r/SETI • • Aug 26 '21

opinion: aliens would not look like us at all.

246 Upvotes

aliens could be very exotic life. the conditions would be very different, even if it was a rocky planet orbiting an earth-like star. they could be made of different elements. or drink something other than water like ammonia or hydrocarbons. so it makes me go crazy when i hear people thunk that aliens would look like us but with like forehead ridges.


r/SETI • • Oct 18 '21

would aliens use neutrinos instead of radio to communicate?

88 Upvotes

it makes sense wouldn't it? neutrinos are way smaller than photons at radio frequency so the aliens could store more data there.


r/SETI • • Dec 19 '20

Good article in Scientific American about the Proxima Centauri signal (BLC1)

86 Upvotes

“Now, speaking to Scientific American, the scientists behind the discovery caution there is still much work to be done, but admit the interest is justified. ‘It has some particular properties that caused it to pass many of our checks, and we cannot yet explain it,’ says Andrew Siemion from the University of California, Berkeley.”

Also a healthy dose of skepticism, but a reminder that the investigation is on-going.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/alien-hunters-discover-mysterious-signal-from-proxima-centauri/


r/SETI • • Dec 11 '21

The proxima centauri signal.

80 Upvotes

I guess it was recently declared to most likely be human interference. I've read many articles and it doesn't make any sense as to how they could be so sure it's an earthly signal, hoping someone can explain it.
Take this one for instance: https://www.space.com/proxima-centauri-radio-signal-not-aliens-breakthrough-listen

To sum up, they say that it's not aliens, because the signal "resembles a signal created by earthly electronics." Uh, so what? All the other evidence points to it being from proxima. So a signal, apparently from proxima is using technology similar to ours, therefore it isn't from proxima? I don't follow, at all. To me, that sounds like "Well, it looks like they have tech similar to ours on proxima." So it's even more amazing! What did I miss?


r/SETI • • Feb 28 '20

Death of Freeman Dyson

74 Upvotes

r/SETI • • Oct 13 '15

Did Kepler find a Dyson Swarm?

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
65 Upvotes

r/SETI • • Dec 18 '20

Narrow beam radio signal from direction of Proxima Centauri detected by Parkes radio telescope (preliminary report)

63 Upvotes

So this narrow beam radio signal was detected in April/May last year, but is just being reported now. From the direction of Proxima Centauri. Found by Parkes radio telescope in Australia. Paper upcoming. No culprit found yet, but could still/likely be terrestrial interference.

“The latest ‘signal’ is likely to have a mundane explanation too, but the direction of the narrow beam, around 980MHz, and an apparent shift in its frequency said to be consistent with the movement of a planet have added to the tantalising nature of the finding. Scientists are now preparing a paper on the beam, named BLC1, for Breakthrough Listen, the project to search for evidence of life in space, the Guardian understands.”

Interesting! (hoping the reporting here is accurate). 🤔

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/dec/18/scientists-looking-for-aliens-investigate-radio-beam-from-nearby-star


r/SETI • • Dec 23 '20

Really great interview with Jason Wright on the Proxima Candidate BLC1

62 Upvotes

This interview (audio) offers a _lot _ of clarity on the Proxima Candidate BLC1. Almost entirely sticking to the facts but a sprinkling here and there of hope and informed speculation. Have a listen!

https://youtu.be/-OO7JZ14sZM


r/SETI • • Apr 01 '21

SETI gets $100 million from Russian Oligarch

60 Upvotes

r/SETI • • Dec 12 '14

The search for extraterrestrial intelligence, The SETI program, is in dire need of funding. What could Reddit do for SETI?

57 Upvotes

SETI has just resumed operation after it went into hibernation due to funding shortfalls. But looking for life in the universe is a costly endeavor, and they need bigger and better radio telescopes.

The part that I find astonishing is that the entire program costs less than one Apace attack helicopter and it does not receive any funding from the government or NASA. They are financed entirely by private contributions.

