Edit: To be clear, I am not a lyricist or make songs with lyrics, nor i plan to become one.
So a lot of justifications in using AI music is when they're "lyricists". They come up with the lyrics and feed it into AI so they can turn it into a song. But does that really make you a lyricist or you're just a poem writer, or something like a sonnet writer instead? Because you can write almost any words feed it into AI and AI will sing it for you.
What really makes someone a lyricist is that if they align the words with the song, and if they are actually the ones who did it not the composer of the song like adjusting to the melodies. Otherwise, the composer is the real lyricist if they're the ones who align the words with the melodies, or if they adjust the melodies accordingly to the words, even if they're not the ones who wrote the words.
Justifying the use of AI for the words they wrote blurs what lyricists are really all about. It's the AI that does all the adjustment. It's easy to pretend about doing all or most of the work, but we all know that AI is doing it completely without human authorship.
So if anyone decides to turn this thread into a song, does that make all of us lyricists?
If it just relies on technical loophole, by just going with its actual definition, and that's exactly why it's not an honorable title anymore, unlike how it originally was.
Edit 2: Another thing is that, you can make the words and claim to be the lyricist. You get the credit of being the lyricist while you let the composer do all of the adjusting, giving them extra work and they don't get the credit for that. The only get credit for the composing part.
Of course this way of thinking is very deep, but how else do ideologies start in the first place?