r/ranprieur • • Oct 02 '21

Dark Ages

24 Upvotes

We call them "dark" because few records survive.

Where I work, at a large university, this is already true. We regularly have people wanting to retire and in need of records from earlier decades, but we often can't retrieve them. Faculty hired in the 70s and 80s are most at risk of this, but it can affect anyone hired before we switched to our current computer system in 2001. At least we try, though, and will make a diligent search of our microfiche.

We contract with a fellow state agency that brokers our medical insurance policies, and their records only go back to 1999. They won't even attempt to retrieve old records, and sometimes people need them in order to prove how long they've been insured. Maybe the agency doesn't have them. Since they are required by state law to open insurance contracts for bids every five years, we can't even tell someone who their direct insurance provider might have been, although those records are probably gone as well.

Oh, and that state agency we broker with? Supposedly it's a "forever" contract. Where is that contract? No one knows. Many attempts have been made to locate it so we can understand its exact terms, but we can't find it. No one even seems to know when it was signed, although it was probably in the early 90s. The partnering agency says they can't find it. Does that mean we even have a contract? Who the hell knows?

This is a problem that will only get worse, and people would be well advised to keep paper records of anything that might be important in the future. Most of what we know about the past is saved by accident anyway. We're fools to think that this time will be any different.


r/ranprieur • • May 13 '20

Dropping Out with Ran Prieur - Hermitix Interview

Thumbnail
youtube.com
24 Upvotes

r/ranprieur • • Jun 12 '20

Getting This Off My Chest

21 Upvotes

From a thread below u/2handband2, you write

I miss the old days, when Ran's forum was a bunch of would-be dropouts instead of would-be revolutionaries.

THEN WRITE ABOUT DROPPING OUT, not what opinions you want us all to hold about unrelated topics. This isn't r/politics and it certainly isn't r/Conservative. I'm not in love with every opinion Ran or the radical caucus expresses, but I know I'm not really going to change their mind. Shit, I've never even done drugs, I don't believe believe Ran's on the right track about ontology (but it'd be cool if he was), and I don't believe in the inevitability of progress -- so I don't really believe the pictures of the future "in a thousand years" Ran makes; I just think they are pretty word poems that can be enjoyed on their own terms.

But I'm not so stuffed with self-importance that I think I need to spam a response to each and every sentence I don't agree with AND share each and every one of my social and political pet peeves through the week.

Re-read this from u/the_doozers

it feels a little bit like when my cousin starts talking to me about UFOs. it's just not a conversation I'm interested in having with him. so I generally kind of wait him out with the bare minimum of engagement and he'll move on to talking about his garden or family stories or something else that I do like talking to him about.

it's also really exhausting to rehash these same things over and over again

From elsewhere in threadville you wrote:

Honestly I wouldn't know. The only blog I still read is Ran's.

This might actually be a useful moment here. First, I believe you. But I want you to understand you really do sound like you're just reading off conservative talking points.

How can this be? Well, you have the same mental structures as those pundits, which are talked about in the Big Five Trait model as high conscientiousness and lower (at least relative to most of us) Openness to new experience (more as an idea, than a practice. Again, my life has almost certainly been more square than yours. . . I just don't have moral disgust when people do stuff that is out of my frame of reference). More descriptive is Lakoff's view on conservative metaphors, in particular Strict Father morality, where you try to deflect legitimately bad things that can happen to people by bringing up whatever life lesson you want them to learn.

Anyone else with the same mental frameworks and a quick internet search can come up with the same points. Most of what you write on these topics isn't special or interesting, and you're exercising virtually none of your IQ in making them.

People who have been elsewhere on the internet 1. have seen them, 2. don't agree with them, 3. know they can't waste their entire life in discussion with people who hold the views, and 4. don't really trust you enough to discuss the matter with you.

If Ran was as boring (and/or bitter) of a leftist as you are a conservative, I'd never read him. (That's not to say you don't ever have any interesting comments, unique twists or information. But when you write these You Know What Grinds My Gears posts, they always suck).

You're confusing a lot of brainstorming for some kind of legal contract we're signing with the future. At least, that's what I know Ran is doing, as well as some of the weird posts that come up.

You and I might be the closest here in terms of what we think is going to actually happen. But you and I don't agree on what would be good, within the bounds of human nature. Still, it's a moot point because what we're going to get is the endgame of empire, consumerism and ecocide.

Lastly, just to piss everyone off a little bit, I taught what is now these young protesters. I know they aren't looking to be mentored by anyone or learn anything from the past. There is no point in trying.

I won't get the society I want, and you won't get any of your life lessons for rugged individuals.


r/ranprieur • • Mar 22 '16

A question to Ran from a reader

20 Upvotes

You touched upon this subject before and it's interesting to me, but you never really expanded on it.

Young people have no real option to change the course of the world, even though they're bound to inherit a dystopian mess. This is an issue I deal with, but I notice it's something that bothers my girlfriend and plenty of other people I speak to as well. It feels as if nothing we do on a daily basis genuinely matters. I noticed in my own experience that I stopped enjoying playing video games when I entered my twenties, although I did like it a lot when I was a teenager. The main reason I don't like it is because when I come home from a day of doing pretend-work that doesn't solve any genuine problems, I can't find fulfillment from more fake-activities.

How should people deal with the day to day confrontation with powerlessness? Is it sensible to compete with each other over a spot on the Steve Irwin, or should we jump into the conventional rat race and hope to end up with enough money to escape society some day in the future (or even forget we once hoped to escape), or should we simply sedate ourselves with hallucinogens, sex, video games and arthouse movies?


r/ranprieur • • Jun 23 '20

Dropout/ERE/NEET... practical thoughts

18 Upvotes

After the NEET thread the other day (I admit I had to look up the acronym), I reread How to Drop Out, marking probably the first time I've looked at it since 2010 or so. I also spot-read my copy of Dorothy Freed's wonderful Possum Living (if you don't have a copy, get one). As a veteran dropout, I have some thoughts regarding practical application.

