r/philosophyself • • Aug 07 '14

Universal Principle of Natural Philosophy

1 Upvotes

Hi all, I was hoping reddit could help me bring the knowledge to the people. If you have knowledge of cosmology, I believe you will find my theory to be most interesting (and even if not!). It uses philosophy first to make sure the model is sound, and then uses observation to show how this fits the philosophically sound model: www.cascadinguniverse.org Thanks for your time! Steve


r/philosophyself • • Aug 25 '25

Ward’s Paradox: Why progress often breeds dissatisfaction

0 Upvotes

I’ve been developing a framework I call Ward’s Paradox, and I’d like to share it here for critique and discussion. The central claim is that both individuals and groups often feel less satisfied after success, not because they lack goals, but because each success recalibrates the baseline upward. Progress itself destabilizes the feedback loop of learning and growth, creating the sense of running in place.

I describe this dynamic as a “helix of progress”: the same struggles reappear at higher levels of complexity. From the inside it feels like a treadmill, but from a wider view it is spiraling progress.

This seems related to existing concepts but not identical:

  • Hedonic adaptation (Brickman & Campbell, 1971) describes the return to a baseline of happiness, but does not formalize the mechanism of escalating goals.

  • Relative deprivation theory (Stouffer et al., 1949; Crosby, 1976) frames dissatisfaction through social comparison, not through self-recalibration after success.

  • Mission creep in organizational theory (Merton, 1940) treats shifting standards as management failure, whereas the paradox suggests it is a predictable psychological and social tendency.

I’ve also outlined a Popperian falsifiability design: a longitudinal study measuring (1) objective progress (e.g., promotions, policy victories), (2) subjective dissatisfaction (e.g., SWLS, PANAS), and (3) mediating mechanisms like goal escalation and the loss of unifying struggle.

I’m curious whether others here think this adds anything philosophically new to discussions of progress and adaptation, or whether it collapses into existing frameworks. To me, the novelty lies in treating dissatisfaction not as a flaw of progress but as a structural consequence of progress itself—and in proposing that the paradox can be used as a navigational tool, not just a diagnosis.

For anyone interested, I’ve also published a longer essay draft on my Substack where I go into more detail: Ward’s Paradox: A Manifesto.

I’d appreciate any feedback, counterexamples, or references I should engage with.

(Disclosure: I sometimes use an LLM to polish grammar, but the idea and structure are my own.)


r/philosophyself • • Mar 27 '19

You Don't Exist.

0 Upvotes

Reality: things being real ,and solidly what they are, and movement itself, basically everything we experience is effectively what it is to us/ in relation to us (it's place is marked /we name it) At the largest and the smallest scale they fall apart in the same way to show us that there is no difference between them at all, (the largest and smallest scale) and that we exist only between two infinities. The picture of reality and the video of movement is infinitely high definition, but if the pixels are infinitely small, how can they possibly exist at all? Their size would be comparable to the size of us, if the universe is infinitely large: because if the whole universe is a big TV with infinite pixels then what are you? You are infinitely small, you do not exist. If the universe is infinitely large, we can run forever but we will always be in the same place: in between two infinities. Yes, we are only where we are, and what we are, in relation to something else that is just as real as us, which is:not.


r/philosophyself • • Feb 11 '15

Women should not be aloud to be a part of special operations teams (SEALs, Rangers, etc.), especially only for the sake of 'equality'

3 Upvotes

I want to start off by saying that I am NOT a special operations forces soldier, but I do not think that disqualifies me from having an opinion. I also want to say that men and women are NOT equal (gasp). However, that being said, one gender is also NOT superior to the other either. Men and women (generally speaking) compliment each other in life. A man is better suited for combat, particularly in a special operations setting, than a woman is. There is the obvious physical advantage (again, generally speaking), but there is also a mental advantage as well. I am NOT saying that men are smarter than women, or the other way around. I am saying that a man tends to be less emotional than a woman and that is helpful in a combat setting. I am all for gender equality in the 'real world,' but in the military, no matter the brach, the priority is the mission. The overwhelming majority of the time, a woman will NOT bring any advantages over a man into a special operations mission and, therefore, women should not be allowed to fulfill these roles.


r/philosophyself • • Jun 19 '18

Any model of this universe/reality based on materialism is creative science fiction.

3 Upvotes

Did your consciousness exist first and create that reality/universe in your dream you had last night, or did that world in your dream exist first and create your consciousness? If there was a pink elephant inside of that dream, would you give that elephant credit for creating that dream and the entire world inside of that dream? Of course not because the elephant itself is part of that reality. You can't use pieces of a reality to explain how that reality began existing.

A reality can't even exist before the terms of that reality are consciously decided for it. Mario Land could not begin existing until the creators of Nintendo decided that it should exist, imagined what its general nature should be, like what it is made of and what should exist inside of it, and programmed parameters to define a range of things that were possible inside of that reality to exclude the things that were NOT possible. Someone saying that this reality could have began with chemical reactions or some other element of this reality doesn't make sense, because something has to decide those reactions happening in that reality is even one of the possibilities, and if those chemicals/elements existing at all was even one of those possibilities.

