lukka, Coppercoat Outcast]]: Lukka is one search target away from being broken again.

[[Luminous Broodmoth]]: I could actually see this card being played in mono white side boards right now.

[[Rielle, the Everwise]]: Totally plausible in a wizards or magecraft deck, or even in cycling.

[[Slitherwisp]]: It hasn't made a home in rogues, but its plausible if a powerful non-rogue flash creature gets printed that it makes the cut.

[[Song of Creation]] Probably a meme, but a cycle of 0 mana cards could make it real.

[[Titans' Nest]] One of the strongest mana engines left in standard, but its interface on arena has made it unplayable.

[[Vadrok, Apex of Thunder]] Maybe someday mantis rider that sometimes casts a card from your yard for free will be good enough for standard?

[[Vivien, Monsters' Advocate]] She's seen a bit of play in green food decks, but a green card that reduces its own cost so that her -2 would let it search up something huge would probably make her a real force.

[[Winota, Joiner of Forces]] We're one good human target away from Winota breaking standard like it did in historic. Clarion spirit is already exactly the 2 drop the deck wants.


Core set 2021:

[[Archfiend's Vessel]]: The right reanimation card could let this see play.

[[Azusa, Lost but Seeking]]: I don't think we know what land cycle we are getting in Strixhaven do we? Until then, I'm not ruling Azusa out.

[[Chandra's Incinerator]]: Between magecraft and potential new burn spells, the incinerator has a chance to be format breaking.

[[Conclave Mentor]]: Abzan counters always feels like its right on the edge of being good. Who knows what support would push it over the top.

[[Grim Tutor]] There is a world where some busted combo deck is out there that wants a tutor.

[[Griffin Aerie]]: Maybe they'll print a "you gain 3 life per turn" card.

[[Jolrael, Mwonvuli Recluse]] I'm honestly a bit surprised that no deck has managed to make Jolrael work since Widerness Rec, but I guess bonecrusher giant is kinda a good card. One good cantrip likely gets her there.

[[Teferi, Master of Time]] notable with the already revealed Kasmina because she doubles the rate he reaches ultimate.

[[Transmogrify]] Similar to Lukka, the right payoff creature could make this card fantastic.

[[Ugin, the Spirit Dragon]] I don't know, 8 mana is pretty expensive and 3 per turn isn't a fast clock. Probably not playable.

Zendikar:

[[Forsaken Monument]] I doubt a mono brown deck will work in standard, but its worth keeping an eye on.

[[Grakmaw, Skyclave Ravager]] a key piece if Abzan counters gets support

[[Kaza, Roil Chaser]] A wizard tribal payoff in a set with magecraft set in a wizarding school?

[[Magmatic Channeler]] probably the strongest 2 drop in the format if you can meet its 4 spell requirement

[[Scourge of the Skyclaves]] death's shadow decks in historic have shown this can be a house, not that I'm expecting much without shock lands.

[[Sea Gate Stormcaller]] I'm keeping an eye on basically anything that copies spells on the stack.

[[Yasharn, Implacable Earth]] A possible tech card if a sac deck becomes dominant

[[Zagras, Thief of Heartbeats]] I'm going to let this stand in for all the party cards. I don't believe party will ever be competitive, but at the moment wizards does seem to the be the weakest link. Maybe a really busted wizard in Strixhaven somehow pulls it together?

This post is already way too long, and Kaldhiem is still fresh, so I think I'll leave it there.


r/spikes • • Jan 12 '18

Frontier [Frontier] Critiquing the MFF RIX Set Review

6 Upvotes

Magic, the Final Frontier Set Review

Magic, the Final Frontier released their set review today for Rivals of Ixalan in Frontier. The podcast review can be found here:

https://soundcloud.com/kevin-finkle-142656842/mtg-final-frontier-podcast-episode-15-part-1

Generally, their reception of the set was favorable. They saw a lot of tools for the format and the possibility of new archetypes. Below I’ll look at some of their individual card evaluations and even show you a few rejected or potential Rivals of Ixalan brews that I tested. For people who care about my Frontier testing, I’ll have an article about it later, but I’m 150 matches into Rivals testing and I do think there are impact cards to be found here.


