r/programming • • May 11 '16

Github changes pricing structure - per user charge with unlimited repos

https://github.com/blog/2164-introducing-unlimited-private-repositories
295 Upvotes

240 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/hallatore May 11 '16

It's expensive when just 5%-10% users commits. With this change I guess we need to change how we do this.

It would be a fair price if our 300 employees worked in github every day. But for us it's just one of many tools we use.

tl;dr: The new price doesn't make sense for idling users that need access occasionally.

4

u/dsk May 11 '16 edited May 11 '16

It's expensive when just 5%-10% users commits.

Sure, so don't buy licenses for the 90% of users that don't commit. And you still have the flexibility to only buy licenses for those in that 90% who express an interest in committing some code.

We do that with Office 365 and Visio. Everybody gets Office/Outlook, but only about 30% of the company gets a Visio license because the rest doesn't need it.

The new price doesn't make sense for idling users that need access occasionally.

Sure. I guess.

1

u/pcopley May 11 '16

Why do 90% of your users not commit?

18

u/dsk May 11 '16

I'll guess: Most of the company isn't made-up of developers.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

[deleted]

-9

u/glucker May 11 '16

We only have 3 or 4 regular committers, but another 15 use the issue tracker.

That means they are still using Github.

Why would commiting code require paying, and using issue tracker be free?

4

u/Dark_Crystal May 11 '16

Because their (poor) issue tracker isn't worth 9 bucks per user per year, much less per month.