Those chemicals/elements didn't create that reality because they were already a PART of that reality. It would be like saying that the reality of Mario Land exists because Mario or something else inside of Mario Land built it. You can't use pieces of a reality to explain how that reality began existing. A law book cannot write its own laws telling itself what law books are allowed to do and if law books are allowed to exist or not in this reality.

A dream is a reality, Mario Land is a reality, this universe is a reality. They all have to begin existing in the same way, the terms of that reality must be decided for it first. A reality can't decide its own terms and can't even decide for itself that it should exist. The reality in a dream must begin with consciousness, the reality of Mario Land must begin with consciousness, the fictional reality in a book or a movie must begin with consciousness. So imagine how any of those things could have come to exist WITHOUT consciousness, then apply that same logic to the reality you live in. Dreams can't dream themselves, video games can't design themselves, books cannot write themselves, movies cannot film themselves, and OUR reality cannot create itself.

If you have any reason to believe that our reality could begin existing in a ANY other way, then tell me what that reason is and how you think it could happen differently. Why would the creation of our reality be different than the creation of any other? Why would all other realities require consciousness to exist first except for ours? What would make our reality special? Do you have evidence to prove that this reality came to exist any other way? Do you even have a hypothesis for how it could happen any other way? You need to reevaluate the reasons why you believe what you DO believe until someone "proves" to you otherwise. Because you don't even have a hypothesis for the origin of this reality without consciousness creating it. You only have a hypothesis for a future hypothesis, that someone in the future will make for you to explain how something impossible is actually possible. ;)


r/philosophyself • • Sep 30 '18

Are Universal Darwinism and Occam's razor enough to answer all Why? (Because of what?) questions?

0 Upvotes

r/philosophyself • • Jan 30 '26

​I've written a short critique and my personal understanding of Plato's Allegory of the Cave. This is how it turned out:

1 Upvotes

Just to be clear: This is my first time on critical philosophical thinking. I started with the Allegory because it's the first subject of my school's philosophy book, and I'm just another guy who's interested in philosophy and wants to delve into and discuss about it

​The narrative is based on the story of prisoners who, since childhood, have lived chained inside a cave. There, they see only shadows of the real world projected onto a wall by a light source. Condemned to observe these projections, they draw their own conclusions about their meanings. Eventually, one of these prisoners decides to break free from the chains and behold the outside world, bathed in light. However, upon becoming enchanted by reality—no longer as a projection, but as a fact—he decides, despite the difficulties, to return to the cave to tell his companions what he saw, only to be met with mockery and threats.

​What are the chains? Ignorance. What is the light? Truth and the real world. Who broke free? The thinker, the philosopher.

​However, there is a definition that is rarely questioned in the allegory: what is truth?

​From this point forward, I present my reflections, shaped by my current beliefs and knowledge. The Allegory of the Cave presents a problem that can be defined in one word: simplism.

​While we can extract valuable lessons on how humans process information, the question remains: what is 'fact'? What is the 'fact' according to man? And what does man truly know about fact? How is it manufactured?

​Currently, at 19 years old and as an atheist, I believe there is no absolute truth behind the creation of the universe and the wonders of nature. At the same time, this belief encounters another: that one thought precedes another, successively, until reaching the point where everything was created.

​Suppose I grew up believing that a red pen is, in fact, blue. I wouldn't know what 'blue' is—heavens, I wouldn't even have the concept of colours! If someone finally described this concept to me and claimed the pen is red, but I remained believing it is blue, I would be wrong from the perspective of someone who understands colours. But is this external definition necessarily the correct one? What guarantees that the definition of colours itself isn't just another projection on the wall? What if this former prisoner is teaching me something that isn't the complete truth? From where does truth emanate?

​In my view, the cave does not represent a place of total ignorance, but rather a crucial stage in the formation of thought: the realm of ideas and imagination. I can accept that the pen is red, but I can also deny that statement and reframe the information so that it makes sense to me. ​To classify the cave merely as the 'dark home of ignorance' is to deny interpretation. In the same way the prisoner freed himself from the original shackles, what stops me from thinking he simply chained himself to new shackles in a different location?

​Does a cave actually exist? In my view, no. Since we are in the realm of imagination, we are free to interpret both shadows and reality as we wish: to revisit ideas and understand the mechanisms of the world through our own prism. The cave, in reality, would be like an anthill of infinite dimensions, filled with interpretations raised to the power of n. In it, the shadow of a man carrying a box could actually be a man carrying a 'non-box'—and that would be but a fragment before the immense void of possible information and interpretations."


r/philosophyself • • Feb 06 '19

Philosophy needs to change

3 Upvotes

Philosophy today is an antiquated mess that needs to change immediately.

Philosophy should not be a field of study considered independent of science or observation. Philosophy is the study of what we cannot necessarily prove. However, philosophy also entails a great number of other aspects of the human condition.

Namely, philosophy may also be referred to as, "Critical Thinking."

Consider philosophy like one considers empathy. It is an invaluable skill that is absolutely necessary in day to day life, however, it is not meant to be taught in a classroom setting. Philosophy is to be taught and adapted from personal belief and experience weighed against ones perception.

That being the case, does it seem wise to only validate the original thoughts and concepts of those who have lived, written and died already?

Secondly, the very nature of post secondary education dictates a somewhat inflated sense of self. "Who are you to question the very nature of existence? Where did you receive your Masters?"

