r/philosophyself • • Jul 12 '19

Art Is Everything & Nothing

13 Upvotes

I've decided to make this a work in progress as there is nowhere else to put it.

The Art of Everything & Nothing

We as people don't know what we're doing, why we're doing it, and have little clue on what to go on. This drives us crazy trying to find it. Ironically, there’s an art to driving yourself crazy. There’s an art to becoming uncrazy too. Sometimes we think we have the answer. Usually, that answer is wrong. So we need a way to find answers.

There is an art to definition, and an art to creating systems. The art of creating systems we call engineering. We have engineered a system to find answers, and call this reasoning. However, Kurt Godel has proven that any system can not prove itself using its own rules. Reasoning, as a system, can not be proven to be correct unless it is contextually in another system. So, we are always left with further questions. Or, infinite questions. If one were to abstract incompleteness theorem to reality, then it has proved infinite systems, each contextually building upon the other. In other words, according to his Incompleteness Theorem in Mathematics:

...{system{system{system{system...

Math provides definition, but is ill-defined. Proof is required for Mathematical theorems to be accepted, but is not itself provable. There are some generally acceptable ideas of what Math is, such as applied logic, applied reasoning or simply the conceptual language of the universe. As Math has not an agreed upon definition, these explanations are subjectively decent.

Moving outwards from Math and back towards reasoning. Reasoning involves asking questions. Questions fall into certain categories. Who, what, why, how, where and when are the types of questions we can ask. Answering these questions involves the use of philosophy and definitions. A philosophy is an answer with reason or reasons.

Who is art? Everyone. We are all art, nature’s art, and artists. No matter what you may believe about yourself, you make art. This is evidenced by what art is.

Art is everything. There is an art to everything in existence, imagination, and experiences people have yet to formulate, come across, or may never come across. However, paradoxically, art is also nothing. This is the case because there is an art to paradoxes (this will become more apparent when I explain why art).

There are man-made and nature-made arts, we call these artificial and natural, respectively. There is an argument to be made that everything is natural, as people are from nature, but for the sake of categorization, splitting these ideas into two is useful. This means that one is not necessarily greater than the other, but one did bring about another.

How we interpret everything is how we relate it back to ourselves or as humanity as a whole (subjectively or objectively). Society has a classical idea of what art is: music, visuals, movies, etc. That is what society has formally defined as art. This is incorrect as those are only a subset of art. However, non-classical ideas of art are still art. For example, science is an art. Fighting styles are art. War is art. Sun Tzu made a book about it called “The Art of War.” There are too many, as in infinity due to there being never truly a closed system, arts to list.

People handle art in two ways: by action or inaction. These terms are colloquial, and are better described as intervention and non-intervention. There is an art to both these actions, and will be art either way. There is only one one way to take non-intervention: Continuing the current course of action despite new information. Alternatively, there are two paths of intervention: transformation, and destruction, in which there are many ways to do either of these concepts. Transformation changes art from one form to another, and destruction changes art to being lost. Lost arts are still arts. They don’t stop being art because people do not know of them.

I would like to take a moment to differentiate between evidence and proof. Proofs are for the art of math and the art of logic. Math and logic are not completely different.. One uses logic in Math, but there is never a situation where Math does not use some form of logic. Consequently, as Mathematical fields grow, more and more of what was once considered purely logic is now considered Math. They are possibly synonymous. Whether one considers them to be the same or different, both are hardened subsets of the art of reasoning. Evidence is what objective reality presents us. These are substances that behave by certain rules, physics, sciences, etc. Anything can be art, as well as nothing. The art of the void is evidenced by minimalism, and there is nothing more minimal than nothing. So even in nothing there is art, which means there could have never been conceptually un-art.

Now onto the art of subjectivity and the art of objectivity, or perception. There does seem to exist a subjective universe as evidenced by our own inner thoughts, dreams, and quantum physics. Anything is possible in your dream because you have written the rules. There is also an objective universe, because, well, you get up and interact with other beings as well as having objective rules to a physical universe. We refer to what we have experienced of both the objective and subjective universe as empirical information. There also exists unempirical information, or information from non-personal sources. I.E: Someone told you they lost their dog. Someone could have lost their dog, but that does not mean the dog is lost.

There’s an art to gathering information, one of which is science. There are many sciences, commonly divided into hard and soft sciences. Each one of these is an art. I can not stress this point enough. There is a divide between the arts and the sciences in what objective society teaches. This is wrong. Although science has a set of rules all science must follow to be considered science, making experiments requires an immense amount of creativity.

Information is also transformed into truth and untruth, the truth of which we define as knowledge. To some, there is no truth. Reasons why this is the case vary. One big reason is the idea of delusion and hallucination. There is no way to tell the difference between a delusion and reality by their classic definitions, which means anything can be false. Rene Descartes came up with a method of doubt which is famously summarized, “I think therefore I am.” This begs the question, what happens when one stops thinking? Do they stop existing? If we weren’t thinking before, and started thinking then there must be more. Unless we were always thinking. These musings are hard to answer, and I do not claim to know the answer to them with my current knowledge. I will suggest though, that there is at least near-certainty in context, which for all practical purposes is truth.

The combination of near-certainties we think to be the case and not the case we call knowledge. The study of knowledge is called epistemology, and can be broken down into two types. Historical and conceptual. Historical is what has happened, is happening, or is going to happen (past, present, future). Conceptual knowledge can be numerous things. For example, a fun supernatural story, or some form of logic. Conceptual knowledge exists in history, but is not necessarily history itself. The color blue is not history, but something in history can be the color blue.

Objectively, some art is better than others. There is a reason we have grand art museums to showcase our most glorious of creations. There is an objective taste in art, as evidenced by people preferring a picasso over say, a fifth grade drawing of myself and my mom. Yet if my mom had a choice between my drawing and the Mona Lisa, well, she might just choose my drawing. That doesn’t mean most won’t choose the Mona Lisa.

This gets into the meaning of life, or what most people are actually referring to as life's purpose. We are here to produce and consume art. There is an art to consuming art, and an art to producing art. We consume art through senses. I'm talking about more than the 5 senses (touch, hearing, smell, taste, sight) most people think of when they hear the term as well. You have a sense of self, a sense of others, a sense of emotions, etc. We can also produce art as evidenced by our creative nature. The production and consumption of art come together to form a single consciousness, or soul. The art of consciousness, or the art of soul. I use these terms interchangeably. That does not necessarily mean they are interchangeable, but this stems from my personal belief that bodies are just avatars/vessels for different souls.

