r/pottytraining • • Aug 03 '21

I think I’ll be prompting my child to pee through high school

271 Upvotes

The year is 2034. A high school gym is decorated for prom. My sixteen-year-old’s copper hair is swept up in a glamorous updo, and she gazes flirtatiously with her blue eyes at her date. A timer goes off. I appear from behind a balloon arch and lead my teen to the restroom for a potty break, promising she can go back to dancing after she does a nice pee pee.


r/pottytraining • • Jan 14 '21

Welcome to r/pottytraining!

237 Upvotes

Welcome! I'm a mod here and I'm thrilled to be here to support any and all potty training questions and concerns you have. This is a space to commiserate, share tips, and truly marvel at the wonder of teaching one of life's most basic skills! Congratulations on getting to this step!

Check out the Wiki tab for resources and books: https://www.reddit.com/r/pottytraining/wiki/index

And to those who have wondered, "What's the deal with this sub? Why isn't it active?" Well, I wondered the same thing for months! I finally earned enough karma points and officially requested to take over r/pottytraining. I was granted my wish and here I am! My aim is to reinvigorate this sub and get it moving again. I can't wait!


r/pottytraining • • Oct 08 '26

Just buy the miralax

219 Upvotes

Do it. Just do it. We started our guy on it this week and I’m kicking myself for not trying this sooner. If your toddler is pooping even just every other day, they might be constipated. Constipation=accidents and withholding. Please just try it. I didn’t see the point for the longest time but I get it now. BUY THE MIRALAX


r/pottytraining • • Jun 27 '26

You guys I think we cracked the code

212 Upvotes

My 3.5 year old has been working on potty training for 9 months. He was having poop accidents every.single.day. For 9 MONTHS.

3 weeks ago he fell and broke his arm and had to be put under anesthesia to have it set. He hasn’t had a single accident since.

Turned him off and turned him back on again. A hard reset, if you will.

This is 100% true but also 100% satire lol not suggesting you get your kid to break their arm but I’ll take the win 🤣


r/pottytraining • • Sep 20 '26 Bravo

Tough love for parents of kids who won’t poop on the toilet

203 Upvotes

First, make sure they aren’t constipated. If pooping hurts, they’re going to hold it, which makes it hurt more, and then you’re stuck in a cycle. Hard or painful stools, bleeding, leakage, or days of withholding = call the pediatrician.

But assuming that piece is being treated: stop making pooping the biggest event in your household.

Don’t beg. Don’t ask every 10 minutes. Don’t keep increasing the prize. And don’t get visibly angry or disappointed when there’s an accident. Your child now knows everyone is extremely invested in where they poop, which gives the whole thing way too much power.

If they poop in their underwear, stay completely neutral. “Poop goes in the toilet. Let’s clean this up.” Then they help. They take off their clothes, put the poop in the toilet, bring the underwear to the laundry, wipe themselves as much as they reasonably can, and help get clean. Obviously you supervise and finish whatever they can’t do, but you do not swoop in and make the entire consequence disappear.

This isn’t a punishment and you don’t need to shame them. It’s just the natural next step when you poop somewhere other than the toilet: it has to be cleaned up. Keep it boring and matter-of-fact every single time.

Have them sit for a few minutes after meals with their feet supported. If they will only poop in a diaper, the diaper happens in the bathroom. Then sitting on the toilet while wearing it. Then you gradually work toward taking it off.

The tough-love part is mostly for the parents. Stop negotiating. Stop reacting. Stop turning every poop into a family crisis. Stay calm, keep the boundary, and let cleaning an accident be less convenient than using the toilet.


r/pottytraining • • Aug 19 '25

I would pay someone $1000 to potty train my kid.

179 Upvotes

He knows he needs to poop. I know he needs to poop. He knows that I know he needs to poop. JUST POOP IN THE FUCKING TOILET!

We've read the books and done the charts. I can't figure out what will motivate him to poop in the toilet. We sit on the potty regularly. I've made it as fun and engaging as I know how, and he's only pooped on the potty a handful of times out of months we've been at this.