Ultimately, the very nature of philosophical thought, is causing a rift to form between the "Amateur," and "Professional," philosophical minds. Giving certain forms of knowledge advanced consideration, based entirely on the formal education of the writer, is biased and unwise.

It would appear, at present, that philosophers are NOT writing for the betterment of man-kind. They are, rather, writing for each other. They seem somewhat motivated to draw a firm line between themselves, and those who lack formal education.

Check this out, if you are so inclined.

https://youtu.be/D-iWLlxrceI

To wrap it up, I say philosophy is an ancient echochamber lf self absorbed academics who will do anything in their power to keep the, "everyman," out of THEIR field.

And it makes me sick.


r/philosophyself • • Aug 07 '14

Can being on this subreddit have secondary effects?

3 Upvotes

This subreddit seems to be targeted at the one who thinks of himself as -out of the crowd- thus making out of you a crowd of such people. Is it not dangerous for such people to be in a crowd ? he is about to take into consideration many ideas and which only because they come from this place, they come with an advantage. Having changed his standards of self sufficiency in thinking his thoughts, now it allow the thinking of external at a much higher rate / to the detriment of time allocated for his thoughts. original philosophical thoughts become tainted by the assimilation of the commercial type. This mimics the loss of culture as result of population assimilation /migration mechanism. Your root characteristic -solitary thinker is replaced with the opposite. . .
this first impression comes from someone who studied the fragility of original thoughts and how surprisingly easy it is to permit external factors dictate your general mood.


r/philosophyself • • Jan 06 '20

A Thought For my Generation

3 Upvotes

How foreign to be writing a letter in 2020. It is slower, the pen travels across the paper in a way that allows your mind the opportunity to think more carefully about that which tattoos the paper I place my ink filled pen upon. The simplicity associated with this particular act creates a mental phenomenon that when examined more closely asks me to look deeply at the direction in which our generation is headed. 

To little do we now concern ourselves with the small things that offer authentic value to our lives. For example, when was the last time the average person of our age within today's modern societies sat down with pen in hand to write a friend, loved one or other a letter? An activity such as this reminds me of a childhood where I would lay in grassy fields and look up at the sky's art with wonder as my mind transformed strokes of clouds into various forms, each one playing a crucial role in the story I attempted to craft. So few within our generation take time to indulge in such peaceful simplicities. In reflection of our current existence, it appears, at least through the eyes in which I observe the world that as we move forward in our cult of progress we've begun to offer our souls to a world of technological creations incapable of embracing them.  Never is this more apparent than when we lay alone in our beds illuminated by inauthentic reflections of ourselves, we crave for someone to cradle our detached souls. 

We have grown away from a willingness to be vulnerable in our pursuit of a modern form of existence that deceivingly promises a simpler life and to make the world a better place. We have been persuaded that likes, retweets, and shares are capable nourishing our starving souls. Blindly we continue to wander within a virtual reality we've been convinced is more fulfilling than the reality into which we were born.

Distracted have our minds become by the portals we use to visit the virtual reality in which we spend a majority of our time. In the digital plantations we farm for manipulative corporations we begin the process of numbing our minds to reality; we have become slaves to the offerings of our screens. Many of us find ourselves quickly entertained by content vacant of true value. Our continued consumption of empty content works to dull our minds in such a way that we become evermore unaware. 

The last decade might suggest we are now more than ever ravenous for constant entertainment. It appears boredom is to be avoided at all costs, perhaps it should even be feared. Of course such a state is a result of a decades worth of conditioning. This I fear, for it is of great importance that our minds are free to think without distraction. Some ask why a state of boredom is so important, the reason is simple, boredom fosters free and independent thought. Free and independent thought with its expression allows freedom to prosper.

If we constantly consume empty content fed to us by algorithms that have learned to know us better than we know ourselves then we will always be entertained which will result in the constant distraction of our minds. A constantly distracted mind cannot think freely. When individual thought can not flow free our minds awareness depreciates, inturn becoming more malleable. When something is malleable and someone has control over that which is malleable it can be molded into whatever the sculptor desires. Our generation and those to come if not mindful will unknowingly hand over the most foundational form of freedom to those who desire to consume the world in their quest for power.

-Wil

  


r/philosophyself • • 13d ago

New Consciousness Argument for God

0 Upvotes

This video explores the meta problem of consciousness proposed by David Chalmers and argues that naturalistic processes couldn’t have given us knowledge of consciousness

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJVvZNi0Fi8


r/philosophyself • • Apr 20 '17

Is kindness always cruel? (Retry)

0 Upvotes

It seems that a lot of the worlds problem stem from nice people trying to the "right" thing.

If I gave you a penny when you desperately needed it that would be considered kind but if you then asked for more and I said no would that be kind as well? Would you understand or would you be angry?

If you don't understand the massive undertaking that goes into charity but only doing it for a fleeting moment of kindness it is cruel. If you act charitable in order to appear kind or doing so because you feel it is the "right thing to do" you are actually not understanding what you are doing.

From my point of view it seem as if nice people are often keen on taking on more responsibility then they are capable of but then opt out the second it gets difficult. What about the people that have grown to depend on this nice person because they have nothing else to lean on? What happens to them when the nice person leaves? Will they ever be able to trust another nice person again? What if they grow resentful towards all these nice people coming and going?


r/philosophyself • • Sep 05 '17

My issues with Reality: HELP please!

