r/ideasfortheadmins • • Feb 08 '13

Turning off private messages.

1.8k Upvotes

Hellllooooo Admins!

I'm a relatively new user of Reddit but I have discovered a bit of an annoying aspect that I'd like to request a future enhancement. I love the unread tab in the message area for new updates to the posts I've made, It helps me to navigate to new content that I can read and respond to. My issue: a lot of what now fills my unread page are private messages asking for autographs, can I call someone, could I donate, etc...

I would like the ability to turn off inbox private messages on my account. Mabye with an option to allow messages from moderators.

OR - maybe separate out the tabs so unread replies to posts are on one page and unread private messages appear on a separate tab that I can choose to ignore.

I thank you for your time.

My best, Bill


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jan 14 '22 Bless Up Bravo

It's 2022 and we still can't change our Reddit usernames?

1.6k Upvotes

I know this has been discussed a lot in the past, with the staff stating that it would be too difficult, and some community members fearing it would cause chaos.

I'm sorry staff, but saying it would be too difficult is just lazy. It sounds like it boils down to the fact that usernames are used as IDs in every database table. First of all, that's truly terrible design. But despite that, it's not that hard of a problem to solve, and any reasonably competent engineering team should be able to come up with a solution. My recommendation would be to simply continue using the current usernames as IDs for existing users, use UUIDs for new users, but allow users to set a new username value that is displayed on front-ends (require settings this for new users). If the display username is not set, then fall back to the legacy username/ID. That would require 1 new relational table (username/ID <> display username), and a handful of front-end changes wherever the username is shown in the apps.

And for the community members claiming "it would be too chaotic". This just isn't true. Literally every single other social media platform allows you to change your username/handle, and it's not a problem. Some restrict how frequently you can change it, which is fine, and Reddit could take that approach if it helps mitigate concerns.

Come on Reddit. It's 2022. Give us this feature.

Edit: why am I being downvoted...?


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Mar 23 '21

New Reddit There is a severe lack of diversity in the hair of the avatar maker. 44 straight hairstyles, 9 curly ones (that are bad). The support for these additions (which took me 20 minutes) is overwhelming. Read comments for more!

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jan 07 '12

REQUEST: Because NSFW does not mean NSFL. (SFW) [x-post /r/pics] NSFW

1.5k Upvotes

I was told to post this here, so as the title suggests here is my request.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Apr 28 '12

Looking for admin support against CISPA in the form of a Reddit blackout.

980 Upvotes

I started a thread in politics, trying to get some support against CISPA.

http://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/swseu/lets_get_reddit_inc_interested_in_opposing_cispa/

We're trying to gain some momentum so that we can get Reddit Inc. involved in opposing CISPA. We can do a "blackout" on our own, but it won't be nearly as effective. If we can't do the entire site, then perhaps you guys could help with a few subreddits or something? Or even if you just gave the link some publicity so that people can decide for themselves? I'm not one hundred percent on where to go with this. Any ideas are more than welcome.

I want to thank everyone for their ideas and participation. Trying to create some momentum and get people to contact those in power. Link


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Nov 08 '12

As an artist who has had my work front-paged on Reddit with no credit given I ask, why not add a 'creddit' section when submitting? (r-post from /r/AskReddit)

882 Upvotes

I first found out about reddit when someone posted a gaming sculpture I made and it front-paged. It was so exciting to get some attention for my piece, but so disappointing that no one knew where it came from, it was just another random picture on reddit.

Since then, I have tried to post my artwork first with a good amount of success, but have learned that linking to my facebook fan site always gets voted down, reddit just prefers image hosting sites like imgur. I've tried to credit as a comment, but since sourcing isn't very witty it tends to just get buried.

Of course, there are also the haters that attack me for posting my own stuff, calling it 'self-promotion', when I am really just trying to post from the source.

I feel that all this could be helped by the addition of an optional credit section when submitting, any generator of content should be recognized for their creations when possible


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jan 13 '11

New thumbnail for NSFW links NSFW

735 Upvotes

This is a thumbnail I created and has been getting some good responses so far from redditors.

http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/f1ar1/i_designed_a_different_thumbnail_for_links_to/

and here is a link to the lighter version: http://i.imgur.com/Tsk3o.png


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Mar 24 '12

Rank threads and the frontpage by discussion rather than by voting.

