r/SETI • • May 30 '25

SETI is pointless as it stands

0 Upvotes

I'm not here to be rude, I want to be proven wrong.

As a believer in ET's or NHI, I find SETI ridiculously underfunded and basically pointless. As I understand it, SETI is searching various areas of space for limited time per section and the chances of noticing a signal blared directly at us is already in the millions of percent?

Akin to:

  • Building one smoke detector for a continent

  • Turning it on for 30 seconds a week

  • Then releasing a paper: “No evidence of fire activity.”

Is this wrong?

It should be scanning every angle all of the time to be worthwhile.

EDIT: To add to the smoke detector analogy, we don't even have reason to assume that fire should be what we are looking for (radio waves). Radio waves have only been around for a tiny cosmic time and we are already moving beyond them.


r/SETI • • Jan 19 '26

Pretty sure we are approaching the great filter

3 Upvotes

I used to be quite optimistic and thinking that there was a different explanation to the Fermi paradox than the great filter, now I am thinking that we are approaching the great filter...


r/SETI • • Aug 11 '20

How similar to humans is the most similar alien race that exsists now or have existed in the abservable universe?

0 Upvotes

What do you think? Share you thought in the comments.


r/SETI • • Sep 22 '25

If we want to make it way more likely that Humanity within one Generation will start communicating with Extraterrestrials (using current technology), why not send a SETI signal specifically toward every Potentially Earthlike Planet that is close enough to us?

0 Upvotes

If you consider the Human Lifespan to be 90 years, to send one message to and then receive one back, the Exoplanet would have to be 45 Light Years or shorter away. (And obviously this would have to be Economically Viable as a project.)

According to my current research, Science's Current Understanding yields 39 potential results for this... and when I mean sending a signal to them all, I mean every single one of these 39:

Proxima Centauri b Ross 128 b Gliese 1061 d Gliese 1061 c Luyten's Star b Kapteyn b Wolf 1061 c Gliese 1002 b Gliese 1002 c Gliese 3323 b Gliese 752 a ab 82 G. Eridani d Gliese 892 g Gliese 625 b Gliese 892 g 82 G. Eridani e 82 G. Eridani f Gliese 555 b Gliese 3192 A d Gliese 667 C c Gliese 667 C e Gliese 667 C f Gliese 514 b
Gliese 3325 b Gliese 357 d Gliese 3988 b L 98-59 d L 98-59 f G 261-6 b Gliese 173 b Ross 508 b HD 85512 b Gliese 180 d Gliese 180 b G 32-5 b TRAPPIST-1g TRAPPIST-1e TRAPPIST-1 f HD 40307 g

One of them would have to answer.... I just hope we like what they have to say.


r/SETI • • Aug 24 '20

Has anyone noticed that FRB 121102 is following a pattern of primes?

5 Upvotes

People should not get lured into non-sense nor should skeptics fall into denial. But, I noticed that this Fast Radio Burst has to do with the prime number 157.

If memory serves correct, it resurfaces every 157 days. And it goes dark for 67 days (which is prime) and wake up in 90 days. 90 is 89+1 the sum of two fibonnaci numbers. Also 89 is a prime.

I also took a look at some of the first 12 fibonnaci numbers and used the 12th number 233.

But, first the estimated distance between the Milky Way and the dwarf galaxy where the FRB is coming from is ~3-billion light years.

Taking 3-billion-2334= 52,704,479. Which is also prime number according to google.

This means the gap between 3-billion and 2334 is a prime number 52,704,479.

This probably means the pattern is unique in nature, but why would the gap between 2334 and 3-billion be a prime?

Why am I finding primes and correlation with the fibonnaci sequence with this FRB? Are there other FRBs out there that are spewing patterns with primes?

Will SETI every take a look at why there are repeating patterns of primes?

FRBs that repeat should have the best chance of being artifical.


r/SETI • • Nov 25 '25

A suggestion for dolphin communication.

0 Upvotes

I was doing some digitizing of voice recordings when I found a surprising effect. The first file linked below is of a voice recording in MP3 format. The digital sampling rate was at the default 44khz. The second file is the result when I applied the slower sampling rate of 8khz to the first file.

