r/shakespeare • u/C0llinFl3tch3r • May 06 '24
Unpopular opinion: the DiCaprio R&J movie is terrible
Most of my classmates disagree, but I will always stand by this. I think they butchered a great piece of Shakespeare. Thoughts?
r/shakespeare • u/C0llinFl3tch3r • May 06 '24
Most of my classmates disagree, but I will always stand by this. I think they butchered a great piece of Shakespeare. Thoughts?
r/shakespeare • u/lethal_universed • Sep 11 '26
Mcbeth famous line " It is a tale Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, Signifying nothing." didn't mean much to me as a 15 yr old reading it for my english class. I assumed the meaning was the same as today, a stupid person. However, when I got older, I learned that "idiot" used to be a medical term for the mentally disabled, which was turned into a slur and then became common usage. One can easily draw the comparison to the r-word, which isn't fully at the common state (though many are trying).
Obviously, as someone with a nonverbal autstic brother with high support needs, this revelation sent a chill done my spine. A lot of the media, particularly older media like the Three Stooges, which used idiot had more nefarious intentions than I thought. Especially considering the prominence of eugenics in that era. But truly what gets me is the lack of literature and commentary on this than, say, on sexism in classics. Its a complete blindspot in criticism, probably due to the lack of those affected by mental disability being present in academics.
But I digress, back to Shakespeare, I wonder if this meaning holds true? After all, idiot used to mean a private person and by the 19th century became a medical diagnosis as far as I'm aware. Its easy to handwave this off as "politically incorrect villain", but I ran across this article detailing sterotypes of intellectual disability presented in a different character from a different shakespeare play https://doi.org/10.18061/dsq.v40i4.6903. There was another thread about it here, but I couldn't exactly parse it. So, in short, i'm intersted in understanding what the elizabeathen perspective of "an idiot" was and what Shakespeare thought of using it alongside his beliefs on (mental) disability.
r/shakespeare • u/TreeKnockRa • Mar 29 '26
Comparing the previous edition of Julius Caesar to the new one, they removed most of the footnotes and shortened the introduction. It's totally destroyed.
r/shakespeare • u/Legal-Highlight-3400 • Nov 27 '22
I've seen this post circulating for a bit and thought what a cool theory. However, I'm not entirely sure whether there's any proof. Does anyone know any scenes where this is applicable?
EDIT: Even if interpretations of literature are not 'correct' I still believe there is value in understanding others' perspectives. For those who are more purist with the texts, I am not stating that any character is homosexual/bisexual. I'm merely curious as to WHY some people have this interpretation. What is it about these characters gives a gay vibe? I suppose it's what we might now call queer coding but of course wasn't prevalent during Shakespeare's time in quite the same way, if at all. So if you don't see it, that's fair. I currently don't either. However, the whole play has a lot of undertones that resonate with queer audiences. What I'm really asking is if it does resonate with you, why does it?

r/shakespeare • u/sodabad4bones_ • Jul 21 '26
r/shakespeare • u/xbrooksie • Jul 14 '24
This is a very genuine question. I just read Othello for the first time and I see a lot of love for older movies with a white actor playing Othello in blackface, with several people calling Welles’ Othello, for instance, a perfect adaptation.
Personally, I believe blackface is abhorrent and while I recognize that it was much more acceptable in the past then it is now, I guess I just want to understand why people are so lenient about it when it comes to Shakespeare. I do not believe, for instance, that a “perfect” adaptation or even a great one can include unironic blackface.
r/shakespeare • u/cedlev • Jan 25 '14
r/shakespeare • u/Greedy_Bed8753 • Nov 18 '25
I would like to know what Shakespeare readers think about his relationship with queerness, since in many of his works we can find characters who are clearly homosexual, bisexual, ...And of course mention the whole topic of cross-dressing! What characters do you think are queer-coded? Do you think Shakespeare himself was homosexual or bisexual? Also, with the example of Ariel, we can even see fluid genre representation. To give a few examples, here are some characters that I think are queer-coded: Mercutio, Benvolio, Antonio (The merchant of Venice and Twelfth night), Bassanio, Orsino, Olivia, Horatio, Richard II, Orlando ...What do you think about all this?
r/shakespeare • u/Consistent-Bear4200 • Mar 22 '24
I've seen a lot of the gender/queer characters that could be encoded as such. Usually supernatural characters like the witches in Macbeth (described as bearded by referred to as she), the fairies of midsummer speaking in Troche, Ariel perhaps even being in unrequited love with Prospero. I've even heard writings suggest Iago is gay and is jealousy over Desdamona is secretly what drives the plot.