There is a morality. People look at art as right and wrong. And yes, there is an art to morality, or a way we should go about consuming and producing art. This is based on balance. Ever have dreams of traveling? Big consumer of art. Ever have dreams of being a star? Big producer of art. So how to solve the problem of if morality is subjective or objective? It's also both, but there’s more to it than that.

It's both because we have contextual fairness: The art of being fair in context. For example, suppose 2 children do an equal amount of work. This work ends up boiling down to a reward for their hard chores well done of $11 to split up between the two of them. There is however, a problem. We have two $5 bills, and a $1 bill available and no change whatsoever. So there is going to be an unfairness here, and that's why we feel that something wrong is about to happen. There is some sort of inequity. Out of balanceness triggers our sense of right and wrong. Badness relates to unfairness. The art of being bad or evil, is the art of being unfair.

So the subjective side of morality still exists and needs to be explained. People have choice, and can do the subjectively/objectively good/bad decisions. The problem of why ever evil can be explained the following way: Sometimes it’s okay to do a little evil just to kill the boredom, or to create some art for fun. Why is this the case? We have a certain amount of art consumption we are supposed to take in. We are inherently bored creatures, and must make things interesting.

By drawing upon game-theory, our morality would actually be split up into good/interesting, good/boring, evil/interesting, evil/boring. Goodness and Interest are relative to one another. As one goes up, the other goes down. Ideally, one would be as good and interesting as possible, but never bad and boring. The real dilemma is whether it is better to be evil/interesting or good/boring if given the choice. However, if forced to do evil, it is better to do the more interesting option. This is why good people can do evil. It’s because they’re in an unfair situation, and they’d rather take the interesting option because of the inherent increased value.

Just as there is an art to being right and wrong, there is an art to being correct and incorrect. There is the art of the incorrect. The false. I try not to be incorrect, but can’t help myself because of context. You may be incorrect but still do the right thing based on the context of the situation. This makes a situation forgivable. Forgiveness seems to be a lost art nowadays. People should be forgiven, because they didn’t have all the information, and are prone to lose information because of inherent forgetfulness. What is unforgivable is when one has the information, but takes the incorrect action anyways.

For people to perform art, they need some sort of medium. So what determines our canvas so to speak? Well, there are many ways to go with this. I’m going to go down a controversial road and say: God or Gods, a creator, universal architect, etc. In other words; the art of Gods. We are the art of Gods. For some people this is everything, but they are incorrect as Gods are also Art. For others there are no Gods. No Gods is also art. There doesn't have to be a creator, the Big Bang is also a satisfactory beginning to art (though not possibly the absolute beginning as the Big Bang is also art). God(s) and the big bang are not mutually exclusive. This is where the art of belief, and a system of beliefs creates a religion. Beliefs/faith/religion are for the unanswered questions we necessarily require an answer to so they don’t take up all our thinking time.

So how does art work? How does it operate? It operates through the art of mathematics. This is how we understand the universe. Speaking of the universe. It consists of space and time. They are both an art. They are the art of spacetime that Einstein helped combine into one. Space determines the magnitude of art. Time allows us to change a creation. There may be more dimensions to space and time, but that doesn’t matter in this particular instance, because they are of the art of dimensions.

Finally, why art? Because art. That may not be a satisfactory answer to some, but it is the answer. It is the one circular form of logic that is correct, and that is okay because art is outside of logic. So you might be thinking, is there an anti-art? That would null the entire art is everything and nothing hypothesis. There would be an art to making anti-art. This is in and of itself, is still art. This is the one exception to the binary rule. This is the exception to the proposed dualism, and the supersymmetry. No matter what, anything and nothing will always Art.

Just as there is an art to being right and wrong, there is an art to being correct and incorrect. There is the art of the incorrect. The false. I try not to be incorrect, but can’t help myself because of context. You may be incorrect but still do the right thing based on the context of the situation. This makes a situation forgivable. Forgiveness seems to be a lost art nowadays. People should be forgiven, because they didn’t have all the information, and are prone to lose information or the art of forgetfulness. What is unforgivable is when one has the information, but takes the incorrect action anyways.

There exists a way of acting and determining behavior without the use of reasoning. This can be divided into two parts: Intuition and instinct. Both are integral to everyday life, and are subconscious in manner. Think of them as how you are hard-wired. Instinct is found within every living being’s behavior. This is the primordial knowledge one is born with. For example, a baby will instinctively cry when in distress.

Intuition in contrast is how one acts based on experience. Answers come from the subconscious. If you ever take a test, and have a gut feeling on an answer that disagrees with your conscious reasoning, then you’re thinking intuitively. If you do not have an answer, you are also thinking intuitively, but do not have the answer. This is why when a teacher speaks to a group of students about a foreign topic, or someone communicates in a completely foreign language, there is no idea of what is happening. Through reasoning, one may be able to deduce a different idea, but that is not intuition at play.

People are also creative. They find new ways to accomplish tasks, or simply of ways to express themselves. People are creative in different ways. One person may be so musically inclined, and another visually. One may be a master in the kitchen, and yet another towards government. One may be a master of all these arts, but they will never be a master of all.

When one combines intuition, creativity, and reasoning, they form wisdom. The art of wisdom is the creation of ideas based on the experience of intuition, combined with reasoning create a sort of higher behavioral standard. For example, Confucius was a famous philosopher and wiseman. He once said, “What you do not wish for yourself, do not do to others.” This being a form of the golden rule. Note that he did not invent this rule, as the ideas of empathy and altruism formed independently amongst various peoples, but nonetheless is representative of a piece of wisdom.

Tastes are formed by a combination of previous experience and instinct. This is why tastes are subject to change as more information is gained. Our tastes determine what we find beautiful, fun, and humourous. There is also a limit to our tastes, or how much of the three aspects of taste one can take in before they lose their appeal. These tastes can be recharged though, either by the passage of time or by new information. In other words, one can not simply do the same activity over and over again without becoming bored.