I was startled to note the effect of using the slower sampling rate was to give the recording the sound of whale song or dolphin speech.
This effect is more pronounced with longer recordings. I had to shorten these to upload them for some online discussions on animal communication back in 2005 when I made them. To observe this, use a program for digitally recording audio, then sample a saved voice recording at a slower rate than it was originally saved at.
There are several free programs available on the net that have this capability. At the time I made these recordings in 2005, I used WinAmp a commonly used audio program then.
I thought then perhaps the difficulty in interpreting dolphin speech was that we record them at a slower sampling rate than what they are actually produced at. However, it is known that dolphin speech extends into higher frequencies:

Oceanwide Science Institute's Research Page.
"One of the main problems is the high frequency content of dolphin signals. Most dolphin species produce three types of signals: echolocation clicks, the faster paced burst pulse clicks, and whistles. Echolocation clicks are used by dolphins to detect and recognize objects in the water from the returning echoes. Burst pulse clicks and whistles on the other hand are thought to be used mainly for communication. Click signals are extremely short (50 microseconds) and broadband high frequency signals, ranging from 0 to over 200 kilohertz. Whistles are generally within human hearing range, but also have ultrasonic components called harmonics which can go up to over 100 kHz. However, conventional audio recording systems only go up to about 20 kHz (also the upper limit of human hearing), and therefore miss the major part of these signals."
https://web.archive.org/web/20090105215936/http://oceanwidescience.org/docs/4ch-UDDAS.html

The higher frequencies necessitate higher sampling rates to accurately record the analog signal. This is a result of the Nyquist theorem:

Nyquist's Sampling Theorem.
http://www.cs.cf.ac.uk/Dave/Multimedia/node149.html

So I presume that when we hear recordings of dolphin speech, they are recorded at these higher sampling rates, or certainly for purposes of scientific study they are.
Then perhaps the problem is that our human hearing can not adapt to the amount of date contained in the audio at these high sampling rates, or their rate of modulation.
So instead of using our audio sense to interpret dolphin speech why not use a sense that operates at (much) higher frequencies? I'm thinking of our visual sense. I suggest associating the sounds in dolphin speech with colors. To represent intensity of the sound you could use the brightness of the color but I think this would be better represented by elevation, that is louder sounds would be projected higher on a screen.
The idea is to use our ability to detect recurring patterns visually in color and form as the means to interpret dolphin speech. There are many different ways this could be implemented. In fact visual artists might be the best people to ask about the best ways to implement this and to be able to "read" the messages produced.

However, the another idea I’m proposing is to try this with individuals with an unusual talent. These individuals have the characteristic of "synesthesia". This is the ability to perceive stimuli to one sense with sensations to the other senses. For example synesthetes will hear sounds accompanied visually by colors or vice versa:

Synesthesia and the Synesthetic Experience.
http://web.mit.edu/synesthesia/www/

The most remarkable case of this is exhibited by Daniel Tammet:

Daniel Tammet.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Tammet

Tammet has been described as an autistic savant, but in interviews he shows a remarkable understanding and insight into his capabilities. He also has a remarkable memory for sounds and numbers. The ability to remember sounds that are not human speech related will be key to this research.

Therefore ideally I would want to use Tammet in a study to try to translate the dolphin speech into a visual form and then through him into normal human language. If Tammet is not available for the research there might be other individuals with this capability and also the insight to be able to translate repeated sounds into visual form.

If this approach is successful its importance could hardly be overestimated. It would be first time humans could communicate to another intelligent species in their own language.

I invite others to observe this surprising effect of digitizing speech audio files at a slower sampling rate than normal.

Here are the two files I made showing what happens when you change the sampling rate on human voice recordings. The first is the voice audio file at normal sampling rate. The second is at the much reduced sampling rate.

test6.mp3
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1XzkbEOw0sxAOLhvZKq2dS-_HEmLSFy9D/view

test6-8khza.mp3
https://drive.google.com/file/d/17xwE8bM-_HWHWcKh5KigsnzqfTmf1oUu/view


r/SETI • • Apr 29 '18

Hey, I'm an artist that's sending your messages into deep space this summer. I think you'll dig this. :)

0 Upvotes

"In Case We Miss Each Other" is an interactive art installation headed to Burning Man 2018. We are collecting messages and broadcasting them into deep space.

What kind of message would you leave?

Here is a little sneak peak of the project! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JjL-1b-qvLs&feature=youtu.be&app=desktop

Thanks and happy spacing!


r/SETI • • Apr 14 '24

Question for astronomers

0 Upvotes

Greetings, positing a question: Since all life as we know it is comprised of energy, at the most basic atomic level... should we consider that planetary bodies with iron-nickel cores (such as Earth's) and a resultant magnetosphere would be most likely to attract enough energy to produce sapient life forms?


r/SETI • • Oct 17 '26

The Silent Constellation Hypothesis

2 Upvotes

Intelligence is only part of the journey from being alive to being heard.

When people discuss the Fermi paradox, the argument often starts with the enormous number of planets. With that many opportunities, why haven't we found anybody?