0 Upvotes

This is going to be long, but here I go.

Ok, so ever since I started living in a parallel universe out of fear 5 years ago, my reality has changed a lot over time. It went from living in a parallel universe (you know where your new reality makes a discordance with your other one, the one you were in before you started living in a parallel universe), to living in a complete fantasy world to having constant reality shifts, to enlightenment. Now why do I have so many constant reality shifts? I haven't had it in a month or two, but I'm still curious to why this is. I also find my reality much more interesting when I live in a parallel universe or a fantasy world! I feel like reality is just dull and boring! I also feel like without the enlightenment I've had for quite some time followed by my reality shifts, also makes my reality MUCH more enjoyable, yet a little more intense. I find it that when I am enlightened I have such really strong passions for certain amount of things I am interested in, it's just intensified! Now bare with me people. This might sound silly to some of you. I don't want everyone to think I am mentally ill just because I am talking about living in parallel universe. It's just this has taken over my life drastically. It effects my mood, emotions, thoughts and perceptions. It makes my life 5x more complicated too! So why does it do this?

Another thing which really stumps me is this.

Ok, so when I look back on certain times in my life. It directs me to the way I viewed/ perceived the world at the time (the reality I had during the time). So like when I look back on my life 5 years ago, I have the memories I had while living in that parallel universe. I also notice this enlightenment makes a discordance with my current reality. Honestly, I've had like 6-7 different realities. And in these realities I find myself to be very imaginative and prone to an obsession with fantasy (But not living in a fantasy world) . Even though this has disrupted my life, I still don't regret it. I'm glad I get to view the world in multiple ways.

Why am I so intrigued by the parallel universe I lived in a few years back? Why does enlightenment intense my reality? Why does it make me more inquisitive on life and the world? Why does it make my reality more interesting and enjoyable yet more unnecessarily intense? Is all this normal? Can you guys tell me what the hell is going on here? I hope I don't have a mental illness. All this is making me starting to wonder. I hope this is all making sense. Sorry if it's not, I just have A LOT to get off my chest.

Thoughts? Advice?

Be honest!

I need to figure this shit out!


r/philosophyself • • Jun 23 '16

There is no true random and a human's belief that anything can happen is a result of their limited viewpoint.

0 Upvotes

As a human we can only experience one timeline. So regardless of whether there are others we are not conscious of them. Just wanted to get that out as a starter.

SO in light of that we cannot physically perceive what would be different about our world if events happened differently. We just cant. from saying what would happen if the nazis won right down to i could have won a fiver on that coin flip. If it didnt happen it couldn't happen, and we know this because we are incapable of imagining a perfect true situation in which something happened differently.

my theory is that to look back on our lives/history we can see a series of interlocking contexts and sequences, all that create a causation for the next events to happen. imagine that time works like a screen that progressively scans. it is given instructions of where to put colours and it fills it in line by line. Now each second is a line in the progressive scan and before it came a wealth of causation which acts as instructions for the events that happen in that second. it is not random, all the events that precede it cause a thing to happen. And looking back at an event we can see the exact causation that lead towards it.

I understand that i'm rambling here but what i'm trying to say here is that humans only believe in random because we are incapable of knowing the entire causation, largely because there is a huge amount of it, and also because there is causation that is pseudo random and instant. they are only understandable to the human brain if we label them as random (i.e. particles colliding in space and lottery balls coming in a specific order) or instant (plucking a string on a guitar creates a sound). And even these often have understandings of their cause and effect within human knowledge. if we are to look back at history at ANY point in the future we would see a list of events that caused modern occurrences to happen. so how can we say that it is in fact random. when hindsight tells us that there is absolutely no other way that it could have happened. And due to the fact that everything has a causation and every causation has a causation then we can safely say that everything in the world, up until this exact moment in time, that COULD have happened DID happen as everything that could happen had an already existing causation.

Who are we to say that it could have happened any differently when we are merely blocks in an infinite game of dominoes. to take a blocks view we can see infinite blocks in front of us that aren't knocked over, but we know that they are dominoes blocks and that they can be knocked over, and thus they are in a state of random. however as an outside observer we can see that the first block has been knocked over and thus even though all the blocks are still upright they are in an inescapable state of falling over. its a bit like schrodinger's dominoes. we cannot know all the causation as we are locked into our singular viewpoints and thus the future is in a perpetual state of unknowing and therefore perceived as random.


r/philosophyself • • Oct 09 '17

Eliminating Chance Nature In Knowing And Attaining Main Utility

0 Upvotes

I am now making actions to eliminate all the (known/unknown) conformations (if they exist), similar to or beyond that of, pain, which we may face after death or during our life. (Conformation known after eliminating all the conformations as described in the last lines = Main utility)

Can we be not knowing all the conformations which need to be eliminated, if complete data is not known? This seems to need us know all the data (now thinking to know all data, via automation from the known data of particle physics, etc).

If we start making actions to know all the data, won't the actions made while knowing all the data have chances/possibility of they not allowing us attain main utility, or any other conformation made, to not allow attaining main utility? It seems that till we know all the data, we will not be able to know on which conformation will be not allowing us to attain the main utility, then how to eliminate this chance nature, and fix the utility of knowing main utility?

