r/poshmark • u/pepperandplatinum • Aug 02 '26
I'm not sorry.
Please don't do this. The order was perfect until I saw two religious flyers in with my item. I don't want your beliefs pushed on me in a freaking clothing item.
r/poshmark • u/pepperandplatinum • Aug 02 '26
Please don't do this. The order was perfect until I saw two religious flyers in with my item. I don't want your beliefs pushed on me in a freaking clothing item.
r/poshmark
•
u/JCandJack
•
May 04 '25
A buyer bought a large jewelry bundle from me. A week after she accepted the order and submitted a very nice review, I realized that I’d left out a piece of jewelry.
I immediately contacted her and said I’d left out a piece and I would send it priority mail asap. She replied and said she’d like to do another order and then I could just ship the missing piece with the new order.
She received the new order and was happy with everything.
Two days ago I got a message from her saying that she sent me a package through Amazon. I received the package today. It was hands down the most thoughtful gift I’d ever received.
I’d mentioned being a dancer briefly and she sent a two beautiful dance bags, a sun catcher, and a pouch with sweet symbols for luck. I’m so amazed and touched that I cried. I wanted to share this story because as sellers and buyers on Poshmark, I think we forget that we are dealing with real people, good people. Every time I get frustrated with a buyer I’m going to remember this amazing person.
r/poshmark • u/Silver-on-the-tree • Jul 16 '26
I’m so sick of seeing horribly shrunken, felted wool for sale as if it’s the same sweater. Sorry but once it’s been washed in hot water and hucked into the dryer it’s no longer wearable, unless it was ginourmous to start and/or you love the feel of incredibly stiff, itchy wool. Trying to pass off whatever that thing is on a hanger as a women’s XS is almost as horrific as trying to sell it for $80.
Some people are good enough to at least mention it shrank, but still try to pawn it off as simply for a smaller person or child when the issue is that it no longer wears like a normal sweater. I know used clothing is buyer beware, and I am a long time seller. This is just one of my ongoing pet peeves.
r/poshmark • u/whattheactualmuck • 5d ago
I’m selling $250 boots at $150 and this girl has the audacity to ask me to match Marshall’s price when Marshall’s doesn’t even have the same size available- I looked. My boots are 8 wide calf, and Marshall’s only has size 11 and 12 regular calf for sale at that price. Why would I match their price (I paid much more) when I know she can’t get the size she wants at Marshall’s anyway?
It also annoys me when people try to negotiate price or say where they found the same item cheaper in the comments- if you want a lower price, send me an offer. Don’t put it on blast in the listing’s comment section. People who do this get an instant block.
r/poshmark • u/Bella_Nova • Jun 18 '25
🤭🤭🤭 might have to steal this one 🤣🤣
r/poshmark • u/IllustratorNo7123 • Apr 10 '25
r/poshmark • u/Fragrant-Station3844 • Aug 10 '24
I got a 4-star rating and this is why: Was this warranted?
r/poshmark
•
u/MountainTop5764
•
Mar 07 '26
Mind you, I'm not even home and have not opened the package yet. This is my 3rd order on Posh. My buyer experience so far has been absolutely hell.
r/poshmark • u/Seattle_Jenn • Nov 01 '24
I bought a ring. At first, I couldn't even find it among all these extras. I do not want any of this stuff. I wish there was a preference we could click to tell sellers not to include extra junk.
r/poshmark • u/Affectionate-Yak-803 • Mar 07 '25
I couldn’t stress to her enough that adding gifts to packages are not expected
r/poshmark
•
u/AvidReader86
•
Oct 08 '25
I am so confused by all the hate toward buyers. I am not a reseller or seller, just a buyer who grew up bargain hunting the secondhand market with her grandma. I see 2 common posts here - "these bottom feeder buyers sending lowball offers, can you believe the audacity?" and "my sales are way down, what is going on?"
Haggling is a part of the secondhand market. Looking for buyers who just need a sale is part of the secondhand market. And the secondhand market is heavily influenced by the economy. You should be finding more buyers in a downturned economy, but only with realistic pricing that reflects that and quality items. Do you have a $2000 item listed for $1200 but are only getting lowball $6-800 offers? That's where the secondhand market is - and luxury is going to be hit even harder in a secondhand market. I'm just genuinely curious why there is so much disdain because it feels more like a misunderstanding of client base and economic factors. But maybe I'm just a bottomfeeder buyer who doesn't understand? 🤷♀️
r/poshmark • u/dandelionroots • Jul 30 '20
r/poshmark • u/haifonly • Jan 11 '21
r/poshmark
•
u/_idontgiveashit_
•
13d ago
Ahh yes, a literal “shoulder bag”
r/poshmark • u/pettynugget • Mar 27 '25
If you were genuinely concerned about the legitimacy of the emails, the contest, the winnings, etc. please know that I appreciate you!