I want to pull my hair out. And I want to pull his hair out.

Venting over. And I don't feel any better. 🙃✌️

Edit: thank you for the validation. My friends' kids all potty trained really quickly (within a few weeks, pee and poop), so I felt very alone in my struggles. We've been at it for months. It puts it into perspective that some of y'all have been struggling for years. Years?!!? My heart physically aches for you.


r/pottytraining • • Apr 21 '21

Does anyone else feel like all the blogs and books about potty training “in just three days” is total shit?

176 Upvotes

It just feels like 3 days is the norm if you ask the internet, but real life it totally sucks and it’s been two months here and it’s total hit and miss.


r/pottytraining • • Apr 05 '20

Update to the ER visit last week!

167 Upvotes

So my son (2 1/2) had a trip to the ER for holding poop and vomiting-I ended up having to give him an enema that I truly thought neither of us would recover from.

One week later, I’m a beaming proud mama after celebrating his first unassisted poop on the potty. I took the advice to just slip him back in diapers but he was adamant about still peeing on the potty which is difficult with diapers. After two days we went back to freeballing in gym shorts, had a few nighttime poops and then today, a miracle. I didn’t make any fuss. Barely made eye contact. I just quietly said now. It’s time to do this. You gotta poop, so just take your time. And I looked straight ahead at the wall and he let out some toots, then finally it just came out. He was so excited!! He leaped down to flush and said bye bye to his poop. Anyway, this was huge for us. Thanks for the advice guys and the kind words last week.


r/pottytraining • • May 23 '25

Lack of evidence in current potty training culture

156 Upvotes

I have noticed on this sub and in parenting circles in general there is a lot of emphasis on waiting until the child is “ready”, signs of readiness and on intensive methods like oh crap/3 day methods.

I wanted to point out for those unaware that this approach doesn’t follow the science at all.

I’m from the UK and there is a really good charity called ERIC https://eric.org.uk/potty-training/ which summarises an evidence based approach to potty training. They emphasise starting early with lots of practice and going slow with no pressure.

I see lots of stressed out parents on here finding it difficult and personally I think most parents are now leaving it too late. Children in the western world are now potty trained later than ever before despite the evidence showing that potty training is easier and better for bowel and bladder health when started younger. Leaving it til they’re 3 and trying to do it in 3 days probably makes a lot of money for the authors of all these potty training books (that’s probably how we got here) but it just isn’t backed up by the evidence.

I was aware of ERIC before I had my daughter as I had used it as a doctor working in paediatrics (it is a good parent resource for constipation). I’ve followed their advice and started early with practice and no pressure from about 18 months, we have now just taken her out of nappies at 25 months and it’s been pretty smooth and stress free as she already has all the skills.

So if you are a parent of a younger toddler wondering if your child is “ready”, I would highly recommend taking a look at ERIC and consider just cracking on. It is also a useful resource for potty problems at any age.


r/pottytraining • • Jul 11 '26

Finally trained my son (just turned 3) after 6 months of him only going in a diaper - What worked

150 Upvotes

Wanted to share our experience because I read basically every diaper refusal post on this sub over the past 6 months and the thing that finally worked for us came from outside reddit, so maybe it helps someone in the same boat.

Background: my son would sit on the potty no problem. Sitting was never the issue. He would sit there with a book for upto 30 mins, nothing, and then ask me for a diaper like 5 minutes later and go immediately. He could hold it basically indefinitely and he could tell us when he needed to go, so physically he was ready, everyone kept telling us he was ready. He just would not release anywhere except a diaper. We tried the warm bath thing, letting him go in the yard, nothing worked, it had to be the diaper. This went on for close to 6 months and I was exhausted and honestly starting to worry something was actually wrong.

Things we tried that did not work for us (we did each one for 3-4 days or so before giving up):

  1. Sticker chart with a prize box. He liked the stickers. Did not change anything about the diaper.

  2. Emptying his diaper into the potty in front of him so he could see where it goes. A lot of people recommend this one. For my son it made things worse, he got visibly upset watching us do it and asked us to stop.

