r/pottytraining • • Jan 14 '21

Welcome to r/pottytraining!

237 Upvotes

Welcome! I'm a mod here and I'm thrilled to be here to support any and all potty training questions and concerns you have. This is a space to commiserate, share tips, and truly marvel at the wonder of teaching one of life's most basic skills! Congratulations on getting to this step!

Check out the Wiki tab for resources and books: https://www.reddit.com/r/pottytraining/wiki/index

And to those who have wondered, "What's the deal with this sub? Why isn't it active?" Well, I wondered the same thing for months! I finally earned enough karma points and officially requested to take over r/pottytraining. I was granted my wish and here I am! My aim is to reinvigorate this sub and get it moving again. I can't wait!


r/pottytraining • • 27m ago

Potty Training 3 year old boy

1 Upvotes

Looking for advice as I feel like all the kids I know have cracked it!

My little boy was three a couple of weeks ago and moved to a new nursery. We potty trained just before Easter so it’s been 7ish months. He got it so quickly I was surprised. He initially struggled at his old nursery but did get better and for a period of time was having 0-1 accidents a day. At home he is usually fine but we make him go before meals, tv time, leaving the house - he does sometimes have accidents if we stay in for a while. Accidents are usually a small leak but often he won’t tell us and if we don’t notice he just carries on until it turns into a bigger accident. When we are out of the house, weirdly he is quite reliable at letting us know he needs to go so he can do it. Never has a poo accident. Chat GPT mentioned constipation but he is regular and soft so that would surprise me.

I hoped it would just get better with time and practice but after a passive aggressive comment from his new nursery today saying we should be doing more at home, I feel a bit lost!

Stamps or chocolate for self initiated toilet trips? Something else?

Hoping someone has experienced something similar as all the toddlers I know are having a lot fewer accidents and had more issue with poos than wees.


r/pottytraining • • 4h ago

23mo rarely goes by herself to the potty if she’s wearing underwear

2 Upvotes

After more than a year of EC we started the Oh crap method with our 23mo.Literally from day one she did not have any accidents while naked and immediately started walking to the potty by herself, so after two days we started going with underwear that were loose and commando when out.The problem is that she rarely brings herself to the potty when wearing anything and only about 50 percent of the time will tell me she has to go on time to make it to the potty, I have to frequently remind her to go, so she’s not having a ton of accidents, but that’s because I’m reminding her.We’ve been doing this for a week and idk if the oh crap method just doesn’t work that quickly for every kid or if I’m just messing up.She hasn’t had a single accident while out of the house because I tell her to go before we leave,when we get to out destination and before we leave, and she is even staying dry at night now and during naps.I’m glad that she is doing well so many aspects and that I don’t even really need to pay much attention if she’s naked but I just don’t know what to do to help her learn to self initiate going to the potty while wearing pants or underwear


r/pottytraining • • 1h ago

Will my kid ever poop in the potty

1 Upvotes

Update: literally never fails. If I post on Reddit the issue is resolved without advice in like 2-3 minutes. She just pooped in the potty. Don’t get me wrong she will pee but it’s been a year. We started when she was 3. And she’s turning four in a few days and I feel like it’s just never going to happen. Anyone else been through this? She doesn’t have constipation. We offer plenty of fiber rich foods/water. Pediatrician said it’ll happen eventually some kids are just late bloomers. But I was FULLY potty trained by 2. I think I’m going insane.


r/pottytraining • • 2h ago

Serious Withholding 2.5 Year Old

1 Upvotes

We started the Oh crap method a week and a half ago. He peed on the potty twice in 5 days. Since then he had to go back to daycare and they don’t allow commando so we have been doing undies and pants. He hasn’t peed or pooped on the potty once since then.

He has 1-4 accidents a day but mostly withholds until bedtime. I’m due with a baby in a month. Do I keep pushing or stop all together or try pull-ups and keep doing potty sits?

It’s like his body just doesn’t know how to “go” on command.

Someone help!!


r/pottytraining • • 6h ago

Night time potty training

2 Upvotes

My toddler (nearly three) is so far doing great with potty training. She's trying so hard and I'm really proud of her. We did the Oh Crap! method this weekend to cement her habits into place after letting her try a potty for a few months.

