I love watching kids learn piano, but the word "prodigy" is on soo many video titles lately and it's starting to get to me.
Being young and play something doesn't make you a prodigy, and that's totally okay.
A true prodigy performs at an extraordinary level well beyond their age. So please stop calling your 5-year-old one when they're playing half the notes of a Suzuki Book 1 piece with mistakes. I don't blame the kid, they're just learning, and that's great.
What bothers me is the label, especially when the same kid is a piano, singing and violin prodigy, even for the thing they struggle with most. Maybe it's for engagement, maybe people truly believe it, but at 5 everything counts as "prodigy" and at 15 nothing is enough, which can really break someone if they don't become incredibly good as they grow up.
The truly extraordinary kids, like the seven-year-old who played the thirds etude and got accepted into Curtis this March, never have the word in their titles, because the playing speaks for itself. I still don't love the label, since it erases the immense effort behind that level, but with her at least it doesn't leave me with that uncomfortable feeling in my stomach.
I've also met people with natural talent who never got anywhere because they lacked discipline.
So, kids don't need a forced "prodigy" tag for us to appreciate their progress, and a lot of us just enjoy watching people learn and grow.
Just needed to vent, I guess