r/Songwriting • u/aaron_thevirgin • May 24 '20
r/Songwriting
•
u/rosstennev
•
Nov 05 '24
Discussion Do songs need to be deep, to be good?
I recently came across this post that said Songs don't need to be deep or have meaning, to be good., and I thought: "Yeah, sounds about right." But then I thought on the matter of how can a song not be about anything whatsoever, for it to "not have meaning". Is "meaning" defined only by serious "real life" matters? What do you think?
r/Songwriting
•
u/RainMcMey
•
Oct 30 '25
Feedback Request Very interested to hear how you think these lyrics land :)
I’m always controversial but this one plays with fire for a minute there.
r/Songwriting
•
u/Normal_Cellist9383
•
Jun 21 '25
Feedback Request Wrote this one this morning. Too fucked up sounding? Or is it kinda catchy in a weird way? Thanks!
r/Songwriting • u/r3art • Jan 10 '25
Discussion Starting to hate all the "I'm a genius, but can't write a single song"-posts here
Every. fucking. day. We get five of these posts here on this sub:
"I have soooo many ideas in my HEAD, I've written fifteen full operas in my mind, but when I try to record them, my mind goes suddenly blank. What is a DAW?!? Anyway, I don't play any instruments, but my music is fucking amazing. Maybe anyone can help me produce and write it? You will maybe get a shared credit :)!!"
I think it shows that people have been massively deluded about writing and producing music. It's a fucking skill. Inspiration and ideas are less than 10% of the thing.
I'd go even further and say that ideas are completely irrelevant. I can have 20 great ideas a day and it's not even worth talking about them. Music is about recording and capturing these ideas. About getting good with tools and instruments. It takes a LOT of practice. Years and years.
Forget inspiration, ideas, genius and cliche shit stuff like that. It has been the popular narrative that art comes from fragile and troubled highly skilled natural gifted masterminds that are difficult and can lose it anytime and even if some of this is certainly true, we artists buy into that way to much and then we tend to think that we are misunderstood geniuses or something like that. We don't need to practice. We don't need any skills. We don't need to write 100 bad songs to get a good one. We are artists after all.
Well: We're not. Work your ass off every. single. day. You might write something good one day.
r/Songwriting • u/helicopter_momm • Jan 27 '25
Discussion This made me scared for the future of music
On my search for musicians to collab with, I reached out to a friend of mine who’s husband is a producer. She tells me (very excitedly) that “he is about to release his best album yet. His past albums haven’t been good enough to go mainstream but he discovered an amazing platform where you just input what you want the song to be about, sound like, and a few key words and AI creates an amazing song for you”
My immediate response was “that’s weird and scary” She didn’t expect that response because her husband was so excited about his new album, and for some reason this seems normal to her? Am I just old or is this super freaking weird. It’s like saying you’re an artist but you didn’t create the art. I would like to listen to human made music for as long as I’m alive. Is this the future of music? What do you guys think?
Edit: I’ve seen some commenters say this is engagement bait, but unfortunately this actually happened. What I think is his wife doesn’t know this is something you shouldn’t just say, let alone be proud of? Not sure, but this is 100% a true story and I am just as baffled as you are.
r/Songwriting • u/puffy_capacitor • Feb 05 '24
Discussion Three Solutions to Fixing Your Boring Songs
Often several of the reasons why your songs might be boring musically include sticking with default structures and tendencies in writing. Here's some great techniques that David Bennett has covered in some videos and I combined them into a single post that you can implement to help break those habits with popular song examples:
Don't always start your songs on the tonic chord: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jfxFcToSnhQ
Don't always use standard 4 or 8 bar structures in your songs: https://youtu.be/IHulFiTl9dc?si=dJGluLv3fUzj6Fy3
Don't always use the same time signature throughout your songs: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rC3_0K1vGF0
If you look at the most memorable and interesting songs by artists such as The Beatles, Elton John, Paul Simon, Burt Bacharach, and etc, you'll find that many of their songs pack at least two or even all three of those techniques in a single 3 minute song!
r/Songwriting • u/AttiBlack • Mar 03 '26
Discussion Topic You're not an artist if you use AI. You're just a plagiarist.
That's all.
[Edit]
I love watching the people who can't actually write music themselves defend AI as if they're artists with a say. If you use AI, you're not an artist. Therefore, you have no say in what's considered an art tool.
[Edit 2]
For all those saying you use it to bounce ideas off of, I'm a very active user in this sub. I've helped MANY people, new or seasoned writers, write or finish their songs in a way that makes them feel better about it. I've helped teach people how to get inspiration, then format and write their own songs, and how to keep improving. It's not like I'm sitting here as a bum with no experience. If you want someone to help, DM me (no charge ofc). Ask someone on this sub. Find a friend who does music. Because all you're doing with AI is tainting the beautiful soul of the web that intertwines between all of us through art. You're making a sickening mockery of all the blood, sweat, and heart everyone else before and around you put into the beautiful things we have. Just to make meaningless noise for a silly paycheck.