Critiquing the Review


First off, regarding vampires, I’m pretty sure that vampires is fringe viable in Frontier, similar to what we saw in Standard: you can catch some people off guard with a relatively competitive version of this list at an event. So, it may have some spike potential. Still, event to event, your highest expected win percentage will just be quality tiered decks like Atarka Red, Jund or UB Control.

So, while they call Legion Lieutenant or Skymarch Aspirant playable, they’re not wrong, but you have to take it in that sense. None of these cards are remotely playable outside of that tribal archetype and need to be understood as such in Frontier. The only exception is Famished Paladin. While no viable combos exist now, this is the sort of card that could easily become a combo engine in Frontier. Whether that sort of combo would be playable one day depends on the power level of the cards surrounding it, of course.

So, where does that leave us with vampires? The most powerful vampire cards in the format are almost certainly the following:

  1. Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet

  2. Gifted Aetherborn

  3. Legion’s Landing

  4. Legion’s Lieutenant

  5. Drana, Liberator of Malakir

The problem is the best vampire, Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet is realistically going to end up in your sideboard. Still, pairing Gifted Aetherborn with Radiant Destiny is a real draw here. So, what might a test list look like? Here’s a rejected brew from season four UOL testing which showed some promise against aggressive strategies.


Vampires Test List by Kevin Finkle

Lands

  • 4 Concealed Courtyard

  • 4 Caves of Koilos

  • 3 Unclaimed Territory

  • 1 Plains

  • 8 Swamp

  • 1 Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth

  • 1 Shambling Vent

Creatures

  • 4 Gifted Aetherborn

  • 3 Drana, Liberator of Malakir

  • 2 Stromkirk Condemned

  • 4 Skymarcher Aspirant

  • 4 Legion Lieutenant

  • 2 Indulgent Aristocrat

  • 2 Sanctum Seeker

  • 3 Mavren Fein, Dusk Apostle

  • 4 Oathsworn Vampire

Spells

  • 3 Radiant Destiny

  • 2 Legion's Landing

  • 4 Fatal Push

  • 1 Sorin, Solemn Visitor


Moving on to Dinosaurs, the card they’re the highest on is Wayward Swordtooth. The problem with the card is in some games it’s a 3 mana spell that doesn’t effect the board, then you die on turn four. While it pairs nicely with Tireless Tracker, it’s not like you’re losing the games where tracker goes off. The place this might see play is pairing with a card Matt Murday essentially called unplayable, Ghalta, Primal Hunger. Being able to get a 12/12 trample as soon as turn four is a real thing and their non-push removal will be heavily taxed in this sort of strategy. Relentless Raptor could see some play as Kevin Finkle mentioned (perhaps in an aggressive Jeskai decks), as a two mana 3/3 isn’t bad.

Alongside dinosaurs, they talk about a pair of powerful enchantments Path of Mettle and Blood Sun. I agree that Path of Mettle is a great card without a home at the moment in Frontier. Finding that home won’t be easy, though. You need to be a controlling midrange deck with access to lots of creatures with first strike, double strike, vigilance and haste. What are some examples of cards that fit these requirements? Mantis Rider is an easy one. Relentless Raptor could fit, but is maybe more aggressive than this strategy can play. Here’s a list of a few more cards that see play in Frontier which could be paired with this strategy: Always Watching, Sylvan Advocate, Heart of Kiran, Archangel Avacyn, Oketra the True, Cataclysmic Gearhulk, Knight of the White Orchid, Thalia, Heretic Cathar.

Alright, now let’s turn to Blood Sun. This is another card I’m pretty sure they just got wrong. Let’s look at the number of fetchlands in some tier one or tournament winning strategies in Frontier: WU Aggro (8), Jund (8), Atarka Red (9), Abzan (10), Grixis Control (11), Bant Humans (11), 4c Control (12), Copycat (12). Fetchlands are, well, everywhere. In very high numbers. To think that a card which turns off up to half of your opponents lands (while cantripping) in an Elvish Mystic format won’t have any impact doesn’t seem correct. Now what sort of impact might Blood Sun actually have? It’s possible that people will just shave a little on fetches and the format stays the same. It’s also possible that new strategies will emerge around this card.