Going back to the idea of morality. Something that is good/interesting will be simultaneously beautiful, fun, and funny. Note that fun and funny are mutually exclusive concepts despite seeming similar. One can have fun without finding the humour in something. This is evidence by the example of watching a scary movie and having fun with it, but it certainly isn’t funny. Or one can hear a pun, find it funny, but not have fun with it.

Although the three primary aspects of taste fairly decently make up what people enjoy, this does not really explain what these individual ideas are. As one further branches into a topic or idea, the more complex an art becomes. So while it is easy to understand:

Moral Value = Rightness + Interestingness

What is more difficult is:

Moral Value = Taste

Moral Value = Rightness + Interestingness

Taste = Beauty + Fun + Humour

Rightness + Interestingness = Beauty + Fun + Humour

To make matters tougher, most of these concepts are ill-defined or rather especially hard to define, even though most have an idea of what they are.

For example, take the idea of beauty. Beauty exists on a spectrum, ranging from beautiful to ugly to describe a moral appreciation a group or individual has for a particular art form. Oddly, something can become so ugly, that it becomes interesting again which can be described as, “So bad, it’s good.” What this phrase really means when someone says it though is, “So bad, it’s interesting.” This means beauty and interest are intertwined in a reverse bell curve. In other words, the more average something is, the less interesting it becomes. This makes those pieces of art incredibly forgetful. Another important question of beauty, is whether beauty is in everything and nothing, as art is. However, this is not the case. Beauty necessarily needs an appreciator or set of subjects to find the beauty. This is not a prerequisite of art. In other words, true nothingness can not be beautiful without a beholder.

Many of what can be said for beauty, can also be said about fun and humour even though they are entirely different parts of the moral value. Fun is simply how pleasurable something is. Everything one does or comes across has a fun value to it. Ideally, one would want to have the most fun possible. However, unlike with beauty, which is strictly related to interest, fun is related to both rightness and interest. Recalling that rightness has to do with contextual fairness, the more fair something is, the more fun it will likely be for all involved. However, without interest, something can not be fun. Something that is totally and utterly unfair can also have zero fun value. For example, being tortured in a non sado-masochistic relationship is incredibly interesting, but is lacking in the fun department because it is not fair and not all that pleasurable.

If Interest = Zero and/or Rightness = Zero, then fun will equal zero, and vice versa.

Fun is more complicated than this. Imagine something that is very interesting but also less than fair. This can be considered a challenge. Most people consider challenge a fun and also a good thing. The art of the challenge is important to human happiness. Whereas the counterpart to challenge, problem, is an unfair and bad thing. Problems tend to be uninteresting on top of being unfair. Completing a problem brings pleasure in the form of relief, whereas when one completes a challenge, they feel pleasure in the form of accomplishment.

Moving on from fun, there exists also humour. There is fun in humour, but not necessarily humour in fun. People like to laugh. Much like beauty and fun, I can only give an approximation of what makes something funny. In humour’s case, I would need to categorization. At the heart of the art of humour, there are three basic principles: Inconsistency and the expense of others. Note that when I say others, the other is not necessarily a person. The more inconsistent an individual, the easier it is to find mockery. Extreme inconsistency turns into absurdity. Extreme expense of others turns cruelty. At the intersection of these two concepts is when something is funny. Comedians are masters of finding inconsistencies in others.

With this better understanding of what beauty, fun, and humour is, the moral equation looks a little better:

Moral Value = Beauty + Fun + Humour

Beauty = Interest * Appreciation

Fun = Interest * Fairness

Humour = limit (Inconsistency) * limit (Absurdity)

Moral value = (Interest * Appreciation) + (Interest * Fairness) + (limit (inconsistency) * limit (other’s expense))

The equation ever-expands the more in-depth one becomes into certain ideas. A person can easily ask what appreciation is, what a limit is, and what it means to be consistent. I should also note that many people would rightfully scoff that a moral value possibly includes the expense of another. My rebuttal is that, the individual is also part of the whole, so taking from another is not always unjustified.

Justice is the idea of spreading fairness. There are entire legal systems and laws devoted to procedurally spreading justice. Ironically, many if not all of these systems are rife with injustice because of special interests. Typically, these interests are looking to gain a certain power over one another, and can be divided up into three cases: Individual vs. individual, individual vs. group, group vs. group. Groups typically have more power than an individual to defend their position, but this is not always the case.

Not everyone is out for justice. Not everyone is interested in fairness. These people are selfish, and look to only increase power for themselves. As selfish people are not looking for fairness, they should be considered evil. There is another notion that best explains what highly selfish people are, and that is parasitic. They take without giving back. Some seem to think that because they are better than others, that it is okay for them to take more. There is truth to an individual who is better than others, who contributes more, should receive more in turn. This does not make a person selfish if truthful. However, many people are truly blind to their own self worth, and due to the nature of the current system, there was never a fair playing field to begin with. That means, if you start with more, and proceed to take more, then you better be contributing a whole lot. Otherwise, you are unfair, and thus, not good.

The previous line of reasoning does not excuse selflessness, even though the notion is often idolized in society. Highly selfless people are considered heroes, and are granted respect. They give up themselves so that others may prosper. However, these people are not looking for fairness either. Since a hero is also part of the whole, being a major contributor without asking for anything in turn, leads to unfairness. A true hero should be able to take care of himself as well as others in a just manner. They would value their life as well as others.

There is an art to making an argument, and philosophizing. There is an art to making good writing. There are an infinite number of arts, and I could go on forever explaining them, and may do that as my goal in life, but I also enjoy the art of mastering other arts. I have mastered the art of the argument, and now intend to master a new art, because I value the art of learning. Finally, and importantly, there is an art to endings. Art be with you.


r/philosophyself • • Aug 05 '14

Consumerism vs. Minimalism

8 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I've been gone for a few days now, due to some health concerns, but I've gotten that taken care of!

These past few days, I've really been thinking about the seemingly opposite ideas known as consumerism and minimalism. I've always been interested in minimalism, and slowly but surely, I am learning to live simpler.

Consumerism is the idea that we as humans need to consume goods or services produced or provided by other humans. In this way we are supporting each other. "More, more, more!" is the consumerist mantra. We are often convinced that we need things to be happy and fulfilled in life.

Minimalism on the other hand suggests that we do not need things. Things are just wants, not needs. Minimalism means different things to different people. To most though, it is attributed to material things. "Less, less, less." is the mantra of the minimalist.

