r/redditmade • • Nov 07 '14

What the hell is this? Nice "featured campaign" guys. You are killing any shred of legitimacy this site had with this type of behavior.

0 Upvotes

Every few hours I check to see if the ranking system updated, wondering why my shirt isn't up near the top even though it has a sale. Yes, I purchased the shirt, but that's specifically allowed. Ok, no problem, I really don't care if it gets funded or not, just having some fun.

Then I see this:

https://redditmade.com/browse?page=2

At the time of posting, it is the first image on the second page.

https://redditmade.com/campaign/boulder-dash-30th-anniversary-got-boulders-t-shirt

Created on November 6, 2014 by /u/robotron4 for /r/BoulderDash

It is a "Featured Campaign" because it is "officially supported" by the subreddit.

robotron4 is a moderator of /r/BoulderDash. Essentially no activity on this account (2 posts at this time, 1 month old account.)

/r/BoulderDash has no activity. No posts at all. 1 month old subreddit. Created by /u/rhygaar, who is a product manager at reddit and one of the heads of the redditmade product.

Now we get to the real problem, and it should be obvious, this is a huge fucking conflict of interest. Like, I can't even imagine the thought process that went through rhygaar's mind that made him think this was acceptable to do.

Now, I don't know if rhygaar and robotron4 are actually the same person, but that is not even relevant. rhygaar is the creator of the subreddit and "head" mod. The timing of the creation of the subreddit and creation of robotron4 account give the appearance of impropriety, and that's not OK.

The ranking algorithm is not public. Beyond ranking (some) campaigns which have people backing it, we have absolutely no way of knowing how they are choosing what shirts go where.

It doesn't seem to rank by "new" because I can see other shirts just below this with the same goal, same number of sales (which is 1), with older ones outranking new ones.

Now OK, I get what the main reactions are going to be to my post. "Relax dude, all the profits go to charity anyways." That's not the point. rhygaar has direct control over what the profits are. Other users are busting their asses coming up with great designs, why is this one outranking them?

And on top of that, it's just not even a good product. It's a shill job for a game. If it was actually a great product, I would be willing to let everything slide, but it isn't. It is nothing more than an advertisement. It even has the fucking facebook page for the game in the description. The only person backing it is the creator (or a friend/co-worker of the creator).

redditmade in its current incarnation is a bust.

I don't know if its the team running it or what, but it is so poorly mismanaged I don't know what else to say. It's almost like this is a long-con April Fools joke.


r/redditmade • • Oct 29 '14

My New Reddit Shirt!!!!!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Oct 30 '14

How do I get unbanned?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Oct 29 '14

Reddit Made RedditMade

2 Upvotes

Incredible

edit: wow thanks for the gold, whoever gave it


r/redditmade • • Nov 05 '14

My life is NSFW NSFW

Thumbnail redditmade.com
1 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Oct 29 '14

Putin T-Shirts

Thumbnail redditmade.com
0 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Oct 31 '14

Reddit is Love Reddit is Life Shirts, what do you think?

Thumbnail redditmade.com
0 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Dec 05 '14

What is this? Slurs are allowed? I can make a t-shirt that says anything I want? There are no rules?

Thumbnail redditmade.com
2 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Oct 29 '14

Bitcoin

0 Upvotes

So is this where I mine for bitcoins then?


r/redditmade • • Oct 29 '14

Can we please get this made! (Shirt)

0 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Nov 04 '14

[deleted]

Thumbnail redditmade.com
2 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Nov 10 '14

Maybe this gets asked a lot so I'm sorry. How do I upload an image and then match the background of the image to the shirt color?

2 Upvotes

Every time I upload an image there is the shirt color, then a box of my image background color, then my image. It looks terrible!


r/redditmade • • Dec 03 '14

Panzdemic

Thumbnail redditmade.com
4 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Dec 31 '14

Got my stuff! Now how or what exactly do I do with the box? Looks like it can be made into something

4 Upvotes

I'll post picture in a moment.


r/redditmade • • Oct 29 '14

Campaign declined by mods of a different subreddit

3 Upvotes

I submitted a campaign, and wanted to make it official for the r/fitness subreddit. Then I got an email saying that the mods of r/None declined my request. What's going on here?


r/redditmade • • Nov 03 '14

R.I.P. In Peace Shirt

Thumbnail redditmade.com
3 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Oct 31 '14

it's a subreddit

Thumbnail redditmade.com
1 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Nov 06 '14

I am trying to create my first campaign to raise funds for an indie game development and I need your opinions

1 Upvotes

I was thinking of maybe writing - "Better RED than dead" alongwith a pic of reddit and its name on a red tshirt for 1$ profit per tshirt.

Or maybe something related to animals?

I am trying to collect greenlight funds for a friend's game through this campaign and any ideas (maybe related to gaming) would be appreciated and that how many of you would actually but it. :)


r/redditmade • • Oct 30 '14

Khaleesi

Thumbnail redditmade.com
0 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Oct 29 '14

I created /r/TheBestOfRedditMade to display the best products on redditmade, and allow displaying of products by the upvote system.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
12 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Oct 29 '14

Can A Web Start-Up Launch A Campaign?

4 Upvotes

Is this allowed? The reddit audience rules and we'd rather do a campaign here than on the other crowdfunding platforms.


r/redditmade • • Jan 24 '15

redditmade Bi-Weekly Update (01/24/15)

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

Welcome to this week's redditmade update!

The Updates

  • We're back and in our new offices!

  • Custom campaign variations are live

Coming soon

  • More custom campaigns

  • Payment method update for customers

The holidays have come and gone, and our team has (sort of) settled into our new offices in San Francisco. Things are beginning to move forward again. As the office comes together, we're busy refining the 2015 for redditmade, with a focus on getting the product out of BETA this Spring. That means you'll be seeing more functional improvements than new features until then. With that in mind, I'm rolling us back to bi-weekly updates.

/u/Bradofarrell is working hard to get through proposals and create a better offering of products.

Thanks!


r/redditmade • • Oct 29 '14

Are we supposed to add pricing tiers?

2 Upvotes

A few things I was wondering about:

Are we supposed to add pricing tiers? Can we use early bird incentives like kickstarter?

Should there be some kind of timeline function to deliver products? I would like to tell my buyers an estimate delivery time.


r/redditmade • • Nov 14 '14

IT'S TOO SOON FOR CHRISTMAS MUSIC

Thumbnail redditmade.com
0 Upvotes

r/redditmade • • Nov 27 '14

Snoo Mascot High Quality

Thumbnail redditmade.com
2 Upvotes