  1. Dropping out is, at the end of the day, about three things. Housing, housing, and what was that third one again? Oh yeah: housing. Ignore anyone who tries to tell you that walkable urban centers are where it's at. This only works for people who are able to couch-surf, don't mind living on the street, or have sufficient funds to buy outright into very expensive property. The truth is, if you plan trips carefully, the total cost of car ownership is a tiny, tiny fraction of what most people spend on shelter every year.

Worse, the costs are either fixed or rising. You get locked into a mortgage, and you're trapped for thirty years. Rent is going to nothing but rise. Dolly Freed opens the housing chapter of her book with a sentence to the effect that if you don't own your shelter free and clear, you're still inextricably tied to the money economy. She's right.

The first and most important consideration for the would-be dropout is getting shelter costs as close to zero as possible. By moving to a rural community where RE is dirt-ass cheap and buying an old house that needed work, I was able to position myself so that I'm living here for the price of taxes (which are also cheap) and utilities. It wasn't what I originally envisioned, but I can't imagine a better outcome when you have kids and therefore can't risk illegal living arrangements. Which leads me to:

2) Opportunism is key. When I first joined the online community centered around Ran's writing, it was the old Yuku forum. The makeup was very different than what we have at present; it was mostly wannabe dropouts. I realized very quickly that most of them would never make it. In the 2014 update to How to Drop Out, Ran sums the situation up nicely:

The message I was aiming for was something like "If you have the mental focus and self-discipline to be successful in the dominant society, but you don't like it, here's how you can change your value system to reduce your need for money and status, and gain some benefits of industrial civilization without being in a position of forced obedience." Or: "Society is your enemy, it attacks you by making you need money, and if you are better than the average person at sacrificing comfort for long-term goals, you can work toward a position where you need relatively little money and have more free time."

Instead, through great carelessness, I allowed people to think my message was something like "If you can't even get good grades or hold down a job, don't worry, there is a gateway to a magical wonderland in the nearest dumpster." Or: "If you have a weak sense of who you are and you need an inspiring story to give your life meaning, how about being a heroic puritan like me, whose goal is to avoid guilt through an impossible lifestyle that has no connection to a society that is viewed as a cartoonish monolithic evil."

Many of them had a VERY fixed idea of what dropping out would look like, lacked the assets to achieve their visions or even an actionable plan for obtaining said assets, and got annoyed when anyone suggested they might have to modify their grandiose plans.

I remember... this is long after the old forum died. It had to have been right around five years ago, because it was just after I moved here. Someone was on this sub, talking about having a handful of likeminded friends looking for a cheap place to live in a semi-dropped-out setting. It so happened that this old quadplex was listed for sale right here in my town... for $24,000. Price probably negotiable. It was cheap because the pipes had burst and there was water damage. A few "likeminded dropouts" with moderate resources could probably have pooled their money and grabbed it for less than $20k. A snoopy belly-up to the windows revealed that the damage was not that bad, and the building in general was in excellent condition. This guy was all like no-no... not going out to live in bumblefuck. Gotta find an URBAN solution! My guess is that he's still looking. The building in question? It's now a pricey rental property.

The point is simply that dropping out is probably not going to look like what you thought it was going to look like. Don't get so married to a specific vision that the overriding goal of not needing a job gets lost. Ran says in the '08 update:

If you're interested in dropping out of society, you are also likely to reject society's rules, and try to replace them with counterculture rules or rules of your own invention. Humans are map-making animals, and we're always trying to make a map so good that we no longer have to look at the land. This is a mistake, and if you reject the dominant map, it's best to learn to not use any map at all. There is one rule that's very simple, but not easy: observe reality and adjust.

3) Car ownership is not really that terrible. The fact is, walkable == expensive. So you get a damn car, and you plan. How much is that car really costing you if you're only driving it once every two weeks? Spoiler: it's one HELL of a lot less than urban housing. If there's one aspect of dropping out in which I STRONGLY disagree with Ran, it's this one.

4) Yes, you're going to have to buy food. Maybe you can get food stamps, but some states make it harder than others for able-bodied childless adults to qualify. If you have kids, OTOH, it's probably not that hard to match the income requirements regardless of location.

Before you go nuts breaking ground for a garden, do some back-of-the-napkin math. What's going to take less labor and time: growing the food, or earning a little money to buy it? It you live in the US, the latter is almost certainly the right answer. Once again, at least if you live on this side of the pond, housing costs overwhelm all other considerations.

5) You might have to work up to it. PROBABLY will. At the time I transitioned over to dropout living I was going through a divorce that ate a fair chunk of my nest egg, but I still had enough to buy this house free and clear. I spent years getting to that point. You can't just decide to drop out and quit your job the next day.

6) You'll probably still have to earn some money. I have passive income, but even during the full-on dropout time I gave private music lessons and played in local bands to have money for extra stuff. If I didn't have kids, I might have skipped that. However... most of you probably don't have passive income. And no matter what certain pundits try to tell you, it's not that easy to set up. So expect to have to do SOMETHING from time to time to bring in cash. It helps if you have a skill people will pay real money for. What I charge for the music lessons comes out to around $50 an hour. If I had to sell gas for $8/hr, the picture would have been different.