[If we continue making actions to know all the data, without knowing on which actions made for it not allow us attain main utility, it seems to be a submission made, similar to not doing any action to attain the utility.]


r/philosophyself • • Aug 24 '16

Can anyone help recommending some books?

0 Upvotes

So I'm very interested in philosophy (especially metaphysics) and it would be awesome if you could recommend me some books, I've never gone through a philosophy course/class of any kind (I think next semester ill have a philosophy class in high-school) so anything's fine preferably something to get me started, ill leave it to your judgment.


r/philosophyself • • Dec 19 '17

If Dark energy is all the spirits in the universe ?

0 Upvotes

then the expansion of universe is accelerating faster and faster because of birth in all universe ?


r/philosophyself • • Sep 07 '16

War against mediocrity and losing the middle ground.

0 Upvotes

I am not really sure if this is fitting subject for this sub, but I didnt know where to post this and get intelligent responses.

It is a thought that i have been having for some time now...In this millenia/age whatever one may call it "2000's" one may notice if they really try a mass push against mediocrity - or should I call it "being average" , almost as similar to push for political correctness.

I will shortly regress and just give a snippet about "political correctness and its relation to Orwell 1984 ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dNbWGaaxWM )

Intentional or not. This is a road to control.

Back to topic of mediocrity. I am feeling that in today modern society - business world - man can only be top or failure.

A company will only hire top performers , and expect people to give their top game 100%. If they not - they automatically fall into failure basket and are left with jobs dedicated to failed populations , like Walmart cashier.

The middle ground is non - existent.

Being 100% on top of your game means that you give 100% to your job , leaving your health or personal life seriously neglected. But in today business world is either you do that , or you are in fail basket.

There is no middle ground.

Dont you think that this "Fight mediocrity" message has only one class - the exploiting class - to benefit ?

I remember the times where people were just doing their jobs, not sacrificing themselves for the jobs. And they were mediocre successful - not rich , but not poor. Middle class.

They had life...

The war for excellence is war against life. War for self slavery. In excellence world people can only be exploiters or slaves...

I want to have life aside from work. I want to read, philosophize, daydream, do art... But i can not - I must be the top....


r/philosophyself • • Feb 16 '19

The Glowing Ones

4 Upvotes

Some people almost seem to glow.

Not literally. But it's like they have an energy that's more intense than that of other people. They're not everywhere. I could count all the one's I've met on two hands. But these people, The Glowing Ones... You know exactly where they are in the room. You're tuned into them on some level, because their existence and proximity demand your attention. Even if you close your eyes, you can still feel them, sense their movement throughout the room. They don't have to say anything to earn your attention. You don't even have to know them. You're just Aware.

The Glowing Ones draw the attention of everybody, not just you. People talk about them. Everyone has an opinion. It's almost like that glowing energy is a magnet. It stirs up all that comes near it.


r/philosophyself • • Feb 03 '26

The Counteroffensive NSFW Spoiler

0 Upvotes

How democratic institutions have begun to curb the advance of the far right

 

Democracies are not only “resisting” the far right; they are learning to defend the conditions that make the vote genuinely free. In the United States, Donald Trump’s erosion is not merely statistical: the escalation of migration enforcement, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement operations and nationwide protests reveal the political costs of governing through intimidation and narrative manipulation. In parallel, fissures are emerging within the Republican Party itself.

Beyond the US, the pattern appears through different channels: in Brazil, a judicial response to coup plotting; in France, Marine Le Pen’s ineligibility; in Germany, the logic of militant democracy; and in Hungria and Polónia, the external decision by the União Europeia to impose consequences when the rule of law is eroded.

The thesis is simple and uncomfortable: when disinformation becomes strategy and the public sphere fractures, democracy cannot be reduced to electoral procedure. It needs “immunitary” mechanisms — internal and external — to prevent lies from capturing the very mechanism of choice. The boundary is delicate, but ignoring it can be fatal.

 

 

A year ago, Donald Trump returned to the White House triumphant with under 50% of the popular vote and a majority in the Electoral College. He promised to be the ‘president of peace’, the man who would end wars and restore American greatness. By late November 2025, his approval rating had fallen to 36% in a Gallup poll—the lowest point of his second term—and 60% of Americans disapproved of his performance. The reversal is stark: he began the term at 47% approval and 48% disapproval; by November he stood at 36% approval and 60% disapproval. Among independents, only 25% approve of him. The figure who had become the model and catalyst for far-right movements worldwide now sees his base fragmenting.

One visible component of this erosion has a concrete catalyst: the escalation of migration policy and the machinery of deportation. In January 2026, two deaths in Minneapolis involving federal agents during an enforcement operation—two American citizens shot in incidents whose official accounts were immediately challenged by videos and documents—triggered large-scale protests and student walkouts, from Minnesota to both coasts. A Reuters/Ipsos poll recorded 58% of respondents saying that ICE had ‘gone too far’, with Trump’s approval on immigration falling to 39% and his overall approval to 38%. The Department of Homeland Security’s response—announcing body cameras for agents in Minneapolis—was already a sign of political cost and of lost narrative control.