We officially ditched diapers on Wednesday of last week (it's now Monday) and she's regularly peeing in the potty and is getting more comfortable with pooping. Our problem is the nights.

At night, we limit her water after 6 PM (though if she asks, of course we give it to her). A last potty before bed at 7:30, then down for bed. We check on her at 10 PM and 2 AM for "dream pees" in a potty next to her bed. She almost always refuses and just wants to get back in bed. We try but don't want to fully wake her and upset her.

At some point between 2 AM and her 7 AM wake up, she pees the bed.

I really don't want her sleeping in her own pee, so my questions are:

-if you had a night accident kid, when did they start consolidating and holding through the night?

-should I time night checks differently?

I'm trying to avoid putting on a night nappy as I think it will cause her to hold regular pees and poos until she gets the diaper. She's fine at nap time, so I hope this will help nights make sense to her eventually as well.

I am thrilled she's doing so awesome (though I understand there will be speed bumps) so I appreciate any help that folks can provide!


r/pottytraining • • 4h ago

Behavioural or situational resistance?

1 Upvotes

We started potty training our 26 month old in October. We loosely followed the “oh crap” method, he was naked for a long weekend & he did amazing! When he went back to daycare the following week (he does half day/morning daycare), they asked that he wear a pull up in case of accidents. He was still doing great wearing a pull up, using the toilet at daycare when prompted & after his nap at home, we would remove the pull up until bedtime. He was mostly staying dry and even doing some self-initiating. Fast forward to this past week where he has all of a sudden started refusing to use the potty for us, saying “no, I don’t want to” and having frequent accidents! He doesn’t seem to care when he’s wet even if we try with underwear or commando. We brought this up with his new daycare teacher who informed us that when the teacher switch happened she was not informed that he was potty training so he went a full week of no prompting from his teacher at daycare. I feel terrible for him as he’s likely very confused now. His teacher was very apologetic & said she will continue with prompting this week. My question is, is his resistance likely caused by the miscommunication? Should I push through this phase, not forcing him to use the potty, but still encouraging? Is this normal behaviour during potty training? Or is he just not ready yet? We are almost six weeks in, we thought he almost had the hang of it, but now it’s becoming a miserable experience for us all. I am tempted to wait out the week so see if there is any improvements after daycare is involved again but I’m frustrated & exhausted (also 27 weeks pregnant)!


r/pottytraining • • 4h ago

1 Week In (3y, 1m): Going Well, I Think, But What Is the Next Step?

1 Upvotes

We are on Day 8 of Potty Training (3 years, 1m) and things have gone decently well. However, I am still terrified about any long trips out for now and we’ve very much been at home/at grandparents this week.

Can regulars review our first week and critique/give tips for Week 2? 

First week (Day 1 - 7):

Pros

  • 87% hit rate - during week 1 our toddler has had 44 wees, 7 wee accidents, 3 successful poos, 0 poo accidents (she has always averaged every other day, this rate is normal for us). 2 of the 7 accidents were right before a poo, and another 2 were during meal-times. All of this excludes any wees in the bath or at nighttime which are impossible to track

  • Wees and poos on the potty every single time she’s awake at home.  

  • Is now officially pullup free unless she’s having her nap or asleep at night, at the caveat we've been pretty much solely at home. Days 1-5 she had her meals and car trips (10-15 minutes) to childminders in pullups, but the last 2 days she hasn’t had pullups on at any point except sleep.

  • Since Day 5 we’ve asked every 45-60 mins rather than 15-30 mins and she pees most times she goes to the potty now. This is at the caveat of going from zero accidents to maybe one a day, but feels like a more realistic benchmark.

  • Is now fully out of the high chair (Day 5) for every meal and has asked to come down for a wee twice (successfully). In general, she was still using a 0-36 month high chair for meals, it’s been nice to be done with it. 

  • Wiping herself clean after every wee (we are obviously cleaning her with poo). 