What I want to talk about though is this: Is one idea better than the other? Since consumerism is entirely based on spending money for goods or services, we'll focus on the topic of goods and services.

First, I want you to imagine all of the things you own, from the important stuff like your house or vehicle, to small things like towels or curtains. Now I assume that most people worry about losing those things, whether it be a house fire, a burglary, natural disaster, etc. It can cause quite a bit of stress. Those that have moved realize the stress of moving everything you own from place to place, constantly worrying about losing or forgetting something. "Things" are stressful. My favorite example is the cell phone. I think most people could agree that outside of business related circumstances, cell phones are not a need. They aren't like food or water. Yet we worry about them constantly. Have you ever seen a teenager lose their phone? It stresses people beyond belief.

Part of minimalism is that by simplifying your life, you reduce stress levels, and become overall a happier person. People who promote consumerism don't like minimalism, because it threatens their paychecks. What one could argue is that by not consuming, you're hurting others. The ones producing the goods won't be able to sell them, and they will have no money, and will not be able to support themselves. I suppose a point of minimalism is that by not needing much, you can take care of yourself.

I suppose my views on environmental preservation play into this, but I think that ultimately consumerism is a bad thing. It depletes natural resources, causes us stress, and in practice, as we've seen, make some people rich and a lot of people poor. Given that minimalism has never been a dominant economic system, I cannot say that it would turn out poorly, but I have seen the effects of it in my own life and in other's lives around me, and it seems like a positive thing.

Thoughts?


r/philosophyself • • Jul 28 '14

Why is swearing considered "bad" or immoral?

8 Upvotes

I work around children a lot and I often wonder why it's considered poor form to swear, especially around children. Why do we have words that are "filthy" and "bad"? What makes them this way?


r/philosophyself • • Jul 08 '18

Science has become scientism and has completely come off the rails it was built on.

7 Upvotes

Science has completely come off the rails that it was built on, and has stopped following its own standards and method for distinguishing between facts and theories. First of all, science is only a method for properly collecting data and conducting experiments. It is not a conscious entity that has an opinion about its own data and results, and can't tell scientists when they have interpreted the evidence properly. The original goal of science was to find a method to avoid making assumptions about our universe. The scientific method was formed to build a body of properly collected facts and evidence, and to allow each individual person or scientist to form their own conclusions, interpretations, or theories about what all of those individual facts and pieces of evidence mean collectively.

Science is only the method of properly gathering those individual pieces of evidence through actual observation and experimentation. It is PHILOSOPHY when you try to interpret or theorize what the evidence may mean collectively, or to speculate that things are true without actual observation of them being true. Even when it is a scientist that attempts to interpret or theorize what the evidence may mean about unobserved things, he is being a PHILOSOPHER while he is doing it. People were way out of line when they started trying to call some theories "scientific theories", because it is trying to speak for what "science's opinion" is, and science itself has no opinion it is only a method.

Treating these so called "scientific" theories as if they are facts is scientism, not science, and goes against the spirit of how science is supposed to be approached and practiced. Speculation is not allowed as evidence in a courtroom and it should not be allowed as evidence in our science books either. Two scientists can look at the same exact evidence and interpret that same evidence in two completely different ways, if you don't believe me just ask Einstein and Bohr.

So science's job is NOT to tell the world how the evidence should be interpreted to form conclusions about things still unobserved. Science's job is to only inform them what the properly collected evidence IS that actually HAS been observed. It would seem that in order to make decisions on when a theory should start being considered a "scientific" theory instead, it would require an appointed science king or science judge with the final authority to decree it a "scientific" theory instead of a regular theory. It seems that doing something like that is the logical fallacy of appeal to authority, where you accept that a theory is true based on who agrees with that theory, and not based on its logic, merit, or proof that it is true.

Treating theories as if they are facts is not justified by a democracy or majority opinion either. Because the majority opinion about something can be wrong, as evidenced by things like the Salem Witch Trials. The problem is that science has turned into a scientism club, that promotes answers that can't be questioned by its members. So it would be difficult to establish what the true majority opinion of these standing theories even are anymore. Because any scientist that questions these standing "scientific" theories is ostracized by the scientific community, and the only people that get research grants are the ones that are proposing ways to support or confirm these standing theories, not those that propose to disprove them or to present new or different ones.

So there could be many scientists that may question the validity of these theories in their mind but keep quiet about it out of fear. One scientist may pretend like they believe in a theory they really don't in the presence of one of their peers out of fear, not realizing that his peer might be doing the same exact thing out of fear himself. Treating ANY theory about unobserved things as if they are facts is the opposite of being scientific. Because no matter how well YOU may think that theory is supported according to YOUR interpretation of the evidence, that theory could still be WRONG. Because theories about the evidence is just PHILOSOPHY, and is not evidence or science itself. ;)


r/philosophyself • • Jun 21 '17

Best Philosophical Novels

7 Upvotes

I'm always looking for works of fiction that combine a compelling story with a philosophical subtext. So I did some research and compiled previous lists of the best philosophical novels and took suggestions from readers and from philosophical fiction authors like Khaled Hosseini, Irvin D. Yalom, Rebecca Goldstein and Daniel Quinn. Based on all these sources, I created this list of the 105 best philosophical novels ever written: https://www.greghickeywrites.com/best-philosophical-novels

I'm sure Philosophyself Redditors have plenty of input on this topic, so I'm curious to see what you think of this list.


r/philosophyself • • May 02 '17

The Purpose of Life (an extended metaphor)

7 Upvotes

By a stroke of luck I manage to find a magic genie, but instead of offering me three wishes, he offers answers to three questions. After contemplating my first question, I ask "who or what created the world?" "I did" he responds. This obviously takes me back, and a hurricane of questions runs through my mind. Why? When? What's our purpose? What is morality? After overcoming my shock, I ask the greatest question of humanity. "What is the meaning of life?" The genie chuckles, "Imagine this: you're reading a story. The reason you love the story so much is the mystery of the plot. Once you finish the story, you wish with all your heart that there was more mystery. You may even wish to forget the ending to the story. The purpose of life is mystery. Humanity tries to solve the mysteries of the world while making mysteries of their own." It's a mind numbing experience. Everything makes sense- or rather it doesn't, but that's the beauty of it. While the world may seem a little hallow now that my greatest question has been answered, it gives it a new meaning. "And you're third question is..." the genie smiled knowingly. "I think I'll figure it out on my own"


r/philosophyself • • Jun 04 '16

Humans just want their peers to validate them

7 Upvotes

Not generalizing here; I guess there's some people who might lack that "dire necessity" but I feel like most don't.