The decline is not confined to polling. In Congress, fissures have multiplied. Five Republican senators—Lisa Murkowski, Rand Paul, Josh Hawley, Susan Collins and Todd Young—voted with Democrats to advance a war-powers resolution intended to limit new military action in Venezuela. Seventeen Republicans in the House of Representatives voted against Trump’s position on health subsidies. In Indiana, 21 Republican state senators rejected the redistricting plan the president had demanded. Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, until then a vocal ally of the president, was blunt: ‘I think the dam is breaking.’ Thom Tillis announced that he will not seek re-election after clashes with the president. In Congress, initiatives have emerged to prevent federal funding for any attempt to annex Greenland. The fear of Trumpist primaries, which for years paralysed the party, is beginning to give way to fear of losing the midterm elections.

In the streets, popular resistance has reached historic proportions. The ‘No Kings’ protests mobilised, according to several independent estimates, between 4 and 6 million people in the United States in June 2025; in October, organisers claimed around 7 million (with other estimates placing participation at roughly 5 to 6.5 million). Either way, it was one of the largest single-day protests in the country’s recent history. Organisers are now preparing a third wave for 28 March 2026, with the stated ambition of mobilising up to 9 million participants. Professor Erica Chenoweth of Harvard University notes that these protests differ from those of the first term: they are more geographically dispersed, reaching into counties that voted for Trump, and they have displayed a persistence the earlier wave did not.

The electoral consequences are palpable. A November 2025 NPR/PBS News/Marist poll showed Democrats with a 14-point lead over Republicans in congressional vote intention—the largest since 2017, at precisely the point in Trump’s first term that preceded the Democratic wave of 2018, which cost Republicans 40 seats. Among independents, the gap is particularly pronounced. ‘The warning signs for Republicans are enormous,’ the poll’s analysis concluded.

This pattern of institutional and popular resistance is not uniquely American. On the contrary, it appears to be crystallising simultaneously across several democracies that have faced the advance of authoritarian populist movements—often inspired or encouraged by Trump himself. The cases of Brazil, France, Germany and Hungary reveal a shared dynamic: when electoral routes prove insufficient to contain threats to democratic norms, judicial and administrative institutions—and, in some contexts, external bodies with the power to impose consequences—move into action.

In Brazil, Jair Bolsonaro is serving his sentence in a Federal Police facility in Brasília. On 11 September 2025, the Supreme Federal Court sentenced him to 27 years and three months’ imprisonment for attempted coup—a plan that included the assassination of President Lula, Vice-President Alckmin and Minister Alexandre de Moraes. On 22 November, after violating his electronic ankle monitor and attempting to flee, Bolsonaro was arrested. On 8 January 2026, exactly three years after his supporters stormed the seats of the three branches of government, Lula vetoed a bill passed by Congress that would have drastically reduced Bolsonaro’s sentence, writing: ‘In the name of the future, we have no right to forget the past.’ In parallel, the Trump administration imposed sanctions on Minister de Moraes—later lifted—and announced 50% tariffs on Brazilian products, later partially rolled back. Brazil did not back down.

In France, Marine Le Pen faces a different but equally consequential fate. On 31 March 2025, a Paris court convicted her of misappropriating European Parliament funds between 2004 and 2016. The sentence—four years’ imprisonment, two of them to be served under electronic tagging, a €100,000 fine, and five years of ineligibility with immediate effect—sent shockwaves through French politics. Le Pen, who had been leading all polls for the 2027 presidential election, was barred from standing. Judge Bénédicte de Perthuis was explicit: Le Pen was ‘at the heart of a system’ that amounted to ‘a serious and lasting attack on democratic rules’. The appeal hearing began on 13 January 2026; a decision is expected in the summer. Trump called the conviction ‘a major event’ and compared it to his own legal cases.

In Germany, the institutional response has taken a distinct form. On 2 May 2025, the Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz—the domestic agency charged with protecting the constitutional order—classified the Alternative für Deutschland as a ‘confirmed right-wing extremist entity’, on the basis of a 1,100-page report documenting anti-Muslim and anti-immigrant rhetoric deemed incompatible with the constitutional requirement of ‘human dignity’. The classification enables enhanced surveillance, the use of informants, and the monitoring of communications. Following a legal challenge, the agency temporarily suspended the public label while the court considers the case, without removing the substantive debate about the report’s foundations. A political and legal debate is under way that could culminate in an application to the Constitutional Court to ban the party—something that has happened only twice since the Second World War. This is Germany’s notion of streitbare Demokratie, ‘militant democracy’: the state may defend itself against internal threats to its democratic foundations.

In Hungary, the institutional counteroffensive takes a less dramatic, but politically more revealing form: the decision by an external institution to impose costs on an illiberal drift. The visible instrument is budgetary—suspension and freezing of funds—but the central point is not ‘finance’ as such; it is the institutional choice to condition access to common resources on respect for minimal rule-of-law guarantees. After the Council suspended around €6.3 billion in cohesion commitments, the persistence of the impasse led, in early 2026, to the loss of more than €1 billion in EU funding whose eligibility deadline expired. It is a form of self-defence that does not depend on the vote: not because it replaces elections, but because it refuses—without conditions—to fund the erosion of the rules that make democratic cooperation possible.