What might that look like? Here’s a test list for what dino stompy in Frontier could look like:


Dino Stompy Test List by /u/nascarfather

Land

  • 4 Rootbound Crag

  • 4 Cinder Glade

  • 1 Sheltered Thicket

  • 8 Forest

  • 3 Mountain

  • 1 Aether Hub

Creature

  • 4 Elvish Mystic

  • 2 Thrashing Brontodon

  • 4 Ripjaw Raptor

  • 2 Carnage Tyrant

Enchantment

  • 4 Blood Sun

  • 4 Oath of Nissa

Instant

  • 4 Lightning Strike

Planeswalker

  • 4 Chandra, Torch of Defiance

  • 3 Nissa, Worldwaker

Sorcery

  • 4 Thunderherd Migration

  • 4 Sweltering Suns


How viable is this sort of list? Well, it’s not there yet, but I’ve ran version of this strategy into a number of tiered decks and Blood Sun can put in work. I tended to beat combo and controlling strategies, but lose to aggro with this sort of build. If you were to test dino stompy, I would recommend playing a lot of aggro hate in your sideboard. Another way to go is to use Kozilek's Return alongside x/3s like Ranging Raptors.

I’ll leave the discussion of pirates, elder dinosaurs and merfolk for another time. The one thing I will say about merfolk is I do think they are real and I do think Kumena is a part of it. But, as I think merfolk is an article to itself, I won’t get into that here.

So, thanks for taking the time to read this. If you’d like a chance to try Frontier for yourself, I’ll give a quick reminder that signups for the Untap Open League close the 17th and are open here. As always, I’m happy to chat with you about this or anything related to Frontier in the comments below.


r/spikes • • Oct 11 '18

Modern [Modern] 10 things you're doing wrong against Krark-Clan Ironworks

50 Upvotes

You've heard of KCI. People like Emma Handy and SaffronOlive have rallied against it in order to get it banned because it's too complex, too good, too consistent, too resilient or something in between.

However, after months playing it to a great success (2 PPTQ finals, 1 PPTQ semifinals, 1 PPTQ quarterfinals in 6 PPTQs total), I can say the most important source of wins isn't its resiliency or consistency: It's the amount of times people misplay against it because they don't know how Magic in general and KCI in particular works. Here I will compile a list of stuff you're not supposed to do if you really want to give yourself the best chance of beating KCI.

1) The double block

We've all seen it. Opponent attacks with Gurmag Angler, which is blocked with Scrap Trawler and Myr Retriever, both die, which gets Scrap Trawler, Myr Retriever and a 1-drop artifact out of the bin and into the hand. KCI grinds out their grindy opponent out of the game. Obviously, the opponent blames this on KCI being too good at grinding while begrudgingly signing the match slip not realizing the rules of the game allow you to place 5 damage on Scrap Trawler an 0 on Myr Retriever, essentially breaking the loop of infinite chumpblocking plus value.

2) Surgical Extraction

"You're so lucky, I sideboarded 3 copies of Surgical Extraction and didn't draw one" - Opponent after getting beaten 2-0 by KCI.

What opponent doesn't know is that those copies are dead cards 100% of the time against any competent KCI player. We always have an artifact to sacrifice in response to Surgical to retrieve whatever you target. A competent pilot will cast the second Pyrite Spellbomb before sacrificing the first one, and then recur that one. If you have Surgical, we have a second copy in the field. It's just not good.

Don't sideboard Surgical Extraction against KCI. The only time they're good is if you Thoughtseize KCI on turn 1, then Surgical it. And even then, if your opponent is remotely competent, they have both Sai, Master Thopterist and Ghirapur Aether Grid in the deck and only 1 copy of KCI that they can tutor out with Inventors' Fair if they need it.

A lot of people ask me "When should I cast Surgical Extraction against KCI?" when the real question is "Should I bring Surgical Extraction against KCI?". The answer is no.

3) Rest in Peace / Leyline of the Void.