[Edit 3]
Remember that every time you use AI to make your slop instead of making something beautiful on your own through hard work, you're also needlessly contributing to the destruction of our planet and the extinction of countless species. Stop wasting our clean water and our only providers of oxygen so you can ask something that has no soul to make an empty, meaningless song just so you can feel cool and get a paycheck
[Edit 4]
I came across this analogy in the comments and I love it:
If you commission someone to make you a painting, you're not the artist. You just asked them to make you something. AI is the same thing. Except in the end, you're passing it off as your own.
[Edit 5]
Here's a video that describes exactly what AI does for us
r/Songwriting
•
u/WrathPie
•
May 09 '26
Feedback Request "A little longer" - original. Does the riff land?
I spent several years on boats so ocean imagery always gets me.
This one's a lot of fun to play, does it work to listen to as well?
Lyrics in comments. Thanks for listening! <3
r/Songwriting
•
u/Trickledownisbull
•
Feb 04 '26
Discussion Topic The "Magnifying Glass" Lyric Trick
r/Songwriting • u/MOMismypersonality • Nov 10 '25
Discussion Topic My 6 year old wrote a song 🤣 “I’m the color”
Just figured you guys would appreciate the cuteness.
r/Songwriting • u/ElliotSylvie • Aug 27 '21
Discussion Unacceptably Honest Songwriting Pro Tip
r/Songwriting
•
u/tjtate6689
•
Apr 16 '26
Feedback Request dont know what the hell kind of music this is.
usually i can tell a specific style im leaning toward, like i can hear influences but this one just confused me, can you all let me know what this reminds you of? dont know if i like it, just curious.
Edit: specific songs or artists it reminds you of, not just genres
r/Songwriting
•
u/Temporary-Event8681
•
Aug 21 '26
Feedback Request My dad told me that everyone who's said my music is good is just being nice. I can't tell anymore.
It's eroded my ability to maintain any faith in my music or ability. Every time I get on stage I think about it.
Like on a basic philosophical level - I will never be able to tell if people actually like my music. People can say it's good, but people don't ever want to be the one to crush someones dreams; generally people try and be supportive and kind and do good in the world. I feel this way too; I want to help others progress and create because it's a worthwhile endevour.
But often it feels like the kindness others give is just fleeting vapour, the feeling doesn't stick around. Sorry, just kindof having a hard one
Edit: I went to sleep when this had 2 comments. I woke up to it having 222 comments. I am very overwhelmed. I can't really say what it means to me to have such a collective reaction; I feel very humbled and grateful by this. I was not expecting it needless to say. Thank you... thank you I'll be reading over all of them today.
Edit2: Also just to say; the message that many have been bringing forward about not caring what others think and creating for creations sake is landing. It feels like that's a bedrock perspective that needs to be there. Needing validation is a hard thing to avail yourself of; but this has helped me on both fronts.
For those asking for socials I don't have too much up - just one song on bandcamp and a collection of really really rough takes on subvert
here's the bandcamp link: https://wesleyblondin.bandcamp.com/track/oscilium-rough-mix
Here's subvert's: https://www.subvert.fm/wesleyblondin
Lastly I used to be an animator so here's my insta - its got some music in reels if you dig deep enough https://www.instagram.com/kidgrit/?hl=en
I am working on my first album (for the last 5+y) and it's almost done. I've been kind of terrified to put it out and have had a lot of trouble finishing it for that reason. I'll add anyone who's already expressed an interest to my list of friends I was going to reach out to when it was done. Just DM me or leave a comment and I will put you on the sheet.
Edit 3: Lyrics for those who asked or had trouble hearing!
Draw back the curtain
Remember the light
Looks like I survived the winter one more time
Disordered thinking reigns in the cold sun
This year's been totalled, let's rack up another one
The dents in the door recall a day that would impart
A distant, violent, punctuation mark
So with the wreckage of the year now square behind
Please let me focus what's left of my good mind
eke out the last iota of sunshine
Unburdened the sky recedes and leaves behind the day
The blood we buried fades
The coast evaporates
Grief is love - changing its shape
I'll sit by the dividing line
Watch the tide changing it's mind
Water, land are becoming their own
While I wait at the riparian zone
While I wait for what's left to completely let go
r/Songwriting
•
u/tjtate6689
•
Dec 02 '25
Feedback Request Is this to dark?
TOO* listening to blues lately and wanted to put a spin on it, thought it might have came out too dramatic, but also thought the hook was kinda cool. also ive gotten some comments my intros are too long, i thought this one needed a longer intro to set a vibe but maybe it doesnt. lmkwyt 🙏
r/Songwriting • u/ThisIsHarlie • Oct 15 '21