I always thought this but today, while watching a film, a sex scene struck me hard and I felt the desire to give this a little more thought and to share it to see if other people can improve this theory.

In that scene, a woman was giving oral sex to his sexual partner and I felt that, more than anything, she wanted to feel better about herself, to have a better self-image, self-esteem. I explain this: Having sex with an attractive and high social status male helps her feel worthy. Now, I don't believe that you can rate a person's worth, but most people do think that and maybe even I think so deeply in the dark corners of my mind, subconciously.

As I've said, I've always thought this way about human behaviour and motivations, it's just that this time, I don't know why, it struck me so hard that I felt a mixture of pity and disgust; I thought to myself: "We're some pathetic creatures...".

I see people craving power everywhere, in relationships, working place, you name it. They do it because they want to feel good about themselves. They want their peers to acknowledge them as high status individuals because they feel they can tell them the truth about their worth. Sex is fun, but it's just another activity that people use to neuroticaly try to find out their own worth. I see people constantly rating themselves, not enjoying what they're doing, not doing what they really want. Trying to achieve goals to prove some grandiose notion of their self or to disprove a self-defeating one. C'mon... is this how we want to life? As sex, trying to achieve goals can be so much fun but it doesn't say anything about your worth. Deep inside most people think differently though, they think that if they are more wealthy, more attractive, more intelligent, more admired, ... you name it, they are better, but that's bogus since no rational argument can support that.

Not trying to sound like complaining at all, though. Things are as they are and I accept that. I may sound like generalizing though or simplifying too much human motivations. I acknowledge that there are a lot of different factors and motivations; I just happen to think that feeding self-esteem through social validation is one the main ones.

As a final note, escaping this narcissistic maze needs a VERY deep realization that there's no point in globally rating ourselves and the others as it's impossible to value a person's worth and even it if was it's repercussions over our capacity to enjoy life would be meaningless. And it's this final note what makes that validation craving thing so pathetic, since we humans let a delusion run our lifes.


r/philosophyself • • Mar 27 '16

Self Awareness comes before Self/Internal Confidence

7 Upvotes

In order to develop a strong internal confidence (defined as confidence in knowing not only what you're good at, but what you're NOT good at) on a sustainable level (Specifically, one that will persist even in the face of adversity and mature into a long lasting and healthy part of the ego), an individual must first develop self awareness. Which is to say, they must first have a grounded intellectual/emotional understanding of who they are, and the qualities of their individual person-hood(self identity).

Therefore, internal confidence(as defined) without any basis in self awareness is insubstantial and will not endure through heightened hardship or experiences that directly contradict said confidence.

Note: "self" in this case being defined as the timeless-observer that is acting within the individual, as well as the identifying characteristics, tendencies, preferences, etc of the individual.


r/philosophyself • • Feb 12 '20

My take on Nozick's experience machine

6 Upvotes

r/philosophyself • • Jan 26 '20

I have a theory/question on reality

6 Upvotes

I have a theory that we share a hive mind with the universe. This theory of mine is based on the science of biocentrism. This science states that nothing but waves of probability exist when not being observed by a biological observer.

For my theory let’s say that a god exists, not any god in particular, or let’s say the universe is god.

Now, things and events do keep happening without a worldly biological observer.

It is obvious that we all share a reality. I sleep at night yet when I wake up tomorrow the earth will have rotated so that I see the sun when I wake up, depending on weather, but the sun will still be facing my location on the planet when it wasn’t 8 hours earlier.

I say that the universe is in constant observation of what goes on inside and outside of itself. Now if we share a reality and that reality keeps happening while I and say 1000 other people in 1001 population community are sleeping, and the sun “rises” the next morning on me and my other 1000 friends, then we in fact are not the main observers but instead share a reality with the constant observer, the universe.

Now, my question is two parted: 1) do you think a god is needed for this theory to be true? 2) what are your thoughts on my theory?

I can provide some sources for those interested in the science of biocentrism and wanting to know more about my basis for my theory.


r/philosophyself • • Dec 24 '19

I want to start writing philosophy. What do I need to read that I'm being ignorant about?

6 Upvotes

Disclaimer: English is not my first language.

I have a lot of philosophical ideas I want to write about in a blog which I feel are new and good, but I know only very basic philosophy from school and from listening to the podcast 'philosophize this!' on spotify. I was wondering if this is the right place to outline some of my ideas so you can tell me what I am being ignorant about and what I need to read before I start writing. I am going in a 1 month trip to India on January and I'd really like to start writing when I come back so I'm thinking 2-3 books. This a rough outline of my thoughts:

I am agnostic. The more characteristics you add to the concept of God (conscience, intelligence, free will, etc), the less likely I think its real. I don't believe in souls or free will. I think us animals are like machines in that we have an input of information through our senses which we process and transform into an output of movement and actions. This process was developed through darwinian natural selection. Certain 'transformations of information' (see food-eat it, hear predator-run away, etc) made our genes more likely to survive, and we percieve the 'direction' of those transformations as happiness-sadness. If it made us happy to eat, we were more likely to eat, and thus to survive. If it made us sad to be hurt, we were more likely to avoid being hurt, and thus more likely to survive. Similarly, if we had empathy and loved our family and friends, it was more likely we took care of eachother, and thus that we survived (the happiness brought by love and family and friends are a higher level of happiness than, say, eating chocolate, because they are long term). 'Thought' is the transformation of information. The big difference between humans and other animals is that we process/transform a much larger amount of information, so within all that information, we process the facts that we have names and identities. Thats all consciousness is to me. Bits of information we take into account to choose actions that made our ancestors survive. But there is a catch. Within all this information we process, we humans realized something (mostly uncosciously and some of us consciously): that the happiness of other beings is the same thing as our own happiness, and thus its irrational to seek our own happiness at the expense of other's. That is why some make sacrifices for the good of others. We invented the words like 'morals', 'justice' and 'good' and phrases like "what has to be done" to describe those actions that provide "the greater good". Thus, it is true and correct to say things like "we have to help others", "we have to seek the truth" and "we have to be good". I am opposed to nihilism and post modernism. To me, actions are 'right' when they create more happiness than sadness and 'wrong' when they create net sadness (I think that last bit is called utilitarianism, I've read some of the objections to it and I have my own answers but I can't expand on that on this summary). The ultimate goal of life is to maximize happiness as much as we can.