7) This kind of leads to another thing. Skills. Part of low-cost living is not writing a check every time something breaks. Some of you might have heard this sermon from me before: any adult who cannot change a tire, check their oil, create a spreadsheet, replace a light fixture, care for a baby, repair a broken water pipe, balance a checkbook, and prepare a meal from raw ingredients, should go back and smack their parents for failing them. But the most important skill is simply the skill of acquiring skills. Are you the kind of person who can pull an all-nighter researching the principles by which your broken furnace operates, then proceed to troubleshoot and fix said furnace? That's the person you want to be.


r/ranprieur • • Dec 19 '13

TED-ism and Ran Prieur-ism

18 Upvotes

I just wanted to point out Ran's landmark post / link about TED-ism (Dec 18). I've been reading his blog for almost a decade now. And while it has been very useful in teaching me how to think, much in the way that Daniel Quinn's works are very useful in teaching the average American quasi-robot how to look at issues critically, I think there is a very important parallel between the "techno-optimist circle jerk" + over-simplification aspects of TED and why people listen to their talks and the reason many of us have been reading Ran's blog.

He's said before that basically what he does is translate articles written at IQ 150 down to IQ 120. When I first read or heard that I was kinda thinking "fuck you man" though he was correct; over the years this blog has primarily catered to the lazy, quasi-intellectual liberal-ish types. And most of the people emailing him just wanted him to do their thinking for them. But it bears mentioning that the average word consumer here wants and gets something very specific and that is Optimism and elegant-simplification.

That has been simultaneously the benefit of this blog and its single greatest weakness. Writers say about about editors that "Editors like the soup better after they have pissed in it themselves." Ran has been an outstanding editor, it is a skill he has developed with a great deal of efficacy by virtue of having not wasted the compute cycles of his brain on a 9-5 for the last 40 some years. But there has been a certain flavor of "piss" going into this concentrate for years. And to me it is an exaltation of the elegantly simple over assessments that are complex in nature but have better evidence.

I remember a specific point from years ago that I disagreed with Ran on: The cause of American obesity. He favored the ridiculously simple explanation that our food has very little nutrition so we feel compelled to eat more to get what we need. At the time I was into elegant simple answers too and my personal experience is that Stress (cortisol) is a primary factor in obesity. Both opinions had elements of truth, and could even be argued to be the same answer, but both were almost totally unqualified. And in both cases it probably would have been better to keep our mouths shut about it, because ultimately we were both at least mostly wrong and a hypothesis shouldn't be stated like a theory. Today science is beginning to see the cause of these metabolic disorders that are seemingly ubiquitous in obesity cases as caused by chronic systemic inflammation related to problem proteins, that DO come from a un-nutritious diet heavy in grains, but cause the inflammation in a complex manner not so much about a lack of nutrition but rather involving something causing permeability in the gut, and a complicated auto-immune response that isn't really an allergy and ...blah, blah, blah, all sorts of shit not working correctly, shit that nobody can really explain yet and CERTAINLY can't be stated easily or FAIRLY in an IQ 120 sound-bite.

So? What's the point?

The point is Ran's more recent posts have been departing more and more from the sound-bites they once were. They are departing from the TED-ism of philosophy. If he has something to say it goes beyond 4 sentences, or gets left as a link sans edits to someone who explains the matter with more of the attention the complexity of the issue requires. And the back-to-the land self-sufficiency, find meaning digging in the dirt stuff has been tempered by contrary experience as well. So while I can't come here and gather up as many slick short and sexy woo-woo-optimistic sound-bites for use in charming the panties off of the young and impressionable hippie chicks, Ultimately I think that's a good thing. Because a sign of a great thinker is one that grows and one who is unafraid to stand naked before you with nothing but questions.

And I'm really looking forward to seeing where Ran will be able to go with the greater wisdom and agnosticism and acceptance of complexity that he seems to be finding.

Maybe Terrence McKenna was (tangentially) right about that Novelty Curve, and Novelty blew its wad not as a thing itself, but as a cultural virtue on December 21, 2012. Good dark days of wisdom to come. Chicken Soup for the Nihilist's soul. =)

Cheers! Ian

tl;dr: Keep up the good work!


r/ranprieur • • Apr 01 '16

short. orwell vs huxley. comic

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/ranprieur • • May 05 '12

Like Ran Prieur, but...

17 Upvotes

I've read his blog for years and got alot of useful advice and philosophy from it. It really influenced me and I changed alot of my life because of his writings. Those were the days when his primary essay was 'How to Drop Out' (version 1.0) and that's what I did.

Was kinda bummed later when I discovered that he was mostly a upper middle class kid that always had something of a safety net throughout his adventures. I supposed he'd call it his lifeboat, but alot of us jumped ship and ended up clinging to scrap wood DiCaprio-style. Yeah, he's explored the dropout life but on his blog there are hints that he's always known he'd be alright.

He's had a golden parachute for years in the form of supportive family, building savings and 'retirement' accounts (all while eschewing the evils of interest to his readers) and eventual inheritance from family estates. He's also lucked out by falling bass ackwards into money now and then.

I was going to blow my top earlier, but he quickly amended his Dropout Essay in 2008 and 2012, essentially reversing alot of what he said earlier. It also makes anyone who points out the discrepancies or contradictions look like an asshole. Well alot of us took the plunge taking everything to heart, along with the writings of other prominent dropouts like Thoreau and Burroughs.

These guys were all privileged from the get-go but they don't put that on the front page of their books or blogs. Without these advantages and networks many are worse off than before. Especially when we sealed our fates by following his earlier advice.

This isn't all Ran's problem, I'm just saying watch out guys, not everything is as it seems. Ran does have some helpful advice and insights but like most people doesn't know what's going on most of the time. Just my two cents, which is all I've got basically.


r/ranprieur • • Jul 18 '24

Weird collapse indeed

16 Upvotes

I don't know if weird collapse is still a thing, but if it is, we've entered it big time. Consider what has happened over just the last few weeks:

If we accept everything that has happened at face value (no conspiracies or coverups), then here is what happened. For years, the Democrats have covered up Joe Biden's steady decline. Biden repeatedly looks befuddled, gazes off into the middle distance, and garbles his words ("We beat Medicare"). In subsequent appearances, he proceeds to make even more outrageous gaffes, calling Zelensky "President Putin," and claiming Donald Trump is his vice president.