I keep wondering about everything that has to happen between a planet developing life and that life producing something we could detect.

Earth is full of animals that communicate, learn, remember, and solve problems. Some use tools. Without humans, this could still be a thriving planet, but none of our signals would be leaving it.

Maybe that situation is common.

An intelligent species might never develop industry. It could lack the physical means, accessible resources, or inclination to do so. Even if it makes useful discoveries, those discoveries have to be preserved and built upon. Can it record detailed knowledge? Does it actually do that? Does the knowledge survive long enough to become something more?

Then there's motivation.

Suppose I had never encountered electricity, and my introduction to it involved getting shocked. There's a good chance I'd decide to stay the hell away from whatever did that. Discovering a phenomenon doesn't automatically mean wanting to investigate it.

A species could be intelligent enough to experiment and still have little interest in doing so. Avoiding a hazard might serve it perfectly well.

I wanted to see what happens when those requirements are made explicit in a Drake-equation-style calculation.

Giving each step a number

These are rough assumptions for a thought experiment. I'm trying to give the process fairly generous chances, rather than making every obstacle almost impossible. Whether those chances are actually generous is something we don't know.

For the Milky Way, start with:

- Stars formed each year, treated as a simplified long-term average: 2

- Stars with planets: 100%

- Potentially suitable planets per system: 0.2

- Suitable planets where life develops: 50%

- Living worlds developing a lineage with relevant intelligence: 10%

Multiplying those gives an illustrative average of 0.02 new worlds with relevant intelligence per year. This is bookkeeping across long periods, not a claim that a newly formed planet produces intelligent life immediately.

Now consider what that lineage would need to accomplish.

- It has a practical way to manipulate materials and manufacture things: 50%

- It investigates unfamiliar phenomena beyond immediate survival needs: 50%

- It persists with experiments despite danger and failure: 50%

- It develops and adopts useful technology: 50%

- It preserves detailed knowledge that later generations can retrieve and build upon: 50%

- It accesses suitable materials and learns to harness usable energy: 50%

- It develops equipment capable of sending signals beyond its planet: 50%

Writing is our example of preserving knowledge. Another species might accomplish that differently. Likewise, it wouldn't necessarily need our exact metals or fuels, but it would need some workable combination of materials, energy, and manufacturing methods.

Giving each of those seven steps a 50% chance produces:

1/2 × 1/2 × 1/2 × 1/2 × 1/2 × 1/2 × 1/2 = 1 in 128.

In this example, one in 128 worlds with relevant intelligence reaches the capability to transmit beyond its planet.

These are conditional chances. Each applies to worlds that have passed the preceding requirements. They aren't seven unrelated coin tosses, and their real values could depend strongly on one another.

Would they actually send anything?

Having the equipment doesn't establish an interest in interstellar contact.

For this example, suppose 10% of capable societies produce deliberate interstellar transmissions. Among the remaining 90%, suppose 10% produce accidental emissions that could potentially be detected from elsewhere.

That totals 19% producing relevant emissions.

Now give that transmitting stage an average duration of 10,000 years.

The calculation becomes:

0.02 × 1/128 × 0.19 × 10,000 ≈ 0.30.

That is a statistical expectation under these assumptions, not a literal count. It certainly doesn't mean humanity is a fraction of a civilization.

It shows that a fairly ordinary-looking set of allowances can produce a low expected number of transmitting societies across the galaxy. And transmitting still doesn't mean we would hear them. Distance, signal strength, direction, arrival time, and the coverage of our searches all matter afterward.

How much should we trust that answer?

We shouldn't treat 0.30 as a measurement.

If the transmitting stage lasts 100,000 years instead, the answer becomes about three. If each of the seven steps succeeds 80% of the time, while the transmitting stage lasts 10,000 years, it becomes about eight.

Different assumptions can produce much larger answers, too.

My suspicion is that some of the probabilities I used may be much lower in reality. Giving half of the qualifying worlds a successful outcome at every stage feels like a substantial allowance. But that is my judgment, not something the calculation establishes. The actual probabilities could be lower or higher.

Adding more conditions doesn't prove rarity. The conditions must represent genuine requirements, and we need evidence before putting much confidence in their numbers.

What this exercise does is expose assumptions that can disappear inside the phrase "intelligent civilization."

A species needs opportunities, capabilities, accumulated knowledge, and a history of actually doing something with them. Its activities must eventually leave evidence another world can find.

The Drake equation already distinguishes life, intelligence, and detectable technology. My proposal is to examine the journey between those categories more closely, especially the difference between being capable of something and having any reason to pursue it.

Maybe the universe contains plenty of inhabited worlds whose living things are doing perfectly well.