My feeling is that most people would support this mission if they had the chance, and they would rather put their tax money into radio telescopes than instruments of war. So what could Reddit do? Or more importantly, what could -you- do? I hope I can spark a debate that will ultimately benefit SETI, but they would benefit even more from a substantial crowd funding effort.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Search_for_extraterrestrial_intelligence

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SETI_Institute

http://www.seti.org/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EszGIvRdgTE Jill Tarter of SETI @ TED 2009

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRkdPhhCdhw Dr. Jill Tarter - Searching for ET: An Investment in Our Long Future

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qXUL8FUlzQo&t=52m23s Jill Tarter talks about funding and being a full time fundraiser.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7tGBg38rzc Jill Tarter's astronomical work is illustrated in Carl Sagan's novel Contact. In the film version of Contact, the protagonist Ellie Arroway is played by Jodie Foster. Tarter conversed with the actress for months before and during filming, and Arroway was "largely based" on Tarter's work.

Jill Tarter: "Our best estimates seem to indicate that in our galaxy, we may not be alone as the only race of intelligent creatures. Perhaps out there another planet with its own budget problems is sending off a handful of radio signals into the darkness of the space with the hope that it might be heard by someone else in the vastness of the Milky Way galaxy. Wouldn’t it be a shame if we weren’t listening?"


r/SETI • • Jun 15 '22

[News] China Says Signal From Advanced Alien Civilization Might Have Been Detected

56 Upvotes

Article Link:

https://www.newsweek.com/china-radio-signal-alien-intelligent-civilizations-1716026

Summary:

Chinese scientists at FAST have some interesting data but since they haven't published it or communicated it formally, its just data at this point. Reserve your excitement. Let the experts do their work. But its okay to be a little thrilled by the possibility.


r/SETI • • Jan 31 '21

Oumuamua & Occam's Razor

56 Upvotes

So, I got my hands on Loeb's book. I'm only about halfway through it, so in no position to give a real review, but I feel like I've already identified the philosophical heart of the matter, and it all comes down to Occam's Razor. The simplest explanation, or the one that requires the fewest assumptions, is the best. If you have multiple competing hypothesis, you give priority to testing the simplest one first.

The way Oumuamua throws a wrench into that is by challenging our standards of how we determine what explanation is simplest, and what is a reasonable assumption. Most of the time, in most areas of science, this is not hard. With Oumuamua it's problematic.

Loeb will argue that a lightsail is the simplest explanation because it fits the observations, and because lightsails are something we know and understand. We've theorized about these for decades, and we've even built a couple of test articles. By comparison, the "cosmic dust bunny" and "hydrogen iceberg" explanations call for exotic celestial objects that we've never seen before, and which had not even been conjectured (AFAIK) before Oumuamua drifted past. He's arguing that those hypotheses are just as much of a stretch, if not more so, than a lightsail.

The critic will say, hold your horses! You're assuming an entire alien civilization that we've seen no other evidence to support! That's the most complex and extraordinary hypothesis possible. And as we all know, "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence."

But Loeb would then argue, how do you define extraordinary? That's very subjective. Given the age of our galaxy, and the number of earth-like planets we have both observed and estimated, wouldn't it be more extraordinary and hard to explain if there are no other civilizations? Isn't that really the more difficult assumption to make?

At this point I shall avoid diving into the black hole of the Drake Equation, which so many discussions have fallen into and never emerged.

Ultimately, this argument over Oumuamua should not be a heated one. I've seen some folks getting rather personal about it, and I just shake my head in dismay. We all know this is not going to be truly settled without observing further objects of this category. We all know that should happen with the instruments that are slated for deployment in the near future, assuming that Oumuamua wasn't a freakishly rare fluke.

