My (30F, lesbian) primary primary partner (31F, bi) met my new partner (41F, lesbian) for the first time 2 nights ago and took an immediate dislike to her, which she thinks is mutual.
This is my first poly relationship: I’ve been in it for 4 years and we’ve been open the whole time. My primary partner (“Anchor partner?” AP?) has had other partners during that time, but no serious ones for quite a while, and I’ve only briefly/casually dated a few people. But a few months ago I started dating my friend of a little over a year (“K”), and that has felt more serious so I wanted AP and K to meet. I’ve met AP’s partners in the past and always enjoyed doing so - I guess I thought we were practicing Kitchen Table or Garden Party polyamory.
I was a little nervous for them to meet though, because AP is prone to insecurity and jealousy - never in an angry or confrontational way, but in a way where she just feels horrible about herself and tries to hide it from me until she can’t anymore. She has BPD and PTSD, and she’s a trans woman whereas K and I are cis women, and so AP has needed a lot of reassurance over the years that I truly love her and am not going to ever betray or abandon her). She is genuinely one of the sweetest, most caring people I’ve ever met, but she thinks I’m way out of her league and I worry that stops her from being totally honest with me about her feelings and boundaries sometimes. That said, I’ve asked her many times if she’d prefer to be monogamous, and she always says “no.” She is in therapy and says she’s wants to work on the fears she has around it.
I think both she and K are wonderful people, but they have very different personalities. AP is a very “emotions right on the surface” type of person, good at perceiving other people’s feelings and giving comfort (the flip side of this is when anxious she will also perceive subtle slights where none are obvious to me). She’s fun, a little wild, and has had a rougher background (sex work, homelessness, etc), so doesn’t always follow a social script.
K, in contrast, is pretty serious, flirty (with me) but not super affectionate, very self-assured and mature and maybe comes across slightly judgmental at times. Definitely leans toward brutal honesty and is not the type to do “emotional labor,” (whatever that means to her, it seems to mean different things to different people). She has also gone through a lot recently as she spent the first part of this year battling cancer. She was already spiritual, but it’s deepened her spirituality I think, and she carries herself with what I’d call a sort of “zen”.
So, basically picture a hot cheeto girl meeting a meditation & Erewhon girl.
I didn’t expect them to be besties or anything, but it went worse than expected. I invited K to one of AP’s band’s performances with a plan to grab a few drinks afterward before I went home with AP (she had Facial Feminization Surgery about a month ago, so I am still helping her carry heavy things too like her guitar case). I talked to AP ahead of time and said I would try to give them both equal attention, but I might end up giving slightly more to K because she is new to poly (compared to us), and as the sort of outside party coming into an established relationship & going home alone, I didn’t want her to feel like a 3rd wheel. AP said she understood, but I could tell she was already in her head about it a bit, so I tried very hard to reassure her.
AP didn’t really make a big effort to get to know K, I think she just asked her like 1 question right when K arrived (“so, what did you do today?”) and after that kind of backed off and didn’t join in on the conversations K and I were having. It was a loud bar and she was having a bit of a hard time hearing, so I made sure to keep talking loud and turning to her to try to include her in the convo, but she wasn’t really engaging. I think she was pretty tired from rehearsing/performing that day while in recovery, which def didn’t help.
K also didn’t really make an effort with AP- she didn’t try to include her in conversations like I was, and when she bought me a drink twice from the bar, she didn’t offer AP anything. I did successfully make K feel included though, because by the end of the night she was saying how good she felt, not having known what to expect from the evening, which I was glad to hear! AP also seemed to be in a good mood at that point, and they’d both said they were fine with me kissing the other in their presence, so I kissed K. That caused AP (whom I’d repeatedly encouraged to share her feelings) to say “Is it bad that I’m kind of jealous? I’m sorry, is that a buzzkill?” To which K replied, “I mean, it is a buzzkill.” Then:
AP: “I’m sorry, I shouldn’t ask you to do emotional labor for me. Now I feel manipulative.”
K: “I mean, I’m not going to do emotional labor. Those are just my boundaries.”
One of the last interactions we had was AP asking K something like “Do you hate trans people?” which, fair - is kind of a startling and confrontational thing to ask someone you’ve just met who’s given no indication (to me, anyway) that they do, but instead of saying “no”, K said, “ummm… I think maybe I should go.”
I was hoping that introducing them would assuage AP’s fears and show her that K is chill with her and isn’t trying to “steal me,” as she’s worried before, and that we can all be friends and have a nice time, but really it did the opposite. AP started crying in the middle of the night last night saying she knew I was going to leave her for K, and she could tell K hated her, and was flipping between anger about the situation, and self loathing. She brought up the fact that K hadn’t bought her a drink, that she donated to K’s cancer fundraiser but that K hadn’t donated to her FFS fundraiser, that she felt inadequate, and she didn’t think K sees her as a woman (again, I haven’t picked up on that at all and wouldn’t date someone who was transphobic, but I realize AP may either be reading into things too much as she often does, or picking up on real vibes what are going over my head as a cis person).
I obviously hate that I’m making my primary partner feel so horrible, and want to put a pause to the thing that has caused her such distress, but I feel pretty dismayed to have to do that. My relationship with K has been a really exciting and positive thing in my life, and we’ve gotten pretty close. I’m the first person she’s dated in over a year, though she also recently started dating another girl whom I haven’t met. She has also been through so much and has an appointment this week to find out if she’s cancer free or has to do more chemo, and I said I would go to that. I don’t want to end things with her, especially not right now when the last thing she needs is any sort of relationship drama, but I think I might have to.
I wanted to ask if it’s generally considered possible to have a poly situation where your 2 partners don’t really like each other, but this situation goes deeper than that and is causing my AP so much stress, I’m wondering if I’ll have to give up polyamory altogether in order for her to feel okay. Like I said, this is the first time I’ve dated someone else seriously since we’ve been together, and I’m scared that any other (especially cis) girl I date is going to make her feel too bad about herself to be worth pursuing, even though remaining open to those kinds of relationships is something that has felt important to me, but not important enough to justify causing someone I love this much pain.
Any advice is really welcome, but please be gentle- I had a really rough couple of nights & haven’t slept much 😞