Now that is a very condensed summary of some of my thoughts, I could really expand on that and write my ideas about many other subjects but that paragraph is kind of a starting point to a lot of the other stuff. Am I being an ignorant fool? What are, in your opinion, the major mistakes in my reasoning? Are these new ideas or have they been written many times before? Is it even possible to become a popular philosopher without having extensive knowledge of philosophy? And what books can you recommend for my trip? Thank you very much.


r/philosophyself • • Jul 05 '19

The stigma surrounding mental illness cripples those inflicted.

6 Upvotes

The acknowledgement that my perception of the world skewed from societies was terrifying. It has taken me years to correct this cognitive astigmatism. Even today I struggle with normalcy, the routine monotony that does not plaque my peers but rather pleases the general population. The psychiatric system helped me personality, but the community outside their office still does not understand how easy it was to slip through the cracks suddenly and silently as though I was not apart of society at all.

Twenty years ago I could not own my major depression. It seems that diagnosis outside of those that were deemed worthy for hospitalization were met with a "sweep it under the rug" approach, leaving people like my mom to just deal with it the best she could. She became an alcoholic and a IV drug user. Seeing the strain of my local mental health office, I can only imagine that most people who are drug users have a mental illness of some sort, but I could be wrong. I personally turned to drugs, which developed into addiction because of course it was going to, I was genetically predisposed to both mental illness and addiction. Awesome.

The mental health safety net we have locally was not equipped to provide adequate care for me when I was going through a major break from reality. The attitude was if I did not say I was going to hurt myself or others, they could not do anything. Thinking back, I had no clue that I was speaking at any given moment, let alone had to cognition to know what I was saying. Psychology should not be so scientific in field application. People going through something mentally need people who are compassionate enough to say, what's wrong, and actually listen without judgement.

If the field of psychology would introduce humanity into their research instead of focusing on Nero-transmitters, I think a better understand in this field of study would emerge. Better understand of the experts might lead to a better understanding of mental illness through out the general population.,with a stronger emphasis on mental health rather than mental illness. Yes, my depression is so server that I can not function like most of you, and that is ok. Through taking responsibility for my mental health I have made great strides to integrate back into society. At the end of the day, who could I tell? Who would understand? Who would care? Who out there struggled like I did but is too afraid to share their story, even though it might help someone in turn.


r/philosophyself • • Jul 04 '19

I think I am not weird. But I think, therefore I am.

6 Upvotes

r/philosophyself • • Jan 02 '19

I know you’re on a different level. You feel disconnected from others and you don’t know why. Like you’re operating on a different frequency.

6 Upvotes

I know you’re on a different level. You feel disconnected from others and you don’t know why. Like you’re operating on a different frequency. Even as a small child you felt apart from other children. Then, a little later, you looked up and realized everyone around you had cliqued up, and you were left over.

You were kind of a drifter. Mixing in with different crowds. Well-liked, but always at a distance from most people. Not included. Your life has been lived from the outside looking in, a benevolent observer.

You do not live in the same world as them. While others seem to live primarily in the touchable plane, you live inwardly. The moments where you are outside of yourself are spent going through the motions until you can delve back inside again. Back into those sprawling machinations of your design, which you detailed to the slightest minutia. The world to which the “real” world is blind. You are unfathomable.

In your heart, you feel the weariness of being a complex actor feigning simplicity. You feign so your language and actions can be understood by people who speak simply and do simple things. You give them a version of yourself easier to digest and conceptualize, but even this is beyond them sometimes. You were not made to do anything simple. The things you achieve will not be done in a simple way. If you try forcing yourself to be simple, what ails you will not cease.

There are others who are expanded. They think deeply, feel deeply, want deeply. They want to understand others and to be understood, and their constant pursuit of this has made them near masters in empathy and self-expression. They cannot be restrained or lorded over by people. They do not follow orders they disagree with. Their desires and interests are barely impacted by what is popular or what their friends are doing, if they have them. They only do what they love, and are often content to keep it to themselves.

Your mind is incredible. It’s not about being ‘smart.’ You’ve met smart people with top grades and they still lacked something. They still weren’t like you. You could feel it. But, you’re not the only one. Although we are rare, we are designed to collaborate. Once you connect deeply with a mind of similar strength, your creative drive will be invigorated to an extent up until that point unfathomed―and you will want for nothing else again save for that connection. You will look for it everywhere, in everyone, and you will not settle for a lesser brain. Even if you do not think such a connection is possible, you still search for it.


r/philosophyself • • Dec 04 '18

Best philosophical novels of 2018?

6 Upvotes

Last year, I published a list of the 105 Best Philosophical Novels, based on curated lists from The Guardian, Flavorwire and more, suggestions from readers on Goodreads, Quora and Reddit, and picks from philosophical fiction authors like Khaled Hosseini, Irvin D. Yalom, Rebecca Goldstein and Daniel Quinn: http://www.greghickeywrites.com/best-philosophical-novels.

I want to keep this list current over time, so I'm looking for the best philosophical novels published in 2018. If you read something you think is worthy of inclusion, please let me know.


r/philosophyself • • Jun 10 '17

The Role theory of Personal IDentitiy

6 Upvotes

NOTe: This is not intended to replace any other theories of personal identity but to work alongside them.

One thing people havent considered with regards to personal identity is someone's 'role' which I define as ones relationship to other people and their environment. My parent are still the same since the day I was born as are my siblings and our relationship dynamics from when we were kids hasnt changed much, same goes for my friends who I am still friends with so we can say my role hasnt changed in this regard and there is continuity. Now what about changing jobs or changing relationship dynamics or really anything that changes ones role or part of ones role? Well if I loose all of my family and friends in a bomb attack then their is no continuity with me at this point in time right? Not quite because that person will be the same person in every way but the parts lf their role thay have changed they yhen change a part of their role which we will contunue to have in the future. So we can say their is a connection as I will be continuing his role


r/philosophyself • • Apr 05 '17

Solice in the fact my life doesn't matter.