Looks like everything worked out in my favor in the end ☺️
r/poshmark • u/FeatherFlyer • Feb 03 '26
I often see people complaining about how little money they make and how upset they are about their sales and then it hit me…..they use it like a second job and stock up on goods to resell. Where I use it mainly as just a way to get rid of stuff. Old sweater I don’t wear? $10. You offer $7? Take it. I think I might be in the minority here!
r/poshmark
•
u/Mother_Heroic
•
Jun 08 '26
This is so incredibly annoying. I purchased one item from this seller and was perfectly happy. I would have gone back to them to purchase again except for this. I never made a bundle with this seller, they made this bundle specifically to pester me with their ads.
Stop making bundles that essentially function as solicitation for your sales and specials. Posh needs to make it an option to turn off the ability for others to make bundles for you.
r/poshmark • u/Spiciest_gingerr • Jan 16 '26
It seems they’re saying their items may come damaged from being in the storage unit? I’m not positive but won’t be purchasing anything from this seller. They have a couple things I really wanted for one of my daughters but the prices of each is the cost new, and they aren’t nwt or nwot even. ☹️
r/poshmark • u/SomewherePositive527 • Jan 13 '26
Why is this giving 12 year old girl?🤣
r/poshmark • u/Puzzleheaded-Arm-130 • Apr 29 '25
FINAL UPDATE! May 13
I am confident you all helped me get my money back. After 2 weeks of runaround where they continually refused to give me the $50 they still owed me from the commission they laughably tried to take from my sale (despite me having it in writing that they would waive it), they gave me a $50 “credit”.
I swiftly was like NOPE you can easily move that $50 credit to redeemable cash since I am never using your site again.
She proceeded to tell me they would not and that they have done everything they would be doing on this matter and they now considered it resolved.
They clearly thought they were dealing with someone who wouldn’t fight them til the death lmao so I replied that they don’t get to decide when this is resolved - I do - and I’m pretty sure the over 200,000 people who viewed my complaint on Reddit would be thrilled to know you are willing to get into a legal altercation with a long time seller over $50 - and then I linked to this thread.
I didn’t expect a reply but got one the next day from a new person “Jennifer” who reiterated some similar nonsense about giving me the credit. So I replied restating I don’t want a credit because I will never be using them again and that this would be my last email to them, and the next one would be to the AG’s office, who I am sure would have NO problem taking this case given every single thing I have in writing from you. And I said if I’m forced to do that, I can promise you it’ll become a case for way more than $50 of damages.
An hour later I had the $50 in my redeemable cash 🙄 They still refused to tell the buyer her claim was unfounded but I cared about the money more anyway. But in case you all want to have someone to add to your block list - go to my closet @jbux and look at the person who commented on the LV grey denim pochette 🤭 (I can’t drop her info here or else I would.)
Anyway, fully convinced this thread is what got this escalated to “Jennifer” who ultimately gave me my full sale amount. So thank you to all of you awesome humans! ❤️
[\UPDATE: April 29] Poshmark finally responded. Their email is below (figured it's easier than putting in the dropbox link but added it on the Dropbox too):
Hi J,
My name is Mary and I work with Poshmark’s Disputes Team as a Community Manager overseeing returns and escalations.
I ask that you only write in once per inquiry, as writing in multiple times causes your email to go to the end of our queue and will result in a delayed response.
At this time, I see the oversight regarding this case. Order #6XX was mistakenly cancelled by a team member who referenced the original rejection of the item, unaware that the rejection had been made in error. At this time, I have released your funds for the original sale of this order.
I have also applied $25 in Posh Credit to your account for the inconvenience.
Rest assured, I have closely reevaluated this particular case to ensure that we improve our processes. We truly value you as an important community member and hope you will give us another chance!
Please don’t hesitate to let us know if you have any further questions.
Best,
Mary
Likeeeee ok that's cute but I was promised a waived commission (like you guys srsly think you're gonna make money off this?!) as well as accountability to the buyer that they were wrong and her claim was false (principle, for me.) My reply is below (sorry god forbid I keep anything brief lol - screenshot also linked above):
Hi Mary,
Thank you for your response and for confirming that the cancellation and counterfeit labeling of this order were made in error. I appreciate the acknowledgment and the release of sale proceeds.
