r/piano • • Sep 08 '20

Discussion Simplypiano stole my job

74 Upvotes

Using a throwaway account to be as anonymous as possible

I was at a barbecue with a few of my friends, one of them mentioned that his friends daughter wanted some affordable piano lessons so I told him about my studio that opened a few years ago, it’s been going well, have a lot of students and they actually practice ;). I got in contact with the mother and just asked her some basic questions (has she had lessons before, what piano does she have, etc...). We got to the prices and she seemed annoyed by the sound of her voice but eventually I convinced her. The lessons were pretty good, she practiced and she was respectful but you can tell when she didn’t practice. Went like that for a few months but then I got a text from the mother, it went something like

Note: none of the names used are real, they are all made up

“Dear Mr.Anon, thank you so for the excellent piano lessons, me and my husband have been seeing great progress in my little Emily’s playing. This year she is going to 6th grade, a big step from 5th, because of this we unfortunately cannot continue the lessons. We hope you understand these unfortunate circumstances.

Thank you, Mrs. Smith”

At first reading this I’ll admit I was a bit down, I was honestly having a fun time teaching her and I really enjoyed it. Met up with the same friend 4 months later, completely forgot the entire thing until he asked me “Hows Emily going?” I just told him that she quit the lessons, he later told me “her mom started a YouTube channel for her, she’s pretty good!”. Told him to send me the link cause I was curious. Just a basic piano YouTube channel, nothing new. Saw a video of her playing Für Elise, clicked on it and watched all of it. I then said to myself... “I don’t remember teaching her that”. My first thought was that she just learned it by herself, but then I clicked the description....

“Emily, age 11, playing Fur Elise, learned with the simply piano app.”

The expression I had on my face, I was so angry. She left me for an app. I haven’t talked to her or my friend ever since. She left just because my prices were actually reasonable.

If you want lessons then don’t waste your teachers time.


r/piano • • Jun 25 '24

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Even "bad-ass-boys" (like myself) sometimes get "soft". "Breakfast at Tiffany's" theme for a girl I met.

13 Upvotes

r/piano • • Jan 29 '26

🗣️Let's Discuss This The pretentiousness of this sub is next level.

0 Upvotes

I’ve never seen anything like it. I thought r/vinyl was pretentious, but this sub makes r/vinyl look so much better. People post videos of themselves playing the piano and they get slaughtered in the comments. I don’t think I’ve seen anyone post a video that’s received even one compliment. It feels as if Beethoven himself could post a cropped video of just his hands playing something under a pseudonym, he’d get roasted like everyone else here or somebody would nitpick something about it.


r/piano • • Sep 12 '24

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) I'm 15 is this good

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/piano • • Jul 06 '26

☺️My Performance (No Critique Please!) Pathetique, Third Movement

0 Upvotes

Yes, I sincerely believe this to be a 19th century Allegro. This tempo HUMANIZES Beethoven. My very favorite thing about this historically authentic tempo regime, is that I’m no longer restricted to performing a singular technical feat. I don’t need to WOW you by playing as fast as I can, better than anyone else. Because this music wasn’t meant to OVERWHELM you. It was meant to express Beethoven’s human experience, *of which you are also part.*

It’s difficult, but not inaccessible. And miraculously, now all of the nuance in the score makes sense. Trills, phrasing, 16th note septuplets: it’s all CLEAR.

I’m using Czerny’s metronome marking of half note = 96. Of course, he was using the 19th c practice of metronome notation where TWO ticks of the metronome equal the given note value. In modern metronome usage this would be written as quarter note = 96.

This is a very THREATENING idea to many who have only ever heard this played faster, and who have no understanding of just how much the pace of humanity has increased in the last two centuries. I would invite them to listen with care and imagination, and refrain from commenting. I've asked for no critique. Instead, if you can't appreciate this, then post your own complete performance the way you think it should be. That way we can celebrate Beethoven's music together.


r/piano • • Feb 24 '25

🗣️Let's Discuss This Just asking, I don't know if this is true, but aren't flats and sharps the same thing? For Example, wouldn't E# and F♭ be the same?

0 Upvotes

Not required


r/piano • • Jan 02 '22

Other A very tired piano turned into a piece of art for my front room

Thumbnail
gallery
555 Upvotes

r/piano • • Nov 23 '22

Discussion While technically correct, I find referring to pieces by opus number to be opaque and it feels a little like gate keeping.

