r/poshmark • • 15h ago

Odd Problem

I recently started selling on Poshmark, though I have been on other platforms for quite a long time. I committed the terrible error of using the wrong label on the wrong package. I know, I know! A Posh item went to an eBay buyer and vice versa. The Posh item was returned to me, and I refunded the eBay buyer when I received it. The Posh sale went through after three days because I did not hear from the buyer. I messaged her the day that I realized the error. I messaged her again five days later, and again at ten days. I did provide her with a return label.

After thirteen days, she replied that I should send her correct item to her PO Box, and gave me the address and also her phone number. I explained I would not send the item until the incorrect one was returned to me, and that I didn't want to do anything off of the platform - call her or send to a different address. It's now been five days since she sent that message, and crickets.

Is there anything I am missing here? How long would you hold her item before you put it up for resale? I'm thinking of waiting 60 days. Thanks for any advice!

2 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

3

u/Dizzy-Ad-8749 13h ago

If the sale already closed, you’re not going to be able to do anything. The time to get PM involved(open a case) was before the 3 days was up. PM would’ve emailed your customer the return label with instructions.

1

u/modest_irish_goddess 12h ago

Thank you! The problem is she just does not read or respond to messages. I'm unsure if she can open a case at this point.

2

u/Happy_Appeal_988 10h ago

If what she received was better than what she ordered then she might not have wanted to return the item. You didn’t specify. There are a lot of lazy and just plain dishonest people out there. Thing to do would have been to notify Poshmark right away about the error.

1

u/modest_irish_goddess 9h ago

Thank you! She ordered a necklace and received an antique creamer. It's worth about $10 less than the necklace.