Meanwhile, just as the public is starting to gain awareness of Project 2025 and Trump's conspicuous presence in the Epstein files, some 20 year old kid in rural Pennsylvania decides to get up one day, grab his dad's AR-15, and head to a Trump rally to kill the ex-president. He asks for the day off from his kitchen job saying he'll be back to work on Sunday. By all accounts he is politically conservative.

He drives to the rally and finds a one-story building with an unsecured rooftop in range of the ex-president within direct sight. He then climbs up to the roof while people at the scene watch and try repeatedly to warn police officers, the Secret Service, anybody, to no avail. This kid, who wears glasses, has no military experience, and was refused admittance to his local gun club for being a bad shot, manages to fire a bullet so close it misses Trump by mere millimeters. The bullet was so close that had Trump's head been turned at a slightly different angle, he would be dead. This is how close it came:

https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/1e4xbt4/trumps_head_movement_during_the_shooting_was/

Trump, a noted coward, pumps his fist in the air and yells "fight" as he is escorted from the scene. Meanwhile a press photographer takes pictures so iconic that you literally couldn't use Photoshop or AI to create a more stirring image. And all of this happens mere days before Trump is to receive the nomination at the Republican National Convention. And, to top it off, at the same time the Supreme Court declares the president to be above the law (for "official acts" which are not defined), and a judge throws out the documents case in a bizarre decision that baffles legal experts.

More strangeness: in the aftermath Trump is compared to Teddy Roosevelt, who also survived an assassination attempt. Where was Roosevelt shot? Milwaukee. Where is the Republican National Convention? Milwaukee (I haven't seen anyone else notice this). And the last presidential candidate to be shot and killed in America was Robert F. Kennedy, whose son just happens to also be running as a presidential candidate in this year's election. And now Biden has Covid.

Oh, and did we forget the total solar eclipse that passed over huge swaths of the United States earlier this year? And yeah, the national anthem at the home run derby was sung by a singer who was drunk off her gourd and checked into a rehab facility immediately after.

I mean, even if you're a believer in a rational universe, this has to be pushing the limits.


r/ranprieur • • Dec 27 '13

"dropping out", society, empire, etc

16 Upvotes

never posted on this website but found this link through Ran's website and found this conversation pretty interesting. i especially like the growing of a fruit tree analogy.

My experience of "dropping out" was that, in the past, i took that idea really seriously and felt as though i was out. felt as though not using money and having what i perceived to be the littlest amount of interactions where i reinforced industrial capitalism was, by omission, or rather by abandonment, almost my duty and certainly was what I should be doing, the world i saw out there being predicated on suffering, hellish social interactions, annihalation of any kind of dense ecology where creatures could thrive. I read Ran, and I read Jensen, and I read crimethinc. and the whole thing was pretty heady.

Over the years my relationship to "dropping out" has changed a lot, i think in similar ways to a lot of punk scene people who have reached our 30s, who still dont want to sell out, but who also need a change in our lives. (i think this is something that is useful to think about when one considers making dramatic changes in our lives: can we sustain this?) Years ago my future planning\self care was almost completely non-existent. there was no future. why plan for it? wellll shit, things are getting on.

One way that this has manifested is, looking back on all the years ive travelled, stole, bummed, gardened, squatted.. (and i look back on them with delight, in many ways) i also see that i was not 'out' at all. in fact, i think those years really showed me just how deeply there is no 'out.' mechanistic capitalistic interactions blanket my reality, they are not in-situ, specific to location, and to quality and texture of an interaction. i believe that literally while global industrial capitalism exists it is an inextricable part of our psychology, of the way we sociailze and are socialized, including our relationship to it when we think we are 'dropped out'... (maybe ièll write more about this another time... its probably a pretty unpopular idea!)

Something that it has taken me a long time to learn, but i think it is totally crucial,is to plan activities around things that i really, (i mean REALLY) want to do. and if one doesnt know those (its taken me my whole life to find a calling that i'm excited about) well my advice would be to wait and do what it takes to explore the things you think MIGHT be that passion for you. in this exploration, try this phrase on yourself: "am i pursuing this because I think it might make me really happy, or because i think i should."

I have seen omitting this self questioning burn out a lot of subculture people, especially primitivist friends. the language of primitivism (down from camatte, zerzan, Green Anarchy journal and also partly fueled by jensen... and of course Rans old writing) is so ideological, so intransigent and even moralist, people get caught up in "should"s all the time. i should be tanning hides and flint-napping for the apoco-rev. when that certainly comes, certainly in 5 years. well i spent a lot of time in the last 10 years doing shit that i wasnt passionate about. dont make that mistake! and dont become a prisoner of a subculture.

secondly, and to the end of the first point, don't be afraid to make and spend money to find the things you love. (i think this resonates wiht the original dropping out essay which, if i remember correctly, said don't bother trying to find work you love, it will still be work and is unlikely to remain enjoyable... something like that?)

