r/Songwriting • • Aug 27 '26

Discussion Topic So many posts in this sub with the entirely wrong idea

28 Upvotes

Lyrics are not a song. Lyrics by themselves are really basically nothing. If you are spending time in your day writing disembodied words that are meant to later go with music, you're really selling yourself short. I would challenge anybody in this sub to take the opposite approach. Write music, and then if lyrics are required, write them.

There should be many posts in this sub that say "I've written this song, what should the words be, or does it even need words?", rather than, "I've written these words, what should the song be?", which is what I typically see. Not attempting to be mean spirited but if you guys really do want to advance in making music you need to get away from the idea that song lyrics really mean anything without a song.


r/Songwriting • • Sep 25 '25

Feedback Request Silenced By A Bullet (about the aftermath of Charlie Kirk’s murder)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

I posted this song in here with a title indicating it wasn’t done. Because it wasn’t. I’m still not sure if it’s done. I don’t think I’ve ever written a song that I felt was completely done. They eventually just get recorded and abandoned

But I reworked some lyrics to tighten it up. I don’t know about you, but that part takes me the longest. The editing. I know not everybody shares this opinion, but for me, getting a song down to as few syllables as possible while still retaining the original meaning is important. It just makes it sing easier.

I absolutely despise the American chaos that results in losing more rights every day. Resist that.

Also, try not to record your songs in the garage.


r/Songwriting • • Feb 19 '25

Need Feedback A very quick expression of love to my trans friends, an expression of hate to the President

0 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • Mar 28 '25

Need Feedback No DEI NSFW

4 Upvotes

I wrote this back in January when Trump started banning DEI programmes.

I'm not interested in debating the topic here, but would love feedback to help me become a better songwriter.

No ambitions, just exploring a new hobby!

https://recorder.google.com/63b8008f-209c-4c2e-887b-341a53a49606


r/Songwriting • • Jun 01 '25

Question / Discussion AI just gave me my voice back.

27 Upvotes

I posted this song here the other day but was so frustrated with how hard it’s been trying to sing. Suno has this new “cover” feature. I just uploaded my track and it fixed all the performance issues so I could actually hear what I’ve been trying to write.

If you are a writer first and a musician second, you need to know this tool exists. If nothing else, it helps me hear what the actual issues are vs my own limitations.

I plan on uploading stems to logic and replacing vocals with my own once I’m feeling better but holy cow this is such a big step.


r/Songwriting • • Jun 17 '25 Heartwarming

Feedback Request How do I make a song emotional but still retain a hint of optimism?

6 Upvotes

I wrote this song from the perspective of an immigrant taken from their family and being deported. Where all that person wants is a better life for their family that stays. I put it into words where the person being taken doesn’t want their family to feel sad that they are being taken and must fend for themselves but instead should be optimistic even without the family member. I decided to include one of my favorite movies in the lyrics “under the same moon” because that movie really helped me understand the helplessness of this situation and how all people want is a better life for their family.

I tried to make it sound sad but lyrically be hopeful where you will never be apart from each other despite being a ways away from each other.

Did I convey this emotion or not? How can I convey this more to listeners and make it emotional that someone may be gone but hopeful that one day we’ll meet again?


r/Songwriting • • Sep 21 '25

Feedback Request “1776-2025 (it was nice while it lasted)”

0 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • Feb 04 '25

Need Feedback “Fascist Pig (Elon)”

67 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • Aug 17 '25

Feedback Request “There ain’t no MAGA hats in heaven”

59 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • Sep 11 '25

Feedback Request In His Name (a song about Christian Nationalism)

2 Upvotes

I wrote and posted this the other week, but I thought it would be good to get some feedback in light of yesterday’s events. Maybe looking at some things, lyrically, from a different perspective could improve it. I like the song how it is, but we can always grow. Musically, it will most likely be full band. I don’t have anything set in stone there. If you hear something, let me know what it is.


r/Songwriting • • Apr 03 '25

Need Feedback Take your Tesla to the scrapyard

0 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • Jul 23 '25

Discussion Topic Hey Eden here: You're not bad, you just don't know how to write songs.

22 Upvotes

Honestly, I'm tired of everyone acting like songwriting is some magical process, Just intuitive, when in reality there is a technique for it. Guys, writing songs is a skill to be learned, not simply a gift. Some people can write songs easily and others will have more difficulties but the result will always be the same, so if today you can't write your own lyrics the problem isn't a lack of gift or intuition, Maybe you just don't know how to write good songs. A few months ago I couldn't write a complete song, I started writing the chorus but I got stuck on the verses, after I started studying more references to understand how they wrote songs nowadays I write complete songs every day, so there is no secret if you can't write songs it's because you simply don't know how so you need to learn.


r/Songwriting • • Aug 06 '24

Discussion Stop writing about your life…

0 Upvotes

… and expand your imagination. Seriously, every song about a relationship is the same as every other. Write about an imaginary relationship like Steely Dan does (“Haitian Divorce”), like Elvis Costello does (“Allison”), like dozens of great songwriters. Write about some interesting fact you learned: when Paul McCartney learned that Americans called parking enforcers “meter maids,” he wrote about an imaginary meter maid. You can write about anything that captures your attention. Reference They Might Be Giants for two writers who can spin lyrics out of virtually anything.

I’m trying hard to learn how to write little musical short stories about imaginary people (not cheesy ones like “The Gambler,” really nice ones like “Brick” by Ben Folds). It turns out your feelings will come out whatever you write.


r/Songwriting • • Sep 04 '25

Feedback Request “Hey ICE Man (what are you doing in my town?)