It is true that KCI cannot perform its combo with Rest in Peace or Leyline of the Void in play. However, again assuming the KCI pilot is remotely competent, the gameplan against any deck that could bring out any of these two revolves against Sai, Master Thopterist and Ghirapur Aether Grid, not Krark-Clan Ironworks. Nothing feels worse than opening with double Leyline only to get your face beaten in by thopters. RIP and Leyline were amazing against the RG version of the deck Matt Nass played before Sai came out. Sai changed that, RIP and Leyline aren't good anymore. Sorry.

4) Chalice of the Void.

First of all, why are you playing Chalice of the Void in Modern? It's such an underwhelming card, don't do this to yourself.

Second of all, if you put Chalice on 0, your opponent will cast EE with X=1 tapping a Citadel, then blow your Chalice. If you put Chalice on X>0, the explosives will be X=0. Chalice isn't good against a deck with Engineered Explosives. Chalice isn't good in Modern.

5) Damping Sphere

Damping Sphere is an amazing technology that allows aggressive and/or midrange strategies to buy one or two turns so they can actually finish the job against KCI, Storm and Tron. Don't get me wrong, the card is super good. However, the focus should always be on presenting a fast clock, not on trying to make your opponent whiff. Games against KCI are always a race, and the only speed that wins against KCI is faster than Sonic the Hedgehog.

Now that you understand this, if you doubt between playing Tarmogoyf or Sphere on turn 2, play the Goyf. Sphere should be only played AFTER you have a clock.

Also, this one is for Bogles players: Don't play Sphere on turn 2. The best way you have of beating KCI (and it's a long shot, it's a very bad matchup for you guys) is to play a bogle on turn 1, and somehow have a Daybreak Coronet on said bogle on turn 3. If you play a Sphere on turn 2, there's no way you can cast Coronet on turn 3. You'll be behind, your opponent will probably Claim the Sphere and go off.

6) Overboarding

If you sideboard more than 8 cards against KCI you're probably diluting your own strategy and hurting yourself more than you're hurting your opponent. Obviously there are exceptions to this rule, but overboarding against KCI is a lethal mistake.

7) Playing your Instants as Instants

Little known fact: you can cast your Instants at any time you can cast a Sorcery. Don't wait for me to untap. Use your interaction while I'm tapped out. While I personally think the Negate sideboard is horrid and shouldn't be played, a lot of pilots think it's great. Other people are going as far as to playing Swan Song, which is bad but still better than Negate. What I mean is, KCI can pack instant-speed interaction. Use yours while I'm tapped out.

I personally think Silence is the superior choice, though.

8) Durdling

If your deck was built by SaffronOlive you're not going to have a fun time. Play a proactive deck. I'm not surprised he wants KCI banned: good decks beat bad decks all the time. Play a deck that can either kill on turn 3, present a fast clock while meaningfully interacting with your opponent, or interact with everything Modern can throw at you. Anything can win a Modern tournament, but playing a deck that doesn't fall into any of these 3 categories will ultimately hurt your chances by a lot.

9) Not knowing how Magic works behind the scenes, how priority is passed and the exact moments you can intervene.

This happens a lot. I cast KCI. Opponent says "ok". I sac Mox Opal and Darksteel Citadel and my opponent wants to respond. Sucks to be you, sacrificing an artifact with no triggered abilities attached to it to KCI doesn't use the stack and I still have priority. You just told me what kind of interaction I have to play around.

Then I cast Scrap Trawler. You want to Fatal Push it immediately, but I have priority and never passed it. I call a judge to explain the situation, the judge says I'm right. If the judge says I'm not right, I appeal to the head judge because I'm right.

Now I have extra info because you're a hasty individual, and I'm absolutely going to play around your Fatal Push. Learn to be patient and only make game actions when the game allows you to. Ask your opponent to always communicate when they're passing priority when they're going off. As Jeff Hoogland eloquently puts it, there's no such thing as too much communication between opponents in Magic: The Gathering.

10) Conceding early

Don't scoop if I start moving stuff quickly and you don't quite get what's going on. Ask me what is going on. Ask me to put every trigger in the stack independently until I've assembled a loop. Once I demonstrate a loop (ALWAYS ask me to demonstrate it), generate infinite mana, draw my whole deck and demonstrate I can recur a Pyrite indefinitely, DON'T CONCEDE.