They just never get around to building a transmitter.


r/SETI • • Sep 09 '26

If SETI came into radio contact with an ETI, how many people think its a hoax?

1 Upvotes

Given other conspiracy theories about nefarious scientists, vaccines, evolution, moon landing, etc, I imagine there would be conspiracy theories about that too. That the signals have been falsified.

How plausible is this depressing scenario?


r/SETI • • Apr 11 '21

How come SETI is not commenting on all the navy videos being released?

19 Upvotes

Is SETI looking the wrong direction and needs to be looking at Earth and Near Earth for ETs?


r/SETI • • Nov 30 '17

The origin of life in a deterministic universe

2 Upvotes

I wouldn't be surprised if extraterrestrial life was absurdly similar to ours, to the point where two of our species can breed together.

When you look at the origin of life on Earth, you realize that we all came from unicellular organisms born from raw materials in exceptionally unique conditions. If those conditions are the conditions for life to be born, I'd imagine that there is a probability for it to exist, because it existed here. If these conditions can exist somewhere in the universe just like they could on Earth, then it's safe to say that they do, and not only on Earth. Thus, there is an unknown amount of life forms that do exist outside of Earth and have the same starting conditions as us.

And if they do, then evolution will apply to them in the exact same way it applied to them. Only the fittest to survive will survive. What if there was actually a "most efficient tactic available" to survive in different conditions? You bet that they will evolve that way.

For example, let's start with single cells. In our origin bath, cells with genetic mutation started to be aware of light, and could survive better than those who weren't. Wouldn't it be the case for all life forms? Scale that until today and you get the general picture.

Multicellular organisms would develop tactics to swim in water, get better vision, some would be able to breathe air, some would have different skin textures, some would be plants, some would be animals. Sexual reproduction is quite guaranteed to exist in a multicellular kingdom as it gives massive genetic advantages early on.

Now, what about the conscious life form that will roam this new planet? They are subject to the same rules as us, so it's safe to say they would be omnivore, have hands and legs, as those literally enabled us to develop a better brain.

What if extraterrestrial life is absurdly similar to ours?


r/SETI • • Aug 14 '23

New way to search for intelligent signals?

0 Upvotes

I was thinking about the double slit experiment and the collapse of the wave function. Would it be possible to run a message out to space through a double slit experiment where we choose to know the “way path” of the signal through a double slit experiment and send the other side of the slit signal into space. That would allow the receivers to know the wave function had already collapsed if they run the signal through a similar double slit (or something easier). They would have a confirmation of the collapse with the experiment without knowing the way path (no interference pattern). That would relay that someone else had collapsed the wave before sending. That being ask.. could we run the experiment as the receiver hoping that others out there are sending collapsed wave functions out into the cosmos to prove a conscious observer origin?


r/SETI • • Aug 21 '19

Just wait.

0 Upvotes

Thinking about extra terrestrial life or even just life in general you have! to take time into account. There could be hundreds, thousands or millions of planets harboring intelligent life we they are in the same boat as us. We have to wait for things. we have to wait for communication. When we find new exoplanets we are seeing them millions sometimes billions of years in the past, That's a lot of time for evolution to take place. We say there is nothing out there because of the lack of ability to see or hear anything but we might not for millions of years but THEY cant either, They might be waiting and watching for the next millions of years just like we are wondering if anything is beyond the reach of their own solar system. Time and the size of the universe is our biggest problem in the search for extra terrestrial life. In our lifetimes we will never ever gain any even slightest form of contact with any sort of intelligent life in the cosmos, its just not the right time and not the right conditions for proper communication.


r/SETI • • Dec 27 '16

Scientists say radio signals from deep space could be aliens

Thumbnail
nypost.com
0 Upvotes

r/SETI • • Aug 31 '16

CONVINCE ME... I WANT TO BELEIVE

4 Upvotes

I REALLY REALLY want a signal from an alien civilization to be heard in my lifetime, but can someone tell me why we are so sure we have the ability to even hear a signal? Lots of creatures on Earth communicate (i.e. cats... octopuses...) and we don't hear a thing. Maybe multiple alien civilizations are talking to us right now.... Someone with technical background, please present an argument. I don't want to lose hope in the possibility.


r/SETI • • Sep 14 '26

Could AI Help Humanity Recognize and Responsibly Answer Extraterrestrial Intelligence?

0 Upvotes

Detection and interpretation are different problems. Machine learning is already useful for the first. The second — recognizing intelligence expressed in an unfamiliar medium, and deciding as a civilization how to answer — may require capacities we have not built. I use Beacon Class as a working label for a civilization that has them.

