r/redesign • • May 09 '18

The redesign should be scrapped and you should start over.

3 Upvotes

This effort seems driven by keeping up with perceived competitors, probably when the redesign project was started, what 2 years ago, I'm guessing?

The redesign draws heavily on Facebook's layout. We've seen this year where FB's priorities are: anywhere their advertisers and anyone with cash wants them. And that's what drives FB's layout.

There's nothing innovative here. It's just a rehash of other sites doing the same thing. So I'm guessing in a year or two, someone takes the essence of what was great about the old design, extracts it, puts some ML on it to better surface content, wraps user activity in a blockchain and eats your lunch.

If you did it right, you could do the same in 6 months.

Good luck, and sorry your design sucks. #noego #sunkcostsyo


r/redesign • • Feb 28 '19

Feature Request One year ago today: "Improved public moderation logs are something we're thinking a lot about as a way to improve the relationships between mods, users, and admins." Has there been any progress on this at all?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/redesign • • Sep 19 '19

Changelog We are making some changes and here’s how to keep the feedback going

0 Upvotes

Hi folks,

We created the r/redesign community back in 2017 to help us get feedback from a few hundred alpha testers. In 2018, when we began to rollout the redesign to more people it morphed into a bigger community with more discussions, bug reports, and feature suggestions. We’ve truly appreciated the r/redesign community and all the feedback and ideas that you’ve shared with us over the past two years.

Earlier this year, the redesign was rolled out to all redditors. While we’ve continued to work on improving new Reddit, we’ve broadened our focus to include platforms like iOS, Android, and mobile web. As a result, we’ve decided to archive r/redesign so that bugs and feedback can be directed to more specific locations.

What this means:

Thanks again to everyone who joined us here and gave helpful feedback. It’s been a wild ride.

Goodbye for now


r/redesign • • Dec 26 '18

Give us a seperate NSFL tag.

0 Upvotes

I don't want to see severed heads when I'm expecting titties.


r/redesign • • Jul 23 '18

i thinks its amazing theyre still trying to force this bad design.

8 Upvotes

is anyone actually even using it?

id love to see numbers detailing new visitors and if they stay with the redesign, or if it tends turn people off compared to before.

i get it'll make reddit more money with adds, but will it kill new users?

how many people are actually using new reddit? its madness.

the redesign is so awful, im just amazed at the decision to keep pushing it. if they didn't let people use old reddit still im sure people would leave by the thousands. so why have it?


r/redesign • • Sep 11 '18

You have to be fucking kidding me.

0 Upvotes

I just typed a reply for over an hour. Like every other website, and like the original reddit, I hit "<tab> <space>" to submit the form.

BUT NOPE. FUCKING REDDIT. Fucking god damn reddit. Why would I have any hope that reddit would respect any norms whatsoever? Why would I expect that reddit frontend engineers have done *literally any* amount of research or basic fucking engineering to design basic UX elements?

The best part? Pre-re-design, the form would keep your comment, even if it were closed.

Just a complete fucking slap in the face, over and over. And of course, THIS HAS BEEN REPORTED BEFORE.

Reddit, the last 3 years has been sad. I know some of your staff. You need to take a look around at what you've done and what you've let happen. As someone who has been here since the beginning (like, the actual beginning), this is just so sad. I'd already closed my accounts after /u/spez's antics and bullshit, but this is just it. I'm going to cross over the dark side and start finding some other alternatives to reddit. I'd rather kill myself because they all seem to be alt-right shitholes, but seriously, I'm not giving you another minute of my eyeballs.


r/redesign • • Jul 24 '18

can you guys stop forcing people to use this ugly re-design?

4 Upvotes

Seriously who had the shit idea to make this? This new design is ugly, let people be with the old design by default and if they feel like they wanna change, make it an option, not the other way around.

Every time I create a new account im forced to spam "opt for redesign", this is fucking annoying, nobody likes this shit.


r/redesign • • Jun 03 '18

reddit needs to have a site wide poll to see who is in favor of the redesign

4 Upvotes

If the majority vote against the redesign, revert it back and have the redesign as an opt-in option.

This site is nothing without its users, and there are a lot of users who are at the point of leaving this site over all this bullshit.

You're digging your own grave


r/redesign • • May 20 '18

Reddiquette forbids taking moderation positions where your employment or biases could pose a conflict of interest with the “user driven nature of Reddit”. Reddit should honor the spirit of Reddiquette by not censoring user feedback about the redesign in r/redesign

29 Upvotes

The actionable suggestion in this post is for the admins to follow Reddiquette to the extent possible:

Please Don’t: Take moderation positions in a community where your profession, employment, or biases could pose a direct conflict of interest to the neutral and user driven nature of reddit.