613 Upvotes

Currently, all of the ranking options for both links on the frontpage and for comment threads are based on some calculation of upvotes, downvotes, and time.

The frontpage can be ranked by: Hot, New, Controversial, and Top

Comment threads can be ranked by: Top, Hot, New, Controversial, Old, and Best

All of these ranking systems incorporate those same three elements – upvotes, downvotes, and time – but give them different importance or weighting.

A fourth element should be added: discussion.

One of the main complaints featured across reddit is the decline in content: links that do not attract good discussion and trivial comment threads dominating discussion.

Most of the observers over at /r/TheoryOfReddit have noted that voting tends to favor low-investment content: it's easier to upvote something simple, like an image macro or a pun thread, than it is to read and upvote a thoughtful piece of in-depth journalism or a long detailed comment.

Step 1:

Adding a new way to rank comment threads would be a good first step toward allowing users who prefer thoughtful and detailed comments to be able to avoid pun threads full of dispiriting one-liners and stale meme jokes. My proposal is not to get rid of upvotes, downvotes, and time in the calculation of comment ranking, but to add a heavily-weighted fourth criterion which is: the length of the comment and its children. This would prioritize comments that are both detailed themselves and those that generate subsequent detailed conversation/responses. The aggregate length of an entire thread of one-liners might be outweighed by a different thread consisting of one or two long comments.

Step 2:

Add a new way to rank the frontpage, based primarily on discussion+time rather than on upvotes/downvotes+time.

A major quantitative study of reddit noted that comment length on the frontpage declined – older comments were 2–3x longer than those that appear on the frontpage currently. The author then demonstrated that the subreddits with the most trivial, low-investment content (nsfw, gonewild, pics, funny, videos, trees, wtf) also feature comments with the shortest length compared to subreddits with in-depth or intellectually-stimulating content (philosophy, truereddit, economics) – here's the chart.

Ranking the frontpage based on the activity and quality of the conversation generated could produce a wildly different experience for users interested in engaging material and discussion rather than low-investment fluff. Using some weighted combination of the following criteria could produce a frontpage ranked by quality discussion rather than by upvotes+downvotes+time:

  • Average (or median) comment length;

  • Total amount of comment text; and,

  • Commenting activity (comments per unit of time).

Hacker News already has an alternate frontpage ranking algorithm that shows stories by the activity of discussion. I believe their source code is open, so that may be a good example or first pass of a system that could be adapted to work here.

Potential Issues

First, what role do upvotes and downvotes play in a system like this? I think will still have a role, especially in downvoting abusive or spam comments below the threshold for visibility. My proposal is not to entirely remove upvotes/downvotes from ranking comment threads, but to change the weighting to favor comment length and discussion more heavily than the other traditional factors. As far as upvotes/downvotes on the frontpage, I suppose they would still matter insofar as you want other people (especially those not ranking the frontpage by discussion) to see content that you value. Finally, upvotes will still accrue to a user's karma as a reward for their contributions (or downvotes as punishment).

Second, will the frontpage be utterly dominated by AskReddit? Maybe, but probably not. AskReddit seems to be only slightly above average in terms of comment length, even though popular AskReddit threads generate disproportionately large numbers of comments. Reddit has already developed ways to make sure that users' frontpages have a healthy mix of stories from gigantic subreddits and obscure subreddits, making frontpage placement relative to subreddit size. The same mechanism should, in principle, work with a ranking system centered on discussion rather than voting.

Third, can this system be gamed? Yes, but perhaps not as easily as upvoting circlejerks. Spammers could start dumping walls of nonsense text into threads. Hopefully this can be countered with good old downvoting and moderation. This type of behavior is probably more transparently spamming than pay-for-upvote networks of dummy accounts, and may actually make countering spammers easier. It's harder to drive a thread or link up to the top of the rankings by making detailed on-topic comments than by clicking the upvote arrow. Finally, unless ranking-by-discussion is made the default method of ranking the frontpage, it's unlikely that spammers and SEO agents will specifically target it for exploitation.

Conclusion

We need a way to preserve constructive interaction in the face of Eternal September's onslaught of trivial low-investment content. People need to be able to see that the effort it takes to write out a constructive contribution to the community is going to be seen and rewarded rather than lost in a sea of one-liner stale jokes.