Civilization as Distributed Intelligence

Human civilization has always functioned as distributed intelligence. No individual knows how to build a computer from raw materials, maintain the electrical grid, operate the global economy, and preserve every cultural tradition. Civilization "knows" more than any person because knowledge is distributed across minds, institutions, texts, tools, and technical systems.

That is more than a metaphor. Research on distributed cognition treats some cognitive work as occurring across coordinated people and artifacts rather than inside one isolated mind. Jensen, Secchi, and Jensen (2022) examine how organizational cognition emerges from networks of individuals, routines, and material systems (Frontiers in Psychology).

The internet intensified this arrangement, connecting much of humanity into something resembling a primitive nervous system but not a unified mind. Information moves globally in seconds while language, ideology, and incompatible models of reality continue to divide interpretation. We have planetary communication without planetary comprehension.

Large language models are neither conscious archives nor complete repositories of human knowledge. Their training data are partial, culturally uneven, and shaped by commercial and institutional choices. Even so, they compress an extraordinary range of human symbolic production into systems that can compare patterns across languages, disciplines, periods, and traditions. Whatever else that is, it is a new interpretive layer added to an already distributed cognitive system — and, as I will argue below, its being built from our symbolic output is as much a problem as a resource.

Machine Learning Is Already Doing SETI Work

This is not speculative. Ma et al. (2023) applied a β-convolutional variational autoencoder to 820 stellar targets observed with the Green Bank Telescope, totaling over 480 hours of on-sky data, and reduced the candidate pool by roughly two orders of magnitude compared with previous analyses of the same dataset while returning eight previously unidentified signals of interest (Nature Astronomy). Re-observations did not re-detect them. NASA has likewise discussed machine analysis as a tool for sorting datasets that overwhelm human teams in technosignature searches (NASA).

Note what that work does and does not do. It is a classifier operating on a well-specified hypothesis class: narrowband, Doppler-drifting signals distinguishable from radio-frequency interference. It searches a haystack faster. It does not address what happens if something is found that carries structure we did not anticipate.

That second problem is the one I want to take seriously.

Interpretation Is a Harder Problem Than Detection

If extraterrestrial intelligence exists, communication may be far more difficult than popular accounts suggest. We cannot assume another intelligence would share our senses, evolutionary history, concept of individuality, experience of time, or distinction between biology and technology. Even mathematics is not automatically a common language: a pattern must first be recognized as intentional, divided into meaningful units, and connected to a shared referent.

Human decipherment shows why footholds matter. The Rosetta Stone supplied parallel texts; Linear B did not. Its decipherment instead depended on Alice Kober's structural analysis, place-name hypotheses, and Michael Ventris's test that the language was Greek (University of Cambridge). By contrast, the Voynich manuscript remains unread: structure without external reference can resist interpretation for centuries (Yale University Library).

The A Sign in Space project made the same point empirically. In May 2023 ESA's ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter transmitted a simulated extraterrestrial signal toward Earth; three observatories received it, and roughly 5,000 citizen scientists extracted the message from the raw data within about ten days. Decoding it took more than a year — a father-daughter team, Ken and Keli Chaffin, recovered an image depicting five amino acids in June 2024 — and the community still has not converged on what the image is supposed to mean (ESA). Extraction was fast. Decoding was slow. Interpretation remains open, on a message designed by humans for humans to solve.

This creates the central objection to my own argument. Large language models compress human language and symbolism. Why should a system trained on human cultural products be any better than humans at understanding a genuinely non-human mind? It may reproduce our assumptions more efficiently rather than escape them. Calling AI a translator smuggles the desired conclusion into the premise.

The honest answer is narrower. AI's value would not be that it knows alien meaning, but that a carefully designed system could maintain incompatible interpretive frames without immediately collapsing toward the culturally familiar one. The same pattern could be tested as language, mathematics, behavior, signal modulation, code, natural process, instrument artifact, or deception. A useful system would identify which features survive across frames, which interpretations require hidden assumptions, and which predictions distinguish them. Current language models do not reliably have this capability: next-token prediction generally favors statistically likely continuations. This is a design requirement for a system that does not yet exist, not an observed property of present models, and building that difference would itself be part of becoming Beacon Class.

Concretely, such an interface might:

  • Compare candidate structures across linguistic, mathematical, visual, behavioral, and physical models.

  • Analyze data from multiple instruments without treating any one channel as definitive.

  • Generate rival interpretations and specify what observation would falsify each one.

  • Search for invariants — ratios, recurrences, transformations, or responses — that persist when cultural assumptions are changed.

  • Test whether apparent information exceeds what chance, prior knowledge, sensor error, or contamination could reasonably produce.