  3. Naked weekend. He held it the whole time and we caved on day 2 because I was getting worried about withholding.

  4. Letting him pick out his own seat at the store. He picked one, loved it, sat on it happily, still asked for the diaper.

So after all of that we were out of ideas and honestly just rotating through suggestions, and looking back I think that was the real problem, we never understood why he was refusing, we were just trying things on him.

The turning point was completely random. We were at a birthday party and one of the other dads turned out to be a child psychologist, and I unloaded our entire situation on the poor guy. What he explained (paraphrasing, he said it better): at this age a lot of kids genuinely experience their poop as a part of their body. So going in the potty is not a hygiene lesson to them, it feels like losing a part of themselves into an object they have no relationship with. And the diaper has been the correct place for it since birth, its warm, its right against their body, so in his head the diaper is where it belongs and the potty is basically a stranger to him. He said think about who you hand your phone to, you hand it to a friend without thinking and not to a stranger. So the first job is not getting him to go on the potty at all, its making the potty HIS first.

I was honestly skeptical, it sounded a little out there, but it was also the first explanation that matched what we were actually seeing, because my son was never scared of sitting, he was scared of releasing. Googling around, I found a plan for exactly for my situation when i described the reason the way we learnt it.

Here is a summary of what we did:
- We moved the potty out of the bathroom and placed it in the living room near his toys. For about a week, we completely stopped asking him to sit on it. It was simply there. He eventually gave it a name and decorated it with truck stickers. My husband thought the whole thing was ridiculous
- After about a week, we brought sitting back only as a game. The potty would “invite” him to sit in a silly voice. He first sat with his clothes on and later without them, but there was still zero expectation that he would actually go. For the first time in months, the potty was not a fight.
- Then we gradually faded the diaper. The first rule was that pooping in the diaper was completely fine, but it had to happen in the bathroom while he sat on the potty. He accepted that within a day, probably because we were not taking the diaper away. After that, we put the diaper on a little more loosely each time. Around the fourth day, it was basically open underneath him while he sat on the potty.He went and looked more surprised than we did. We let him flush and wave goodbye, which he thought was hilarious. We also tried to keep the praise focused on what he had done rather than on how happy or proud it made us.
- Pee followed about two days later using the same gradual approach. It took around another week before poop was consistently happening in the potty.

Altogether, it took a little under three weeks after six months of getting nowhere. What I would tell my past self is that, at least for our son, the refusal was not stubbornness.

The diaper was where poop belonged in his mind. Everything we had tried before was essentially an attempt to take away the familiar option without giving him something that felt safe enough to replace it.

Once the potty stopped feeling like a random object, many of the same things that had failed for months started working within days.

Sorry for the length. I may come back and add details as I remember them. If your child is also willing to sit but refuses to go, I am happy to answer questions. This sub kept me sane for months, so I hope our experience helps someone else.


r/pottytraining • • 26d ago Bravo

The pressure and shame around potty training is exhausting

140 Upvotes

Why is there such a militant culture around potty training in this subreddit? Some folks seem to have hard rules about when you must start, how many days it should take, and why you can never go back to nappies once you’ve started.

I feel like we’ve turned a teachable skill into a test of parenting competence. People find a method that worked for their child and suddenly act like it’s the only correct way, as if all children have the same temperament, readiness and experiences.

I get that consistency and routine can help, but surely there’s a difference between providing structure and rigidly sticking to a method when your child is distressed or struggling. Taking a break or adapting your approach shouldn’t automatically mean you’re confusing your child or setting them up for failure.

Not everything needs to be a battle of wills with an arbitrary deadline. Why can’t we focus more on what’s making things difficult for an individual child and what might help them feel safe enough to learn, rather than shaming parents for not following a particular method?

If you’ve found this corner of the internet I want you to remember that you can trust your instincts and listen to your child. Having empathy and kindness goes a long way and you can still find results this way.

Edit to remove developmental milestone. I agree. This is more a learned skill and culturally relevant than a true developmental milestone.


r/pottytraining • • Jul 21 '21

What worked for our stubborn kid who held it forever...