Because writing long comments and engaging in discussion is a better indicator of engaging material than an upvote is, and is a better measurement indicator for discriminating between low-investment and high-investment content, giving redditors the option to rank content by quality discussion can help preserve a core community of users committed to making informative and interesting contributions.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Apr 29 '20

Make reddit great again! Integrate redgifs (for adult gifs) just like gfycat.

590 Upvotes

Since gfycat is moving all adult content to it's sister site (redgifs) it would be nice to have redgifs with the same functionality as gfycat.

Make the gifs embeded on reddit. That would be awesome.

Thanks


r/ideasfortheadmins • • May 02 '14

How about a rule that no one person can moderate more than 10 different Reddits?

589 Upvotes

A few users I have seen who are mods in some of the most "war torn" or "drama filled" reddits have mod ownership of as much as 126 different reddits, or more. Nobody I know of has the time for that many unless they are being paid to do the work. Thus, in order to crack down on "professional mods' I would like a rule to be placed that limits the number of reddits a persons account can be the moderator of at one time to a reasonable limit of 10 or so at the same time.

This number of 10 that I chose randomly doesn't need to be an exact limit; it could just as reasonably be as much as 15, however anything over 25 seems unreasonable to me given the dedication, time, and effort needed to moderate a sub-reddit successful to the benefit of the greater community. It would also cut back severely on the number of people who basically get paid to collect reddits, parrot and promote things/manage the social graph, etc in different reddit's and I think that removal of the abuse that is currently happening in a lot of reddits is an important thing for the reddit community as whole.

Even if it cant be proven that individual people are acting as bad apples, this would at least mitigate the risk of people being able to create a power base in order to do so.

Edit:

A lot of good feedback in this thread so to be fair let me clarify a few points:

  1. If a reddit has a low sub rate it really doesn't make sense for a limit on the number to be in place unless it grows; but once it does the limits should be enforced for non-NSFW related reddits. As the community grows, so does its needs, and so its only fair to your users that you give them more attention.

  2. There is currently a rule that states one user is allowed to moderate no more than 3 default subreddits. Should this be restricted more to a lower number? We think so.

  3. Maybe we create these restrictions for Reddit's that only that have at least 100k subscribers or more?

For example would the following make sense:

No one user account can be the mod of no more than:

  1. A limit of only 2 'default' reddits. This would restrict the current rule from 3 to 2 and spread out the power a bit.

  2. No more than 10 reddits that contain more than a 1,000,000 sub'ed users each. Most users wouldn't hit this limit at all and redirect groups wouldn't be hit either as nobody subs them.

  3. No more than 50 reddits that contain more than 100,000 sub'ed users. Most users wouldn't hit this limit at all and redirect groups wouldn't be hit either as nobody subs them. People who modded reddits that had 1,000,000 subs would have these reddits count against this total, as this count is above the 50k limit.

  4. No more than 100 reddits total, no matter their activity or subs. This is to stop the most extreme forms of abuse and most users would not be hit by this.

  5. The NSFW Subs are an issue; but nobody says why and nobody can prove why so we are still waiting for people to answer this question. Still, mods should work with the community not against it.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Apr 15 '13

Different colored "NSFW" buttons depending on what kind of post it is (x-post /r/Crazyideas) NSFW

526 Upvotes

Like orangered for porn, red for gore/disgusting things, black for death, yellow for anything else.

I'm tired of not knowing what will be inside of a post.

Edit: periwinkle for NSFW text posts


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Feb 23 '26 Bravo

Reddit App Please stop taking away /r/all from the iOS app

496 Upvotes

My idea is to add back access to r/all on the mobile app. A month or so ago, the same thing happened and was quickly reversed. It seems to be on a per-account basis, because I can switch to another account and it changes the layout back.

Just hide it somewhere, please. 90% of the time when I’m browsing Reddit, it’s exclusively through r/all .

Edit: locking the thread was a weird decision. Sure, there was a lot of talking shit about Reddit as a platform, but that’s what happens when you remove a feature that a lot of people use. Feels like sticking your fingers in your ears and yelling “LALALA” because you don’t like what is being said.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Sep 26 '25 Wholesome Seal

User Settings Can we go back to when users couldn't hide their profile history?