Useful not because it understands, but because it may help us build and compare bridges between incompatible systems of meaning.

What Would a "Beacon-Class" Civilization Be?

The Kardashev scale classifies civilizations by energy use, which can in principle be estimated. Beacon Class is not comparably quantifiable; it combines observable capabilities with political and ethical judgments, and I offer it as a working label rather than a scale. It names a threshold an energy scale cannot capture: recognizing another intelligence and responding without surrendering interpretation to panic, monopoly, or force.

Five conditions:

  1. Detectable — measurable. It produces technological or informational signatures distinguishable from natural background; evidence would be independent detection of those signatures at interstellar distance.

  2. Self-aware — currently judgeable. It can describe itself as a planetary civilization while preserving internal plurality; evidence would be durable institutions able to frame species-level interests without pretending that national interests have disappeared.

  3. Interpretively capable — partly measurable. It can recognize possible intelligence in unfamiliar media; evidence would be successful blinded tests on synthetic signals designed around unknown rules, followed by accurate novel predictions rather than retrospective pattern-matching. Failure would be disqualifying, but success would establish only a floor: human-designed unfamiliarity does not solve the Linear B/Voynich problem of grounding genuinely unknown meaning. A Sign in Space is roughly what such a test looks like, and it was easier than the real case in every respect.

  4. Coherent enough to respond — currently judgeable. It has a legitimate process for deciding whether and how to answer; evidence would be a publicly accepted international procedure that prevents any government, corporation, religion, or AI system from unilaterally speaking for Earth.

  5. Ethically contact-ready — currently judgeable. It can contain disruptive information without defaulting to weaponization or domination; evidence would be enforceable rules for access, civilian oversight, benefit-sharing, and restraint that survive a high-stakes technological shock.

These conditions are interdependent but not strictly sequential. Detectability may arrive long before maturity, while interpretive capacity and governance must develop together: better detection without legitimate response institutions could increase danger, and ethical rules without the ability to identify a signal would remain untested.

Humanity may already satisfy the first condition. Radio leakage, atmospheric industrial chemicals, artificial illumination, and nuclear activity could function as technosignatures. We clearly do not yet satisfy all the others.

The Probabilistic Case Must Remain Probabilistic

The possibility of extraterrestrial intelligence deserves investigation, but ambiguous results should not be stacked into certainty. K2-18 b, for example, has yielded detections of methane and carbon dioxide and a less robust possible indication of dimethyl sulfide. NASA stresses that the latter requires validation and that habitability remains uncertain (NASA). A contested biosignature candidate is not a technosignature, and a technosignature would not be a message.

Drake-equation estimates likewise explore the consequences of uncertain assumptions rather than directly counting civilizations. The strongest defensible form of my hypothesis is therefore conditional:

If a confirmed technosignature is ever detected, then the difficulty will shift almost immediately from detection to interpretation and response — and a globally networked civilization equipped with well-designed analytical systems may be better positioned for that shift than one relying on ad hoc improvisation.

That is a claim about preparation, not about the prevalence of extraterrestrial intelligence, on which I take no position here.

Could AI Manufacture a Signal That Isn't There?

Yes, and the field already knows the shape of this failure. Humans detect faces in clouds and intentions in coincidence. Generative systems can amplify that tendency because they are optimized to produce coherent output even when evidence is thin. A system asked repeatedly to decode a message may eventually produce one.

BLC1 is the instructive case. A narrowband signal near 982 MHz, recorded in 2019 during Breakthrough Listen observations of Proxima Centauri with the Parkes telescope, had characteristics broadly consistent with a hypothesized technosignature. It took an exhaustive analysis to attribute it to an electronically drifting intermodulation product of local interferers — dozens of lookalike signals turned up at frequencies harmonically related to common clock oscillators (Sheikh et al., Nature Astronomy, 2021). The lasting value of BLC1 was the verification framework built around it.

Any AI-assisted analysis layer would need comparable discipline against machine-generated mythology:

  • Open, standardized multi-instrument data.

  • Preregistered predictions.

  • Blind analysis and control datasets.

  • Independent teams using different models.

  • Clear separation between interpretation and physical evidence.

  • Public audit trails showing how conclusions were reached.

  • Human oversight representing multiple disciplines.

AI should generate hypotheses, expose assumptions, and test predictions. It should not be treated as an oracle. Its output would become credible only when independent observers can reproduce the result and when its interpretation predicts information not used to generate it.

Post-Detection Protocols Exist — but They Do Not Cover the Hard Part

Humanity is not starting from zero. The International Academy of Astronautics adopted post-detection principles in 1989 and revised them in 2010 (Garrett et al., 2025). Those principles emphasized independent verification, disclosure to the scientific community and public after confirmation, preservation of data, notification of the United Nations, and consultation before any reply.

