r/programming • • May 11 '16

Github changes pricing structure - per user charge with unlimited repos

https://github.com/blog/2164-introducing-unlimited-private-repositories
295 Upvotes

240 comments sorted by

View all comments

50

u/hallatore May 11 '16

The price change for large organizations is insane. If you have a private repo with 100 collaborators it will cost you $10800 pr year.

We have 300+ users and 70+ repo's. (Everyone in the company have access to github for internal open source projects etc). We are now looking at $30 000 pr year...

The only way I see this new plan viable is if they only count active users (with commits) each month.

33

u/dsk May 11 '16 edited May 11 '16

We are now looking at $30 000 pr year...

Is that really that much for a core tool? The burn-rate for 300 employees is $10million-$20million/year - so in relation $30,000 is nothing. This price went from insanely and irrationally cheap to merely market competitive.

Pretty much every cloud service has comparable pricing model.

9

u/hallatore May 11 '16

It's expensive when just 5%-10% users commits. With this change I guess we need to change how we do this.

It would be a fair price if our 300 employees worked in github every day. But for us it's just one of many tools we use.

tl;dr: The new price doesn't make sense for idling users that need access occasionally.

4

u/dsk May 11 '16 edited May 11 '16

It's expensive when just 5%-10% users commits.

Sure, so don't buy licenses for the 90% of users that don't commit. And you still have the flexibility to only buy licenses for those in that 90% who express an interest in committing some code.

We do that with Office 365 and Visio. Everybody gets Office/Outlook, but only about 30% of the company gets a Visio license because the rest doesn't need it.

The new price doesn't make sense for idling users that need access occasionally.

Sure. I guess.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/kn4rf May 11 '16

Or you know, you can host repoes for free on your own company server. Or get unlimited repoes and users for 200$ at bitbucket. Or you could use Gitlab for 40$ per user per year. I'm not sure why anyone would choose Github..

38

u/awj May 11 '16

I'm not sure why anyone would choose Github..

Because they realize that self hosting is only free if your time is worthless, and plenty of developers are already familiar with github, so is the productivity loss of learning a new platform worth the savings?

→ More replies (8)

23

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

Or you know, you can host repoes for free on your own company server.

Which means now you need a dedicated guy who deals with all the trouble that git can be.

5

u/Dark_Crystal May 11 '16

Which means now you need a dedicated guy who deals with all the trouble that git can be.

Using github doesn't free you of that you know.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '16

At least it takes away the server-side troubles.

2

u/justinpitts May 11 '16

How many hours per user per year do you estimate that to be? I just haven't seen that much time necessary.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

Given my private experience with git being a big bitch sometimes, and the fact that my employer (40 developers) has a developer who fiddles with TFS about an hour per day on a regular basis, I would say somewhere around 20% of a person's time to keep it running smoothly and securely.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/kn4rf May 12 '16

Literally all you need to do is setup a bare repo (git init --bare) on a server, give the developers access, and setup a cron job for automatic backup. Not something worth crying about. A little extra job and you can quite easily setup gitlab and get a fancy UI as well.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/dsk May 11 '16 edited May 11 '16

Or you know, you can host repoes for free on your own company server.

That's an option, but I personally love cloud services. For companies of a certain size, it's nice when there's one less server to worry about.

3

u/ellicottvilleny May 11 '16

Don't companies wonder what would happen if they can't collaborate for a day because Github is DOWN? There hasn't been a big outage recently, but I remember some in the past. More likely than Github being down is that we have local networking and power at our office but an office-wide internet outage. Don't like that.

12

u/ungood May 11 '16

You make it sound like hosting a git server yourself magically gives you 100% availability. It doesn't.

2

u/cdrt May 11 '16

He's saying the opposite actually. He says that it's more likely the company network goes down than GitHub goes down.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/ellicottvilleny May 11 '16

uh. no. github can have five nines but our uplink may not.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/dsk May 11 '16

Don't companies wonder what would happen if they can't collaborate for a day because Github is DOWN?

Yes it is a risk. A hosted service is not for every organization. Usually small-to-midsize businesses benefit from hosted solution - risk of an outage and all. Large enterprises will usually have their own IT department and specific policies around data governance that may preclude using a hosted solution.

2

u/balefrost May 11 '16

I mean, the magic of Git is that you can collaborate without a central server. Sure, GH also has issues and Wiki pages and other things that are important... but you can definitely do some amount of development - and code sharing - even during a GH outage.

4

u/ellicottvilleny May 11 '16

As a mercurial user I even can type "hg serve" and then send someone an http://10.101.123.45:8000 url, and they can clone or push directly to me. I wish Git had that. Git Instaweb is close but no cigar.

I am moving our org to git and I set up gitlab for our own on premises purposes. Now we have another thing to add to our disaster recovery plan. But we are self-sufficient for at least a few days of development. (Can developers even work in 2016 without internet? Maybe not, but that's their problem, not mine.)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/kn4rf May 12 '16

It's not like you can't rent a VPS and host your git repos there. You can still host git repos yourself even if your company server is "in the cloud".

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

Sorry, but hosting your own repositories that replicate off site is not "free".

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

[deleted]

1

u/jsmonarch May 12 '16

When using gitlab.com, instead of the enterprise edition, unlimited users is also free.

→ More replies (2)