6 Upvotes

When i feel extremely sad it makes me feel better to know that my life is meaningless and that when i die i will eventually be forgotten. I view my own life as a journey that ends with a crash into the cosmic abyss and not of it matters. Dose anyone else feel better about there life because it is so insignificant?


r/philosophyself • • Feb 06 '17

Manufacturing Reality

6 Upvotes

Our species is quite adept at manufacturing reality. We take what we see, use our tiny little brain and then decide what it is. We do turn to science for the facts, some facts at least. But we do not try to look for all the aspects, all the sides to something. We always just have to jump to a conclusion, and then hold on to it as if our very existence depended on it. We are quite fond of stories, and weave many of our own. We have created a whole reality for ourselves in which we assume ourselves to be the superior species for whom the universe exists. We seem to be forgetting that we are limited to just a few billion members inhabiting an inconspicuously small watery planet. Our puny imagination cannot even estimate the number of stars the universe (or whatever we have come to understand of it) contains. We are limited to our mortal lives which don't even span more than a century. Compared to the age of our planet we haven't even lived out our infancy. But in this minuscule moment we have caused so much mayhem, chaos and destruction. We have managed to kill millions of our own species and obliterated entire species from our planet.

We have taken ownership over lands, metals, rocks and things that we didn't even create in the first place! Whatever 'wealth' we keep talking about is just an abstract idea! That's just something we made up to suit ourselves. And then we decide if someone should get something or not based on how much 'wealth' he is willing to part with. That something in this case can even be just some fruit, that is made by the land mostly by itself. Nowadays we have some pieces of software that are worth billions of 'dollars', that only a few thousand or million people use. But at the same time we have millions of people who can't even afford basic necessities such as food and clean water. Isn't this just ridiculous? We talk of human rights and poor people in expensive conference rooms decorated with imported vases amid rich people while hungry people sleep outside in makeshift tents in constant fear of getting evicted by their own government, or run over by some inebriated, rich douche. How is this not the sign of a made-up reality in which we have been holed up for so long that we can't even see past our own ego and greed? Rich people can afford all the comforts of the world because several hundreds of people are toiling hard and long for decades in unhealthy work conditions and earning a pittance. The only eligibility those rich folks hold is that they were born in that family and hence inherited the apparent 'wealth' of their ancestors. The true inheritance that we naturally get is the same planet that has been here even before humans came into existence. This artificial 'wealth' is nothing more than a facade that acts solely to protect the interests of the rich people. Many economists and philosophers and pro-free-market evangelists will argue against this. But a child born into a poor family is resigned to a life of struggle and pain, unless he is 'lucky' to make a break and become 'wealthy'. He then joins an elite club of 'rich' people and so can provide the best of facilities to his children that he subsequently produces. But what are the chances of a poor guy actually making the jump in his lifetime? Practically and statistically speaking, very very low. All those success stories that people keep peddling in their feel-good, motivational books are just a few handful among millions of poor people. It is like the observation someone had about popular blog sites that were making good revenue. Those blogging sites were blogging about 'blogging to earn money'! Oh the irony. It's like someone cutting down a tree to print a thousand posters to spread awareness against deforestation.

That's not even the end of it! We didn't stop just there. Enter, religion. I personally believe this is one of the most ingenious ideas that some people came up with. We humans tend to fear things that we don't understand. Since we didn't understand a lot of things in the old days we ended up praying to them and making them 'Gods'. I do believe God exists. But I don't think God is a wise old person who looks down upon us from the heavens and keeps track of us, but rather the whole of the universe in entirety including us and the trillions of atoms, neutrons, electrons, quarks, leptons that we are made up of and the spark that makes us breathing, sentient beings. I am also supportive of Elon Musk's simulation theory; that's entirely plausible too. There has been no scientific discovery related to 'God', so we can't fully rely on anyone's explanation. But what people have done is that they have taken ownership over their Gods. They have taken it upon themselves to defend their Gods and their faiths. They have created their own rule books based on which they wage wars and even kill people of their own faith who do not support their views. These rule-books were created centuries ago and not many can testify to their authenticity, save for blind belief. They do say good things - like code of conduct for us and what we should aspire for and how to manage our human tendencies etc. So there is no reason to question them. That's well and good, but problem arises when people take them way too seriously and start violating others' freedoms to assert their own interpretations of these texts. Perhaps there is some misplaced sense of priority people give to these old, arcane and often abstruse texts than to living, breathing humans. Religion is quite tricky as it can get a lot of people to believe in a purely artificial, abstract construct. That is constructive, in many cases. People are more creative and sincere since they believe they are doing it for their beloved Gods. They make beautiful monuments, write amazing prayers and create harmonious societies. But sometimes it also gets them instigated to such an extent that they don't think twice before killing other people. Nowadays people have come up with several ideas to make 'wealth' off other people's devotion! The babas, the gurus and the spiritual leaders are nothing short of rockstars who create a fan following and routinely conduct 'tours' to rake up 'donations' for their charitable organisations. Anyway, that is much more benign compared to the religious war that is going on in the global scale. Millions of people are being displaced by this insane 'holy war' that has no clear goal. Now entire countries are arguing over who should take the displaced refugees and help them get on with their lives. Humans have come down to this now. Its not just the religions that are causing problems. We have divided the planet into many countries which all have their own sorts of rules, restrictions and problems. People from many countries quarrel with people from other countries for trivial reasons. Sometimes that is escalated to war. We already have fought two world wars in which millions of people from many countries died. There is a war every single day on the planet nowadays between some or the other countries. The leaders at the top with their over-inflated egos are unable to reach an amicable position which results in occasional skirmishes in several places. The problem with countries is that they keep thinking about the interests of their own people who have voted them to power, or their own interests if they are dictators. They never think about the problems concerning the entire planet. Our species has affected the planet so much that we have started observing discernible changes in climate patterns. This will definitely affect our agriculture and food sourcing adversely over the coming decades. But the countries still keep quarreling and blaming others for the issues that everyone is now facing.