That said, there are still several key points that remain unresolved:
- In the original message from support following the authentication error (re-attached), Poshmark stated that commission fees would be waived in full if the item was relisted, which it was. Since the final sale price was $450, the full proceeds should be honored as previously promised.
- As outlined in my original message, I would like written confirmation to both myself and the buyer that the item was verified as authentic, and that Poshmark’s initial authentication error was the root cause of this issue. The buyer’s claim should also be formally acknowledged as false, and I want confirmation that any counterfeit flag or negative mark has been fully removed from my seller account. This is not just a transactional issue — it’s a reputational one. As a long-standing seller with a verified history on your platform, having my credibility questioned due to internal errors damages my professional reputation and calls into question the integrity of your seller protections.
- While I appreciate the $25 credit, the time, effort, and frustration involved — particularly given that the same error I was previously assured would not happen again did in fact happen again — merit a more appropriate goodwill gesture, especially considering my long-term business relationship with your platform.
For context, this item originally sold for $500. It was improperly rejected during authentication and returned to me. The buyer later mentioned she was leaving for vacation, so I relisted it at $450 and shipped it directly to her — something I did purely to be accommodating, not because I was obligated to. That goodwill ultimately led to a second preventable error that has cost me hours of unnecessary work to validate an item that never should have been questioned.
Every other party involved — the authentication team, the support team, and the buyer — made mistakes. Yet I’m the only one who has paid the price. The buyer kept the item and was refunded, despite never returning it (and I know my refund did not even come from her — it came from Poshmark.) Meanwhile, Poshmark retained a significant portion of the commission despite mishandling every step of this process. And I’ve been left cleaning up the fallout.
To fully resolve this, I am requesting:
-A payment adjustment to reflect the full $450 sale price -Written confirmation that my account is in good standing, with no counterfeit flags -Formal communication to the buyer that the item was authentic and her claim was unfounded -A reconsideration of the $25 credit, adjusted to reflect the time lost and repeated errors involved
I hope we can continue to resolve this directly, but I need this handled thoroughly and correctly. I appreciate your attention and look forward to your response.
Best,
J
I almost just took it and ran but thank you to everyone who commented, gave advice, and pushed me to escalate. It’s been invaluable. 🙏 I will update with any response.
-------------------------------------------------------
OG POST
i listed a 100% authentic LV Neverfull pochette (if you’re not familiar, the pouches are a standard accessory that comes with every Neverfull bag.) i have over 10 years experience successfully selling authentic luxury items that are solely purchased by me or my family.
someone bought it for $500, so it went to Poshmark HQ for authentication. for whatever reason, they incorrectly labeled it as inauthentic. i immediately sent them tons of documentation (invoice, receipt, even a dated photo of my mom carrying it in the store where we bought it bc i happened to have it bc we were on holiday). 4 hours later they apologized and agreed they were wrong and agreed to send me the item back and refund seller fees to re-list it. fine. questionable but fine.
annoying bc i then had to do all of this unnecessary convincing to the buyer that this was in fact 100% authentic. sent her the same docs i sent Poshmark and even more images of tags etc. so i let her repurchase it at $450 so we could avoid the HQ hassle just in case they made the same mistake again.
she gets the pouch and messages me telling me the “label is smudged” (??) and the “stitching is uneven” which is of course BS bc i have photos of all of those things and of course bought the bag in person myself. but before i could even reply, she opens up a case claiming its “inauthentic.” when i tell you i nearly lostttttt it.
poshmark asks her for more info and a few days later they RULE IN HER FAVOR that they have “reason to believe” that my very authentic item with several forms of documentation to support this is “inauthentic.” the best part? they refunded her her money AND she gets to keep the item.
this whole thing literally kept me up all night esp bc i had to then YET AGAIN email Poshmark support with every single receipt, and cc’ing their SVP of seller experience (thank you ChatGPT) because this is literal theft. sent that email sunday night. haven’t heard a peep which is interesting bc i am no stranger to the legal world and made heavy mentions of legal escalation should they not resolve this properly in 5 biz days.
i have zero problem making this a legal matter but what’s more mind blowing is that they’re allowed to get away with this as a business. they’re allowed to dictate what’s “authentic” and what isn’t despite irrefutable evidence and then they’re allowed to essentially take your property from you (and also not provide a means of immediate contact for established sellers other than a mass support email.)
they really have some nerve. if you are a seller considering starting on this platform, i’d recommend you sell literally anywhere else.
EDIT: I can’t add images but here is a dropbox link to the initial Posh authentication error communication. 😑 Emails