Ran doesn't believe anymore that humans will return to the type of lifestyle we've had for 99% of our species' history. Ran and most of us consider civilization to be somewhat of a nightmare, thus we're drawn to evidence that would suggest that the effects of the Neolithic revolution are a temporary anomaly in our species' history. With that cognitive bias to which I fall victim kept in the back of my mind, I'd like to look at the evidence for the case that civilization is a temporary anomaly.
Fossil fuels still occupy 87% of global energy production.1 We know that this situation can't be sustained forever. Gail Tverberg argues that we'll hit peak fossil fuel consumption in 2015, limiting us to a 2 degree temperature increase compared to pre-industrial.2 Experiments with carbon capture and storage have completely failed.3 If it turns out that the "optimistic" projections of unconventional fossil fuel use are correct, then we'll be dealing with an even higher temperature increase, perhaps anywhere from four degree Celsius to six degree.
Which brings me to the next point. There's a lag to the effects of just about anything we do. The amount of carbon we've emitted isn't done raising our temperature yet. If civilization were to stop emitting greenhouse gases today, we'd still witness a 0.4 degree Celsius temperature increase over the coming decades. There's then a lag in the response of the ecosystem to that temperature increase. Species take time to migrate to new areas, trees take time to die or grow in new habitable environments, parasites may have to wait with settling until that new ecosystem is functional, and so forth.
Agriculture as we know it is really only a viable survival strategy under rather specific climatic conditions. You need a gentle climate, with few weather extremes. If precipitation happens in strong downpours, the effect is to destroy the soil. Tropical forests have the ability to suck up water during such downpours and emit water during droughts, thus providing greater stability for the entire ecosystem. Agricultural fields can't do that, so those fields suffer soil erosion during downpours, while the plants die during droughts.
Africa will be first to run into problems. During the past thirty years, the rate of soil erosion has increased 20-fold.4 The effects of agriculture are already turning the continent into a wasteland as we speak. Globally, half of the world's fertile soil has been lost in the past 150 years. According to the WWF, in the past fifty years, a third of the world's arable land has been lost.5 Thus it's clear that this is a problem that's accelerating.
Why don't we notice anything going wrong, if we've destroyed half of the world's fertile soil already in the past 150 years? The answer is because so far we've had the ability to move on to new places to colonize and extract. The global land grab in Africa is happening for exactly that reason. It's a temporary solution however, as Africa has such vulnerable soils. Another part of the equation is that fossil fuels have effectively turned us into Gods over our ecosystem. They allow us to extract the particular few minerals we need to create life in a soil that can no longer sustain life by itself. We ship phosphorus from Morocco all over the world and together with nitrogen that we artificially fixate from the air with natural gas use it to make a soil able to host life. Because the soil is dead, the plants are weak, which we hide through the application of fungicides and a variety of other pesticides, like a kid kept isolated in a bubble because it was born without a functional immune system.
Fossil fuels have so far allowed us to mask most of the effects that climate change is having. When we lose the fossil fuels, we will have to practice agriculture in a global climate that's simply completely different from the one we had before we started using fossil fuels. One effect that is clear is that plants become more vulnerable to a variety of pathogens, through multiple mechanisms. Plants benefit from the temperature drops that happen at night, because those kill off many fungal pathogens. Most of the increase in global temperatures from the greenhouse effect happens at night however. In addition, studies under isolated circumstances, where atmospheric carbon dioxide is increased to simulate a future environment, tend to find that necrotrophic fungi benefit from elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide. Fungi for which the beneficial effects of higher atmospheric CO2 concentrations are most clear are those that infect wheat plants, like stem rust.6 Also important to note is that climate change causes a global increase in humidity, which also tends to benefit plant pathogens like stem rust.