However if Shakespeare were gay or bi, he probably knew that. Things like autism were not really concepts in his time, though that doesn't necessarily mean Shakespeare couldn't write about them. I remember Simon Russell being interviewed when he played Lear and finding a medical journal that discussed how Lear's breakdown adheres to certain types of dementia.
Of course dementia existed back then, we just didn't have the understanding of it that we do now. It is quite possible that Shakespeare observed people who went through this and chose to write about it with Lear. Even if he didn't know what it was he could still chime into as something humans have always been experiencing.
But what about neurodiversity? As an autistic person, I've noticed a lot of contemporary works that seem encoded accidentally. As if neurotypical writers have based characters on people they knew, without realising they were on the spectrum for example. Abed from the show community was simply based on the writer Dan Harmon, but got such a response from the fans Harmon began looking into whether he was autistic?
Does anyone in Shakespeare stand out in this way? I appreciate the subjectivity these choices could hold, I just wanted to know if they were any likely contenders in people's eyes.
r/shakespeare • u/[deleted] • Sep 06 '24
Interesting doesn't necessarily have to mean good, mind you.
r/shakespeare • u/junelikes_cats • Feb 13 '24
I'm supposed to write an essay tomorrow on who's the most to blame for Romeo and Juliet's death and I wanted to be different by picking the families instead of Friar Lawrence. I need 3 specific reasons but all I'm finding and thinking of is the hatred between the families. If anyone could help I'd appreciate it!
r/shakespeare • u/femboycable • Jul 18 '24
I was reading the venus and adonis sonnet, and i noticed it said was written for a guy. Please don't give me hate for this, I might be wrong and I'm only just getting into shakespeare so please be nice
r/shakespeare • u/Any_Clue_1632 • Jan 28 '24
I need resources for conversations around decolonializing Shakespeare. Looking to start a Shakespeare in the park in a majority minority city.
r/shakespeare • u/Soggy_Spinach_7503 • Jun 13 '25
Wanted to post this while the thoughts are fresh in my head from the play I saw last night. The first part of the play before it shifts to Bohemia is nearly perfect, but after that it turns to a bit of a confusing disaster. Here are some of the things I thought it needed:
- Develop the relationship between Polixenes and his son. Have Polixenes be concerned about his son marrying for love since it was love that caused his friend Leontes' huge jealousy. That would make the opposition to his son's marriage make more sense (perhaps I didn't understand Polixenes opposition).
- Change the setting to either ancient Greece or a polytheistic country where the opinion of an "oracle" would be relevant.
- Make the discovery that Perdita is Leontes' daughter more dramatic. How it was just explained by some townspeople was very anti-climatic.
- Get rid of the statue scene. I understand WS was going for a happy ending, but there needed to be some consequences for Leontes' actions. It made even worse by the fact that Paulina lost her husband, who died doing the heroic thing saving baby Perdita's life.
This was my first introduction to A Winter's Tale so if my opinions are off base, let me know.
r/shakespeare • u/[deleted] • Jun 06 '24
Anyone else feels that the entire history plays reminds them of the MCU/Star Wars?