  • Is commando with clothes on. She still prefers being bottomless getting to the potty but has been fine the last 24 hours wearing clothes again commando. 

Negatives

  • Very much still having to prompt 90% of the time. She has told us “help” a few times followed by a successful wee where she made it, so there is some signs of initiation, but she’s still not actively telling us when she needs to go. I'm not sure if this is normal at this stage or not.

  • No experience out and about yet. Our solo trip out this week, which we couldn’t avoid, we did pullups as we could tell she wasn’t close to ready. We are thinking of trialing car journeys to childminders (15 mins) pullup free as a small starting point. We naturally don’t have many outings planned this week, but she starts school in 6 weeks so we are keen to get this nailed quickly. 

  • Still having 1-2 accidents a day. Days 2-4 she didn’t have any (but was also a bit pee-shy in general), Days 5-7 she’s averaging 8-10 successful wees and 1-2 accidents a day. Is this a “regression” or fine?

  • She still hates underpants. 

Our general plan this week is to consolidate clothing when not trying to go toilet, consolidate no pullups for meals and short car journeys, and starting short 15-30 min trips out with a portable potty. 

Any other advice on self-initiation and growing confidence out and about, or anything else I'm "doing wrong"? As long as it isn't brutal, I'd rather hear it!


r/pottytraining • • 5h ago

Nighttime help

1 Upvotes

My 4.5 year old boy has been fully day trained for almost exactly two years.

He has never woken up dry, ever. Save for once about a year ago when my husband realized at 5am he forgot to put him in a pull up and woke him up and he was dry.

Two nights ago, he put on his pull up before bed and peed in it, while awake. My husband has been suspect for a while that he’s knowingly peeing in them. So we decided it was time to take them away.

His bedtime routine is that we brush his teeth, he uses the potty, he has an hour of quiet play and a story on his Yoto, and then goes potty (used to put on a pull up here!) and gets into bed by 7:30. So he did that last night sans pull up and all was well. We heard him stirring around 9, I told him over the monitor to go ahead and try to pee. He did! I was so proud. I checked on him when we went to bed at 10, he was dry. I woke up and checked on him again around 1, he was dry. I checked on him again around 4:30, he was dry. All of those checks I didn’t wake him up. At 6 I went in to get him for the day and he was awake and had wet the bed. My husband said he heard him stirring around 5:30, he usually wakes up for the day between 5:30 and 6.

So I know there is a hormone they need to be ready. He seems to have it if he was dry the whole night until literally just before he wakes up for the day. My husband thinks he’s been peeing into his pull up upon waking for a while and he did it out of habit. I think I agree.

I guess I’m just posting this as vibe check that we should continue doing what we’re doing. Should we try waking him around 5/5:30? I don’t think he’d go back to sleep if we did that. He seemed to last all the way until his morning wake up.

I didn’t scold him at all, I just reminded him he really ought to get up and go on the potty. I reminded him if it’s scary he has a flashlight he can bring with him. He seems to want us to go with him but I know he can do it by himself (he does all day and before bed).


r/pottytraining • • 4h ago

Can you tell me if my son seems ready?

0 Upvotes

My son is 2 years and 8 months (32 months old).
We started potty training yesterday however he’s used the potty several times at home off and on, both on his own and prompted.

He does not like being naked and wants pants on all the time so we just got him undies to put on under his pants which he likes.

He sometimes gets mad or annoyed when we try to get him to sit on the potty and will just leave the bathroom in a fuss while other times he is excited and willing. Yesterday he had about 2 successful pees and 1 poop on the potty, and then about 4 pee accidents.

For the pee accidents he just kind of laughs about it, the wet pants don’t bother him and if I say oops next time let’s try to go on the potty instead he just goes “no!!!” lol.

So many mixed signals I just don’t know if this means he’s not ready or if this is normal potty training.

This is my first kid so I’m not sure! If someone can help me out :)


r/pottytraining • • 1d ago

Literally crying because of potty training

22 Upvotes

I have twin girls who turn 4 in 2 weeks, and they're not potty trained yet. I have no idea what to do. I feel like we have tried everything and nothing is working

We have tried no pants day, potty training underwear with plastic ones over them, we've tried just regular underwear, setting a timer to go, just randomly telling them to go, sticker charts, candy rewards- literally everything.