In Poland, this type of external constraint was among the first large-scale European trials of the approach. For years, the European Union made access to disbursements under the Recovery and Resilience Facility conditional—and kept funds withheld—in response to judicial reforms deemed incompatible with judicial independence and the rule of law. The message was the same: political and budgetary cooperation cannot be neutral in the face of the erosion of the guarantees that sustain the democratic order itself.

The American administration’s reaction to these measures was hostile in every case. Secretary of State Marco Rubio called the AfD classification ‘tyranny in disguise’; Vice-President JD Vance accused Germany of ‘rebuilding the Berlin Wall’. The German Foreign Office responded tersely: ‘We have learned from our history that far-right extremism must be stopped. This is democracy.’ International solidarity among far-right leaders—Geert Wilders, Matteo Salvini, Viktor Orbán, Elon Musk and Bolsonaro himself expressed support for Le Pen—did not alter the course of the institutions that acted.

The data demand interpretative caution, yet they also reveal something that exceeds the conjuncture. In the United States, despite Trump’s decline, Republicans retain control of Congress and the White House. The AfD won 20.8% in Germany’s February 2025 federal election and leads some polls. Bolsonaro remains an influential political figure in Brazil, even in prison. Le Pen’s Rassemblement National retains its electorate. These movements are not disappearing; in some cases, they continue to grow. What the data show is not a public-opinion ‘turn’ against the far right. It is something more structural: an unprecedented activation of institutional mechanisms—judicial convictions, administrative classifications, disqualifications from office, parliamentary resistance—that operate outside strictly electoral logic. Democracies are defending themselves through instruments that transcend the electoral procedure itself.

The question imposes itself: why now? The answer lies in what these movements do to the democratic mechanism itself. A study published in January 2025 by researchers from the University of Amsterdam and Vrije Universiteit, analysing 32 million parliamentary posts across 26 countries over six years, reached a conclusion that ought to be unsettling: disinformation is not an accidental by-product of social media but a deliberate political strategy of right-wing radical populist parties. Neither left populism nor the traditional right shows a significant correlation with the dissemination of false information. Only radical populist right parties do. The study documents how these movements exploit the crisis of trust in institutions, create alternative media ecosystems, and use disinformation as a tool to destabilise democracies and gain electoral advantage. In the United States, a 2024 PRRI survey found that 19% of Americans believe core QAnon theories—and among Republican Trump supporters, the figure rises to 32%. A substantial portion of the Republican electorate continues to sustain the narrative that the 2020 election was ‘stolen’, despite the absence of credible evidence.

Here the problem becomes philosophical. Democracy presupposes informed citizens who make rational choices on the basis of facts. It is not merely a tally of preferences: it is a decision regime anchored in a minimally shared public sphere. If information is systematically distorted, if lies are disseminated as political strategy, choices cease to be genuinely free. A vote grounded in falsehoods is not a genuinely democratic vote—it is the capture of the democratic mechanism by those who seek to destroy it. Truth cannot be held hostage by the lie. Allowing the lie to prevail through the vote is allowing democracy to be turned against itself.

In 1945, Karl Popper formulated the paradox of tolerance: a society that is unlimitedly tolerant will inevitably be destroyed by the intolerant. A democracy that tolerates anti-democrats to the end becomes complicit in its own dissolution. For decades, this principle remained largely theoretical in Western democracies. What 2025 and 2026 demonstrate is its coordinated practical application—and the reason is precisely this: when the vote itself is manipulated through systematic disinformation, to wait for electoral victories to correct the course is to wait for the disease to cure itself. Germans call it streitbare Demokratie—militant democracy—and inscribed it into the Basic Law after the Weimar experience. But the current phenomenon is broader: multiple democracies, simultaneously, activating self-defence mechanisms that do not depend on the vote. Trump in the White House with 36% approval and fissures within his own party. Bolsonaro in a cell in Brasília. Le Pen barred from standing. The AfD under constitutional scrutiny. Millions in the streets shouting ‘No Kings’. The paradox is resolved as follows:

And perhaps it is here that a necessary evolution becomes visible—not by historical destiny, but by functional necessity. In an era in which disinformation is strategy and the public sphere fragments, democracy cannot be reduced to electoral procedure; it must protect the conditions that make the vote free and meaningful. This entails an immunitary dimension: internal and external mechanisms that do not replace popular choice, but prevent systematic lying from capturing the mechanism of choice itself.

The boundary is delicate. If these restraints detach from criteria of proportionality, due process, transparency and judicial oversight, self-defence degenerates into punitive technocracy. But when they are activated to defend the integrity of the public sphere and the reversibility of power, they are not ‘less democracy’: they are democracy preventing its openness from being used to destroy it.

Democracy, to survive, cannot be merely democratic. It needs institutions capable of acting when truth is under attack—and when the popular vote is precisely the instrument of that attack. It is an uncomfortable conclusion. But it may be the only honest conclusion this historical moment allows.


r/philosophyself • • Dec 24 '19

I want to start writing philosophy. What do I need to read that I'm being ignorant about?

6 Upvotes

Disclaimer: English is not my first language.