137 Upvotes

My husband and I started potty training our 3yo daughter Monday of last week. It was a lot of tears and frustration and feelings of failure.

We started doing the 3-day method, cold turkey - gave her diapers to a baby. Taking her to the potty every 15min. Nothing except tantrums. We started saying every 30min "tell me when you need to use the potty." Nothing. We tried to bribe her - candy, screen time, toys, trips to the bakery, library, etc - nothing.

She began holding it forever and it started to hurt. She would cry and refuse to release until we put her in a pull-up at naptime and at night. We felt so bad for her. She was so so sad.

With advice from my seasoned SIL who also had stubborn, headstrong kids, we did as she suggested. All she said was. "I wonder what will happen if you just put her in underwear, left the potty in plain sight, and didn't mention it at all." We said we'd try anything.

It worked! Yesterday, I was busy doing something and she just pulled down her underwear and went! The same thing happened four times today! We haven't nagged or bribed her at all and that was that! We even went out for the morning and she held it till she got home. She seems to be mostly motivated by keeping her underwear dry so we don't say "It's time to use the potty." we say "are you keeping your underwear dry?"

Hopefully, this advice works for someone else too! We know it's not over, but we're so relieved that she's not crying, afraid to use the potty anymore.


r/pottytraining • • 20d ago Bravo

I promised myself I would post the success story I wanted to see.

136 Upvotes

In my darkness days I scrolled this sub looking for success stories but I’ve realised most people leave once they’ve had success. So here’s the success story I wanted to see.

We started training my twin toddlers (now 3) a few months ago now. We did 4 days at home naked, didn’t go anywhere, and worked really hard on it. We had an absolute wild ride. Initially they did well, then they didn’t. We had pee withholding until they couldn’t anymore, refusal to try the potty, many many poo accidents, horrible days at daycare where they needed to be put back in pull ups because they had so many accidents. I felt in my soul that I shouldn’t go back to nappies so I kept going.

I can finally say that we are seeing light at the end of the tunnel. As frustrated as I was reading this at the time, I am convinced now that it was genuinely just time that did it. Repetition, familiarity and staying strong even though I was crumbling. And let me tell you, I have found this to be the hardest parts of parenthood, second only to my children being born early and being in hospital which of course far outweighs this. But I will make a list of things we did and didn’t do. Maybe they’ll help you, maybe they won’t.

The final piece of the puzzle has been daycare and I just want to say to the daycare parents here, it’s so hard. Twin B was just not going to the toilet for poo at daycare for AGES. I think time was the only thing that changed it for her. They still have a potty preference for poo at home and we are working on it, but I don’t consider it insurmountable as they do poop in the toilet at daycare.

What we did

-We played some pottyganda for them. They don’t watch TV and so the novelty effect was huge. Daniel Tiger and Ms Rachel.

-Read a copy of the Lovavery book about going to poo – it’s genuinely good

-Took photos of the toilet at daycare (obviously with no kids) and showed the kids the photos at home and talked about how we pee and poo on the toilet at daycare

-Made up little social stories.

-We pushed for undies at daycare, not pullups. Look, I am of the opinion that a pullup is a nappy/diaper. I’m sorry. There’s no difference in feel for them.

-Made potties available in multiple rooms and also got a toilet seat reducer

-Got them some novelty foamy handwash

-Kept fucking going even though every fibre of my being wanted to give up.

-Recognised and praised them listening to their bodies, not just the poop or pee itself.

-Backed down when they started resisting (the hardest thing EVER). No constant reminders.

-Talked to daycare, talked to them again, talked to them again. Supported the teachers as best we could – eg we take the girls to the toilet at drop off.

-KEPT GOING. I felt it in my bones my kids were ready. If you doubt it, then take a break. But my kids were almost 3, and they were ready. I believed it.