They know what to do because our oldest (she's only 15 months older than them) goes to the bathroom, they've seen me go to the bathroom, and all of that. You tell the twins to go potty, they typically do with no issues. But whenever they're adamant about wearing underwear (like today) they will just stand (or sit) there and pee or poo. They make no attempt to go to the bathroom or even the small potty training potty we have as a backup.

I am at my wits end and had a couple breakdowns about this because I don't know what to do and I feel like I'm failing them

Any advice would be amazing 🥺 It can be the most unhinged thing you tried- I do not care. I will try anything


r/pottytraining • • 19h ago

Toddler poop withholds even with diapers

4 Upvotes

So my daughter has chronic constipation her whole life but last 6 months she's been on miralax daily so it's very soft and not painful but her instinct is still to hold her poops. Her poop is so soft that even when she tries to hold it a little comes out and we had to change her like 10 times a day. We got fed up and thought potty training would avoid so many diaper changes but shes doing same thing still. Our whole day can revolve arround her crying every few mins that she has to poop and you see her whole body goes rigid. There's no way her poop has hurt in the last 6 months, her poop is pretty much newborn consistency. I'm worried she's going to give herself a pelvic floor dysfunction from making it instinct for her body to clench when a poo is coming. And how do I potty train when she's just leaking poop all day. She pees on the potty fine, no issues there at all. She's in daycare so I can't expect them to deal with her poop all day. And she's an expert at holding poop. When she was younger she held so much poop in that it blocked her ability to pee and had to be hospitalized and catheter and enima. Also there's nothing diet related we can do to help, shes the most picky eater in the world.


r/pottytraining • • 1d ago

My reflections on two months of toilet training my 2.5yo

39 Upvotes
  1. I wish I had regularly introduced the potty when he was a baby (under a year old) for whenever i could see a poo coming, so that it was normalised early and not such a dramatic change.

  2. I used the Oh Crap method. While I appreciated her insights and I’m sure the method works well for a lot of people, in hindsight it feels a lot like the equivalent of cry-it-out for sleep. Throws the kid in the deep end. I wish I’d recognised that would fall flat with my kid, and taken an approach with less pressure - gradual and starting very very early.

  3. I wish when first training, I'd brought the potty to him and put it under his stream of wee, rather than the high-flurry process of whisking him from wherever he was to the potty. Introduced too much of a stress association for him.

  4. I wish I’d been more disciplined to get enough sleep every night - forget all housework, messages etc - so that I could more easily be a complete angel in the face of accidents and show zero reaction.

  5. If I’m lucky enough to have a second kid, I will be using a potty from as early as they can sit well; daily potty sit after waking; nappy free time in a playpen where I bring the potty to them and gently sit them on the potty if I can catch any accidents; and ultimately dropping nappies with a good week of advance discussion & positivity building.

That’s what’s on my mind as we revert to nappies 8 weeks in.


r/pottytraining • • 12h ago

Toilet timed, not trained

1 Upvotes

Hi all,
Started toilet training my 2yo over 2 months ago now. She’s picked it up pretty well, uses the big toilet for wees and poos, but will only go when prompted (I prompt approx every hour). She goes just about every time, but if she needs to go outside of me asking her, she won’t tell me and will just wee herself. I guess I’m wondering if anyone has any tips on encouraging some initiative? I know she’s young and it will probably eventually come, but what can I do to maybe get her there sooner?


r/pottytraining • • 13h ago

Potty Training Problem

1 Upvotes

I need help. We started potty training our son at 23M. After a month of potty training he finally lets us know when he needs to use the restroom, but now he uses that as an excuse to get out of his high chair and car seat after he no longer wants to sit in it. The problem we now have is he says he needs to use it, we take him but he doesn’t use it. Just uses that excuse so he can get out of it. We are now having accidents in the car because he constantly says he needs to use the restroom but we don’t know when he’s lying or not thus resulting in accidents in the car seat. Has anyone experienced this and how did you guys deal with it?


