I'm a 25 year old singer-songwriter and I've been having an internal crisis for the past 20 years or so: am I really a musician?
I started learning how to play guitar when I was 9 years old to impress a girl. The girl came and went, but for reasons I can't say, I chose to make it my identity and set my life's course upon being a musician. Ever since I was a kid, my goal has been the same: make music for a living and tour the world while selling millions of records. Easy. Lately though, there has been a room (my mind) and a massive, angry elephant in it (the fear that I might not actually be a musician). My whole life I've felt like I have to force music, I hate practicing and when I do practice I don't improve to the level I want. Songwriting has never come naturally to me, nor has playing the guitar or the piano or the banjo or the drums, but I learned them all because it's who I told myself I was. A music guy who made music.
When I see rising artists, there is always something special about them. They have some factor about them that just "hits". Some innate quality that makes it clear they were born for this. Some examples being Joe P, Annika Bennett, Joel Ansett, as well as artists who have already rocketed to stardom like Shakey Graves and Declan McKenna but who started out in the same boat. Anyone, in fact, who "makes it" has that inexplicable quality. I'm in crisis because I don't think I have that quality. The songs I write are medicore at best, unoriginal, and no matter how hard I try to articulate my innermost emotions it all comes out sounding like every other song ever written. It makes me wonder, have I ever had an original thought? Am I not feeling things as deeply as these other musicians are? Is there something wrong with me? And the same goes for writing music, I have never written a hook that was so catchy that it got stuck in my own head. I've been writing for almost 15 years, and not once has it happened. Nobody around me really seems to have much enthusiasm for the music I decide to share, which confirms my fears. I'm worried I've wasted so much time and energy on something that, no matter how hard I try, I'll never succeed at. Has anyone else felt this way?Is it all in my head? And if so, how do I get that hit quality when it doesn't come naturally to me?
TL;DR - Songwriting and performing don't come naturally to me at all and my music sucks. I'm worried that natural talent is a requirement for success that I don't meet, am I wrong?