461 Upvotes

This change has made it more difficult to tell who is a bot/troll and who is legitimate. With the ever increasing amount of bots on this site, I don't understand why Reddit made this update when the site is largely anonymous anyway.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Dec 11 '24 Take My Silver Heart of Silver

User Settings A suggestion regarding the removal of the previous UI

447 Upvotes

In settings there should be an option underneath preferences saying "UI layout" or just "Layout" providing three options

Old *when hovering over this option would show an image example of what it looks like, this will save users time so they don't have to click it to see what it looks like*

New(Or any word you find suitible for the UI that we had when replacing www. with new./the one before this current one) *same thing happens when hovering over this option*

Newest(or if renaming the "new" option you can rename this one as new) *Same hovering function*

also for the previous UI to have the option that is in this current UI which is to search in someone's profile for something specific like for example if you went to someone profile and clicked search and searched "Cody the dog" for example only things where the words "Cody the dog" was mentioned will appear but only from the user's profile, I find this option useful for finding something specific.

overall I think adding this new option of choosing UI version preferences will make many users very happy!

This option would be nice to be available on both Mobile and the desktop site and I think it would bring users who have quit due to the enforcement of the newest UI back due to them being able to go back to their preferred layout.

Please forgive me if there's any poor English or explaining!

Also please forgive me again if this is the incorrect flair I'm not sure which flair is suitable since this is a suggestion including both new, newest and old reddit and also mobile and desktop site suggestion, I put the user setting flair on since the main idea is for the suggestion to be a setting in user settings ^^


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Nov 29 '10

Custom stylesheets need a larger capacity

427 Upvotes

Recently, a lot of subs have been using a tagging system. For those of you who don't know what that is, take a trip over to :

That's around 35,000 users in these 7 subs alone who use the tagging system. These are just 6 of the subs I know of that use tags, I am sure there are many more.

Look at the extra items beside some of the usernames.

philkav becomes philkav(philkav1989)[360]

These are redditor's gamertags and platforms for when they playing online.

This is done by adding the following CSS :

.author[href$="/philkav"]:after {content: "(philkav1989)[360]" !important}

The 2 subs I moderate have over 2,500 members each (a lot of the same people, but it's still a large range of users). The problem is, not everyone can get one of these tags as the stylesheets only allow something like 100kb of data* . It would be great if the capacity of the custom stylesheets was increased because both my subs ( r/mw2 and r/codbo ) are completely full and r/codbo has a backlog of about 500 users waiting to get their gamertag and platform appended onto their name . I know I'm not the only moderator who is having this problem.

*I could be completely wrong with this number


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jul 25 '25

Moderator Idea: Add a rule that prohibits moderators from banning users for using other subreddits

359 Upvotes

I see a lot of people being banned from certain subreddits for simply interacting with a subreddit that the other subreddit dislikes.

Many subreddits will ban people for simply interacting with subreddits with different religious and political beliefs. With many larger subreddits doing this.

It makes me scared to interact with new subreddits as I could be banned for simply commenting on a post.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Dec 28 '17

As reddit grows, newer posts naturally aggregate higher vote counts which means that in most cases a subreddit's "Top: Year" and "Top: All Time" are identical. Please give us an option to pick "Top: Year=XXXX" i.e. "Top: 2014" or "Top: 2009" That way great older content isn't impossible to find.

346 Upvotes

As a non-programmer this seems like it would be pretty easy to incorporate, so I'm naturally looking forward to hearing how it's impossible.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Aug 08 '10

Can we get the option to add a NSFW tag AFTER a post has been submitted? NSFW

328 Upvotes

Either from the OP or even a way for other users to vote the tag in afterwards. This recent post of dog mutilation on the front page is a perfect example of why it's needed. Maybe a link or button that people click, maybe with a caption that says something like "other users have suggested this post be marked as NSFW" so people can vote it NOT to be NSFW if it really isn't. And the ability for the OP to enable it on a whim would be great too.

Original post with comments: http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/cyuof/hey_reddit_can_we_get_an_option_to_add_a_nsfw_tag/

EDIT: A lot of people use the NSFW outside of work to decide whether to view questionable content or not. The NSFW tag doesn't apply to only people at work who shouldn't be surfing in the first place.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Nov 17 '18

Make another NSFW tag and separate porn from violence. I'm tired of getting my boner ruined by mass genocides. NSFW

Thumbnail
self.crazyideas
289 Upvotes

r/ideasfortheadmins • • Oct 08 '25

Feeds Why does Reddit refuse to give us the ability to block subreddits?