Anyways, what i am trying to say here is in years past i got so caught up in trying to learn things for free, and from the internet, and from books i never stole because they were too guarded, i created a whole world of activities that were free but that i was not even that excited about, and was afraid, hesitant, or felt that it was painful to spend a hundred dollars on a class or some books.

so really my advice is don't create morality based on what the subculture is doing but find something deeply satisfying and follow that, in the way that makes you feel most free, if that makes sense. and also dig into the subculture for info, ways of getting there, friends, good reading, passions for destruction, and all the rest.


r/ranprieur • • May 09 '12

My dropout/homesteading story

16 Upvotes

Ran’s been posting a lot about dropping out recently, so I thought I’d share my own story. I’ve actually been wanting to write something about this for a while, but I have been having trouble organizing my thoughts around what exactly I want to say. As such, this may be a bit long winded and disorganized, but hopefully it’s useful to some on the dropout path.

I won’t go into details about how I got interested in breaking free from the dominant system. I guess I was fortunate enough to read the right things and think critically about my life. In the course of a few years, my whole outlook on life was radically transformed, and there was no going back. Since then, I’ve been working to break free from the oppression of the dominant system.

About a year and a half ago, My wife and I moved to Bellingham, Washington, to a rental house a few miles outside of the city to start our homesteading journey. Our lot was a couple acres, with fruit trees and a grass area around 4000 square feet that we could turn into a garden. When I do something, I tend to go all out, so I decided to have a huge garden that used nearly the whole 4000 square foot area. I was working from home, so I was able to take lots of breaks during the day to work in the garden.

At first, the work was fun. Being outside and using simple tools. Planting and watching things grow. Harvesting and eating the freshest most delicious vegetables I have ever had. And then, it just got old and tiring. Harvesting pounds and pounds of veggies every day. Washing, sorting, freezing, drying, fermenting, cooking. It just became so much work, and I stopped enjoying it for the most part. Not to mention the isolation. We had moved without having jobs in town. Jobs are the main social network for people out of school, so this turned out to make things very difficult. We made a big effort to go to events and meet people, but we always felt isolated living there. The neighbors were mostly nice, but all much older, extremely conservative folks. It’s hard to fit into that kind of area being in your late twenties and extremely liberal.

I’m sure some people will say that we did it all wrong and that’s why we didn’t like it. Maybe we should have moved to some intentional community somewhere to be with more people. In the end though, I think the result would have been the same. If you don’t truly love the homesteading life, I just don’t see how it could work. I liked growing vegetables as a hobby and learning about farming, but it turned out the farming life just wasn’t for me. The fact is, most the people that sit around daydreaming about dropping out have no idea what it’s like to live this way. Maybe they have a small experience living the simple farming life, and assume that doing that everyday would be amazing. Doing something once in awhile, is not the same as having it be your lifestyle.

By coincidence, I ended up following a similar path to Ran, and I think Toby Hemmingway also wrote about this. I bought a house in a nice neighborhood, close to downtown Bellingham, where I can walk or bike everywhere I need to go and have a small garden. At first, it felt like I was giving in. I kept thinking that maybe I just needed to try a little bit harder at the homesteading lifestyle. I think the myth of homesteading is so strong that I felt like it just had to be the right path for me.

I’m so thankful for my year of homesteading. I learned so much in that year about gardening and life. I think it was inevitable that I had to go through that experience to find out for myself that it wasn’t for me. If someone else had written this and I had read it a couple years ago, would it have convinced me not to try? Probably not. I would have just told myself it would be different for me.

I still hear so many people my age talking about saving up to buy land. Certainly it may work for some. I’m not trying to say this lifestyle isn’t for anyone. I just want to point out that it’s not for everyone. You can’t just run away from all the problems in society. Sure, you can hunker down out in the woods with a community of 20 people and be mostly self sufficient, but the world that you hate is still all around you. There are existing communities (towns and cities) that don’t suck, and it’s much easier to become a part of one of them than start your own.

I’ve heard Ran and others talk about depression when dropping out, and this is something I’ve struggled with, and am still having problems with at times. The fact is, it’s much easier to live an average commercialized life and have average happiness. Your life might be more shallow, but you’ll probably be reasonably happy. If you want to do better than this, it suddenly becomes much harder just to be as happy as you were in the crappy superficial life. You now have to work much harder to make social connections and find meaningful things to do. And sure, you may have a much happier and more meaningful life eventually, but it’s like you have to build everything up from scratch. You throw away all the structure that has been given to you your whole life, and you have to start over. I think a lot of people simply aren’t aware there is this aspect to dropping out. I’m finally starting to see myself getting there, but it’s been so slow. Still, it’s definitely worth the struggle.

Trying to undo a whole lifetime of being trained to seek outside motivations is not easy. I used to consider myself a very self-motivated person, but this has been so hard for me. Sometimes I just want to go back, get another office job that I don’t care about, and spend every minute outside of that job having as much fun as I can. The truth is, the happiest I ever was, was when I was working a flexible office job I didn’t care about. I was lucky enough to be able to leave work early most days, and often walked to the park to slackline, play frisbee and just lay about. I worked for the man, but I felt free.

I don’t like to think in terms of dropping out anymore. For me, it conjures up too many images of isolation and all the things that I tried and found not to work. I’m no longer trying to run away from anything to find freedom, but to recognize the beauty and freedom that is all around me. We all have to walk our own paths to freedom. If somebody working 9-5 feels they are free from the system, who’s to say they need to change anything?


r/ranprieur • • Nov 21 '11

Tribes and Meaning

16 Upvotes

I thought I would be able to repeatedly link to posts on my home page by sticking "resubmit=true" in the URL, but for some reason it's not working. Either the feature is broken or they only let you do it once. So I have to do it as a text-based reddit post. The link for my new post is here:

http://ranprieur.com/#meaning

If I later decide to permalink it, I'll post the permalink in the comments.


r/ranprieur • • Apr 14 '15

Ran Prieur...BEFORE and AFTER...what happened?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/ranprieur • • Jul 02 '14

"I no longer think it's realistic for humans to return to forager-hunter tribes" Here is my opposite perspective.