4 Upvotes

Chopin Opus 28, No.15 is so much less helpful than Prelude 15, or Prelude in Db, or ‘Raindrop’.

BWV 815 is far less informative than Bach French Suite in G.

Piano is difficult and intimidating enough as it stands, let’s try to use less opaque language when possible.

I think that if more people played piano, the world would be a nicer place. So let’s make it easier for folks to join us.


r/piano • • Jan 19 '23

Question What does the hashtag looking thing mean? Just started learning piano

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/piano • • Jul 03 '15

How I’d redesign piano sheet music

Thumbnail
medium.com
7 Upvotes

r/piano • • Nov 06 '17

For >$100 you can hook this up to your electric piano and make it sound incredddiiibbbllleee.

7 Upvotes

Hey guys I have a weighted 88 key Privia, anyways it sounded sub par, then I hooked this [currently best 2.1 system I've found and Ive tested many over the years] I WAS BLOWN AWAY! It sounds like a real concert grand, you close your eyes and I swear you cannot tell the difference, I am so excited I wanted to share this with you. The internal speakers [and no sub] sounded like sh!t before and this thing costed me $850, I was blown away. I hope someone out there does this. You will freak out. I can't stop playing now, it sounds like a brand new instrument.


r/piano • • Oct 08 '25

🗣️Let's Discuss This Unpopular opinion: Playing fast octaves whilst having large hands is not a showcase in 'impeccable technique'

19 Upvotes

So many times I see posts and videos of people with 'insane technique and speed' playing rapid octaves, meanwhile they can reach an 11th and hitting an octave for them is the same as most women/children hitting a 7th.

People who can only reach an octave/just about a 9th and are able to play main repetoire are ridiculously underrated and may pound for pound be even BETTER technical pianists than most of the famous large handed virtuosos today.

I wonder what they would think if they were forced to play on a large key piano where they could only barely reach a ninth and be asked to perform the same repetoire, I'd imagine the progress with smaller key pianos would gain a lot of interest and support all of a sudden.


r/piano • • Sep 23 '23

Discussion Why do people in this community keep reinforcing the belief that anyone can learn anything at the piano?

0 Upvotes

I see posts every so often, where they ask if someone starting in their 20s/30s, or even anyone realistically, can achieve La Campanella, or a Rachmaninoff concerto, or Gaspard de la Nuit, if they just put in enough effort. The comments which say "anything is possible" are upvoted to the stratosphere.

But have you seen anyone achieve it? I bet the answer is no. And we've seen many people who have played 10-20,000 hours, and are still nowhere near that level. Most music university students aren't at that level and certainly have a stake in trying to get there, but eventually admit they can't.

It doesn't look like putting in the time is in itself sufficient. It looks like very few people have the genetic predisposition to achieve great technical or musical feats. Any longtime teacher will tell you that vanishingly few students reach that level.

So why do people on this sub keep insisting that anything is possible for anyone? Is it simply cope or is there a more solid basis?


r/piano • • Jan 18 '25

🧑‍🏫Question/Help (Intermed./Advanced) What style is this piece in?

0 Upvotes

It’s clearly got Novelty and Jazz influences, and maybe a little classical, but I was wondering if there’s any specific term for this piano style. Excuse the sloppy recording. I’ve only played this a few times


r/piano • • Sep 12 '22

Question First piano lesson with a teacher

5 Upvotes

So I just had my first piano lesson (as an adult beginner), but it was extremely frustrating.

I explained to the teacher that I had the following goals:

  1. Rhythm style piano to accompany singers as a part of musical team (keys, lead guitar, bass guitar, drums

  2. Play by ear the things I hear

  3. Play pieces by Ludovico Eunadi / Phillip Glass / Hans Zimmer / John Williams

I then explained that I know a decent amount of music theory, have been singing and playing guitar for over 10 years, but can't read sheet music at all.

Then she handed me the sheet music of Elvis Presley's Can't Help Falling in Love and sat me in front of the piano, asking me to practice the melody line and reading from the sheet.

I've prepaid the lessons for one month, but it feels like she's just going to force this "play from sheet music" down my throat until I can play from sheet music...

It feels like her lessons will only be able to help me with my 3rd goal on the list.

She is a classically trained pianist and piano teacher who've been paying since she was 8, but is this what a piano teacher does?


r/piano • • Nov 09 '25

🧑‍🏫Question/Help (Intermed./Advanced) Is my performance good enough for a first place?

