I'll start by saying that I'm not looking to trash anyone's favourite book. This is just my opinion as a lover of SciFi and books, and I wanted to start an honest discussion.
This post contains spoilers and mentions sexual violence.
I read it on a strong recommendation from this sub, and I had my doubt within the first chapter. I only finished it because it's fairly short and I was waiting for a payoff that never came.
This won't be a full review, but just some thoughts I had. Overall I found the story quite dated, and would have a very hard time recommending it to anyone. I'd love to hear some disagreeing opinions though. Change my mind?
The Good
The initial setting of Gully trapped on a destroyed ship in deep space for 6 months is interesting and evocative. His abandonment by Vorga sets up a clear motivation and plot for the story.
The speculative elements have clearly established rules that the author generally resists the urge to break.
The Bad
IMO this is a space fantasy more than a SciFi (not that that's necessarily a bad thing). The main speculative elements of the story are that humans can teleport on command and some are telepathic. There's also a high-explosive you can detonate with your mind.
Maybe it's soft SciFi, and the point is the corporate takeover of earth, or the war between the outer planets and inner (which IMO The Expanse does a much better job of). But for a soft SciFi I'm disappointed that Alfred Bester could imagine a caste system based on how far you could teleport, but couldn't imagine society accepting lesbians as human beings, and couldn't imagine someone seeing a Maori face tattoo without fainting.
I also found the characters incredibly flat. Most lines of dialogue could have been said by any character in the story without changing their meaning. For some reason, despite Gully having no redeeming qualities, and despite the horrible way treats women (more on that later) every woman he meets falls madly in love with him.
The ending didn't really resolve any of the plot threads. It introduced some new twists and then just sort of stopped.
The Ugly
The protagonist Gully is an unrepentent rapist and woman-beater. He spends the story rampaging the solar system killing most men he meets, while beating and assaulting the women.
He is never punished for this, no justice is ever done, and at the end he decides he should stop doing that and he's suddenly a hero.