15 Upvotes

Ran doesn't believe anymore that humans will return to the type of lifestyle we've had for 99% of our species' history. Ran and most of us consider civilization to be somewhat of a nightmare, thus we're drawn to evidence that would suggest that the effects of the Neolithic revolution are a temporary anomaly in our species' history. With that cognitive bias to which I fall victim kept in the back of my mind, I'd like to look at the evidence for the case that civilization is a temporary anomaly.

Fossil fuels still occupy 87% of global energy production.1 We know that this situation can't be sustained forever. Gail Tverberg argues that we'll hit peak fossil fuel consumption in 2015, limiting us to a 2 degree temperature increase compared to pre-industrial.2 Experiments with carbon capture and storage have completely failed.3 If it turns out that the "optimistic" projections of unconventional fossil fuel use are correct, then we'll be dealing with an even higher temperature increase, perhaps anywhere from four degree Celsius to six degree.

Which brings me to the next point. There's a lag to the effects of just about anything we do. The amount of carbon we've emitted isn't done raising our temperature yet. If civilization were to stop emitting greenhouse gases today, we'd still witness a 0.4 degree Celsius temperature increase over the coming decades. There's then a lag in the response of the ecosystem to that temperature increase. Species take time to migrate to new areas, trees take time to die or grow in new habitable environments, parasites may have to wait with settling until that new ecosystem is functional, and so forth.

Agriculture as we know it is really only a viable survival strategy under rather specific climatic conditions. You need a gentle climate, with few weather extremes. If precipitation happens in strong downpours, the effect is to destroy the soil. Tropical forests have the ability to suck up water during such downpours and emit water during droughts, thus providing greater stability for the entire ecosystem. Agricultural fields can't do that, so those fields suffer soil erosion during downpours, while the plants die during droughts.

Africa will be first to run into problems. During the past thirty years, the rate of soil erosion has increased 20-fold.4 The effects of agriculture are already turning the continent into a wasteland as we speak. Globally, half of the world's fertile soil has been lost in the past 150 years. According to the WWF, in the past fifty years, a third of the world's arable land has been lost.5 Thus it's clear that this is a problem that's accelerating.

Why don't we notice anything going wrong, if we've destroyed half of the world's fertile soil already in the past 150 years? The answer is because so far we've had the ability to move on to new places to colonize and extract. The global land grab in Africa is happening for exactly that reason. It's a temporary solution however, as Africa has such vulnerable soils. Another part of the equation is that fossil fuels have effectively turned us into Gods over our ecosystem. They allow us to extract the particular few minerals we need to create life in a soil that can no longer sustain life by itself. We ship phosphorus from Morocco all over the world and together with nitrogen that we artificially fixate from the air with natural gas use it to make a soil able to host life. Because the soil is dead, the plants are weak, which we hide through the application of fungicides and a variety of other pesticides, like a kid kept isolated in a bubble because it was born without a functional immune system.

Fossil fuels have so far allowed us to mask most of the effects that climate change is having. When we lose the fossil fuels, we will have to practice agriculture in a global climate that's simply completely different from the one we had before we started using fossil fuels. One effect that is clear is that plants become more vulnerable to a variety of pathogens, through multiple mechanisms. Plants benefit from the temperature drops that happen at night, because those kill off many fungal pathogens. Most of the increase in global temperatures from the greenhouse effect happens at night however. In addition, studies under isolated circumstances, where atmospheric carbon dioxide is increased to simulate a future environment, tend to find that necrotrophic fungi benefit from elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide. Fungi for which the beneficial effects of higher atmospheric CO2 concentrations are most clear are those that infect wheat plants, like stem rust.6 Also important to note is that climate change causes a global increase in humidity, which also tends to benefit plant pathogens like stem rust.

What's important to keep in mind here is that we already suffer the effects of fungal pathogens on our crops. Right now, our fossil fuels and global economy allow us to respond effectively to that. To get rid of stem rust, we looked for a particular variety somewhere that happened to be genetically resistant to stem rust. Through our global economy we then managed to introduce that particular variety around the whole world. Thus agriculture has so far become more effective over the past two centuries, continually increasing yields, reducing necessary labor and eliminating pathogens that threaten our crops.

One unexpected benefit effect that's easy to underestimate is the delaying effect pesticides have on the evolution of pathogens. If there are 1 billion stem rust spores produced every day globally, the rate of new mutations can be expected to be a thousand times lower than if there were 1 trillion stem rust spores produced every day globally. By applying fungicides, we give ourselves an advantage in the evolutionary arms race, because the pathogens we have to fear now can not evolve as rapidly as they could evolve if we did not apply those fungicides.

This doesn't mean that we're going to witness a global extermination of grasses. Climate change is believed to make our climate rather similar to the Pliocene. The temperate climates where we now witness grasslands tended to have forests. C4 carbon fixation practicing grasses survived in those places where temperatures are relatively high, because their carbon fixation mechanism loses less water while fixating carbon, thus they have an edge over other plants there.

Plants coped with the increases pathogen burden they suffered through biodiversity. If you have a field where one species of grass grows, it's vulnerable to fungal pathogens. If a hundred different types of grass grow there, out of which just a few can harbor one particular fungal pathogen, that fungal pathogen species may never reach critical mass. Agriculture is not really a viable survival strategy under those conditions, since agriculture tends to require the practice of monoculture. You focus your effort on selectively breeding one species to produce better nutrition for humans. Note that the effects of soil erosion would also increase under those climatic conditions.

When it comes to pastoralism, it has to be noted that anthropologists don't really believe that pastoralism ever occurs in isolation. Pastoralists continually interact with agricultural settlements, exchanging their resources with one another. Pastoralist communities also tend to be very vulnerable to having their animals lost to predator species. Those were historically exterminated, but such extermination is somewhat difficult if you have very large densely forested areas and don't have high population density farming settlements to fall back on.