I have a lot of philosophical ideas I want to write about in a blog which I feel are new and good, but I know only very basic philosophy from school and from listening to the podcast 'philosophize this!' on spotify. I was wondering if this is the right place to outline some of my ideas so you can tell me what I am being ignorant about and what I need to read before I start writing. I am going in a 1 month trip to India on January and I'd really like to start writing when I come back so I'm thinking 2-3 books. This a rough outline of my thoughts:

I am agnostic. The more characteristics you add to the concept of God (conscience, intelligence, free will, etc), the less likely I think its real. I don't believe in souls or free will. I think us animals are like machines in that we have an input of information through our senses which we process and transform into an output of movement and actions. This process was developed through darwinian natural selection. Certain 'transformations of information' (see food-eat it, hear predator-run away, etc) made our genes more likely to survive, and we percieve the 'direction' of those transformations as happiness-sadness. If it made us happy to eat, we were more likely to eat, and thus to survive. If it made us sad to be hurt, we were more likely to avoid being hurt, and thus more likely to survive. Similarly, if we had empathy and loved our family and friends, it was more likely we took care of eachother, and thus that we survived (the happiness brought by love and family and friends are a higher level of happiness than, say, eating chocolate, because they are long term). 'Thought' is the transformation of information. The big difference between humans and other animals is that we process/transform a much larger amount of information, so within all that information, we process the facts that we have names and identities. Thats all consciousness is to me. Bits of information we take into account to choose actions that made our ancestors survive. But there is a catch. Within all this information we process, we humans realized something (mostly uncosciously and some of us consciously): that the happiness of other beings is the same thing as our own happiness, and thus its irrational to seek our own happiness at the expense of other's. That is why some make sacrifices for the good of others. We invented the words like 'morals', 'justice' and 'good' and phrases like "what has to be done" to describe those actions that provide "the greater good". Thus, it is true and correct to say things like "we have to help others", "we have to seek the truth" and "we have to be good". I am opposed to nihilism and post modernism. To me, actions are 'right' when they create more happiness than sadness and 'wrong' when they create net sadness (I think that last bit is called utilitarianism, I've read some of the objections to it and I have my own answers but I can't expand on that on this summary). The ultimate goal of life is to maximize happiness as much as we can.

Now that is a very condensed summary of some of my thoughts, I could really expand on that and write my ideas about many other subjects but that paragraph is kind of a starting point to a lot of the other stuff. Am I being an ignorant fool? What are, in your opinion, the major mistakes in my reasoning? Are these new ideas or have they been written many times before? Is it even possible to become a popular philosopher without having extensive knowledge of philosophy? And what books can you recommend for my trip? Thank you very much.


r/philosophyself • • Jul 27 '25

Is there anyone actually out there?

1 Upvotes

At this point I am less interested in finding out whether you, who reads this, has a mind (Or how it could ever be possible for me to find out whether you do).

The question is more practical: Is anyone actually reading this? Or is this subreddit dead?


r/philosophyself • • Jul 25 '26

MY FICTIONAL CHARACTER BEATED ME UP IN REAL LIFE🙀🙀🙀🙀🙀

0 Upvotes

My 0D Character destroyed real life😁

My another OC came to real life and I called it as a hyperstition🙀


r/philosophyself • • Aug 22 '15

LOVE

0 Upvotes

Love is a legitimate state of emotion which has the potential to gravitate the bearer towards it. It is almost all the time incited naturally. It grows into a very strong state if visited adequately in its positive light and not negative. Also by adequately doing acts that are the fruits of it. The legitimate state of love is a potential emotional gravitational force within oneself that has different tunes and textures.Love does not only grow in the emotional environment of the one that is showing love but also it grows in the emotional state of the one that is being loved as well. eg:- A child growing to have love for parents.Like most things granted to living things by nature, love also is devised by nature for life or species showing this emotional state to have a better chance of survival. Love gives the bearer a push to do something that otherwise the bearer wouldn't have done or would have been a lot more reluctant and a lot less effective. By doing so it is most likely to guarantee safety for some and ability to reproduce for others. Some examples are:-Parents care, nurture and protection for their children, Fighting for someone one loves, Taking care of elderly family members etc.Nature also sugarcoated love with temporary pleasures and displeasure(displeasure if negated). It coated it with emotional satisfaction and emotional dissatisfaction(If action taken against and despite the feeling.) eg:- Moral satisfaction, Self guilt, Pleasure of love, Loneliness etc...Like everything else, a more evolved and mature love is the stronger and a more stable one. Love feltin an instant or an infant love is a potential to be a strong stable everlasting state. But it is prone to death and elimination if not paid adequate care, attention and if not fed. The main food for love is the response or feeling of the other party.Hate is the opposite of love. As its opposite, acts of hate in its environment is like an antimatter. If the love is in an infant state, it(hate) has the potential tokill it quickly.There are different types of love that differ in tune and texture. For example, love for a mother is not the same as love for a wife.The deciding factor that plays a role in determining the texture that a love turns out to have is on what the love was based on and from what state and intention that the love was born out of also in what direction it was directed to take in its infancy and young state.The texture that a love is suppose to take is incited at first by nature. For example, a mother feels a certain type of love by nature when she first bears achild and she can make it grow in that direction. Also a young man naturally may feel love in a different texture when he sees a woman he is attracted to and also he can make it grow in its owndirection. Differences in texture can be seen in examples of different types of love. Eg:-Love for parents or childrenLove for a wife or girlfriendLove for selfLove for general othersLove for something one does. etc...