What's important to keep in mind here is that we already suffer the effects of fungal pathogens on our crops. Right now, our fossil fuels and global economy allow us to respond effectively to that. To get rid of stem rust, we looked for a particular variety somewhere that happened to be genetically resistant to stem rust. Through our global economy we then managed to introduce that particular variety around the whole world. Thus agriculture has so far become more effective over the past two centuries, continually increasing yields, reducing necessary labor and eliminating pathogens that threaten our crops.
One unexpected benefit effect that's easy to underestimate is the delaying effect pesticides have on the evolution of pathogens. If there are 1 billion stem rust spores produced every day globally, the rate of new mutations can be expected to be a thousand times lower than if there were 1 trillion stem rust spores produced every day globally. By applying fungicides, we give ourselves an advantage in the evolutionary arms race, because the pathogens we have to fear now can not evolve as rapidly as they could evolve if we did not apply those fungicides.
This doesn't mean that we're going to witness a global extermination of grasses. Climate change is believed to make our climate rather similar to the Pliocene. The temperate climates where we now witness grasslands tended to have forests. C4 carbon fixation practicing grasses survived in those places where temperatures are relatively high, because their carbon fixation mechanism loses less water while fixating carbon, thus they have an edge over other plants there.
Plants coped with the increases pathogen burden they suffered through biodiversity. If you have a field where one species of grass grows, it's vulnerable to fungal pathogens. If a hundred different types of grass grow there, out of which just a few can harbor one particular fungal pathogen, that fungal pathogen species may never reach critical mass. Agriculture is not really a viable survival strategy under those conditions, since agriculture tends to require the practice of monoculture. You focus your effort on selectively breeding one species to produce better nutrition for humans. Note that the effects of soil erosion would also increase under those climatic conditions.
When it comes to pastoralism, it has to be noted that anthropologists don't really believe that pastoralism ever occurs in isolation. Pastoralists continually interact with agricultural settlements, exchanging their resources with one another. Pastoralist communities also tend to be very vulnerable to having their animals lost to predator species. Those were historically exterminated, but such extermination is somewhat difficult if you have very large densely forested areas and don't have high population density farming settlements to fall back on.
There are other potential problems I haven't addressed. For every two degree increase in global temperatures, the number of Katrina magnitude storms is expected to increase tenfold.7 This would have the ability to greatly reduce human carrying capacity. More importantly, ecological simulations tend to show delayed effects of a rapid population growth of a particular species on other species, that will seek to utilize the new ecological niche.
A number of diseases are crossing species into our human population. HIV has been successful in this, measles entered the human population from rinderpest somewhere around the 11th century AD, Ebola may be gaining a foothold right now, while in Saudi Arabia MERS seems to have crossed species. The explosion in human population is a very recent phenomenon, the effects it has are still revealing themselves. Note that studies find that malaria simply can't gain a foothold in places where human population density is relatively low (3.3 per square km) and too many non-human mammal species live, because the malaria parasite ends up entering animals from which it can't spread.8
In an effort to survive, the whole non-human biosphere is trying to figure out how to survive in the new ecological niches that we have created, often at our cost. They have no other choice, because the total biomass of humans is now an order of magnitude higher than the total biomass of non-human terrestrial vertebrates. I expect that we will simply return to the level of population density found in hunter-gatherers.
References
1 - http://www.energymanagertoday.com/fossil-fuels-dominate-global-energy-consumption-096446/ 2 - http://ourfiniteworld.com/2014/04/11/oil-limits-and-climate-change-how-they-fit-together/ 3 - http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-09-20/norway-drops-moon-landing-as-mongstad-carbon-capture-scrapped.html 4 - http://www.worldwatch.org/node/554 5 - http://wwf.panda.org/what_we_do/footprint/agriculture/impacts/soil_erosion/ 6 - http://www.reddit.com/r/deep_ecology/comments/22utzi/response_of_wheat_fungal_diseases_to_elevated/ 7 - http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2013/03/19/1741861/five-katrinas-a-decade-warming-projected-to-boost-extreme-storm-surges-ten-fold/ 8 - http://www.plosntds.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pntd.0002139