 

What we didn’t do

-Reward charts or prizes or sweet treats. I know my kids. This wouldn’t work for them and they’d clock it immediately. You know your kid best and if they’re motivated by reward, it’s a great tool in the toolbox

-Put nappies on when we finally left the house. It’s convenient but it’s confusing. We packed clean up supplies, extra clothes etc and tried to time it as well as we could.

I think there’s also a huge mental mindgame for parents in this and I wanted to talk about this. I am very Type A and for the first time in parenting I felt that the amount of effort I put into it did not correlate with the amount of success. I found that so fucking hard to reconcile that I actually had to seek therapy. Not even kidding. What helped me was actually a tool I learnt in therapy which is called the circle of control. Google it. There are some things in your control, some things you can influence, and some things outside your control. I made a visual for myself. I can’t post it here but here’s a list of some of the things

Things I control

-A positive potty environment

-My attitude, facial expressions, language

-Whether I show them pottyganda and read to them

-Conversations with daycare and advocating for my kids

-My own will power.

-The research I consume.

-Providing fibrous foods

Things I influence

-Daycare hours and days for one day a week. I have a flexible job where I can influence the time they go to daycare on a Friday.

-The potty environment at daycare. I can make suggestions but cannot enforce them

-Emotions – I can respond to their emotions but I cannot stop them from feeling them.

-Foods that they consume – I can encourage consumption of fibrous foods but cannot control it.

Things out of my control

-Whether my kids pee/poo. It’s their body and I do not control it.

-Whether the pottyganda “sinks in”

-Whether they go to daycare at all. I need to provide for my family.

-Their rate of physiological development. I cannot make them become more aware of their body at a rate faster than they are able to.

-Daycare actions in the moment

-Their digestion

– how often they go

I hope this helps someone, anyone. May the poo gods be with you, I sure felt like they abandoned me for several months.


r/pottytraining • • Mar 21 '20

Unpopular opinion: pull-ups are just diapers that are harder to change.

135 Upvotes

Potty training is going pretty well for us except for pooping. She has always had issues with pooping and at this point I could care less that she poops in the potty. I just want her to poop. She wears underwear most of the day and goes pee on the potty but asks for a diaper when she has to go poop. I got some pull-ups for her to use and my experience with them is that they are just less convenient diapers.


r/pottytraining • • Oct 06 '21

If my daughter could read, I'd put this in her room

Post image
128 Upvotes

r/pottytraining • • Nov 07 '21

My son just told me he was proud of me for peeing in the toilet

122 Upvotes

We're pretty open about using the bathroom in our house and I usually forget to close the door when I'm in there. Tonight I went to pee while I was putting my son to bed and he came over to tell me he was proud of me, hand me some toilet paper, and help me flush. It was super cute and also clearly we live in the potty train bizarro world


r/pottytraining • • May 05 '23

Toddler is potty trained, we used the bribery method

Post image
121 Upvotes

r/pottytraining • • Aug 14 '25

3 day method/Oh Crap Method is really doing all of us a disservice

120 Upvotes

I think the 3 day potty training / oh crap method is just a load of (no pun intended) crap and setting us parents up for frustration and feelings of failure. Expectations are way too high, and so far from reality!

Everyone recommended it to me and was like “potty train on a weekend!” But I didn’t realize it would take so much longer and more of a commitment.

There are unicorn children, of course, those who really take to potty training and are trained within a few days, but I want to give my experience:

My newly potty trained 3 year old took 2 weeks to get down to 2-3 accidents a day, 1 month to have only 1 accident, and 2 months to have 0 accidents. OH, she took 2 months to even TELL us when she has to go to the potty. Before that, she would never say anything! Like what?? That took so dang long! Also, she’s still in pull ups for nap and bedtime.

So yeah…it’s incredibly disheartening on day 3 when you think your child shouldn’t be having accidents, yet they have 8 accidents that day…and you’re frustrated, and don’t know if you should keep trying to train him or her.

I’m here to say… you have to keep going. Potty training is for the long haul. Progress wont be instantaneous or linear. It takes a long time and different for every kid!