r/pottytraining • • 15h ago

Potty training accident - Terrified of the toilet

1 Upvotes

daughter is just under 2 (in january) we started potty training yesterday. we got her a pink potty it flushes and everything she absolutely loved it. spent all day no diaper just sitting on it, even had two successful wee’s in the toilet. it went very well. i turn away for one second and she pooped on the carpet, i didn’t mean to react badly. i didn’t yell at her or anything she was just scream crying because she stepped in it. we were both over stimulated, i told her it’s okay accidents happen but she was already very worked up.

today comes around and she is fully refusing even going near the toilet. she won’t even sit on it and i can see her holding her but and clenching her butt like she’s afraid to poop. i know it’s only been one day of trying but she’s such a fast learner and yesterday went so well.

i’m feeling so discouraged now she only wants a diaper. how do we get past this?

appreciate no judgement, first time mom and potty training is so daunting to me


r/pottytraining • • 18h ago

How often and how long are you promoting block one oh crap or any PT method?

1 Upvotes

What’s the fine line between pressure and practice?

Do you only move them to potty mid pee or poop? I think that’s the oh crap method. What about other times? Upon wake? Before meal? Etc? How LONG do you have them sit for? I see conflicting advice amongst experts some say less than 15 seconds if nothing is happening others say minutes.


r/pottytraining • • 18h ago

Need Advice on 21 month old boy potty training

1 Upvotes

Okay so my son (21 months) has been showing ALL of the signs of being ready to potty train. Says when he needs to go potty, tells me when he needs a new diaper, knows when he has to pee vs poop, takes his diaper/pull-up off if it’s dirty, and wants desperately to sit on the toilet when he feels like he needs to go potty. But for some reason as soon as he sits on his training toilet he just won’t go to the bathroom. He’s successfully peed in the potty once but we were sitting there for a good 10-15 minutes before he finally peed. I feel like I’m losing my mind and he needs to be potty trained by 2 years old to be able to go to daycare which is a necessity since I work full time from home and having him home with me while working and trying to stay on top of housework and cooking is leading to a mountain of burn out for me. Has anyone had a similar issue? How did you work on it? I’m so desperate at this point that I’m willing to try any method


r/pottytraining • • 19h ago

Potty training for about a month and still having multiple accidents a week

1 Upvotes

Potty training my 21 month old for almost a month. He is successful in a lot of ways; when he’s with me (mom) he self initiates 80% of the time, doesn’t fight the potty when prompted, and has maybe 1-2 accidents per week.

But in daycare and when he’s with other people (dad, grandparents) he has accidents, usually more than one per day. He was with his dad most of the day yesterday and had 4 accidents (among many successes though).

Daycare believes his issue is that he doesn’t empty his bladder and doesn’t hold his pee and I kind of agree; while he doesn’t have many accidents with me, he pees a little bit fairly frequently. I’m now focusing on not taking him to the potty as soon as he prompts and instead having him wait a couple minutes before taking him. I’ve only been doing it for one day so it’s hard to tell progress but he hasn’t had any accidents so far.

I fear he’s not actually ready to potty train because of how he does with other people plus not emptying his bladder or holding pee. If you were me, would you take a break at this point?


r/pottytraining • • 21h ago

Not self initiating at daycare/shy toddler

1 Upvotes

Any tips for helping a shy 3yo feel confident enough to tell staff at daycare that they need to go toilet?

Fully self initiating at home, fine for long drives, public outings etc and at grandparents houses are all solid.

At daycare she will not tell an adult she needs to go and being very short for her age isn't tall enough to get up onto the (toddler sized) toilet independently. Also still working on pulling pants back up (she can, but tends to just leave the bathroom with no pants on) so she does need a little assistance/reminding to wipe and wash hands etc..

Id hate to have her need to be in nappies at daycare just because she is too shy to let anyone know she needs to go. We had a hard time getting this far, she was very attached to nappies (lots of begging for them back). I dont want it to cause a regression at home by using them at daycare.


r/pottytraining • • 1d ago

Kinda losing it 3 and 2 months.