In June 2026, following committee approval in a December 2025–January 2026 vote, the IAA SETI Committee issued a further update. It strengthens guidance on verification, peer review, archiving, public communication, researcher safety, and international consultation before responding. It also defines its boundary plainly: the declaration applies to astronomy-based searches for technosignatures and not to UAP in Earth's atmosphere (SETI Institute).

These are serious foundations, but they remain voluntary principles rather than binding international law (American Journal of International Law). They have no enforcement mechanism and do not settle who could legitimately authorize a response for humanity. They also say comparatively little about the interpretive phase — what happens during the months or years between confirmed detection and any agreed understanding of content, which is exactly the window A Sign in Space suggests would be longest and most contested.

If a confirmed detection occurred, three outcomes seem plausible:

  • Cooperation: confirmation creates enough shared interest to strengthen international science and species-level institutions.

  • Concentration: states or companies classify data, monopolize interpretation, and convert informational advantage into power.

  • Fragmentation and absorption: the most likely outcome may be neither. Competing institutions dispute the evidence, fold it into existing conflicts, generate incompatible narratives, and gradually make even an extraordinary discovery feel politically mundane within a decade.

Preparation should therefore focus less on declaring who speaks for Earth than on constructing a legitimate process: transparent publication of non-sensitive data, independent international review, explicit separation of data from interpretation, and a prohibition on autonomous systems issuing a response. Conditions four and five are not aspirations to add after detection; they are institutional work that has to begin before the stakes are known.

The Deeper Possibility

AI may help find an engineered signal in astronomical data or identify a repeatable structure in anomalous observations. Yet the central objection returns in reverse: because these systems are made from human symbolic production, the first unfamiliar intelligence they help us examine may be our own.

By compressing our languages, sciences, contradictions, and rival accounts of reality into interactive systems, we are building an externalized view of civilization. That view will be distorted and incomplete, but it may still force us to confront which of our assumptions are actually universal, which are parochial, and whether any legitimate "humanity" exists that could participate in an exchange.

Perhaps that is the real transition to Beacon Class. The beacon is not merely radio leakage or nuclear technology. It is the point at which a civilization becomes capable of encountering radical difference without instantly mistaking it for itself — and capable of answering without allowing its most powerful faction to impersonate the whole.

Can we build that interpretive and political capacity before we need it — and if a signal is ever confirmed, who could legitimately decide that humanity has understood enough to answer?


r/SETI • • Sep 21 '26

Behavioral SETI — a new hypothesis after 66 years of silence

0 Upvotes

Behavioral SETI — a new hypothesis after 66 years of silence

Since 1960, the search for extraterrestrial intelligence has mostly meant listening for a radio signal on or near the 21 cm hydrogen line — the "magic frequency" everyone assumed a transmitting civilization would choose. Sixty-six years later, that search, and the broader technosignature work featured at NASA's technosignatures workshops and in Breakthrough Listen, has turned up nothing.

Those efforts all look for things an advanced civilization would build or broadcast: a radio or laser beacon aimed our way, the waste heat of a Dyson sphere, pollutants in an exoplanet's atmosphere. They assume someone is either deliberately calling out or leaving a footprint big enough to spot from here.

I've been running a small solo project on a different premise, which I call Behavioral SETI. The key concept is to look at the communication problem from the point of view of the people who would have designed the system. A rational designer conserves energy — you don't build a galaxy-spanning lighthouse and broadcast rich content in every direction forever on the off chance someone's listening. You gate it: send the cheapest possible signal that just says where and how to look, and only spend the energy on real content once a recipient has proven they received and understood that first pointer.

Energy conservation plus this gating principle change what the signal should look like — not a loud beacon, but a subtle modulation of a natural source we already monitor, like sunlight, the neutrinos from the Sun's core, or the brightness of distant stars. The idea is that an established network wouldn't hope we find its lighthouse; it would nudge something we're already staring at. That reframes the whole problem from "detect a faint transmitter somewhere in the sky" to "check whether the data we already have has structure in it that nature doesn't put there" — which means the search can run on public archives that already exist, including solar-neutrino data shared by the Super-Kamiokande (neutrino) collaboration.

So far that's 50 searches, each one a clean null — every test quoted with the sensitivity it actually reached, so a null means "no signal down to this level," not just "we didn't find anything." And this isn't hand-waving: the searches so far run to on the order of a hundred million individual statistical tests — about 10¹⁵ floating-point operations, some 80 days of a 1976 Cray-1 running flat-out. That's the shallow end. Searching the full space of channel-combinations the method opens up runs to tens of Cray-1 years, and the deep fast-band tier to tens of millions of them — which is the whole point: a message hidden in a relationship among observables is gated behind compute nobody on Earth had until recently.