Some weeks ago I got second at a PPTQ with 84 people. I went 5-0, ID twice, won quarters, won semis and lost the finals. Three of my opponents scooped when I started moving stuff around without actually making me go off. One of the times I didn't have the kill, I didn't even have infinite mana. I won that round because my opponent conceded early.

To be fair, I had some draw power in the field and I would most likely have gotten there. But I don't know if I would have gotten there. Neither did my opponent. The deck bricks sometimes. There are times when you draw 10 lands straight, brick and die. Allow your opponent to brick and die.

Honorable mention) Stony Silence.

Just kidding, the combo of having 2 mana, one of them white, and casting Stony Silence isn't complex enough to fuck it up. This is the one thing you are doing correctly against KCI. Congratulations!


r/spikes • • Nov 14 '17

Frontier [Frontier] UOL S2 Top 8 and S3 Preseason

3 Upvotes

Hello, r/spikes! My reddit name is AwakenedSomnus, but I am more commonly known around the online Frontier community as Somnus21. I am an active online Frontier player, and I find the most success competitively with my own brews.

On the last season (Season 2) of the Untap Open League, currently the largest of Frontier’s online circuits, I wanted to go for a linear, aggressive deck that would dodge most hate people I expected people to bring. Dark Atarka is undoubtedly the best pure aggro deck in the format, but I didn’t want to go that direction in a world where people are bringing 3-mana sweepers to the table at a regular basis.

I ended up registering this deck, which I call Shrapnel Red.


Decklist


Lands

  • 4 Bloodstained Mire

  • 4 Wooded Foothills

  • 4 Ramunap Ruins

  • 4 Darksteel Citadel

  • 7 Mountain

  • 1 Smoldering Marsh

Spells

  • 4 Bomat Courier

  • 4 Monastery Swiftspear

  • 4 Earthshaker Khenra

  • 4 Scrapheap Scrounger

  • 4 Hazoret the Fervent

  • 4 Smuggler’s Copter

  • 4 Wild Slash

  • 4 Lightning Strike

  • 4 Shrapnel Blast

Sideboard

  • 4 Exquisite Firecraft

  • 2 Kari Zev’s Expertise

  • 3 Chandra, Torch of Defiance

  • 2 Smash to Smithereens

  • 4 Sweltering Suns


Since I have lots to discuss, I won’t go in-depth into this deck, I will say however that it worked very well, letting me finish off with a 4-1-1 record in the Swiss, losing only Round 5 to Bant Humans off Dromoka’s Command being a hard counter to my deck, and drawing into Top 8 lock with another Bant player. I would also end up leaving the Top 8 gauntlet early off some bad draws against UB Control, which I feel is a 50-50 matchup for this deck.

The deck is good, but I wouldn’t run it into the meta for Season 3, which is expected to be chock-full of Bant decks.

So for this season, a lot of us organized into testing teams for the Untap Open League’s Season 3.

I decided to form Team Cockatrice, named after the platform we first played in. It had most of the consistent performers from the Cockatrice League that wanted to test for the UOL. Our timezones just never really meshed perfectly, and instead of looking for a definitive best deck, we ended up resorting to just helping each other refine our brews. I’m not quite ready to share what I’m locking in just yet, but I can share the best of what we were able to create.

First off, is what we almost locked in on.