280 Upvotes

I'm not interested in muting. I want to BLOCK subreddits as in never seeing them regardless if I'm searching or on all. For a website full of spam, this doesn't seem like we're asking much here.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • May 03 '14

Give active sub users the ability to vote in/out mods

274 Upvotes

Purpose

We need to restore trust to Reddit. It has been reported that some mods are abusing their position - giving all mods a bad name. That they are pushing content from certain publishers, and silencing others, and being rewarded for their activity on the side.

We submit that this fundamentally compromises Reddit as a channel for free speech. And we ask that we be given a mechanism for active users of a sub to vote for the addition/removal of users as mods of that sub.

Mechanism

Any active user of a sub can create a post that has a special tag in it with a username of a mod, and a flag indicating whether they should be added/removed. After a certain amount of time (say 10 days), if the number of upvotes is greater that 50% of all the existing active users in the sub, then the mod changes are automatically committed.

Some specifics...

  • Active users are defined as subscribed users that have accumulated 50 post+comment karma in that sub each quarter over the last six quarters. (obviously these numbers are up for debate).

  • The post cannot be removed by the mods.

  • Multiple users can be set in the post for addition/removal.

  • The list of users proposed cannot be edited after posting.

  • Voting forces CAPTCHA. (bot prevention)

  • Activity on Reddit in general requires a CAPTCHA every six months upon login. (prevent bots from maintaining accounts)

(Optional) It also goes without saying that it would be great to have more transparency on what mods are doing. The posts/comments they've removed (omitting the content if they say it was a privacy violation or malware link, child porn, etc...). As well as aggregate numbers on which mods have removed how many posts/comments over the last 6 months.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jan 21 '12

On behalf of the entire book and TV-show subreddit communities I humbly request a real spoiler tag.

274 Upvotes

I am not referring to the black text spoiler tags in comments, I speak of spoiler tags on posts.

I'm a mod of /r/mylittlepony, and we currently use the NSFW tag as a spoiler tag, because we don't allow NSFW posts.

What's nice about this is we can, as mods, set any post as a spoiler without the user tagging it. It also lets the users not have to include the word "spoiler" in their posts. It hides the thumbnail, and lets the browsers know what they're getting into.

Although the nsfw tag serves our purposes, we get a lot of modmails like this, as our posts appear to be "NSFW" on /r/all when really they aren't.

Please, I implore you guys, consider adding a real Spoiler tag for posts.

It would have the EXACT same functionality as the NSFW tag, except that you would be able to enable/disable it in the community setting section, and it would be titled "Spoiler" with it's own thumbnail. That way mods/posters can set something to be a spoiler after the fact. Another helpful (possible) feature would be to have a checkmark in the sidebar that hides all spoiler posts when checked, so people can browse the sub without worry.

This is not just our subreddit either, many other TV show, book, and even game subreddits have this same problem, and they all have their own workarounds for it. (/r/skyrim, /r/gameofthrones, /r/breakingbad (uses our same system of nsfw), /r/doctorwho to name a few) They all, however, pale in comparison to a real, actual, supported spoiler tag.

Thanks so much for reading this, keep being awesome.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Mar 26 '26

Feeds Give us back r/all!

273 Upvotes

r/all was my and many other's preferred way to use reddit. Without it I will use the site far less, and I doubt having its users spend less time on the site is what reddit wants.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jun 17 '11

User tagging

222 Upvotes

It seems that tagging specific users in subreddits has big advantages:

Reddits that utilise "tagging" usually resort to user-specific CSS to display a badge/crest/label next to the comments of particular users. If mods were allowed to maintain lists of categories/tags to assign to specific usernames then the complexity is moved from CSS to simple list maintenance.

I suggest that we allow mods to categorise users to make this easier. As a moderator, I would like to be able to do the following:

  • Create and maintain a list of tags/categories

  • Associate user names with these tags

  • Use CSS selectors associated with the tag (e.g. .tag-chemistry)

Thoughts? Improvements?