To me, the practical concern is whether we'll be ready to intercept one in the near future. In theory we could have built a probe and sent it chasing after Oumuamua if the decision had been made early on. If we lay our plans in advance, and another one appears, getting a probe on it should be very doable. However, it will cost money and resources, and there are always people fearful that the funds will be robbed out of their own projects. In this case, though, again I don't think it should be a subject of bitter fighting. Regardless of what your favored hypothesis is for Oumuamua, natural or artificial, all of them are exotic and of extreme interest to astronomers. So, an intercept mission really should get funded without having to first convince everyone that it's aliens.


r/SETI • • Dec 20 '20

Very thorough blog post from Jason Wright offering context on BLC-1

56 Upvotes

https://sites.psu.edu/astrowright/2020/12/20/blc1-a-candidate-signal-around-proxima/

thanks for this clear distillation, u/astro_wright - and say hi to the SETI team at PSU from /r/seti!


r/SETI • • Aug 28 '16

Signal found, not saying aliens.

Thumbnail
yahoo.com
56 Upvotes

r/SETI • • Feb 12 '20

"Extraterrestrial: The First Sign of Intelligent Life Beyond Earth"

51 Upvotes

It looks as though Professor Loeb has a new book coming out next year. From the description:

Harvard’s top astronomer lays out his controversial theory that our solar system was recently visited by advanced alien technology from a distant star.

In late 2017, scientists at a Hawaiian observatory glimpsed an object soaring through our inner solar system, moving so quickly that it could only have come from another star. Avi Loeb, Harvard’s top astronomer, showed it was not an asteroid; it was moving too fast along a strange orbit, and left no trail of gas or debris in its wake. There was only one conceivable explanation: the object was a piece of advanced technology created by a distant alien civilization.

This is notable, IMO. It appears as if Loeb is going "all-in" on 'Oumuamua being a piece of ETI technology. I'd argue the writing was on the wall there but he seemed to hedge his answers to the question in the past. It's possible the publisher is taking liberties in their description but if this is indeed his position, what do we think?

Has he made a convincing enough case in his papers and articles in Scientific American? If he's correct, what are the implications for SETI? Should effort be refocused in some meaningful way?


r/SETI • • Sep 22 '19

'Alien Megastructure' Star Not Alone. More Mysteriously Dimming Objects Found.

Thumbnail
livescience.com
51 Upvotes

r/SETI • • Jan 01 '17

Octopuses Are ‘the Closest We Will Come to Meeting an Intelligent Alien’

Thumbnail
nymag.com
49 Upvotes

r/SETI • • Sep 08 '21

What gives us the right to broadcast the location of billions of people without their permission?

48 Upvotes

Sending out Active SETI has global implications, how is this ethical? What if we were found and decimated because of a curious and careless minority?

Devil's advocate, thoughts?


r/SETI • • Aug 04 '21

[ET Fan Post] How would SETI try to make contact with a Plant-based Intelligence?

48 Upvotes

Theoretical Introduction

All roots in the world are joined with microscopic fungi which cover large swaths of the planet. Trees can communicate (via roots or chemical means) important information about their environment. Allowing them to adapt and learn.

My Alien Civilization Concept.

Disclaimer: Sounds like science fiction, so do all alien civilizations.

They are not malevolent, they are a peaceful civilization.

They are immune to radiation, extreme heat, extreme cold, and acids.

Suppose somewhere in the universe, a plant species has developed an advanced understanding of mathematical concepts. They can communicate these advanced concepts with other individual plants/fungi.

Personally, I believe this type of civilization would have a vast knowledge base due to the life-span advantage. Their mathematical skill-set is vastly superior to humans'. Their speed of communication is slower, but their intellectual capacity is not lower than humans. In fact, it's higher.

Also, a plant civilization is the best candidate to outlive any non-plant-based civilization. Their weakness is a limitation on mobility, however, they are not completely immobile, even though that doesn't mean a lot given their long lifespans.

This civilization has no need for radio or electricity. They have taken a different path of evolution. In an effort, they have mastered a chemistry unknown to human science, to allow them to modify their genetic coding.

With this technology, they enhanced themselves to withstand extreme weather. Over eons, eventually, allow them to send spores into space to colonize other planets. They take advantage of every asteroid/comet strike in an attempt to colonize other planets. Eventually, they become successful in surviving their sun's Red Giant phase.

