I was picking up a few essentials at M&S today when I spotted a couple of waters I don’t usually see. With enough new coffee beans to practically fill a drawer, I figured I’d bring them home to try. IIRC, one was £2.80 for 750ml.
I used my usual remineralized water from my Viomi Master M1 as the baseline, comparing it with Icelandic, Waitrose, and Sant Aniol.
The coffee was GESHA VILLAGE - OMA WASHED from French roaster Datura. I kept the brewing setup the same for all four:
10g coffee, 160g water
Comandante C40 at 24 clicks, 93°C water
V60 02 with fast-flow filter paper
40g pours every 20 seconds, finishing all pours within 1:30
At a high temperature: The M1 brew had the clear florals and acidity I’m used to. Icelandic and Waitrose were pretty close to each other. With Sant Aniol, the acidity was noticeably muted, leaving just a little floral aroma.
At a medium temperature: The floral and berry notes in the M1 brew started opening up. Icelandic came closest to it, with plenty of flavor complexity too. Waitrose stayed balanced. Sant Aniol tasted much thinner—more like lightly coffee-flavored water than a full cup of coffee.
Room temperature: M1 and Icelandic still had plenty of flavor, with Waitrose close behind. Sant Aniol was mostly down to a faint floral note.
For this coffee and this particular brew recipe, I haven’t found a reason to buy bottled water specifically for brewing. I’ll stick with the M1’s remineralized water for everyday use. Among the bottled options, my preference was Icelandic > Waitrose > Sant Aniol.
Still, the comparison was fun. I’ll probably bring home another unfamiliar bottle to try sometime. The beans already take up a whole drawer. Hopefully the water won’t follow.