2 Upvotes

We’ve been potty training him since a month after he turned 2. He instantly took to peeing, he refuses to poop on there, he says he’s scared of the feeling, he just sqauted down to pick up his toy and (no underwear) shit on the floor. We’ve tried so many books, ms Rachel, candy, sitting on the toilet leads to nothing for an hour, then he will immeditealy poop on the floor/underwear. No accidents at night, no accidental pees in public.

I don’t know what we’re doing wrong


r/pottytraining • • 19h ago

One-page checklist for poop refusal (free, I made it)

0 Upvotes

Poop seems to be where many of us get stuck, so I put the basics on one page. The short version:

  1. Feet flat on the floor or a stool, knees a little above hips.

  2. Short, relaxed sits of about 5 minutes after meals.

  3. Keep your voice neutral after accidents.

  4. Change diapers in the bathroom so poop and the bathroom start to belong together.

  5. Pain, hard stools or holding for days? Check with your doctor.

Happy to share the printable ('Poop on the Potty: A calm checklist') if anyone wants it. Disclosure: I wrote it and I also sell a potty training ebook, The Daycare Potty Plan. Mods, please remove if this breaks the rules.


r/pottytraining • • 1d ago

Transitioning from EC to pantless went fine but sudden regression when we trasitioned to underwear/pants.

1 Upvotes

I started Elimination Communication (EC) with my now 21 month son at 6 months, and he’s been diaper-free at home since 11 months with very few accidents. Up until recently, I relied mostly on timing (45 minutes after fluids, after wake-ups, before leaving the house, coming back home) and subtle cues rather than him explicitly telling me he had to go.

Since I work from home, EC worked great for us, and I planned to wait until he was talking to fully potty train. However, we decided to start him in part-time daycare (2 days a week) at 20 months. But I learnt daycares generally don’t accommodate EC (which makes sense and its fine) so I wanted to transition him to full potty training before he started.

He has always grunted to signal poop, so a month before daycare, I taught him the sign for pee. It took a few weeks for him to connect the dots and sign it back to me when he was peeing on the toilet. Once he started daycare last month, I switched him to going completely bottomless at home. He picked it up quickly and within a few days he was consistently signaling his urges, and last week, we’ve had almost no accidents.

Starting this week, I finally put him in underwear and thought of letting the daycare know that he can sign to pee now but he has started peeing in them. I assumed going bottomless was the best bridge, so it feels like we're starting from scratch. The frustrating part is that he siesnt follow EC timings anymore and I have been wiping pee out of carpets the last few days. I am being adviced that he needs to go back in diapers which sounds like a bigger regression.

Has anyone else dealt with this? How did you get past the underwear hurdle?


r/pottytraining • • 1d ago

Explain like I’m 5

1 Upvotes

Okay so my toddler is 21 months, soon to be 22. I have a 6 month old too so we held off any earlier attempts in case it was too much going on for him with a new sibling but I’m trying to prepare myself now so I can start soon. Ideally I’d like to start by 24 months but I know that’ll hugely depend on him. I had a few questions for those who are more experienced:

  1. Obviously overnight dryness is hormonal so he will still have a nappy, but do you allow them to poop in that morning nappy too? For context, sometimes he wakes up and just plays in his crib for about 20-30 minutes and we usually let him as it just prepares him for the day. Sometimes he will poop during this time. Does that count as a setback or is that fine?

  2. Do you actually have to stay at home for the time it takes to potty train or is that purely dependent on the child?

  3. Would it still be wise to start even if they’re not properly speaking yet or does this not matter?

Any tips would be greatly appreciated! Sorry if they’re stupid questions lol


r/pottytraining • • 1d ago

Pull ups at daycare

1 Upvotes

We started potty training my 2.5 year old boy, we are at day 3 and its not going so well... a lot of refusal to go on the toilet or potty and when he has accidents he just takes off his underwear and keeps playing. He is supposed to go back at daycare tuesday and they will put him in a pull up if he has a lot of accidents. He uses his pull ups as diapers and does not care if he pees and poos in them. I am wondering if we just give up and try later like during christmas vacations. Any advice or ideas?