6 Upvotes

I’m a 14 year old amateur pianist who is entering an online music competition tomorrow and I’m hoping to ask if my performance is good enough for a first place( 27/30 minimum for first place). The rubric consists of interpretation (style, musical form, phrasing, intonation, articulation, rhythmic accuracy, tempo, dynamic control, balance, and pedaling)/10, musical achievements (memorization, tone-facility, expression)/10, as well as the participants’ age, and the complexity of the musical selection/10. If you guys think my performance doesn’t deserve first place, I’m switching it to uploading my other piece for the competition. Thank you so much guys.


r/piano • • Jan 23 '26

🎶Other Major Scales TIER LIST (Ranked by MOST FUN to PLAY)

1 Upvotes

This is the definitive 100% accurate major scale fun ranking. It assumes you're playing each scale with 2 hands for 1 octave.

Make your own here: https://tiermaker.com/create/the-scales-984371


r/piano • • Jun 25 '26

🎵My Original Composition The Most Intense Piano Piece I've Ever Written

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

He is pretty good, especially for a homebrew based comp piece dome by him self. I would say this piece is ready for professional components wouldn't you say?


r/piano • • Apr 10 '23

Discussion How can I love music and practicing again? (Please read)

0 Upvotes

So, I am a professional pianist that is successful and has many reasons to continue his career. Lately I've even been invited with a full scholarship to one of the most prestigious musical environments (college, school, conservatory, university, music place, however you want to call it) in London.

Since about last year I have gotten a very, very insatiable hunger for music, I started to listen to music all the time like Mahler's pieces, Wagner's, even Schoenberg.

I have gotten a great appetite for learning about music and its whole history, even since the Ars Nova period.

I even started to seek out memorize Glenn Gould speeches even by just one listen as I loved what he said so much.

And while practicing and I have practiced a lot, Liszt Etudes, ranging from the transcendental set to the Paganini set, Beethoven Concertos, Rachmaninoff Concertos, some of the so called hardest pieces for piano, I was able to learn in days.

Because whenever I saw the piano I had a hunger to just play and learn and hours and hours would pass, I would be like a day at the piano and I wouldn't even notice.

Last year I learned the Dante Sonata by Liszt (Fantasia quasi una Sonata, Apres une lecture du Dante) in a very short time just because I loved reading through it and playing it daily in the summer.

I have even attempted the Liszt B minor sonata recently and have been going through it for some time and loving every single second of it and finding it quite comfortable to play after learning Mephisto Waltz, Dante and a lot of Liszt's other works that share his fascinating piano writing method.

Bur some days ago, while studying some Bach, Beethoven and the B minor Sonata, I have just gotten all of a sudden this sense of misery and apathy and kind of lost that appetite for learning, it isn't because of the pieces or their difficulty as I just sometimes feel a kind of mood to not practice and not have the same ecstasy regarding music.

How can I return to that phase that lasted so much?

Thank you kindly.


r/piano • • Nov 30 '25

🗣️Let's Discuss This This sub sucks

0 Upvotes

Comparison is the thief of joy. Cliche quote but very true.

Every time this sub pops up in my feed it's "6 years old and just started learning piano 2 hours ago" and some clip of a flawless la campanella.

Of course I can step back and realize I shouldn't compare myself to others. I practice at my own pace and with my own goals in mind. That said I think the natural human reaction to these posts is to compare and to feel less than. This is such a natural and obvious reaction.

I see posts like this all the time and I just think its toxic honestly. Should people be proud of their accomplishments and skills? Of course. But how much satisfaction do you get from your upvotes? Objectively it is a net negative post. You are making hundreds of people feel inadequate in exchange for your moment of glory.

Go share your talent with your family and friends.

I just really hate these posts and I think it contributes nothing of value.

/Rant


r/piano • • Jul 02 '25

🎶Other "How can I improve my sight-reading?" Guide

2 Upvotes

"How can I improve my sight-reading?"

If you've been learning piano for a while, chances are this question has crossed your mind, or someone else has asked you the same. It's one of the most common struggles among piano students of all levels.

Having played piano for over 26 years, and helped countless beginners (both children and adults), I’ve noticed a pattern: those who follow a structured, octave-based visual-motor method tend to develop far better sight-reading skills, consistently and quickly.