Decklist


4c CoCo Humans

Lands

  • 4 Flooded Strand

  • 4 Windswept Heath

  • 2 Polluted Delta

  • 2 Canopy Vista

  • 1 Sunken Hollow

  • 2 Prairie Stream

  • 2 Plains

  • 1 Island

  • 1 Forest

  • 1 Swamp

  • 2 Blooming Marsh

  • 2 Concealed Courtyard

  • 1 Unclaimed Territory

Spells

  • 4 Thalia’s Lieutenant

  • 4 Glory-Bound Initiate

  • 4 Kitesail Freebooter

  • 3 Renegade Rallier

  • 4 Reflector Mage

  • 2 Duskwatch Recruiter

  • 2 Thalia, Heretic Cathar

  • 2 Anafenza, the Foremost

  • 4 Fatal Push

  • 2 Dromoka’s Command

  • 4 Collected Company

Sideboard

  • 2 Tireless Tracker

  • 2 Archangel Avacyn

  • 2 Arashin Cleric

  • 2 Shapers’ Sanctuary

  • 2 Solemnity

  • 2 Spell Pierce

  • 1 Dispel

  • 2 Dromoka’s Command


This is basically a Bant Humans deck that splashes into black for Kitesail, Anafenza, and Push. It completely demolishes Atarka Red variants, which is always going to be an important matchup for any deck. Plays like exerting Glory-Bound Initiate then using Dromoka’s Command to fight one of their creatures is already ten points of lifegain that’s doable as early as Turn 3.

It’s definitely up there with the best of Frontier decks, but it does have one problem matchup in UBx Control, and no amount of SB help has made that matchup favorable. We tried Spell Quellers, Negates, and some other things I’m humiliated for even considering, and all of them largely just made Game 2 even. It’s power level is very high though, so if you’re looking for a deck with raw power, this is a great choice.

Next, we have a deck built around the concept: What if we could cast Dig Through Time on Turn 3?


Decklist


Sultai Wayfinder Control

Creatures

  • 4 Satyr Wayfinder

  • 3 Torrential Gearhulk

  • 2 The Scarab God

Spells

  • 2 Search for Azcanta

  • 4 Fatal Push

  • 2 Grasp of Darkness

  • 2 Disallow

  • 2 Vraska’s Contempt

  • 4 Dig Through Time

  • 2 Hieroglyphic Illumination

  • 2 Sultai Charm

  • 3 Liliana, the Last Hope

  • 3 Languish

Lands

  • 4 Polluted Delta

  • 4 Bloodstained Mire

  • 4 Flooded Strand

  • 2 Swamp

  • 2 Island

  • 1 Cinder Glade

  • 1 Canopy Vista

  • 3 Blooming Marsh

  • 1 Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth

  • 1 Lumbering Falls

  • 2 Sunken Hollow

Sideboard

  • 1 Tormod’s Crypt

  • 1 Dragonlord Silumgar

  • 3 Gifted Aetherborn

  • 2 Sultai Charm

  • 2 Negate

  • 2 Disdainful Stroke

  • 2 Transgress the Mind

  • 1 Crux of Fate

  • 1 Painful Truths


Taking some inspiration from Gerard Fabiano’s Sultai Control list from Theros-Khans Standard, this deck is using Satyr Wayfinder as a justification to run less lands, and as a Delve enabler. Lumbering Falls is a control mirror-breaker; I’ve had games vs. Grixis where they were able to resolve two Dig Through Times and still weren’t able to beat it. UB Control is one of the pillars of the format, and being able to get an edge in the Dig battle in any way is great.

It is not without its drawbacks though, as Sultai’s manabase for a Control deck like this is just barely passable. This deck is far from refined; I could definitely see myself making a lot of tweaks in the numbers here and there if I do choose to play it, but I can definitely see it being good enough to win a lot of matches, with enough tuning.

Next up, we have a deck that I first had success with, taking a 3rd place finish in the Cockatrice League’s Season 1.


Decklist


Marvelli

Lands

  • 4 Aether Hub

  • 4 Botanical Sanctum

  • 3 Inspiring Vantage

  • 2 Spirebluff Canal

  • 5 Forest

  • 1 Island

  • 1 Mountain

  • 1 Plains

Creatures

  • 2 Reflector Mage

  • 4 Servant of the Conduit

  • 4 Felidar Guardian

  • 4 Rogue Refiner

  • 3 Emrakul, the Promised End

Spells

  • 2 Grapple with the Past

  • 4 Harnessed Lightning

  • 4 Attune with Aether

  • 4 Saheeli Rai

  • 4 Aetherworks Marvel

  • 4 Woodweaver’s Puzzleknot

Sideboard

  • 3 Kozilek’s Return

  • 2 Naturalize

  • 3 Negate

  • 4 Bristling Hydra

  • 2 The Scarab God

  • 1 Swamp


The main draw to Marvelli over a more consistent one-combo deck is to make hating your deck out very difficult. The deck is very hard to play, and requires a lot of practice, particularly in its sideboarding. It has a plethora of effective plans, it’s just up to you to decide which one works best for that given game, be it Marvelli, Saheeli, Marvel, or even fair 4c Midrange.