There are other potential problems I haven't addressed. For every two degree increase in global temperatures, the number of Katrina magnitude storms is expected to increase tenfold.7 This would have the ability to greatly reduce human carrying capacity. More importantly, ecological simulations tend to show delayed effects of a rapid population growth of a particular species on other species, that will seek to utilize the new ecological niche.

A number of diseases are crossing species into our human population. HIV has been successful in this, measles entered the human population from rinderpest somewhere around the 11th century AD, Ebola may be gaining a foothold right now, while in Saudi Arabia MERS seems to have crossed species. The explosion in human population is a very recent phenomenon, the effects it has are still revealing themselves. Note that studies find that malaria simply can't gain a foothold in places where human population density is relatively low (3.3 per square km) and too many non-human mammal species live, because the malaria parasite ends up entering animals from which it can't spread.8

In an effort to survive, the whole non-human biosphere is trying to figure out how to survive in the new ecological niches that we have created, often at our cost. They have no other choice, because the total biomass of humans is now an order of magnitude higher than the total biomass of non-human terrestrial vertebrates. I expect that we will simply return to the level of population density found in hunter-gatherers.

References

1 - http://www.energymanagertoday.com/fossil-fuels-dominate-global-energy-consumption-096446/ 2 - http://ourfiniteworld.com/2014/04/11/oil-limits-and-climate-change-how-they-fit-together/ 3 - http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-09-20/norway-drops-moon-landing-as-mongstad-carbon-capture-scrapped.html 4 - http://www.worldwatch.org/node/554 5 - http://wwf.panda.org/what_we_do/footprint/agriculture/impacts/soil_erosion/ 6 - http://www.reddit.com/r/deep_ecology/comments/22utzi/response_of_wheat_fungal_diseases_to_elevated/ 7 - http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2013/03/19/1741861/five-katrinas-a-decade-warming-projected-to-boost-extreme-storm-surges-ten-fold/ 8 - http://www.plosntds.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pntd.0002139


r/ranprieur • • Dec 16 '18

Ran 12/14... still a dropout after all these years

14 Upvotes

The main thing that drew me to primitivism, and also homesteading, was my desire to escape the busyness of modern life. All I want is to have nothing I'm supposed to be doing, as much of the time as possible. So I traveled around, met back-to-the-landers, visited intentional communities, even tried it myself. And it turns out, those people work even more hours than the average urban person. It's like the idea that they're living in a more natural way, or living in a community, is a motivational trick to get themselves to do more chores than anyone should have to do in this age of material abundance.

I loved this, and thought it deserved re-emphasis in light of the direction this sub has gone in recent years. I and several others have been called more than a few names for giving voice to that exact same line of thinking. At some point what used to be a drop-out community has become a hang-out for would-be warriors.

The writer whose work this subreddit focuses on has never, so near as I have ever been able to determine, been terribly interested in overthrowing the forces of evil. His focus has never been on protest, activism, or forcing radical change. The journey here has never been to take down the system or even to change it, but to DISTANCE oneself from it. And for mostly personal (one might even say selfish) reasons. Because 9-5 is our idea of hell. That's it. Not because we're trying to save the world.

Regarding the article Ran linked about millenials, the problem is not the world around these people but a failure to adapt. A predictable failure. In his 2012 update to The Slow Crash, Ran adds in italics:

just because these adaptations are available and helpful, doesn't mean average people will change. Jared Diamond has written that the Vikings in Greenland starved to death rather than change their culture to eat fish.

Millenials are falling on their asses because they're trying to do what worked for their grandparents. And it was never going to happen any other way. When he updated the essay in question here, Ran described himself as having been too optimistic about popular adaptations at the original time of writing. Frankly, so was I around that same time frame, and with a bachelor's degree in anthropology I should have known better. History is not on our side, and I should have realized that. Here's what I think: things are not going to get better for people in the US until there is mass recognition that the post WWII economy was a fluke and is not coming back. This author's critical failure is that his whole article focuses on the raw deal millenials have because the benefits of the boomer economy are no longer available to them. it would be better to consider what millenials could do as ALTERNATIVES to the boomer economy. But first we have to acknowledge that it's gone forever.

One quick aside: Ran should try essays again. He seems to be getting his mojo back.


r/ranprieur • • Nov 26 '17

Ran and John Michael Greer

14 Upvotes

I’ve been following Ran and John Michael Greer (formerly of the Archdruid Report, now Ecosophia.net) since 2011 or so.

From my perception, both of them have changed a lot over the last few years, with the Archdruid increasingly thinking that a collapse is accelerating, and Ran deciding that the big systems will “continue to muddle through,” giving us self-driving cars and, eventually, artificial intelligence.

When I discovered both of them it seemed like their ideas about the future were roughly in-line. I know there are other John Michael Greer readers here and I’m curious what other people think of their diverging ideas about the future.


r/ranprieur • • Jul 16 '15

People want the McPherson extinction story because real collapse is boring and sucks

14 Upvotes

I think one thing that makes the McPherson extinction theory so attractive is the fact that it offers us a way out of having to deal with the real collapse. John Michael Greer was probably the first to notice that.

I suspect that part of the appeal of McPherson is for people like me, who thought that collapse would be exciting, but while waiting for the collapse began to figure out that the collapse is already happening and it looks far more depressing than we were expecting it to be.

The real collapse doesn't seem to look like MadMax, total anarchy where you move from place to place and are at continual risk of being brutally murdered. That's what I've hoped for all my life, but I'm starting to think that probably won't happen.