Below, I’m sharing a method I’ve recommended many times over the years. It may not appeal to everyone, but when applied seriously, it simply doesn’t fail. I’ve seen people reach a level of fluency in 6–12 months that outpaces many students with years of unstructured practice.

The Philosophy Behind the Method

Sight-reading is not magic, it’s pattern recognition + muscle memory + reaction speed. In practice, it's no different from learning a new alphabet. But the piano adds a twist: you’re dealing with both treble and bass clefs, and an 88-key instrument spanning over 7 full octaves + a few extra notes.

This method breaks that visual-motor problem down into structured layers.

Step-by-Step Breakdown

1. Octave Segmentation

Visualize the piano keyboard as 7 distinct octaves:
1–2–3–4–5–6–7

Center everything around Octave 4, your home base. This is the octave where middle C lives, and the one your eyes and hands should learn to navigate first.

2. Isolate Octave 4

Start by writing out every note of the 4th octave on staff paper in both treble and bass clefs.
Drill recognition:

  • What does each note look like in each clef?

  • What key does it correspond to on the piano?

Keep practicing until you can recognize 300 random notes from the 4th octave (in either clef), instantly identify them, and play them on the keyboard with zero hesitation.

At that point, you’ve completed Stage 1.

3. Add Surrounding Octaves (3rd and 5th)

Once Octave 4 becomes reflexive, start expanding outward.

Choose either Octave 3 or Octave 5. Doesn't matter which comes first, what matters is keeping Octave 4 as your reference point. Repeat the exact same process:

  • Write the notes

  • Drill recognition

  • Practice fast identification and immediate playing

Once you're equally fluent in both 3 and 5, you're ready for integration.

4. Integrate Octaves 3–4–5

Now that you've mastered three central octaves, start mixing them together. Drill with randomized notes from all three. The goal is to eliminate hesitation when switching ranges and clefs.

5. Add Outer Octaves (2nd and 6th)

Now bring in the next layer: 2nd and 6th octaves.

You can practice them separately or in combination (e.g., 2 with 3, 6 with 5), depending on how you learn best. The point is to continue building fluency outward, always grounding yourself in what’s already familiar.

6. Mastery & Maintenance

By the time you can effortlessly read and react to notes across Octaves 2–3–4–5–6 in both clefs, you’ve essentially built a full-scope sight-reading reflex for 90% of standard piano literature.

From here, you can begin to target weak areas:

  • Random interval jumps

  • Ledger line note drills

  • Fast clef-switching

  • Rhythm integration

Why This Works

  • It’s repetition-based, not just recognition-based

  • It respects motor learning principles (like chunking and layer-by-layer skill stacking)

  • It prioritizes reflexive clef reading, which is the bottleneck for most pianists

  • It builds a mental map of the keyboard, tied directly to notation

This is not a method for musicality, expression, or repertoire. It’s pure sight-reading training, a way to program your brain and hands to react instinctively to notation in real time.

⚠️ A Note on Expectations

Yes, it can feel tedious. But learning to write was tedious too, wasn’t it?

The human brain is wired for repeated, layered learning. Piano is not an instrument you can “fake it till you make it” with, especially when it comes to sight-reading. You either build the reflexes through direct training, or you stay in the loop of hesitation and second-guessing.

This method is about building those reflexes, deliberately and efficiently.

Note:

English is not my first language, so I used a language model (GPT) to help me translate and refine this post. I believe language should never be a barrier, especially when trying to share a method that could genuinely help others improve their skills.


r/piano • • Dec 15 '24

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Am I good for a 14 year old??? The entertainer

0 Upvotes

Note: iv'e done this fast like bar style


r/piano • • May 31 '25

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) What level would i be?

0 Upvotes

Basically, I want to know around what level this kind of playing would put me at. The piece is Scherzo no 1. Note: only latter half of Scherzo.


r/piano • • Jun 26 '26

🙋Question/Help (Beginner) Why is everyone’s advice for every problem “get a teacher?”

0 Upvotes

something I’ve noticed with this type of place is whenever someone asks for advice on something a lot of the comments are just saying ”you really need a teacher“ or whatever. obviously that’s logical advice but it’s a little strange that everyone is just saying that like you can just go and do that. CAN you just go and do that? how easy is it to get a piano teacher? how much does it cost? I’m just flying by the seat of my pants when it comes to solving issues cause all the advice is “jeez sounds like you need a teacher” but like I don’t have a job or anything I can’t really just up and take lessons with a one on one teacher I don’t think.