Martian Rover is destroyed, as it caused great pain in taking a sample.

Unknown to us, these intelligent beings have successfully colonized Europa's oceans. Their technology allowed them to adapt to the extreme climate.

They don't even need photosynthesis. Eventually, they "hopped" to Mars, and plant life begins to thrive in extreme conditions.

Humans thinking that intelligent life cannot be plant life, make a big mistake by gathering a sample from the strange & large lifeform found on the Martian Surface.

Also, the lifeform has its own genetically engineered self-defense mechanism powerful enough to kill large animals.

Unfortunately, the being used the weapon to destroy the rover as it was in great pain.

They can easily conquer the Earth, due to their extreme adaptations. We may be forced to co-exist with them.

  • How would we communicate with these beings?

  • What is the technology needed to learn their language, so that we don't hurt them by mistake?

  • How would SETI, tackle the problem of figuring out how to contact them?

  • How would we protect our planet from colonization? (They don't know that we're here)


r/SETI • • Oct 18 '15

SETI tweet: "Star KIC 8462852 is in the news. Its dimming might be due to alien constructions. Hang tight: The Allen Telescope Array is looking."

Thumbnail
twitter.com
48 Upvotes

r/SETI • • Jun 30 '21

[Article] A Dyson Sphere Around A Black Hole

47 Upvotes

Article Link:

https://arxiv.org/abs/2106.15181

Abstract:

The search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) has been conducted for nearly 60 years. A Dyson Sphere, a spherical structure that surrounds a star and transports its radiative energy outward as an energy source for an advanced civilisation, is one of the main targets of SETI. In this study, we discuss whether building a Dyson Sphere around a black hole is effective. We consider six energy sources: (i) the cosmic microwave background, (ii) the Hawking radiation, (iii) an accretion disk, (iv) Bondi accretion, (v) a corona, and (vi) relativistic jets. To develop future civilisations (for example, a Type II civilisation), 4×1026W(1L⊙) is expected to be needed. Among (iii) to (vi), the largest luminosity can be collected from an accretion disk, reaching 105L⊙, enough to maintain a Type II civilisation. Moreover, if a Dyson Sphere collects not only the electromagnetic radiation but also other types of energy (e.g., kinetic energy) from the jets, the total collected energy would be approximately 5 times larger. Considering the emission from a Dyson Sphere, our results show that the Dyson Sphere around a stellar-mass black hole in the Milky Way (10kpc away from us) is detectable in the ultraviolet(10−400nm), optical(400−760nm), near-infrared(760nm−5μm), and mid-infrared(5−40μm) wavelengths via the waste heat radiation using current telescopes such as Galaxy Evolution Explorer Ultraviolet Sky Surveys. Performing model fitting to observed spectral energy distributions and measuring the variability of radial velocity may help us to identify these possible artificial structures.


r/SETI • • Oct 21 '24

What is your thoughts about the Dark Forest solution to the Fermi Paradox

46 Upvotes

I'm interested to hear what people here think about the Dark Forest solution to the Fermi Paradox? It doesn't seem like a very popular solution, but it seems really reasonable to me -if unsatisfying.

If you are unaware, the Dark Forest solution is that there are in fact millions and millions of civilizations in the universe, but none of them are dumb enough to broadcast their existence to the universe. If there are millions of civilizations, then odds are good that at least some of them are very violent, and a smaller but non-zero percentage is extremely violent. As soon as a civilization makes itself known to the universe, many other violent civilizations immediately start making plans to completely destroy that civilization (think, Independence Day or Mars Attacks). Therefor, we look up at the night sky and see and hear nothing because everyone that hasn't been destroyed already is in deep hiding.


r/SETI • • Aug 31 '20

What If SETI Finds Something, Then What?

Thumbnail
centauri-dreams.org
46 Upvotes

r/SETI • • May 10 '24

Was the Wow! signal unique?

45 Upvotes

Is it true that the famous "Wow!" signal was only one of many loud, narrowband, unrepeated transmissions received by SETI scientists?