A multi-generational franchise with two warring factions with recurring supporting characters . Starts with King John and ends with Henry VIII. Plus you have The Merry Wives Of Windsor as a "spin-off".
r/shakespeare • u/Crok_Valkyrie • Dec 07 '23
Not even all of Neptune’s oceans could wash that thing
r/shakespeare • u/im_a_silly_lil_guy • Mar 10 '26
Macbeth: haha dumbass no man born from a woman can kill me
Macduff: I WAS C-SECTION BIIIIIIIIITTTTTTCCCCCCCCHHHHHHH
r/shakespeare • u/TriedUsingTurpentine • Oct 26 '23
I have a long standing personal theory...not scholarly in any way, just a hunch...that "To Be Or Not To Be" was not written for Hamlet. Just like a Broadway composer will pull an old song out of a drawer to stick in a libretto it wasn't written for because he was looking for a place to use it, or whatever.
Why?
1)It's the only soliloquy in the play that makes absolutely no mention of the events of the play. This has probably contributed to its broad fame, as not needing to know anything at all about Hamlet to appreciate increases its accessibility removed from its context.
2)The doubt Hamlet expresses about death makes no sense. He calls it "the undiscovered country from whose bourne no traveler returns." Really? Someone returned from death two acts earlier and spoke at length to Hamlet! He talks about the possibility of oblivion as an end to all suffering (and by a sleep to say we end the heartache, etc.), but then acknowledges that the POSSIBILITY of an afterlife that will be worse ("What dreams may come")is the "respect that makes calamity of so long life." Why would Hamlet think that oblivion vs. afterlife is even a question???? He knows that the afterlife is real! He knows that it is at least potentially full of suffering because his father is splitting time between haunting Elsinore and being tortured in Purgatory. (There's a similar moment where he's talking about Old Hamlet's fate in the hereafter and he says "who knows how his audit stands?" and I always want to shout "YOU! YOU KNOW HOW HIS AUDIT STANDS!!)
Now, as a poem, something like a Tennysonian dramatic monologue, the speech itself is full of profound truth, in my opinion poetic expression of the highest form. BUT in the dramatic context of the play itself, either q2 or F, it is borderline nonsensical.
You know what actually does make slightly more sense, at least given what has happened in the play? The speech as it is written in Q1...
To be, or not to be; ay, there's the point./To die, to sleep—is that all?/ Ay, all.No, to sleep, to dream—ay, marry, there it goes,/For in that dream of death, when we awake,/And borne before an everlasting judge,/From whence no passenger ever returned,/The undiscovered country, at whose sight/The happy smile and the accursed damned...
Here, the question is not between oblivion or afterlife, which the play has already answered, but a more conventional theological question of ones fate in the afterlife: reward or punishment. Q1 reads "when we awake..." There is no doubt about the existence of the soul or a final judgment: the doubt is simply about "how our audit stands," to paraphrase Hamlet later. Don't get me wrong, I'm not making an argument in favor of the artistic quality of the Q1 text of the speech (it's a mess, clearly a memorial reconstruction or something like it), simply pointing out the irony that it fits the play rather better than its more famous counterpart. (Though it still preserves the by now proven false "undiscovered country" form which no one ever returned bit.)
r/shakespeare • u/goodticklebrain • Jun 12 '26
r/shakespeare • u/yoyodragons • May 05 '24
Has anyone else seen Andrew Scott's (the hot priest from Fleabag) adaptation of Hamlet? He is fine, I guess. He brings a certain absurdism and strangeness to the role which I have always read in the character. But its the play and the narrative structure that I have more of an issue with. The scenes are jumbled and out of order, almost told in a non-linear style. Which to me atleast, seems like experimentalism for its own sake.
Am I the only one who feels this way?
r/shakespeare • u/ChristianPacifist • Jan 15 '24
As a Protestant, who interprets the play through a Protestant lens seeing Shakespeare's aim to criticize certain Catholic views, I definitely view the ghost as a demon that is trying to corrupt Hamlet into wickedness and vengeance.
The fact that the ghost might be a demon is alluded to in Act 2 Scene 2, and even though it speaks truth about the father's murder, this itself could be a scenario whereby a demon weaponizes facts to lead folks down a sinful path, this being revenge and violence of course.
I think it could be argued the ghost is authentically his father, especially a Catholic view seeing the ghost in purgatory legitimately, and I don't think the argument the ghost is a hallucination makes sense given the facts that others see it first.
What is all of your interpretations?