0 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • Mar 03 '25

Discussion Politics in music (update)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

I posted a couple of weeks back regarding politics in songs. With everything going on in the world right now I find it difficult to think/write about much else.

My latest song is my most political/direct ever by far. I would be really interested to hear what people think, if this is too strong for some, or if you think the world needs more of this kind of material…


r/Songwriting • • Mar 30 '24

Discussion Am I really a musician?

1 Upvotes

I'm a 25 year old singer-songwriter and I've been having an internal crisis for the past 20 years or so: am I really a musician?

I started learning how to play guitar when I was 9 years old to impress a girl. The girl came and went, but for reasons I can't say, I chose to make it my identity and set my life's course upon being a musician. Ever since I was a kid, my goal has been the same: make music for a living and tour the world while selling millions of records. Easy. Lately though, there has been a room (my mind) and a massive, angry elephant in it (the fear that I might not actually be a musician). My whole life I've felt like I have to force music, I hate practicing and when I do practice I don't improve to the level I want. Songwriting has never come naturally to me, nor has playing the guitar or the piano or the banjo or the drums, but I learned them all because it's who I told myself I was. A music guy who made music.

When I see rising artists, there is always something special about them. They have some factor about them that just "hits". Some innate quality that makes it clear they were born for this. Some examples being Joe P, Annika Bennett, Joel Ansett, as well as artists who have already rocketed to stardom like Shakey Graves and Declan McKenna but who started out in the same boat. Anyone, in fact, who "makes it" has that inexplicable quality. I'm in crisis because I don't think I have that quality. The songs I write are medicore at best, unoriginal, and no matter how hard I try to articulate my innermost emotions it all comes out sounding like every other song ever written. It makes me wonder, have I ever had an original thought? Am I not feeling things as deeply as these other musicians are? Is there something wrong with me? And the same goes for writing music, I have never written a hook that was so catchy that it got stuck in my own head. I've been writing for almost 15 years, and not once has it happened. Nobody around me really seems to have much enthusiasm for the music I decide to share, which confirms my fears. I'm worried I've wasted so much time and energy on something that, no matter how hard I try, I'll never succeed at. Has anyone else felt this way?Is it all in my head? And if so, how do I get that hit quality when it doesn't come naturally to me?

TL;DR - Songwriting and performing don't come naturally to me at all and my music sucks. I'm worried that natural talent is a requirement for success that I don't meet, am I wrong?


r/Songwriting • • Mar 05 '25

Need Feedback “The drooling masses drowning in their drool” a song about conservatives

0 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • Feb 25 '25

Question I Can't Write Bad Songs.

2 Upvotes

I was an on-and-off writer between June and December. What made me repeatedly stop and come back before stopping for 2 months and counting is being too critical of myself. Before I got started, I read stuff about the number of bad songs you write before you write your first good one and similar things. However, I completed 2 songs in my time as a writer that I think are good... but that's not a good thing bc it took so much out of me to write them. When writing, I'd tell myself, "It's okay if this isn't good; you can rewrite when you're more experienced." And I only SORTA listened to myself. I would accept okay lyrics, but not bad ones. I'd constantly hit roadblocks where I tried to think of how to continue a song and I'd brainstorm so many lyrics I thought were bad and shoot them down. It made the process feel like work and I wouldn't write for days because I didn't want to go through that stress again and that repeatedly led to not writing for weeks.

I first wanted to become a writer and eventually learn singing, production, etc. until I became an artist after really getting into music in the beginning of last year, but my relationship with music became more casual and I changed my mind. But now I'm back to the level of appreciation for it that I was at before and I want to give writing and the whole music thing another go, but I'm just paralyzed with the fear of the stress. I was also reading a few songwriting books and I forgot most of what I learned from them and I don't want to have to re-read. I just don't understand how you can create something you don't like and be okay with it. How do I change my mindset?


r/Songwriting • • Mar 15 '25

Discussion Downvoting without feedback

21 Upvotes

I posted a song on here once asking for feedback, and I didn’t get any but I did get downvoted. It’s something I see a lot on this sub, people will post their songs and will get downvoted without any sort of feedback. It makes me not want to share my work or ask for feedback on here. Maybe I am missing something and those posts don’t follow the sub rules or format or something, but I don’t think this sub should be about “if the song is good upvote if it’s bad downvote” if someone is posting and asking for feedback. We’re all songwriters trying to improve our craft here so I don’t see the point in just downvoting a song because you don’t like it. You write 100 bad songs before you write a good one, right??

If you downvote in here without commenting is there something I’m missing? Is it because people don’t follow the sub rules or just because you think the song is bad?


r/Songwriting • • Mar 07 '26

Discussion Topic No matter how much I like you or your music, I will *never* click a #Spotify link.

3 Upvotes

And I'm not the only one who feels this way.

Worth thinking about when sharing.


r/Songwriting • • Feb 11 '25

Need Feedback “i’m a loser”

33 Upvotes

i posted a more incomplete version of this song, but this take is more polished and i added and changed some lyrics :)


r/Songwriting • • Apr 09 '26

Discussion Topic Day 20 of 30 | I challenged myself to record one topline every day

0 Upvotes

I’m a French artist making R&B, Rap/Hip-hop in English.

I realized I needed to get more consistent with my music,

so I started this 30-day challenge.

Just focusing on getting better, one topline at a time.

Day 20


r/Songwriting • • Dec 08 '19

Let's Discuss Friend recently texted me this. Need help with writing lyrics if anyone is interested.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • Oct 25 '23

Need Feedback Tried for something political.

0 Upvotes

Not sure if the idea is fully communicated.