Now clearly, it’s unavoidable to have Reddit moderate itself, but Reddit could maintain the spirit of Reddiquette by remaining as hands off regarding redesign feedback as it has done in the past.

These removals were supposedly done in the name of curation (this is not a comprehensive list):

I don’t think any of these posts should have been removed, and my suggestion is that posts like these should not be removed in the future.


r/redesign • • May 06 '18

I actually really like the redesign

6 Upvotes

I think it looks neat!


r/redesign • • May 09 '18

How do I permanently remove this abortion of a design?

3 Upvotes

Every time I click a reddit.com link, I get thrown on to the disgusting, vomit inducing new layout. How can I permanently redirect all reddit links to old.reddit.com?


r/redesign • • May 06 '18

Boooooooooo

2 Upvotes

This reminds me of Facebook when they just change shit and the attitude is like "get over it." I'm here to support r/GreenBayPackers and how it is really bad to those that work so hard to give their subreddit a unique look.


r/redesign • • Jan 11 '19

Design I hate everything About this

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/redesign • • Apr 25 '18

Absolutely loving the redesign!!

3 Upvotes

I really love the redesign!


r/redesign • • Jul 09 '18

LPT: Use https://old.reddit.com/ to browse reddit using the old design. It loads more quickly and it's a bit more intuitive. Assuming everyone knows this, but for those that don't there ya go.

Thumbnail
self.lifeprotips
3 Upvotes

r/redesign • • Jun 21 '18

Any chance of aborting redesign?

5 Upvotes

I have seen a lot of people dislike the redesign. I personally hate it.

I'd cite Digg and Lifehacker as examples of a redesign killing a site (for me at least). I happen to like reddit- and don't want to see the same fate fall upon it. Any chance of getting the redesign reverted? Pack it up, try again? I'm using old.reddit but I've heard threats of this going away any time now. And honestly, if it does, so will I as a user.

A long list of gripes, but I personally hate the way each post pops up and if you accidentally click in the margin, the entire post goes away. It seems that we're going backwards to circa 2007 web design conventions. I hate the "feel" of the design, as well as the "look." It really is going backwards IMHO.


r/redesign • • Aug 24 '18

WOW. What a slap in the face experience.

1 Upvotes

So I moderate a little sub, and lately I've had issues with people not following the basic rules. Turns out, the whole sidebar doesn't appear on the redesign. Uhhhm, okay? So I have to opt into the redesign to set it.

Thanks so much for telling me that. The sidebar is a huge piece of information for a lot of these things, and it's gone 6+ months without being visible to the poor kids who don't know how to opt-out.

..Here goes.

I enable it, now everything's laggy as fuck, it took me 3 minutes to find the "new post" option on this shitty sub because of my small screen resolution, it takes 4 seconds to open the widgets tab, I have no customization compared to the old Reddit, it's unresponsive, looks like shit and as a moderator of several subs I'm expected to do this shit to all of them?

What the fuck Reddit?


r/redesign • • Jul 10 '19

Design Please tell me I'm not the only person that constantly clicks this X expecting it to clear the contents of the search box?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/redesign • • Jul 19 '18

I hate the new design

1 Upvotes

how the hell do i keep the old original design permanently cause i cant stand this ugly design it reminds me when youtube tried out this crap and now we cant go back to the better design. So can someone tell me how to go back to the better design or is there a way to edit the cookie so i can go back


r/redesign • • May 03 '18

Why is reddit trying to become facebook?

3 Upvotes

The redesign is basically a clone of facebook. That begs the question, why?

Is there any reason other than ad revenue?


r/redesign • • May 03 '18

I hope you realize that you are going the way of Digg

3 Upvotes

There have been changes to Reddit. I was using a now long dead account when Reddit first implemented Subreddits. There was a freak out then, but this is different. What is great about Reddit is its simplicity, easy sorting method, and the uniqueness of all subs. All subs are now identical and it is no longer as simple. If you lose the features that things like CSS brings to the table you become any old forum site. There is a reason I use (and even pay for) Reddit over them.

I dare you to do a survey tomorrow. Every person who logs in tomorrow is given a simple 3 choice quiz. Which do you prefer? The old reddit, the redesign, or do you like them about the same? I would bet that >80% of people entering Reddit Tomorrow will select the Old Reddit.


r/redesign • • Nov 27 '18

New reddit is still awful and here's why.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
3 Upvotes

r/redesign • • Sep 27 '18

Feature Request Subreddit level opt-out

0 Upvotes

As a Moderator, we have to support two different reddit interfaces. Apparently, the rules are limited to just 10. Also, our hard work for our css is just going down the drain . Please, for the love of god, give us an optout.

The day reddit closes """"old""""" reddit, is the day i and a LOT of my fellow Moderators will leave the site.

Edit: fu


r/redesign • • Jun 11 '19

display username when logged in!

Post image
0 Upvotes