The test results and the github source code are provided in the link below along with a simulation of the hypothesis.

See: https://dxtra.com/static/galactic-dx/summary.html?src=reddit


r/SETI • • Nov 07 '15

Scientists Take a Closer Look, Find No Evidence of Alien Megastructures

Thumbnail
fromquarkstoquasars.com
2 Upvotes

r/SETI • • May 09 '12

/r/SETI, I almost forgot that I made this for you. Use if you like, ignore if you don't.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/SETI • • Nov 04 '25

NASA says 3I/ATLAS is a "simple comet." The data shows a sunward jet, a nickel anomaly, and a blue color. Why the discrepancy?

0 Upvotes

I've been digging into the timeline of 3I/ATLAS, and the discrepancy between the public NASA narrative and the actual data (from NASA's own assets) is alarming.

The public narrative (per NASA Admin Duffy) is "just a comet."

But the data shows:

  1. JULY 21: Hubble (NASA) sees a "sunward jet" (anti-tail). (Source: Keto & Loeb, 2509.07771). NASA's blog post omits this.

  2. AUG 24: Keck confirms "prominent nickel emission" without iron. (Source: arXiv 2510.11779). NASA's JWST blog post omits this.

  3. OCT 28: Zhang & Battams confirm a "blue color" & r^-7.5 acceleration.

  4. OCT 30: NASA Admin Duffy ignores all 9 anomalies and just says "No aliens."

The "simple comet" model does not fit the data. The real story isn't the object; it's the discrepancy in NASA's communication.

I just published a full analysis of this timeline and the data NASA is ignoring:

https://medium.com/@haymo_sachs/nasas-simple-comet-narrative-for-3i-atlas-is-contradicted-by-its-own-data-378807d2f77d

Why do you think NASA is actively omitting the anomalous data from its public statements?


r/SETI • • May 04 '17

I found an installer for "setiathome" in my intern computer task manager, wtf is this?

0 Upvotes

Can this get distributed at malware? Is this a virus? Can someone explain what this thing is? It has appeared on one of our office computers, the one that the interns use.


r/SETI • • Jan 19 '15

The Possible Reason We Can't Find Alien Signals From Space!

5 Upvotes

(TL;DR at the bottom)

Ever since SETI started searching the skies in 1960 with radio telescopes for electromagnetic radiation from advanced extra-terrestrial technologies, nothing really has been found. The most significant find that was detected was the "Wow!" signal in 1977 by Jerry R. Ehman who was working for SETI. But it is still unclear what exactly the "Wow!" signal really was.

I think that the reason why we are unable to detect extra-terrestrial (E.T) signals is because simply the E.Ts are way much more technologically advanced than us.

Space is unfathomably massive! If advanced ETs are able of space travel, I would imagine they have discovered a shortcut in traveling across massive distances. If a planet is 10 light years away, that would mean that light traveling at the speed of light, it would take 10 years to reach. Now since nothing can travel faster than the speed of light, because it would be breaking the very laws of physics, the ETs must probably have advanced their technology to such a level as to be able create wormholes to pass through and appear at the other side of the galaxy in no time at all! Or are possible able of multi-dimensional travel like through some kind of "hyperspace"!

So, if the ETs are to travel from one planet to another without crossing the in-between space, then they must be also using this technology to communicate at an interstellar level. Radio waves travel at the speed of light, so if an ET would send a radio message to a planet 10 light years away, it would take 10 years to reach...and that's very inefficient! So sending messages thought "hyperspace" would be so much faster (10 years faster XD)! This would mean that there are no ET signals traveling in-between the stars for us to be able to pick them up with our radio telescopes!

Or they could also be exploiting quantum entanglement properties to communicate! They would be able to send a message that would be instantaneously received at any part of the universe! This is also means that the message signals don't travel across the in-between space! So there is nothing for us to pick up with radio telescopes!!

This is probably why we haven't detected any major extra-terrestrial signals with radio telescopes.

TL;DR: The ETs are more advanced than us. They are probably using "hyperspace" or quantum entanglement technology to send message signals at an interstellar level. This would mean that there are no ET signals traveling in-between the stars for us to be able to pick them up with our radio telescopes!


r/SETI • • Aug 29 '16

Russische Astronomen empfangen potentiell intelligentes Signal aus dem All

Thumbnail
grenzwissenschaft-aktuell.de
0 Upvotes