Instead, when you look more carefully at what has happened, we didn't get chaos or anarchy, rather, it seems that the government and the economic structure that rule our world stays in power and new money is to be made by dealing with the consequences of the collapse.

Half the houses in a street may be deserted, but they're administered by corporations on behalve of their formal owners so you can't move into them and if you do, the frightened neighbors call the cops anyway.

You will still need to eat and if you're poor or unemployed people still think of you as a loser, even the other poor and unemployed, so 90+% of people still won't want to interact with you. What happens to jobs is that they become more boring and ethically disgusting. Instead of having a chance to become an artist, there's a massive surge in employers looking for debt collectors, or 3 dollar an hour jobs as waiters.

Instead of moving out of the city to a remote space to grow your own food, the land is made more unaccessible than ever before, used to grow biofuels or trees that are used as "renewable energy". You're forced to stay stuck in the city, because that's where jobs are and you can't afford transportation anymore.

Instead of land or buildings gradually going to waste and being overgrown with plants, the government "creates jobs" by paying people to maintain infrastructure that's no longer needed, to turn the place into a potemkin village and attract investors.

Instead of people feeling more liberated and caring less about what others might think, they become forced to be ever more obedient, because leaving any bad impression anywhere might render you permanently unemployable if someone photographs you and uses your real name on the internet. "Oh that's Sarah O'Connor!" as a line anonymously commented somewhere on the world wide web under some picture of a woman dumpsterdiving is enough to force her into an endless series of minimum wage jobs.

You might think I'm exaggerating, but this is simply what happens. Shock-blogs in my country post pictures of some drunk student who urinated in a train. Bad behavior obviously, but most of us have done bad things while drunk, without having our face plastered all over the internet for millions of people to see. Note the important part here: His friends published the photographs. Why? Well, if you're permanently impoverished, giving some shitty weblog a scoop will net you a few hundred euros, which becomes more valuable than your friendship and self-respect.

People become unemployed, but it doesn't give them free time to figure out meaningful experiences for themselves. Instead, they find themselves "volunteering" or doing unpaid internships, to build up "experience". If they do this long enough, they're allowed to work somewhere for a bit.

Collapse so far appears to result in centralized control not dying, but rather, being internalised by the population itself, government itself becoming part of "the cloud". There are even programs to financially reward people through use of Bitcoin who anonymously report pirated movies on the internet. It is as if we all become part-time mall cops.

Thus, in light of what collapse actually looks like, I can't blame people for hoping that the oceans simply boil off instead.


r/ranprieur • • Mar 02 '14

"I see computers as humanity's suicide"

14 Upvotes

This is from Ran's post on Feb. 28, 2014. What do you all think that means? I am planning to personally ask him but I am asking here to see if I can get some interesting ideas or discussions.


r/ranprieur • • Oct 03 '13

Has anyone else dropped out a la Ran? Really getting sick of doing shit I don't like, but I have no idea where to begin.

14 Upvotes

r/ranprieur • • Mar 07 '12

Ran Prieur Unplugged (unedited interview footage recorded for "What A Way To Go" / 1hour 40min)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

r/ranprieur • • Jan 26 '12

Chris Martenson explains why the current economic crisis is a permanent one, that we will not recover from.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

r/ranprieur • • Nov 18 '11

A BSc in Collapse Preparation - What would you put in the course content?

14 Upvotes

Three years, six semesters.

That's how much time you have to teach your class of eager undergraduate students about how best to prepare for a society transitioning into something... else.

What topics do you cover? Of course, you can have compulsory and optional modules, so that students can personalise their course.

Of course, this is just another way of asking the question -- what are the best things to learn in order to prepare? What skills, what knowledge? What is most and least important? It'd be useful to have a big comprehensive list somewhere.


r/ranprieur • • Feb 20 '10

Who is Ran Prieur? (In the off chance someone stumbles upon this subreddit unawares)

Thumbnail
ranprieur.com
14 Upvotes

r/ranprieur • • Jan 19 '24

The importance of everyday objects

13 Upvotes

I was thinking about this from the recent blog post:

"Probably, Indigenous Americans thought it was quite strange that white people just bought knives from a general store -- as if knives were interchangeable and their origins unimportant. The further back you go in anthropology, the more art is embedded in (is synonymous with) objects of daily use. In my wife's office, she has little gnomes on her bookshelf that sit there just for fun. A hundred thousand years ago, if someone had three little figurines in their home, they probably had deep spiritual meaning and long histories."

I suppose it's an obvious point that the more things we have the less important each individual thing is to us. In this we lose the fact that the history and relationships an object has with the world and with ourselves can be an enriching element of life. But I think we all have belongings in which we have a similar feeling of an object's history and importance.

For me it's my guitar. I bought a restored 1969 Gretsch hollowbody a decade ago and I played the hell out of it, on stage and in the studio. Nowadays I've been wanting to cut down on possessions but I've realized that there's no way I could sell that thing, even though I barely play it nowadays. To sell it seems almost sacrilegious; it goes beyond mere 'sentimental value'. The experiences that are embedded into it are too numerous and deep. To do it justice, the least I could do is gift it to someone who I know would love it and use it. But in truth, I'm probably stuck with it til the bitter end, because I love it.

I used to live with a hoarder, and I wonder if hoarders simply treat things the way people eons past treated things. Perhaps it’s not that they place too much importance on everyday things, its that they place the correct amount of importance on too many things. The modern habit of accumulation doesn't work well with an intense recognition of the story of all belongings. For us to function, we either have to learn to not care, or be selective about the objects we allow into our lives.


r/ranprieur • • Mar 07 '20

Programmers generate every possible melody in MIDI to prevent lawsuits - A way to disrupt rent-seeking in musical domain without having to beg to change IP law

Thumbnail
musictech.net
13 Upvotes