Most of my teammates decided to get off it since the time we had to learn the deck was highly limited, and the disparity in experience with the deck just showed in our testing. I might play it though, who knows?

Next is a deck that’s a modification of a deck I worked on with u/loopholbrook from way back before Season 2 even started:


Decklist


Temur Black

Creatures

  • 4 Rogue Refiner

  • 3 Bristling Hydra

  • 2 The Scarab God

  • 4 Longtusk Cub

  • 4 Servant of the Conduit

  • 4 Savage Knuckleblade

  • 2 Glint-Sleeve Siphoner

Spells

  • 2 Harnessed Lightning

  • 1 Kolaghan’s Command

  • 3 Stubborn Denial

  • 4 Fatal Push

  • 4 Attune with Aether

Lands

  • 4 Blooming Marsh

  • 4 Spirebluff Canal

  • 4 Botanical Sanctum

  • 4 Aether Hub

  • 2 Forest

  • 1 Island

  • 2 Swamp

  • 2 Mountain

Sideboard

  • 1 Carnage Tyrant

  • 4 Deathgorge Scavenger

  • 1 Kolaghan’s Command

  • 2 Harnessed Lightning

  • 1 Stubborn Denial

  • 3 Radiant Flames

  • 3 Duress


Temur Black is probably a familiar deck to most Standard players right now, but surprisingly, it has yet to make it big in Frontier. This deck is your quintessential example of an midrange-aggro deck. It often wants to go aggressive, but it does have the tools to grind it out, with cards like Glint-Sleeve Siphoner and The Scarab God.

The most exciting additions to the deck are Stubborn Denial and Kolaghan’s Command, which have near-singlehandedly made the control matchup highly favorable. This is a powerful deck, but it might struggle with Atarka Red variants Game 1.

The last list for today is a deck that u/Acc95 put most of the work into:


Decklist


Grixis Control

Creatures

  • 3 Torrential Gearhulk

  • 1 Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet

  • 1 The Scarab God

Spells

  • 2 Grasp of Darkness

  • 4 Fatal Push

  • 2 Disallow

  • 3 Kolaghan’s Command

  • 4 Dig Through Time

  • 2 Abrade

  • 2 Kozilek’s Return

  • 2 Vraska’s Contempt

  • 4 Anticipate

  • 2 Liliana, the Last Hope

  • 2 Languish

Lands

  • 4 Bloodstained Mire

  • 4 Polluted Delta

  • 3 Sunken Hollow

  • 1 Smoldering Marsh

  • 4 Wandering Fumarole

  • 3 Island

  • 2 Swamp

  • 1 Mountain

  • 4 Drowned Catacomb

Sideboard

  • 1 Sphinx of the Final Word

  • 2 Search for Azcanta

  • 2 Negate

  • 2 Dispel

  • 2 Disdainful Stroke

  • 2 Lost Legacy

  • 2 Collective Brutality

  • 2 Crux of Fate


Again, UB Control is one of the format’s pillar strategies, leveraging effective removal with the power of Dig Through Time and Torrential Gearhulk to find success. Acc’s deck stays true to that plan, now adding the power of cards like Abrade and Kolaghan’s Command to its arsenal. While the mana becomes less consistent than that of straight UB’s, though not by much, the tools we get from the splash are definitely worth it.

These are just some of the brews that we’ve made, however, and everyone else in my team may or may not be bringing one of these; even I don’t know. It’s been a fun experience, and I think that while the preseason did not go as planned, it went well enough.

If you read through this whole thing, thank you for your time! If you want to join the Untap Open League’s 3rd season, it’s not too late! Signups close November 15th (midnight.) Click the link for more info: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeVc-bjDfSxlmWR-w80r1mHyaEq6E05KscV5kHQJOqCgYbj5A/viewform?usp=send_form

This has been Somnus21, team captain of Team Cockatrice, signing off.