Keep going and keep it positive!! You’re literally training a toddler who can’t even figure out shoelaces or buckles or how to eat food without it landing on the floor or making a mess of their hands and face… don’t expect such a quick turn around for them to learn how to pee and poop on a toilet (+ pushing down their pants and undies and then pulling them back up! It’s a lot!)

( Open for thoughts )


r/pottytraining • • Jan 26 '22

To the mom who had the idea to make a “Christmas bathroom” for her child. I LOVE you and thank you!!!!

120 Upvotes

I remember reading that post in this sub over the holidays - fellow mom saying she’s had the brilliant idea to transform her bathroom into a Christmas themed bathroom where it was like Santa threw up in there, and her kid loved it. I thought, ok that’s what I’ll do if all else failed. Well, all else failed. So I transformed my 3yo’s bathroom into his favorite obsession these days. Stickers, decals, lights, you name it!! And omfg it worked!!! I mean it was still a pain to get him to go on the toilet everyday, but at least he was super excited for the first few days. And we got to establish the start of a great routine, let him know he was capable of doing it, and we overcame his fear! It’s now getting easier and easier everyday.

Thank you u/mamaofasharkie !!!!! You are a friggin genius!!! I’m so happy to say goodbye to diaper changes I can cry.


r/pottytraining • • Jan 16 '22

Stop letting the “it only took me three days crowd” discourage you.

120 Upvotes

I to was given the speech of “wait until they’re ready! It only took me two days to get him trained!” And I did just that, I waited. The thing is, it’s not always one size fits all. Sure lots of people will have that instant success. But at the end of the day our kids will be vastly different. Im on attempt 3 and finally seeing success but I know it’s going to be slow because even though my kid is very ready she’s still not all that comfortable. Just take a deep breath and know it will click and a confident kid on the potty is way better then a kid who comes to resent it.


r/pottytraining • • May 31 '26 Bravo Mindblown

There’s no rewards for cleaning poopy underwear

118 Upvotes

… just in case you didn’t know or needed to hear it. If there was an award I would have already earned it so trust me… I know.

“But underwear is so unnecessarily expensive”

I know, so here’s what you’re going to do so that you can throw out all the poopy underwear - next time someone is offering up their kids underwear sized 2-5 in your neighbourhood buy nothing group instead of thinking “absolutely not, that’s weird” you’re going to be all over that free used underwear so that you can throw it in the trash instead of scraping all the poo from it.

“But this might be the last time my kid poops in their underwear”

Great, then you’ll only be throwing out 1 pair.

Trust me, it’s not worth it.

Signed someone, that for some reason, is still rescuing their nearly potty trained kid’s underwear every.single.time.

For the love of everything someone needs to tell me to throw out the underwear!


r/pottytraining • • Aug 29 '26

Ms. Rachel + potty training

115 Upvotes

Quick advice for those who may need it - watch the Ms Rachel potty training episode with your toddler! She talks about telling someone when you have a “pee feeling” and my kid (2.5) started telling me this after watching the episode a few times. A huge help!


r/pottytraining • • Jun 29 '22

You know you’re a parent when you’re sending poop photos to your family at 7am

Post image
113 Upvotes

r/pottytraining • • Dec 23 '24

PSA: Stop Trying to Potty Train

111 Upvotes

As you can see from my previous posts, my husband and I tried and failed to potty train our child for over one year. We bought stickers, prizes, snacks, a chart, two special potty seats, books, a potty watch…. nothing.

I can’t speak for all kids, but I can say that for ours, pressure and expectation backfired completely.

She is finally potty trained. And you know why? Because we quit trying until one morning she announced “I want to wear underwear today” (unprovoked) and pretty much nailed it since.

How much heartache could we have avoided if we’d just LET HER TAKE THE LEAD???

So. If you feel like literally nothing is working… and it’s become a huge power struggle… maybe just wait for it to be their idea. Might not work for every kid, but it sure worked for us!


r/pottytraining • • Nov 29 '19

We used these videos to potty train all 4 kids. We bought the DVDs back when that was a thing. Now, they put them up on YouTube. Enjoy!!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
110 Upvotes