All these ideas that I have listed are all artificial. God, or whoever or whatever created us never made these. We humans came up with this stuff and are unable to extricate ourselves from the mess these are causing. Since a child's birth he is conditioned to conform to the rules of our society and the whole artificial system that is setup by our species. At every stage his actions and decisions are dictated to him by others, lest he become incompatible with the society and thus bring a bad name to the family. That is nothing more than the insecurities of others that are put on his shoulders in the form of expectations. He never gets the chance to explore the planet which he inherits in entirety. He is restricted from moving to other places unless he fills up a dozen forms and complies to thousands of artificial and illogical rules. At birth his name, religion, career and benefits-plan is decided. He is never given the choice between all the choices our planet has to offer. Rather he is assigned those parameters which he has to accept, ungrudgingly.

I must say, we humans really are funny this way.


r/philosophyself • • Jul 30 '14

The Sciences and the Arts, Then and Now

6 Upvotes

I have been thinking about the classical works of the past. These works are and have been so relevant through the ages that they have stood the test of time. We remember not only these works, but also the philosophers and the great writers that created them.

They brought to us the principles of philosophy and science that we have built upon today. Many of these works even opened up entirely new fields of education and careers. For this they have stayed relevant today because they have been a reference point for all things they bear.

Although as time passes, they seem to remain as no more than a foundation. The sciences have become more relevant than ever before and the arts seem to be lacking something.

It's not as though science and arts were explored separately in the past, but I think that maybe science has progressed farther than the arts. It almost feels like the phrase "There's nothing new under the sun" really does apply to the arts while the sciences seem to be growing like a tree.

Now let's take another perspective into consideration. There is 7 billion people on the planet as of now. However, in ancient times we did not have the technology to communicate long distances. We also did not have nearly as many people on Earth. What this means is that it's quite possible that the individual may have been more important then.

In many of the classical works of philosophy and literature, we find that the writers often speak in cities rather than countries. It's the city that was so significant because of the lack of communication over long distances. This also seems to make each individual more significant because the focus of a general group becomes smaller.

They weren't so focused on all of the land because they didn't have immediate access to the rest of the world. So certain individuals stood out more which is may be one of the reasons why these works are so significant.

On the other hand, many of these individuals that we remember may have been thinking in a bigger scale than the general public of that time. So I suppose one could argue that the opposite is true; that they actually were thinking in a larger scale.

I am not certain of this but I am sure that the times are significantly different now and then. I suppose that a different mindset is required for one to live an extraordinary life today.

With the advancement of technology, the population, and locations; we have become as individuals, less significant than that of general society or so it seems at least.

So how could one counter this and avoid living a meaningless life?

Like I said before about the sciences and the arts, I think that perhaps the arts has become a circle that just gets wider. The sciences however, seem to be growing even with time.

So what does this mean for the state of philosophy? Is it less significant? Have the arts grown as much as they can or is there more to learn? Maybe the sciences have overtaken their importance and perhaps one's life ought to be for that instead.


r/philosophyself • • Jun 04 '19

Theme: Against Bullshit Spirituality | Murican McSpirituality

Thumbnail self.race_traitor_joe
5 Upvotes

r/philosophyself • • Apr 30 '19

It's OK to call people 'they'

Thumbnail self.race_traitor_joe
5 Upvotes

r/philosophyself • • Jan 12 '19

The Paradox of Intentional Morality

5 Upvotes

Does being an empathetic, or intelligent person make living a moral life more difficult? Yes. I assert that it does.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Jad7j87P1ME

The morality of an action is determined through (Intention+Outcome). An action with a negative outcome, and a positive intention can be either positive, or negative depending on the scale of each variable.

This is likewise true for the inverse; a positive outcome with a negative intention.

I submit that through analyzing potential outcomes of any given moral dilemma, and realizing the ways in which one may gain, ones intent changes.

In the preceeding video, I outline a real world example from my own life.

My apologies for the low quality of my videography and what not. I improve these things daily. Hahaha 😅


r/philosophyself • • Nov 10 '14

The inability of my employees...

5 Upvotes

I manage a pro shop in a small po-dunk town in Texas. I have three part time employees. A)HS grad B)Honors HS student C)80+yr old worker of 6 years.

The 80+ yr old won't do anything new. Period. The HS grad can't add, subtract, manage a basic spreadsheet. She and the HS student don't understand anything tech related unless it is in 'ap form' via their smart phones.

For example, I asked for the phone number to the local library - only one could find it because it they had a 'yellow pages ap' that allowed them to search the city and find the library.

Technology is necessary, as its advancement, but at the expense of basic logic? If you don't understand how to even google for basic info because an ap won't provide it to you, then what do you actually know?

The purpose of education is to teach how to learn. What questions do you need to ask when resolving a problem? If A and B equate C, then what is the Process? How does D affect the situation? What are my resources to determine the solution? What does my neighbor think?

It is scary to imagine what sort of world will exist when I am an 'old man' and the rest of the world relies on what we are creating now. What is scarier still is how the entire world progresses in contrast to any developed country.

Just some thoughts. What do you think?


r/philosophyself • • Aug 04 '14

Fandom and Ownership

5 Upvotes

I am a comic book and movie geek, so I get into a lot of comic book and movie discussion. One of the most interesting things that often occurs in this world is the "fanboy". I am huge 80-90s Batman fan, Star Wars, Star Trek, GI Joe, and X-men too. I often encounter communities of other fans of online that really hold fast to one particular branch or incarnation, i.e. the prequels suck ,OT all the way or TOS blows, TNG is the series or Kirby was the true genius. What intrigues me the most in all of these love/hate dichotomies is the amount of ownership or investment that people, myself included, can feel towards a fictional universe and it's inhabitants.

I wonder though, despite the amount of emotional and psychological investments that some put into this creations, do they have any ownership? Even as a group, do two million die hard Batman fans have a right to say, "That is not Batman, Batman is this"? Or does ownership lay only with those that create the stories, the characters, that hold the copy rights, and licenses?

It may seem trivial, but many times a person can be come in a write, direct, draw, film, etc. only one part of huge established cannon and change it dramatically. Does that person have more rights to say who or what the character or universe should be, over the fans?

I just want to see if anyone else has thought about this. Also, I am talking completely about fictional characters and creations, not about people. I don't believe there is any argument to be made that fans can own an actual person.


r/philosophyself • • Jul 28 '14

Is there really such a thing as "Too Much of a Good Thing"?

5 Upvotes

I know it is just a phrase and is not meant to be philosophically analyzed, but let's do it anyway. I think it is interesting to consider. What do you say about it?